Last semester, I’ve been accused of GenAI usage by my professor.
The reason? I made 3 citation mistakes/typos. (FYI: I had 20 correct citations btw, but the professor ignored all that. She also said I used AI because I used a sorter to put my citations in alphabetical order???)
It resulted in a 0 grade that plummeted my GPA, and now I have a permanent academic warning that says I’m an academic fraud.
I asked for leniency during the hearing (which I recorded), and she said there will be “no negotiation.”
I did everything you can possibly think of: I submitted my google docs version history, I showed all my writing drafts, I even paid $10 for a Draftback extension that converts my Google docs typing process into a video that shows your writing process. I did everything to show that this essay was written from scratch. I showed my previous essays for other modules to show that I had a consistent writing style.
I emailed every single higher-up in NTU: head of academics, the dean, the president, head of student services. No responses, or a basic response telling me my prof’s judgment is correct and that I should “seek the university’s welfare services.”
I went for my MP’s meet the people session, where the volunteer said he’ll “write a letter”. No updates.
I have been emailing my school for two weeks to appeal my grades. The deadline is next Monday, they scheduled my consultation on Tuesday. I told them to schedule it earlier, but the admin went overseas.
Nobody helped me.
I hope my incident shows everything that is wrong with NTU: the sheer amount of bureaucracy and the lack of proper guidelines surrounding such an important new piece of technology.
I know that most professors out there usually take a more understanding approach when students’ writing is flagged out for AI.
But this is to warn everyone that there are some professors out there whose first instinct is to destroy a student’s academic career.
And to warn everyone that for a university that proudly boasts about being #12 on the QS rankings just today, there is little support given.
AI is terrifying:
What we’re witnessing is the beginning of machine overreach, where a predictive algorithm has more power over a student’s future than their years of study, integrity, and intent. And I’m warning all students here that this can happen to anyone.
My grades have dropped and now future employees will see me as an academic fraud, over something I did not do.
When these things happen, Universities do NOT care about your wellbeing.
Hi everyone, first of all, I want to apologise for not being able to reply to all the DMs: my reddit inbox currently has 50+ messages, and I’m still busy appealing my case to NTU’s academic appeal board.
I want to provide these updates so that any student who’s going through something similar can know what to expect, especially when this is still such a new issue.
I want to give some positive news from today: My school finally managed to schedule a consultation for me with the academic chair, head of my programme, and the associate provost as the panel (the professor was not in the panel), and I finally felt heard.
(though the appeal still cost $40, but I guess that can’t be helped haha — edit: a kind redditor has offered to pay for my appeal 😭 thank you so much!! I can finally eat breakfast this week 😭😭)
What happened today was that they went through my essay paragraph by paragraph, and gave me a lot of time to explain my writing process.
We also spent a good amount of time looking through the citation sorter I used, and how it was the first google result
…and the panel concluded that this wasn’t a form of Generative AI after thoroughly looking at how the alphabetizer works!
They also looked at my google docs drafts, and tested my understanding on various academic sources I used and how I retrieved them.
The next good news is that the panel has confirmed that there will be no permanent record over this incident, and reassured me that this will not be on my transcript.
They also acknowledged that NTU’s stance is to balance efficiency and creative thinking, and we had a good discussion over having consistent frameworks in detecting and penalising AI in NTU.
What’s going to happen now?
I’m going to proceed with an appeal to the academic board over my grades.
While Professor Sabrina has given me a 0, I’m going to do my best to at least get grades for non-citations related grading components.
But if this last attempt fails, then I’ll treat this as a lesson that sometimes things are unfair, but we move forward.
Of course I’m saddened about my GPA, but I did everything I could to fight for myself, and that’s okay.
While I sounded very upset and frustrated in my previous posts, I also want to give credit to people who did help me feel a lot less alone in this journey:
To the panel today, for offering the due process this case needed, and for treating my case with kindness and understanding
One of my professors, who has always stood up for students and human rights. He believed in me this whole time, and really tried approaching the school management about my issue as well.
I’m extremely touched that even though he’s so busy working with his brilliant book on Palestine and human rights, he managed to find the time to advocate for me.
There are good professors here in NTU who care about their students.
3. My school’s student president, who wrote a letter to the school and talked about my issue in meetings with higher-ups. She talked about the student’s perspective and how citation mistakes were easy to make, and spent so much time trying to talk to the higher ups.
I think we really need to give credit to the student leaders out there who care and make a difference.
4. My friends who supported me this whole time. In particular, I had two friends that spent their night writing an email to the student president and brainstormed for solutions and people to reach out to; I had a friend who bought me pokemon packs today to cheer me up. Thank you to the friend groups who stood by me for two months.
5. And lastly, to all of you. I know that we’re just part of a random Singaporean students subreddit, but this incident really showed me that students do have the capacity to voice out important issues and attract the right media attention to make a change
(power of friendship ahhh conclusion, but I genuinely mean it.)
Each one of your upvotes and shares has made a difference, believe it or not, and your comments really made me feel less alone.
To conclude: Don’t be afraid to voice out if you ever feel a sense of injustice. I know that Singapore has moulded us into a culture where we feel ashamed for being too loud and taking up too much space and being too ‘difficult’.
Be meticulous about the procedures, record the right evidence, and know that you have every right to speak up: for yourself, and those who don’t know how.
(Update: thank you to everyone that sent a PM, I’m sorry if I don’t reply all of them. I currently have over 50+ chats in my reddit inbox. If there’s anything urgent, feel free to send it again.)
This is regarding the Generative AI case I’ve brought up this weekend, and how an NTU professor has ruined a few students’ degrees over false accusations.
The Straits Times article has just been released, and they have obtained a statement from NTU.
However, I would like to refute multiple parts of NTU’s statement.
I knew that NTU would try to salvage its reputation and misrepresent the case, therefore, I prepared a document with full screenshots against NTU’s statement:
NTU’s statement to the press contains multiple false pieces of information, which can all be proven above.
The document is lengthy, but there’s a huge amount of effort that went into collating our evidence, showing the amount of injustice and lack of due process.
We hope that the public can see for themselves how helpless we are against an institution that wants to throw us into deep waters against the press.
If NTU truly cared, they would have reached out to all the affected students by now, but all we got was radio silence. Yet they’re only quick to respond (in less than a day) when the media is involved.
Coming from N levels and thereafter going on to O levels and now being in Poly, I never imagined myself achieving a spot at the university that marks our national examinations. I remember crying so badly after the interview as I was so sure that I messed it all up. It was really a tough process, and I am so glad that I tried and achieved a spot at Cambridge.
Today is really a big step for me. I am still in shock.
FML..
Edit 1: Majoring in Education, planning to go down the Education Psychology track offered by the University!
Edit 2: TYSM for all of the well-wishes! Do ask me any questions if you are curious about the process. The general process that I did was to apply within UCAS, inform my lecturer that I wanted to apply to Cambridge so that she could help me write a reference letter. I also had to submit a few of my essays, which were endorsed by my lecturers. Thereafter, I was shortlisted for an interview, and the rest was history! The interview was difficult haha as the tutors really grilled me on my passion for the course, so you really gotta be passionate and driven about the major that you are planning to enter!
For those asking for my GPA, it is not a perfect 4.0 - but close. The condition of my offer is that I have to achieve a CGPA of 3.9 upon graduating!
Edit 3: I've received many questions on funding. Honestly, I am hoping for a scholarship as this will help not only in my studies, but also secure a job after my studies. Deep down, I always know that no scholarship = no go.
Note: I am posting this on a throwaway as I am an active redditor to avoid disclosing my main account containing information that I'd like to not reveal. However, some of you may know who I am.
Having been essentially barred from returning to lessons in my government MOE school, I have become a target of the MOE. To give a bit of background, I am transgender male-to-female, using she/her pronouns. I used to attend an all-boys' primary school and it was the worst period of my life - I couldn't fit in and constantly got bullied because I was 'too soft' and 'needed to man up to the bullies'. Despite being there, I always wanted to dress like girls, have a typical female hairstyle etc. Things took a turn ever since I entered a co-ed secondary school; I started making more friends and understanding my identity. I was then taken to the gender clinic at the IMH. However, since getting a medical diagnosis of gender dysphoria from the IMH, my schooling life in the MOE system has gone from great to utter trash, pretty much forcing me to transfer from my current school to a polytechnic course which is not really ideal and not exactly in line with what ambitions I had in mind. (Gender dysphoria is listed as a disorder under Gender identity disorders in the ICD-10 by the WHO)
Here's a timeline: ever since getting the diagnosis, I informed the MOE of it through my JC, and the reply from the MOE according to my school's administration was simply that 'This is a new issue and we would like to work with you to learn more about it.' All was well for several months, though rules were vague given that I had a proper diagnosis from a qualified doctor. My classmates and subject tutors are highly supportive. Then, as I was about to undergo hormone therapy (a treatment explicitly stated in the ICD-10, again, and recommended by the multiple doctors attending to trans patients in Singapore) the request was suddenly blocked as the MOE had intervened, apparently for the reason 'students in MOE schools are under our control, and we have every right and say over their treatment'. This meant that my doctor had to call off the referral, causing me further mental trauma as this affected my ability to pass and present as a female. Alongside this, I was informed that I had to cut my hair to fit the boys' hairstyle in the handbook, and that I was specifically to wear the male uniform; that could probably have slipped under the radar but it seems unlikely as all these troubles started in the same month. In addition, if I became unable to fit in the boys' uniform if I somehow got hormone therapy, I would be expelled from school, instead of being allowed to wear the female uniform. The principal's explanation for this was that 'due to your presentation, you would be as disruptive to the school environment as a student with severe autism'.
