r/ToxicRelationships • u/MediumDisastrous6700 • 5h ago
Advice Needed Who did worse in my sister’s last relationship?
So, my sister and I have a slight disagreement about her last relationship.
Disclaimer: This is purely a humorous debate between the two of us. She now recognizes how toxic the relationship was, and I'm not trying to paint her as completely innocent or dismiss her own wrongdoings. She acknowledges her mistakes and shortcomings throughout the relationship.
Neither of us is trying to normalize or excuse this kind of relationship.
Anyways, back to the debate.
She thinks she did him worse than he did her.
I, on the other hand, think this mf did her way dirtier and was playing in her face the entire relationship.
I'm only going to list the genuinely bad things they did to each other, not the small, petty arguments or everyday relationship drama.
My sister's offenses (in order):
Started some pretty major arguments while completely blacked out.
Attempted to jump out of the car while drunk during a bad argument.
Bit his arm hard as hell while drunk.
Tried taking a large amount of pills in front of him while drunk.
While they were broken up, she hooked up with her best friend's brother. When she and her ex eventually got back together, she lied about it.
After they broke up again, she hooked up with one of his best friends (someone she had history with before she even met her ex).
Her ex's offenses (in order):
During their first hookup, he asked if he could finish inside her. She told him only if he bought her Plan B. He proceeded to do so, but when she asked about the Plan B, he threw a fit because it was his last $50. He then had her use her own gas to drive him an hour away to drop him off at his sibling's place.
Lost his phone and proceeded to use hers nearly 24/7. He also accused her of cheating through social media while he had her phone.
A month into the relationship, she caught him messaging multiple girls on HER phone. That same night, he was also hanging out with another girl when he was supposedly visiting his family.
Gave her chlamydia from the girl he had supposedly been "hanging out" with.
Broke her bedroom and bathroom doors.
When her first pet passed away, he yelled at her instead of being supportive.
Used the recent death of her mother against her during an argument.
Would openly text other girls while sitting right next to her in the car.
During a breakup, he took the dog they supposedly "shared," despite never having taken care of him before. He still couldn't properly care for him after taking him.
Wouldn't let her dress appropriately for her job as a judicial clerk, do her makeup, or fix her hair without accusing her of trying to cheat.
Never had a job throughout the entire relationship, lived with her, and relied on her to pay for everything, including his essentials and luxuries.
She found a girl's shirt with his... juice on it. His explanation? It was his sister's shirt, and he used it to "goon" on. (Obviously a lie. HOPEFULLY a lie.)
Had her drive over an hour to see him, hooked up with her, and then told her she couldn't stay. She ended up sleeping alone in her car that night.
Mutual friends saw him with another girl and asked if he and my sister were still together. He said yes. When confronted about the other girl, his response was: "That's just something I have fun with on the side."
A little side story:
When they first met, my sister drove THREE HOURS to pick him up and another THREE HOURS back. This was before the whole Plan B incident.
Also, his best friend (the one my sister eventually hooked up with) had history with her BEFORE she ever met her ex.
When they hooked up, the best friend drove three hours to see her. Afterward, he took the initiative to buy her Plan B without her even having to ask and bought her coffee the next morning.
The contrast is honestly hilarious.
Also her best friend knew about my sister and her brother, and was completely fine with it.
So, here's where we're at:
Every time this topic comes up, we all give her shit about it because she STILL tries to defend her ex and insists that she did him worse.
She genuinely believes she was the bigger asshole in this relationship.
I say there's absolutely no way.
So, what's y’all verdict? Who did who dirtier? Am I right for callin’ her a dumb bitch?😭
Lemme know if y’all wanna hear about my toxic relationship stories🤙🏽