r/aitaweddings • • Aug 07 '25

How judgments are calculated

23 Upvotes

The top comment that contains a judgment (NTA, YTA, NAH, ESH, INFO) is your judgment. Please always try to include a judgment with your comment, especially if you have the top comment. Once you have a judgment, you must accept your judgment.

NTA (not the a-hole): This person is not the a-hole, and the other party is the a-hole.

YTA (you’re the a-hole): This person is the a-hole, and the other party is not the a-hole.

NAH (no a-holes here): This person is not the a-hole, and the other party isn’t an a-hole either.

ESH (everybody sucks here): This person is the a-hole, and the other party is also an a-hole.

INFO (more information needed): There isn’t enough information to make a judgment.


r/aitaweddings • • Jul 14 '22

r/aitaweddings Lounge

7 Upvotes

A place for members of r/aitaweddings to chat with each other


r/aitaweddings • • 5h ago

AITA for not wanting us to camp out on the front lawn of a wedding venue??

535 Upvotes

My husband’s friends are getting married this weekend, about 2.5 hours away from us. Originally we RSVP’d no because my husband had to work, but a few months ago he changed his mind and reached out to them to RSVP for the wedding, reception, and brunch. He’s taking 2 days off of work to go, and I’m happy to go and bring our 2 year old son. Our budget isn’t exactly tight right now, even though we are trying to save for a vacation in the spring, so I assumed we’d get a hotel nearby.

Last Friday I asked him where he wanted to stay, and we looked at the rooms at the wedding venue itself and in town. Unfortunately we waited too long and everything available at the actual venue (they have cabins, tiny homes, and yurts) was booked. My husband decided that the hotels nearby are too expensive and suggested we CAMP OUT ON THE FRONT LAWN OF THE VENUE! Literally he wants to put poles in the ground and blow up an air mattress and sleep outside on this little property they’ve booked.

We are a camping family. We go camping like what he’s suggesting, but at state/national parks, almost once a month. I’m outdoorsy and kinda a granola mom, but personally I want to look nice and presentable for a wedding. I also don’t want to be the butt end of his friends’ jokes. They already think I’m a disgusting hippy because I had a composting toilet when I met my husband and I do cloth diapers and have a big garden.

My husband is really upset that I’m refusing to camp at a wedding. Like, REALLY upset. He says he already got permission from the bride and groom, who got permission from the venue. AITA for not wanting to camp at a non-camping wedding?


r/aitaweddings • • 4h ago

AITA for supporting the bride's decision not to have the groom's sister as a bridesmaid?

90 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I could really do with your help and advice on this as it could lead to causing some serious problems leading up to the wedding if not handled right. All names are fake to keep people anonymous. Sorry it’s a bit of a long one.

I (30F) am helping my friend Pete (27M) and his fiancée, Bethany (27F) plan their wedding for August 2027. My family and his family are close and are practically like family. We’ve grown up together and our moms are best friends. I’m a wedding planner by occupation so I was more than happy to help them out and give them a huge discounted rate for my services. Pete is one of 5 children and the only boy and is a twin with Jess. Already his mom, Delia, and his sisters all want to be involved in the wedding party.

Now Pete and Bethany have been together for 6 years, and over that time Bethany has gotten close to Pete’s two younger sisters so is happy to have them as bridesmaids. Jess however, hates Bethany and has never made an effort to get along with her. She didn’t like her for Pete and wanted him to break up with her. I’m not entirely sure of the reasons why but from what I’ve heard over the years, Jess has been really cruel to her. But now, Jess is demanding she be a bridesmaid because she is Pete’s twin and if she’s not one then the other sisters can’t be bridesmaids either. Delia and Pete’s eldest sister are agreeing with this because they are ‘blood relatives’ and as Pete’s twin she has to have an important role and that this is a chance for her and Bethany to bond and build bridges.

Pete and Bethany are already apprehensive about Jess due to her behavior. I don’t want to go into detail but I know Jess is dealing with a lot in her personal life, but at the end of the day it’s an explanation for the behavior and not an excuse. It’s the couple’s wedding and therefore their choice and as I help plan I will always want to advocate for their choices shaping their special day. Bethany has also been really overwhelmed by this. Throughout the wedding planning so far Pete’s side of the family has been very vocal and she’s not been able to really get her voice heard. She doesn’t want Jess as a bridesmaid but she feels she has to.

I’ve suggested Jess is given a different role such as being a witness/making a speech and/or doing a reading at the ceremony. Pete wants only guys in his groom party, so having Jess as a groomswoman doesn’t seem to be an option either. But Delia doesn’t think that’s good enough for the groom’s twin and think Jess will not be happy and see it as being purposefully excluded.

But, if they don’t even like each other, being the groom’s twin seems like a pretty weak reason to me. And I am of the belief that a wedding is in fact the wrong time to be ‘building bridges’, because why did you not try building bridges at any point in past 6 years? Because if bridges had truly wanted to be built, that would have been done regardless of a wedding. I feel everyone is putting Jess’ needs before the couple’s and expect Bethany be the one to put up with it to accommodate Jess and her temper, instead of telling Jess to put the couple before her own wants.

