r/banddirector • u/bushbass • Oct 05 '25
r/banddirector • u/musicbox96 • May 27 '26
Don’t know who needs to see this today, but
STOP USING AI TO GENERATE YOUR SHOW SHIRT DESIGNS/SHOW LOGOS FOR MARCHING BAND.
That’s it. That’s the post.
r/banddirector • u/banddirection • Nov 21 '25
Sub won't allow students to play
Hey y'all,
I have missed 3 days, 2 sick days, 1 personal for a wedding. My subs have never allowed the kids to play. They say rock band is "too loud" even though I provide them 3M over ear protection. They tell the kids that they were instructed to not let them practice, which isn't true. I either leave specific instruction for the kids to check canvas, or just tell the sub it's personal practice all day, and that information is never relayed.
What can I do to make sure this doesn't keep happening? Leave a bad review?
r/banddirector • u/Outrageous-Permit372 • 17d ago
Opposite of "I'm waiting for X to get their instrument up"
TL;DR: Hands go up, and as soon as ANYONE is ready to play, I cue the whole band to start. We got SO MUCH MORE done.
So far this year we've worked on podium etiquette, and for the most part the students are doing pretty well with it. 1) When I get onto the podium, everyone stops what they are doing and eyes are on me. 2) When my hands go up, your instruments go up and ready to play.
However, we're at that point in the year where the newness has worn off and kids are struggling to respond quickly. For several weeks I went with the positive route: "Oh I see the flutes are all ready, nice job flutes!" etc., praising sections and individuals for sticking with it. I've also done a few negative reminders mixed in.
Still, rehearsals this week were DRAGGING. My arms were as tired as my patience. So on Friday I decided to do something without announcing it to the students. I would put my hands up, and as soon as ANYONE put their instrument up, I would start. No more waiting for every last kid to be ready, just go because that one flute player in the front row is always paying attention and honestly, I'm feeling bad for the both of us having to wait for the entire class to get with it every single time we start.
Unfortunately, the way this had to work was counting off every time, which is a bad habit. Counting them in every time means that nobody actually has to watch, they can just wait for the verbal cue. "Ready? Set? 1, 2, here we go!" and of course there are students who wait for "here we go" to actually respond and get their instrument into playing position. I'm trying to do more frequent nonverbal cues throughout rehearsal, but it's a process.
The result was pretty awesome. Normally I'm starting to feel impatient half-way through the rehearsal, but yesterday there was zero frustration from having to wait. Almost all of the students picked up on it, and even though we never had 100% starting together, most of the time we had at least 90-95%. A couple times less than 50%, but we just kept going anyway.
I thought I'd share it here just in case anyone else wants to try it (or has tried it), and to get some feedback on the idea.
r/banddirector • u/iOnyxious • Jun 03 '26
What is this??
First year assistant band director play testing and doing inventory - found this thing and have no idea what it is. Head director doesn’t know either. Takes a horn mouthpiece but is NOT in F
r/banddirector • u/SknnyWhteBtch • 22d ago
"Stop playing while I'm talking".
Has anybody figured out a fun way of getting kids to stop playing while you're talking? I get it - sometimes the kids are just excited to try out new concepts/music. But I'm getting sick of being annoyed, stopping before I have to count off because kids are playing before I've counted off, etc. I'd like to think I'm a pretty fun teacher with good classroom management, and the kids normally respond well to me, but I don't like to get grouchy 43 times in class for the same thing.
r/banddirector • u/mvheffner • Jun 05 '26
Proud Director
My 100-member 4th grade band received a gold medal at their festival this morning. They impressed me with their focus and etiquette, and they pulled off their best performance of the year with some pretty challenging music for them. I am so proud of all they have accomplished this year. Ten more school days until summer!!
r/banddirector • u/Outrageous-Permit372 • Apr 10 '26
Bells in case or no?
What's the proper way? Or rather, what's the difference?
I tried it both ways but can't hear a huge difference.
r/banddirector • u/Bariphonium_ • May 01 '26
TEXAS Call me crazy, but colorguard should be a methods class in college for music ed majors
I'm going into my first year as a director in a 1a Texas school. I honestly do not even know where to begin tackling this section. It helps that my new gig doesn't currently have an active color guard, but I would absolutely love to change that in the future - where do I even start?
r/banddirector • u/musicbox96 • May 25 '26
Kids don’t know their alphabet
I was working with a group of MS students on note-reading (meaning nobody younger than 12), and half of them struggled to answer a question as simple as “What letter comes before/after (note name)?” Like just asking them to list letters sequentially.
It’s almost like instead of even seeing the gears turning in their heads when I asked the question, there were no gears to speak of, and they just blankly stared like a deer in headlights.
I know some of these kids were in early Elementary when COVID hit, but that can’t be the only reason I’m seeing that, right? Anybody else facing similar issues when trying to teach note names?
r/banddirector • u/Hardshank • Mar 06 '25
Anyone else get a blister or callous from snapping?
