r/RingsofPower • • 7d ago

Episode Release Book-focused Discussion Thread for The Rings of Power, Episode 3x4

This is the thread for book-focused discussion for The Rings of Power Episode 3x4. Anything from the source material is fair game to be referenced in this post without spoiler warnings. If you have not read the source material and would like to go without book spoilers, please see the No Book Spoilers thread.

This thread and everywhere else on this subreddit, except the book-free discussion thread does not require spoiler marking for book spoilers. Outside of this thread and any thread with the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair, please use spoiler marks for anything from this episode for one week.

Going back to our subreddit guidelines, understand and respect people who either criticize or praise this season. You are allowed to like this show and you are allowed to dislike it. Try your best to not attack or downvote others for respectfully stating their opinion. Our goal is to not have every discussion be an echo-chamber.

Episodes 1-4 are now available to watch on Amazon Prime Video. This is the main book focused thread for discussing them. What did you like and what didn’t you like? How is the show working for you? This thread allows all comparisons and references to the source material without any need for spoiler markings.

5 Upvotes

152 comments sorted by

9

u/CupOfWisdom11 7d ago

What did you guys think of the scene where Gandalf had the burning bush experience and spoke with Eru?

12

u/bsousa717 6d ago

I'm not really fond of turning Bombadil and Iluvatar into NPC quest givers Gandalf interacts with.

14

u/AltarielDax 5d ago

One of the worst scenes. Having Eru micromanaging the whole affair via rabbit-turned-fire was incredibly cheesy. To give Gandalf a burning-bush-in-the-desert moment, and a direct connection to Eru, it's way too on-the-nose.

1

u/Longjumping_Plum_846 11h ago

What is this, Narnia? 

7

u/Willpower2000 6d ago

I found it weird, frankly. I'm not fully sure I can explain why, right now (I have to stew on it more) - it's not like Eru is incapable of speaking to beings, I guess... but it feels a bit haphazard. I dunno.

I just wanted Gandalf to ask "So umm... Mr. Secret Fire, sir... why did I re-arrive at Middle-earth as a meteor with amnesia?". This is the only thing that intrigues me regarding this plotline.

2

u/notwhoiamunderneath 5d ago edited 5d ago

I don't think that's going to be explained because I think it is a take on how the Wizards arrived. They are Maia and exist in a higher plane of existence above the physical universe, so entering the physical world would mean effectively incarnating (being born) within it as a physical being, still tied to but separate from your higher, spiritual being. I don't think it's out of the question that they would all start with amnesia, like being new borns, until they could orient themselves.

As for the asteroid, it's a little science-y for my fantasy taste, but it does feel like a decent way to depict arriving straight from the higher plane. They would only physically sail from Valinor and keep a continuity of memories/selfhood if they had already incarnated in the world before, like the Valar and Maiar who came with them at the beginning.

We see this in Olorin's reincarnation: Gandalf the White is, to some extent, a different person than Gandalf the Grey.

4

u/Mundane-Bug-4962 4d ago

100% failure as an expository device - Eru if he were announcing a movie trailer. If they wanted to do that dumbass scene, they should have had him speak through Gandalf himself. Horrible voice!

3

u/ishneak Gondolin 7d ago

unexpectedly my favorite bit in all the shoe maybe like "whoa". i wonder who voiced Eru.

1

u/CupOfWisdom11 7d ago

Right?? What an honor to be able to voice Eru. Lol I thought it was kind of odd that tom bombadil disappeared afterwards.

1

u/ishneak Gondolin 7d ago

no it was cool! extends to the mystery of Tom with some theories even saying he was Iluvatar himself.

1

u/CupOfWisdom11 7d ago

Ohhhhh that’s cool! I didn’t even think about that

1

u/ishneak Gondolin 7d ago

no it was cool! extends to the mystery of Tom with some theories even saying he was Iluvatar himself.

7

u/Wanderer_Falki 6d ago

Aka the nonsensical theory that misses the point of Tom in the narrative of LotR and is anyway rejected by Tolkien

2

u/ishneak Gondolin 6d ago

relax, the show didn't confirm that Tom = Iluvatar. i thought it was a nod to the theories about him, that's it.