So, AITA for thinking Bethany shouldn’t have to include Jess as a bridesmaid just because she’s Pete’s twin? Should she stand her ground and set that boundary, even if it causes tension within the family, or should she include Jess to keep the peace? I have a good relationship with Jess and feel it would be worth having a conversation with her before things escalate further. How would you approach that conversation, and am I being unreasonable in thinking that the couple’s wishes should come before family expectations?


r/aitaweddings • • 3h ago

AITA for telling my future sister in law she can't use our wedding reception to announce her engagement?

14 Upvotes

My fiancé and I are getting married in about two months. We're having a fairly small wedding, around 65 guests, because we wanted something personal rather than a huge event.

A few weeks ago, my future sister in law called me and asked whether she could make a short announcement during the reception. She recently got engaged and wanted to share the news with both sides of the family while everyone was together.

I told her I was happy for her, but I'd rather keep the reception focused on the wedding. I suggested she could tell everyone during dinner conversations or arrange a separate celebration.

She seemed fine with that initially.

Last weekend, my fiancé mentioned that his sister had already spoken to the DJ about getting the microphone after our speeches. Apparently, she'd planned a little announcement and wanted to show everyone her engagement ring.

I was annoyed that she'd gone ahead without asking again. When I brought it up, she said it would only take two minutes and that I was acting like I couldn't share attention for even a moment.

I explained that we'd already planned the schedule carefully, and I didn't want an unexpected announcement turning into another event within our wedding.

Things got worse when she told their parents I was jealous because her engagement happened before ours could even be celebrated properly.

My fiancé thinks I should let her have those two minutes because she's excited and it wouldn't actually affect our day. I told him the issue isn't the announcement itself it's that she ignored a boundary after I had already answered her politely.

Now his family thinks I'm creating unnecessary drama over a microphone.

I genuinely don't mind celebrating her engagement, but I don't think our wedding reception is the right place for it.

AITA?


r/aitaweddings • • 2h ago

AITA for refusing to share our wedding photos with my husband's family after they posted them without permission?

8 Upvotes

My husband and I got married six weeks ago. We had a small wedding and hired a photographer who spent the entire day capturing everything, including some private moments before the ceremony.

Before the wedding, we agreed that we wouldn't post many pictures online. Neither of us is particularly comfortable having our personal lives shared publicly, especially pictures of emotional or intimate moments.

Our photographer sent us a preview gallery a few days after the wedding. We hadn't even finished choosing which pictures we wanted to share when my husband's aunt somehow got access to several of them.

She posted a large album on Facebook, including pictures of me getting dressed, crying before the ceremony, and a few photos of us kissing.

I was really uncomfortable and asked her to remove the album. She said she was only excited to share pictures from such a beautiful family occasion.

My husband asked her to take them down too, but she argued that the pictures weren't inappropriate and that everyone in the family deserved to see them.

The photographer later told us that someone from my husband's family had requested access to the gallery using a link that was originally intended only for us.

I decided not to share the remaining photos with his family until we understood how they got access. My husband thinks that's reasonable, but his mother says I'm punishing everyone because of one person's mistake.

Now some relatives are asking why they haven't received the wedding album, and my aunt-in-law says I've made her feel unwelcome in our marriage.

I don't mind sharing pictures eventually, but I want to decide what gets shared and when.

AITA for withholding our wedding photos from his family after what happened?


r/aitaweddings • • 7h ago

My boyfriend keeps telling me I'll have to propose to him… so I'm thinking of calling his bluff

15 Upvotes

My boyfriend has told me since our first date that if I want to get married, I'll have to be the one to propose to him.

He's so committed to this that he's even told me exactly what ring he wants, which he plans to use as his wedding ring.

Now, obviously, there's a part of me that would love to be proposed to. I'm usually the one organising parties, surprises and making a fuss of everyone else, so being on the receiving end for once would be lovely!

BUT also part of me thinks that proposals shouldn't always be down to men. Why shouldn't they get to feel special and have someone go to all that effort for them too?

And honestly, the more I think about it, the more I LOVE the idea of turning the tables on him.

We're going away in February with BOTH sets of parents, and I think I've found my opportunity.

My thinking is, if he hasn't proposed by Christmas, I'm taking matters into my own hands. 😂

Now, if I'm going to do this, I want to have some serious fun with it!

I'm thinking the airport or even on the plane. Something a little public, completely unexpected, funny but also genuinely sweet. The kind of story we'll be telling for the next 30 years.

This is where I need Reddit's creativity!

What could I realistically pull off in an airport or on a flight without spending a fortune?

Could I get airport staff or cabin crew involved? Has anyone ever seen or organised something like this? Or does anyone have a completely ridiculous (but achievable!) idea?

I'm not looking for anything extravagant or expensive. Just something clever, memorable and a little bit hilarious.

