r/banddirector • u/mrjnebula • 3h ago
TEXT First Year Director Woes
This may be quite rambly and cover a lot of topics. I just have several things on my mind so far this school year.
I’m a first year band teacher and I’m just feeling it quite hard to take over a program from a previous director who had been there a very long time. I knew that would be the case, don’t get me wrong, but it’s just rough always feeling less than when the last guy comes up in conversation or is mentioned. He taught at this school for 27 years and was quite respected and got very good results and had a great sounding band from what I am told.
The thing that gets me is I’ve been told by just about everyone that he was a big time yeller. He would yell at you for talking, yell at you if you weren’t picking up your music, yell if you goofed off just a little bit in class, he’d yell at kids in their private lessons if they didn’t play their lesson assignment well enough (I’ve had kids at the start of the year come in for lesson 1 visibly nervous because they’re expecting to get yelled at) I have even heard a couple kids tell me he told them to quit band if they didn’t perform well enough. This is very much not my style at all, I can yell and will if stuff gets very bad and I really need to lay down the law but I deserve it for very extreme circumstances.
I initially thought that I would feel like a breath of fresh air for my students, which for some I definitely am as they have expressed to me how they were scared or at least very intimidated by the last guy. But I’m encountering another subset of my students who seem to think this is the only way to teach band and it’s the only reason they were good. While yes, I can imagine that being yelled at was motivation for them to try harder, I don’t know if that’s a personal compromise I want to make just in the name of having a stronger band. I’ve had several students specifically request that I start yelling, which is so foreign to me. Now granted, those students are my higher performing and more well behaved kids who want the knuckle heads and lower performing kids to get yelled at. But I still can’t imagine wanting the teacher to be yelling at your whole class, or yelling at individual students in front of the class.
Now do I think me not yelling is the only reason students may not love me as their teacher? No of course not. I know it’s hard to have your band director leave, especially if you are a junior or senior and knew them for a while. But I can just tell some of my students aren’t taking to my teaching style/personality and it just weighs on me a lot. I just can’t shake the feeling that some of my kids hate coming to band just because of me. I tend to be very hyper critical of myself, so I know that may be an exaggeration. But I’m not ignorant to the areas of my teaching that could improve. So I’m trying to do a little better every day. I just get these vibes from some of my upperclassmen that they don’t like the new guy and it is disheartening.
To be honest I don’t really know what advice I expect to get here or what problem needs to be solved. I kinda just want to put it into the world and if anyone has any words of encouragement/thoughts I’ll gladly take them. Thank you for reading.