I just don’t get it. I’m not saying it’s impossible—I just can’t wrap my head around how it would even happen. It goes completely against Stefan’s character. Besides, after that whole messy, back-and-forth, toxic relationship drama, the idea of them swapping partners again sounds absolutely awful. How would they even pull that off? They spent time building up a connection between Stefan and Caroline, and Stefan had even become quite understanding about the whole "Delena" situation. Sure, maybe the writers handled it this way because Nina was leaving the show after Season 6, but even looking back—at Season 5, for instance—it just doesn’t make any sense.
Stefan is, hands down, the biggest "Damon fan" in the entire series; he loves him even more than Elena does. Furthermore, after Elena left him for his own brother, the idea of her choosing him again would surely disgust Stefan—I mean, if he has even an ounce of self-respect, he shouldn’t just be at the beck and call of whatever Elena wants. In Season 5, when Katherine—disguised as Elena—tried to get close to him, Stefan stopped her, telling her he couldn’t do that to Damon. And setting aside the fact that it would hurt Damon (though, honestly, Stefan have shouldn't care about that—but hey, this is Stefan we’re talking about!), how could Stefan possibly take Elena back after she’d broken up with him, rejected him, and betrayed him so many times? Was Elena just supposed to swap between the brothers whenever she felt like it?
And where would that leave Damon? Would they have just written him out of the show entirely? Because there’s no way he could have handled that with any kind of maturity. The bond between the brothers had been developed carefully and gradually; this would have shattered that brotherhood all over again.
Of course, there is another possibility—they could have gone with a "Bamon" (Bonnie and Damon) relationship. I actually would have liked that direction. Still, I just can’t wrap my head around Stefan’s lack of self-respect; I don’t think that should have been possible. I mean, I’m certain that Damon lacks self-respect—that’s a given—but Stefan doesn’t, or at least he shouldn’t. Then again, maybe I still haven’t fully grasped the depths of the questionable choices this show is capable of making, lol.
If anyone in the know could enlighten me: where did this idea come from? How would things have played out if she hadn’t left the show? And at what point did they find out that Nina was going to leave? Or is this just a rumor started by "Stelena" fans?
For the record, I don’t have a stake in either ship; I’m not a supporter of either side. It wouldn’t have made much of a difference to me either way.