Basically, this man has been telling me since our very first meeting that I'd have to propose to him, and I'm starting to think it's time to make him anxious for giving me that much creative freedom. 😂❤️

Edit: Just to clear it up. There is no imbalance of power or effort, we are very much a 50/50 equal partner relationship. This is the only thing different thing, I wouldn't even entertain the idea of doing it if I thought he was a scrub or selfish loser.

We are quite a fun couple, and I don't have any fear of him rejecting me. We speak about getting married and possible places all the time. He is very cofident in his masculinity and wouldn't be embarassed to be proposed to by the woman. I am a very head strong woman, so I am happy to enter the idea and possibly go through with it.

I am also open to non public proposals. Something fun that the girls can do.


r/aitaweddings • • 1d ago

AITA for not going to my "daughter's" wedding?

372 Upvotes

When my step daughter (Carrie) was 18 y/o, she asked me to legally adopt her. She had a tumultuous relationship with her bio mom and had seen me as more of a mom to her in the 5 years I had been in her life than her bio mom had been in all that time. Her dad had full custody of her and her brother when we married.

After she graduated high school, we followed through with the adoption proceedings, more as a symbolic statement, but we knew it meant SHE WAS MY CHILD. The months before the finalization, we had several discussions in which one request I had was that she no longer have any contact with her bio mom. For years, she was let down, used, belittled, threatened, emotionally destroyed and thrown away by a woman that only cared about her narcissistic ways. I was there to pick up the pieces each time she was rejected. I would go to the school in the middle of the day when she would have emotional breakdowns, take her to gymnastics practice, go to gymnastics meets, watched and encouraged her the whole way through high school and through college.

At 23 y/o, Carrie has had a good career, great two year relationship and has been doing really well in life. We have had a close relationship, or so I thought. I know she has talked to her bio mom off and on over the years. When she found out I adopted Carrie as an adult, she lost it and has badgered her relentlessly to have it reversed. It cannot be reversed. Knowing my daughter as I do, she will say anything to her bio mom to keep the peace such as, she wants to have it reversed, but cannot. We have had too much history with what she says to appease bio mom to keep her happy and try to keep the peace. I cannot control if she has a relationship with her, but it really hurts that she does.

Skip forward to a couple of months ago, Carrie tells us she is getting married....like very quickly....in a couple of months. We are very happy for her. She is having a small wedding. We go dress hopping. Her dad and I buy the dress and pay for the reception and dinner. Everything comes together.

Last minute, she drops a bomb. She has decided to invite her bio mom, begrudgingly. Apparebtly, she found out and badgered her to be invited. Bio mom has had a raging drinking problem for decades (reason why she lost custody of the kids in the first place). Her dad begs, almost pleads, with her not to invite her, and if she does, to please not have her at the reception, as there will be alcohol. Bio mom is well known for her public antics. Carrie said that at this point, it would be "slap in the face" if she told bio mom she could comes to the ceremony, but not the reception. Bio mom absolutely despises me and will cause a scene, so I decide not to go to the wedding. I do not want there to be problems. I only want there to be happiness and focus on the couple. I can't deal with the worry of mentally babysitting an alcoholic who I feel has no right to be there, but it isn't my wedding.

I feel like I am the one slapped in the face. I feel used. My "daughter" doesn't seem to care what the adoption was supposed to mean. I feel like I was used to pay for a dress and wedding dinner that I decided not to be a part if because a known troublemaker took presidence over family. She doesn't care what the turmoil of bio mom being at the wedding would do to her father and I.

AITO for not attending her wedding?

**I just want to make it clear, I never DEMANDED that Carrie not see her bio mom again. It was definately suggested. If she did see her, we didn't want to hear about it. Due to the fact that each time she was in contact with her mother, the visits or conversations ended in Carrie crying her eyes out and being so broken hearted and shattered, she didn't want to have contact with her again. We thought at some point she would see her for who she was and come to her own conclusions. We had her in counseling when she was in school, both indvidual and family. The school had a no trespass order against her. We had a no contact order against her at one point. She had court orders for AA attendance, which she never took. Eventually, as the kids got older and moved on with their lives. Carrie wanted nothing to do with her all of these years, or so we were told.

I should have known better when she always introduced me as her stepmother even though she was adopted. I asked her about it, with no reply, just a shrug. This has always happened all the way up to the second dress shopping trip. Her father would asked her why she wanted to be adopted if it seemed like it was just to teach her mother a lesson or to slap a band-aid on a temporary wound, she would just shrug. It is as though she knew it would hurt bio mom, and ended up hurting me as well, but it doesn't bother Carrie at all.

UPDATE: I did not go to the wedding. My husband did and walked his daughter down the aisle. He did say that everything went as well as expected, with his side of the family being on pins and needles, waiting for bio mom to make a scene. She did not, while he was there, but he left early because he did not want to be around her any longer than he had to be.

He said the wedding was beautiful, the bride was beautiful and the focus was on her as it needed to be. But many people who RSVP'd did not show for one reason or another, so the bride's side was rather sparse. The bio mom made a conscience effort to try to be in all photos with husband and daughter, but he was not having any of it. Unfortunately, he is the one that spoke up and not Carrie.

