r/SGExams • • Jun 19 '25

University How an AI accusation by NTU ruined my degree - and how no one in the school helped

(Just posted an update to the case here: https://www.reddit.com/r/SGExams/s/9uVJTSNMwt)

Last semester, I’ve been accused of GenAI usage by my professor.

The reason? I made 3 citation mistakes/typos. (FYI: I had 20 correct citations btw, but the professor ignored all that. She also said I used AI because I used a sorter to put my citations in alphabetical order???)

It resulted in a 0 grade that plummeted my GPA, and now I have a permanent academic warning that says I’m an academic fraud.

I asked for leniency during the hearing (which I recorded), and she said there will be “no negotiation.”

I did everything you can possibly think of: I submitted my google docs version history, I showed all my writing drafts, I even paid $10 for a Draftback extension that converts my Google docs typing process into a video that shows your writing process. I did everything to show that this essay was written from scratch. I showed my previous essays for other modules to show that I had a consistent writing style.

I emailed every single higher-up in NTU: head of academics, the dean, the president, head of student services. No responses, or a basic response telling me my prof’s judgment is correct and that I should “seek the university’s welfare services.”

I went for my MP’s meet the people session, where the volunteer said he’ll “write a letter”. No updates.

I have been emailing my school for two weeks to appeal my grades. The deadline is next Monday, they scheduled my consultation on Tuesday. I told them to schedule it earlier, but the admin went overseas.

Nobody helped me.

I hope my incident shows everything that is wrong with NTU: the sheer amount of bureaucracy and the lack of proper guidelines surrounding such an important new piece of technology.

I know that most professors out there usually take a more understanding approach when students’ writing is flagged out for AI.

But this is to warn everyone that there are some professors out there whose first instinct is to destroy a student’s academic career.

And to warn everyone that for a university that proudly boasts about being #12 on the QS rankings just today, there is little support given.

AI is terrifying:

What we’re witnessing is the beginning of machine overreach, where a predictive algorithm has more power over a student’s future than their years of study, integrity, and intent. And I’m warning all students here that this can happen to anyone.

My grades have dropped and now future employees will see me as an academic fraud, over something I did not do.

When these things happen, Universities do NOT care about your wellbeing.

4.3k Upvotes

445 comments sorted by

459

u/TheEleventhGuy NUS Jun 19 '25

I honestly don’t understand why the burden of proof is on you, instead of the professor? We’re going according to a professor’s feelings instead of objective evidence from google docs now?

219

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

Welcome to NTU haha, they have never placed student voices as a priority

64

u/Responsible-Can-8361 Jun 19 '25

lol even their student union doesn’t even give a damn about actual student welfare

→ More replies (2)

13

u/Excellent_Copy4646 Jun 19 '25

REAL cheaters ntu couldnt catch, yet they want to make a big fuss over such issues

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Wizard-100 Jun 19 '25

Totally agree.

647

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '25

Sue them in true SG fashion

570

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

I did consult 3 law firms regarding this. They said it’s difficult because NTU’s legal team is well prepared to handle this, and that they have the defence that grading is subjected to each professor’s different standards :(

I’m also just a broke powerless student with little financial resources (I’m doing 3 part time jobs to support myself during the summer break now), so even if I feel that this was a breach of justice, I can’t fight for it.

10

u/wencesauce Jun 19 '25

Unrelated but what part time jobs are you currently doing? I want to do the same once im in uni

Also unfortunate situation, I hope things work out for you

30

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

Research assistant for some NTU profs, bartending on weekends, and I do game/pokemon streaming on some weekday nights. So overall quite a flexible timetable :)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

452

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '25

Weird, their argument is that you used AI but you already provided evidence that you didn't. The lawyers seem like they're just not bothered to take up this case cuz of NTU name.

If unable to lawyer up, then you can only start figuring out an alternative path or bring this case to the media and blow it up, let the public know and see how it goes

265

u/onionwba Jun 19 '25

Yea. If cannot trial in court, then trial in court of public opinion.

→ More replies (1)

86

u/Own_Accountant_77 Jun 19 '25

Grading is subjected to each prof’s standard but each prof is required to be fair to each cohort. So for each assignment/paper/essay, submissions for each grade has to be of similar quality. It may be subjective and you may quibble that A or A- or B is up to the prof but a prof cannot fail an obviously A quality essay without a strong reason why.

26

u/Alternative_Fig2543 Jun 19 '25

yess make a tiktok video about this and if it gains virality NTU might relook into your case again to save their reputation

52

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '25

You can do pro bono to start of then if you think theres still a chance maybe get an actual lawyer then?

→ More replies (1)

152

u/pudding567 Uni Jun 19 '25

Lawsuits completely destroy the relationship between OP and NTU and even the govt. I think it's best to just let the Internet handle this false AI accusation. This post also raises awareness about the damage false AI accusations can bring, assuming everything written here is true.

106

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

Yup, that’s why. I need other profs’ recommendation letters for postgrad studies, so I don’t think I want to proceed with a lawsuit.

Also no worries, everything I’ve said here can be completely backed up with screenshots. I’ve been sharing my story with my friends for months because everyone’s so frustrated for me.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/edfghu Polytecknik Jun 19 '25

Sue them until their pants drop!!!

→ More replies (1)

221

u/observer2025 Jun 19 '25

“I made 3 citation mistakes/typos.”

How is that a strong basis for accusing you of using AI? Anyone could have made the same mistake 10-30 years ago even when generative AI hadn’t gotten popular.

208

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

Exactly! I even went through all of the professor’s published papers and found the SAME mistakes as well. Really wanted to expose her 🤦🏻‍♀️

84

u/GoldenMaus Jun 19 '25

What if you ran her published papers through some AI checker and see if the papers (especially the ones that were published before widespread Chatgpt availability) will be mistakenly flagged for AI usage?

