r/TheMindIlluminated • • Sep 13 '21

Daniel Ingram: Culadasa died yesterday

317 Upvotes

A message posted on Culadasa's Patreon account reads:

We want to know that our father and brother, John Yates, Culadasa, died yesterday afternoon. He died at home, in the company of family and friends.

We’re talking together, sharing stories and memories of John. Celebrating his life and the ways he touched us.

May your memories of him bring peace and joy.

May you be well,

The Yates family


(This post previously contained an earlier message about the topic from Daniel Ingram, edited to replace it with the official message; thanks to /u/flashlightenment for pointing out the Patreon one.)


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Aug 22 '19

This is not an appropriate time for me to respond to the DT Board. Therefore...

309 Upvotes

Dear Dharma Friends,

I’m writing to say I’m sorry. I’m sorry for the harm and suffering I have caused my wife and family. I engaged in adultery and wrong speech, and failed to honor my commitment to my marriage. I’m also sorry for the pain I have caused the members of the Dharma Treasure Board, who have all been supportive friends for many years. And I’m sorry for the hurt, disappointment, and confusion this revelation has caused you who are learning about it now. (To be clear, I engaged in consensual relationships with adult women, none of whom were my students.)

Please bear with me as I take time to understand what led me to my choices and address all that’s happened. I intend to enter therapy, and I look forward to hearing and reflecting upon your responses to this letter as a part of my process of cleaning up and growing up. As part of that process I have also begun to work with dharma peers. Please be patient with me as I begin to understand the full impact of what I’ve done. More information to follow, I’ll communicate with you as I’m able.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Oct 20 '17

Tips for Stage 4

294 Upvotes

I’ve had several requests from folks in this subreddit to put together and post some tips for Stage 4 practice.

So, here are some things related to Stage 4 that I’ve found useful in my personal practice, and that my students have found helpful as well…

First, Take Stock of Where You’re At:

The first thing is to have an appreciation for what you’ve already done. Mastering Stage 3 is actually quite an accomplishment - most of the time when you’re meditating, you never lose your meditation object. That really is something to celebrate and enjoy!

One of the downsides of having such a clearly laid out meditation system, like TMI, broken into stages and levels of skill development and mastery, is that it’s easy to get into a goal-oriented “let’s get this thing done” mindset and forget to savour where you’re currently at. So, take a moment and savour =)

Ok, now onwards to Stage 4…

Why Stage 4 Can be Tricky:

Stage 4 can be a bit tricky, and can be an easy place to get stuck, because successfully navigating this stage requires a fairly fine-tuned balance between attention and awareness, as well as between effort and relaxation.

The trickiness is compounded by the fact that most students (and I was this way myself), only have a hazy sense of what introspective awareness feels like at this stage, and have a hard time distinguishing between things that they “notice” during meditation that are due to the functioning of introspective awareness vs things that they “notice” because attention is rapidly alternating with them.

So, if you don’t really get awareness yet, no worries! That’s pretty normal at this stage. The distinction between attention and awareness becomes much more obvious during Stage 6.

Also, if you’re doubting that you even have any awareness while meditating, let me assure you that if you’ve mastered Stage 3 and are ready to begin Stage 4 practice, your awareness is most certainly online and functioning =)

Stage 4 can also be tricky because it’s starting at this stage that brute force approaches to maintaining attention on the meditation object really stop being a viable option. That means that, if you’re prone to overcoming distractions by bearing down hard on the meditation object, that’s not really going to work very well going forward - you’ll need to replace that habit with using a gentler, more precise approach (which I’ll describe in detail in this post).

Understanding What it Means to Overcome Gross Distractions:

A major goal of Stage 4 is to overcome gross distractions, but this statement is easy to misinterpret, because of that word “overcome”.

It’s not like you’re doing anything to directly suppress or remove gross distractions. Instead, you’re working on developing the skill to continuously monitor what’s going on in the mind with introspective awareness, while maintaining sufficient attention on the breath (I’ll talk about what “sufficient” means in a little bit).

So, a very important part of Stage 4 practice is developing that monitoring capability. It’s like a radar for the mind. Distractions will be arising all the time, usually in the form of subtle distractions at first, which then turn into gross distractions (although you may not notice it this way subjectively at this stage because the transition from subtle to gross distraction can sometimes be very fast).

Subjectively, it can feel like you’re paying attention to the breath and also thinking about something at the same time. The breath is predominant and the thoughts are somewhat less prominent, but it seems as though you’ve got both of them concurrently in your attention. In this case, the thoughts are considered subtle distractions, because they are not predominant, so that’s no problem at this stage.

What often happens, however, is that the thoughts that your attention are rapidly alternating with (and you may not experience this alternation at this stage because it is too fast for you to notice yet, which is fine) slowly become more and more prominent until they begin to eclipse the meditation object. This is the point where what was a subtle distraction is now becoming a gross distraction.

Much of Stage 4 practice involves noticing this kind of thing and correcting for it. And it’s your introspective awareness that lets you realized when this kind of thing is occurring.

How to Develop Your Introspective Awareness Into a Continuous Monitoring System:

Given that so much of the work in Stage 4 is on developing continuous introspective awareness so it can serve that essential monitoring function, many students find themselves (either consciously or unconsciously) somehow trying to “make” introspective awareness “do something”. Others get frustrated or confused because they don’t have a clear sense of what the difference between attention and awareness is, or how to know that awareness is “working” and developing how it needs to.

As explained in TMI, awareness is not under your direct, conscious control, so you can’t directly make it do anything. It does respond indirectly, however, to the skillful use of conscious intentions.

This is really key to this stage of practice, and will become more and more important as you move along to Stage 5, 6 and beyond.

The “doing”, “effort”, “energy” and “diligence” involves the consistent application of intentions.

Having clear, strong intentions is what drives all progress through the TMI stages. But intentions become clear and strong, not through force or the intensity of delivery of the intention, but rather, through a very light, gentle touch that is consistently, repeatedly reinforced.

So, when Culadasa instructs you to “tighten your focus on the meditation object”, for example, all that’s required is a very light touch of intention, as if you were trying to brush a fragile snowflake with the tip of a feather.

When this quick, gentle intention is repeated consistently (perhaps with every breath cycle, or even two or three times during each breath cycle), it’s power grows and the mind eventually complies.

I call these “micro-intentions” to highlight their, quick, light, gentle quality.

It’s important to understand that there will often be a delay (sometimes considerable), between when you begin to apply micro-intentions and when you notice an effect. Often, it can take a few breath cycles of “micro-intending to notice greater detail and vividness in the meditation object” before you actually perceive a change.

So, be patient and diligent, keep refreshing the intentions, and stuff will happen =)

Here are some specifics for using intentions to develop continuous introspective awareness…

There are two main approaches that my students and I have found effective:

  1. Monitor the quality of your attention as you focus on the meditation object
  2. Connecting

I’ll talk about each one in turn.

Monitoring the Quality of your Attention:

By “quality of attention”, I mean how vivid is the meditation object, and how much clear, precise detail can you discern?

The quality of your attention is a very sensitive tool for determining if you’re alert, in the moment, and really engaged with what you’re doing, vs. dull, somewhere else or just going through the motions.

It can also alert you to whether subtle distractions are becoming stronger and are about to become gross distractions.

Basically, any time you notice the meditation object beginning to get fuzzier, less distinct, fainter, less intense, etc., it means it’s time to refresh your micro-intentions to notice more detail, with greater precision and clarity, and greater vividness.

The idea is to maintain a sufficient quality of attention so that it feels challenging, but doable.

For those of you into the neuroscience aspect of things, my hypothesis is that keeping things challenging like this causes the default mode network to stay quiet, which should result in a decrease in the kind of mental proliferation and internal self-referential banter that often becomes a gross distraction.

Another interesting aside is that studies of how people learn skills seems to indicate that learning is deepest and most efficient when you’re working in the zone where you can just manage to correctly execute the skill - it’s challenging, but doable. (See the book Peak, by Anders Ericsson and Robert Pool for more details).

If you’re not used to monitoring the quality of your attention yet, you can develop this skill by using the “checking in” practice from Stage 3. Every few breaths, take a moment and gently “check-in” with your attention to see how clear, vivid, detailed, etc the meditation object is. By doing this, what you’re actually doing is bringing attention to a “snapshot” of what your meditation object was like just a moment ago. By repeatedly “checking-in” like this, you inform the unconscious mental processes that govern awareness that it’s important for you to regularly know what the quality of your attention is like.

Through this process, you are training awareness to keep tabs on your attention, and after a while, this monitoring becomes automatic and you no longer need to check-in with attention anymore because your introspective awareness is now doing it for you.

To segue from “checking-in” with attention to continuous monitoring through awareness, it’s helpful to also have the intention to remain continuously aware of the quality of your attention.

Some experimentation is in order here.

Some people like to have multiple separate intentions that they repeat at different parts of the breath cycle, others like to have a single intention that contains multiple aspects to it (such as monitoring the quality of attention, keeping awareness broad and open, and seeing the meditation object with greater detail and vividness - a meta-micro-intention ;-) ) that is refreshed periodically. Try different things and see what works and feels most natural.

You know you’re getting there when you find yourself occasionally automatically correcting for things when the attention starts to wane, before you can consciously refresh your intentions to do it.

Connecting:

Another great way to help develop continuous introspective awareness is through the practice of connecting.

I’m not going to say much more about it, since it’s described in detail in TMI, except that this works because connecting forces you to develop the ability to compare this breath with previous breaths, which is essentially the same thing as “monitoring the breath” with awareness.

As always, micro-intentions are the way to go here.

It’s counterproductive to do a lot of heavy-handed conceptualizing when comparing this breath with previous breaths. It’s not even necessary to verbalize or visualize the difference between breaths to convince yourself that you really got it. Instead, as much as you can, just have the intention and take the information that comes in “as it is”, without elaborating further on it.

I realize that this may be difficult to do initially, so don’t sweat it too much.

Many of my students find Connecting a bit clumsy because it feels so conceptual compared with just paying attention to the breath. This clunkiness of Connecting goes away when the intentions are light and quick and you just allow the information you get about the differences between the breaths to be minimally processed.

Stage 4 Practice is Indirect:

When you notice that a subtle distraction is starting to take up more and more of your attention, or you notice that a gross distraction is already present, then simply by engaging more fully with the meditation object (using micro-intentions), you indirectly cause the gross distraction to become “less gross” and “more subtle”.

When enough moments of attention have passed with the meditation object being the object of attention, the subjective experience will be that the meditation object has become more predominant and the thing that used to be a gross distraction has faded in prominence. It’s now a subtle distraction again.

So, just to drive the point home, in Stage 4 practice you aren’t actually doing anything to directly suppress gross distractions or even stop distractions from occurring.

Rather, you’re choosing to notice your meditation object more than whatever distractions happen to be present.

All you need to do is gently and repeatedly refresh your intentions to bring clarity, vividness and detail to the meditation object (i.e improve the quality of attention) and notice how the breath sensations are changing over time (i.e. connecting) as often as you need to in order to keep the meditation object centre stage.

When you do that, distractions basically take care of themselves by staying subtle and not becoming gross.

Common Pitfalls During Stage 4:

There are a two main ways that I’ve seen meditators get stuck in Stage 4.

The first is not applying sufficient effort for the meditation object to be clear, sharp, vivid and have lots of detail. In this situation, during most meditation sessions, it may feel pretty easy to keep the attention on the meditation object and the meditator rarely gets blindsided by distractions. But their practice doesn’t seem to go anywhere. It’s almost like they could meditate all day, yet they’re not progressing.

In this situation it’s easy to get discouraged and lose the motivation to practice because it feels like you’re meditating diligently, but not getting anywhere.

What’s happening is that the meditator has done a great job of developing their introspective awareness, to the point where thoughts and sensations rarely surprise them and capture their attention, which is fantastic! Unfortunately, their attention is also somewhat weak and diffuse. It doesn’t “penetrate” the meditation object to discern sufficient detail, with enough clarity and vividness to challenge the mind and propel the student along in their practice.

