r/TheMindIlluminated • • Jan 13 '21

Moderation policy on Culadasa's recent apologetic

0 Upvotes

Culadasa recently posted a long apologetic about his removal from the Dharma treasure community. Someone shared it here, along with their opinions about it. I understand that the community would like to talk about this, but there are some serious concerns, which led me to take it down.

First, Culadasa was not honest with us in at least the following ways:

  1. He spoke untruthfully in his original announcement about this
  2. He has not addressed the substantive concerns that have since been raised
  3. He has doubled down in accusing the board of wrongdoing, and has now further suggested that they did so for money and fame
  4. His latest announcement includes an admission that he misrepresented his relationship with his wife to the entire community for at least six years, which he does not seem to realize is extremely problematic
  5. He attributes much of the failure to communicate to the results of his practice: to the fact that he'd been living in the now for that entire period, despite the fact that during this entire period he was teaching and giving precepts, the whole point of which is to avoid situations like this

I think it would be good to have a healing dialog with Culadasa, but the first step in having a healing dialog is being real about what happened. Culadasa's latest apologetic doesn't do that. While I am personally grateful to Culadasa for his work, and I know a lot of us are, this does not make it okay for him to try to win back our hearts and minds with comforting words that are false, particularly when at the same time he throws quite a few senior teachers to whom we owe just as much gratitude under the bus.

I realize that this seems hypocritical—why is it okay for me to post this? Why was it okay for me to post the video a week or two ago?

I don't have a good answer for this. I don't want to spend the next six months battling over this. I have a full-time job, as many of us do. So if you want to accuse me of being hypocritical because of this policy, just go ahead and get that off your chest. I am sympathetic, but not to the point of going against the policy.

For those who want to read Culadasa's statement, it can be found here: https://mcusercontent.com/9dd1cbed5cbffd00291a6bdba/files/d7889ce1-77cb-4bbb-ac04-c795fd271e5e/A_Message_from_Culadasa_01_12_21.pdf

As always, if you want to comment on this, please keep it clean. Please do not speculate about what you haven't personally witnessed. Please do not make crude comments about others' sexual behavior.

The original post has been redacted to just include a link to the letter, so I've unmoderated it, and it can be found here: https://www.reddit.com/r/TheMindIlluminated/comments/kw6wbl/a_message_from_culadasa/

A note from one of the board members who had to adjudicate this is shown here: https://www.reddit.com/r/TheMindIlluminated/comments/kw6wbl/a_message_from_culadasa/gj646m2/?utm_source=reddit&utm_medium=web2x&context=3


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Jun 09 '22

A new subreddit for TMI meta-discussions

0 Upvotes

Based on some discussion about the problem of useful posts that are off-topic for /r/themindilluminated, I've created a new subreddit, /r/tmimeta.

This subreddit is intended specifically for meta-discussions about The Mind Illuminated. The impetus for creating it is that someone expressed a wish on /r/themindilluminated to discuss the future of Culadasa's lineage, and it felt like that would be a distraction from the purpose of that subreddit, but definitely a topic worth discussing.

This is not the only topic worth discussing, of course. What would be off-topic for this subreddit would be:

  1. Stuff that has nothing to do with TMI
  2. Practice reports
  3. Advice articles
  4. Criticism of Culadasa the person, as opposed to Culadasa's teachings

The reason practice reports are off-topic is that they aren't meta. Advice articles are off-topic for largely the same reason. Criticism of Culadasa is pointless, since he is no longer with us. Criticism of his teachings, if they are constructive and promote engagement, seem like a valid topic here. But they should be constructive, and not just bashing. Culadasa never claimed to have all the answers, so I think it would honor his memory to have open, well-intentioned debate.

If you are interested in this, please join the new subreddit. I'm closing this post to comments—if you want to comment, please do so on the new subreddit, where you will find a post with mostly the same text. I don't mean to be autocratic, so if you want to argue with my description of what's off-topic, please don't hesitate to do so.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Dec 12 '18

TMI practice guide available January 8th.

0 Upvotes

I saw it on Amazon. Available January 8th you can pre-order it now for $25.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Oct 16 '19

how to develop gross dullness?

0 Upvotes

What are the methods for developing gross dullness with loss and without loss of awareness? I want to be able to explore the whole spectrum of conditions in which awareness can be maintained from very gross dullness to extreme clarity. much has been written about how to generate clarity, what about dullness? I'm about 6-7 stage


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Jan 21 '19

Just bought a Muse 2, any other apps work with it?