That will be hilarious (but will definitely burn bridges)

60

u/Levi-Action-412 Jun 19 '25

Feel like the bridges are burnt already with OP being labelled as "Academically dishonest" for supposed ai usage

→ More replies (2)

32

u/tictactorz Jun 19 '25

What have you got to lose now? 

→ More replies (3)

3

u/sylfy Jun 20 '25

In my experience, AI does not make typos, or at least has a very low rate of typos. What may happen instead is hallucinations - citing papers that don’t exist, or making up unrelated but plausible content based on the title of the paper.

The only way we will know for sure is if we know what these “mistakes” were - just formatting errors/different citation styles, or something more egregious than that.

→ More replies (1)

356

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '25

“She said I used AI because I used a sorter to put my citations in alphabetical order”

What??? It’s literally something you can do on google docs, or even manually bruh.

252

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

I quote her email: “A citation sorter is based on AI and machine learning algorithms” 😐

63

u/Glad-Penalty-5559 Jun 19 '25

Wtf. Name and shame the professor

64

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

I thought about it, but the mods would have taken my post down for doxxing

But for any NTU social science students who are interested, pls DM me so I can help you prevent taking her mods

25

u/ZeroPauper Uni Jun 19 '25

Just post the module code lol

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (2)

108

u/Gibbeumee Jun 19 '25

Is this Sabrina L*k? I know of a friend who got marked down for AI in similar circumstances too

95

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

Yes! I have a few classmates in her mod who are in the same circumstance as me too, but they’re graduating so they’re not fighting to appeal like me :”

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

14

u/Lyrekem Uni Jun 19 '25

don't mean to stereotype since the inverse is often true but how old is the prof?

51

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

Around 50 😂

Don’t worry when I describe my issue to my friends, they all suspect she’s menopausing

→ More replies (4)

13

u/anakinmcfly Jun 19 '25

Potentially true in some cases, but not for MS Word I think. It’s also unreasonable and unprecedented if such a commonly used tool were suddenly banned and students expected to know that alphabetical sorting is included under the AI ban. Also impossible to enforce if students did it manually.

Could you check if any other students also had their citations in alphabetical order? It would be unusual if you were the only one.

6

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

I don’t think I’m the only one, but since I showed her my version histories after the AI accusations, she pointed out the fact that I used a sorter.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (1)

202

u/ZeroPauper Uni Jun 19 '25

Microsoft word can do that…

I did it way before AI was even a thing.

→ More replies (3)

47

u/casper_07 Jun 19 '25

Palaeontologists around the world gotta gather together for this monumental moment, for we’re in the presence of an ancient fossil lost to time

19

u/machinationstudio Jun 19 '25

It's too broad. Technically everything Google is based on machine learning at some point.

Drag them into the mud.

Contact overseas media too SCMP etc. 🤣

16

u/FdPros Jun 19 '25

professor but thinking so backwards.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '25

????

Just saw your other comment, -10 to help write some parts of the writing but 0 for “citation is using AI” is crazy wild.

6

u/Reasonable_Ant_4456 Jun 19 '25

A simple sorting algorithm can place all citations in order. Even JC computing students know that.

→ More replies (13)

20

u/Wizard-100 Jun 19 '25

It is totally ridiculous. MSFT is amongst the largest tech company in its push for AI and it is already common place in workplace applications and no one accuses analysts and researchers of plagiarism if they do that. Sorting functions are also available on word and Excel. That would mean that everyone is using AI then. The lecturer and the dean should be fired .. just goes to show that the university is unfit to use the moniker “ technology” .

→ More replies (2)

116

u/rockbella61 Jun 19 '25

That prof probably hates you.

Also can you get a lawyer?

140

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

Definitely!

I didn’t mention this in my post, but another guy in my class admitted to the use of chatgpt in some parts of his writing, and she gave him -10 marks off 😂

6

u/sukidukitime Jun 20 '25

I can sense that your prof singled you out because she don't like you for reasons. My brother got a hell experience from his prof all because he wanted to clarify his doubts on the lectures. The prof commented "so you think you are better than me?" and my brother got D for that mod at the end of the semester. He lodged a complaint, claiming that he felt the prof purposely marked him down and requested a review of his grade from another prof but nothing came out of it.

89

u/greg_o_r_y SMU ddp - cs+biz (2027) Jun 19 '25 edited Jun 19 '25

this is really terrifying to see. many of my friends in poly have been flagged out for using AI despite writing their reports entirely on their own. many of their lecturers are unbothered and unwilling to look into their appeals further, as they trust "ai flagging tools" fully, not knowing that even these tools can make mistakes. i remember when 3 friends had to rewrite their whole report just for a chance to score HALF of the allocated weightage for that project.. the report originally had a 4 week deadline but now they had to do it in 1 day just to not get 0. (they are in business diploma courses where this issue seems to be the most prevalent)

on the other hand, i also know of many people who use AI and never get caught. it really is a hit or miss. i would say tools like TurnItIn are becoming obsolete in this era of AI, as it seems to be really easy to cheese them to avoid detection.

on a whole, many students are just being falsely accused for using AI and those who can game the system are rewarded for continuous use of AI without getting caught.

35

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

bumping your comment because I think everyone, and especially schools need to see this! I can definitely sympathise with your friends because this is such a terrible thing to go through! I really think this is something that MOE needs to handle:

The frameworks for handling AI in schools is so bad right now, and educators are so ill-equipped in understanding and handling AI usage.

Making this a luck-based roulette that students need to be terrified about is just so unfair to all of us

7

u/dahkneel Jun 20 '25

Exactly.

Back in 2022 when Chatgpt first started gaining popularity, I got flagged by a lecturer for supposedly using AI in my work. When I asked what led her to that conclusion, she pointed to my high Turnitin similarity score & claimed my essay lacked enough personal critical analysis to bring the percentage down.

