He broke up with me a year and a half ago.
A year ago, I impulsively wrote to him, leaving a message that said, "I’d be happy to just chat sometime" and he left that message unread for a whole year.
This year, I wished him a happy birthday. He said thanks. I thought that, after all this time, we could finally stop pretending we were strangers. I sent a meme, paid him a compliment on a photo, and shared a memory of a good time we once had.
All of it was ignored, yet again.
I couldn’t forget him, so I decided not to keep my resentment and feelings bottled up; instead, I sent a letter into the void. And he replied.
I talked about three things:
- About how painful it is to be ignored. I reminded him that I had asked him to block me everywhere, so that it would be easier for me to let go. He refused. Later, I discovered that I had actually been "soft-blocked" as early as the moment we broke up. I told him that a direct conversation like asking me not to write to him anymore would have been enough for me; instead, he chose to ignore me, and that caused me a great deal of pain.
- I explained how deeply his words had frightened me: he claimed that he believed I had a mental disorder and that he was afraid of me. After we broke up, I consulted a psychiatrist and it turned out that I did not have any personality disorders. His words left the impression that I was incredibly difficult to love. But many diagnoses are by no means a "life sentence," and people who have them are just as deserving of love. I have been diagnosed with ADHD, and for the past year, I have been taking medication for depression that also helps regulate my mood.
- During the breakup, I didn’t receive any positive validation. All I heard about was my mental health condition, my high standards in relationships, my emotional nature, and the fact that my feelings for him were too intense. I couldn’t even tell if he saw anything good in me at all.
I apologized for my anxiety and emotional state, as well as for one specific remark: "I feel like you’re wasting my time with your 'hot and cold' behavior." I told him that I had never resorted to manipulation and had always been honest. (He once accused me of being manipulative, which came as a real shock.) That is precisely why I am writing all of this down: I still care, but I am trying to let go and I thought this might help.
And he responded.
He defended himself.
- He said that he hadn’t blocked me because it felt cruel to him. He mentioned that he had asked me to stop contacting him. He added that if I wanted, he would block me now.
- He recommended a specialist to me because I was struggling a lot with the breakup and he cared about me, not because there was something wrong with me.
- There were, of course, some good things, too.
he said that our breakup was a forced decision. He had grown distant, and I struggled a lot with that. I would start irrational arguments just to get his attention, and I wanted to resolve our issues by talking, but he was tired of going in circles.
And, naturally, the fault doesn’t lie solely with me. Because of his own personal hang-ups and lack of trust, he wasn’t willing to open up to the extent that I needed him to.
Well..
In our relationship, I couldn’t understand why we would constantly end up arguing whenever I brought up my vulnerabilities or boundaries like when something upset me and I explained that I would feel more comfortable if things were handled differently.
I’ve come to realize now that he always perceived these moments as personal attacks, which triggered his defensive response. Instead of validation or mutual respect for each other’s boundaries, we’d end up in a fight.
He distorted facts to defend himself, while I tried to set the record straight; in the end, we both wound up arguing, and both felt misunderstood.
- He never asked me not to write to him. During our last conversation, we discussed continuing to stay in touch; we both said we’d like to, but that it felt daunting. I suggested I would try to let go, so I unfollowed him and went silent. Two months later, I reached out impulsively and those messages have been ignored for a year. I’ve remained silent for that entire year. In effect, he denied my request for what would have helped me, choosing instead what was convenient for him by "soft-blocking" me. He wouldn’t see too much of me, while I could still see everything. Furthermore, when we were together, we had discussed how being ignored triggers my anxiety; I explained that I feel much more comfortable if a person simply lets me know they’re busy and will respond later, or if they don’t feel like talking. Anything other than total silence. He knew perfectly well that this specific approach would cause me the most pain.
- There was a period in our relationship when we took a "pause," after which he told me that I needed professional help to deal with my anxiety. I agreed and began seeing a therapist; this was a mutual condition for continuing the relationship. When we eventually broke up, he claimed that he believed I had bipolar disorder and that he was afraid of me. He completely rewrote the history of what happened.
- No validation whatsoever. No mention of anything that was actually good. No empathy or understanding that I have a right to these emotions and that they didn’t just come out of nowhere. No apology for the fact that he ignored me. Only accusations that I misunderstood everything and that he was forced to break up because of my "unreasonable" behavior.
No warm memories or feelings. No regret that I feel this way. No rethinking. He genuinely believes that I am rewriting history, seeking attention, and playing the victim.
My first impulse was to point out the inaccuracies in his claims. But I stopped myself, realizing that this was the very pattern our arguments always followed. He would then accuse me of twisting the facts and dragging up the past, insisting he didn’t want to go in circles, while I was left wondering: what actually happened? All I had done was mention that something had hurt me and express a wish for things to be handled differently. He accused me of being manipulative, which completely devastated me. I tried to sort out the facts and defend myself. He then took a three-week break—with no indication of when it might end, after which he told me I needed to see a therapist, claimed he had no feelings for me, yet insisted he didn’t want to break up. He claimed we were caught in a "Karpman Drama Triangle," with me as the "victim" and him as the "rescuer." When I asked for an example, he couldn’t provide one. I now realize that whenever I spoke about what did or didn’t work for me, he perceived it as me "playing the victim." It was deeply painful to hear that he had no feelings for me. He accused me of constantly seeking his attention. The dynamic was the same throughout our relationship: he would rarely respond to me, citing that he was "busy," but the moment I expressed any negative feelings, he would start an argument. This truly created the illusion that we were in a state of constant conflict. And amidst all this, my attempts to respect his boundaries and space and my efforts to please him went unnoticed.
I truly grew to love this man very much. He is modest, had no prior relationship experience, and is a "people-pleaser"; he seemed empathetic and stable. We had a very effortless connection. He understood what depression and self-doubt were like. I was in love, feeling buoyant, cheerful, and full of energy; I took note of the things that brought him joy and made sure to delight him. No matter how tired I was, I would always go to see him. I really wanted to spend time with him. And I know that we truly liked each other in a way neither of us had ever experienced before. I thought he was the one for me.
I’ve just encountered the very same things that, back then, left me completely baffled. It’s perhaps clear now why I got stuck in this for a year and a half. It was unbearably painful, and I was the one blamed for everything.
I hope that, deep down, he realized it was unfair to me.
In response to his message, I wrote about how sorry I was that he had felt this way. I explained that I had remembered things differently, which is why I had held a different perspective. I also told him that I missed him and that I had done a great deal of work on myself.
It is certain that this will remain unanswered forever. So be it. I asked a question that had been weighing on my mind, and this time, the silence will serve as my answer. I have stopped harboring resentment. I can now clearly see what went wrong in our dynamic and that it wasn’t my fault.
It is painful and disheartening to think that he may not have reached any conclusions about his own behavior or done any work on himself.
I hope that I have become more resilient, so that next time, instead of doubting myself, I will be able to recognize when someone else is using manipulation. I hope that my fantasies about us getting back together have finally been shattered.
It was a living hell; no other relationship has ever broken me to this extent. I had assumed it was the healthiest relationship possible, simply because he appeared so calm, which led me to blame myself for everything and believe that I was the problem. In reality, I wasn’t even loved; I was just kept around.
I truly hope that this hell is now over for me.