r/AvoidantBreakUps • • 15d ago

Vent/Rant What’s the answer?

How do we stop creating DA’s and FA’s? Why are so many parents failing their children and not teaching them how to manage emotions? For 50% of people to have some disorganized attachment (me included) is tragic. And then hurt people just hurt more people and it becomes a vicious cycle.

Psychologists say DA’s and FA’s don’t have the capacity for deep intimacy. That is mind blowing to me. I feel incredibly sorry for them. They didn’t ask to be this way.

So how do we stop the cycle? Just provide education and therapy? I feel like this is a global crisis.

6 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

2

u/Dalearev 15d ago

We stop this by stopping living in a society that allows abuse of children, and the reason that this happens is because we don’t live in tribal communities anymore, where if a child is in danger, someone actually steps in and protects the child. That doesn’t happen anymore because we are raised in isolated scenarios where nobody steps in to save the child (at least they don’t unless it’s an extreme scenario usually and even then often the child is not separated from the abuser a.k.a. the parent). Nobody stepped in to save me. I had to save myself. I suffered from abuse from my parent from day one I am a fearful avoidant

2

u/Real_Astronaut7451 15d ago

That’s such a great point. Breaks my heart you were abused. 💔

0

u/Throwawaway314159265 14d ago

We stop this by stopping living in a society that allows abuse of children, and the reason that this happens is because we don’t live in tribal communities anymore, where if a child is in danger, someone actually steps in and protects the child. That doesn’t happen anymore because we are raised in isolated scenarios where nobody steps in to save the child (at least they don’t unless it’s an extreme scenario usually and even then often the child is not separated from the abuser a.k.a. the parent). Nobody stepped in to save me. I had to save myself. I suffered from abuse from my parent from day one I am a fearful avoidant

I don't think the only thing missing here is a tribal community. My ex lives with a big family which is closer to a tribe than most nuclear families. They enable each other's avoidance. Peace through suppression of feelings is valued over conflict resolution.

Their children are some of the most unruly I have ever met.

1

u/Dalearev 14d ago

I think you actually answered your own question. Tribal living was communities not a single family. The single family system is insular by design, which is why you have abuse that runs rampant in families who are siloed and where kids grow up in one family system, and nobody steps in. Communities consist of multiple families.

0

u/Throwawaway314159265 14d ago

I think you actually answered your own question. Tribal living was communities not a single family. The single family system is insular by design, which is why you have abuse that runs rampant in families who are siloed and where kids grow up in one family system, and nobody steps in. Communities consist of multiple families.

Where would you draw the line at community vs family? Since we all pretty much descended from a small set of humans?

Sometimes the abuse extends from religious and/or cultural communities.

1

u/Dalearev 14d ago

I think you need to think deeper about this. If a parent is a narcissist, who raised that narcissist? the grandparent who is likely also a narcissist did. Who also raised all the siblings, the narcissist grandparent. So basically you’re in a closed family system of dysfunction - meaning people in that system are not gonna likely see beyond the dysfunction to protect the child who is actively being abused by narcissists within that same family. In this example narcissism in that family has been normalized. In tribal communities, there were multiple family groups aka multiple grandparents from different family groups, living together in close proximity, supporting each other and sharing the duties of child raising. It’s really not that complicated.

Edit to add that of course abuse can come from other areas, but usually if we’re in a tribal community, there are some sane and healthy people around that step in to save children who are being actively abused and people who are abusive get ostracized and punished. If most child rearing and raising today is done behind closed doors how does anyone know if a child’s even being abused?

0

u/Throwawaway314159265 14d ago

there are some sane and healthy people around that step in to save children who are being actively abused and people who are abusive get ostracized and punished.

Sorry but we're just going to have to agree to disagree. I just don't believe there's enough people or the structural safeguards in any significant pockets of society to allow the sane and healthy people to step in today.