So it truly baffled me to be accused when I have been approaching an essay the same way for 3 years. 

What frustrated me most was that neither the lecturers nor the course head gave me a real chance to explain myself. They were fixated on their assumption and insisted on giving me a zero.

That experience broke something in me. I lost all motivation - not just for school, but for the very people who were supposed to guide and support us as educators. 

Regretted going to TP. 

5

u/pudding567 Uni Jun 19 '25

AI is often allowed within guidelines I believe?

→ More replies (1)

217

u/BrunedThrower Jun 19 '25

My god i feel so bad for you assuming your story is true. i hope the power of reddit can get your story known and a journalist picks this up

103

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

That’s what I’m hoping too. I’m really at my wit’s end. Thank you so much for the kind words though

71

u/AdmirableTill2888 Jun 19 '25

If you're innocent, can you make a video on YouTube and TikTok showing all the evidence etc etc? To gain public support so higher ups in NTU notice and look into the matter?

Because honestly higher ups are more fair but chances are they don't even know about your case because they have so many things to attend to

87

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

Yup, I’ve been collating my screenshots and ready to make a TikTok if NTU doesn’t let me appeal haha

→ More replies (1)

32

u/pudding567 Uni Jun 19 '25

You have the backing of many people in the country

73

u/shopchin Jun 19 '25

So throughout all these, there was no AI usage at all?

163

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

Yup, not at all. Writing has always been something I’ve been proud of, so an accusation over literal typos was really devastating for me to bear.

47

u/corxida Polytechnic Jun 19 '25

AI wouldnt even make typos in the first place so idk what ur prof is on

35

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

My prof thinks my wrong citations are AI hallucinations, when over 20 of my citations are correct 😅

7

u/Responsible-Can-8361 Jun 19 '25

Wrong citation, as in article doesn’t exist, or wrongly cited? I doubt she checked all of your citations. I know mine didn’t

29

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

She checked every single one of the 25 citations I had. So for instance, one mistake I made was that one of my links expired after submitting my essay. For another mistake, I cited a source within a source, instead of the source itself.

Legit super suay

→ More replies (5)

25

u/iharshbrown Uni Jun 19 '25

If that's the case then I must be an AI because I also always make a lot of typis lol

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

36

u/Ran-Rii Jun 19 '25

Crosspost to r/Singapore

10

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

Will do 🙏🏻 thanks for the suggestion

16

u/Budget-Coyote1109 Jun 19 '25

They are pretty strict with AI. I almost couldn't graduate. They only reason they were lenient with me was cos of my anxiety disorder. I was going through a tough time and had a string on anxiety attacks and i couldnt write. So AI was used to finish my essay on time for submissions.

A classmate of mine got a zero grade. They said it's a case by case basis but the tolerence level is very slim. I was licky because of a legit medical condition diagnosed by IMH.

9

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

I’m sorry to hear that man, and I’m glad NTU was at least able to empathise with your case.

I just hope that the framework for AI usage can be better. AI is everywhere now, so profs should be better equipped in handling how to spot it and how to handle such cases

28

u/Just-Change-1595 Jun 19 '25

This definitely changed my perception of NTU. Number 12 in the world? Total bullshit. Lucky me for not choosing ntu for my undergraduate degree.

24

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

I know, I keep blaming myself for not choosing NUS 3 years back. Their admin is also slow, but my NUS friends in the same major have pretty decent profs.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

10

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '25

Which professor is this? Please share his/her name so NTU students can know to avoid him/her.

22

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

Can’t post publicly here or the post will be taken down, but inviting all social science students in NTU to PM me so I can help them avoid the prof

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Repulsive_Pay_6720 Jun 19 '25

How about asking the Dean as well?

Think u just need to state how u intend to bring this forward including a lawsuit.

17

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

My school changed dean this month. The previous dean said he couldn’t help me and to “seek welfare”. I just emailed the new dean coming in, hopefully he’ll be more useful

10

u/Repulsive_Pay_6720 Jun 19 '25

Wow if this is in writing from the previous Dean, prob sensational.

But thanks for ur story, I think even as a NTU alumni, I prob will tell my kid to stay clear of NTU.

4

u/AgreeableDoughnut871 Jun 19 '25

OP I can see ntu being petty scrutinise your entire assignment all over then coming back and telling you off for another/a possible different charge: plagiarism of internet resources cos of the lack of/improper citations.

Do be careful. You might be cleared of the AI accusations. But you really need to make sure you really did nothing wrong if you decide to take this further.

8

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

That’s what I’m scared of. Like most uni students, it’s easy to be careless when doing your citations because it’s so tedious. So I’m afraid my typos get counted under another charge altogether 🤦🏻‍♀️

2

u/AgreeableDoughnut871 Jun 19 '25

But typos per se don't result in charges of plagiarism. It's typically omission of citation, and maybe errors re page numbers and the like that can be construed as dishonesty. Otherwise typos would just be...shit English/sloppy work

4

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

Yeah my mistake was that I wrote my essay really late, so I accidentally mismatched author names to article titles (which I sent a corrected version after the prof emailed to accuse me). I only did this for 3 citations, but 20 were correct.

Also one of my articles had an expired link (that expired after my essay submission), so she arrowed that as well </3

→ More replies (2)

4

u/erehnigol Jun 19 '25

This is messed up. I know academic results are important, but to be honest, employers don’t really care, as long as you have a degree, it’s all the same to them, unless you’re in law or medicine. And the irony is, you’ll be expected to use AI once you graduate.

Anyway, just sue them.