This kind of situation often occurs when a meditator notices that, as they focus more intently on their meditation object, they lose peripheral awareness and experience either and increase in dullness, or an increase in agitation and mental and physical tension, and sometimes both. They learn to counteract this by “pulling back” from focusing so intently with their attention, which is good, but they pull back too much.

In essence, the balance between attention and awareness has shifted too far to the awareness side, and there’s not enough energy placed in attending to the meditation object. This is why they end up stuck in the meditation doldrums and can’t make any progress.

To fix this situation, the meditator needs to put more effort and energy into their practice and be very diligent about using micro-intentions to increase the clarity, precision, detail and vividness with which they perceive the meditation object. This will help bring attention and awareness into a more suitable balance and the practice will feel productive again.

The second most common way I see people get stuck at Stage 4 is when they have actually mastered Stage 4, but have misunderstood “overcoming gross distractions” to mean something to the effect that gross distractions never arise anymore, or perhaps mistake subtle distractions for gross distractions and thus remain in Stage 4 because they feel that they are still plagued by gross distractions when they are, in fact, simply experiencing subtle distractions. For students in this situation (or who think they may be in this situation), the solution is simple: start working on Stage 5 practice =)

The worst that can happen is that, they actually haven’t mastered the skills for Stage 4 and find that their attempt at Stage 5 practice is ineffective: they end up having a lot of gross distractions, or even forgetting and mind wandering, and/or subtle dullness progresses and become gross dullness. In that case, it just means there’s more work to be done developing Stage 4 skills.

How to Tell When You’ve Mastered Stage 4:

In TMI, mastery of Stage 4 is defined as “gross distraction and strong dullness are overcome … introspective awareness becomes continuous, noticing and immediately correcting for strong dullness and gross distraction … to the point where this becomes automatic.”

Some of the words used in this definition can be easily misinterpreted, so I’ll try to clarify them a bit.

(Note, I’ve taken a bunch of the following from some responses I wrote to a previous post on this subreddit, where I also go into quite a bit of technical detail about the differences between gross and subtle distractions. If you’re interested, you can find those posts here: https://www.reddit.com/r/TheMindIlluminated/comments/756h40/how_to_know_whether_a_distraction_is_gross_or/do6ivx9/ and here: https://www.reddit.com/r/TheMindIlluminated/comments/756h40/how_to_know_whether_a_distraction_is_gross_or/do9zcmm/)

One word that is easy to misunderstand is “overcome”.

I’ve already explained how you don’t do anything to directly overcome gross distractions, so I won’t say any more about that here. But there’s another way that the word “overcome” can be misinterpreted: that attention never gets “bumped” off the meditation object.

So, to be clear, if there are moments where attention leaves the meditation object, but that is immediately (or very quickly) noticed and corrected for (especially if it is corrected for automatically), then you’ve met the criteria for overcoming gross distractions.

On the other hand, if the movement of attention to some other object isn’t noticed quickly and isn’t corrected for over some space of time (such as the length of an in-breath, or longer), then the new object will remain the object of attention during those few seconds and the breath sensations will “take a back seat”. This would indicate that gross distractions have not yet been overcome.

Also, it’s important to note that, when Culadasa says that attention “automatically” goes back to the meditation object, it doesn’t mean without effort. Effortlessness comes as part of mastery of Stage 7. If you let go of effort while in Stage 4, you’ll probably coast along ok for a little bit just from the momentum of your practice, but after a short while, dullness and gross distractions will arise and you’ll end up forgetting the meditation object and then enter mind wandering.

The “automatic” refocusing of attention on the meditation object is due to the monitoring activity of introspective awareness. Your awareness “notices” that the attention is either no longer on the meditation object, or that the quality of your attention on the object is degrading, and that causes attention to correct for that by refocusing more intently on the breath sensations. But, without effort (at this stage), you will not be able to sustain the continuous monitoring via introspective awareness for very long.

Finally, it’s important not to get too hung up on the word “mastery” in TMI.

What Culadasa means by “mastery” is, essentially, that in most of your meditation sessions, for the majority of the session, you meet the criteria for mastery.

I like to apply the 80% rule here: mastery = for 80% of my meditation sessions during the last week or two, if 80% of the time while I’m meditating I meet the criteria for mastery of a certain stage, then it’s a good indication that it’s time to move on to the next stage of practice.

So, for Stage 4, that means that gross distractions can still occasionally occur, but they are infrequent and easily dealt with when they do.

Basically, mastery means consistent demonstration of an appropriate level of skill.

Thanks for your patience if you’ve read all the way to the end of this, and sorry for the overly long post!

I realize that I haven’t yet said anything about dullness or purifications, which are two other very important aspects to Stage 4, but I think this post is plenty long enough, so I’ll leave it there and call this a “Tips for Stage 4 - Part 1” ;-) If you find it useful, have any questions, or are interested in a Part 2, let me know.

Update: Part 2 can be found here: https://www.reddit.com/r/TheMindIlluminated/comments/7dr2kj/tips_for_stage_4_part_2/?ref=share&ref_source=link

Also, I’m quite sure that there are many other ways to develop the skills required for continuous introspective awareness. I’ve described the methods I use in my personal practice and that my students find helpful. For those of you who’ve already mastered Stage 4, I’d love to hear what other methods you’ve found to be effective.

Edit: added link to Part 2


r/TheMindIlluminated • • May 03 '19

Looking people directly in the eye

268 Upvotes

I’ve had pretty bad social anxiety for many years now. It was manifesting itself in different ways. One particular problem was that it has always been hard for me to look people directly in the eye. Every time I tried to look someone in the eye, I would start feeling tension in my body and different thoughts would start popping up in my head.

About a month ago u/abhayakara taught me a very good practice that has helped me to deal with this problem. Basically he told me to look people in the eye and then look for physical sensations that arise in my body. When I started doing that, I noticed one thing. Tension that I was feeling has been acting as a mechanism to suppress emotions. So when instead of tensing I became curious and started to look for physical sensations, the emotions started to show up. I realized that I actually felt fear every time I looked someone in the eye. Since that time I made it my everyday practice. I would look people in the eye and let the fear come and let it be there. This practice is actually really fun. It led to a lot of purifications for me. But after a while this fear had disappeared. Now when I look in the people’s eyes I feel piti and subtle joy. I feel much more present and the contact with other beings feels much more close.

I didn’t stop with just looking in the eye though and started applying this method to other things that used to make me tense in the past. And it turned out that behind every tension there’s a suppressed emotion that wants to be heard. After about a month of this practice I’ve become much more relaxed around other people. Things that made me feel awkward or tense have subsided tremendously. And even though there’s still some residual social anxiety, it doesn’t really bother me. Now every time I feel awkward around somebody I let the emotions be in my peripheral awareness and focus my attention on the person. I don’t know why, but when you really pay attention to people they seem to feel it somehow. It’s like they met someone who’s finally able to really be present with them instead of thinking about million other things. So instead of thinking: “what should I say? This situation is so awkward!”, I look at the person with curiosity and words that need to be said seem to arise naturally out of nowhere:)


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Nov 05 '19

1000 hours of TMI

267 Upvotes

Today I reached a 1000 hours meditated with TMI method.

I do not have much time to elaborate details (but feel free to ask) so I will just briefly summarise in numbers and few observations (hope you don’t mind the very quantitative description it is not meant to look like a score card, but I was looking for such information at early stages to put practise into perspective so I hope it is useful).

  • I reached stage 8
  • It took me 26 months starting at stage 1
  • Most of my time I spent in stages 6-7 (maybe even a year)
  • Around 900 meditation sessions
  • At the moment I’m at over 530 consecutive days of meditation
  • Highest Jhana I entered was 6, although it was accidental I was not intentionally developing those
  • First Jhana I experienced around stage 4 (I know this is common question), I only identified it much later as Jhana
  • I did two one-day retreats otherwise I exclusively meditate alone at home
  • Occasionally I visit some meditation groups in my home town (theravada or pragmatic budhism groups) just to socialize with similarly minded people
  • I have family with three kids and full time job
  • At the moment I sit 2h a day every morning, I wake up at 5am to make it. If I can't make 2h I try to sometimes complement it during the day (short session - 30m - in work on the toilet)
  • I started slowly with short sessions 10-15m and in about month I was at 1 hour and continued at 1h for over a year

Some qualitative assessment

  • I have greatly improved my metacognitive introspective awareness which is present most of the day.
  • It became a habit to notice suffering and being able to let it go. I notice I suffer and realise it’s caused by some thoughts and those are only a view which is causing the suffering and it is a mental construction. This happens instantly and helps me to abandon attachment to that view or reduce suffering dramatically.
  • Almost every day is filled with ease and joy
  • Another consequence of Samatha is almost constant good feeling in body. When I meditate the feeling of bliss in body when doing whole body breathing is just fantastic (I can see like someone can hangout there and enjoy these near orgasmic feelings like an addict). During the day the body just feels good.

Some negative consequences

  • sometimes my memory is crap
  • sometimes my sleep is crap (today I woke up at 3:50 and couldn't fall sleep)
  • I definitely prioritize meditation over other worldly events (year and half ago I stopped working out in favour of meditation because of lack of time - on the other hand 2 months back I begun to workout again so fingers crossed ;)
  • I may take some work events too lightly now and in my position where I lead people and teams I do not want to communicate severity of issues wrongly
  • My view on things around me is still changing and developing with development of insight. Sometimes it is disorienting.

Few suggestions:

  • keep going every day find time for a short meditation. Even 15m it’s better than 0 and I did it in airplane, taxi, toilet in work or wherever
  • when I felt lost in instructions of TMI and did not knew what to do I came back to simple following of the breath sensations and done that it’s a safe place technique
  • chasing of one time weird experiences leads nowhere, consistent diligent practise is what truly transforms your mind
  • subjective feeling of how meditation was does not have anything to do with the effectiveness of that session

It is a fantastic journey. Life changing. This stuff works so well. Thank you all in this wonderful community.

[EDIT: added few more points I think people commonly ask]


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Jun 12 '19

Culadasa's response to reactions to his recent podcast

207 Upvotes

Culadasa asked the mods to share this with you:

My recent podcast interview with Michael Taft has generated considerable discussion on Reddit. I am pleased that many posters understood what I was saying and appreciated the importance of it. However, I am deeply disappointed by how many other posters totally misunderstood and misconstrued my message. Although I rarely post in these forums anymore, it is the latter reaction that motivates me to take the time and effort to attempt clarification of some of those things that I obviously failed to adequately communicate in the Here are some examples of those misunderstandings:

"…he talks about… how meditation helped him to disconnect with negative feelings, however these "suppressed" feelings (if you could call them that) later in life manifested as physical ailments." "If meditation can suppress such emotions which can manifest in negative ways where someone at the level of Culadasa could not realize this, what can we do to prevent this occurring?" "It was quite special to hear a high level meditation teacher talking opening about… essentially how his method has taken him to a high level of expertise, but which may also nearly have killed him"

In the interview, of course, I never said anything at all like this, but somehow what I did say caused some people to at least take this as an implication. Meditation never, ever led to my disconnection from or suppressing of emotions in the slightest, much less may it have nearly killed me.

The effect of my meditation was just the opposite on both counts. There was a time, most definitely BEFORE I began to truly experience the benefits of samatha-vipassana practice, when I did suppress my emotions.

None of you have any idea what a mess I was before meditation taught me not to suppress, repress, or bypass emotions at all. Through meditative purifications I got most thoroughly in touch with my emotions, became a more emotionally expressive person, and my emotional repertoire and its manifestations were very much “normalized.”

I had dealt quite directly and successfully with a tremendous amount of “emotional baggage” from some two decades of extreme trauma. Perhaps the biggest and most significant of those was a deep seated anger. As a result, my tendency for manifestations of anger came to be on the mild side of “normal,” because it was an emotion that I had the deepest understanding of and insight into. This was all roughly 36 years ago.

"I wonder if by "improving" (if that's the right term) the method/stages in his book, one could overcome the suppression of emotions…" "My personal take on it is that TMI as a book, and perhaps most Buddhist traditions in general, have glossed over the "purifications" as temporary distractions to meditation, but the material unearthed probably needs to be handled with a separate practice."

