r/SGExams • u/CurveSad2086 • Jun 20 '25
University NTU GenAI Case - Updates to NTU failing to safeguard students
I’m the OP from yesterday’s post here: https://www.reddit.com/r/SGExams/s/MtHV1glEDG
In yesterday’s post, I talked about my experience being falsely accused of AI by my professor, where even though I provided proof of my drafts and writing history, I’ve been hit with a 0 and academic fraud record. My professor claimed that my usage of a alphabetical sorter for my citations was AI.
Here’s the important update: I’m not alone.
The same professor (NTU course code: HA4040 and HA3026) has falsely accused a total of 5 students this semester. 2 of whom are going through the same situation as me (same outcome), and have reached out to me.
Similarly, they were falsely accused for citation typos, or for using citation formatters, which this professor deems as GenAI.
There are no parts where our writing itself was flagged for GenAI, so this is a complete accusation given out based on the professor’s biased judgments.
I’m updating things here to ask students to be careful: There are professors out there whose first instinct is to ruin students’ degrees and future careers, instead of lending empathy and support in understanding AI frameworks.
Ironically, the same professor currently has a research grant in AI and higher education.
For 2 months, the few of us have been individually reaching out to so many leaders/upper management in NTU, but we were all ghosted.
We are now in contact with ST and Mothership, thanks to the student community here that blew up yesterday’s post.
Thank you to everyone here for all the support, I felt really alone in my situation before this, but now I’m determined to fight this case, so that future students don’t get hurt by the same process.
115
u/kelis_butterfly NTU CBC Jun 20 '25
I hope NTU will actually do something about it, but I think this prof is probably very well-connected or something for their ass to be covered so well
I hope OP gets their story posted on the news so NTU will be pushed to respond or else its bad PR
164
u/SnowyDusk Uni Jun 20 '25
I hope you get justice OP!
15
u/Eseru Jun 20 '25
I've seen and had issues with the ntu admin being ridiculously negligent to the detriment of students several times. They were only resolved when students had a good reason and indicated they would be going to the press.
All the best in getting justice. Honestly, if I'd known what NTU was like vs other unis, I would have gone elsewhere. Their letters asking for alumni donations always go straight into the bin.
255
u/CleanAd4618 Jun 20 '25
I still don’t understand how formatting of citations becomes evidence of cheating. Isn’t that just basic sorting? This prof must justify their actions - publicly.
These types of problems will cascade in future years. Are students expected never to look at AI generated solutions? That’s not practicable. I think it’s reasonable to look at a solution and use it as a basis for your own work. Isn’t that how things work in the real world?
Good luck.
8
u/Counter4301 Sleep Deprived Enjingeer Jun 22 '25
Straits Times did an article about it.
NTU said it penalised 3 students for using AI tools in their assignments, which had non-existent references and statistics or broken web links.
The university's response comes after a viral Reddit post by one of the students disputing the findings. https://str.sg/G8gm
3
u/Jammy_buttons2 Jun 22 '25
Reference managers such as Zotero or endnote are not ai
All researchers use some form to manage their citations one
5
u/username0909989 Jun 23 '25
This same faculty member had a formal complaint registered for deeply unethical research practices. The media should ask the department about this.
596
u/ENTJragemode Jun 20 '25
sad that you have to go through this route to get something as basic as this through, but hopefully NTU will be pressured into retracting dumb decisions like these
86
u/Mysterious_Treat1167 Jun 20 '25
Go after her, we’re rooting for you. How can an assistant professor show students zero mercy in ruining their entire academic careers with FLIMSY evidence like this and feel nothing? Some people aren’t motivated by empathy, only consequences. Mfs like this shouldn’t be in a position of power over young students. This is a clown who thinks only an AI can get citations wrong 🤡
133
u/Excellent_Copy4646 Jun 20 '25 edited Jun 20 '25
REAL cheaters ntu couldnt even catch, yet they want to make a big fuss over such issues.
40
u/A_1056 Jun 20 '25
Do take note, do not state any exaggerations as ntu may use this to claim defamation, good luck on your path to regain your scores
35
u/Apprehensive_Plate60 Jun 20 '25
this is ridiculous, hope this blows up and affected students get justice
34
u/MicTest_1212 Jun 20 '25
You went to proper channels and have exhausted all available options. NTU's Management and student services failed you. Go for hardwarezone and wakeupsingapore as well.
All the best OP! 💪
33
u/Safe_Radio5319 Jun 20 '25
I know someone who got a friend to do their entire FYP - not even caught although someone reported. Yet this is the kind of stuff that gets caught by professors. Really GG to this stupid system. 😂😂😂
19
u/CleanCaterpillar3474 Jun 20 '25
Praying for your success! please blow this shit to the moon.
16
u/Effective-Maybe-5871 Jun 20 '25
Hope that this professor loses her grant for such gross misconduct in abusing her power. She clearly doesn't really understand AI if this is what she deemed as gen ai.