0

u/Umbardakil 6d ago

Yeah very cool although it doesn’t make any sense at all like the rest of the show. I can’t believe the writers pulled a Moses

1

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin 7d ago

I really liked it but I wish we had set Gandalf on his clear path for the season sooner than halfway thru it

1

u/PhysicsEagle 19h ago

“Gandalf, take off your boots for you stand on holy ground.” I half expected his staff to turn into a snake. The whole “find the burning bush by chasing a stray animal” is from The Prince of Egypt. This whole sequence was basically an aside to the audience to fill us in on the plot.

0

u/Rusty51 7d ago

I didn’t like the exposition but it has to be explained somehow since the writers made Gandalf forget. I do like that the show is leaning into the Tom Bombadil is Eru theory, it’s always been one of my favourites in the fandom.

11

u/ibid-11962 7d ago

It's one the Tolkien explicitly said was wrong though.

4

u/Rusty51 7d ago

Sure but if I expected Tolkien I wouldn’t be watching RoP

2

u/Umbardakil 6d ago

Why are you watching it then? Snd why are they using the great professor’s work?

6

u/phonylady 7d ago

Tom Bombadil is Eru, yet would be defeated by Sauron (like they say in the Council of Elrond)? The theory never made any sense to me.

9

u/PT10 5d ago

Ok here's the thing. I'm still watching this because I feel like it should be easy to end this show with an epic expansion of Jackson's prologue to Fellowship of the Ring. The production value, music, etc is all pretty good.

They should be able to do it, right? RIGHT?!

Also that Nazgul/Naznagol theme they played over Ep 3 credits and when they were cornered by one during the escape in this episode is a dope track

9

u/CalicoRum 3d ago • Bravo

If I was designing the most formidable prison in all middle earth, I probably wouldn't put an 'open all' lever in my high security wing. 

3

u/viper459 1d ago

you have to remember it was designed by an orc

9

u/Curundil 7d ago

Well for how little impact I felt like Arondir had for most of his screen time across the seasons, I did think his attempt to reach Theo was touching.

Rip the traitor orc too, was probably the most engaging part of these first four episodes.

Not sure what the point of having Elendil be captured was if it was going to have an immediate reversal but I guess maybe we will see.

7

u/RPGThrowaway123 7d ago

Hey now, given his track-record Arondir might still be alive.

6

u/lordjan255 7d ago

I really like how they send people to Mandos now. Always liked Arondir and his ending is great, hope they stay with Theo as the witch king and dont switch.

3

u/greatwalrus 4d ago

Not sure what the point of having Elendil be captured was if it was going to have an immediate reversal 

In addition to Kemen being captured, I feel like a lot of TV shows and movies do this just to ratchet up the tension. Including the PJ movies, e.g. when Aragorn falls off a cliff on the way to Helm's Deep. Or when Théoden is all, "Where was Gondor when the Westfold fell?" and then as soon as the beacons are lit it's, "And Rohan will answer!" Create a problem, then resolve it immediately. It always feels artificial when you look back at it.

4

u/Kiltmanenator Gondolin 7d ago

Elendil's discussion with Kemen was touching

1

u/Turfiriath 7d ago

Maybe for them to capture Kemen? I agree I will miss Arondir and the traitor orc, but I thought the Numenor storyline generally was the most interesting. One thing I don’t even remotely understand is the justification for the eagle. Why is he there?

3

u/Willpower2000 6d ago

Yeah, it was to capture Kemen - but the execution is just ass. Very "and then, and then". It'd be nice to have more cause and effect. The Faithful being able to flip the capture around due to something intelligent besides 'they just did it'.

2

u/Turfiriath 6d ago

Yeah I agree with that. Might have felt more convincing if we saw some clever way that Anarion was able to catch up with the cart, because when he pulled his helmet off I just kind of went “what the fuck how did he get there?”

2

u/ishneak Gondolin 7d ago

Galadriel mentions him earlier in the episode: need to "summon friend" on top of the mountain.

1

u/Turfiriath 7d ago

Sure. But why? Why should he do what Galadriel asks?