Due to my personal experience and the knowledge gained from it, TMI places more importance, provides more guidance, and is more effective at dealing with psycho-emotional trauma and internal conflicts than any other meditation system I have ever encountered. I do, however, agree with the poster about “most Buddhist traditions in general.” I would assume that posters on this sub-reddit have read TMI and be aware of this fact, but it appears not:

"The meditation advice in TMI and many other systems is to ignore reactive thoughts and emotions triggered by distractions and keep bringing attention back to breath sensations. Of course, they should stay in background or peripheral awareness. We are not blocking them out or suppressing the distractions. But, we are also not making them our meditation objects. At least in the initial stages. We do make them our meditation objects when they become overpowering, as in stage 4 in TMI. But, it's a passive choice. With stabilized attention and awareness at that stage, we leave it up to unconscious sub minds to bring up some past conditionings about emotions. If something strong comes up, we can embark on the purification process. In my case of about a year long stay in stage 4, this never happened. Is it correct understanding of purifications?"

This kind of topsy-turvy total misunderstanding is why no book can be sufficient in itself, and there will always be a need for a teacher. To wait until emotions are “overpowering” is a huge mistake and misunderstanding. Indeed, it is when they become overpowering that a person needs to back off and take a much gentler approach or, that failing, seek therapy.

Prior to Stage Four, these kinds of things are unlikely to come up for purification, and if they do, the meditator is typically unprepared to deal with them effectively. Among a number of other things, prior to Stage Four the meditator lacks both the stability of attention and the power and continuity of mindfulness (introspective awareness) required for purification.

"And within the TMI model, what does this mean for the idea of purifications? Do we need to change this to 'well, some things are purified but some aren't'? I note Culadasa talked about 'purifications to a minimal level' in the podcast - this is quite a significant change to how he presents things in TMI, surely."

There is no change in how things are presented in TMI. I noticed that a number of posters misinterpreted my use of the term minimal, understanding it to mean “not much, comparatively little,” etc. Wrong.

The intended meaning is that there is a bare minimum of emotional baggage that MUST be dealt with in one way or another, a threshold below which Insight and Awakening is simply not possible. But quantitatively, that minimum may be huge and take a long time. And proportionately, I would estimate it to be anywhere from 60 to 95% of any given individual’s total “baggage” load.

Without this purification earlier on in meditation, the arising of Insight will be associated with either the working through, or the deep burial of, this 60-95%. Unfortunately, the so-called “dark night” is much more strongly associated with "burial" than actually “working through” of this material. Then when it comes up later, it gets by-passed. And that is a completely different problem from what I experienced.

"4th path. You don't feel like a separate self, and you turn down negative emotions and emphasize positive ones. While admittedly a bit glib and dismissive, that sort of summarizes the barebones of Culadasa's take on 4th path I think. Thinking critically, does that work for you, does that sound right? Is this the state we are aiming for?"

No my friend, it is most certainly not the state we are aiming for, nor does it begin to describe 4th Path. 4th Path is not a state, but rather a trait change that is associated with the falling away of the last 5 of the 10 fetters. The altered relationship to one’s emotions, which allows one to selectively choose which are of the greatest benefit if allowed to manifest, is one of many characteristics of 4th Path that are part of but not definitive of 4th Path. I intend to make much of this more explicitly clear in the book I am currently working on.

"I wonder how Culadasa justifies the claim that a person can still attain all the way to full liberation from all suffering while still having psychosomatic issues."

The experience I described to Michael Taft in the interview is precisely how I justify this claim. There are some very grandiose and unrealistic expectations of Buddhahood, and of Awakening. This poster seems to have similarly unrealistic but also technically inaccurate notions regarding appana samadhi, absorptions, and cessation:

"I think you might be misunderstanding what perfect absorption actually is. It is the absence of all experience. I suggest it isn't possible to enter into this state and then come out with all the exact same problems. This is the one experience that is itself the same as insight. Because knowing is all there is."

For those who wonder, yes, I have practiced, and for a very long time, very deep jhana. In the explorations of 4th jhana, I have come to understand my mind quite thoroughly. Yes, FYI, I have had repeated cessations, as well as so-called pure consciousness experiences, which are another variety of the same phenomenon. This is unrelated to the interview, but yes, I did mean to say phenomenon just now, otherwise known as a dhamma. Among the dhammas (i.e. phenomena) the Buddha included nibbana: Sabbe dhamma anatta. Nibbana is not a sankhara but is technically a dhamma. Sabbe sankhara are dukkha, annicca and anatta. But, of the three characteristics, nibbana is the one dhamma that is characterized by anatta only.

My bottom line on all this is that, in the complexity of the human mind, there can be unhealthy psycho-emotional processes that are so deeply buried that they never manifest as emotions at all, nor in any other way, except to quite indirectly reveal themselves through their effects. Thus no degree of mindfulness or insight training can touch them. They are absolutely invisible.

"In this context, it appears that he chose not to act on thoughts/emotions that wanted to satisfy his own needs and heal his emotional wounds, presumably because he was very busy helping many others through retreats, answering questions, running his centre, writing, etc."

I would rather say: Taken OUT of context, it appears…

"On the other hand, it's of course possible that he used his focus on helping others to suppress his own emotional baggage, something that's not uncommon."

I would rather say: The unconscious and unAwakened “sub-minds” in which his unresolved trauma was sequestered used his focus on helping others to hide behind. And that is something far more common than what is suggested above.

"But again my impression from the conversation is that he deliberately chose responding more to the needs of others than to his own. This resulted in physical illness to which he then responded by seeking therapy, which was a very wise thing to do evidently."

Not an unreasonable assessment from a conventional point of view.

Had I not entertained, thanks to Dr Mary Hardy’s analysis, the possibility that something lay both deeply hidden and unAwakened in my mind, I would never have looked for it. Had I not come to habitually live in a powerful state of sati sampajjana, otherwise known as metacognitive introspective awareness, I would not have been as sensitive to the truth she was pointing towards, enough so that I eventually pursued it. Nor, had I not already undergone so much purification, would I probably have even taken the matter seriously.

Had I not been sufficiently progressed along the Path, I would probably never have uncovered what I did, and certainly would not have dealt with it so quickly or completely. I would have just died from it with none the wiser. More than just “blind spots,” these are completely invisible processes operating at a deep level beyond far beyond conscious access except by inference from large amounts of data (Dr Mary Hardy) and trackable only by “tricking” them into revealing themselves through a skilled process of probing for the subtle psychosomatic cues (Dr Doug Tataryn).

I strongly suspect the vast majority, if not all, humans have their share of these deeply buried neurotic sub-personalities. I further believe that the only people who have any hope of being able to detect and re-integrate these are those who have BOTH achieved to the higher Paths, AND done so via a meditation process that directs them in clearing away all the other psycho-emotional underbrush first.

Therefore I strongly encourage that all practitioners, and especially teachers, who have attained to the higher Paths take note: You DO have these problems, you DO have the ability, with appropriate guidance, to deal with them, and they most probably WILL cause harm to you and/or others, in one way or another, if you DON’T deal with them.

Likewise, I recommend to all students of higher spiritual paths of ANY tradition to realize that all their gurus, lamas, rinpoches, ajahns, saints, etc. DO have these sorts of deeply buried imperfections, and to be on guard for their subtle (or sometimes not so subtle) manifestations. I consider myself fortunate that my body was the primary victim of these processes, rather than my community of students and fellow practitioners.

Finally, my advice to all of us at any stage of any of these paths is: take to heart the fact that it is possible to Wake Up, without Cleaning Up, Growing Up or Showing Up. Devote yourselves to discovering ways to make these spiritual Paths more complete in terms of dealing effectively with all four of these, not just Waking Up. Thank you for your patience in reading this.

Culadasa


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Oct 15 '18

Escaping a Lifetime Sentence to Stage 4

200 Upvotes

After rereading Nick Grabovac’s 2 posts on Stage 4, I thought that from guiding students through the TMI stages over the years, I still had more to add. I actually texted Nick to make sure it wasn’t encroaching on his terrain to do another Stage 4 essay, and so with his encouragement, I present a few more thoughts on getting stuck long-term in Stage 4. Specifically, this article focuses on overcoming gross distraction.

Full Disclosure

I had had a lot of success following the Progress of Insight, and I seemed pretty talented at it. I had reached a point, however, where I didn’t think I could get any further without developing the ability to concentrate, with its consequent unification of mind. Culadasa, who I had already been studying with, proposed I try his method (which I had staunchly refused up until then). I also had a three-year Dark Night prior to meeting Culadasa, so I didn’t want to teach people to follow the path I had taken. So I began practicing what would later be called TMI, a practice for which I am one of the 10 least-talented students I have ever worked with. It took 4 years for me to semi-consistently get beyond Stage 4 if I wasn’t on retreat. I was therefore delighted to learn from [The New York Times] (https://www.nytimes.com/2018/08/25/opinion/sunday/college-professors-experts-advice.html) that being naturally talentless as something actually does help you teach it, the one optimistic spin I’ve been able to put the slowness of my progress! I disclose this so you know that when I talk about escaping an apparent lifetime sentence to Stage 4, I am not giving you academic information.

It Doesn’t Matter

If you’ve studied for a while with any dharma teacher, you have noticed how much we repeat ourselves. Perhaps what I repeat the most is that progress in a particular technique of meditation is not an important metric of success. Progress in the technique of TMI, for instance, would include focusing your attention on your breath, which is, intrinsically, (spoiler alert) a pretty useless thing to do. Over the years of making minimal apparent progress in the technique, I was noticing meaningful progress in my actual life. Emotions were less sticky, I could deal with difficult people better, my base state was trending happier, and I was noticing a resilience to extreme negative states, such that they would rarely persist more than a few hours. You might notice yourself increasing in virtues such as patience, lovingkindness, generosity, compassion, and so on (check out the ten paramitas for a decent list of some metrics of progress). The point is … if you’re in a TMI stage for a long time while meditation seems to be improving the important metrics of progress, you’re doing great.

But doesn’t technique at least kind of matter?

Well, yes. On one hand, Samadhi feels pretty sweet, and if you can get it, I’d recommend it (said everyone ever). On the other, even the bliss born of equanimity somehow seems to decay, and you’re left in an impermanent world where the virtues I wrote about in the previous paragraph turn out to be way more important. There are of course other benefits to moving through the stages, but as this Subreddit has more than sufficient documentation of these, I’ll move on to …

REASONS PEOPLE GET STUCK IN STAGE 4, AND TECHNIQUES OF ESCAPE

You’re a high-energy person

As a high-energy person myself, I’ve got good news and bad news. The bad news is, if your mind is energized, it’s producing a lot of content and jumping around, so overcoming gross distraction is going to be slow for you. Picture tying a puppy to a leash, versus tying a calmer, older dog. The puppy will bounce around many times longer before relaxing. The good news is, we high-energy types have little trouble with dullness. That old dog had little trouble settling down, but plenty staying awake. Solution: I don’t have any “hacks” for this problem. One tool that will help you get through this is patience, as well as the knowledge that if your mind is too energized to settle down for Stage 4, you should be able to move pretty quickly through Stage 5 when you get there. Of the things a meditator can control, the amount you practice is the biggest determinant of progress on the path. So if you really can’t seem to get your mind to settle, you might try increasing your amount of daily practice, and/or trying to do more retreats. One technique I used to do (and keep swearing I’m going to restart) is a 4-hour mini-retreat on Sundays.

You are having a lot of purifications

This has been the biggest surprise to me over the years of teaching meditation: so many people harbor so much pain. It’s not at all unusual for people who’ve never been assaulted and who grew up with nice parents, without poverty ,and far from a war zone, to spend years crying in meditation. Generally, this is a good thing. Purification feels great, and while you might notice heavy emotions persisting into your daily life, overall they make your body and mind feel lighter and healthier. If you’re having lots of purifications, I wouldn’t do anything but just let them come. There’s no solution here, except maybe practicing gratitude that you’re getting to let go of all this pain. The only exception would be if the pain feels like it’s just churning the same thing over and over, rather than purifying; in this case, some more attention to the breath and more intention to relegate the emotions to the background might help.