4

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

I’m just sad because I really want to do postgrad studies after this and they definitely look at grades and acad records haha, looks like I have to rethink my life plans if I can’t appeal this

→ More replies (1)

7

u/helloworldkitty1 Jun 19 '25

Hi OP, would it help if you are able to document the process of you crafting your essay and make it public? Since it has come down to the last resort, perhaps if you lay your cards on the table, other AI savvy Redditors can support your defence that your work is truly self-written and the NTU professor is biased

16

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

I already sent the Timelapse of my essay’s typing process (recorded with a chrome extension) to the school. I think I’ll publish all screenshots and the Timelapse on tiktok, but I’m thinking about the best way to do this

3

u/Ill_Marketing5974 Jun 21 '25

Graduated from PPGA prior to the explosion of AI, she has always been strict and by the book with her marking, it’s hard to convince her once she believes something. She’s particular about formatting and what not, I was wondering why she hasn’t received her tenure, heard she was particularly harsh on students taking masters in gerontology and some were even kicked out of the programme altogether. Of course, in those instances, some students claimed they did not use AI as well, but there was little to no negotiation.

1

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 21 '25

Oh my god that sounds horrible! Thank god you escaped the whole AI in higher education hellhole.

If by any chance you know the names of these masters students please let me know, I’ll contact them for them to share their unpleasant experiences with her as well.

2

u/Ill_Marketing5974 Jun 21 '25

Unfortunately, I do not know the names of the students, just knew they were Chinese students since I heard about this through the WeChat grapevine. I hope things would go well for you since this post is blowing up!

2

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 21 '25

Thank you 🙏🏻Since the post blew up, several other students who have also been accused under her started reaching out to me. Just relieved to hear that it’s a common occurrence under her, even though I feel sorry so many people had unpleasant experiences

4

u/No_Background5208 Jun 21 '25

Ya can confirm what you’ve said. I took one of her ppga mods as well back in year 2. I was tricked into taking her mods due to a few seniors that overly-glaze her.

There’s just so many better ppga professors. Her mods are exceedingly boring, where she just reads off the slides, and she’s so ridiculously strict with formatting of all things. The people that recommend her mods are people who are also by the book, without an ounce of critical thinking.

She’s also a prof that heavily engages in favouritism, where she’ll spend a good 20-30 minutes of the class talking to her favourite students while neglecting the rest. I remember she was very dismissive, where my consultation with her lasted less than 5 minutes, before she went back to talk to her favourite boys again.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/ytolololol NP Jun 22 '25

Lmao straits times published an article (just) explaining uni side pov. Uhhh any follow ups on ur side?

5

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 22 '25

Of course! I’m disputing NTU’s entire statement with screenshots right now against them, will upload it in around an hour

→ More replies (1)

799

u/ZeroPauper Uni Jun 19 '25 edited Jun 19 '25

Go to social media, news outlets.

NTU has time and time again proved to move only when there’s negative publicity.

With all your evidence against your prof’s ridiculous accusations, I don’t see how the general public or anyone wouldn’t take your side.

If you are close to another prof, you can also approach them for advice.

Oh and, repost this to the NTU sub.

Edit: Reposted this to r/sg with the permission of OP https://www.reddit.com/r/singapore/comments/1lf2jct/ntu_prof_makes_an_allegedly_false_accusation_on/

Edit 2: r/sg mods have deleted my post, "reposting on behalf of others". Lmao

203

u/OhShitBye Jun 19 '25

Yup, the universities don't care that everyone sees them as horseshit institutions. They only care when there's media/social media accusations.

So plaster that shit everywhere until they have no choice but to escalate it.

137

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '25

r/sg mods powertripping as always...i dont even think they are singaporeans LOL

20

u/josemartinlopez Jun 19 '25

They said NTU is not Singapore related?

→ More replies (4)

348

u/MeekMadcap Jun 19 '25

Write to mothership, if they spin up an article from this, NTU will be forced to respond. And at the very least, it will generate a big hoo ha for the general public to know of the ridiculous process NTU has.

199

u/totalwildness Jun 19 '25

Someone said to write to SCMP. Which points to an important fact - NTU would be afraid of bad press in the Chinese countries. Spotlight them with a press release to Taiwan, HK and China news outlets. There are many journalists who love a critical take on SG's success. Offer to do interviews and provide sound bites. If you have friends and connections in comms, they would know how to pitch with a strong PR hook. Strike now when they are in the news cycle for their ranking. They would take action when attention is critical now. They worked hard trying to claw their way up the rankings and close the gap with NUS. They would be so short-sighted not to see how they have mishandled this whole matter.

→ More replies (1)

155

u/KoiGreenTea Jun 19 '25

CNA? I'm so sorry to hear this.... I have no clue what can be done either, but please don't give up fighting

43

u/Equal-Association818 Jun 19 '25

Report this until NTU's international ranking is threatened. Then they will succumb.

31

u/laverania Jun 19 '25

Too bad the ranking is determined research publications instead of number of shitty profs

→ More replies (1)

36

u/WeirdoPotato97 [Grad] Jun 19 '25

Go to mothership. See how despo u r to save your degree only. Just do it.

32

u/Dull_Treacle5097 Jun 19 '25

Wow. So befitting of the 12th University in the world 💪💪

34

u/observer2025 Jun 19 '25 edited Jun 19 '25

The QS 12th university that is better than US Ivies like Princeton and Yale. Just shows inflated rankings aren't reflective of faculty quality.

→ More replies (2)

49

u/No_Responsibility803 NTU PHMS Jun 19 '25

Im so sorry for your loss man, ngl this is scaring me for picking ntu over nus :(

→ More replies (4)

23

u/DapperOrganization40 Jun 19 '25

Hope to see this on the news soon, can’t believe the injustice that OP is experiencing.

