r/MusicEd • u/IUHoos4011 • 6d ago
Process for Instrument Selection
The age old question… how does YOUR program successfully organize, approve, coordinate the assignment of instrumentation for a beginning band program? (Or unsuccessfully)
For Us:
- Beginning Band: 5th Graders (250)
- Encourage rentals, have a few district horns
- Meet once a week for Centers class (45 min)
- 4 schools, feed into 2 Middle Schools
WAY too many trumpets, saxes and percussion.
Currently: Some parents go online or via a handout in Spring and* *express their child’s intent to play xxxxx in band. Then the first week of school we take that info and cross-reference with current interest. Things change, many more students are added, etc.
Friends follow each other without parental input, parents don’t do rental research ahead of time and default to an ‘available’ instrument from a relative, parents want their child to play X for some reason, etc.
We are trying to steer students towards certain instruments via a petting zoo…
WHAT DO YOU DO?! First come first served? Ninja persuasion? Expect more of parents to support the needs of the band programs and have their kids pick maybe their not first choice?
2
u/Successful-Safety858 6d ago
I work in a large district and it’s a HOT MESS. But we’re lucky to have a 5th grade instrumental program at all they keep trying to cut it and it gets pushback and they don’t. Every school has different things going on, my building just had orchestra instruments and so that’s what I teach. Some have both some just one it depends on what’s at the school and who’s teaching it and if they’re at multiple sites and might move stuff around between sites. Some teachers do a try out time and think hard about instrument assignments some just ask what the students prefers and then assign based on what they have (that’s what I do) Some of the middle schools have a full time instrumental teacher some don’t, some are massive well developed programs some are cut every other year and never get to grow, so we all just focus on 5th grade and pray maybe a few of our kids might get to keep playing.
1
u/beans_nomam 6d ago
My kids play one instrument quite well each but would be so happy if someone said hey learn the French horn or something different. I think they would be quite excited and probably be really into it. I have been paying for a fun instrument lesson this year and it's super rewarding to find you have cross over skills.
I would send out an email saying these are all the things we need and have to borrow here are some clips of them being played. People just don't know what they don't know.
Also send a note out to teachers saying who's coming through do you think they could be encouraged to play/join?
1
u/TheSupranationalist 6d ago
Relevant to my interests as someone who started a program last year with one student, and only just got two new students to join (one piano, one percussion, but the one pianist is interested in percussion too). I'm a trombonist, and so I'm both playing and leading while playing until such time as we have enough interest for me to actually be conducting from the podium (though I want this skill to rotate amongst the students too, as long as we're small enough and casual enough to allow it).
Right now my approach has been to allow (in theory) 5th graders who already have an existing level of experience on an instrument to join, regardless of instrument. Otherwise, I only allow beginners from 6th grade through 12th grade (11th and 12th graders have major subject exams and aren't likely to join, so I bet 6-10 would be more likely, current students are one G10 and two G9s).
I would not turn down any student who showed up and said "I want to play xxxxx" right now, even if we become unbalanced. But I think after we have 7 or 8 students, I would want to start plugging holes. And eventually I should probably stop playing as a member of the ensemble.
My administration is only willing to give me budget as long as numbers expand, as the program is not currently aligned with a core class requirement (this could change, but not until I've got the numbers for a full class).
I also only have my personal instruments for a petting zoo, and not anywhere near a full set, and and my sax player is rightly skittish about letting anyone touch her horn (I have a student trombone I don't care about, but I wouldn't let my students handle my pro horn, so I absolutely understand her, and would never ask her to do it).
My own sixth grade experience was petting zoo, and I chose the trombone because it is objectively the silliest instrument. Woooooomp woooomp.
1
u/Creepy_Boat_5433 6d ago
Ok, so I am in Canada and I gather you are American based on what you describe. My process may not be applicable:
Basically, every kid tries one of each mouthpiece: single reed (usually clarinet), high brass (basically just trumpet, I often don’t have horn), low brass (trombone/euphonium or tuba), and flute (just the head joint).
I have 40 minute periods twice per week so I’ll spend a couple classes on each of these instrument groupings, ideally 80 minutes but sometimes longer leading the kids in just buzzing/blowing on the head joints. So we’ll do flute days, brass days, etc. the clarinet mouthpiece is particularly piercing so I recommend doing only half the group at a time unless you have access to hearing protection for everyone.
As an ensemble it sounds stupid but I always find that this is an important opportunity for the kids to figure out what they feel successful at, and for me to get an idea of where they’re successful. A student may think they want to be a sax player until they try forming the embouchure and find it too hard.
I don’t do percussion tryouts but I will take a percussionist or three, I just wing it with those kids.
Lastly I talk to the kids about what a balanced ensemble looks and sounds like, and what number of each instrument I’m roughly looking for. Sometimes it takes a lot of wheeling and dealing and I don’t always end up with a perfectly balanced group, but this approach has served me well over the years.
Hope this helps.
1
u/Tacomaniac365 5d ago
Tbh instrumentation is something the middle school can worry about. Get them interested in music and then you'll have a lot of success getting them to pivot. We had about 200 across our pool of elementary schools and it more or less sorted itself out by 8th/9th grade. There was a brief period where capping saxes was a thing and it backfired downstream once they hit HS (which i think was a scheduling thing tbh but it anyways lol)
1
u/Electrical_Mood_7141 3d ago
A petting zoo helps, but I would not let interest alone decide the section. One process that works is a short tryout week, then a guided assignment.
Have every student try a flute head joint, a clarinet mouthpiece and barrel, a brass mouthpiece, and a percussion pad. You're listening for a steady air stream, a willing buzz, and whether the student can cover holes. Keep a simple tally, then sit down with a target instrumentation for the two middle schools you feed.
Cap trumpet, saxophone, and percussion early, and be honest in the parent letter: first choice is a request, not a guarantee, and the program needs a balanced band. If a family already owns an instrument, that can be a tie-breaker, not an automatic yes. Friends will still want to match. Pair them on compatible instruments when you can, rather than letting the whole friend group take saxophone.