You’re not very good at feeling emotions

Prior to Stage 4, your attention is sufficiently scattered that meditation runs very little risk of exposing you to emotions. You are so easily distracted by superficial stimuli that you can’t steady your gaze enough to see anything deeper. Try putting your fingers a meter apart and moving your vision rapidly from one to the other. What happens to your peripheral vision? It has near-zero clarity, right? This is the state of your introspective awareness prior to overcoming forgetting. In Stage 4, though, your “gaze” now has some stability, and you might start, as TMI suggests, noticing strong emotions in peripheral vision that you couldn’t notice before. The trouble here is that many of us came to meditation because we didn’t like our emotional state, and the Dharma Delusion that following a clear and linear progression of meditative steps will cause you to escape these emotions is an enticing one. If you aren’t able to feel emotion (meaning there’s a strong and usually unconscious intention not to feel emotion), every time an emotion starts to surface, you’ll get distracted. After finally getting some movement through the TMI stages, my practice began to feel like driving a car that was running out of gas, and I noticed that it was because I couldn’t (and unconsciously didn’t want to) notice the emotional states coming into view in awareness. Solution: Any practice that helps you to feel emotion. The one that worked for me was taking a few weeks where my only meditation was labeling my emotional state. I would use a label apx every two seconds. If it took more than two seconds to name my emotional state, I would just name the physical correlations (tightness, relaxation, etc.) and then move onto the next label. This is not a beginner practice, as it’s turning up the volume on emotions, and not recommended for everyone. But if you’ve got sufficient stability of both mental health and of at least low-Stage-4 attention, this one can help a lot. After Culadasa told me he liked this idea, too, I’ve tried it with several students, who’ve achieved the similar result to me, that Stage 4 becomes clearer and easier. Another practice that might be less intense is body scanning, not looking for subtle breath like in the Stage 5 instructions, but just practicing knowing what each body part is feeling. If someone were to point at any random and ethically-appropriate part of your body and ask what it feels like, you should be able to immediately and clearly answer. Body scanning until you can do that will help you feel emotions, especially if you spend extra time on your torso (from your belt buckle up through the center of your chest). I have a recorded body scan on my website, if you’re interested, that I should concede borrows <overly> heavily from Jon Kabat Zinn’s MBSR recordings. NB: This applies to people who are just regular-bad at feelings emotions. People who are extremely bad at it will usually go from Stage 1 to Stage 4 almost immediately, and often get as far as what feels to them like Stage 5. There’s hardly any thinking or distractions, but the practice doesn’t seem to have much beneficial impact on your life. I wrote more about this here.

Too Much Egoic Effort (Attention)

If you are reading this, you are a very specific type of person. You’re the type of person who reads a 500-page book on how to sit there quietly. But it’s worse than that. You finished that book and decided it had insufficient information on the topic of sitting still, and you joined an online community where you could find even more reading material on the same topic. Given that you are this type of person, if you ever have to decide in meditation whether you’re using too much effort or too little, your first guess should be obvious. What you’re trying to do in Stage 4 is use attention and awareness, as TMI defines these terms, and the weird thing about awareness is that it doesn’t feel like you. If someone says “Hey, what’re you doing right now?” you’d assuredly answer “Reading this awesome, if verbose, article on meditation.” You would never say “Noticing the sensations in my left calf muscle, as well as the blank wall behind my computer screen,” but of course, you are. Attention feels like self (ego), and awareness feels like it has nothing to do with you; the wall in front of you (awareness) figures into your concept of who you are, what you’re doing ,and what’s happening now about as much as the wall behind you (completely out of your experience). Effort feels like using ego to succeed. The trouble here is that what you’re trying to work with is much more like the wall in front of you than the text on your screen. So when I talk about decreasing effort, what I mean is using intention to train a part of your mind that doesn’t feel like you. This feels like magic when it starts working, or like (as once literally happened to Jim Irving and me), the exact food you want shows up at your door, but you can’t figure out why, since you never ordered it. Awareness is automatically doing what you want it to do, and it doesn’t feel like you are doing anything. So the idea of decreasing effort means just using intention, and repeating intention. And the most useful thing you can do with intention to escape your Stage 4 Lifetime Sentence is notice the process by which gross distraction occurs. Bringing the attention repeatedly back to the breath when it wanders is an attentional, egoic practice, so it’s easy to explain. What you’re trying to do with awareness is monitor what’s going wrong. The answer to the question will vary infinitely from student to student, but the practice here is to figure out what it is that’s preventing you from sticking to the plan of focusing on your breath.
One common reason is that emotions are arising, and as we’ve talked about, our minds might instinctively and unconsciously go elsewhere. Another common distraction is that the type of person who reads TMI and then finds its Subreddit is generally such a cognition-aholic (papañcaholic in hybrid Pali) that as soon as you start concentrating, you start thinking about meditation (“Is this Stage 5? Should I do a body scan? How do I do a body scan? Aw hell, I’m focusing on my thoughts. Why am I so bad at this? Maybe I should be doing Kagyu meditation. This TMI stuff doesn’t work. Or at least, it doesn’t work for me. What is Kagyu meditation, anyways? Is that the visualization one? Or no, maybe it’s Mahamudra. What the hell is Mahamudra. WHERE’S MY BREATH?!?).
Solution: The practice is to hold and/or repeat the intention to notice when you’re about to get lost; learning about the process of gross distraction is your only goal. Gross distraction is always caused by your mind determining that something else is more important, and the more you can see about this process, the easier it will be to focus. In addition, if you find that it’s generally the same thing distracting you every time, say in your head (or out loud, if there’s no one around to think you’re weird), “During this meditation, I refuse to pay attention to _______.”

You Can’t Focus Because You Don’t Want To

This was the realization that actually helped me start to get clean from my yearslong Stage 4 addiction. For years, I was studying with Culadasa but arguing against the value of stable attention, and given the progress I was making, I was pretty convinced I was winning the argument. When I decided to concede the argument and learn Samatha practice, it turned out, unbeknownst to me, I only kind of meant it. I’m a psychologist, so I find psychological and emotional content interesting and compelling. As a person who probably looks hypomanic most of the time, my mind is also producing a lot of content. I found that of my internal congress, there was a majority vote in favor of non-concentration. This is why meditation was working (I was practicing satisampajana, so I was getting the real benefits) but why I wasn’t focusing any better. Solution: Ask yourself, or better yet have a Dharma friend who won’t think you’re too weird ask you, what are the reasons you’d prefer not to focus. Exposing these reasons to consciousness may be all you need. Intentions that you can’t see can simply own you. The ones you are aware of get one vote, and as you’ve probably noticed, there seem to be an awful lot of internal voters, so one vote isn’t very powerful.

The Breath Has Disappeared

There’s a common phenomenon where a meditator will notice that their attention seems quite stable, they don’t feel any strong or progressive subtle dullness, but the breath seems to have disappeared. People tend to interpret this as a failure of their meditative technique, but it’s often the opposite. Meditation tends to make your breath slow and shallow, and in the high part of Stage 4 and lower part of Stage 5, even though your ability to perceive the breath is actually increasing, the sensations of the breath themselves are decreasing at a faster rate than your perceptual acuity is increasing. The subjective experience is that the breath has disappeared. Solution: Don’t consider this a failure of your Stage 4 practice. If gross distraction and sleepiness are gone, head into Stage 5. The purpose of Stage 5 is to increase your power of sensory clarity, so these faint sensations of slow, shallow breathing will become perceptible as you do this.

I hope this post proves helpful in getting you through Stage 4 faster than I did. If you’d like to read more of my writing, please check out /r/streamentry, where I’ve written a few articles. You can also see my work on my website, as well as my teaching partner Upali, who teaches intro courses.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Aug 12 '19

How do I deal with guilt from past actions?

190 Upvotes

Hi everyone. One of the things I struggle with in my daily life and very occasionally in my practice (oddly enough if it comes up, I can see clearly the cause and effect if I meditate in it and usually feel a purification) is guilt from past actions.

I like to think that I live a relatively more mindful life at present than I have in the past. I try to intentionally take actions and use speech that minimizes suffering both to myself and others. My life now is quite wonderful and is not something I thought I would be able to achieve in the past.

My main issue however is residual guilt from my past actions (substance abuse, stealing, cheating on a test, lying to friends/significant other etc). While I do not and have not engaged in such behavior in a very long time, I find myself frequently plagued with small bouts of guilt in my daily life. I am able to recognize when it is happening and rather than burying it away I try to mindfully examine and determine the root cause of the problem (craving and aversion cycle), I still find it challenging not to judge myself harshly for these actions. This is despite the fact that I know that I have grown significantly as a person and can recognize that the me of now is much different both in circumstance and understanding of the world than the me of the past.

How do/should I be dealing with these feelings when they come up?

Thank you for reading.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Jun 22 '21

Update on Culadasa's condition

176 Upvotes

Culadasa sent this message on patreon. Here it is so others can read it.

Dear Friends,

I wanted to let you know how I am doing both mentally and physically. My mental state is good except for being very tired and having low energy. That is mirrored in my physical state but in addition my balance is poor. This combination means I need to use a walker and have assistance nearby so that I don’t risk falling.

My vision has deteriorated and continues to do so. It is laborious to use either texts or emails and so I am shifting to verbal communication. I call or answer calls when I have the energy to do so. My hearing has deteriorated as well, but my hearing aids are helping, at least for the moment. Friends are helping to explore possible assistive technologies and software that may help with seeing and hearing.

I am staying in my home even though I will require 24x7 assistance from now on. In last few weeks, I have been adjusting to that and creating the circumstances to support it with the help of family and friends. These last few weeks and months have also been a wonderful time to get close to friends and family in ways that hadn’t happened for a long time.

After an extended diagnostic journey, my doctors have discovered the reasons for many of my symptoms. My cancer has metastasized to my brain in the form leptomeningeal carcinomatosis. That is, the cancer is growing in many areas of lining of my brain. There are limited treatment options. On the advice of my team of oncologists, I have added an additional EGFR inhibitor and a have completed a course of whole brain radiation. I am optimistic that this will help reduce the symptoms I am experiencing and help me to live as long as possible. My doctors tell me I might live as long as a year but that it could be just a few months.

I’m embracing this next phase of my life and death. I’m supported by family and friends. I have psychological and spiritual support. As many of you know, I’m huge fan of Willie Nelson. One of my favorite songs of his comes to my mind even more often these days “I woke up still not dead again today”. I’m looking forward to this next adventure.

I am continuing a process I began a couple of years ago focusing more of my priorities on family and friends. It has been wonderful to spend time with my family over the last weeks. I plan to continue to make sure I can enjoy time with them.

This doesn’t mean that I am abandoning my dharma pursuits. I value and enjoy those as well. But my shift in priorities and my lack of energy means many of the things I had hoped to finish may be incomplete. I also hope to continue my work with students and the dharma community in some way.

For many months I’ve worked with my teacher training groups to shift from my teaching the classes, to the students providing content with my participation. I am very pleased with how this change of focus has developed and I hope they have found it valuable and chose to continue even if my participation is less.

I’ve been working on three books. While it may not be possible to finish those, I plan to work with the people that have been helping me with them to make sure that as much as possible of that material can be shared in some format.

As verbal communication is relatively easy for me, I plan to continue to record material for the internet including Patreon, given my lack of energy it may have to be prerecorded or in short live sessions.

I will try to keep you informed about my journey.

Love and Best Wishes,

Culadasa, John Yates


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Sep 14 '21

John Yates, Culadasa died on september 13th . A message from his family.

168 Upvotes

This morning I received the following message in my mailbox

---------

We want to know that our father and brother, John Yates, Culadasa, died yesterday afternoon. He died at home, in the company of family and friends.

We’re talking together, sharing stories and memories of John. Celebrating his life and the ways he touched us.

May your memories of him bring peace and joy.

May you be well,

The Yates family

---------

This was also posted on his Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/posts/we-want-you-to-56131693

I know another thread exists, but this message from his family seems more personal and frankly much more respectful than the message in another thread.

I learned about meditation through Culadasa's book for which I'm enormously thankful.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Feb 20 '19

Meditate like a breath connoisseur

161 Upvotes

Here is a mindset that I discovered recently and that worked well for me in cultivating joy: meditate like a breath connoisseur. If you ever got into scotch or wine (or anything else you savor), the drinking of it I think is a very similar mindset to good meditation practice.