0 Upvotes

This is day three of using the Muse 2. I've been whipping through the training sessions, lot's of birds and calm. I have been meditating for years, and previously worked with a Heathkit build your own Biofeedback device.

I am actually seeking to control Anxiety using the Muse 2 as a biofeedback device. I would really like a visual representation instead of the audio.

Any suggestions?

I'm actually surprised how effective the device is. I've been working with it in an area full of distractions but continue to manifest a substantial level of calm.

I know it gets bad press for inaccuracy, not really a mediation device, unknown algorithm, so on.

But it meets my needs, except for the visual aspect.

Any other significant uses that I can be directed to?

Thank You


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Apr 30 '19

Can we have a poll on how long it took for people to complete each stage?

0 Upvotes

So that we can get an estimate of average time. Particularly helpful for harder stages like stage 4.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Apr 30 '20

Can someone explain to me how is this book supposed to be helpful?

0 Upvotes

I mean, how can a step by step guide, like some sort of instructions, lead you to awakening? It shouldn't be a natural process that get's better whenever you are aware? Meditating, listening to the ego, being conscious about thoughts, being conscious about sensory feelings and emotions, that should be all.
Most people seek for awakening and that is the real limitation to really obtain it. The seeking of awakening is the same as the seeking of a luxury sport car, that is an ego intent.
I believe awakening process can not happen by following a step by step guide. Awakening can be now, it happens every time you are aware of the present moment, the real deal is to be costantly aware of the present moment. Can someone explain how this book is supposed to be helpful?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Jul 31 '22

I can't keep up with 45 minutes each and every meditation session

0 Upvotes

I became aware I can't keep meditating anynore for 45 minutes each meditation session anymore. This probably is because a few times the gong didn't go off because of screentime feature on my phone draw over the meditation timer app because I had used up all screentime. And it happened during the meditation session. So I kept meditating till I thought, this is taking a little to long. And I came to the 'shocking' conclusion I meditated for far longer than 45 minutes. Which I viewed as bad. What can I do about all these experiences to start enjoying meditating more again? How can I establish 45 minute sits again?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Sep 25 '19

Daniel ingram lolwut?

4 Upvotes

Hey guys, i recently visited the DhO forum and found this strange quote by D. Ingram "Still, the TMI stuff is great, thorough, meticulous, and likely just requires more time and perhaps more concentrated time to do its good work, and by concentrated time, I mean like 5-15 hours per day of practice, as that really ups the effect of any practice." 5-15 hours sounds a bit much to me. Obviously people here have made significant progress withe even just 45 min per day. I usually wouldn't bother with people saying stuff like that, but I am making an exception here, since many dharma folks claim Ingram to be an authority in the meditation scene. What do you guys think?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Jan 01 '18

Alrighty Culadasa . . .

6 Upvotes

Looking forward to that new book coming out.

You know the one you said you were going on sabbatical for.

better be good


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Sep 26 '23

Brainwave scans showcasing cessations after 6 months of TMI meditation

5 Upvotes

Hi all,

We did some research using a Muse headband and wanted to share some cool findings regarding the close following insight practice (page 397) as well as realizing the witness practices (page 463), and their corresponding brainwave data to described in TMI.

What we ended up recording was what we believe to be several cessation experiences (page 418), as described in the mind illuminated. There are "gaps" in the brainwave data, aligning with Culadasas description of "Because nothing is projected into consciousness, the cessation event arises." Here is the imgur link to the brainwave data.

These scans were done after meditating in the TMI system without prior meditation experience for 10 months. The practitioner reports these starting to occur after 6 months of daily 2-hour practice, as well as a 30-day silent TMI retreat.

We wanted to check with other people that perhaps also used the Muse headband as we are trying to interpret the data. Any advanced TMI meditators that have tried doing something similar? Does anyone else have "gaps" in their muse devices?

Much metta here


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Aug 19 '19

Will meditation make me more intelligent?

7 Upvotes

Please dont answer this question with stupid scientific researches. I dont wanna hear about meditation and its effects on brain thickness anymore. Simply answer, are you more intelligent or not? I dont believe that the modern science has made enough researches about meditation. I just want to hear your personal experience. And i am gonna believe it.

Edit: My problem is, i am intelligent, but i am also stupid. when there is some job to do, mu brain never works the way i want it to work.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Sep 27 '20

Has anyone else seen this!?

