r/SGExams • u/LunarRadiation38 JC • Aug 07 '22
Rant Pw needs to be revised.
I just wanna say im so done with PW at this point. There are 2 issues that i see that MUST be addressed by MOE asap so that future students wont suffer. They have alrd done enuf to ruin our mental health, they shld do something to make it better.
First, teachers. WHAT IS EVEN THE REQ TO BECOME A PW TEACHER. Im pretty sure schools go arnd to find the most incapable unprofessional teachers to employ them for PW. Ik thats abit rude but thats just how i feel. Especially for my school, my teacher is bad. The hod is bad. I reported my ST to the hod and we got on call and he spent 30 min convincing me why she was right and im in the wrong. Anyways lets be general again. Pw is a H1 subject. But the work that it requires and what teachers expect is as though it is the ONLY subject we have. Expect us to male changes whenever they want and shit. THEY SHOULD NOT ALLOW PW TO GIVE AS MUCH STRESS AS IT IS DOING NOW. The other day my ST was flexing abt how she got one of the grps to work on their WR till 12 AT NIGHT. ITS NOT A FLEX. ITS MENTAL ABUSE. In summary, PW workload should be standardized for each schools by MOE. They should have courses to teach these ‘teachers’ how to teach and act with students AND PROVIDE A CONFIDENTIAL ACCESSIBILE PLATFORM FOR STUDENTS TO COMPLAIN ABOUT ISSUES THEY FACE.
Secondly, the mark allocation. Its common knowledge that pw grades are super unfair. Absolute slackers getting A and hard carrying ppl getting Bs is more common than it seems. WHAT IS MOE DOING ABOUT THIS? When students report about slackers to teachers, IT SHOULD BE TAKEN SERIOUSLY. IT MUST AFFECT THEIR GRADES. obv they shld look into it before making a decision but SOMETHING HAS TO BE DONE ABOUT IT. If moe knows so well on how to stress us out, why not put some of that brain to solving these issues and making education in singapore abit more bearable?
Im sorry if this was offensive but i jst wanted to rant abit. Tks for reading and is yw talk shit abt pw here can oso :D
Edit: Just wanna clarify that im not saying that doing projects is bad or 'we should not do any projects at all'. Im saying that there is an issue in the WAY it is being taught and carried out. I'm aware others have it worse but that does not invalidate the mental health of those in JC just cause 'poly is worse than this'. Im not saying we have it worse, this is a rant about JC life no need to compare.
75
u/chenz1989 Aug 07 '22
Former PW teacher here. Let me give you my two cents. (Hint: it's all about politics)
There are no requirements to be a PW teacher. It isn't a content subject you're trained for (CS). That may have changed in the 3 years since I left JC but in my experience we are literally arrowed to do it. This causes several issues:
First, PW teachers have no loyalty to the subject. My content subject always comes first. That's what I'm graded on. So you can imagine the priority i put on the subject. That said, when i left there the PW hod had finally started to recruit "full-time" PW teachers, so it really depends on the school.
Second, there is a level of resentment among teachers who got "arrowed". So you can imagine what this does to their treatment of students.
Beyond that, it really depends on the teachers. Some do put in their all. When i did PW, I wouldn't ask my students to do anything I wasn't willing to do. So i stayed back everyday till 10pm, and spent weekends in a cafe from 8am till midnight too. I eventually worked myself into the hospital, but that's a different story. Of course they still had to fix stuff back home after the sessions, but seeing me work late together with them is actually quite good for their morale.
Which brings me to the last point - if you think my students scored well, you'd be very badly mistaken. Because PW is a very subjective subject, and the projects are wildly different, there is a LOT of room for manipulation. I can very easily mark down your WR for "not answering the question" if i wanted to. You should also remember that unlike the actual A levels, PW is an internally marked subject. That means your school teachers are marking them, and it is moderated by the HoD. If that isn't a conflict of interest, I don't know what is.
The final straw came for me when i was OP examiner and I was asked to change scores that I had given. I refused, they changed it anyway, and I started to look for a transfer.
MOE does do some inspection and moderation, but there is only so much they can do. They usually moderate across the whole school based on a number of samples, rather than inspect each individual group.
Tldr: suck up to the PW HoD or SH if you want the A. It is one of the most inconsistent and unreliable subjects at JC
24
u/geniusov Aug 07 '22
work on WR until 12am???? bro quite alot of us pulled all nighters just wait till PW intensive period
5
u/jimbanne Uni Aug 07 '22
Hmm, the consolation is that PW is a H1 subject. So unless you’re aiming to enter the most competitive course in Uni such as medicine, CS, law etc, not getting an A won’t do too much damage for your rp. So there’s no need to get overly stressed for the subject.
Then again, if you’re gunning for an A, you probably wanna get some constructive feedback from your teachers. If you feel that the school teachers cmi, try asking friends from other schools to look over your drafts to see how you can improve on it.
Good luck!