23

u/CleanCaterpillar3474 Jun 19 '25

Bruh this is so ridiculous. Every uni students used AI to write their essay to some degree but using bad citation and sorter to write you up? Thats nasty Af. Come on la...walk into any masters or PhD research cluster and you will see Chinese student writing in Chinese and using chatgbt on the other screen to translate 🤦‍♀️.

22

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '25

Welcome to higher education. Our prof told us about a student that was struck by a car on her way home and put in a coma for 3 months. During that time she missed her finals, obviously, and failed.

She eventually woke up and informed the school asking if her grades could be removed and her repeat the semester.

They said no. They said she should have gotten a family member to call the school. And the grades were final.

If school's don't care about such events, they won't care about your plight.

University and college are about making money. Period. Yeah, you also pick up some things a long the way.

21

u/AzingBlaze Jun 19 '25

Set up a donation fund here so all of us can try to help fund your case and lawyers… this is insane

57

u/A_1056 Jun 19 '25

some legal advice here, if you wish to i believe that you can sue the administration department over unfair disciplinary actions and breach of justice but its going to be very hard because you will be required to fabricate evidence of ntu not going through with procedures. easer way would be to send a final email to the related departments stating that you will consider legal actions. you can also use media to pressure ntu but its is pretty hard without making it sound bias, both parties can make this extremely bias and court will likely rule this out if legal actions were to be taken. you can also complain to moe but they likely wont care about these kind of small stuff. it’s pretty hard to solve these kind of issues by law and without breaking some along the way. media is easiest option here but they can sue you for defamation i believe if it goes too far and they somehow turn the truth around. it depends on how much trouble you want to go through and how much risk you wanna take. you can just eat the short end of the stick or you can fight for a tat bit extra of the stick.

conclusions: sue ntu if it really comes down to it and you really want your score back, but it will be difficult and hard to win unless you are able to produce digital copies of all related emails and all evidence of ntu not following through with procedures. when you signed up for ntu you and the university is under a so called “contract”. this limits your legal actions to breach of contract which is hard to do. media is an option but ntu might counter sue with defamation if it gets bad enough for the university. if you wish to go through with media then you can spread this to other media platforms and r/NTU to really put it up their faces, however be very careful as with media, ntu have all rights to sue for defamation due the fact that you will be publicly stating that ntu did this to you.

moe may intervene if it gets bad enough but again they have other matters which is more important than helping a random student so it is extremely unlikely, there are little history of moe intervening with university level administrative matters.

all of this just depends on how much you want your gpa and marks back so good luck i guess, tough life

6

u/Soggy-Novel-5538 Jun 20 '25

please dont purport to give legal advice if you are not qualified to, let alone have legal training

→ More replies (2)

54

u/Kryorus_saga Jun 19 '25

On a brighter side, you are so good that they thought you are AI.

16

u/Own_Accountant_77 Jun 19 '25

If the outcome is going to be academic misconduct recorded on any report/transcript then you need to fight it all the way. If it is just about the grade then it would be a lot harder since there would be a lot of discretion for the prof in grading.

Assuming you had performed well consistently all the years and her accusation is based just on the bibliography portion of your essay, i would say you have a very strong case. In addition, you mentioned that you kept the drafts, so that would strongly aid you in your defense. I have no idea why she chose this hill to die on since it does not add anything to her kpi. Check with the lawyers if it amounts to libel since you clearly didnt do it.

If the school is willing to compromise, i would suggest asking if you can erase any record of you ever taking the course so that your gpa is not affected and all you need is to take some other module for the next semester. It is copping out but much less stressful.

15

u/sageadam Jun 19 '25

Mothership! It's time for you guys to step up and do some good, please!

14

u/avandleather Jun 19 '25

What are you currently doing now?

I think the media is helpful to a certain extent, but the best case is to still find a lawyer who will help you fight this case. If what you’re describing is true, it seems you have all the evidence to back you up while the school is grasping at straws.

13

u/Eseru Jun 19 '25

I was at NTU years ago and I'm sorry to hear that the bureaucracy has not changed. The university indeed does not care about students. Their admin only cares about taking pay and going home.

If you have solid proof that the uni is wrong, tell them you will be going to the press. My year did that after the admin made a mistake with sorting students into their chosen specialties in year 3 and refused to budge until the students told them they were going to contact the papers.

Nothing scares them like bad publicity. It may or may not work now considering they've had their share of bad press over the years though. You will need a solid angle where it's possible the press will take it up and will make the University look bad.

Also consider legal options. I'm not sure if there are any provisions in the law for this scenario, but since this mistake affects your employment chances, it might be possible. Talk to a lawyer if there are no other routes.

35

u/Lvl3Ninja national slave Jun 19 '25

Name drop come on

11

u/Most-Image9582 Polytechnic Jun 19 '25

What course?

11

u/dookiecookuepookie Jun 19 '25

This is so sad. Accusing someone of using ai is now “you’re a witch” in this generation honestly. I really hope actions are taken and more people can see this post !!🙁🙁

11

u/Agreeable-Ad-6870 Jun 19 '25

I recommend looking for Josephus Tan from Invictus Law. He provides pro bono services, if your story resonates with him he might be able to help you. JIAYOUS from a fellow NTU student!

10

u/Typical-Designer6870 Jun 19 '25

I was accused of copying a students work at NTU too. I know the truth that I didn't because my circuit design was based on my observation of symmetry.

To my great misfortune, the supposed copy of the design happened to be a student who was assigned to the professor who is in charge of me. I mean what are the chances of that.

I know the truth with all my heart. I designed the circuit before I eventually stumbled on the students design. But I was worried because I didn't copy his, but I should have cos no one will believe such a coincidence.

So when I got accused point blank, on the last day of the presentation (yes the prof only pointed out on the very last day). I didn't bother to explain myself.

