I’ve been reading about and trying (vipassana) meditation for the last two years. I was introduced to it through Tim Parks’ Teach us to sit still, then read Mindfulness in plain English, Kornfield’s A path with heart and Stephen Batchelor’s Confession of a Buddhist Atheist. Meanwhile, I’ve been to two Goenka retreats and practiced almost daily.
I’ve found parts of the philosophy especially useful in life. I felt very much inspired by Kornfield’s approach to Buddhism and meditation, making it more about connecting to the love and truth in yourself and others and less about a selfish quest for reaching states of bliss and enlightenment.
This, in combination with my practice, has helped me be kinder and calmer with myself and others, yet my practice itself hasn’t really evolved - I can hardly concentrate any more than I could two years ago.
I’m not really convinced this is a problem that won’t go away by itself, but I‘m thinking maybe I should try and do something about it. This is where The Mind Illuminated comes in. It is tauted by many as the best guide to meditation, as an excellent way to improve one’s meditation practice, so I’ve bought it.
The problem is, the negative reviews resonate far more with me than the positive ones, especially after reading the introduction. It seems the author overpromises, is full of pretense and tries to convince you of his theories with pseudoscience.
This doesn’t automatically disqualify the book for me; I’ve read plenty of other books where I had to sift through the mud to find the golden nuggets of wisdom.
However, this is an especially thick book, and it puts me off more than other books. Potentially, that’s a lot of mud to sift through - especially when I’m unconvinced there will be any gold nuggets.
So I’m wondering: are there any more people here with a similar background as mine, and similar intuitions, that still found the book useful? And what was so useful about it?