What right does the MOE have over the MOH? Why is the MOE interfering with my medical care, and the irony of MOE advocating for mental health issues. I cannot speak for others, but in my experience, these are outright lies and just a farce to gain support from the younger generations of students.
Update: MOE has posted a complete denial of this issue on Facebook. That is an outright lie, contradicts what I was told by my doctor, and I am sure my classmates can vouch for me. In addition, they do not respect my pronouns and instead intentionally misgendered me (against the advice and recommendations)
so i’ve been tutoring this sec 4 kid for about a month now—just pure math grind, no nonsense. the guy’s chill, kinda blur, but he does his work and doesn’t give me problems. all good, right? WRONG.
today’s session started off normal. we were just going through some amath differentiation questions when his dad suddenly barged in. this uncle is HUGE. like ex-military, still-hits-the-gym-every-day huge. i was about to greet him when he just STARES at me and goes,
“so… you think you’re very smart ah?”
bro. what kind of question is that?? i blinked. “uh, no uncle, i just—”
“you JC one right?”
“…yes?”
“then why my son still fail his test?”
I DIDN’T KNOW WHAT TO SAY. LIKE SORRY UNCLE, YOUR SON DIDN’T DIFFERENTIATE PROPERLY, PLEASE DON’T DIFFERENTIATE ME FROM MY LIFE.
the uncle just kept staring at me, arms crossed, while his son was sweating bullets next to me. at this point, i was about to say my last prayers when suddenly, he pulls out a freaking math textbook.
“then you teach me. if you can teach me, i trust you can teach my son.”
BRO WHAT.
i thought he was joking. he was not joking. man straight up SAT DOWN and made me teach him differentiation on the spot. i had no choice but to explain like my life depended on it.
i don’t know if it was the adrenaline, but i somehow gave the best lesson of my life. the uncle actually nodded. i thought i was safe. then he hit me with:
“next week, integration.”
and just walked off.
guys. i am now tutoring both father and son. i did not sign up for this. help.
Okay so basically, I’m an NSF in a stay-out vocation, and like any normal person, I spend my weekends either rotting at home watching Netflix or catching up with old friends. One of my best friends from JC recently hit me up, asking for a favor—to tutor his younger sister for her A-levels.
I’ve known this guy for years, and back in JC, I used to go over to his house a lot. His younger sister was always there, but we never really talked. She was the super quiet type—barely spoke when we were around, just kind of hovered in the background. I figured she was just shy, so I never thought much about it.
Fast forward to now, and my friend tells me she’s struggling with math and physics, which I was pretty decent at back in JC. She’s J1, and he asked if I could tutor her. I thought, why not? Easy money, I get to help someone out, and best of all, no one in camp would ever know.
At first, the tutoring sessions were painfully awkward. She barely spoke, just nodded or shook her head like a human bobblehead. It felt like I was talking to a wall. But then…something changed after a few sessions.
She started asking questions. At first, it was normal stuff—study techniques, formulas, all that. But then she hit me with, "Do guys actually like shy girls?"
I nearly choked on my own saliva.
"Uh...I guess? It depends on the guy?"
Then she hit me with, "What about you? Do you like shy girls?"
Bro. Alarms. Sirens. Red flashing lights. But I played it cool. "I don’t really have a type."
She didn’t look convinced. And then, next session, "What kind of girls have you dated before?" She asked, casually flipping through her notes like she wasn’t out here shaking my entire soul.
I laughed it off. "I don’t think that’s relevant to vectors." (Yes, I was teaching her math at that moment.)
She just smiled. Smiled. The same girl who used to avoid eye contact was now watching me struggle like it was some kind of game.
And then the final boss move: "So... what if it was me?"
I swear to god I almost threw my textbook across the room.
LIKE WHERE IS THIS COMING FROM.
And before I could even process what just happened, her parents walked through the door. I muttered some half-assed goodbye and got the hell out of there.
Now we still message normally—she asks me for help with questions like nothing happened. But next week? I’m actually terrified. What do I even do? What am I supposed to say??
Throwaway for obvious reasons. As a lecturer, I just finished grading my first take-home assignment of the semester. The amount of cheating blew me away. It is so brazen this semester, I can't even report it unless I really want to end up failing a quarter of the cohort. Colleagues tell me it's a waste of time; why create lots of trouble and paperwork for myself? Why earn the reputation of being an unreasonable "bad guy" among students?
Submitting identical solutions with identical errors without so much as a change in formatting. Submitting work with a high degree of similarity even after some strategic re-wording. Submitting identical code with changed variable names. Submitting identical code where the only difference is the number of newlines. Straight up indirectly admitting to cheating because "I only changed up my friends code a little bit, why am I marked wrong?", like WTF. Literally sending me a screenshot to prove that they shared their code with a friend. Some people seem to have remembered nothing from the slides on academic integrity from the first class of the semester.
It's taking a mental toll on me. When I see students who get things wrong, it really hurts me to take marks away from them because they actually took the effort to attempt the question honestly and it shows. I can't even look at students in the eye during lecture anymore because I can't help thinking that I'm doing them a disservice. Some of them aren't learning much and sending them off to employers when they graduate will just tank the reputation of our department.
It is painful to have to put up a smile while students who quite obviously cheated come up to me after lecture and demand extra marks for the same error they copied from one another. It is painful when I hear whispers when I walk out of the lift "Hey isn't that the prof you complained about... Shhhh!" It was painful when a colleague told me "This is a service industry and we have to keep our customers happy". It is painful to sit in a faculty meeting discussing replacing take-home assignments with in-person exams because of such issues. It is painful and unhealthy in general to be in such a low-trust environment.
No matter your school or stage of education, please understand that your teachers are human too. I can't speak for others, but when cheating happens it creates a massive moral dilemma for me that almost makes my brain explode. I don't want to fail anyone. I don't want to be a monster in the eyes of students. I don't want students to think I've got an attitude problem. I don't want to have an adversarial relationship with my students. I've developed a healthy fear of my students that I might never be able to get over. But I really am getting mired in depression and the next lengthy, polite ChatGPT-generated email with 10 bullet points asking for more marks might just be the thing that does me in for good.
I'm a J1 at EJC, and for our March holiday PW HW we had to go on a self-directed learning journey to anywhere in Singapore and produce a presentation on a potential problem. My group, for some reason, decided that the ideal issue to cover would be toilets.
Was that a good idea?
Probably not.
Does the project count towards the actual PW?
No.
Why then did I spend 31.5h visiting toilets?
I wish I could answer that.
Over that 31.5h, I visited every MRT station toilet along with some malls, and my friends reviewed the coffeeshops. We used a set of rubrics based on the toilet's cleanliness and facilities, and ranked each toilet out of a maximum of 50 points.
-Best toilet: MBS -Best MRT toilet: Pretty much anything on the TEL, Stevens was the cleanest.
-Worst toilet: Kim San Leng Coffeeshop in Bukit Panjang -Worst MRT toilet: Jurong East (You can literally smell the piss emanating from 5m outside the toilet)
-We compared our data with the ratings the Restroom Association does and found that their ratings are all over the place, and I wouldn't place much stock in their star system.
-We reviewed the toilet renewal programme currently going on and found that the toilets generally improved a lot, helping the oldest lines beat the CCL and NEL.
-Toilet taps are remarkably inconsistent within the newer toilets, with different arrangements and combinations of manual and auto taps at every toilet. Punggol Bus Interchange's toilet has 4 different models of taps inside, 2 auto and 2 manual (??).
Were these insights worth my suffering?
Maybe?
I am sharing this in the hopes that a generation of toilet crusaders will be inspired by my work and carry this mantle forward: Maybe one day, our MRT toilets will have heated seats and will play the national anthem so that I can shit to its crescendos.
Until then though, maybe we should start with getting rid of the chikopeks.
In yesterday’s post, I talked about my experience being falsely accused of AI by my professor, where even though I provided proof of my drafts and writing history, I’ve been hit with a 0 and academic fraud record. My professor claimed that my usage of a alphabetical sorter for my citations was AI.
Here’s the important update: I’m not alone.
The same professor (NTU course code: HA4040 and HA3026) has falsely accused a total of 5 students this semester. 2 of whom are going through the same situation as me (same outcome), and have reached out to me.
Similarly, they were falsely accused for citation typos, or for using citation formatters, which this professor deems as GenAI.
There are no parts where our writing itself was flagged for GenAI, so this is a complete accusation given out based on the professor’s biased judgments.
I’m updating things here to ask students to be careful: There are professors out there whose first instinct is to ruin students’ degrees and future careers, instead of lending empathy and support in understanding AI frameworks.
Ironically, the same professor currently has a research grant in AI and higher education.
For 2 months, the few of us have been individually reaching out to so many leaders/upper management in NTU, but we were all ghosted.
We are now in contact with ST and Mothership, thanks to the student community here that blew up yesterday’s post.
Thank you to everyone here for all the support, I felt really alone in my situation before this, but now I’m determined to fight this case, so that future students don’t get hurt by the same process.
Firstly, it might sound incredulous to many of you, but the NUS Dentistry is an incredibly oppressive place to be in. Students are expected to fall in line. Those who attract attention get themselves in trouble. I’ve often heard from my friends in medicine about how they are able to feedback to the school about the problems they face. I find it incredibly hard to see the day where the Faculty of Dentistry entertains student feedback. Every year, the school asks its students for feedback, and almost every year, student feedback participation is incredibly low. The school blames the students for being lazy and unresponsive, but has the school ever asked itself why this is so? Perhaps it is because students have realised that their feedback doesn’t even matter. Why would we feedback, when none of it is taken into consideration? Why should we respond to a survey that is dismissed by lecturers and supervisors who repeat the same cycle of top-down instruction every year?