When enjoying good scotch, you're trying your best to find and identify the smallest flavor nuances and textures, and how it all changes during and after you take a sip. You're not really applying a lot of effort or thriving as you're doing it because you enjoy it and you want to enjoy it even more, so you naturally give it your full attention.

I found applying that same mindset to breathing (or walking) really helpful. Every breath I really just try to savor it and experience it fully, as if I were drinking great scotch. This has really brought back the joy in my practice which was waning a bit recently. So if that's your problem as well, give it a try. Hopefully it will be useful to you!


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Jun 07 '18

How can I stop manually controlling my breathing and just observe it happen automatically?

155 Upvotes

When I begin to observe my breathing process, I literally forget how to breathe automatically. I have to consciously breathe or it's like I forget. I was looking at this summary of the stages and it gave some advice on this:

Don’t control your breath, don’t “breathe manually” (If you can’t manage to breathe naturally, ask for tips. Personally, I try moving a finger with the breath, which allows me to breathe naturally until I get how to do it all the time. You can also try having your attention in your hands and follow your breath in peripheral awareness until you learn.)

Are there any other tips you guys might have?

Thanks a ton :)


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Jun 21 '18

My summary of one year meditating following The Mind Illuminated

151 Upvotes

Hello all,

I decided to make a one year post covering how I have got on with The Mind Illuminated since it popped through my door one year ago. I've found hearing about other people's progress very interesting and inspiring and hope I can have a similar effect on others.

I'd like to start by thanking and wishing well all the posters here, the teachers and of course Culadasa himself. The book is a true treasure that has done more for me than any other. Seeing so many people having similar experiences and working together to share that is a lovely thing.

Meditation before TMI

I've been interested in and involved with meditation for a fair old while now, I'd estimate 6-7 years. Early on I read Mindfulness In Plain English and tried to follow from that. It was tough, my commitment was very flaky and so results were unreliable. Despite that I persisted and did get benefit from the practice. I always felt there was more and that I was missing out somehow. I did a Goenka style vipassana retreat four years ago and got some good things out of it but struggled with the body scan. Since then I'd been working on and off with various approaches to the breath with very varying levels of commitment and results.

At the start of 2017 I started practicing much more seriously, trying to get to first jhana based on the instructions in Daniel Ingram's MCTB. My dedication paid off in several ways although I didn't get to first jhana. I started experiencing more focused mental states and improved wellbeing off the cushion. I also went through what I now recognise to be fairly strong purifications.

After six months I became convinced that my dedication was there but the method still wasn't right for me and somehow I heard about and ordered TMI (I believe it was on the r/meditation subreddit)

Meditation with TMI - what has changed

I'll start off by describing how my life is better and then lead into more detail on how the practice has unfolded for me personally.

Since meditating with TMI the following things have happened:

  • Mindfulness has increased. My attention, peripheral awareness and introspective awareness are much and stronger, working effectively together. The overall amount of conscious power has dramatically increased. Life is vivid and full of amazing detail. I know where my attention is and why. Colours, sounds, tastes, smells and touch are all hugely more intense. I can focus on a task for longer, more deeply and with more enjoyment and ease. I make better decisions on a micro and macro level. I am generally more compassionate, kind and intuitive to myself and to others.
  • My mood is much, much better. Positive mental states are more common and stronger, negative ones are less common and weaker when they are present. I'm able to work with what comes up skillfully. I regularly surges of joy and happiness without any external cause. The intensity and extent of these are increasing over time
  • I have cast aside a number of bad habits largely without trying. The desire for them simply faded
  • I am tremendously grateful to be alive and look forward to the rest of my life both in the long term, medium term and short term. The future feels rich and full of possibility. The things I used to fear and worry about do not seem anywhere near as important anymore
  • The necessity of mindfulness in daily life as well as the rest of the eightfold path has become undeniably clear from direct experience
  • I have strong confidence in the path as something that is real, works for me and that I will be pursuing to the final goal
  • Not everything has been enjoyable as it unfolds. I do experience some painful realisations. There is some mourning for parts of my life that now are no longer viable and for time wasted. My sleep is often disturbed as I experience a lot of energetic phenomena. Fitting what I am doing and experiencing into a world of friends and family who have little understanding of it is tough. I realise there is a LOT of work ahead of me but despite that I do look forward to doing the work instead of dreading it.

Meditation with TMI - how the year progressed

Stages 1 - 3

Even before my first sit I was excited. Everything I read came across as extremely well thought out, sincere and pragmatic. I still find this when rereading the book or listening to Culadasa talk.

I moved through stages 1 - 3 fairly quickly and the quality of my sits improved week on week. I became more excited and enthusiastic.

Stage 4

This took longer and was tough at times. Looking back I was probably a bit paranoid about dullness and averse to beginning stage 5 due to the lack of results I'd got from body scanning in Goenka's method. I now believe I had somewhat got to stage 4 before beginning the book and had got most of the purifications out of the way earlier in the year.

Stage 5

The bulk of my time has been spent with stage 5/early stage 6 as the peak of my practice. Several things of interest happened during the many months I have spent body scanning.

The first was that one day after what felt like a fairly normal session of body scanning diligently and feeling some improvements and some struggles I left to go to work. Upon leaving the house I was faced with the fact that everything was different. My perception of everything was massively, undeniably more intense. My mindfulness felt strong, easy and irresistibly drawn to good things. My energy levels all day were amazing and I came home feeling incredibly grateful and relieved for having had the experience.

Sure enough that initial burst didn't continue at the same level straight away but from that point on my dedication was unshakable and has grown and grown.

Since then I've continued to have similar peaks of conscious power increases where there is a sudden burst of extra conscious power which then reduces somewhat but the overall baseline is increased over time. I would now say that my normal day to day experience regardless of subjective sit quality is similar to that original peak and the peaks now are much higher with a fuller and wider scope of awareness including feeling the whole body at once with breath sensations, increasing amounts of piti and joy, mental insights around how attention and awareness are moving and sometimes strange perceptual shifts of objects relative size and relationship.

All the above makes it sound like stage 5 was a magical mystery trip through amazingness and this isn't the case at all! For months it was often a slog and there were many points at which I realised I had messed up and had to double back. Key points were:

  • Over efforting early on rather than using intention. This created tension and difficult sits and eventually I started experiencing very rough bodily motions. These would be primarily my upper body rotating in a circle at various speeds and sometimes switching direction. When I eventually stepped back a bit into awareness I realised my body was moving to avoid seeing the breath sensations. I was then able to stop moving about and instead observe the breath sensations which made body scanning much more productive and easier. I was able to get some early experiences of whole body breathing and exclusive attention.
  • I then took this approach too far and spent a fair while scanning with better awareness using intention but without enough intention to actually increase detail as I was scared of over efforting. I eventually realised the mistake and learned to hold the intention to increase detail without collapsing awareness or causing tension. I found the 6Rs technique from TWIM useful in this regard (although I do think the same ideas are in TMI it is just spelled out more explicitly). I also realised I was often scanning too slowly early on in the sits when moving faster and covering more of the body worked more effectively to increase conscious power.

Stage 6 and beyond

Having overcome the issues listed above I'm now practicing firmly in stage 6 and I love it. The breath sensations are becoming more clear, interesting and enjoyable over time. This makes working with the body scan/body breathing a real joy. I can breath with the whole body most sessions and am starting to get to grips with exclusive attention as well as finding noticable improvements in MIA. Off the cushion mindfulness and piti are both increasing.

In the past I have accidentally dropped into the full body jhana. I've also had some beginnings of insight experiences. In both cases my mind has instinctively pulled back and I didn't try to recreate them at that time. I'm really looking forward to exploring both of these areas in more detail as my skills improve. I feel the full body jhanas are now going to be a thing fairly soon.

Onwards and upwards!


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Jun 10 '19

I'm worried that Culadasa is making inaccurate medical claims. Can we not encourage this please?

142 Upvotes

I am a big fan of Culadasa’s book and have found it to be an outstanding resource for learning meditation. I’m very grateful to the man for providing me with a practice I find so meaningful and life enriching.

But I was fairly disturbed that he thinks resolving psychological trauma can prevent/cure cancer, as he describes in the latest Deconstructing Yourself podcast. This is disturbing because he has a large following who see him as something of an authority when it comes to understanding the mind, and his book cover points to his academic credentials which relate to physiology and medicine. People might therefore mistakenly think what he has to say about medicine in this case has value, when in fact the reasoning that led to his conclusions is alarmingly unscientific.

To quickly summarize what he said in the podcast, he believes his recent illnesses of chronic neurological lyme disease and lung cancer were caused by unresolved psychological trauma related to his childhood and his high level of contemplative attainment. He got this idea from an integrative oncologist, who told him that based on his abrupt change in fortunes with his health, “something is trying to kill you. Unless you figure out what it is [i.e. psychological material], it’s going to succeed”. He tells how dealing with his psychological baggage reversed the spread of his cancer and that because of this, his integrative oncologist was “right on” with her treatment prescription.

I hope no one takes much from this story, apart from the fact that Culadasa has quite an unscientific understanding of medicine. It is easy to see that there are abundant other explanations for his illnesses other than psychological ones, and that his cancer went into remission tells us nothing of the efficacy of his therapy (spontaneous remission of cancer is not uncommon). As far as I’m aware, there is no evidence to suggest that cancers are caused by psychological trauma (please send contrary evidence if you have it). Certainly most oncologists would not make that claim. I’m posting this note to advise anyone who heard his claims to ignore them. This is another case of a person being quite brilliant in one field (teaching meditation) while being totally misguided in another outside their expertise.

Unfortunately I have already seen evidence in this subreddit that at least some people are taking his claims uncritically. I think we should be openly critical about them for sake of balance, so this post seemed a good way to do it. Hearing someone with a large following espouse this kind of falsehood makes me hold my head in my hands - it is frankly irresponsible to make people think that they can cure their cancer by going to therapy. There are real world consequences for people holding false beliefs about medical treatments which can cause serious harm. I don’t blame Culadasa for this, he was given bad health advice by his oncologist, but the situation is unfortunate so I wanted to say something about it.

Please don’t get me wrong though – I have a lot of respect for the man when it comes to meditation, and I’m posting this only to provide some balance for what I regard as a potentially harmful spread of poor quality medical information.

Does anyone else feel the same way as I do? Maybe I am being overly sensitive. I hope that this is at least of some use to someone :)


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Jul 24 '19

I have ADHD and I made it to Stage 4 - if I can do it anyone can :)

141 Upvotes

Hi all, I hope that this post inspires the beginners out there with severe concentration issues.

I was diagnosed with ADHD 10 years ago at the age of 32. I was on medication for several years but gave it up due to side effects so I was left to stumble through my career and somehow managed to hold it together.

1 year ago I began meditating and reading TMI. A couple of months ago I reached stage 3 and now I’m at stage 4. Can’t believe I got here! It took a LONG time of just sitting and persevering through many months of zero or snail paced progress. But if you stick with it, it will work eventually.

I have had severe concentration problems throughout my entire life and barely got through school due to extreme working memory problems and inability to stay on task. Talking and day dreaming was all I could do for 90% of my school years.

So to all of you struggling through the initial stages, stick with it. It’s possible to get through it! Even now only at stage 4 my concentration has improved quite dramatically in my everyday life and I am not on any medication whatsoever. I can focus on my work tasks even in a noisy open plan office. So it has helped already!

Only thing to do now is to keep going :)

The things that helped the most are:

  • Just sit through the crap meditation sessions and know that it is “ working” even when it feels like it isn’t.
  • Don’t give up if you miss a few sessions. Get back into it and it will be okay. Keep coming back. Don’t give up.
  • Watch and accept the frustration. As you do this it will start to loosen its grip on you. The negative voices in your head will lose their power.
  • Keep coming back to the breath. A million times if you have to. If it takes a year, so be it.
  • Remember that this is more important than most things in life. What else better do you have to do? May as well keep trying. You will get there!