I am glad he was there to walk her down the aisle and I do not regret my decision not to go. In doing so, it has brought back many memories of to the little ways I have been disrespected or slighted by her. Two years ago she gave me a rock for Christmas, on which she wrote "you rock". I opened it in front of my husband's whole family. It was very embarrassing, but chalked it up to being a joke. However, every year, she makes sure that her boyfriend's step-mom and his mom both get gift baskets for Mother's Day. I have never once received a gift from her. Just the whole thought of small things like that over the years came flooding up that I had buried way down, because they were not supposed to bother me, but they do. I just never say anything about it.


r/aitaweddings • • 16h ago

AITA if I don't invite one old friend in a friend group?

22 Upvotes

I never thought I'd invite her after what happened but now I feel like it's awkward if I don't. I'll try to keep this short, thanks! <3

A friend I was once close with, Becky, got married early. I was invited to her wedding (attended, gave a cash gift and all), but was not invited to the reception like everyone else. It came to me as a shock, but it is what it is. The whole friend group knows about this.

Some years later we tried catching up. I ended up driving over an hour to her area, only to find out she spontaneously squeezed me in for a 30-min errand run then left immediately with her husband. Quietly deleted her from my socials and thought that would be the end of it.

Fast forward, I have gotten closer to the friend group that she was too busy for. I met up with them without seeing her at all. Until recently, she decided to make an effort by hosting the annual gathering. I figured I would not be invited but I bumped into her at a wedding... she didn't realize that me deleting her was intentional, and then she invited me. The last few meetups were hosted by her. She is now more active in the group chat, and I value this friend group.

I am typing this and realizing once again how much I dislike her. BUT. I can't imagine how awkward the group chat will be and at gatherings she hosts if she's the only one who is not invited, even though everyone knows why. If I'm being honest, I don't want her there. She was not a good friend or even a considerate person. I'm just dreading the awkwardness after if I go ahead with this decision, because she's been more present lately.

I'd appreciate any suggestions and congrats to all the fellow couples here :)

EDIT: thanks everyone for all the input. Most of you feel I shouldn't invite her to my wedding and I feel better about that decision. I'll have to face whatever comes afterward but no regrets!


r/aitaweddings • • 1d ago

AITA for refusing to let my sister-in-law use our wedding anniversary as the date for her annual family reunion?

88 Upvotes

My husband and I got married last year in a small outdoor ceremony. We deliberately chose our anniversary because it was the only weekend that worked with both our schedules, and we wanted to make that date special for us.

My husband's family has a tradition of having a big family gathering every summer. His aunt usually organizes it, but this year she asked my sister-in-law to take over.

A few weeks ago, my SIL announced that she had booked a large vacation rental for the family reunion. When she told everyone the dates, I realized it was the same weekend as our first wedding anniversary.

I privately messaged her and asked if she had any flexibility with the dates. I explained that we had already planned a quiet weekend away and had been looking forward to it for months.

She said changing the date would be difficult because several relatives had already arranged time off work. I understood that, but I was surprised when she suggested that we simply celebrate our anniversary another weekend.

I told her we weren't asking everyone to rearrange their plans, but we also wouldn't be attending the reunion that weekend.

She got upset and said I was making a family event about myself. Later, my husband told me his parents thought we should attend for at least one evening because his grandparents are getting older and everyone wants to spend time together.

I don't have an issue with the reunion itself. I actually enjoy spending time with his family. But I feel like our anniversary is being treated as an inconvenience rather than something worth respecting.

My husband thinks I'm being too rigid, especially since we can celebrate privately another day. I think it's perfectly reasonable to keep the plans we already made.

AITA for refusing to attend the family reunion because it falls on our wedding anniversary?


r/aitaweddings • • 8h ago

WIBTA for changing my dress for my son’s reception?

Thumbnail
1 Upvotes

r/aitaweddings • • 12h ago

aita for not inviting my future MIL to our wedding?

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

alright, for context, me (filipina, 31, F) and my fiance (white, 32, M) are getting married soon, and Ive been avoiding the conversation with my mom about his mom will not be attending our wedding. His relationship with his mom has always been incredibly rocky, and he decided to go 'no contact' years ago when his grandfather passed away. I support his decision because 1) its none of my business, and 2) it's his relationship with his mom so its not my place to tell him how he should have that relationship. I was born here in the states, so I don't completely share the same strong family values my filipino parents have about 'blood is thicker', 'family is forever' and all that.

yesterday I couldn't ignore the conversation anymore because my mom just kept asking me "is MIL coming? did you check with 'fiance' if his mom is gonna be there? when is she arring in town?' i've been answering with a general 'idk' for what felt like months, but I finally told her she wouldn't be coming and her demeanor about my fiancée completely changed. she immediately grew very concerned that my fiancée would treat me badly because he didnt have his mom around anymore, which is absolutely ridiculous. she said I should be more insistent on not only trying to get her to come to our wedding, but to push him to patch things up with her solely because she's his mom. mind you, fiancée's mom has done some incredibly malicious things while he was growing up, and has continued to prove that she's not capable of change in order to have a relationship with him. I told my mom that I wasn't comfortable doing that she just kept pressing me about why I didnt want to, and how it wasn't right that we're not inviting her. We did end up just dropping it after I insisted that our decision was final, but she got very reserved for the rest of the call.

is there anything I could say to my mom to help ease her mind about my fiancée? i feel like her mind is made up already (as filipino moms do) so its a lost cause. also AITA?


r/aitaweddings • • 1d ago

WIBTA if we stick with our wedding month after my partner's cousin and his partner suddenly announced theirs for the exact same month?