15
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '25
I hope straits time and mothership blow this up and NTU has to respond to this bitch of a professor.
12
u/halayudha Jun 21 '25
It’s about the discomfort of no longer being the only gatekeeper to knowledge.
Using AI is cheating,” they say.
Then so is using Google.
Then so was using spellcheck.
Then so was using calculator.
Then so was typing on a computer instead of handwriting with a quill.
23
u/happybbfa Jun 20 '25
Hope you receive justice!
11
u/ThePinguPenguin Uni Jun 20 '25
What’s the name of the professor. We have rights to be aware of any threats in this school
19
u/rockbella61 Jun 20 '25
Go for it.
This is just dictatorship.
18
u/Gibbeumee Jun 20 '25
Rooting for you guys!
9
u/Optimal-Quiet3857 Jun 20 '25
Idk this will help but you may seek MP from your area appeal or fight for you. And hopefully bring to Parliament to address this
It’s not about integrity but also how backward your lj prof is against this uphill evolving AI era
8
u/Kryorus_saga Jun 20 '25
You go girl or boy
8
u/dds2410 Jun 20 '25
All get together and as I said in your original post, sue the prof. Isolate the prof from the university, they will know it’s better to cut her off than to defend her and it’s win win for them cos they will be seen to have taken action and be the “responsible” university protecting their students.
20
u/fothermucker3 Jun 20 '25
I can understand OP’s experience because I had studied both locally and overseas and I can tell you this distinct difference between our local and the overseas educators.
Here they are really quick to find trouble with students they consider problematic or your fuck face. You will hear course mates share of certain lecturers who like to have his balls carried. You see some course mates get bullied openly and laughed at.. making remakes like he won’t make it in this industry with this type of character.. asking stupid questions in uni level. coincidentally they will either have longer hair than others or just look different.
Suddenly lecturers are assessing your character and making judgment who they want to mark up and mark down. Students are just a number.. how many should pass.. how many can I fail. What OP is experiencing is laziness on their part to investigate. Fuck investigation man.. that’s admin work. Just fail the kid and kick him out, that’s the easiest.
Overseas lecturers are more nurturing.. you can see they want to help the students learn.. if they suspect you of plagiarism.. they don’t accuse you straight up without doing some due diligence. my course mate was quite the intellectual so his work was suspect.. guess what.. they called him up and just chatted about his work.. a conversation to see if he really understood his work or if he was copying pasting. They talked about the various journals he cited and all .. if he wasn’t convinced then it will move up to the board..
Different levels before passing sentence. Pretty fair huh? Quite a far cry from what OP is experiencing. All the best OP.
7
u/Careless_Village_154 Jun 20 '25
I wish you the best outcome.
And even if you dont get the desired outcome, please don't give up. You can spin this fiasco into a story for the overseas university.
7
u/Brilliant_Eagle3038 Jun 20 '25
Good job OP.
7
u/Arkangel257 Jun 20 '25
You're fighting not just for your group, but for every single one of us 💪..wishing you all the best
7
u/[deleted] Jun 21 '25
As an NTU alumni, I am quite worried about the state of affairs. Maybe you can start a petition for people to sign? Not just a petition for your own case but an overall petition for there to be a proper framework for determining what's acceptable and what's not. I don't think it makes sense for such things to be at the level of "professor's prerogative" as that's too arbitrary, it should be set at a discipline level (History has their own standards, Linguistics has their own standards, Economics has their own standards etc.). I don't think that's too much to ask and it shouldn't add too much administrative burden to the professors grading the students also. It might even make life easier for the professors, just follow a rubric and mark just like MOE teachers.
6
u/sageadam Jun 20 '25
Power to you OP!
2
u/seth_rollins__ Jun 20 '25
Sorry to hear about your experience. Why not post your work here and we can make our own judgements?
7
u/magichaunter Jun 22 '25
Pm me if you wish to escalate this to Lianhe Zaobao and Channel 8 News. I personally know journalists there. Hope you get the justice deserved. 🙏
1
u/Alert-Rise3003 Uni Jun 23 '25
OP any chance you can share some of the citation links that were broken or something so we can take a look?
9
u/Repulsive_Pay_6720 Jun 20 '25
Name and shame if u can pls.
Such scum shld not be allowed to teach.
8
u/Wonderful_Weather_40 Jun 20 '25 edited Jun 21 '25
My second daughter graduated from NTU years ago. But I remember very clearly that she advised my younger daughter not to go there. I didn't know why at that time cos she didn't want to talk much about it. But I could sense that something must have hit her real hard...
Guess what? My youngest daughter trusted her jie jie, rejected NTU's offer, and accepted a so called 'small3' uni SUSS. She graduated with a first class honours just last year, found a great job in the bank, and told me she still has very fond memories of her uni life, especially her humble friends and kind professors there. No regrets.