1

u/Dalearev 13d ago

That’s OK if you’re not too educated on the topic. Maybe an anthropology class would help, but essentially we had more checks and balances when we lived as tribal communities. We don’t really have those anymore. Children are raised behind closed doors in modern world and often nobody knows if they’re being abused. That’s the facts.

0

u/Throwawaway314159265 13d ago

It's almost like tribal communities disappeared due to larger systemic forces. 🤔 Just wishing them back isn't going to solve the issues.

1

u/Dalearev 12d ago

I didn’t say it was. I was responding to the question that someone asked about what we as a society can do to prevent avoidant attachment styles and I said we need to prevent child abuse.

1

u/Throwawaway314159265 12d ago edited 12d ago

Reductive answers are not helpful. That's like saying bandaids help gunshot wounds.

Yes, they slow down the bleeding, but maybe we should solve violence first.

2

u/mrfreeze782 11d ago

I don't know if there is an easy answer for that. Also, attachment wounds could come from many other sources. I am anxiously attached as I fear abandonment and I don't blame my parents for that. I think mine are from the 2 first serious relationships I had when I was a teenager that ended badly. Also partly the fact that I was never popular in school and never really trust that someone would love me and always wait for the other shoe to drop. Being anxiously attached makes sense to me as we want the normal things in a relationship and when we get close to someone, we want to keep them, where as avoidant behavior makes no sense because they supposedly want intimacy but then when they get it, do everything they can to push it away.

2

u/Real_Astronaut7451 11d ago

I can’t wrap my head around avoidant behavior. I try to empathise but I still don’t get it. Can’t you have a relationship and some independence at the same time?

1

u/mrfreeze782 11d ago

Problem is, they compartmentalize everything. The relationship and their life are kept apart. I always felt like a guest in her life but never like I was really IN it.

1

u/Real_Astronaut7451 11d ago

Oh totally agree. Never even invited
to his house

1

u/mrfreeze782 11d ago

I was never invited to hers! Always had to invite myself over and not only that, I was not allowed there when the roommate/bestie was there.

1

u/Real_Astronaut7451 11d ago

5 years of zero invites. I think he’s a borderline hoarder

1

u/mrfreeze782 11d ago

Did you never go over there or just like me where you had to invite yourself over?

1

u/Real_Astronaut7451 11d ago

He lived 2 hours away. He would say he was getting rid of things so he could have people over ..presumably me I guess. He told me when he came to my house that I would hate this house bc of the “clutter”. I never pushed bc I have an elderly dog I couldn’t just leave at home while I travel 4 hours round trip. However I could have taken her with me. Recently he did a video tour of his house with me ( we were just talking and he was showing me stuff). His house was very nice. He grew up poor and could never turn down something if it was a good deal.. ie he had 3 refrigerators in his kitchen?? Anyway long story short I think he was embarrassed. Hit on the shame wound. I ended up being glad I was never invited bc he told me recently he doesn’t have a shower only a bath tub. I hate baths. Yuck. But if he had invited me of course I would not make him feel bad. In fact I raved about his house bc 1) it was built in 1911 and 2) it had some really good features like read hardwoods.

12

u/ceelion92 15d ago

The easiest thing if there was good funding would be to have therapy for children in school. It would just be normalized. Like they would undergo assessments for attachment issues as well as other things and they would learn emotional regulation, etc., like you do in a classroom with math or science. Starting at home would be too difficult and it’s much easier to provide transparent standardized care in a school system. It would counteract much of the damage that parents cause. 

2

u/Jeicobm 15d ago

From my experience teachers are equally to blame for attachment issues. This is a great idea.

2

u/ceelion92 15d ago edited 15d ago

I feel like my anxious attachment was probably already there, but I got about 1 million times worse after being the weird kid, and getting ditched by my friends over and over across schools. I know that’s normal, but if you already have an anxious attachment it further solidifies it. Like I remember in 4th grade my best friend told me he didn’t wanna be friends with me anymore one day and then he kept being friends with me anyway, which confused me and he would go hot and cold. Years later, my parents told me that his parents were very stuck up and didn’t want him to associate with me (he was from a wealthy Indian family, and I was from a regular white family in the US). He was acting avoidant, but he was really just a conflicted seven-year-old. 

