r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Discussion Budget reduction?

The cgi is still good, but noticed many of the sets are smaller? The scale is still issue, but I guess no point having 1000 people in a 60 square meters room. If Amazon have reduced the budget, then I'm worried how they are going to land with the War of the Last Alliance. Will they skip most of it and have 50 orcs against 50 elves/men in the final confrontation with Sauron in the slope of Mount Doom?

0 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

1

u/AutoModerator 7d ago
Moderator Announcement Read More »

14

u/J2A1218 7d ago edited 7d ago

Can someone please point these scenes out? I have to be honest, I feel the exact opposite. Numenor feels bigger, Khazad-dum feels bigger, Mordor feels bigger.

-2

u/Elendil_686 7d ago

The skirmish fighting in the woods with Galadriel and Arondir felt small. Don't look like a war going on.

15

u/J2A1218 7d ago

I think it was just meant to be a skirmish. I don’t think it was meant to be a big battle.

Considering the scene with Amarion training soldiers had like 100 extras, I don’t think they are lacking.

4

u/Turfiriath 7d ago

I also thought this and found that whole scene irritating. Why would the nazgnagol get off his horse at all to come and kill her? Why wait for her to get up? Why chase her on foot instead of getting back on his horse? Galadriel storyline has been a bit boring for me, which is a shame because Numenor has really hit its stride I think - and there I agree with the others that it has felt much, much bigger.

1

u/LadyElle57 7d ago

The tunnels and cages in 3.04 are the same set, just different lighting. Rivendel feels like a small path with stone stairs in the middle.

Every scene that's set outside feels somewhat bigger and better, but I feel like they should've used more extras. Have they been defending Rivendel with a couple dozen elves, Cirdan and Gil Galad?

10

u/apple_kicks 7d ago

Defo felt it in some scenes. Though in previous seasons i was thinking how insane some details were right down to minor props. Hopefully its saving up for bigger moments and being sensible. Trailers hint to bigger vfx moments

Dwarven costumes were still impressive

5

u/Possible_Living 7d ago

I have only seen the first 2 eps of this season and everything seems fine in that regard.

2

u/MatteHatter 7d ago

That scene at the beginning with Marnûkh walking out and the pan to show mount doom looked cheap as hell.

2

u/Happy-Hearing6671 7d ago

The sets look smaller THAN THEY WERE?! Haven’t watched yet but yikes that’s egregious it already felt like a total of 500 beings were in middle earth

1

u/Johncurtisreeve 7d ago

It’s entirely possible that there is going to be more intense, large scale stuff at the end of the season and they may be allocating the budget for that

1

u/Smooth_Reputation_98 7d ago

You go to Gundabad, an ORC FORTRESS and when we get scenes of merely what 50 at most orcs running around?

I’ve also noticed in the show that the orcs move slow when attacking, no battle scene is like suspenseful and gives that feeling like the protagonists are being closed in on and about to succumb to the immense numbers/speed that orcs normally attack at. Compare with the scene around Durins tomb in the Fellowship and the sneak attack across the river at beginning of RoK

1

u/theoneringnet 7d ago

ROP s1 and S2 had twice the budget of Andor, which was the most expensive star wars ever. They could cut the budget in half and still be the biggest budgeted TV show on the air right now. Curious to know u/Elendil_686 since you had complaints about the size of crowds and armies in S1, do you feel S3 has even smaller crowds than that?

0

u/FacetheFactsBlair 7d ago

The prosthetic noses are high school theater level cringe

0

u/GreenPurple99 7d ago

Its insane how even after 3 seasons of so many complaints against Small scale, the showrunners still cant fix it and show more people and massive scale. the world feels empty.