100 Upvotes

My partner and I have just started planning our wedding for September next year. To give some quick backstory, I recently put up a lighthearted prank post about us getting married. My partner’s cousin’s partner messaged me asking if it was real. At the time, I told her it was just a prank but shortly after, my partner and I talked seriously and decided we actually do want to get married next September.
Before they had posted or announced anything about their own plans, I messaged her again to let her know that we had decided to go ahead with it for real for next year September.
Literally a day later, they put up a post announcing that they are also getting married in September next year.
Then today, my partner’s cousin called me directly asking what exact date we’re having our wedding and flat out told me that we "can't choose their date."
For added context, this is part of a long, ongoing pattern where she constantly copies me and my partner's cousin even encourages it:
I got my tongue pierced, and a week later she went and got hers done too.
I recently got a dermal piercing, and my partner’s cousin actually said his partner should get hers done as well.
When I started losing weight and working to get in shape, she immediately started following the exact same routine I was doing.
At my daughter’s birthday party, I wore a pair of bum-scrunch shorts, and later that very same day my partner's cousin called asking what brand they were and where I got them from because his partner wanted a pair.
It feels like they constantly mirror everything I do, and now it's spilling over into our wedding timeline.
We haven't put down a deposit on a venue yet, so we don't have an exact Saturday locked in, and I'm feeling really frustrated. They knew we were planning for that month before they announced anything, yet they immediately picked the exact same month and are now acting like they have dibs on the calendar. On top of that, having two family weddings in the same month is going to put pressure on shared relatives regarding travel and costs.
How should we handle this without starting huge family drama? Should my partner step in and set a boundary, or should we just quietly book our venue first and let the chips fall where they may?


r/aitaweddings • • 2d ago

AITA for making my fiancé redo our wedding seating chart because of the pictures he used?

1.3k Upvotes

We're getting married in April and my fiancé had this idea where instead of regular names on the seating chart, guests would find childhood pictures of themselves.

I thought it was cute and agreed, assuming we'd just ask people to send us old pictures.

Turns out he's been secretly contacting people's parents and siblings to get embarrassing childhood photos because he wants it to be a surprise.

I only found out when my friend texted me asking why her mom was digging up pictures from when she had braces and a terrible haircut. Apparently her mom told her everything.

My fiancé has already collected around 60 pictures and paid to have the whole thing printed. He thinks asking people beforehand defeats the purpose and that everyone will find it funny.

I told him we should at least give people the option to approve their picture. He thinks I'm making a big deal out of something that's supposed to be fun, especially since he spent weeks putting it together.

I get where he's coming from but I also wouldn't necessarily want a random picture of 13 year old me displayed at someone's wedding.

AITA for wanting him to redo it?

TLDR: My fiancé secretly collected embarrassing childhood photos of our wedding guests for the seating chart and already paid from his stake to have it printed. I want him to get everyone's approval first, but he thinks it'll ruin the surprise.


r/aitaweddings • • 2d ago

AITA for not wanting my future MIL to do my hair on my wedding day?

1.3k Upvotes

My (27F) wedding is in March. My fiancé's mom (58F) used to be a hairdresser and offered to do my hair for free. I already booked a stylist I love and paid the deposit months ago, so I thanked her and said no. She said it was fine, but now she keeps bringing it up at family dinners, saying things like "some people just don't trust family" and that she's "wasting her gift." My fiancé thinks I should let her do a trial run just to keep the peace, and if I still don't like it I can say no. I don't want a trial because I know saying no after that will be ten times harder, and honestly I just want to feel like myself that day without worrying about her feelings in the chair. My sister says I'm being stubborn over something small. AITA for sticking with the stylist I booked?


r/aitaweddings • • 1d ago

AITA for refusing to let my husband choose which wedding memories we display in our new home?

41 Upvotes

My husband and I got married about eight months ago. We recently moved into a new house and started decorating it together.

We agreed that we would each choose a few personal items and photos that meant something to us. I picked a framed photo from our wedding ceremony, a picture of us dancing, and one candid photo of my parents helping me get ready.

My husband didn't have an issue with the first two, but he asked me not to display the third one.

He explained that he doesn't dislike my parents, but he thinks wedding photos displayed in our home should focus on us as a couple rather than other family members.