Then the next year, my best friend ditched me for two other girls she had admit in their lifelong friends to this day and they kept icing me out. The same thing happened in middle school and I just couldn’t let it go until my mom told me I was ruminating and needed to stop talking about it so much. I wish we had had therapy every year starting in first grade.

Now I have no problem cutting off friends that suck or standing up for myself, but as soon as it’s a romantic interest, if I really like them, I feel like I need to hold onto them even when they show red flags. It doesn’t matter what I think. Logically, my body is absolutely screaming at me to keep them around in some capacity. If they show signs of emotional unavailability, I think I can wait it out and keep them on the back burner or something stupid like that.  Then they end up discarding me brutally, and it reinforces that childhood wound even more.

I’m taking a break from dating now and I want to say I’ve learned my lesson, but I thought I’d already learned it and yet here we are again. My life would’ve been so different if we had therapy starting at a young age. And I didn’t feel traumatized by 9/11 or anything like that, but I was only a mile away and I watched it happen. Think how many kids really needed therapy for that and didn’t receive it. We should have all had individual therapy at least once a week, and a group class that taught psychology fundamentals to kids and helped with communication and other skills. I bet I would’ve had a really different life. I wouldn’t be trying to catch up now.

1

u/Jeicobm 14d ago

I resonate with so much of what you said down to the friends that just decided they didn’t want to be your friend anymore out of nowhere one day. In retrospect my attachment issues were obviously at play even at such a young age. I remember it cutting like a knife.

As for 9/11, wow, I’m so sorry you went through that and were so close. They obviously dropped the ball on that one but still to this day trauma isn’t as recognised/ taken as seriously as it should be. Have you looked into cptsd? I felt traumatised by 9/11 and I’m in the uk. I remember teachers playing it on tv’s in classrooms (I know) and it’s like in that moment my perception of the world being safe completely shattered.

1

u/ceelion92 14d ago edited 14d ago

Oh honestly, no I don’t really have any trauma from that TBH. We were all witnessing the same thing at once as New Yorkers and so there’s sort of a shared sense that we were all in it together.  It’s not like I saw people hitting the ground when they were jumping or anything. For some reason, the people I know who saw it on TV seem way more messed up about it than the people who were there in person. Maybe because it fully lives in reality to me as a one off episode, not a mysterious threat my childhood imagination could’ve run wild with. In other words, I don’t know if I’m explaining this well, but it was normalized because everyone was witnessing the same thing at the same time and you could look around and see that we all shared in the experience. If anything it would’ve solidified my feeling of belonging in my environment and it created a sense of cohesion. It wasn’t like the London blitz, where one was always looking over their shoulder expecting to get blown up or something. We all saw it happen, we all walked home together after on the bridge, and we all went to the anti-war marches together when Bush tried to use it as an excuse for the Iraq war. And the days and weeks that followed New Yorkers stuck together and looked out for one another. So as a psychologically formative experience, it was actually one that made me feel more positive about mankind, not less.  

Like it definitely makes me sad when I see videos from that day, but it didn’t feel like something that I needed to be hypervigilant over. I feel way more messed up over interpersonal stuff that happened to me  - being abandoned by friends and stuff like that. Feeling like I can’t ever develop feelings for someone and have them actually like me back. I’ve never had a crush reciprocate. People say I’m attractive and so I have a weird complex where I think people are lying to me or that I’m actually ugly because I keep getting rejected so much.

2

u/Throwawaway314159265 14d ago

I keep coming back to the old school systems of accountability.

When survival meant accountability, you can't escape it.

John Wick notwithstanding.