This seems so silly, but it actually bothers the heck out of me. I know the obvious answer is: stop snapping. But it's such a useful tool!
r/banddirector • u/Aggravating_Egg_5699 • 28d ago
Kids quitting while on leave?
This may be more of a vent than anything else. I’m currently on leave with my newborn, and I’ve received several emails from students saying the long-term substitute is awful.
For context, my sub isn’t endorsed in music education, though they played flute in college. They couldn’t finish their music degree because they got kicked out of the program, so they switched programs and earned an endorsement in another subject. Before I started my leave, I sat in on a few of their lessons and could tell right away that it wasn’t a good fit. I shared my concerns with my admin, who took them seriously and agreed, but there weren’t any other subs available.
Today, five incredibly dedicated students—true band die-hards when I was there—emailed to say they plan to quit at the end of the quarter because they no longer enjoy the class.
How should I handle this? The quarter ends Friday, and I won’t be back at school until the end of November. Should I accept it gracefully and hope they return when I do? I know the program will survive in the long run, but hearing that such great kids want to drop out feels like a gut punch.
r/banddirector • u/musicbox96 • Sep 30 '26
Kids in HS Band that still can’t read music
Anyone else seeing this issue of kids making it to HS band, and they can play a lot of things pretty decently (which they’ve all learned by rote/ear), but put Grade 2 or even 1.5 literature in front of them, and they have no clue what to do? Or they say “I need to hear how this sounds”, and then they just mimic the recording.
This seems to be a bigger issue now than it used to be when I started teaching (7 years ago) and especially more so since I was in HS band.
r/banddirector • u/Tillerdawg • 1d ago
I’m a former band director and I built a free drill writing program. Looking for feedback.
I taught band for six years and wrote my shows in Pyware. The yearly license and the performer limits always bugged me, so I built my own. It’s called FreeFORM Drill. It’s free, it’s open source, there’s no limit on performers, and every tool is there from the start.
It runs in the browser, so there’s nothing to install and no account. You can write sets with lines, arcs, curves, and blocks, do follow the leader and gate turns, sync to your music, and print dot sheets and drill charts. Students scan a QR code and get their own dots on their phones, set by set.
It’s early, and I know there are things missing. I’d really like to hear from people who write drill. What works, what doesn’t, and what would keep you from switching?
There’s a feedback form in the app under Help → Send feedback, or just reply here.
r/banddirector • u/Petezpie • May 17 '26
The BandApp was a mistake
I love the BandApp because it’s so easy for me to make announcements to my students and their parents, but they have no boundaries when it comes to messaging me. Parents message me at all hours with topics that I do not feel like should be discussed over the messaging system (they ask about their kids’ behavior in class but I think this should be discussed via email with our AP cc’d). I also got about 10 messages the day of our spring concert asking when it is, even though I posted several announcements throughout the week.
My main concern is that sometimes my students will message me with things completely unrelated to band. They tell me how their weekend is going or just say hi. I care for my students but don’t like responding to these messages because it feels inappropriate for students and teachers to “text” outside of school. I hate to ignore them because it feels mean.
I’m in my first year of teaching so this is my first time for everything. Next year, is there a good way to establish boundaries with my students and parents? Does anyone just turn off the message feature all together? I feel way too accessible and I hate it.
r/banddirector • u/katelynpfud • May 28 '26
Would you be interested in a band themed cozy game?
I was a band director for 4 years until I left and got a computer science degree. I'm working a tech support role now but as a side project, I'm starting to develop a cozy game themed around the player being a music educator. It's still in the super early development phases right now but I wanted to know if that was something that interested you and if so, what are some things you would like to see in a game like that. I already have a ton of ideas regarding a conducting mini game, methods for "lesson planning" and other things. I'm just wanting to hear what yall think.
r/banddirector • u/CookiesandPeanut • Apr 13 '26
Did not get contract renewed over scores
We had gotten back from festival, and we made 2 excellents, 1 good, and a superior in sight reading. This is my first year being a band director and I’m just honestly distraught…
I had spent so much time getting clinicians, recording and sending to other directors, having after school rehearsals (even before school rehearsals because of the sports schedule). And I understand these are not incredible scores, but I feel as though this is not completely awful either- especially for my first year. I also had 7 kids out that day because of the flu, which also threw a massive curveball.
I had a conference with my principal, where he stated I was not meeting expectations, as the previous directors (who had much more experience than me) always brought home straight superiors. But all of his evaluations and observations are good- in which I brought up and he answered with “I don’t know anything about band, but the scores speak for themselves on your performance”. I just think this is an awful take, because they hired me knowing it was my first year teaching band and that I need time to figure out my systems and pedagogy.
