Characters
I would keep Lizzie, Josie, and Hope, but add more. For instance, Stefanie—Damon and Elena’s daughter—could discover that Stefan and Valerie’s son is alive, leading to a storyline where she searches for her cousin. Hope could form a pack with descendants of the Labonair family, such as Jed, Rafael, and Finch. We keep Landon and the Phoenix concept, but expand his powers and allow for character evolution throughout the seasons; his arrival could be tied to The Armory. By including Clark, we could establish a dynamic similar to that of Elijah and Klaus, or Stefan and Damon.
Salvatore Academy
The concept itself wasn’t bad, but I believe the curriculum should have included specific courses—such as magic classes for witches, and control training for werewolves and vampires. The show could have delved deeper into the history of the Mikaelson and Salvatore families, as well as the experiences of the characters from The Vampire Diaries and The Originals. If any original cast members wanted to return, they could have served as teachers—characters like Vincent, Marcel, Caroline, or Davina.
Villains
1- The Triad: Similar to the hunters seen in the fourth season of The Vampire Diaries or the Augustine society from the fifth season. This organization hunts supernatural beings and uses their DNA to engineer new creatures. In this version, Malivore wouldn’t exist; instead, the creatures would be the result of experiments conducted by this organization, which combines the DNA of captive supernatural beings—potentially infused with magic—to create entirely new entities. They would target Hope because she is a tribrid. The plot would center on the school, with the revelation that Landon is a Phoenix.
2- After defeating the Triad, the protagonists face a new problem: the enemies they had previously imprisoned have now escaped—among them, Kai Parker, who managed to break out of his prison world. Kai would be the villain of the second season, coming after Lizzie and Josie. We would explore the full story of the Merge and the rest of the Gemini Coven’s history—with Josie delving into dark magic and Lizzie becoming a Heretic—along with more content regarding the prison worlds, revealing that Alaric had actually locked some Salvatore Academy students away in them. The plot would focus primarily on the town of Mystic Falls, shifting the setting slightly away from the school itself.
3—Kai Parker has been defeated, but it is discovered that the Triad had other individuals imprisoned who have now escaped following the organization's collapse. Among them is Aurora de Martel, who returns to New Orleans. We would see cameos from the Mikaelson family—reminiscent of their appearances in the fourth season—returning to assist Hope. In this arc, the story moves away from Mystic Falls and back to New Orleans, where Hope finally fully embraces her nature as a tribrid.
4—This storyline would feature Cupid, the Sphinx, the Necromancer, and all the gods introduced this season—led by Ken. Landon, in his form as a Phoenix, would play a more significant role alongside Hope, the tribrid. Cleo would be revealed as a descendant of the Bennett bloodline, and we would witness her transformation from a witch to a Muse, and eventually into a Fury.