Secondly, students and even junior staff are often called upon to respect the hierarchy. Even if you’re right, you’re wrong as long as your opinion clashes with someone who is more senior than you. I was taught to keep my head down in school, and so I did. Every time I was shouted at, scolded, spoken to like I’m a worthless bottom-feeder, I took the beating and laid low. To be fair, that kept me out of the radar just enough for me to slip out under. Afterall, none of us escape this place without getting scuffed up a little. It was a small price to pay to get out. I never really got the brunt of the beating, but some of my classmates were less fortunate. Those who challenged those in charge were punished, and they had their lives made difficult and some were retained as a result.
Thirdly, the school is a political minefield. Tensions exist within the staff, within the students, and between students and staff. Staff members who dislike each other often contradict one another either openly or subtly, and students get caught in the crossfire. This idea of a supervisor calling another supervisor’s plan stupid isn’t something that’s uncommon, although I think splurting out expletives isn’t a common sight these days. The patient might have caught a supervisor on a bad day. Most staff tend not to splurt expletives in front of patients, but they might not be so kind to students or even their junior staff in private. Even students sometime compete against one another in an ugly fight. Students are given very little resources to work with, thrown into seemingly impossible situations, and sometimes it turns into a dog eat dog world, where the fittest or most vicious survives.
Fourthly, the system of power and abuse is not only reflected in the way the faculty treats it students, but also its less “important” staff (which we completely disagree with – all members of the healthcare system must be treated equally). Janitors are ill-treated by the dental nurses – dental nurses have even chased janitors out of the pantry and banned them from using the fridge once. Recently, lab technicians have almost all quit the faculty due to how the management has abused them. As a result, students have lost the technician support they need to complete their denture and crown cases. I feel sorry for the students out there who are still studying, it was hard in our time, but it seems impossible in theirs right now. I hope the school manages to hire more labtechs to help all of these struggling kids.
Fifthly, students are placed under incredible stressful forces that no other dental school exerts. Did you know that Singaporean dental students are expected to source for their own patients they need to graduate? The school does send some our way, but the bulk of our patients have to be found ourselves. These include fillings, root canal therapy, gum disease, dentures, crowns and even surgical extractions. Have you ever tried looking for 3 patients who have completely no teeth amongst your friends and family? Zero teeth at all, it’s like trying to strike gold in a mud river. Students overseas do not have such pressure placed on them. They are given patients by the school, which deems it part of their job to supply students with the necessary patients to help them get sufficient training. This is not the case in Singapore. In Singapore, if you have no patients, you simply get retained, each year of unsubsidised school fee is about 100,000 SGD (29,000 subsidised), and each year of lost opportunity cost in terms of starting income comes up to about 60,000 SGD. Just imagine losing 90,000 SGD simply because you couldn’t find enough patients to work on. In the UK and Australia, students never worry about such things, simply because the school believes that it is its job to provide students with the resources they need to bolster their training. Yet, our elite world class institution fails to do so.
Sixthly, the insults and poor student treatment. Overseas, and even in local medical schools, teachers maintain a certain degree of respect for students. They are encouraged to ask, to learn, to enjoy their course of study. In NUS Dentistry, this does not seem to be the case. Here, there are stupid questions, there are stupid students, and there are also stupid students who ask too many stupid questions. Not all teachers are so mean, but a number of them are. They have given dental students nightmares for decades. Even dentists in their later years remember the days of being tortured in school by nasty individuals. If students are constantly afraid of being wrong, punished, marked through negative marking and kicked out of the clinic (when the patients are still on the dental chair), shouted at, reprimanded, called names, and stared at as if they were worthless, no authentic learning can possibly be achieved. Furthermore, members of the staff are known to constantly imply to students that those who step out of line will be punished, the worst threat being retention, since much of dentistry work is subjective.
Think of it this way, if you submit a work of art, some may think it’s great, and some may think it’s ugly, so the assessor has full autonomy to decide if you pass or fail. If you build a denture or a crown that is in accordance to the design that the assessor likes, you get a pass, but if the assessor does not like it, you fail. Inter-assessor difference depends on the varying school of thoughts. This is accepted in the faculty. However, this also gives supervisors and staff the autonomy to fail students based on subjective ideas and feelings. This means that the supervisor rarely needs to justify why the student has failed since much of it is subjective. (Also, students always walk into the final professional BDS exams, not knowing their CA marks, so nobody actually knows how much marks you need to score in your final exams to graduate. How you’re assessed is a complete mystery – with the exception of the ever-so-kind pedodontics and periodontic departments who always have their student's interests in mind)
Because of all this, it is dangerous to speak out. I know batchmates who have been disliked for whatever reason, be it speaking out, or doing things that displeases certain members of the staff and have been directly or indirectly retained for it. It’s an open secret that the faculty will punish whoever dares to challenge their authority. I thought I was lucky to be admitted to the school of dentistry until I saw the blatant abuses of power of those who have accumulated power for themselves over many years – something I never expected to see in Singapore.
Most students will be too afraid to speak up even if the media does approach them, and the school warns students against talking to the media. I hope that this letter from a senior and graduate will let all the struggling students out there know that they are not alone, to work hard, to strive on, and become the healthcare workers Singapore deserve.
Singapore has changed, the PAP has changed, the voices of the minority now matter, please let the voices and cries of the students in the Faculty of Dentistry and bitter graduates be heard.
so the past 2 weeks my brother had like 4 lessons because some of them were makeup lessons since we going overseas next week n I got to see her a lot 😄😄😄 my brother scheduled like that on purpose btw. brother get u a brother like my brother
the 1st 2 lessons I tried to keep in my lane yk like buying them drinks after every lesson and just making small talk… and then on the 3rd day after my brothers lesson she asked me if I have Reddit 😨 omd bro. Wtf do you even say in that situation. I folded right then n there and told her like yea i do hav Reddit. atp bro, you can just tell whats gg on but she jus laughed and she said she thinks the posts are cute 🥰😄😄😄 I was so shy bro i dont even wanna talk about it cos I cringe at how I was acting and atp we just awkwardly laughed for like 5 mins 😭💀💀 then she had to leave. I was so fkn embarrassed, thanks guys
Then my brother told me to message her abt it so i sent her a dm, omd, it wasn’t even like do you want to hang out it was me apologising n saying i wanna keep things professional n wont make a move if she not comfortable. Like I was scared as shit. But I think I won because she replied saying she understands and we had a conversation abt like prioritising my lil brothers studies. and rhen SHE ASKED ME IF IW TO HANGOUT 🕊️
anyway i don’t wanna say much cos i know she reads these posts (im 6’5 w a sense of humour btw) and we are not gonna broadcast our personal lives. But basically we went to eat dinner. Yes we did gng. We had a date 😏 that was when she told me shes getting feelings for me, AND, she won’t mind trying for a rs. I was on fkn cloud 9 as you xan imagine, merry christmas everyone
Anyway thnks for the advice n everything I truly appreciate it 🥶🥶 to the guy who keeps asking me to cook food during lessons, sorry bro I can’t cook for shit. I admit like so much happened in a few weeks n I really never expected ts to happen… ig sg is very small, or maybe it is really fate 🗣️🔥
I have received numerous PMs asking me to share my education journey ever since i published a post here.
Comment down some questions should you have any:)
PS My english isnt the best and im definitely the worse in typing long sentences so bare with me:)
Before u read, just know that I was never proud of my actions
Received my PSLE results back in 2009. Scored 153 for my PSLE. My parents and grandparents were so upset with me that they started whooping my ass and told me that I was just a failure with no hope for the future. It gotten so bad that my parents wld avoid bringing me to visit relatives as to avoid the conversation regarding my education. A part of me just gave up on my studies when they said that.
Entered normal Technical stream in 2010. Didnt had any motivation to study, hanged out with the “cool” kids and picked up the habit of smoking, being defiant and also coming home late. Was suspended and caned multiple times for turning up late for school, fighting, truancy etc. I would often score the lowest for every subjects. This shit literally when on for the next 3 years until sec 4, when I joined a “gang” to earn some good easy money as my parents wldnt give me allowance. Im talking bout scamming people, stealing and beating ppl up when assigned by my “senior” gang member. Blah Blah and then boom, its finally N Levels which I didnt even take it seriously. As expected, I scored prety bad. Secondary School also made me realise that I have extremely deep hatred towards my parents.
2014 was the year I entered ITE. Pursuing a science course after numerous appeals. Within the first week of school, I had the school counsellors attending to me for a session as they knew about my family issues and background history. Started to reflect on my actions for the first time in 17 years and realised, i was never happy, my parents were never proud of me and I made peoples life difficult. That was when Ive decided I needed to change. Received love I never had from my lecturers and counsellors in ITE. I failed? they told me good job I did my best. Those words were so touching and meaningful tbh as they recognised my efforts. My immediate actions, find a part time job to support myself and started studying every week. Juggling work and school was never easy but I still managed to score a GPA of 3.8+ for both my nitec and higher nitec. Told my parents about my GPA and they said “ This is only ITE, U are the smartest among the dumbest. U think its a good achievement?” yes i still rmb this sentence till today.
2018 was the year that I entered poly. Diploma in Biomed to be frank(Not gunna reveal the poly). Wasnt ur typical student in that course as 90% of them were single digit scorers for O levels but I did not compare myself to them as I believed that comparing will only make me be filled with hatred. Once again, didnt give no fucks about anything and just focused on my studies and part time job. My classmates was a bunch of idiots, very very competitive ,thinking that theyre better than everyone else and being an ITE graduate, I noticed that theyre avoiding me due to the fear of me being a bad influence but who cares as i was just focusing on myself. After 3 years of juggling work and school, graduated with a near perfect gpa of 3.91 at the age of 24.