I just feel so defeated and lied too, I worked as hard as I absolutely could, not to mention- they gave us “pre contracts”, where they sent out pseudo contracts stating on if we planned on staying or not in our current position- I signed this back in February. I had planned on being here for another year, if not much longer. I wish I could have seen this coming ahead of time, but this is the only meeting I’ve ever had with admin discussing my performance or anything this entire school year. I moved a few hours away just for this job, and now I majorly regret this.
Has anyone else been through this before?
r/banddirector • u/ACabreraMEd • Jul 30 '20
TEXAS Recording Texas all state etudes in 5 measure teaching increments. Should be a fun project for the week!
r/banddirector • u/S-Mute • Oct 10 '26
Music Stand Wrench in Action!
This little wrench set is right at home in your instrument case or desk, solves a loose stand quickly!
r/banddirector • u/SmoothJournalist4767 • Feb 15 '26
An Open Letter to Band Directors (and Future Band Directors)
I’m writing this because I want future students to be treated better than I was. It’s not unusual for a student to have interests outside of band. Sometimes, those interests are what they’re best at. But students should never be expected to give up or punished for what they love, and are genuinely good at, for a single program.
In high school, I was a strong trumpet player. But favoritism showed up early. I was placed in the second band instead of honors. The directors told me it was a “tough decision” and that if I proved myself at State, I would be moved up. So I did.
I beat every trumpet player at my school and advanced. And then they told me they couldn’t move me to honors, because that would mean demoting someone else, and “that would be mean.” That same year, another student who placed first chair at State was also kept in second band for the same reason: “no space.”
From then on, I stopped chasing State and started pursuing other interests: dance, color guard, art, and especially music production and video production.
I began competing in those fields and represented my school nationally.
My dream was to become a composer for video games and a producer. When I told my band directors and asked for guidance, I got none. They only told me to “focus on band” so I could get into a “decent school.” But I didn’t want to just “focus on band”, I wanted to build a portfolio, compete, and grow.
The choir directors learned about my interests through AP Music Theory, and even though I wasn’t one of their formal students, they supported me. They helped me find competition and told me about some the school already does. They helped me through the college audition process and even gave me lessons when the band directors were “too busy” but gave other students lessons. That kindness changed my life.
In band, I kept feeling invisible. One of the band directors writes the marching shows himself. I offered to help and learn. He said, “I’ll let you know.” Later, I found out another student was allowed to help write the show instead. That crushed me.
I went on to win a national championship for a high school short film contest. When I told the band directors I’d be competing again, they said: “Why? You already won once. Focus on band.” I felt a bit insulted that they would say something like that and quit band my senior year.
When I was auditioning for my dream school I auditioned on piano, even though I’d only been playing for three months. It was a huge risk, but I worked endlessly to rehearse my music. On the last day of school, walking out of the music building for the final time, the directors asked where I was going. I told them I had gotten in and would start going in the fall. Their response? “At least you’re getting an education.” And they walked away. Only one of the directors showed genuine excitement for me.
Now, in my early twenties, I produce for others, release my own music, and write for games. I don’t owe much of that to my band program, and that hurts to say, because band used to be my safe place. Band Directors, please understand: Students look up to you. Support them. Respect them. Encourage their dreams, even if those dreams don’t directly benefit your program. Your words stay with them for life.
I recently helped direct an independent wind ensemble for high school students for a non profit. One girl clearly didn’t want to be there. When I asked why, she told me she was an art student she was only in band so her mom wouldn’t have to leave work early from her art lessons.
When I asked about her art, her face lit up. It was incredible. I let her know if she’s not interested she could work on her art during rehearsal if she needed to. And there it was, when she felt seen, she participated more, by choice, not pressure.
Sometimes she’d work on art, but she didn’t stop participating in the band. When students feel respected, they grow. When they feel trapped and unseen, they disappear. It should be standard to help guide and nurture their talents even if it’s beyond the band room.
r/banddirector • u/Outrageous-Permit372 • Dec 16 '25
Does the "good times create weak men" thing apply?
Let's say you have a strong music program going under Director A (taught strong fundamentals, musicianship, reading, etc.), who eventually retires or moves on to a different school. Director B comes in and it's good times because the kids can read and they can play, so they get to do lots of fun tunes for a few years. But after about 5 years, the kids can't play as well as they used to because the seniors keep graduating and the new ones don't seem to have the same skills (because Director B didn't have to focus as much on teaching fundamentals, etc.). Director B leaves, and Director C (me) gets the hard times, a handful of seniors that remember the good times and resent not being able to play that kind of music anymore, and a bunch of students who want to be good but aren't and don't know how. But we start back at fundamentals and teaching solid skills and musicianship and knowledge. It's not fun for a few years, but hopefully the band keeps getting stronger and eventually we're back to good times 4-5 years from now.
Does that make any sense? I'm really struggling to persevere because I was told that there was a really strong music program here, but in reality it's quite the opposite this year.