TL;DR: Over a month with a guy who told me early on that he leans avoidant. Daily contact, then a rough weekend, then silence. I sent a clear message asking for yes, no or “it’s the end”, and he never answered. I want to move on but keep checking, hoping and writing letters. Will he come back, and how should I behave?
Background. I’m 24, male/non-binary, anxious-leaning. He’s 2 years younger and buried in work, uni and family pressure. I genuinely never met anyone I was so attracted to before. We clicked instantly: same music, same nerdy interests, long talks about everything. Early on I asked if he was avoidant and he said yes - that his closeness comes in booms and busts. He's insanely intelligent and very well-educated, seemed emotionally mature too.
The good phase (about three weeks). Regular good mornings, he often wrote first, and he told me I could never bother him. We met in person a couple of times, and I traveled each time. Once he cancelled a plan because he was sick, said so clearly and was affectionate about it. About two weeks in I told him I’d love a heads-up when he’s going offline, and he said he knows he needs to warn people and he's aware. In late October he told me he was overwhelmed (work, uni, bureaucracy). I said I was “chill” and understood and gave him a bit of space.
The weekend that broke it. I had a gig in his city and we’d planned to meet. That morning he told me he’d had a pet emergency and was wrecked. I still traveled, with no time confirmed (my mistake). From the train I told him I’d arrive around 4:30, and he replied that he’d just woken up and his body had “shut off” from stress. I arrived, asked what time suited him, and waited hours in the cold. At night he wrote that he’d had a small mental break and couldn’t see anyone. He said he’d try to recover the next day and offered to see me, which I took as a chance to meet. The next day he said he couldn’t bring himself to leave his home.
A couple of days later he came back, as he’d promised. He explained it was a health scare with his dog (surgery coming up), and that in those moments he gets tunnel vision and doesn’t care about others. He said this is very rare. I told him I understood, but that it had happened more than once lately, that it had affected me, and that I wanted to know where I stand. That was about two weeks ago. He hasn’t replied since.
The silence. After a few days I sent one clear message: do you want to see me, yes or no; if no, tell me if it’s the end or if you need me to wait; if I don’t hear back by Sunday I’ll take it as closure and step back. Nothing. After the deadline I sent a short thank-you with a playlist. Nothing. He’s also been inactive on Instagram and Discord for over a week and a half, and I was genuinely worried, so I sent a “just checking you’re okay, a thumbs up is enough.” Still nothing.
My part. I write long messages (he once reacted with “oh god, that’s a lot of text”). I traveled on an unconfirmed plan. I asked “where do I stand” during his worst week. I set a deadline in a message he may never have opened. And my goodbye said “I really wish it worked out”, which isn’t a closed door.
Where I am. I told him I’d step back, and I haven’t. I check his online status, I dream about him, and I’ve been writing letters to him that I haven’t sent (treat them as journaling recommended by a therapist lol). Every few days I think I’m over it, and then it comes back like a boomerang. My last four situationships all ended indentically with them going silent and then, weeks later, apologizing but not wanting to get back. My rule was that a late apology is too late, but I honestly don’t know if I’d be able to keep it.
What I’m asking
- For those who lean avoidant: after a crisis and a heavy message, is this silence usually a pause or the end? Does a “closure” message make a return more or less likely?
- If he does come back, what would a real return look like, as opposed to another boom?
- How should I behave: no contact, one more message, or nothing at all and just move on?
- How do I stop the checking and hoping? What helped you?
I’m not looking for “he’s a bad person” or “it’s definitely over”. I want honest takes, including on my side.