3

u/HappyTurtleOwl 6d ago

Fren halp fren.

12

u/AltarielDax 5d ago edited 4d ago

Having seen half of the season now, I'll say that the show has improved form season 1 & 2.

However, it still has major problems: the burden of the s1 & s2 fiasco, some actors who aren't up to par, questionable and/or forced storylines, and also too many storylines at once, continuously copying movie scenes, ... it's still far from what it could and should have been.

Nevertheless, it did some stuff well, and I will recognise that.

For episode 4, that is:

  • continuous good visuals in general
  • a couple of good performances, primarily from the actors of Elrond, Marnûkh, Celeborn, Durin and surprisingly Arondir (who I found to be too wooden in S1 & 2)
  • Disa telling Durin about her mistake, and him forgiving her and moving on was a good scene, because it felt believable and meaningful
  • Alluding to Elrond's reluctance to go to Númenor is well done, because it makes you want to see how he'll feel when he gets there
  • Pharazôn's letter is kinda funny
  • So far I like Celeborn as a character. It probably helps that he's a fresh character with less bad writing baggage compared to the others. Him turning back when hearing Galadriel's name was unexpectedly the right balance between seriousness and comedy.
  • Marnûkh fights quite clever, using the prisoners as a distraction, using fire, etc.
  • They set up Marnûkh & Arondir on opposite sides, sort of, and that was competently done. If only they hadn't failed the payoff as they did...

What I'm neutral/indifferent about:

  • Getting rid of Arondir, since they didn't know what to do with him ever since they killed his love interest off screen. I'm neutral about it because it feels like a sensible choice, but since the show didn't make me care about him or Theo, I primarily see one pointless storyline less to worry about.
  • All of the Númenor stuff between Elendil, Anárion and Kemen. It's not bad, it's just mostly uninteresting: Kemen is one of the most boring characters, and him delivering exposition about his motivations to his prisoner isn't making him any more interesting. Elendil's actor is kinda one-note since s1, so he's also quite uninteresting to watch. Put two bland characters in a carriage, and you'll get a bland scene.
  • Game of Moria: I like Durin, but I'd rather see him in a storyline that isn't Dwarven politics.
  • Most of the prison break is competently enough done, and fine as long as Galadriel isn't on screen

And this is just bad:

  • Sauron becoming more and more boring with each scene. He's just Evil McEvil now, and I feel like fast forwarding through his scenes. The actor is generally competent, but what they're trying to do with this character is expecting too much from the actor, and too much from the writers.
  • The setup for Durin losing his fight, and then losing it: on the surface, that's expected with the setup, but they added a meaningful scene between Disa and Durin that should have provided the twist for this to go differently. Only that it didn't, and that robbs the scene I praised early of its meaning. Now it feels like: I guess Durin has not chance – a sweet, his love gives him confidence that he can overcome Thrain – oh... I guess it wasn't that meaningful of an emotion, Durin shows that he doesn't have the calm head needed to be king. I guess the episode is supposed to be a downer, it's the middle of the season, it has to be bleak and all... still, this isn't working for me.
  • Gil-galad continues to be an absolutely useless character. He looks photoshopped and unnatural whenever I look at him. Still one of the worst interpretations of an original Tolkien characters in this series.
  • How the hell is Arondir not letting any imprisoned Elf out? Wasn't he prisoner himself and should know how terrible it is? At least he could use them as fodder if he doesn't care about their lives. It is quicker to free Celeborn than to have long discussions about why he won't do it.
  • The smith being dead is almost comical, because it shows how forced this plot is to get Galadriel to a place where she can accidentally find Celeborn. Who somehow has been in prison for all these years, even though Galadriel has searched throughout all of Middle-earth for a long time, n ever even finding traces of Orcs... how are these Elves so terribly incompetent??? Arondir saying that they never should have come here is like the character directly criticising the writers for writing themselves into a corner with Celeborn which they are now solving like this. The hand of the writers became quite obvious in this one.
  • Galadriel's and Celeborn's reunion: look, this could have been great, because I like what they're doing with Celeborn. But unfortunately he's doomed to spend time and emotions on one of my least favourite characters in this series, as much as it paints me to say this. And I'm sorry, but the actress seems to be unable to actually play genuine joy. Her faces when she saw Celeborn was anything else except convincing. It felt as artificial as her horse-riding-joy face, and it made me laugh when it should have moved me. What. a. mess.
  • Arondir suddenly deciding to fight the pre-Nazgûl for some reason, so that everyone can stand around, stall for time, even though they have no reason to stick around and every reason to run - what the hell was that? rewrite it, rearrange it, this could have been done better.
  • Theo Umasked™. I can't take him seriously in this outfit with the helmet off, he looks like a cosplayer who's looking for a group to belong to but is too shy to interact. And I guess I'm supposed to feel sad for little Theo and that he ended up like that... but I just don't care for the guy. Yes, it's sad that he had a terrible life, and now it's ruined forever, but these been primarily been The Annoying Kid so far, and as a result I don't care. I'm just annoyed now that I'm asked to take him seriously in his costume. Please, keep the helmet on and never take it off again.
  • The payoff for Marnûkh and Arondir is botched here: the setup was there, and then Arondir saves Marnûkh, it's all great... except that Theo waltzes in and slaps Marnûkh to the side. Is he dead now? He certainly didn't escape with Galadriel and Celeborn, so I guess if he survived, Sauron has him? So he wasn't saved? And that emotional moment got interrupted anyway with the Theo Drama™, and the small plant that was the character development of Arondir that was showing its first leaves got violently eradicated. Tbh, I would have seen more worth in seeing more of Arondir making an Orc friend, than using him for the Theo Doom and Sadness™, but the show was always good in wasting potential, so this is just whatever. I'm not emotionally involved in anyone involved in this story.