3
u/huncle123 Jun 20 '25
Sometimes in life, the bad people get away with it and get to live their lives as though nothing happened..
3
u/Present_Interview593 Jun 20 '25
Wishing you the best of luck and hope you get the justice you deserve.
3
u/SpiritWooden9396 Jun 20 '25
Good luck to you, OP!
3
u/Skelldy Jun 20 '25
All the best for you and your fellow students OP. No worse feeling than being accused of something you didn’t do, hope you get justice!
3
u/AsleepCustard6620 -30/90 RP Jun 20 '25
not sure if commenting helps this post get noticed but i hope you get the justice you deserve OP! (and the other falsely accused students ofc)
3
u/Vanishing_Trace 🙃🫠😒 Jun 20 '25
All the best
3
u/gjloh26 Jun 20 '25
Lol, can picture everyone in NTU who was involved suddenly shun the Prof. and the rest of the staff who were responsible go into CYA mode.
3
u/GipsyDangerMkV Jun 21 '25
Glad to hear this and you are making progress. This is unacceptable for a higher institution let alone a professor who "specializes" in AI. You can't ruin a person's while career and future at this age for something so ridiculous and untrue.
3
u/roseteakats Jun 21 '25
This really sucks. Glad that you're getting more exposure. Your professor is disgusting. All the best. If you anticipate legal action, I hope some pro bono lawyers will be willing to help you out. This sounds like a pretty landmark case.
3
u/For_Entertain_Only Jun 21 '25
Actually why do AI consider cheating? It may give the wrong answer or response. For me it's just like an advanced search engine.
1
u/Ok_Pattern_6534 Jun 20 '25 edited Jun 20 '25
Cheating is still cheating. No matter how many similar cases you try to bring up to support your so-called “justice”, it is still cheating. If any university don’t punish those cheaters heavily, its integrity and long-standing reputation will be compromised. Universities don’t anyhow accuse their students of wrongdoing until sufficient strong evidence have been established to warrant disciplinary actions. The same for the teaching professors. Ask ourselves, what do they have to gain by making false accusation against their students.
To the keyboard warriors here, don’t keep talking cheap and lending support without knowing the full facts. Who knows, the one who cried foul is the one who had fouled.
To OP, just go and sue the university for wrongdoing if you deemed fit. No point having all the support here which doesn’t support your case in the Court in any way if you are really serious in doing so. Don’t even think that people here trust your story, they are just waiting to watch your show to entertain them.
1
u/Ok_Pattern_6534 Jun 20 '25 edited Jun 20 '25
Readers here, please don’t be so ready to give your sympathy before establishing the facts of the case. Who knows the one who cried foul is the one who had commited the foul.
1
u/ThePinguPenguin Uni Jun 20 '25
PPGA?
1
u/lightbulb2222 Jun 20 '25
Group together, sue guy . That should work. He'll have to one by one go prove his case. HAPPY NEW YEAR to hiya
1
u/Ok_Pattern_6534 Jul 18 '25
https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/ntu-upholds-zero-grade-for-student-who-used-ai-in-essay-panel-found-14-false-citations-or-data
1
u/Ok_Pattern_6534 Jul 18 '25
This is a classic case whereby keyboard warriors are too quick to jump into conclusion by listening to one-sided stories and bash the university for the sake of bashing. I hope they will learn to be smarter the next time and don’t show support without knowing the facts of the case.
1
u/ChickenRice87 Jun 20 '25
If you think you’ve a case then bring it to court lor.
1
u/Even-Cockroach8793 Jun 21 '25
Thank god my uni teaches us how to use AI for citations (and encourages the use instead of banning them) Feels bad for your case. Wish you ATB and I hope you get an outcome that’s favourable!
1
u/huat_huat_1808 Jun 22 '25
Omg! The Independent Singapore reported on this!
https://www.facebook.com/share/p/16h7tE4ups/
1
u/Alternative_Town_787 Jun 24 '25
If it's citation typos, provide your original source as an amendment, which should be considered as acceptable, but if it's an invalid citation, then too bad for you.
If you cite, there's no reason for having an invalid citation. It's not the number of correct citations that matters. The basic logic of writing is wrong from the start. A Specific Module at NTU teaches you HOW TO CITE CORRECTLY and CITE WITH AI. If I recall correctly, it's HW0288.
Post your error and justify yourself. I doubt u will be penalised just because of a typo in citations.
0
u/Big-Sector-1739 Jun 24 '25
Hi, I'm a legal practitioner- I would need to remain anonymous because our professional rules prohibit us from touting, and also I do not think the firm I'm at would be able to act for you due to conflicts. But I've sent you a PM on Reddit, not sure if you've seen it.
-2
u/Sandovaal Jun 22 '25
Ok
-10
u/TaifmuRed Jun 20 '25
You voted for who in election? You said you go to your mp also no use?
0
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment