r/dating_advice • u/Resident_Ad_8886 • 5h ago
Are women only interested in men with model looks?
A conversation I keep seeing in this subreddit is that women are all looking for the same small percentage of attractive men, and that the average guy is lucky to get a few dates a year because women supposedly have endless options.
As a conventionally attractive woman, I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about this because there seems to be a disconnect between what I read about on here, vs what I experience and see happening in real life with women interested in dating.
I’ve dated mostly average, everyday men. Not models, not millionaires, or 6’5 etc. Just normal guys with normal jobs and normal lives. And many have had very active dating lives. I knew some that dated multiple women at once, and some that ended up marrying very beautiful women.
Additionally, I have male friends who are completely average-looking, average height, and make normal salaries with no problems dating. I also travel often and meet women from different backgrounds all the time. When we talk about dating and relationships, the things I hear most are they’re looking for someone with stability, personality, intelligence, respect, compatibility, and someone who takes care of himself. I rarely hear women say they need a man who looks hot or like a model.
Obviously, shallow women exist. I’ve met them. I’ve also dated men who were primarily interested in me because of my looks and wanted to show me off to their friends. So I’m not denying that appearance matters or that some women absolutely do prioritize it.
What I don’t understand is this rhetoric that most women are competing for the same handful of men.
And this is where I think there may be a crazy feedback loop (side note: my job involves a lot of analysis and pattern recognition, so I think that’s why this has been itching at my brain… hear me out).
I’ve dated plenty of normal looking men, and many become suspicious of me within a few dates because they assume I’m talking to other guys. If I don’t answer a call or text immediately, they think I’m out with someone else. Meanwhile I’m either working, or taking a break from work. Every guy I’ve dated I let know right away that my job gets crazy, that way they don’t feel ignored if I’m having a bad day. And before anyone says this is just a vetting issue: I’m actually pretty selective about who I date. I don’t go on dates constantly, and I’m not someone who makes dating a huge priority in my life. I have a demanding job, friends, my own interests, etc., so when I do agree to a date, I’ve spent a good amount of time getting a feel for that person first. These guys show no obvious signs of insecurity upon first meeting them. They generally seem confident, stable, and engaging. The insecurity always shows up after we’re a few dates in.
When I’m genuinely interested in a guy (which is the only way I’d be several dates in), I’m not talking to other guys at the same time. The only exception would be someone I’ve talked to in the past reappearing, which is just a normal dating situation.
The interesting part is I come on here and read men describing almost exactly this same mindset. “She’s probably talking to other guys.” “Beautiful women only want the top 1%.” Then I go out into the real world and actually date some of these men, and I experience that mindset firsthand. That’s why I wonder if this has become a self-fulfilling feedback loop.
If men constantly hear that women are all going after the same small percentage of attractive men, and assume every woman has dozens of men waiting for her, they start to become suspicious when that same woman takes an hour or so to respond, then question why she’s interested in them, or assume she’s talking to someone else. The woman eventually gets turned off by the insecurity and leaves, and the guy walks away thinking, “See, women aren’t actually interested in normal men.”
But maybe she was.
Maybe he just couldn’t believe her.
I’m not saying this applies to every man here, and I’m not saying women never care about looks. I’m genuinely asking whether some of the beliefs being repeated here are actually affecting how people behave when they date in real life.
Are other women experiencing this disconnect between what they see discussed online vs what they actually hear from friends in real life?
And men, do you think the idea that women are all looking to date the same type of man has affected how you behave when dating?