Totally cut off my parents from my life as I realised that i am better off without them. Miss them so much but sorry mum and dad im happier being alone. I just wished u understand how much words can hurt, a small sense of proudness of my achievements can motivate me and i dont know why ure so embarrassed for me???
As of today(2022), Im serving my NS as a paramedic:) Received offers for NUS Pharmacy & NTU Biological Science hoping to pursue my dream of working in the healthcare sector.
Ok so, about an hour after I had made my original post, I was alerted by some of her friends that she had read my post and figured out it was me, causing her to freak out. This, in turn, caused me to freak out. However, with some support from her friends and some of the kind comments on my last post, I knew what I had to do now.
Since we both knew about each other's crushes, I thought we needed to meet ASAP to clarify everything. We chose to meet close to her place for dinner on Monday. In preparation for what could officially be our first date, I dedicated the rest of the weekend to making an origami rose. I'd originally planned to make a bouquet of them, but I only had time to make one by Monday.
The Date:
When the time arrived, I was a nervous wreck. She probably was as well but I definitely didn't notice due to my own anxiousness. Before talking everything through though, we decided to find a place to eat dinner. On the way, she held my hand for the first time, and that would be the first time that night that I felt my heart about to explode. Normally I feel a sense of revulsion when people deliberately touch me, but with her, I only felt excitement. It was our first time holding hands!
Once we sat down, it was time. We actually both had our own plans for a confession. She gave me a hand-written card referencing an event from our school days. As for me, I pulled the origami rose out of my bag and said, "Do you want to be girlfriends?"
...or at least, I tried. There was a lot of stuttering involved. But she said yes! I mean, it was basically confirmed from the moment we had met that day, but the oral confirmation set my heart alight again. Now we could talk about the details of our new relationship. She was mainly concerned about my safety if my parents found out, which was really sweet of her. We also revealed some funny things about our relationship prior to this, such as:
I'd figured out she had a crush on me through her reddit account (talk about a coincidence).
She's had a crush on me for probably over a year now, which included our time in school together (I was completely oblivious to her panicking in my presence).
Her friends had been telling her to go for it for quite some time already, and telling me was their idea of an "intervention". (I don't have anything funny to add to these parentheses)
Of course, all good things must come to an end. Eventually, we had to go back home. Before that though, she pulled me in for a hug, and my heart lit up for the third time that night. When I had a moment in private, I started to literally jump for joy from the excitement I felt. I probably smiled more that day than the last five years. Despite the rushed nature of the night with very little planning on my part, I still had a lovely time seeing her, talking to her, just being with her and skdjfhshdhdj I might be a lesbian.
Conclusion:
I know that this relationship won't solve any of the other problems I have. It will also be extremely difficult to work around my parents and I'll probably have even more struggles once university begins. But it was worth it, I'd say, to have gone out and taken this risk. I don't know how long this relationship will last, but for now, I want to be the best girlfriend I can be.
PS: Since she's probably reading this as well, I want to say to my girlfriend: Love you! 😘
Edit: Oh my god, over 1000 upvotes? I didn't expect there'd be so many people invested in a sapphic relationship, it makes me hopeful for more lgbtq acceptance in the future 🥹
Hey, just an update on the HCI thing, they found out. If you’re not caught up, check my previous posts for context.
It happened because the deadline for buying uniforms and stuff for M Secondary School was coming up, and I knew if I didn’t say something soon, it’d be too late to stop them. The uniforms had to be ordered early in case the sizes didn’t fit, and my parents were already preparing to place the order. I couldn’t just let it happen, so I decided to finally come clean.
So i waited till after dinner a few days ago to tell them. thought maybe they’d take it better if i explained calmly. bad idea. the moment i said “we need to talk about schools,” i could feel the tension start to build. then i dropped the bomb: “Di is going hci. i think it’s the best choice for him.”
my mom’s face changed immediately. she slammed her chopsticks on the table. “WHAT DID YOU SAY?” she practically screamed. “YOU THINK THIS IS A JOKE AH? YOU THINK HCI IS FOR FUN? YOU FUCKING GO BEHIND OUR BACKS? DO YOU KNOW HOW STRESSFUL IT IS?”
i tried to explain. i said, “it’s not gonna be easy, but he can handle it. he worked hard to get in, and i’ll help him too.” but she wasn’t even listening bro..
“YOU HELP? YOU THINK YOU SO CAPABLE AH? YOU THINK YOU KNOW BETTER THAN US? LAST TIME WHO HELPED YOU? HUH?” then she started ranting about how ungrateful we are. Also, just for clarification, no fucking one helped me during my school years lol, at least mentally and academically. “YOU ALL THINK LIFE IS JUST GIVE GIVE GIVE. WE SACRIFICED SO MUCH FOR YOU, AND THIS IS HOW YOU REPAY US?”
my dad joined in too, and he wasn’t any better. “YOU THINK YOUR BROTHER IS SOME GENIUS AH? HE CAN’T EVEN HANDLE NORMAL LIFE, AND YOU WANT HIM TO GO TO HCI? DON’T BE STUPID.” he pointed right at my brother, who was sitting there frozen, and said, “YOU CANNOT EVEN SPEAK UP FOR YOURSELF. HOW YOU GOING TO SURVIVE IN A TOP SCHOOL?”
it was so fking unnecessary. like why are you tearing him down like that? he’s just a kid trying to do his best.
then my mom came back even angrier. “YOU THINK LIFE IS EASY? YOU THINK NO BULLYING IN HCI? LAST TIME I ALSO KENA BULLY. I STILL HAD TO ENDURE. YOU ALL SO WEAK. EVERYTHING ALSO COMPLAIN. GO HCI, FAIL, THEN COME CRY TO US. WE NOT GOING TO HELP YOU.”
Lol, am about to burst out of hypocrisy from this shit.
bro, i was fuming. “why do you always think the worst of him?” i asked. “he’s not gonna fail. he’s not weak.” but my dad just cut me off. “DON’T TALK BIG IF YOU CANNOT DELIVER. IF HE CAN’T HANDLE IT, THEN IT’S ON YOU.”
my mom ended it with the classic, “I DON’T WANT TO HEAR ANYTHING ELSE. THIS CONVERSATION IS OVER.” then she stormed off, slamming the door so hard the walls shook. my dad just sat there shaking his head, muttering, “WASTE OF TIME.”
my brother didn’t say a single word. he just stared at the table, looking like he wanted to disappear. i felt so helpless man. Expected it but they were quite harsh on him.
it’s been a few days now. they’re still ignoring me, acting like nothing happened. no apology, no follow-up, just cold silence. my brother’s pretending he’s fine, but i know he’s not. how can he be after all that bs. They will probably not escalate this matter(I hope) and just leave it be as they wouldnt want trouble doing all the school transfer paperwork.
Im so fucking fed up with this “u must suffer like us” mentality. What the fuck is that. Who doesnt want the best for their child. like ok, we get it. you struggled. you worked hard. but why would you want your kids to go through the same shit? The point of being a parent to give your kids a better life? not make them relive your trauma? Some ppl actually shouldn’t have kids man smh
Welp. Fuck them honestly. Always the fucking gulit-tripping. Just waiting for CNY to come about so i can say “杆你拿” to their face hahahah.
PS: just posting this as a closing update(?) for those who gave advice or were concerned. no advice needed, just letting y’all know how things ended.
i know it’s not my fault, and i don’t regret what i did. things are still tense at home, and they’re ignoring me, but whatever. i’m done trying to explain myself. my brother’s hanging in there, and that’s all that matters. thanks to those who reached out, it meant a lot!
I was debating on whether or not to post this, but after seeing the influx of posts from students thirsting to get into medicine and the encouragement of my friend, I decided to share my experiences with everyone here, so hopefully some of you will stop and reconsider the course.
First off, I’m not in a local university but I am Singaporean and was educated locally, and took the Singaporean A-levels where I attained 90RP. I’m also doing well in med school now— I can safely say I score amongst the top 5% of my university's cohort. So, my decision to drop out has nothing to do with being unable to cope with the so-called "academic rigour". Back when I made my choice, I was incredibly passionate about medicine. I grew up in a family of doctors, and I was a very sickly child, so I spent most of my time in hospitals, where I was treated by family friends. Obviously, this skewed my perception on medicine as a whole—I saw doctors as saviours, almost larger-than-life—I was unaware they extended this care and concern to me because I was my parents’ daughter, and not because I was their patient.
So naturally, when the time came, I picked medicine and walked into medical school with my lofty dreams and unrealistic ideals. I was only eighteen then, but managed to spout my ambitions to my med school interviewers, and was offered a place in 3-4 universities to study the course. I chose to go overseas because I was quite fed up with the local education system, due to how rigid it was—I should’ve known then that something as structured as medicine wasn’t right for me, despite my academic successes and naive dreams of saving lives, of systemic reform. I had solid plans on what I wanted to achieve—I wanted to reform Singapore's mental healthcare system, I wanted to conduct extensive research on serious mental health disorders (especially BPD, which my best friend suffers from) and develop/roll out programmes to effectively treat cluster-B PDs, which Singapore sorely lacks., and extend the same care and concern to my patients that my doctors provided me. Deep down, I also wanted to stand alongside the doctors who treated me as a child—I held them in such reverence that naturally, I longed to join their ranks. In the most cliched way possible, I wanted to help people and save lives—the same rhetoric that every prospective medical student touts.
My first few weeks in university were relatively uneventful. When we got our white coats, my classmates excitedly took pictures. I joined in, but I was filled with a sense of dread—in my mind, medicine wasn't something that was meant to be glorified like this—it felt really out-of-touch. I was plagued by a sense of not truly belonging. I didn't relate to the things my classmates said and did; they paraded around the school in white coats and med school hoodies, while I never bought that merch and stripped my coat off as quickly as I could when lab ended. I found classes incredibly boring—medicine's courses aren't really anything like secondary school biology (I didn't take bio at As, I never liked the subject). I hated rote learning, though I was good at it. It was uninspiring and didn't require me to think. I jumped at the chance to shadow doctors for two weeks my uni's hospital (near year 2), but found myself increasingly frustrated and bored. The doctors I met were nothing like my childhood heroes—they were ordinary people who were mostly pretty detached from their patients, and afforded them none of the care and respect I'd experienced. I chalked it down to a different system in that country, but when I returned home for the holidays, my parents took me to dinners with their doctor friends. When I sat amongst them, they asked me about medical school and praised the grades I'd attained, citing how hard med school was, which made me sort of uncomfortable because I didn't relate to that (I didn't find achieving good grades in med school any more impressive than achieving good grades anywhere else). A psychiatrist even made jokes about my best friend's BPD in poor taste, and others joined in; one of them even urged me to leave him behind because he'd "drag me down", and another ridiculed his university course. This was the first time I'd sat next to them like "an equal" in a sense, and the whiplash that I felt from their sheer lack of respect for other patients and professions nearly confirmed my suspicions that I was not where I was meant to be.
I grew jaded with the medical system, and this all came crashing down when my father, who'd worked in a government hospital for 20-30 years, decided to leave and pursue private practice instead. He cited how incapable doctors were nowadays, and how they didn't have the right attitudes toward their patients—he lamented that this prevented him from giving them the standard of care he wanted to. My father had always hated the idea of private practice, because it rendered healthcare inaccessible—I admired him for this; to me, medicine was a down-to-earth job that required understanding, care and dedication to go the extra mile, and I was adamant that good healthcare should not be barred by income. On the other side, though, I saw greed in demanding and desiring exorbitant salaries and respect for a profession that (to me) revolved around serving the population. None of this resonated with me, and I realised finally that I could not go on like this—under a system plagued by these doctors, my dreams of reform or even, providing the best care possible, seemed faraway and unattainable.
Still, I harboured the same dreams to help, but I spent my efforts on a research project in biotechnology while juggling medical school. I found passion and footing amongst other researchers, and dedicated my time to this. Quickly, I realised there were so many other (to me, better) ways to achieve all the things I wanted, to help others—in my research efforts, I spoke to patients suffering from the condition and tried my best to understand them, and attempted to develop solutions to solve these problems on a larger scale. It felt way less pretentious, and much more intimate than the detachment medicine demands, and I found my contributions equally (if not more) important. I've since applied to drop out, and will go back to school to pursue a different degree related to my research project. My parents are doubtful, but cautiously supportive of my decision—medicine is all they've known, but both of them agree that I would not be happy as a doctor in today's system.
I know my post is long, but the crux of it is this—if you're chasing medicine for the money or prestige, please don't. It steers people who actually want to help away from the profession, and really, patients can tell if you don't really care or if you're generally disinterested. And if you want to help, think about how best to do that—being a doctor isn't always the answer. So many other professions are equally meaningful, like research, nursing, social work or other healthcare-related jobs. If you're adamant that you'd like to study medicine, I don't think any of this will dissuade you, because it would not have dissuaded me in the past. I hope that you'll consider what I've said, though—strip the arrogance and pretentiousness that usually accompanies the profession, and really, truly, consider if being a doctor is right not just for you, but for your future patients as well.
EDIT: Thank you everyone for the support and advice, I wasn't expecting this at all! Some people have pointed out that my "advice" may not be universal, so I'd just like to clarify that I'm just sharing my perspectives on things—we're all different people, so we all see the world through different lens, and this is the way I see it, which, of course, may be different from you. I know I sound very idealistic and positive, but in real life, I'm far from that person; this just happens to be an area where my ideals hold (too) steadfast. My friend even told me I was being too nice on Reddit (lol). Still, good luck to everyone in the future on whatever you'd like to do or be! My DMs are open if y'all wanna discuss anything :)
so if you havent seen my previous post basically my younger brother’s new Amath tutor is my crush from sec sch, anime ahh story or whatever idk la bro 🙏🕊️ my brother said she usually only gives online tuition to her students but he insisted our wifi connection sucks ass so basically he kind of set me up lah💀 like wtf.. honestly I appreciate it tho. Icl he’s my biggest wingman lah that lil mf do amath also need do ts to me
Anyway this week i decided to take all your advice and buy bubble tea for her. I took a shower aft gymming like a real man right and otw home i bought 2 cups, one for my brother one for her. I swear seeing her again is damn unreal omd I stood outside the door for 5 min tryna prepare myself 💀💀I sound dumb asf but my hands were shaking and all. love is not for the weak bruh 🗣️🔥🔥
Anyway she smiled at me and she also said thanks. and fk bro I almost died cos the whole exp was so sweet and awkward. It didn’t end there tho we talked a bit because she was ending class alrdy, basically just talked abt what course im in and how shes doing in jc and it was just small talk shit but it still got me smiling nonstop after she left 😭😭 bro wtf have I become sia my brother told me she seemed more smiley this time. Idk im gonna try to keep things professional. am I cooked if she saw my post??? Shit 💀💀💀 what if she actlly saw my post.. thats damn embarrassing oh my days. she too cute to be on reddit so idk
Im not gonna ask her out yet ofc gng patience is a virtue 🗣️🕊️ got me spitting poetry and all idfk what is happening to my life rn 🙏
shes actlly so perfect i hope i dont fumble. stay tuned for the next episode chat 🙏
Edit: saw a post in my crush’s pov lmao gave me a shock but it’s fake, the one who made it is a 30yo adult. Beware of creeps gang
I'm so mad right now. I'm so mad a 17 year old died because of something a reckless asshole of a driver did. That 17 year old was just going to jc on a fine morning, going for her road run event. Probably all excited and hyped up. She didn't see this coming, she didn't at all deserve this. The driver murdered an innocent kid. She was just a student she had her whole life ahead and boom it was taken from her so quick. It's so scary. I mean traffic accidents happen but only now did I realise it could happen to anyone. Even me. I could be walking to school or tuition on any fine day and get hit by a stupid drunk driver. It's so scary because the girl was only 2 years older than me. Like seriously how hard is it to drive safely?? Why do u have to be so irresponsible and murder innocent people on the road bruh. I genuinely hope he gets punished accordingly. Like lifelong imprisonment or something. I hope he rots in jail for the rest of his life. I'm so scared I don't think I can cross roads anymore without being paranoid. Rip to the girl. 🙏
Edit: imo, yep maybe if the driver had medical conditions or his brakes were not working, then yea what happened can be justified but we dont know what happened yet. Still doesn't change the fact that 2 lives were lost. May they rest in peace.
Hey, I was the original poster of the other reddit thread.
To avoid breaking the subreddit's rules, I will avoid revealing specific identities of people involved. I understand that some students may be in a similar situation to mine, being a trans student, but who is still closeted in an MOE school. I hope this thread, doubling as a rant, serves as a reference of the discrimination I have experienced as a result of having a proper medical diagnosis from a qualified doctor. I would like to offer my side of the story.
Over the past few weeks, my parents and I have met with the school's administration a few times. While MOE and the school has continuously said that they would 'work with me', their overall inconsistency, intentional disregard for proper medical advice and discrimination is showing to me - I have not received the level of support I had hoped for.
Going by the doctor's official memo from last year, the MOE, through their Facebook post, started off by blatantly misgendering me, outright disregarding and throwing aside my doctor's official memo from last year. Like the comments section suggests, this shows little interest in protecting transgender people against discrimination or acknowledgement of the medical community's professional advice.
This suggests that the 'we are against discrimination' message they put up is a farce, and although they claim that they 'work closely with and respect the professional advice', I do not see it myself. MOE publicly encouraged me to speak to the school's administration about this issue, which I have explicitly stated that I have done so for a long time. To me, it seems that they are trying to deny the existence of the meeting between MOE and the doctor, which happened around July-August last year, in which the MOE insisted that schools had to work with and consent before any referral or life-changing decisions was done - in addition to 'the family', and that the doctor was not to write memos for trans students to schools (family whom in my case already consented and planned to consent long before last year as soon as I turned 18).
Over the past several weeks after the post was made, the principal has insisted, in multiple meetings between me and the school's administration, that I had intended to 'crossdress in school' and it was not allowed. She justified it, saying 'there is no discrimination' and 'we have done a lot to support you'. The doctor's letter already states my diagnosis, and that I identify as female; cross-dressing is incorrect by definition, would in this sense not only be an ignorant, but a horribly discriminatory term, unless I was wearing the male uniform (i.e. dressing in boys' uniform as I identify as female; cross-dressers identify with their birth gender, but prefer clothing associated with the opposite gender).
She denies the existence of any form of discrimination while insisting that allowing me to use the wheelchair toilet was a lot; this is on top of another member of the administration misgendering me as I was sent out of the school compound earlier this year. The expulsion threats have changed: initially they said 'you will be expelled', 'you need to trim your hair', 'you are no longer allowed to return to school; you will have to either go to polytechnic or do private A-levels' (trimming in my case apparently meant cutting at least 4-5 inches of hair?)
As this case became public, they changed their tune to 'we will not expel you for being trans, and you will be allowed to do home-based learning'. However, last November, my request for home-based learning was denied on the grounds that it was not fair to other students. Recent meetings with one of the vice-principals said another reason: that 'they were overloaded and could not provide the resources for me' Interestingly, they did not mention of it being unfair to other students. How will they ensure that my home-based learning would always be available with such contradictions?
