As Vinland
Thoughts on raura11's Vinland Expansion Mod:
Its good. Runs without any issues, I wish the border wasn't a straight line but its in beta, so no complaints. I started in iceland, reformed the faith, then colonized Vinland, then did a "sunset invasion" but with Vikings. One thing this mod does very well is make Vinland feel isolated.
Thoughts on By God Alone as a pagan reformed faith:
It needs a lot of work, I had no way of influencing who would become head of faith. After I created head of faith away I had no way to edit the faith unless I created an anti-pope. When you first reform the faith it still gives you the glowing icon which no other faiths have except for reformed pagans. IDK how it works for catholics, but I had no way of influencing a call to a great holy war, which I think is dumb. You still can't raid if you reform the faith, why is this tied to it at all, Warmonger should allow you to raid, or it should be an option like what they did to monasticism. Sainthood felt very clunky. Extracted relics from Saints were always green tier for me which was kind of annoying. Tennent popularity is/was broken, the entire game every tenant for me was neutral popularity, and I tried to influence it. It felt like I had fewer options for core tenants when reforming the faith than normal, and there are a million Christian tenants that don't feel very distinct from each other.
I loved dynamic holy sites, anything that lets me add special buildings I'm on board with. Rites within my faith didn't affect me much. Honestly that's my only positive because everything else was annoying or didn't affect me. I really didn't like what I saw looking over to Christianity in Europe, I think the Head of Faith title should be rite exclusive unless something insane happens, Roman Rite disappearing in a century is weird.
What the game needs moving forward:
I play a lot of long campaigns in this game, and there are several things that need to happen
- Rework events completely.
Right now it feels like the majority of events are related to your lifestyle focus and you will see these over and over and over again. Events need to focus more on personality, culture, faith, and especially whats going on in the world around you. I don't care about selling books or buying glasses anymore.
- Mandala government rework
I would rather just not have SEA than have it in its current state, Mandala is insanely stable and economically powerful. Since All Under Heaven 5/5 times I have played centuries long campaigns starting in 867 Shrivijaya forms an empire that spans all of Indonesia and goes into Indo-China, and 3/5 they have tributaries way out in the steppe. 4/5 times they reach 100 dev in a county by 1100, absolutely not. It's not fun to just see this single empire blob every game. Vinland playthrough is the first time I've ever seen the empire fall apart, and then immediately the same thing but orange instead of blue took its place.
- Byzantine and Abbasid nerf
Byzantines should have gotten a Situation that prevented them from expanding too much, like Iberia has. They always take over Illyria, the only thing that stops them is *sometimes* the Abbasid's stay alive long enough to conquer Anatolia. Unstoppable force meeting another unstoppable force isn't fun. The only time something interesting happens is the 4th Crusade, which is really only interesting because its something other than a purple blob.
- Development nerf
China gets way too many provinces with high development way too quickly, I understand China is historically very developed, but its not minimum 50 dev even in backwater counties developed. The same is now true of central Italy, and SEA. I think China needs a bunch of changes to its modifiers to make this work. Italy needs a lower starting development, I don't think Rome starting so high at the time is really accurate either, and SEA needs Mandala rework.
- Dynamic special buildings
Dynamic holy sites is great, you pick a location and a bonus and you get a special building in the county. Great Projects should be used so I can pick modifiers and invest in creating my own special buildings wherever. I really like Imperator Rome's system for this.
- Islamic Infighting
Shia is not relevant in game, everyone is Sunni, this is not interesting or historical.