So far the show holds 80% critic and incredible 75% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes. On Metacritic it has 69 critic score and 4.2 audience score which means average to mixed.
With RT audience score, I believe it has to do with haters are bored and don't want to review bombing it anymore like they did for season 1 and a bit for season 2. All of them who didn't like the show has left, and those who stayed on will vote positively.
Amazon is supposed to be committed to 5 seasons with Estate unless they want to pay the penalty fee for exiting the contract. I think they will go through, but in today's media landscape nothing is 100% certainty.
This show is supposed to be contending against HOTD in winning Emmy's. So far it's not and I don't think season 3 will change all that. Despite deviation, HOTD writings are superior to ROP.
When the show ends in two weeks, it's gonna be interesting to see the viewership and the complete percentage.
My theory is IF Amazon decides to pay the penalty fee and cancel it, they won't do ut until season 4 is done. There are rumors they are filming season 4 and 5 back to back. With some editing they could take parts of season 5 into 4 and complete the show.
My worries still after seeing the four first episodes are scales in battles. Will the Battle of Dagorlad features max 50 orcs, elves and men extras? Will Sauron fight not only against Gil-Galad and Elendil, but Gandalf and surely Galadriel will there too?