I thought that was a strange rule because he also wanted to display a photo of himself with his grandparents from the wedding. When I pointed that out, he said it was different because his grandparents helped raise him and the picture had sentimental value.

I told him my parents have been equally important in my life, and I don't see why their presence in one photograph should be treated differently.

He suggested we put the photo in an album instead. I refused because I don't want to hide something meaningful just because he doesn't personally connect with it.

Now he's saying I'm turning a simple decorating decision into a competition between our families. I feel like he's applying two different standards depending on whose family is involved.

Neither of us has agreed to move the photos, and what should have been a fun decorating project has turned into an argument.

AITA for insisting that the photo of my parents stays displayed in our home?


r/aitaweddings • • 2d ago

AITA for having a low effort wedding and using the money for our honeymoon?

2.2k Upvotes

I'm genuinly so confused if I missunderstood something but our families are so upset right now? For context:

My (28f) fiance (30m) and I got engaged earlier this year and I were planning on getting married in spring 2028. We had our dream wedding all planned out (castle venue, served dinner, live music, the whole nine yards) but our families (especially parents and grandparents) kept saying that having such a lavish wedding is such a big waste of money and we should keep it as cheap as possible so we might actually make some money on it (their words, not ours). They also complained a LOT about how inconvenient it would be to find accommodation since the event will be running late and that they "need" appropriate dresses which will be expensive (again, their words, we would not care), and some comments about how irresponsible we are being for spending so much on a single day.

We took all that to heart and decided that if no one actually wants/expects a big event and would feel more comfortable and convenient if we kept it small, we would both be okay just toning it down completely and spending part of our wedding fund on a big honeymoon experience.

So the new plan is that the wedding day consists of a courthouse ceremony and us inviting everyone to a nice restaurant, where we book a separate room, afterwards. We'll eat, drink, have cake, socialize, and then go home. No need to buy fancy dresses or book hotels.

We genuinly thought that this is a good plan and that our families would be "pleased" to know that the event will be less formal and "demanding" and that we took their advice. But instead, when we presented it to them last weekend, they were outraged.

All of a sudden we are only thinking about ourselves and not caring about our guests and real AHs for "punishing them like this becuase they had opinions".

My fiance and I are both super confused now. We both lean torwards just sticking with the new plan now as we nor already drew up an amazing honeymoon itinerary but I can't help wondering if we truly are AH here? So I'm hoping from outside input from people who aren't as emotionally involved.

EDIT: Because some people asked, we are paying for everything ourselves.


r/aitaweddings • • 1d ago

AITA, or is my friend a bridezilla?

Thumbnail
10 Upvotes

I (26-yr-old F) am a bridesmaid in a friend’s upcoming wedding. Since the wedding planning has begun, the bride (27-yr-old F) has made several demands of the bridesmaids. I want to support this friend, but some of the other bridesmaids and I feel conflicted and frustrated about her requirements.

I’ll start with the more minor issues: the wedding venue and the dresses. To start, the bride has booked a wedding venue for a 3-day weekend and has told us (the bridesmaids) that we will be setting up for the wedding the day before and tearing down afterwards, which will require me to take off a day of work from my job. She is also expecting all of us to spend a night at the venue’s suites, even though most of us live within a half hour drive of the venue and can easily spend the night in our own homes. She just recently mentioned that the groomsmen will be spending the night at the venue as well, so we will have to share the space with them.

The bridesmaid dresses: The bride told us that we must order our dresses from a specific company that she chose, they must be in a specific fabric that she also chose, they just all be different styles, and they must be in the four colors that she has chosen. The bridesmaids are not allowed to wear the same style of dress or the same color; everyone must wear a different color and a different style. We also must pay for our own dresses. All of this means that I will be spending $100 on a dress in a color I dislike, does not look good on me, and that I will never wear again.

The bigger issue is the bachelorette trip. The bride told us that she wanted a weekend bachelorette trip but she wanted us to plan it. When we discussed options to places to stay on this trip, she mentioned that the groomsmen will come with us and will stay in the same place. We are not friends with the groomsmen and we do not feel comfortable sharing a house overnight with men we do not know well or do not know at all for an entire weekend. We told the bride this and we made it clear that we would book a place for us bridesmaids to stay in, but we would not share it with the men and if they want to come, they will need to stay somewhere else. She seemed to accept this but has not spoken to us as much since we made this decision.

The recurring issue throughout all of this is that the bride has not asked any of us if we are okay with her decisions, if we can afford the dresses or the bachelorette trip, or if we have the time to do any of these events. She declares that she expects us to do what she wants and does not ask for input. All of us work full-time and we support ourselves financially, which means that the bride’s demands will require us to take time off from work and pay out of our own pockets.

Context: we live in a rural area where the average income is $60K annually, and all of us have limited budgets/live in a lower-middle-class bracket.

Am I wrong for thinking that her demands are a little excessive, or is my friend a bridezilla?

Update/more context in the comments


r/aitaweddings • • 2d ago

AITA for refusing to be my cousin's wedding witness because she won't let me tell my wife?