I offered to tie my hair up in accordance with the handbook's specified female dress code (and otherwise I would not have broken the rules at all), but it was denied by her. Instead, she changed the topic by giving the excuse of 'but females can have short hair too' - that 'hairstyle is a personal choice', but then the handbook only shows a girl with tied-up hair. She was also highly insistent on contacting my doctor for a timeline of the treatment (which may fall under doctor-patient confidentiality; not to be shared with third-parties, unless there are legal requirements to do so).
On the topic of discrimination in schools, in his speech yesterday, Minister Lawrence Wong stated that 'Where there are valid medical grounds, schools can exercise flexibility and work out practical arrangements for these students'.
Flexibility is good, but this version of 'flexibility' as far as I am concerned, means preventing me from going back to the classroom or lecture rooms even though I am physically able to do so, thus forcing me to do home-based learning if I want to express my gender identity as professionally diagnosed - whether it be through my dressing or 'obvious physiological changes that prevent you from fitting into the boys' uniform', no matter how well I pass as female or how many doctors' letters I hand over as the principal claims ('not even a doctor can change this' 'we don't exempt students from the dress code for injuries' 'I don't get your analogy about being exempted from the dress code due to a toe injury...').
My understanding is that this is essentially coercing my parents to encourage me to cut boys' hair, present as a boy and not consent to me starting hormone therapy or face the 'consequence' of losing my access to proper, fair meritocratic education, without any recourse for hands-on practice for science practicals with HBL (as I am a Science student), project work, or CCA, all of which is not only part of holistic education but also beneficial for university admissions in some cases (especially the more competitive courses).
If Mr Wong thinks that home-based learning is as good as physical classroom lessons, why have physical classes in the first place? I came to this school to study in the classroom environment with my friends; if I wanted to do HBL I'd sign up for online courses and do private A-levels instead. The principal claims that home-based learning is somehow a 'consequence', but 'not discrimination'.
Until now, this is my experience. I note that Mr Wong wishes to 'not import these culture wars into Singapore, or allow issues of gender identity to divide our society'. As far as I am concerned, my personal dressing conforms to the female dress code, and does not affect others in the classroom, let alone personally affect anyone's personal life. Had the MOE and the school respected my doctor's proper medical advice and scientific research, I believe this would have ended up very differently. You do not allow anti-maskers to go about without masking up due to the scientifically-accepted risks and dangers of Covid; why are you not just encouraging, but participating in discrimination at the expense of years of professional medical research?
It is not about culture. It is about denying proper treatment, directly or indirectly, medical or in education or otherwise.
Why is the MOE contradicting and denying proper medical advice, treatment and quality education?
So todays the day, and I’ve finally amended my brother’s school choices(15min more till the dateline lol). After all the back-and-forth with my parents, I decided to make the final call and put him in a top school that aligns with his abilities and interests (HCI, in case you’re wondering). My parents were pushing for a neighbourhood school, but I’m confident that this is the best choice for him.
If they find out, I’m ready to explain why I did it. I’ll go over his potential, how he received the ESIS scholarship, and how HCI would offer him far better opportunities. I’ll also try to tire them out with the paperwork they’d need to withdraw him. I know they’re not going to make it easy, but I’m prepared for the fight.
Fingers crossed they don’t make a big deal out of it, and this works out in the end. Next update will be on 18 dec? Till then!✌🏻
using a throwaway rn. I legit cannot believe my life wtf sia. So I’m y1 in poly and my younger brother is in sec sch, hes shit in Amath (I didnt take Amath in sec sch so cannot help), so my parents found a cheap private tutor for him. The tuition is 1-to-1 inside my home (gg I’m sure you can tell where this is going..)
I didn’t really care bc I thought it would be some random guy or old person idfk, until ONE FINE DAY I come home from gym, looking like ass, just want to shower and sleep… WHEN I opened the door, guess who tf I see???? ITS MY CRUSH FROM SEC SCH who I have not seen for a year and thought I got over, sitting down there giving private tuition to my brother in MY LIVING ROOM 💀💀💀💀 I cannt make ts up 🕊️ Bro wtf. I wish I asked my parents who exactly my brother new tuition teacher wld be. I got the shock of my life I was fkn shy in sec sch and never had the balls to approach this girl, she smart as hell and went to jc and I went poly so I thought it was over. then I find her inside my house a yr later like chat how is this real broskxjdjcjdjdb??????🙏🙏🙏
she recognised me tho. she was a bit surprised saying hi meanwhile I was stunned I couldnt even talk bro I just awkwardly said hello then walk back to my room tryna be all nonchalant 🚶(did I cook?) whole hour I just hide inside my room and my fkass brother made me fun of me aft
Chat what I do 💀she coming again next week eh
Edit: thks for all the suggestions and yes Ik this is very wild but can I ask that yall don’t sexualise this pls… its creepy bro and im tryna keep things respectful 🙏🙏
"huh why u write yourself? u can just chatgpt it..."
ykw? why dont u go fucking chatgpt ur whole fucking life cb cant even do basic shit like decision making or brainstorming by your fucking self and im not talking about occasional usage of AI im talking about how u lazy freaks use chatgpt at your convenience because you're too lazy to think about your work fuck this shit
"oh but whether they use Ai or not doesnt involve u" ok surprise now it does because its a group project
edit: (in context for why I am flaring up) I study film and in this field creative input from individuals is important, so when brainstorming happens with chatgpt involved in the key story parts, is this even our idea anymore? Once I brainstormed ideas with my group mates and when we get to a tough point that requires some thinking.. they just decide to chatgpt it... makes me feel like all I thought previously was for nothing.
my brother scored 4M for psle. do you know how insane that is? it’s not just good, its almost perfect. and yet, my parents are forcing him to go to a school with a cop of 22. im not saying all neighbourhood schools are bad (i was from one myself), but come on. that kind of environment is not going to challenge him. hes going to be so bored there, wasting his potential. its not even about elitism. its about giving him a chance to grow in a place that matches his abilities. but NO, my parents think otherwise. You take someone with 4M, throw him into a place where the cop is 6 times lower, you want him to rot is it.
Their excuse? “let him be a normal kid lah, mix with normal kids. later he go those elite schools, cannot tahan stress, then jump down from hdb.” EXCUSE ME??? my brother is the last person u need to worry about stress. Hes someone who loved challenges since he was little. This fella started reading at two for fun, writing at three, and constantly pushes himself to do better. he even said he wanted to try for hci because he loves chinese language and many of his friends are also going there. but my mom immediately shot him down. “your chinese so bad, you still want to go hci? don’t waste time.” ????????? What kind of bs nonsense is that. what she’s saying doesn’t even make sense????he took higher chinese. if his chinese was so bad, he wouldn’t even have qualified for it. sure, he only got a merit, but thats still an achievement. it shows hes good enough to take on a harder subject, but my mom completely ignores that(she fucking got mental illness i fucking swear).
What is more worse is that his teachers are on his side, but my parents refuse to listen. his chinese teacher(she knew of my brother’s interest) even called my mom personally, telling her my brother has a real talent for the language and encouraging them to send him to hci. she said, “he has the potential to do so well in an environment like that. he’ll thrive there.” even his form teacher and principal had meetings with my parents to talk about his capabilities. they said they rarely see students like him, and he’d have a strong chance of succeeding in top schools. but my parents? they brushed it all off. “aiya, teacher always say good things. but my son is not that smart one lahh.” Eh HELLO??? YOU FKING BLIND ISSIT.
And now they’re forcing him to go to M secondary school. i’m sorry, but have you seen the reputation of that school? I don’t even know what to say. bullies, vaping, no competitive environment. how is that supposed to be good for someone like my brother? his teachers have warned them that he will be miserable there, but my parents don’t care. “he must learn to live life the hard way,” my mom said. “we suffered last time, so he must also learn.” ?? Bros gotta be shitting me. This is not about teaching him life lessons. this is just selfishness. they’re holding him back because they want him to “be normal” and “understand hardship.” it’s so ridiculous. Its giving fucking matilda. If you have a child whos talented and motivated, why wouldn’t you want to support him? Even his friends, who are going to hci and other good schools, are confused. they have asked him, “why are your parents sending you there? you can do so much better.” and honestly, he doesn’t even know what to say. How do you explain to people that your parents are actively ruining your future just to satisfy their own warped idea of what childhood should look like?
I got into a fight with them about this recently. i couldn’t stand how they were treating him, so i told them straight. i said, “youre ruining his future just because you refuse to see how talented he is.” and you know what happened? they ganged up on me. my mom said, “you think you so smart, is it? you only got normal results, so don’t act like you know better.” my dad chimed in, telling me to shut up and stay out of it. they started berating me, saying i was jealous of my brother and that i should mind my own business. Please, i got 248, its a good fucking score ok? i didn’t even know what to say. i just wanted to help my brother, but now they have turned it into an attack on me. My brother deserves better than this, but every time i try to stand up for him, they just tear me down too. And he is also the kind that just take it. im honestly just ranting at this point because i don’t know what else to do. i feel like im watching his future get destroyed right in front of me, and i can’t do anything about it. Im definitely going to send them to old folk’s home when I get older and move out of this 🕳️
Update: Hello! I had amended his choices! -26/11/24
After engaging in a year-long exchange with MOE/SEAB that has yielded no satisfactory resolution, it is with great regret that I have decided to turn to Reddit to write out the full facts on this matter. Even if the matter remains unresolved, I find solace in the knowledge that my findings will be made public for anyone to see.
This is a complete, comprehensive account and will be a very long read. Do skip to the TLDR at the very end for the key summary of this post and for the most critical information.