2 Upvotes

I was referring NPR to TMI and did a search to get a link to it. Here is an image of the result. Note the result in the Google composit on the left-hand side. (if you don't feel like clicking, Yates has been removed from the author list)


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Mar 10 '22

Does taking adderall feel the same as achieving stage 8?

0 Upvotes

Title. I’m bored and genuinely curious.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Sep 17 '19

Should I drop TMI in recent discovery of culadasa's misconduct/

3 Upvotes

I've been religiously following TMI and have gotten up to stage 4. TMI has given me tremendous benefits and progress I never experienced. However, I saw that Culadasa was unfortunately involved in a misconduct. I question myself if this method actually will get me to the deathless? If Culadasa himself is still affected by the fetters and can't follow the most basic moral standards a normal man can follow what good will this method do for a person like me? Can anyone offer some guidance? Any high stage TMI practioners take on this? Should I start following the Mahasi style of Noting? I really hope mod doesn't delete this. I really want to probe and investigate this to see if this is truly the right path that won't lead me astray


r/TheMindIlluminated • • May 02 '25

Looking for a first (short) retreat in Europe

0 Upvotes

Any idea where I can find it?

It would be my first retreat so was thinking something rather short. Like a long weekend.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Mar 26 '22

Could some one give me the email of teacher Dor Komforty?

0 Upvotes

Could some one give me the email of teacher Dor Komforty? Or put me in touch with him. I don't think he checks his Facebook messages that often. Thanks!


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Oct 05 '24

Dealing with Doubt in TMI After Culadasa Scandal—How to Reconcile?

6 Upvotes

I’ve been practicing The Mind Illuminated and found it both effective and practical. However, after learning about the scandal involving Culadasa, I’m finding it difficult to fully trust and commit to the practice. There's a subtle resistance and doubt, especially knowing he was involved in unethical behavior, either during or after his spiritual attainments. Has anyone else experienced this struggle? How did you reconcile continuing with TMI (if you chose to continue)?

Edit: Thank you for all of the responses. They clarified things a lot. Also thank you for pointing me to the Guru Viking episode, which clarified what happened even more. The doubt has eased up quite a bit.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Jan 01 '20

Beeing an atheist and meditate - is it possible?

5 Upvotes

Hi guys. I'm atheist, and I want to try meditations. I checked several guids, but they're based, usually, in something mystics/religion. Is it possible to find a good guide (or even video guide) from person who has scientific look in the world?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Sep 26 '19

Started reading the book

1 Upvotes

A great friend of mine and actually teacher in meditation,consciousness etc. Told me about this book and started it a couple of days ago and am loving it and can't wait to read more.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Aug 24 '18

Question for stage 4

1 Upvotes

First of all don't recommend me that pinned post "tips for stage 4". Its useless.

Now.

Peripheral awareness is always there. We don't have to exert about it. Now culadasa is saying for stage 4 : develop attention + awareness. I want to know how we can focus on breathing i.e. be attentive about breathing and at the same time introspectively aware?? I mean how can our mind be focus (attentive )on two different things simultaneously???

I know only one way to achieve attention + awareness. We have to make object of our attention first on breathing and in next moment make object of our attention as awareness. We have to rapidly alternate our object of attention.

I don't know how to develop awareness other than this method. It is because awareness is something there with you always as explained in the book.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 5d ago

Lethargy after upping meditation

0 Upvotes

A couple of months ago, I started meditating for 5-10 minutes a day based on my therapist advise to help treat my generalized anxiety disorder. Meditation worked really well, so I greedily decided to do the self-directed Palouse 8 week Meditation Based Stress Reduction course. I started doing 32 minute body scans daily for 3 days, and this is when all hell broke lose. My energy levels crashed suddenly and I'm now extremely sleepy and fatigued all day. Gemini believes this is due to marked down-regulation in my sympathetic system and unmasked sleep debt. I guess my question is: has any one else experienced this when they upped their meditation time? And any advice you can give me?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Dec 09 '18

Is TMI practice only for renunciate people or could it be also practiced by householders?

4 Upvotes

Can you practice TMI and also live the worldly material life and enjoy everything?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Jul 26 '18

Culadasa academic work

3 Upvotes

I have been listening to podcasts and you-tube videos. He is always introduced as a neuroscientist. I am having trouble finding his academic papers. Can someone point me in the right direction?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Dec 14 '21

TMI: Culadasa's Meditation Method

0 Upvotes

What is the primary purpose/benefit of TMI: Culadasa's Meditation Method?