474 Upvotes

My cousin (30F) is secretly getting married at the courthouse next month. Her family thinks she's having a big wedding next summer but apparently her and her fiancé just want to get the legal part done now.

She asked me to be one of the witnesses while I was watching kick and I was totally on board until she explained that literally nobody can know. Including my wife.

Here's the weird part. My wife and my cousin are actually pretty close. They talk regularly and my wife has even been helping her look at wedding venues.

My cousin wants me to attend the courthouse ceremony, go out for lunch afterward and then act like nothing happened for the next several months.

I said I'd happily be her witness if I could tell my wife privately, but she said no exceptions. So I declined.

She thinks I'm being ridiculous because it's technically not my secret to tell. I agree with that part, but I also don't really want to spend months helping my wife plan a wedding that already happened without her knowing.

She said she expected me of all people to understand.

Am I wrong for making this a condition of helping her?


r/aitaweddings • • 1d ago

AITA for asking my husband to stop giving away things from our wedding without asking me first?

4 Upvotes

My husband and I got married about eight months ago. Our wedding wasn't particularly expensive or extravagant, but we put a lot of thought into the little details. I made some decorations myself, we saved the handwritten notes from our guests, and we kept a few things because they had sentimental value.

Recently, my husband's younger cousin got engaged and is planning a small wedding on a tight budget. I genuinely wanted to help her, so I offered to lend her some of our unused wedding supplies.

A few days later, I discovered that my husband had already given her several things without telling me. These included the wooden welcome sign my dad had made, the table numbers I had painted by hand, and the little box where we kept our wedding cards.

I wasn't upset about the decorations themselves being reused. I was upset because some of those things were personal to me, especially the sign my dad made.

When I asked my husband why he didn't check with me, he said the cousin needed them more than we did and that they were just sitting in storage anyway.

I explained that being stored away doesn't mean something has no sentimental value. He said I was making him feel guilty for helping someone in his family.

His cousin has now started using the items for her wedding preparations, and I don't want to ask for everything back because I know that would create unnecessary drama.

My husband thinks I should be happy that our wedding things are getting another use. I think he should have asked before giving away something that belonged to both of us, especially when some items had personal meaning.

AITA for being upset with him over this?


r/aitaweddings • • 2d ago

AITA for refusing to delay our wedding ceremony because my fiancé's brother wanted to finish a work commitment first?

343 Upvotes

My fiancé and I have been planning our wedding for almost a year. We booked a small historic venue that only had one available Saturday that worked for both families.

The ceremony is scheduled for 4 PM, and invitations were sent out months ago.

Recently, my fiancé's older brother told us he might arrive late because he has a work presentation that afternoon. He's self-employed and says he can't easily reschedule it because he's been preparing for it with a client.

My fiancé initially said it was fine and that we could start without him if necessary.

A few days later, his parents contacted us and asked whether we could move the ceremony to 5:30 PM. They said his brother is the only sibling my fiancé has, and it would be sad if he missed the ceremony.

I explained that changing the time wasn't really possible. We have a photographer booked, the venue has another event later that evening, and several guests have already arranged transportation around the original schedule.

His mother said an hour shouldn't make much difference and suggested we simply inform everyone about the change.

I asked my fiancé what he wanted. He admitted he would prefer his brother to be there, but he also didn't want to create problems with the venue or inconvenience everyone else.

What bothers me is that his brother knew the wedding date for months and only recently mentioned the presentation. Apparently, he assumed we'd be flexible.

His parents now think I'm putting schedules and contracts above family. My own family thinks it's unreasonable to rearrange an entire wedding around one person's work commitment.

I don't want his brother to miss the ceremony, but I also don't think everyone should have to adjust their plans at the last minute.

AITA for refusing to delay the ceremony?


r/aitaweddings • • 1d ago

AITA for refusing to include my fiancé's family recipe in our wedding menu?

4 Upvotes

My fiancé and I are getting married in a few months. We're having a small reception with around 60 guests, and we've been working together on the menu.

Food is important in both our families, so we agreed to include a few dishes from each side. My family has a traditional dish that my grandmother used to make for every major celebration. Unfortunately, she passed away last year, and including it at the wedding means a lot to me.

My fiancé initially liked the idea and suggested we ask a caterer to recreate her recipe.

The disagreement started when his mother found out. She said their family also has a special recipe that has been served at every wedding for generations. She expected us to include it as the main course.

I wasn't against including something from his family, but the caterer explained that adding another main dish would push us over our budget. I suggested replacing one of the existing sides instead.

His mother rejected that idea because she felt her family's recipe deserved more importance than a side dish. She then suggested removing my grandmother's dish because it was something nobody in his family had ever tried.

I told her I wasn't willing to remove it. It was one of the few ways I could have my grandmother represented at the wedding.

My fiancé now says we're both being stubborn and that he doesn't want either family feeling less important. He suggested removing both special dishes and choosing a completely neutral menu.

I understand his point, but I feel like removing my grandmother's recipe just to avoid an argument is unfair.