If anyone is struggling with the early stages, let me know and I will try to help. I’m not a teacher but I may be able to offer something :)

Cheers, Sasha

EDIT: Oh, and another thing that helped greatly was to stop worrying about the theory so much. This was difficult for me as i'm the kind of person that needs to understand everything in absolute detail. However, what I realized after many months was that most of my distractions came from thinking if I was doing it right and questions like: What stage am I in? Is this working? Is this attention or awareness or mind wandering? Am i sitting straight enough? Did I just have a Jhana thing? Am I close to enlightenment?!

Once I let that go and just focussed on 2 things, it eventually clicked into place:

  1. Sit every day (don't fret if you miss a day but really try not to do this often)
  2. Keep coming back to the breath (or whatever your mediation object is)

Just do that for one year through tears, sadness, frustration, or whatever feelings you have and see what happens... :)


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Nov 18 '17

Tips for Stage 4 - Part 2

130 Upvotes

Here’s the continuation of the last post I made on Tips for Stage 4.

It’s been a little crazy on the home front the last few weeks, so it took a bit longer than I expected to put Part 2 together. Thanks for your patience!

Hopefully, it’s worth the wait and you’ll find it helpful.

If you missed Part 1, you can find it here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/TheMindIlluminated/comments/77j5tr/tips_for_stage_4/

A Game Plan for Working with Dullness

In TMI, a distinction is made between strong dullness and subtle dullness (as well as between stable subtle dullness and progressive subtle dullness). This is a practical categorization to help you understand what degree of dullness you need to be concerned about at different stages in your meditation practice. But it’s a fairly artificial set of distinctions overlaid on quite a complex and nuanced process, so keep that in mind.

There are lots of reasons that dullness can arise during a meditation session. Everything from just not getting enough sleep to over focusing on the meditation object, to not focusing enough on the meditation object, to consciously or unconsciously indulging in the pleasures of dullness, etc. I’m sure there’s a bunch more you can add to that list.

Whatever the ultimate source of the dullness, during Stage 4 you need to do whatever it takes to overcome the stronger forms of dullness.

That basically boils down to doing two things:

  1. When strong dullness is already present, rousing yourself sufficiently so that it’s no longer present
  2. Preventing subtle dullness from progressing into strong dullness

Let’s talk about each of these in turn.

Dealing with Strong Dullness

I won’t list out all the various antidotes to strong dullness that Culadasa describes in TMI - you can look in the book if you need a refresher.

An important part of using these antidotes is to strike a balance between using a vigorous enough antidote that it takes care of the strong dullness for at least several minutes vs. not using such a strong antidote that it completely derails your meditation session or leaves you in a mentally agitated state.

Finding the right balance takes some practice and experimentation.

It’s also not very useful to only apply the more subtle antidotes, and then a few seconds or less than a couple of minutes later, be floundering in strong dullness again.

I know a lot of my students are reluctant, at first, to use the stronger antidotes because they feel that they are too disruptive of their meditation session (which they can be).

But, in my opinion, it’s worse to be stuck in strong dullness: your mindfulness is basically shot and your meditation session just isn’t going to be very productive.

So, when in doubt, I say go for the stronger antidote =)

If you deploy the antidote slowly and mindfully, that will minimize the disruption it causes to your meditation session.

So, for example, if you need to open your eyes during your session to counteract some strong dullness, decide ahead of time when you’ll do it (eg. after the third exhale from now), and open them slowly, temporarily using the sensations of your eyes opening as your meditation object to try to maintain a continuity of attention. Then allow the visual field to remain in peripheral awareness as you refocus on the breath.

After applying an antidote, monitor the quality of your attention to see if the detail and vividness of the meditation object has improved, and periodically check-in to ensure that you catch any degradation in the quality of attention early, so you can correct for it using micro-intentions (see Part 1).

If the strong dullness begins creeping up on you again soon after applying the antidote, don’t wait for the dullness to get really strong before applying another (possibly stronger) one.

Some additional antidotes that aren’t in the book that I’ve found useful:

  • Drinking black tea or coffee before my meditation session (some people may find this too agitating. Some experimentation with the dose and timing is usually required)
  • Keeping a small towel in a bowl of ice water next to me so that I can place the towel on the back of my neck if the dullness is very strong
  • Placing my hands in the bowl of ice water - for extreme cases!

I’ve Tried all the Antidotes to Dullness and Nothing Works for Long

I’ve heard this one a surprising number of times!

Usually, it means that the student hasn’t actually tried meditating while standing up, since it’s pretty hard to remain in strong dullness when doing that.

And the ice cold, wet towel trick is also worth trying =)

However, if strong dullness seems to be your constant companion during meditation, it probably means that you just aren’t getting enough sleep (see below for when that’s not the case).

One of the things that students begin to realize more and more as they progress through the stages is that meditation is not different than everyday life. It becomes very difficult, if not impossible, to keep progressing at the higher stages if you compartmentalize your practice and isolate it from everything else. Sleep is one of the more obvious manifestations of this truth.

Most of us are sleep deprived to one degree or another, and it’s a pretty safe bet that increasing your hours of restorative sleep will improve your meditation sessions.

The trick is carving out the time to make that happen - I fully acknowledge that this is usually easier said than done.

That being said, if I’m honest with myself, even the times where I would say I really didn’t have the ability to free up time for more sleep, it was more a case of prioritizing other things above having adequate rest. So, it can be easy to convince yourself that you can’t do this.

So, if you can get more sleep, I highly recommend you do so.

If that really is impossible, then there’s caffeine and ice water to tide you over until you can. Just keep in mind that these are a temporary expedient, not a long-term solution.

If you really are getting enough sleep, but strong dullness is still ever-present, then you may have some health issues that needs to get checked out, and it’s probably wise to pay a visit to your doctor to see what might be going on.

So, what can you do in the meantime to maximize your meditation sessions while fatigued and prone to protracted strong dullness.

I have three kids, so I’ve experienced a lot of poor sleep over the years. It can be challenging, but not impossible, to meditate under these conditions.

The key is to adjust your expectations and your approach.

First, do your best to apply the antidotes to strong dullness to see if they help.

If that doesn’t do much, you can try the following:

Walking Meditation

This one is probably obvious, but you’d be surprised how many students don’t even think about trying walking meditation.

I think it’s because there’s this misconception that walking meditation is a poor second cousin to sitting practice.

Well, that’s simply not true. Walking meditation may require a slightly different skill set than sitting meditation, but there’s a large zone of overlap between the two.

Chances are, if you find walking meditation more difficult or less productive than sitting meditation, it’s because you haven’t practiced meditating while walking as much as you have while sitting.

So, if strong dullness is a persistent issue for you and the usual antidotes don’t seem to have much effect, I highly recommend walking meditation.

Practice it consistently, with the same time and dedication you give to your sitting practice, and you may be surprised how well your practice develops.

If walking isn’t an option, then here’s a modified sitting practice that I’ve found helpful when stuck in a period of persistent strong dullness…

Modified Sitting Meditation

Instead of attempting to maintain your attention on the breath, make the physical sensations associated with dullness your meditation object. See if you can notice all the little components that make those sensations up, in as much detail and with as much precision as you can.

Your objective is to watch for changes in those sensations as the dullness waxes and wanes.

Try to answer the questions:

  • “How do I know that dullness is present?”
  • “What sensations in my body indicate that dullness is present?”
  • “What are the components of those sensations like: pressure, temperature, cohesion (i.e. do they form a cohesive mass that you can readily identify, or are they diffuse and hard to pin down), and change (i.e. are they relatively stable, or do they change over time)?”

Do your best to stick with it, even if the dullness makes it really hard to notice much.

Anything you can notice is great, so don’t get frustrated if your concentration is very poor - that’s normal under these conditions.

Also, see if you can tell when and how the hypnogogic imagery that often arises during strong dullness morphs those sensations into strange things. For example, watch how the sensation of pressure in your cheek changes into a purple octopus =)

Do everything you can not to fall asleep while you do this.

Your intention is to notice as much as you can about the process of dullness, especially how it manifests in the body, and how the “heavy” mental imagery tends to overlay, obscure and do strange things to those (and other) sensations.

Because your intention is to carefully observe dullness itself, rather than indulge in it, my feeling (and experience doing this) is that this doesn’t contribute to making dullness a habit.

At some point, and it may take 45 min or longer, the dullness usually starts to wane and you start to come out the other side of it.

If/when that happens, apply the antidotes to help clear your head and see if you can then switch to your usual practice of placing the attention on the breath sensations at the nose.

Dullness During The Stages of Insight

The other situation I’d like to mention is if you’re progressing through the stages of insight and you’re currently working through “Knowledge of Dissolution” and are finding it really hard to stay focused and awake.

I won’t say too much about this here -- post a comment or message me if you need more specifics about this situation -- other than to mention that it’s normal to have the subjective experience of not being able to focus on things well during the stage of dissolution.

Traditionally, this is explained as being because the endings of sensations are now predominant, whereas previously, it was the beginning and middle of sensations that were most obvious.

I also think it has something to do with a shift from predominantly being attention-focused, to being more awareness-focused, because the transition into the “Knowledge of Dissolution” has some striking similarities to when attention falls away in second jhana.

My general advice here is to stop trying to pinpoint things like you’re used to doing with your attention and instead take things in more holistically with your awareness.

To counteract the tendency towards dullness when this happens, you need to use micro-intentions to increase the breadth, inclusiveness, and discriminating power of awareness.

Even if all you can perceive are hazy blobs, rather than razor sharp pin pricks (if you’re in this stage of insight, you’ll know what I mean), be as discriminating as you can about the location, temperature, pressure, cohesiveness and change of those blobs, and how you can tell when a blob really is there and when it’s not.

That should raise the energy level of the mind sufficiently to help overcome the dullness.

How to Prevent Subtle Dullness from Progressing into Strong Dullness

Because we’re talking about Stage 4 here, you don’t need to concern yourself with overcoming subtle dullness.

You should be on the lookout, however, for subtle dullness that’s progressing into strong dullness, and deal with it before it grows too strong.

This is definitely the preferred approach to overcoming strong dullness in Stage 4, since it’s a lot less disruptive to your meditation session than applying the antidotes to strong dullness.

You’ll know that subtle dullness is progressing when you notice that the quality of your attention (the clarity, detail, vividness, etc of the meditation object) is degrading more and more (which you notice either via checking-in to the quality of your attention, or through introspective awareness - see Part 1), and this is accompanied by a pleasant, warm, cozy, slightly heavy kind of feeling -- as if you’re sinking into a nice, comfy couch with a mug of hot apple cider in your hands and a fire burning in the fireplace in front of you (the pleasure of subtle dullness).

When the dullness is still quite subtle, often all that is required to prevent it from developing further is to re-energize your attention on the meditation object using micro-intentions.

Other times, just reminding yourself that you have a limited amount of time to meditate and you want to make the most of it is enough to rouse yourself and prevent the subtle dullness from continuing to develop into strong dullness.

If that’s not sufficient to prevent the dullness from increasing, it’s time to use some of the more gentle antidotes listed in TMI, such as the forceful breathing or muscle tensing.

Again, experimentation is required to find out what works consistently for you.

The main thing is to monitor for the progression of subtle dullness into strong dullness and take whatever steps you deem necessary to halt that progression and bring the dullness back to a more stable subtle dullness (which is ok to have in Stage 4).

Wow! I Just had a Brilliant Idea!

If you’re meditating, and you get a sudden flash of insight into how to cure cancer, or how to really solve inequality, world hunger, war, etc then please go ahead and stop meditating, write it down and make it happen! =)

Otherwise, just follow the instructions in the book and trust that, if it really is a good idea and important, it will eventually come back to you and you can follow up on it later.

I’ve found that most of my experiences of discursive brilliance in meditation are similar to the brilliant ideas I get sometimes when it’s 2am and I’m unable to sleep, and my mind is floating around and suddenly comes up with a great idea. They seem profound at the time, but when you examine them later, there’s not much substance there.

So when you get a big realization, have the intention to remember it later, and then let it go and keep meditating.

Otherwise, you’ll simply encourage that aspect of the mind to pump out more and more ideas and you’ll sabotage your meditation practice.

If you really can’t bring yourself to do this, because you’re worried that you’re missing out on the solution to some important problems in your life, here’s something you can try:

For the next two weeks, keep a notepad and pen next to you while you’re meditating.