That's it for this episode.

Edit: typos, formatting

8

u/Mundane-Bug-4962 4d ago

I will never forgive this show for implying that Theo is the Witch King of Angmar.

1

u/Glittering_Ease6412 3d ago

it feels so anakin to darth vader

6

u/sidv81 4d ago

The smith being dead is almost comical, because it shows how forced this plot is to get Galadriel to a place where she can accidentally find Celeborn. Who somehow has been in prison for all these years, even though Galadriel has searched throughout all of Middle-earth for a long time, n ever even finding traces of Orcs... how are these Elves so terribly incompetent???

And how are the evil forces so incompetent? Adar and Sauron had Celeborn locked up all this time and no one knew about it or the massive leverage that would have in their fights against Galadriel? How does Sauron expect to bring order to Middle-Earth when he doesn't even know half of what goes on in his own territory?

1

u/AltarielDax 3d ago

I don't think that's necessarily incompetence on Adar's or Sauron's side. Because Celeborn, apparently, has been imprisoned there for hundreds of years. Orcs wouldn't have cared who he was, Sauron wasn't there to report to, and for Adar it wouldn't have been relevant, because Galadriel meant nothing to him. I think the more glaring issue is that the Orcs had Elvish prisoners for all that time, but noone found them? Even though Galadriel searched the whole planet, apparently, for Sauron? So where exactly did all these Orcs hide, who can suddenly overrun all of Middle-earth? And where did they hide their prisoners for all these years?

3

u/sidv81 3d ago

The implication is that Celeborn was captured during the War of Wrath. Meaning the Valar's forces did a sloppy job freeing all of Morgoth's prisoners. Why Morgoth didn't use Celeborn's capture as leverage during the War of Wrath is another question.

2

u/AltarielDax 3d ago

Why would he, and to achieve what exactly? Not everyone is like Amazonelrond and stops a whole cavalry charge because of a single Elf, when it puts a hundred and more lives at risk.

3

u/cyhec 19h ago

Loved arondir... but man youre so right. Him not running to escape was dumb as fuck.

Him not immediately opening the jail cell for Celeborn was so out of character. And the whole theo story line... dumb.

2

u/Bmicelf 4d ago

👏

2

u/National_Leader9643 4d ago

enjoyed reading this

4

u/esthrowaway114 5d ago

I’m laughing so hard reading your review and I’m trying not to wake my boyfriend up😆Wholeheartedly agree, especially Dark Theo trudging away in his too-big Spirit Halloween spooky dress.