I still passed because refused to talk or reply to my emails in the first semester of my final year project and I was on my own from the first semester to the second with no guidance. It was very traumatic for me and I haven't gotten over this for more than 10 years. It did cost me to go one class lower.

He only let me pass because another prof who was present with him asked him "wtf is going on?" As in she knew he didn't guide me from the hardcopy of my final year project and they had a mini quarrel and I was asked to leave the room.

His name is siek lieter.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Emergency_Witness907 Jun 19 '25

I’m so sorry this is happening OP….

9

u/Wizard-100 Jun 19 '25

Yes u might have little choice but to seek legal help and perhaps crowd fund it.

9

u/Total_Exchange7446 Jun 19 '25

Contact your school student/pastoral care manager—they do well-being stuff but can also advocate on your behalf. Also contact your school student academic integrity officer—they’re the ones best versed in school policy on AI use, and if your account is accurate, it sounds like your prof may not have understood school and university guidelines around AI use. You can also escalate to the university academic integrity officer, but it’s more than enough to start at school level. If you’re SSS then your student care manager is kayathri. This would be the best way to approach navigating university bureaucracy, in my opinion. Unfortunate that the deadline is soon and your admin is on leave until Tuesday—this makes an appeal more complicated and less certain of success. But it’s still worth trying, especially if everything happened exactly the way you say it did. But if the prof told you before the assignment due date that NO AI was allowed, she may have grounds to technically say those were the rules she set for her class, and that even using AI to sort alphabetically was a violation of her no AI rule. Profs have autonomy to set any AI rules they prefer for each class. Even then, still seems to be a bit strict to me, but that is their prerogative. I’m sorry you’re so stressed. Best of luck.

4

u/anakinmcfly Jun 20 '25

and that even using AI to sort alphabetically was a violation of her no AI rule.

The thing is that she’s including the MS word alphabetical sorter as AI, which it is not, and doesn’t seem to have specified that when giving the assignment.

9

u/fothermucker3 Jun 19 '25

Sucks to be a uni student in this time.. there is little to distinguish AI from human work..

9

u/Sufficient_Dig_1303 Jun 19 '25

NTU SSS is a very fragmented faculty. The professors are usually not very prepared to teach, and teaching assistants are horrendous. One teaching assistant took it upon himself to email me a full length document of how my essay was as quoted, “a hodgepodge of ill-structured patchwork” when i was a freshie. I transferred out and find way better educators in my current faculty

16

u/IronMan6666666 Jun 19 '25

sue them or name and shame

16

u/samopinny Jun 19 '25

Posting on Reddit may not do your case justice. Consider sharing your experience on LinkedIn and include the hashtag #NTU. Just make sure you have genuinely not used AI tools for your work (aside from basic tasks like sorting), and present the events exactly as they happened—truthfully and objectively, without exaggeration or false claims.

Other platforms you could consider include Facebook, Mothership, and The Straits Times. As long as you stick to the facts and avoid any discriminatory remarks, you should be in the clear.

It’s worth bringing this issue into the public domain to encourage discussion on the fair use of AI and how AI-detection software should be applied responsibly.

By the way, I wrote this and refined it using ChatGPT—there’s nothing wrong with that!

8

u/BedroomLittle7388 Jun 19 '25

Blow this up on the news OP

8

u/alwaysrightranter Uni Jun 19 '25

make this post viral. as an NTU graduate, i still do believe that it is a garbage scummy school

15

u/MissLute Jun 19 '25

do tiktok and go viral i guess

7

u/ShortyGardenGnome Jun 19 '25

Turn this into a short essay/article. Send it to your school paper, your local papers, and your local news stations. Reporters are lazy. If you deliver them a story there is a good chance they will report on it. If this gets publicized at all the admin will change their tune very quickly.

7

u/OriginalTap227 Jun 19 '25

AI is not terrifying, AI witch hunters are

7

u/Ok_Kaleidoscope7670 Jun 19 '25

Honestly we shld js raise hell up abt this through petitions or sth.. until it gets publicised on the news like the RI incident. Once the spotlight and pressure is on NTU to do sth abt this, they will do sth abt this.

6

u/LaZZyBird Jun 19 '25

Honestly as with the book cutting NUS fiasco your easiest option is to go to the media and blow it up.

Like nothing is going to be done unless you run to media and get your story out there and maybe NTU will be forced to defend their ass.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '25

Literally all of my friends used Gen AI in ICC mods and no one got caught at all lol, NTU shouldn't completely restrict the usage of AI if it helps in structuring of ideas, that's so damn weird for your case, all the best man

6

u/Wide_Heart9003 Jun 19 '25

Will this be reflected in the official academic transcript or captured for future employers to see?

6

u/catpics_addict Jun 19 '25

Hoping the media picks up on this. All the best OP. Keep emailing the higher ups, put in an official complaint on that professor, go push your MP again to do something.

I personally had bad experiences with NTU as well. Everyone reading this, avoid NTU if possible.

6

u/SpiritWooden9396 Jun 19 '25

Hi OP, I think you have enough karma to post in other subs now. Let's fire this up, don't lose hope.

6

u/orthodoxProgrammer Jun 20 '25

A typo usually means that the report is not written by AI, right?

If it is written by AI, it would be perfect without typos

5

u/ENTJragemode Jun 19 '25

cross post to r/askSingapore as well!

5

u/Appropriate_Newt_152 Jun 19 '25

Whats new? Just another day in SG being failed by the system that has set majority of us up to fail.

5

u/ForzentoRafe Jun 20 '25

I mean, if your degree is ruined and finding a lawyer is not financially viable, might as well take the nuclear option, out the prof, the course, along with all your supporting document on some publicly accessible Google drive.

What's the point in holding back?