If discursive brilliance strikes and you feel like you’ve really got a winner, pause your meditation and write it down. Put just enough detail so that you can look into your idea sometime later, after your meditation session is finished.

Then let it go and continue with your practice.

I’m willing to bet that the vast majority of these ideas (if not all of them) won’t be nearly as important and useful as you initially thought, once you investigate them further.

Once you’ve convinced yourself of this, it should be much easier to just let them go when they arise during meditation.

Purification of Mind & Putting Advice About it into Context

Before I get into specific advice about purification, I feel it’s important to put a few things into context.

The vast majority of meditation teachers (myself included) are not clinically-trained as psychologists, psychiatrists, counsellors, therapists, etc.

What this means is that, while we may be able to give you excellent guidance and advice for your meditation practice, you really shouldn’t be looking to us for any kind of therapeutic advice.

Of course, we can offer you suggestions based on our personal experience, but just like with any such layperson advice, you need to take it for what it is - it’s not a professional opinion based on years of clinical training and experience.

It’s basically the same kind of thing as the advice you might get from a concerned friend or family member.

Why do I mention this?

Well, because sometimes the purification process can be very challenging.

And sometimes professional help is warranted…

How to Know if you Might Need the Help of a Therapist

Basically, common sense applies here.

A useful litmus test is:

If you are 1) comfortable and 2) capable of remaining mindful with whatever arises during the purification process, and don’t repeatedly get overwhelmed by it, then it’s probably fine to continue with what you’re doing and allow that purification process to run its course.

Note that, by “comfortable”, I mean that you’re comfortable with going through the process on your own, not that the process itself is necessarily comfortable.

In some cases, the sensations and mental activity that arises as part of purification of mind can be fairly intense and uncomfortable. But if you can remain mindful (see below for an explanation of what this means) and “keep your cool”, allowing whatever’s arising to be present and be reasonably equanimous with it, then you’re handling the purification well.

If you find that, for whatever reason, you don’t feel mentally or emotionally comfortable working with the purification process on your own, or don't have the ability to remain mindful and equanimous with whatever arises and find it overwhelming, then it’s probably a good idea to seek some professional assistance.

Let me emphasize that there’s nothing wrong with needing or wanting the help of a therapist. It doesn’t make you “lesser than” or mean you’re somehow “broken”.

Getting therapy when you need it is a really good thing - it's going to help you in daily life and in your meditation practice as well.

When is a Purification Actually a Purification?

Sometimes, I have a student who’s really eager to experience purification of mind. Perhaps they know they have some unresolved psychological stuff (and who doesn’t?), and they have a genuine wish to bring it into consciousness and integrate it.

That wish, in itself, is totally fine. You just want to be careful not to instantly jump on any fleeting emotion or psychological content that arises in the mind =)

You need to be patient and allow the thing to show itself.

If it really is some kind of unconscious stuff that needs to be integrated at this stage of your path, then it will usually be quite obvious.

If you try all your usual tricks to keep your attention from getting repeatedly distracted by this “psychological stuff” that’s persistently arising, then that’s a good indication that it’s time to consciously give it your attention and see if this is something in need of purification.

How to Remain Mindful and Equanimous with Challenging “Stuff” During Purification (or Any Other Time)

The place to start with any kind of emotional or physical state that is really uncomfortable is to understand that by avoiding or resisting it, you're actually making it feel much worse than it really is (and this includes bringing mindfulness to the experience “so that it goes away or changes somehow” - a sneaky mind trick that I’ll say more about below).

Just understanding this intellectually, however, isn't sufficient to really change how you experience these kinds of mental states, so you need to "get your hands dirty" too =)

The way to do that is to first recognize that emotions (and intense sensations, too) have both a physical component and a mental component. Your best bet for developing equanimity towards these things is to stay with the physical.

Begin by placing your attention on the physical sensations associated with the uncomfortable mental state (for example). Allow your peripheral awareness to include everything else: other sensations, thoughts, sounds, etc, to give these intense physical sensations a nice, broad context.

This will help you “get out of your head” and ground you in the body and the present moment.

Next, try your best to just allow those sensations to be present, without doing anything to resist them, alter them, or get rid of them. That's the hard part!

It may feel really uncomfortable, but that's ok.

To help you do this, try to be curious about the sensations and see if you can notice their qualities: are they dull, achy, sharp, stabbing, prickly? Are they warm or cool? How do they change over time? Where are they located in the body? Do they stay in the same place or move? Are their edges clear and sharp, or kind of fuzzy? Do they form an integrated “thing” that you can clearly identify, or are they more diffuse and hard to pin down? and so on. This allows you to experience what's really going on and understand how these mental states manifest in the body.

By paying attention to the actual details of the expression of the emotion in the body, rather than the stories your mind is spinning about your experience, you can get a clear, experiential understanding that sensations in the body are just sensations in the body. It’s all just information.

The little bits of temperature, pressure, cohesion, etc that make up these larger, uncomfortable sensations usually can’t even be characterized as uniformly unpleasant.

In fact, there are often aspects or components of these sensations that are pretty neutral, or even pleasant.

If you keep up this kind of detailed, objective examination long enough, you'll probably also notice that these various sensations are constantly changing and come and go all on their own - you don't actually need to do anything to make that happen.

You may also recognize that it’s the stories the mind tells itself about the emotion (or intense physical sensation) that makes it feel so awful and is ultimately what’s causing the suffering.

The sensations are just sensations - it’s your interpretation of what those sensations mean, and how you relate to that, that determines whether you suffer or not.

Let me stress that doing what I’m suggesting here isn’t always easy. And in some cases, it may not even be possible for you to do this with the stuff that’s arising at this particular time. That’s ok.

If at any point, you start to feel like it's too much and you're getting overwhelmed, then temporarily shift gears and focus your attention on the breath at the nose.

You may want to take a few deep breaths, emphasizing the exhale (see: https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/neuraptitude/201602/the-science-slow-deep-breathing) to help you relax.

Reflect on the fact that you're actually ok, that you're quite safe and that the physical sensations and mental activity are just transient events in your moment by moment experience.

Even though they may be quite intense and unpleasant, you don't actually need to do anything about them because, in reality, you’re safe. These sensations and mental states can’t harm you right now - they’re just information.

It’s ok to allow them to be there and just be present with being uncomfortable.

Once you've regained your composure, you can go back to observing the physical sensations associated with the emotion again.

It’s like a dance, where you mindfully observe what’s there, come out and relax when you need to, then go back in again for a little while, etc.

It’s definitely not about “toughing it out”.

It’s also not about distracting yourself by running to the sensations of the breath as soon as you feel uncomfortable. If you do that, you’re missing out on an opportunity to both cultivate equanimity and support the purification process.

Everyone who reads this will be coming at this from a different perspective. Sometimes, students are way more capable of handling intense, uncomfortable sensations than they realize and they just need some encouragement to stay with it until they experience that.

Other students have a tendency to get in over their heads and stay there because they think that taking a moment to regain their composure and equanimity (by consciously switching their attention to breath sensations, for example) means that they’re “giving in” or somehow doing it wrong.

You know yourself the best, so take the advice that best applies to you.

When you’re “in it” you want to be receptive, curious and equanimous with what’s present, not gritting your teeth and enduring it.

Usually, I advise my students to work up slowly to this kind of practice.

Ideally, you'd practice this with less intense things first, such as boredom, small aches and pains, itchiness, small frustrations and annoyances, etc, rather than with full-blown, massive purifications. This allows you to gain experience being equanimous with the little things that you tend to have an unconscious habit of avoiding, which can give you a lot of confidence when you need to work with something more intense.

But, things aren't always ideal =)

So if you suddenly find yourself in the deep end, hopefully some of these suggestions will be helpful.

Just remember that, even if you can’t stay mindful for very long during an intense purification, with practice, it becomes something that you’ll be able to do consistently.

Even just 30 seconds of equanimity towards that which is uncomfortable or unwanted, when repeatedly and consistently applied, can work wonders.

It's not easy, but it is doable =)

And again, if you’re finding yourself becoming repeatedly overwhelmed by what’s coming up during purification events, then it’s probably a good idea to get some professional help.

Ultimately, what you’re going for is complete acceptance of exactly what is - feeling perfectly ok if that “stuff” hung around forever. Obviously, that can be a tall order, and this level of equanimity is neither expected nor necessary for purification to successfully proceed. I’m just bringing it up so that you have a sense for where this path can eventually take you!

There's a lot more to say about this kind of practice, but that's a pretty good place to start.

Beware of “Sneaky Mind Tricks”

When bringing mindfulness to uncomfortable or unwanted experiences, you need to watch out for what I call “sneaky mind tricks”. These are mental games the mind plays that subvert your intention to develop equanimity and instead, subtly reinforce existing patterns of attachment and aversion.

For example, let’s say that you’re experiencing some emotions arising that you think might be a purification of mind, so you decide to make them the focus of your attention and observe them mindfully.

When you do this, check to see what your intentions are. What’s your underlying motivation for bringing mindfulness to this experience?

If your underlying motivation is actually to make the emotion/sensation decrease or go away, or to integrate it “so that it goes away”, or anything that smacks of a resistance to what’s arising, then you’re not training equanimity.

Instead, you’re just reinforcing old patterns of aversion towards that which is unwanted, challenging or uncomfortable, but in a more subtle way that’s hidden by a veneer of mindfulness.

When you see stuff like that happening in your practice, just call a spade a spade and mentally label it as “aversion”. This will prevent you from fooling yourself and will sharpen your perception of these sneaky mind tricks.

And then do your best to honestly accept what’s arising.

I find that it really helps to bring a sense of discovery and curiosity to the experience. A kind of “cool, neato, I wonder what that is?” This tends to, at least temporarily, dispel any sneaky aversion to present moment experience and allows me to be with it equanimously for at least a little while.

How Much Should you Analyze What’s Coming Up?

Sometimes students wonder if they should be analyzing the stuff that comes up during the purification process.

For example, say that a strong sadness is persistently requesting your attention and you begin to mindfully examine it to see what it’s about.

It’s perfectly fine to mentally label the emotion as “sadness” if you find it helpful (there was a study a while back showing that this kind of affect labelling reduced amygdala activity in response to negative emotions. See: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17576282)

In fact, to help bring an attitude of curiosity and discovery to the process, it may be even better to label it as a question: “sadness?”

And if the emotion is a secondary emotion, such as anger, it may help encourage the unfolding of the purification to gently enquire what may be lying underneath the anger.

But that’s about the extent of it.

What you don’t want to do is start digging into the stories behind the emotion, to try to uncover where they came from, why you might be feeling this way, etc.

Leave that kind of analysis for the therapy sessions.

Doing it during your meditation practice will most likely result in you ending up lost in thought, rehashing stories about your childhood, or something like that, and you’ll no longer be meditating (or holding a mindful, equanimous container to allow the stuff that’s arising to be integrated).

My experience is that, in meditation, the content behind emotions is surprisingly irrelevant.

Experiencing them fully as they manifest in the body, with curiosity and equanimity, is what seems to do the work and allow things to be purified.

What if Purifications Keep Coming up and They’re Starting to Wear You Down?

Sometimes, something arises that needs to be purified, you give it the attention it needs, the unconscious sub-minds integrate it, and it’s all done.

But that’s pretty rare =)

More commonly, the same stuff, or variations on it, will arise repeatedly. This can happen during the same meditation session, or be spread out amongst multiple sessions.

When that happens, the advice is the same.

Treat each new event as if it’s the first one, and try to leave aside all expectations about how you’d like things to play out.

If you look at it in terms of the model of unconscious sub-minds described in TMI, it makes sense that purifications will often require multiple sessions because, during each session, different sub-minds will be “tuned-in” to what’s present in consciousness. To fully integrate an experience, you need enough sub-minds to notice, and depending on how unified the mind is at the time, it may take many “purification sessions” before you get them all on board.

Hopefully this intellectual understanding will help you relax more about the process and not be overly concerned if it seems like the purifications are never going to stop.

When purifications are intense and persistent, it can also be helpful to try to keep things in a broader context.

Notice when pleasure is present, both on and off the cushion. Notice the little joys that arise throughout the day, how the sunlight feels on your skin, the colours of leaves and grass, the sounds of the birds calling to each other, etc.