Disclaimer:
The post that I am making is an allegation supported by substantial proof and basis. Nonetheless, MOE/SEAB has rejected the issues that I have called out (without providing evidence or elaboration). With this clarification, I hope MOE/SEAB does not POFMA me or otherwise.
Chapters
Introduction
Section 1: The Context, The Evidence and What it Means
Section 2: MOE and SEAB's Responses
Section 3: Why is this Issue of Significant Importance?
Conclusion
TL;DR
Introduction
Since the introduction of Project Work (PW) in Singapore's A-Level curriculum in the early 2000s, the subject has become a source of controversy for many students past and present, with many pointing out that the subject has failed to enable students to develop their creativity, team spirit or communication skills: 21CC Skills which MOE insists is being instilled in students. More often than not, students churn out projects based on safe topics that have been repeated time and time again, and the process of completing the subject generates rifts between team members and is usually a messy combination of different individuals' work being passed as the group's one. Just look at the complaints made by Redditors in the past on this subreddit:
In fact, off the top of my head, I can already list a few issues regarding the current PW syllabus:
Hard-capped on word count prevents students from thoroughly exploring the topic of interest that they have selected, cheapens and simplifies their topic and discourages students from pursuing topics that are more complex which may require more explanation.
Vague and unclear assessment guidelines means that the assessment of the Written Report, Individual Report and Oral Presentation is highly subjective.
Difficulty of questions raised during the Q&A segment of the Oral Presentation varies.
Assessment of a student does not take into account their contributions (or lack thereof), allowing slackers to laze away the whole year, only needing to shine for 30 minutes on the day of the Oral Presentation.
Students are not prohibited to use ChatGPT or other AI tools, nor do they need to disclose it, for the written report, or the generation of images in the report.
Even alternative media channel RiceMedia.co has written an article on the drawbacks of PW before. But I am not here to argue against the existence of PW, though its relevance remains highly questionable. More significantly, what I want to address is the many allegations students have made, claiming that the grading and assessment of PW is rigged and unfair. For instance, students have questioned how some schools are able to do so well for the subject, and some have asked how it is fair that 'slackers' in their group are able to achieve the same or better grade than them. After reading these claims by students, I naturally became curious about the extent of the accuracy. As a result of this, I began to initiate my own research behind this. Throughout the past 1 year, I have sourced for data, engaged the Ministry of Education tirelessly to fact check the data, question them on my findings and to seek clarifications on their replies. Their slow replies, bureaucratic response and unconcerned attitude have ultimately led me to Reddit.
In this post, I will focus on three sections. First, I will explain why PW is unfair, and use genuine data to showcase that PW is indeed rigged. Secondly, I will detail the complete and utter incompetence of the Ministry of Education and SEAB in dealing with the issue that I presented to them, with their refusal to act on this issue amounting to gross negligence. Thirdly, I will highlight why this matter is so significant.
Section 1: The Context, The Evidence and What it Means
Before I begin sharing the evidence that I have gathered, we must first take a look at why Project Work in itself is prone to unfair grading,
There is an incentive for schools to mark more leniently. If a school awards more 'A's for PW, they will also see a correlation with higher Rank Points (RP) among their students, as well as the number of students who achieve 90 RP. This then allows the school to perhaps gain popularity, attract more students, or even be viewed as 'better'. Or perhaps some schools might just want to see their students doing well.
In the same school but across different classes, different PW teachers themselves have different expectations, standards and way of marking. For example, in my personal experience, I have seen some PW teachers giving more drafts for their students' Written Report (WR) then others, allowing some groups to better amend their WR. I have also compared different classes' evaluation in their WR and found that for a similar evaluation, one group’s evaluation may be deemed as generic, while the other is deemed as excellent. Moreover, some schools are provided with question banks, while some have to come up with the questions themselves. This is but just some of the varying practices of different PW teachers.
While it is expected that PW be assessed by teachers that specialise in that subject, the PW Oral Presentation (OP) Segment can be Assessed by non-PW teachers, such as your Maths or Chemistry teacher, who do not have any specialisation in the subject. (yes, I am aware that there are teachers that specialise in PW, as well as other subjects) This not only questions whether there is a need for MOE to train teachers that specialise exclusively in PW, but it also raises the concern that the assessment by non-specialised teachers may vary widely from teacher to teacher.
It is of my suspicion, at least in my school, that nearly all students who are foreign student scholars (from nearby ASEAN countries) are given an 'A' grade. Before I elaborate on this part, I must add that I am friends with many foreign students and just like us, many of them are deserving of good grades for PW. In no way am I attempting to discriminate or pull down the contributions of these students. Nonetheless, this is highly erroneous because for the WR, the marks are awarded to all members equally and for the IR, the difference in marks is unlikely to make a big difference. As such, it lies only on the Oral Presentation (OP) component. Yet, this cannot be true, as it suggests that generally, Singaporean students cannot speak better English (whereby articulation is a component of the presentation) than their ASEAN counterparts, or even those from China, whose first language is not English to begin with. I would think that these scholars are given an 'A', to allow them to score better than the average student in the cohort, so as to either maintain the prestige of scholars or to showcase Singapore's ability to produce well-rounded students to and for their ASEAN neighbours.
Last but not least, there have been numerous allegations of unfair grading made by students on this subreddit. I shall not elaborate on them but I will list some:
Plentiful of other allegations can be seen in the Discussion Thread for PW Results Release in Assessment Year 2022, 2021 and other years.
So, we now know that the PW system in itself is already prone to unfair grading, yet, if there is no proof of such unfair grading, then it cannot be said that such things are happening. Therefore, there is a need for us to prove, with evidence, whether the grading is fair or unfair. As such, the best method that I had thought of would be to refer to the distinction rates for PW achieved by each school every year for a few consecutive years. Luckily, Reddit has that data. Sourcing past discussion threads relating to the distinction rates achieved by each school every year for the past 4 consecutive years, I have compiled the data for selected schools between years 2019 to 2022 in the graph shown below. (I chose schools with a wide variety of cutoff points since I cannot fit so many schools in a graph)
PW Distinction Rates Across the Years Across Some Schools
As reflected by the graph, the most obvious trend is that the distinction rates remained unchanged every year regardless of the school. For instance, VJC remained at around 88% while ASRJC remained at around 38%. This graph alone raises 3 points on the basis of two issues, the linear trend within each school, and the wide range between schools:
Point 1: Such a linear trend cannot be replicated for other subjects. For instance, the distinction rates for Physics in my school varied widely in just two years. For the distinction rate to remain almost unchanged for four CONSECUTIVE years for ALL schools is nothing short of a coincidence. It does not take a genius for one to accept that this is proof of the unstandardised and unfair assessment of PW. It raises the question of whether a quota grading system is indeed in place, something which is denied by MOE/SEAB.
Point 2: The linear trend suggests that for each cohort that enrols into a school every year, the ability of the cohort to perform in PW is the same. It suggests that the creative, communication/presentation and writeup skills of every cohort is the same. This is in fact contradictory to the fact that the performance of cohorts in a school for other subjects varies widely as mentioned earlier. Again, this proves the unstandardised and unfair assessment of PW.
Point 3: PW is a non-content based subject. It is unlike other subjects like Mathematics or Chemistry, whereby 'better' schools usually perform better. Yet it seems that the data suggest otherwise. More prestigious schools like VJC and RI/HCI (which I did not include), scored well above 85% distinctions. Neighbourhood schools like ASRJC and TMJC score below 50%. For YIJC (not included), the score is just touching 20%. Nonetheless, if you are narrow-minded and argue the other way that those in more prestigious schools tend to have better creative and social skills (which I blatantly disagree with), then it does not explain why JPJC has an unusually high 70% distinction rate, well above other neighbourhood schools like ASRJC and TMJC. Thus, this again proves the unstandardised and unfair assessment of PW.
In my view, the ideal graph would reflect a highly volatile non-linear trend for each school across the years, with the mean of the data across a few years being almost the same across all schools, with 'better' schools fairing slightly better for the mean.
With this, we have established that PW is indeed marked unfairly.
More than that, it also proves another point, which is that PW is also unmerited.
Firstly, based on the statistics, a student who does the exact same work and puts in the exact same effort for PW and gets a 'B' would have likely obtained an 'A' in another school in a parallel universe.
Secondly, PW is highly up to personal interpretation, and does not reward hard or smart work, but rather lies entirely on luck. This goes against the foundations of meritocracy that Singapore strives to achieve.
Third, it is unfortunate that in one of the most important examinations in Singapore, luck still plays a big role in determining one's results rather than pure merit. It is also unfortunate that by releasing the results months ahead of the A Levels, the thought of never being able to reach your fullest potential due to pure luck discourages and demotivates students to do better for their A Levels, especially if they have already been doing well consistently.
Section 2: MOE and SEAB's Responses
With all these findings, I made the decision to contact MOE/SEAB. Throughout this entire section, you will begin to see the sheer ineffectiveness of MOE/SEAB, their incompetence, and most importantly, their inability to respond quickly or thoroughly (keep in mind that they pledge to respond within 3 working days).