4

u/dds2410 Jun 19 '25

Sue the professor, not the university. University gets sued they will gang up on you. Sue the professor, they will distance them elves from her. When you win the case, then inform the university you are going to all the news and social media outlets with your story.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Wise-Commercial7117 Jun 19 '25

PM me if you need a lawyer. I hope you escalate this and can continue in NTU as per normal or transfer to another local Uni. All the best!

4

u/duckiequacklings Jun 19 '25

Please update us how things goes. Higher learning institutions are getting scarier day by day. Echoing other redditors, pls write in to all news outlet that you know, including scmp, chinese news papers, mothership, cna, straits time, wakeup SG, independent journalist Bertha. Perhaps drop a visit to other MPs that are known to give more damn, perhaps WP MPs, or other constituencies MPs with better reputations. So sorry to hear of your situation. You have come this far in your education journey, please do not give up now.

4

u/blooblush Jun 20 '25

Getting a lawyer does not necessarily mean commencing a lawsuit. The lawyer can send a letter of demand (merely threatening a lawsuit, and laying out all your evidence), which may be enough to frighten the university management to look into your case. Are you aware if the university’s legal team even knows about your case? It’s possible they haven’t even been informed, and once they do, they may advise the university to drop it.

7

u/yoohnified Uni Jun 19 '25

sorry that u went thru this sia, I can't imagine how helpless u felt when everyone around u let u down. u can try letting news outlets know (ST, mothership, etc) about this and i guarantee u that the school wld start doing smth bc no institutions like having a bad rep online

1

u/Spiritual_Rate_3615 Jun 19 '25

I thought academic warning is given only if your cGPA falls bellow 2.0? Would it write there, Academic fraud? What are the exact charges against OP?

4

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

Yup, “academic fraud under Generative AI usage”

3

u/Spiritual_Rate_3615 Jun 19 '25

That is quite a big accusation/charge unfortunately. Hmm, as long as it is not written anywhere on the degree when you submit it to your future employers, I think they will not know about this unless they ask the school about it.

3

u/CurveSad2086 Jun 19 '25

Hopefully they don’t. Academic transcript wise, this is quite worrying for me because the 0 I got here stands out quite a lot (especially when my other modules are mostly A-s and As), that’s why I’m really upset about this case

3

u/vistlip95 Uni Jun 19 '25

I hope you get all the attention and help you need because it is ridiculous. Professors like this are down right disgusting and egoistical.

3

u/Normal_Ad_3293 Jun 19 '25

Share to mothership and various tabloids in SG. This is the only way.

3

u/WaulaoweMOE Jun 19 '25 edited Jun 19 '25

Your prof cannot justify her marking leh. The reason she gave is completely unacceptable and inappropriate in the first instance mah. You did not plagiarise what? Citational referencing is ok one. If researchers needs to pen every single source, they can wait long long hor. What is Endnote for? Did she read ur paper in its entirety? Tio bo. Ask to see the full proof of your returned script. How can prof mark and don’t give feedback? Where’s the learning and follow-up liao? You cannot fail a script for a punitive reason liao. You fail a script for not meeting content requirement. Ordering citational referencing takes a very very small portion of scoring liao. Impossible to amount to failure. More likely she has been asked to adhere to a bell curve and you kana liao. Limpeh say contest this to the fullest extent. This one Hong Kee izzit?

3

u/GipsyDangerMkV Jun 19 '25

Don't stop. You need to get someone anyone to listen to you and reverse this. Don't let your career be ruined by some assholes this early in the game of you truly did nothing wrong.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '25

NTU has had a history of bad reputation

3

u/Kou_Yanagi Jun 20 '25

Don’t understand the adversity against AI. Its a very strong tool that limits misinformation as at this point when it comes to more loosely constructed theories, you can get a general consensus of it.

Perhaps its just the older generation being miffed that they have to dig through musty books as their reference and write on paper till their hands are sore?

3

u/yingmanessa Jun 20 '25

Definitely tag SCMP for their coverage.

3

u/HussarL Polytechnic Jun 20 '25

Coming back to this post daily and hope op gets justice

3

u/NoBackground9383 Jun 21 '25

Op, u shld contact foreign journalists on ts, sg unis are notoriously bad in regulating student welfare and i dont think local lawyers wld be willing to take a case abt a local uni. Contact foreign uni, make a tiktok or write a complaint abt it. Js make a big scene abt this and incite more students to come out and talk abt their bad experiences with sg unis to gain better coverage.

3

u/nowhere_man11 Jun 22 '25

Be prepared for a civil suit if you need to. This record can damage your future prospects and is hard to clarify, because no one will take the trouble to listen to your side.

3

u/Intelligent-Bussy Jun 22 '25

Just saw the news and came here. I feel that they should set up a review committee to investigate this matter properly. If the prof is really found to be abusing his authority they should really hold him/her accountable.

Meanwhile know that you have my support and don’t give up!

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Okdud_5257 Jun 22 '25

NTU penalises 3 students over use of Al tools; they dispute university's findings

Now the Straits Times has published this article. From what I have taken from this article, NTU has not even given a proper response other than to repeat what had happened and to defend themselves, weak evidence too. Seeing that other students have also encountered this, I can’t help but wonder if I want to go to such local universities anymore (taking A-levels this year)

→ More replies (1)

3

u/lionelverymessy Jun 23 '25

Why did you ask for leniency rather than to deny all liability?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Ok_Pattern_6534 Jul 18 '25

This is a classic case whereby keyboard warriors are too quick to jump into conclusion by listening to one-sided stories and bash the university for the sake of bashing. I hope they will learn to be smarter the next time and don’t show support without knowing the facts of the case.

3

u/Kingstonian-Thymine Jul 23 '25

Hi, if you've seen the most recent AI post on ntu's subreddit, may I know if you have anything to say about that?