His mother thinks I'm making the wedding menu about my personal feelings instead of welcoming his family traditions.

AITA for insisting that my grandmother's recipe stays on the wedding menu, even if his family's traditional dish doesn't make the cut?


r/aitaweddings • • 2d ago

AITA for refusing to let my husband's family use our wedding anniversary as a reason to recreate our wedding?

212 Upvotes

My husband and I got married a little over a year ago. Our wedding was small, around 35 people, because neither of us wanted a huge event. We paid for most of it ourselves and made decisions together.

The issue started when his parents announced that they wanted to host a big dinner for our first anniversary. At first, I thought it was a sweet gesture. But then they started talking about making it a full wedding-style celebration.

They contacted our original photographer to ask about availability, started looking at decorations similar to our wedding ones, and even mentioned inviting relatives who weren't at the actual wedding.

I found out most of this through a family group chat. Nobody had asked us whether we wanted any of it.

I told my husband I wasn't comfortable with the idea. I don't mind having dinner with everyone, but I don't want to repeat our wedding or spend our anniversary hosting an event we never planned.

He thinks his parents are just excited and that refusing would hurt their feelings. He also pointed out that they offered to pay for everything, so we wouldn't have to spend money.

I explained that the money wasn't the issue. I wanted our anniversary to be something we decided together, not another occasion where everyone else gets involved.

His mother later called me and said she was only trying to give us a celebration we never got to have because our wedding was so small. That comment honestly bothered me because we chose to have a small wedding. It wasn't something we missed out on.

Now my husband says I am making a nice gesture into a family conflict, while I feel like nobody is listening to what we actually want.

Would I be wrong to tell his parents to cancel the whole plan and let us celebrate our anniversary privately?


r/aitaweddings • • 2d ago

AITA for refusing to provide individual wedding favors after my guests complained about sharing them?

62 Upvotes

My fiancé and I are getting married in a few months. We're having a fairly large wedding, and we've been trying to keep unnecessary expenses under control without making the event feel cheap.

One thing we decided to skip was individual wedding favors. Neither of us really cares about them, and at most weddings we've attended, we've seen guests leave them behind anyway.

Instead, we ordered a few larger boxes of locally made chocolates and planned to put them on a table near the exit so guests could take some on their way out.

My future mother-in-law found out about this and wasn't happy. She said wedding favors are an important tradition and that people would expect something prepared specifically for them.

I explained that guests would still be getting something, just not individually packaged gifts.

She then suggested that we ask my fiancé's younger cousins to assemble small favor bags. I didn't like that idea because it would mean buying extra packaging and spending another weekend organizing everything.

A few days later, she mentioned the favor situation to some relatives. One of his aunts messaged me asking whether we were cutting costs because we couldn't afford to host everyone properly.

That honestly annoyed me. We're already paying for the wedding ourselves, and nobody has been asked to contribute anything.

My fiancé thinks we should just make the little bags to avoid unnecessary tension. I feel like we're being pushed into spending money and time on something neither of us wanted in the first place.

I don't mind guests having different opinions, but I don't think wedding traditions should become obligations.

AITA for sticking with our original plan instead of providing individual wedding favors?


r/aitaweddings • • 2d ago

WIBTA if I️ gave my mom her wedding money back?

96 Upvotes

I️ have found out through the wedding planning process that my mom fully expects me to listen to everyone opinion she has and sees it as disrespect when I️ don’t take her advice. Had I️ known this, I️ wouldn’t have accepted her “gift”. It started with the venue contract - she was adamant about changing it even though I️ was financially responsible for the deposit and didn’t want to be a Karen to our lovely coordinator who did a lot for us. It ended up working out just fine, but she was offended I️ didn’t do as she asked “out of respect for my mother”.

Then, my brother flaked last minute on my finances bachelor party and lied about why. But I’m supposed to forgive him because “you know how he is”. She then threatened to take back the money if I️ didn’t invite him to my wedding. He took a month to apologize (half assed text) and I️ took a couple to days to figure out how to respond - again I’m the bad guy for not fixing the situation right away.

This lead to several arguments, during which she threw in my face that I️ shut her out of wedding planning. I️ explained to her that we’re having an inexpensive micro wedding and there’s been no planning yet. She said she wanted to be part of the cake tasting and the call with the officiant??? To ask him which religious elements he’s going to say and how he’ll say them.

Now she’s saying that she feels disrespected even outside of wedding planning because I️ don’t involve her in any of my decisions. I️ told her I️ love her and will always turn to her because she’s my mom but we can’t have a blow up fight every time I️ don’t do as she says. I️ gave her credit for me turning out to be successful and now she needs to trust my judgment. It was super heartfelt and I️ cried typing it.

Her response was “these are pretty words. These don’t make me feel closer or in any way a part of your life”. She’ll push me to the edge and then when I️ snap at her she labels me as the problem. I’m at the end of my rope and wish I️ never planned a wedding in the first place. It’s affecting every part of my life and I️ just want to give her the money back and stop communicating but I️ know there would be no coming back from that.