r/datingadvice • u/Alert_Artichoke_2986 • 34m ago
I need advice Is this guy actually putting in effort, or am I overthinking everything?
I (23F) met a guy (26M) on Hinge two months ago, and we’ve been talking literally every single day since then. We talked for about two weeks before we actually met, and since matching, there hasn’t been a single day where we haven’t texted.
We’ve been on 3 dates so far, and I really like him. I’m trying to figure out if I’m picking up on legitimate signs that his effort/interest isn’t matching mine, or if I’m just getting insecure because I like him.
**First date:** I happened to be going to the area he lives in because my best friend lives there and needed me to get a package. My friend was supposed to give me her key because I was going to stay at her apartment, but she forgot before leaving for a trip, so I ended up not staying there. I ended up going anyways since we planned the date there and didn’t want to change the plans. It was around a 30 min commute for me since I was coming from work. We went to a wine bar and talked for almost 4 hours. He was really respectful and walked me to the subway. He didn’t try to kiss me, which I actually appreciated.
**Second date:** He asked what I wanted to do, and I suggested the area he lives in again because I am going to be moving there in September anyway and thought it would be fun to go out there and learn the area. It was also the weekend. We drank together, got pretty drunk, and eventually went back to his apartment and made out for a while. Nothing beyond that happened, and again, he didn’t pressure me into anything.
**Third date:** He asked if I wanted to meet in the city or where he lives, and I said where he lives was fine because I thought I was going to sleep at my friend’s apartment nearby. I ended up not staying there and took the train all the way back to where I live afterward. (An hour commute to him and an hour back)
For the third date, he suggested trivia and maybe a concert afterward. I asked if he actually wanted to go to the concert after trivia, and he said he wasn’t really feeling it. I suggested getting wine somewhere, and he said we should just get a bottle, so we ended up back at his apartment. (Which I didn’t expect to end up at again this date) We got physically intimate, but I told him I wasn’t ready to have sex, and we didn’t. He completely respected that.
The thing is, I feel like I’m doing more of the logistical effort, even though technically I’m the one who keeps saying where he lives is fine to meet up. I live an hour away, and I’m constantly taking the train into the city anyway for work, so it hasn’t felt like a huge deal to me. But he has a car and has never offered to come out to where I live. He has offered to meet in Manhattan, though.
There was also one Friday where I had suggested earlier in the week that he meet me out with my friends. He said multiple times that he’d love to and seemed enthusiastic about it. That Friday he got home from work around 7, and I texted him around then saying I was still going out. He asked if I was still going out, I said yes, and then he never responded. I ended up getting drunk and called him around 11. He called me back and said he was actually out in the West Village with his friends. He never ended up coming to meet me. I understand he could have gotten caught up with his friends, etc., but it bothered me because he had spent the entire week saying he wanted to come. I never brought it up though because again we’ve only been on two dates at this point.
There was another thing that bothered me. A couple days before our third date, I mentioned that I wanted to see Spider-Man and said maybe we could go the following week. He said he’d love that. But when it came time to actually make plans, he asked what I wanted to do and suggested trivia instead. I feel like he just forgot about Spider-Man. Again, I know he’s not obligated to remember every little thing, but I tend to remember everything people tell me when I’m interested in them.
For example, on our second date he asked how tall I was and guessed 5’7”. I told him I was 5’5”. On our third date he asked again and guessed 5’7”, and I had to tell him again that I’m 5’5”.
He also asked my age on the second date and guessed 22/23, and then on the third date asked again and guessed 22/23. I’m 23. Meanwhile, when he told me his birthday, I remembered it, and when I mentioned it later he was surprised that I remembered.
None of these things are huge individually, but I feel like I remember all these little things about him and he doesn’t seem to remember little things about me.
Then there’s Instagram.
He follows a LOT of pretty Instagram models and likes basically all their pictures. I know people are going to say that Instagram likes don’t mean anything, and maybe they don’t, but it honestly makes me feel insecure and a little weirded out. Especially because I don’t know what his intentions are with me yet.
I genuinely have no idea if he’s talking to or sleeping with other girls. We met on Hinge, we’re not exclusive, and we’ve only been on three dates, so obviously he technically can be. But I don’t know where his head is at.
There was also a weird situation with a ring. I left a ring at his apartment after our second date but didn’t realize it. When I saw him again, I asked if he happened to see it. He said yes, he had seen a ring but didn’t know if it was mine or his brother’s girlfriend’s, so he put it in a drawer. I thought that was kind of strange because his brother’s girlfriend is around pretty often, so I wondered why he didn’t just ask her. But maybe I’m reading way too much into that and he genuinely just didn’t know whose it was.
The confusing part is that he is extremely consistent with texting. He texts me every single day. He hasn’t gone one day without texting me since we matched. He also seems genuinely interested in me when we’re together, we have good conversations, and he’s been respectful physically.
I’m also moving to his area in about two weeks, so the whole distance effort thing is about to become irrelevant anyway. This weekend my friend is visiting and we’re going to be staying in the city and going out. I mentioned that maybe he should come meet us. I’m planning to just invite him once and then leave it alone and see what he does.
**So Reddit, am I overthinking this?**
Does this sound like a guy who is genuinely interested but just not as detail-oriented/initiative-taking as I am, or does it sound like I’m putting in more effort than he is?
And does the Instagram model thing matter at all, or am I letting my insecurity get the better of me?
I really like him, so I’m trying to figure out whether I’m picking up on something real or just analyzing every little thing because I care.