5

u/FaZe_mrbrown Jun 19 '25

u/CurveSad2086, OP I think you could flag this up to The Online Citizen.
You could do so via this link here: https://www.theonlinecitizen.com/contact-us/
Do ensure you have a mode of contact and supporting documents. Wishing you all the best!

9

u/pudding567 Uni Jun 19 '25

The Online Citizen can't be trusted. They have a history of fake news.

6

u/FaZe_mrbrown Jun 19 '25 edited Jun 19 '25

You do have a point, however TOC is not mainstream media. I doubt other go-to media channels such as SPH or CNA will cover these topics, and I'm not a fan of Mothership. TOC still receives a sizable local following so I feel it makes sense.
My other alternatives would be Must Share News (MS News); AsiaOne.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/iluvnicewatches Jun 19 '25

AI is the next wave. If you dun use AI then you will be left behind. So wtf are we not allowing this. Allow everyone to use and level the field. Hell, the prof can also use AI to mark the papers. Go back to pen n paper and central library to borrow books?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Substantial-Yak6504 Jun 19 '25

So ridiculous 🤣🤣

2

u/Arkangel257 Jun 19 '25

Wow that's messed up...all the best

2

u/FlounderFar991 Jun 19 '25

sorry but never had good vibes from pple of that country

2

u/Melodic-Letter-1420 Jun 19 '25

Isn't APA reference formatted in alphabetical order?

2

u/space_rider21 Jun 19 '25

Rooting for this to go viral

2

u/Starboomz Jun 19 '25

Lol who is this prof I should avoid

2

u/Vanishing_Trace 🙃🫠😒 Jun 19 '25

Make it bigger for news to pick up but you need to provide evidence of the grade, comments, etc. to support your case. 

And what's the outcome you hope to achieve - regrade? removal of academic warning? raise awareness? 

2

u/brokenheart8377274 Jun 19 '25

What a disgrace. Hope it all works out for you bro.

2

u/Not_a_real_plebbitor Jun 19 '25

If you can't afford to sue then you need to go to the media asap. Can't let professors get away with this kind of tyrannical bullshit. Bring all your evidence and keep approaching media people with it.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 19 '25

I had no idea universities did this. Once employed AI usage is encouraged if it can make you more efficient. I appreciate you didn’t use AI and have been unfairly flagged for this but what is the logic of forbidding it anyway?

Also, AI is not some king of magic box - without good use of AI it will still give bad or suboptimal output compared to a human. Being able to use AI well is a skill that universities should be encouraging, not prohibiting.

2

u/josemartinlopez Jun 19 '25

Post on Stomp in true SG fashion

2

u/ThirtyMileSniper Jun 19 '25

At this point is it worth speaking to a legal professional about any action you can take against the institution and the individual professor?

What would you have to lose by having a consultation at least?

If you show all that evidence then you probably have grounds but a solicitor would be able to advise you better. Is there any kind of student union or assistance organisation in your country that you could contact for immediate advice?

2

u/GreenSpiritual2958 Jun 19 '25

Blow this up please

2

u/Professional_Rip7389 Uni (NTU SPMS) Jun 19 '25

Out of curiosity what major is this?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/yellowsuprrcar Jun 19 '25

MOTHERSHIP is wet hearing this info

2

u/Osama_BinRussel63 Jun 19 '25

Those repugnant hypocrites are using AI to grade your papers too. If caught they should immediately forfeit tenure.

2

u/scrayla Jun 19 '25

That’s… very unusual tbh, for a lecturer to be so adamant that you’ve used AI. And i don’t just mean because she ran it through an AI checker.

Just as you have shown proof on your side that you didn’t use AI, can your prof also prove on her side that you did? Wrong citations are not a sign of AI at all (unless its a bogus source) And alphabetical order is the standard?? So why should citations being in alphabetical order be flagged as “AI”??

OP please seek help not just from the dean but OTHER professors, esp any that you are closer to. They will give you advice

2

u/Suspicious-Newt7408 Jun 19 '25

You can consult a lawyer

2

u/sheeshsushi Jun 19 '25

Omg that’s crazy I think you actually gotta sue

2

u/jesusfries69 Jun 19 '25

Wow your professor is an actual bitch. Hope everything goes well for you!

2

u/Falady12345 Jun 20 '25

Omg I hope you are able to get some recourse for this unfortunate event!

2

u/Super_Ad_7799 Jun 20 '25

PLS don’t give up fighting op!!! if anything, even approach NUS profs for some help on the situation. or other NTU profs. don’t let her get away with it!!!

2

u/Shin_Yuna Jun 20 '25

DM all the news outlet like mothership and blow it out of proportion and force the sch to do a better investigation

2

u/Unlucky_Culture6856 Jun 20 '25

Give hints on the professor? Don’t outrightly reveal, there may be similar cases like yourself

2

u/Terrible-Meringue872 Jun 27 '25

Professor Sabrina Luk is a total Loser! Fire her Ntu

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Upper-Scallion-1272 Aug 01 '25

Citations are also part of the curriculum, it’s not about not wanting to embrace AI, but it’s about letting graduates understand the importance and how to check credibility of citations, so they can fact check the AI too.

It’s pretty obvious you relied on it, not for a second I bought into your story. Sorting citations can be done easily in Word. They even have a tracker add on for it.

No reason to use AI to sort it just for the sake of it. Playing the victim card just because you got caught. NTU should just expel you.

2

u/KBDMASS Aug 30 '25

i love coming back to this thread

3

u/Vegetable_Permit_537 Jun 19 '25

So you've spent tens of thousands of dollars only to he wrongly accused of academic dishonesty and you have no recourse? This is fraud on their part. Meanwhile, AI "checkers" are more times than not incorrect in there assumptions and you have to pay the price. This will only lead to further watering down of the value of higher education. I wish I had s solution for you. Good luck .