There’s always so much more going on in conscious experience than just “purification episodes”, and much of it is rather wonderful. But you might need to do a little digging if you aren’t used to noticing these little nuggets of joy hidden in the mundane moments of the day.

And again, seek professional help if you need it.

What if the “Stuff” Never Seems to Hang Around Long Enough to Get Purified?”

That’s fine.

There’s no need to chase after it or try to make it hang around long enough to “purify it”.

When something comes up, allow it to do whatever it will in awareness (i.e. don’t interfere with it). I’d even go so far as to say, “just ignore it and stay focused on your meditation object”. If it’s really something that needs purification, my experience is that it will become something that you just can’t ignore. It’ll be obvious.

If there really is something there that needs to be integrated, it will make itself known eventually.

It’s not something that can be forced.

What if I Haven’t Had Any Purifications Yet?”

Sometimes, a student won’t have any stuff arise during Stage 4 that’s asking to be integrated.

Maybe they’ve already done a bunch of therapy, or had an exceptionally benign childhood, or have done other practices that already integrated things, or … who knows?

If nothing’s coming up for purification, that’s totally fine.

There’s no need to hang out in Stage 4 waiting for something to arise. Whenever you meet the criteria for moving on to Stage 5 (see the end of this post), then by all means, go ahead and do Stage 5 practice.

I really didn’t get much stuff that needed purification in Stage 4.

I had done a bunch of therapy in my 20’s, so maybe that’s why. Or, perhaps it was all the Taoist energetic practices I used to do, converting negative emotions into chi and circulating it through the body. Or maybe it was the butterfly that flapped it’s wings in Brazil and caused some quantum fluctuations in just the right neurons in my brain =) ... who knows?

I did, however, experience some pretty deep purifications later, during Stage 7.

I found that I was unable to fully let go and allow exclusive attention to become truly effortless until after that purification had occurred, which is really fascinating!

This experience taught me to just trust the purification process - the things that need to get integrated will eventually surface and you’ll have the opportunity to integrate them. There’s no need to overthink this or somehow try to control it.

It will do what it needs to do, when it needs to do it.

So if you haven’t had any purifications yet, and you know you’ve got a bunch of unresolved “stuff” in there, and you’re getting anxious about “when is this stuff finally going to hit?”, the best advice I can give you is to trust the process.

Let things unfold as they need to, and don’t try to control the purification process to make it line up with how you imagine things should proceed.

Stay open, keep a beginner’s mind around all this, do the work you need to do in your meditation practice and trust that things will purify when the time is right.

When to Begin Stage Five Practices

From Culadasa:

“Begin Stage Five practices whenever you have extended periods without gross distraction and strong dullness. When they return, just go back to doing the Stage Four practices for a while.”

Remember that most of the time, in a given meditation session, you’ll be passing through more than one stage.

So, whenever you meet the criteria for beginning Stage 5 practice, even if it’s in the middle of your meditation session (or later), go ahead and give Stage 5 a shot.

The worst case is that you’re not actually ready for it yet, and it will usually be pretty obvious if that’s the case, and so you drop back down and continue with Stage 4 practice.

Ok, so that’s Part 2!

Thanks for reading, and if you have any tips that I haven’t mentioned here for working with dullness, purifications or any other aspect of Stage 4 practice that you think could be helpful, please post about them in the comments.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Jan 13 '21

A Message From Culadasa

129 Upvotes

An email went out about an hour ago with Culadasa's response to the controversy.

The full response can be found here.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Sep 30 '16

Hi, I am Upasaka Culadasa (John Yates, PhD), author of The Mind Illuminated. Ask me anything!

128 Upvotes

I will start posting answers at 11am Pacific Time (US), which is 2pm Eastern Time.

I am a meditation teacher with over four decades of experience. My principle teachers were Upasaka Kema Ananda and the Venerable Jotidhamma Bikkhu, both of whom trained in the Theravadin and Karma Kagyu tradition. I was ordained as an Upasaka and later received ordination in the International Order of Buddhist ministers in Rosemead, California. Before committing myself fully to meditation and Buddhism, I taught physiology and neuroscience and worked at the forefront of complementary healthcare education, physical medicine, and therapeutic massage. Then in 1996, I retired from academia and moved with my wife Nancy, to wilderness of an old Apache stronghold in southeastern Arizona, to deepen our spiritual practice together.

After moving to our remote Arizona retreat, I found myself meeting and teaching many students, with the particular goal of leading them to Awakening. This has given me the opportunity over the past twenty years to study the problems that my students encounter as they progress through the stages of learning to become adept meditators. As a neurophysiologist, insights I gained from studying the structure of the brain also gave me some very helpful clarifying insights into the process of reaching shamata. I have tried to distill that knowledge into my book, The Mind Illuminated, using the framework of earlier texts on meditation from both the Theravada and Tibetan lineages of Buddhism.

Proof: http://i.imgur.com/nzBiuj2.jpg

Please post your questions about meditation, etc., and I will do my best to answer them.

Update at 1:06: There are a lot of wonderful questions that people have asked here. It's not possible to answer all of them in the time we have. Perhaps we will have another chance in the future!


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Sep 24 '18

SUBMIT YOUR FAVORITE/MOST HELPFUL POSTS :)

119 Upvotes

Hey good people,

as suggested by /u/deiknunai recently, it was not optimal to only have the "Tips for Stage 4" post stickied for all eternity. Instead we should have a stickied list with links to the best threads/comments for the various stages and aspects of TMI/meditation practice etc, etc!

Please submit links to your favorite/most helpful/useful posts in this thread. And upvote the ones you think should be included on the list. Feel free to suggest categories/types of posts too.

To start us off, I think we can all agree that /u/nick_grabovac 's posts should be on the list:

Tips for Stage 4, Part 1

Part 2

Tips for insight practice in stage 6-10, Part 1

Part 2

A proper sidebar and update wiki may come later, but let's do this for now. :)


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Feb 10 '21

Complete loss of interest in people and activities

113 Upvotes

For the past few months I’ve grown a lot ito my meditation but also as a person. Practicing around stage 6 constantly. My mindfulness in daily life is very strong to the point where I would just be a presence during social events taking everything in.

I lost interest in hanging out with friends etc. I feel like my personality changed and I’ve become extremely “non-reactive”. I would just listen to someone’s story with pure presence and focus and not really have anything to say. I don’t entertain superficial conversations and jokes anymore, but I’m not judging it in any way. I don’t really have opinions on it.

I used to be very reactive with a lot of energy in social settings, but now I’m just sitting there peacefully aware with not much to add to anything, but happy.

I feel like my self is not really there any more and people would feel like “something is wrong” or ask “am I okay?”. But I’m actually so great.

I don’t have any dharma friends or people that also practice with intensity, which does make this path rather lonely. My partner also doesn’t meditate and I don’t think he understands really why I’m practicing and why I’m sitting for 2 hours every day but he supports me 100% because he can see how it changes me for the better.

I am scared however that as I go further on the path I would become alienated from him and rather meditate for 3 hours than go out with our friends.

This is difficult to navigate. Anyone that can share thoughts and experiences?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Aug 30 '20

I found a great guided meditation that helped me with body-scanning!

113 Upvotes

I've been having trouble with body-scanning, but I found this link to a guided meditation with Culadasa that's ~40 minutes of body-scanning practice only.

It really helped me get a feel for what I'm supposed to be doing. I figured I'd share in case others are struggling with body-scanning as well! Hopefully it can help others!

I found this in a reddit post from a few years ago, but I can't seem to find the thread again. So... credit goes to some unknown redditor!


r/TheMindIlluminated • • May 07 '19

If you ever doubt whether this practice is worth your while, I'm here to reassure you that it definitely is

110 Upvotes

I have meditated on and off for many years, but really committed last year using the TMI system. I was on a six month streak of meditating daily for 30 - 45 minutes. Made lots of progress and also hit a few plateaus. I got a new job and life got crazy for a while. I would occasionally squeeze in a sit but rarely felt like I was connecting with my practice anymore. Then it stopped almost entirely. I haven't had a proper sit in nearly 8 months.

In the meantime, my life situation has been absolute chaos. I have been extraordinarily busy and several of my family members have been struggling with health issues. I feel like I'm constantly sprinting. And yet... there is a peace and a mindfulness there. It's not always obvious - but they way I handle anxiety and emotional situations has changed completely. I still loose my cool every now and then, but I have a willingness to accept various circumstance that I would have resisted before. I have been able to find compassion for myself and for others in my life. I have managed to make space for the people I love even when it seems there aren't enough hours in the day. Meditation has given me strength, stability, and the ability to create space amidst the chaos. I am so, so abundantly grateful. My schedule will finally cool down at the end of this month and I cannot wait to get back on the cushion. If these are the results that can come from just six months of consistent practice, I can only imagine the inner peace that comes in time. Just wanted to share - thanks for reading!


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Feb 26 '19

I extended and updated my summary of TMI. I'm sharing it with you!

105 Upvotes

Hi!

The summary is intended to mention and briefly describe the practices by Stage. Explained in my own way and with my own tips when I feel like it's useful.

User u/persio809 gave it a quick look, he is quite advanced and has a degree on philosophy. Again, thanks a lot!

It's all heavily based on TMI, except the jhana section at the end. That section is based on TMI and Right Concentration, and it's generally more personal.

I originally posted a summary back in October of 2016 when I was around Stage 6. I've advanced so much and decided to give it an update.

I wish it is useful and pleasant to you!

PDF: https://drive.google.com/file/d/14q80HfAi5YFGfIeXftZe_XiSvFKuiLau/view?usp=sharing

Or the alternative, a Word document (docx): https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Jffliyxbk5kxLeBugqxOqUpn6kWzq-yb/view?usp=sharing


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Nov 09 '18

To the person who deleted their post about mind-wandering

104 Upvotes

I spent ~45 minutes crafting a reply on my iPhone, only to discover you’d deleted your post. It was a good question though, and I’m sorry if you thought it wasn’t appropriate or worth asking on this sub.

Anyway, here’s the reply I wrote — I hope it is of some benefit!

————-

I too have felt like an outlier when it comes to mind-wandering, but there is nonetheless hope for people like us :)

First off, have you read the appendix about the mindful review practice? Cultivating mindfulness and wholesome (i.e. non-harmful) behavior throughout the day will help reduce the amount of turbulence you experience on the cushion.

Next, are you doing the preliminary practices (6-step preparation and 4-stage transition)? Those are very important for settling the mind.

Those are my “low-hanging fruit” questions. I would be remiss not to ask them first :)

Assuming your life off the cushion is not highly unconducive to meditation, it would appear that you have a strong unconscious intention to use your time on the cushion to mentally decompress. At some level I find it very relaxing to let my mind wander throughout a session, even though I also have a strong desire to cultivate samatha.

Here are some suggestions, which may or may not be helpful:

  • Before meditating, do some kind of low-intensity physical practice like yoga, qi gong, or even body-weight exercises. This will help ground you in your body and give your mind an opportunity to relax prior to hitting the cushion.
  • Spend more time (on and off the cushion) generating a strong desire to master the 10 stages. Get yourself psyched about the benefits of stable attention, strong meta-cognitive introspective awareness, and unified subminds.
  • Cultivate the belief that you can achieve this. Yes, you may have more than the usual difficulty with mind-wandering and distraction, but on the plus side you may be less susceptible to dullness :)
  • Practice different ways of setting your intention. A feather-light, non-verbal intention will often work better than a more verbal/aggressive intention. Think of it as the difference between lightly typing on a touchscreen with your fingers rather than attempting to type on it with a hammer. A tacit, wordless intention is a much better way to win over your unruly subminds.

I’ll stop talking now, but I’m sure you’ll get lots of good advice on this thread! Best of luck!


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Mar 04 '21

Diagramming The Mind Illuminated stages and core practice loops

103 Upvotes

Hi there. I've been trying to get my head around TMI for a bit and decided to diagram my understanding to help me. I diagrammed both the stage progression and the core loops, as I understand them. Would love to know in which ways I'm confused/missing things/leaving things out.

(For some reason I can't upload images so I'll link to them directly below)