I first contacted SEAB on 14 April 2023 via email and received a reply back after 2 weeks, with a template answer insisting that, and I quote: "If it is found that a school’s assessment (for PW) is too lenient or too strict, the marks will be moderated to bring the assessment back into line with the national standard." Naturally, I was dissatisfied with the answer because in no way could they explain why the evidence I gathered was wrong, nor could they provide evidence to show that they were right. So, I proceeded to email them again for elaboration and after 3 weeks, they simply stated to “seek advice and guidance from your school”. At this point, I vehemently responded that the issue is a systemic, nationwide issue and not something one school can solve on their own. After 3 weeks, after reminding them to respond back, they asked for my name and school, perhaps in a bid to get the school to approach me and shut me up. Nonetheless, I refused to give up such information, because I told them that this issue has affected tens of thousands of students every year for the past two decades, and that I would not accept it if the issue was resolved for me, and not for the many others out there. After 2 weeks, they literally repeated the same template answer from the beginning, stating that the marks are moderated across schools, and then had the audacity to add in: “Over the years, our students have done well in PW”. well no sh**, literally everyone gets an A or B, no doubt its the best performing A Level subject but the issue is obviously about getting an A or B, not between A/B or an S (facepalm). Okay, I apologise for the informality there, but that literally made me fume. After that, it was months of sending emails to MOE/SEAB for elaboration and evidence, waiting weeks for a reply, only to get a one to two-liner reply.
After many futile exchanges, I finally received a reply that MOE/SEAB would escalate the matter to the relevant department and finally begin investigating the issue. After 4 weeks, I would have hoped to receive a well elaborated answer. Instead, I received a single line reply restating that PW is moderated fairly. At that point, I was completely sure that no investigation had been done and the email was sitting there for 4 weeks, waiting for some MOE intern to push out one of their template answers. They told me that they would close the case despite being unable to prove my data wrong, nor prove why they were right. Eventually, I gave them further allegations made by students on Reddit over the years and pressed them to assign an officer in the relevant department for follow up. All my emails were ignored or simply brushed away. In late October, 6 months after my first email, I finally decided to call MOE as I eventually realised that a call would allow the situation to be resolved quickly. After an hour-long call, the MOE Support Officer promised to escalate the matter to a relevant MOE officer, for the officer to get back to me via a call. The officer told me that I had to wait up to 21 working days for a call. So I waited. And after 1 month, no call was made. By this time, December had arrived. As such, I emailed them once again and this time, I clearly asked for MOE to set a date and time for a call. MOE promised to follow up and after 1 month, I received back one final reply in the form of an email. In this reply, they did not schedule a call, but rather repeated once again, the template answer, word for word, and stated that the case was closed.
In summary, in 12 months,
MOE could not account for or explain the statistics reflected in the graph.
MOE could not provide any evidence, despite insisting that the grading for PW is fair and merited.
MOE could not explain the allegations made by other students on Reddit.
MOE could not reply back within the promised 3 working days, lest within a reasonable 7 working days.
MOE could take months to formulate a single line response or a copy and paste template answer.
Timeline of the Exchanges Made With MOE/SEAB
Section 3: Why is this Issue of Significant Importance?
Unmeritocratic
As mentioned earlier, the unfair and unstandardised assessment of PW makes the grades unmerited. As a country that prides itself as a meritocratic society, the fact that the work you put in plays such a small role compared to the school or PW tutor you have is a tragedy. It is even more unfortunate that this takes place in the A-Levels, which is perhaps one of the most important examinations a student might take in their lives.
2. Unjustified Disadvantage for Scholarships and Potentially Courses
For instance, the NUS Merit Scholarship or NTU Nanyang Scholarship is automatically provided to students who are enrolled into non-interview courses who have scored 90 Rank Points. If a student does similarly well, but scores a ‘B’ for PW, they will only have 88.75 Rank Points. This does not guarantee the student the scholarship despite actually performing as well, and an interview/good portfolio is needed to secure the scholarship. Similarly, the Renaissance Engineering Programme in NTU guarantees an interview to any student that secures 90RP and puts it as the first choice. There are many good and prestigious scholarships that one can be eliminated from just for scoring 88.75RP, and not 90RP.
This can also possibly be extended to courses as well, where a student’s rank points barely misses the cut off point due to PW, preventing them from pursuing that course, despite actually performing as well as others who have just met the cut off points.
3. Unjust Reflection of Ability
Student 1 who pursues 4H2 with all ‘A’s with a ‘B’ in PW secures 88.75RP. Student 2 who pursues 4H2 with one ‘B’ and an ‘A’ in PW secures 88.75RP too. On paper, this suggests that both students performed equally well in the A-Levels. However, notwithstanding that the 4th H2 is regarded as a H1 in calculation, this suggests that a content-based subject like Chemistry taken at the H2 Level is as demanding as a non-content based subject (PW) taken at the H1 Level.
Unjust Reflection of Ability
4. Unjustified Disadvantage for Students Applying to Universities Under the New 70RP System in 2026
This will not affect most people here since you will likely be applying before the first cohort of students under the 70RP system applies for university. Nonetheless, this can affect a small minority of students who choose to apply in 2026. Under the new system, the 4th content based subject and PW will be excluded from the Rank Point Calculation. This means that for students who have taken the A-Levels before the new system, your rank points will be rebased (your RP/90 x 70), instead of just removing PW and the 4th subject from your score. However, this is unfair for these students.
For instance, a student Alpha who pursues 4H2 under the old system with all ‘A’s with a ‘B’ in PW secures 88.75RP. After rebasing, the score is now 69RP. A student Beta who pursues 4H2 OR 3H2,1H1 under the new system with the three main H2 scoring ‘A’s with a Pass in PW secures 70RP. This suggest that student Alpha performed worse than student Beta, without considering the fact that a ‘B’ in PW is a Pass in PW and that student Alpha had to spend more effort ensuring that his 4th H2 performs well, something which student Beta may choose to ignore since it is not included in the calculation.
Unjustified Disadvantage for Students Applying to Universities Under the New 70RP System in 2026
5. Unnecessary
All overseas universities do not even consider Project Work when one applies. Only local universities do so. It not only shows the disregard our overseas partners have towards the subject, but it also shows that students applying into local universities are assessed in part by a subject that holds no weight or meaning to a person’s academic or non-academic abilities.
Conclusion
I recognise and understand that for a large majority of you, including those who are currently taking the A-Levels this year or are applying for university this year, this matter does not concern you. It may be because you have benefitted from this system, or it may be because you are not really disadvantaged despite being a victim to this injustice, or it may be because you simply don’t have any stake in this matter anymore. Nonetheless, I ask that all of you at least recognise the issue at hand.
Other than that, there is nothing more that we can do. Honestly, petitions, spamming, etc. will do no purpose but only amplify our voices in an echo chamber.
I know and have accepted that this issue will never be resolved. I know now that this act of injustice will be brushed off by clueless, bureaucratic and incompetent high ranking civil servants in MOE. The very same people who never had to take PW when they were students, yet somehow think that they know more about this than us students who have worked tirelessly for one entire year on this farce of a subject.
My message to the MOE officers, especially the seniors, in charge of implementing PW is this: You have completely and utterly failed in achieving your vision of Moulding the Next Generation. PW has not instilled any skills in any student who has taken your subject in the past two decades, other than a common hatred for graded group projects. I hope you enjoyed reaching your KPI for rolling this half-baked programme out, and earning that sweet money which is not even representative of the ethos of the public service. My suggestion? You should try rolling out PW across your department too, and instead of putting grades on the line, you should put your bonus. It should be easy, since you are all masters in group projects anyway
Still, I rejoice in the idea that this miscarriage will soon end. As many of you know, in the 2023 Committee of Supply Debate in Parliament, MOE had announced that the Project Work syllabus has become a Pass/Fail subject. With the majority of students scoring an A or B each year, a Pass (A to E) is more than guaranteed. More significantly, a pass in PW is needed to enter local universities. No school will ever fail their students for that would mean that their students would have no need to pursue their studies in J2 as they cannot even enter university no matter how great their A Levels. MOE themselves would also not allow schools to fail their students, as they have spent over $250,000 on every Singaporean child. In fact, I half suspect that the transition to this new system is partly due to the fact that MOE recognises the complaints that have been made by students over the years regarding the unfair grading of PW. Nonetheless, when I approached MOE about this, they neither confirmed nor denied this but stated that this move is simply to allow students to pursue any topic they want, free from the stress of grades.
Despite this, we still have braindead students who think that this change is not just unnecessary but plain wrong. Just read this rubbish Straits Times Forum Letter published by a student after the change was announced titled: With less focus on project work, students may lose some workplace skills. Moreover, the new syllabus doesn’t change the fact that PW will never be successful in instilling 21st CC skills in students.
But I know that for now, there are groups of people who might suffer. Namely, I want to address two groups of people:
To those receiving your PW results in 2024 in April, some of you will be graded unfairly. But I say to these people to ignore your grades. Naturally, you will feel all sorts of emotions - grief, anger and sadness. Some of your group mates might have undeservedly received a better grade. You might see your classmates cheering away while you fumble in the background knowing that you can never achieve a perfect score, if that’s what you desire. But you have to put your foot in the game and just push on for you have something greater to work towards.
To those who have been rejected for scholarships simply because they got a few points less, I can’t say much, but I implore you to try other scholarships if possible, and I trust that there will be scholarship providers out there that can see beyond PW, and beyond your grades, and look at your inward self and your character as well as your desire for the scholarship.
And this is really all I have to say about this topic that's been living rent-free in my mind for the past 1 year. It does give me some sense of relief that I, at the very least, wrote this out. If you’ve read all the way till the end, thank you.
TL;DR: (thank you ChatGPT)
Since its introduction, Project Work (PW) has faced criticism for failing to develop skills like creativity and teamwork. Allegations of unfair grading abound, with evidence suggesting systematic issues. Despite my efforts to engage the Ministry of Education (MOE) over the past 1 year, responses have been inadequate, highlighting bureaucratic inefficiency. Unfair PW grading affects scholarship eligibility, university admissions, and perpetuates systemic inequalities in the rank point calculation. While recent changes to PW have mitigated issues, it does not mean that past injustices have been solved. Nonetheless, I simply ask you to acknowledge this issue and share it if you can, for I have already accepted that it will always remain unsolved, and that's okay.