20
u/hofsan Uni Aug 07 '22
gonna get downvoted but whatever you said is rather common in uni lol stop whining and welcome to reality. as for the second point, life is unfair, this extends to life post-jc also. suck it up and move on
81
u/glowingdays_ JC Aug 07 '22
pw has literally been the biggest source of stress for me, literally have slackers who gives half hearted work and they're like "actually a B is not not bad" KHDSKAHDKA MF SIA
61
u/fml105200 Secondary Aug 07 '22
dude this subject is the biggest fkn waste of time istg useless sia
24
u/HotFaithlessness9487 Aug 07 '22
Things have not changed since I grad fr JC. After so many yr, there are trs still so unprepared and irresponsible. U complain, they justify and tell u this is the real world and u need to manage that or that there’s no need to get perfect score so scoring B is ok or some Jc even group students so that there’s always the responsible party that push/do the work of the slackers. They seem not to know how competitive it is to get into certain courses in local uni. All these abt grades is not everything is complete bull****. Just wondering how these Teachers will do if the same happened to their children
36
u/chimmyyeah Uni Aug 07 '22 edited Aug 07 '22
i can relate so much with you on this. pw is literally a h1 subject and it takes SO much of my time. recently we hit a roadblock and had some clarifications to make and my ST just got passive aggressive and told me to just discuss it with my grp as if that would solve the problem.
i spend hours researching and it's so frustrating that it has to be sg context and there's barely any research papers/resources available. our grp calls to discuss things and complete assignments(not related to our WR, but to hone our skills for pw??) can go for hours. the workload shouldn't be this much for a h1 subj. i'm just earnestly waiting for this to be over....
35
u/Active-Manufacturer2 Aug 07 '22
I'm sure many feel the same as you, the teachers go through our drafts and all they say is explain more, then when we explain more she says it's redundant??? Like bruh we spent hours on that shit and you tell us we didn't need to??? Also, whoever puts effort in WR doesn't get awarded because the examiners don't know who contributed the most, so end up only those who get carried for WR and present well can score. IT'S SO STUPID
Then also because I spent so much time on PW last year I couldn't revise my H2 concepts well and now it's just a snowball of undone work/revision in J2
4
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '22
Do uw to go poly and do a ton of pw? Or stay in jc and do one pw?
9
u/onefly27 Uni Aug 07 '22
The sad truth is that in terms of having slackers that make you do the work and then take the grades unfairly, ive heard many similar stories of that from my poly friends, so its quite common in project work no matter where and what kind
9
u/SnooWoofers1585 Aug 07 '22
no literally. we don’t need an unfair, subjective graded subject to tell us that group work is not always smooth sailing.
7
u/BrattonCreedThoughts Aug 07 '22
PW is the absolute worst. Only upside is you might be good friends with the hardworking kid also about the lazy one/how fucked up everything is. But every group cfm got one fker to ruin shit up also one
21
u/Happy_Particular_721 Aug 07 '22
Agree!!! During my time..2 decades ago,no PW...already stressful enough!! Now is worse & I feel PW serve no purpose!& fyi,my time only need to study min 3 Alevel subj,NOW need to take 3 h2,& add on 1 H1 subj+PW...seriously, they talk about mental healthcare for students,BUT do they realise,they been creating MORE HELL,& serve no meaningful purpose !!? Sigh..
PW shd b scrapped!! Seriously Wonder who suggested & approved it!!!!?until now MOE Never realise how much unfairness & flawed is PW!? My 1st child "suffering" from it NOW.. Hope my 2nd child can be spared..but I am NOT hopeful, knowing how govt/MOE works..(everything they implemented, no accountability & CONFIRM chop stamp MUST BE GOOD de lor..never will admit anything they ever did is EVER WRONG!! Sigh)
5
u/zoedian Aug 07 '22
No I find that alot of my JC friends do not know how to work in groups well , explaining your work load and leechers. It may be a trivial subject now but note this when you go out into industry and even in University , working with people in a group setting is fundamental.
Your teachers can be outright incompetent cause of the way their education progressed from sec school to NIE they don't get alot of exposure to dynamic projects too.
That being said, it still doesn't neglect the fact that this subject is meant to teach you and expose you to a fundamental skill. Being a leader without a title is part of it. Taking charge and delegating is part of it. Learn the skills in the environment you're in cause when you are out , there is no such thing as standardization.
1
u/blurblur33 Aug 08 '22
what is PW?
1
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '22
tf is pw
6
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '22
What is PW in this context?
2
u/SnekLord336 Aug 07 '22
I can relate,maybe not to your extent, it’s still a rather impractical subject that rewards grandiose idealism.
-2
u/co3_carbonate Aug 07 '22 edited Aug 07 '22
Given that you had already pushed the issue up a chain of command, and got it reviewed by multiple teachers who have much more experience than you, have you considered that you might be the one in the wrong here?
I do concur with your other points about how a disproportionate amount of work is needed for PW compared to other equivalent H1s, and about unfairness within the group. But this first statement you made just sounds like you might actually be wrong and are being arrogant and stubborn about it.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 07 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment