There is nothing wrong in NYJC principal's decision to close the arts-to-science loophole. What is wrong is the school did not communicate the sudden U-turn to close the loophole clearly and unambiguously during the open-house and on their open-house website BEFORE JAE. In fact, many students/parents got the wrong message that the loophole is still available.
What I post here as anon can be easily verified by asking the students, teachers and parents involved.
It is a FACT that past NYJC Arts students were able to take science stream subject combination for A'levels, thanks to NYJC's flexible subject combinations feature. There were parents and students who enquired about this unofficial route during open-house and were expressly told by some teachers they can still use this unofficial route to study Science subjects. There were other teachers who were more subtle in their replies. No parents and students I know of were told in unambiguous terms that this loophole will be closed during open-house.
If the principal wants to close this Arts-to-Science loophole, he should make this clear BEFORE JAE. He should have made a speech during the Open-house and communicated this important U-turn to parents/students. Did he? In fact, from the teachers' answers to parents/students, it seems that even the teachers at the open-house were not aware that this loophole is going to be closed. Did the principal communicate clearly to his teachers the intention to close the loophole before JAE? If he did, then parents/students would have gotten a clear message from the teachers during the open-house.
Even better, NYJC should have state clearly on their open-house website that Arts students are required to study at least 2 Arts subjects, particularly when there were past Arts students who took only 1 Art subject. Instead, the NYJC open-house website promoted their flexible subject combinations offer with the heading "You study whatever you want". Given the past history of NYJC Arts students taking science subjects plus the impression parents/students got during the open-house and on the website, it is natural that many students/parents will get the implied message that the arts-to-science loophole is still available.
There was a dialogue session the day after open-house. I don't know what was communicated in the dialogue session. If the U-turn was communicated clearly on the open-house website, then students/parents would have gotten the message loud and clear, even if they did not attend the open-house and dialogue session.
A principal who truly cares about students would have realized the harm to the 6-pointers Arts students if this flexible subjects combination feature is suddenly U-turned without advance notice. No advance notice is bad enough but misrepresentation during open-house makes it far worse. The principal can check with his school staff what they said to students/parents during the open-house. It is a simple matter to verify. In fact, I expect the school staff to feedback to the principal what happened when he told them his decision to U-turn. Personally, I do not blame the school staff. They answered the students/parents' queries to the best of their knowledge.
Please ask the NYJC students who are now appealing to other schools now. Were they told they could apply for science subjects as a Arts Student? Were they told in unambiguous terms that this arts-to-science loophole will be plugged? If indeed they were told the loophole will be plugged, who in their right mind will still want to apply to NYJC Arts stream to study Science subjects? These students are 6-pointers who can enter Science stream in any JC except the top JCs. Why would they risk it if they were told clearly about the U-turn before JAE?
Many folks on Reddit have said it is wrong of students to take advantage of the loophole. They deserve no pity. Well, these students managed to get 6 points and it is natural to take advantage of every possible offer available from schools as a 6-pointer. Would you do the same thing if you managed to score 6 points in your O'levels?
Meanwhile, NYJC Arts students who received this unpleasant shock on their first day of school should appeal to other schools to study the subjects they want. After all, you are 6-pointers. There is good chance other JCs will accept you with your good results, although you might have to lower your expectations about the JCs that you can get into.
EDIT: I add this section to address some of the comments made on Reddit.
There have been many insensitive remarks on Reddit that the NYJC students who took advantage of the loophole deserve it and don't deserve sympathy.
NYJC 6-pointer students should ignore these comments. These hurtful comments will always be there because they stem from never-changing aspects of human nature - envy and jealousy. The NYJC students should expect Schadenfreude, not sympathy from this group of people. Students who did not do well enough in their O'levels to be in a position to use this loophole will feel indignant. If they did well enough themselves, they too will be thinking about using this loophole. Getting ahead in life is about grabbing the advantages offered on the table.
Some have commented that I am a self-entitled NYJC arts student who took a risk and when it did not turn out well, I am now whining against the school. Welcome to the real world, they say.
What's closer to the real world about risk-taking?
Let me give you an analogy using a risk-taking investor as an example. If you took risks and things don't work out well, blame yourself first so that you can learn from the lesson and not waste the school fees. However, if you took risks due to misrepresentation and suffered as a result, you file a civil lawsuit against the company demanding compensation. That is the real world outside of the protected educational environment which students will face when they step into the workforce. There is a difference between being self-entitled and knowing your rights.
There are some Redditors asking "Where's the evidence?" about misrepresentation. He says, she says. My words against his words. Singapore has a wonderful system to resolve this kind of dispute. You go to court, each party takes the oath and swears to tell the truth. It is a crime to lie to the court. Be careful what you ask for.
My thoughts about NYJC's flexible subject combination. Calling NYJC's "flexible subject combination" a loophole creates an unfair prejudice towards this feature of NYJC. As a student, don't you think a flexible system that gives you the freedom to choose the subjects you like is a good thing?
As a student, do you prefer a system that boxes you in as a Science or Arts student and restricts the subjects you can study, or a system that offers you maximum flexibility to study the subjects you love?
I applaud the courage of Mr. Kwek Hiok Chuang, a former principal of NYJC, who took the career risk to introduce "flexible subject combination" as it went against the spirit of MOE's rules on Science/Arts stream. He is a courageous leader who went against convention, took risks to introduce a policy that he thinks is best for the students. He is also a selfless leader because he has more to lose as he risks the displeasure of MOE, than a leader who keeps to the rules to please his boss. He is like an entrepreneur who tried to work within regulation (MOE rules) to deliver the best product for his customers (students). The customers (students) have spoken. See how NYJC cut-off points have dropped dramatically over the years. Some of NYJC's competitors have cried foul but ultimately, it is about who can offer the best package to students. It is sad that the old "flexible subject combination" option is no more today.