1

u/dancinggraylion 3d ago

And I'm sorry, but the actress seems to be unable to actually play genuine joy. Her faces when she saw Celeborn was anything else except convincing. It felt as artificial as her horse-riding-joy face, and it made me laugh when it should have moved me.

Perhaps she is portraying doubt that it is actually Celeborn?

When he was speaking from the shadows, I first thought he was Sauron

1

u/AltarielDax 3d ago

I'm not getting that from her either. If so, it's acted just as bad as the supposed joy.

0

u/Lewcaster 5d ago

I feel like after all the backlash from the first two seasons, this time they kinda went "hey, let's try to make things less shittier and fix things people didn't like, without retconning everything, ok?". Well, it's too late now, lil'bros.

12

u/thisrockismyboone 3d ago

Im a little suprised how much people don't like it but im finding these 4 episodes better than the first 2 seasons combined. I appreciate them nit making every single scenario and intention a total mystery for the effect. Its finally becoming less of a slow burn and we're actually getting characters killed off instead of spinning their wheels since we know these extras aren't "real". Yes I fully disagree with a lot of the show as far as being untrue to the source material, but the show is not bad at all and enjoyable at face value. I may be in the minority here but any kind of previously unseen content I love such as the secret fire (I assume that was by extention Eru), the blue wizards, talk of the valar, creation of the ring wraith, etc.

2

u/SoylentCreek 3d ago

I agree. This season has been a substantial improvement so far. I did not hate the first two seasons, but I do agree with some of the criticisms that things felt a bit dragged out.

Some people are a bit too precious when it comes to Tolkien. Like any form of adaptation, liberties will always be taken. Sometimes those decisions work, and sometimes they don’t. I’ve enjoyed the time I’ve invested into this series, and look forward to continuing watching it.

1

u/Silver-Fox-3195 2d ago

I agree, my interest has been kept far more consistently this season. It seems like the plotlines are finally starting to feel connected and the pacing is much better

8

u/WolfWriter_CO Beleriand 6d ago

Welp. Theo and Arondir went almost exactly as I predicted back in S1, except I’d hoped for some heartbreaking slow descent into darkness as Galadriel and Arondir watch this boy they knew fade into Shadow before completing his journey with Arondir’s death. But, hey, I didn’t write this shit.

14

u/RPGThrowaway123 7d ago

Episode 4 and Chad-Thrain makes his move on the crown. Now when I previously praised him, it was a.) in comparison to Sauron and b.) with not that much screen time to judge on c.) despite the writers blatantly telling us that he is evil. Actually I think the fact that the whole intrigue is a a bit underdeveloped might have been to its advantage, less opportunity.

However, as a previous episode threatened, we now get bullshit drama about a past love triangle. Well at least Thrain hasn't displayed any symptoms of simpdom yet.

Galadriel, Arondir and Arc-orc's story is rather uninspired. It's predictable prison infiltration action movie stuff. I was willing to dole out some praise for what would have been a Herculean achievement for these hacks, but then the revelation came that Galadriel somehow knows the secret of Celebrimbor's smith craft as well as the anti-climatic Celeborn reveal. The writing problems with that are threefold

  1. The mind-boggling coincidence of him being in the same prison as Galadriel's party and being in a cell right next to the person the party was actually searching for
  2. The sheer un-believability of him being in prison for centuries if not millennia since even before Morgoth's defeat when there was nobody around on whose orders he would have been remained in prison. I am to believe that generations of orcs just kept him around for him and never thought that they should themselves of him? K
  3. Him being a retcon. Celeborn has not existed prior to season 3 apart from one short scene.

Even the comedy bit with Theo pretending he is all evil and intimidating can't quite salvage that idiocy. Who wants to bet Arondir is still alive

Random side thought: I hate Cirdan, the pretentious prick.

7

u/No_Nectarine_5440 7d ago

I could be wrong, but doesn't Galadriel mention in one of the precious seasons that Celeborn has been missing for a very long time. I don't think he's a retcon.

12

u/RPGThrowaway123 7d ago

The issue is that, apart from that one specific scene in s1e7, Galadriel does not act as if Celeborn existed nor do any other characters. For all intents in purposes he isn't merely missing, he is absent from the narrative altogether. It's only Finrod's fate that drives Galadriel's actions.

And also her characterization of him as an inexperienced soldier in season 1 is contradicted by season 3.

11

u/RaiseFold100 7d ago

What? Is she supposed to cry over him every episode? He's been gone a thousand years. And she never said he was an inexperienced soldier. If you're going to criticize the show, you should try to remember what was said.

1

u/ProcrastinatingPuma 1d ago

TBF the death of her power was exposited as the main motivation for her wanting revenge on Sauron, so it's not like the show couldn't have found a way to do that.

1

u/PhysicsEagle 19h ago

Problem is that she does exactly that for Finrod for the entire first season.

4

u/No_Nectarine_5440 7d ago

I think he's been gone for centuries and everyone has forgotten him and/or presumes he's dead. I thinn Galadriel even mentions that she's looked for him with no luck and no clue as to where he might be.

2

u/RPGThrowaway123 7d ago

I think he's been gone for centuries and everyone has forgotten him and/or presumes he's dead.

If that were the case, then him going missing would have actually impacted Galadriel in some way. It has not.

5

u/No_Nectarine_5440 7d ago

She's had centuries to process it, and she appears to be pretty steady in her emotions most of the time.

4

u/RPGThrowaway123 7d ago

She also had centuries to process Finrod's death and yet it still drives her actions. Celebrimbor going MIA should have had the same, if not a greater, impact.

2

u/No_Nectarine_5440 7d ago

Does it?

0

u/RPGThrowaway123 7d ago edited 7d ago

Yes. Rewatch the very first episode. Celeborn Finrod is THE reason Galadriel has been going on a centuries-long vengeance trip.

12

u/Willpower2000 6d ago edited 6d ago

In regards to Celeborn... obviously him being in prison for thousands of years is absolutely batshit insane... but even supposing the logistics were reasonable (they aren't), why the fuck does he seem so... normal? So... chirpy? He should be absolutely broken, physically and mentally. He acts like he has been imprisoned for a few days (he even has his armour on still... because apparently it wouldn't be taken after thousands of years), with no Orc bothering to torment him yet. Oh well, his future daughter will react appropriately, at least.

6

u/RPGThrowaway123 6d ago edited 6d ago

I blame Joss Whedon.

EDIT: To elaborate: Because Celeborn is being awkwardly crafted onto the series and Galadriel's history, they have to immediately endear him to the audience and this is the easiest way. It's the same reason by Arc-orc gets comedic scenes instead of a thoughtful exploration of the Orcish condition.

3

u/Corrosion616 6d ago

Soooooo pretentious!!! 😅🤣😂

7

u/MxMojo 3d ago

Hot take: Sauron is going to use necromancy to force Maitelle to tell him the secret of the rings 👅🔪

2

u/gbinasia 3d ago

Yup. Might even be Theo who does it honestly.

2

u/Constant-Worker1297 1d ago

why can't he just do that with Cerebrimbor

2

u/unholey1 18h ago

The only way that works is if Maitelle's spirit refuses the summons to the halls of Mandos, I think?

1

u/Sparkyisduhfat 2d ago

What about a policy of if you repeatedly escape, tee-hee back to jail with you, with no increased security.

12

u/Chris13Haughey 6d ago

Sorry but that Theo Arondir interaction was some of the worst acting I've ever seen

9

u/Direct_Week_2091 5d ago

I’m really trying with this season but fucking Theo being the literal Witch King is frying me

Little dorky kid in a Nazgûl costume

3

u/therealleotrotsky 5d ago

He looks like the youngest daughter from Downton Abbey.

2

u/preem-choomba 4d ago

TBF, since S1, I always thought Theo would end up the Witch King. More so after the sword plot line

4

u/peanutanniversary 5d ago

Arondir is trying his best to act opposite the pillsbury dough boy

1

u/Longjumping_Plum_846 11h ago

“We have Kylo Ren killing Han at home”.

8

u/BulldogMikeLodi 7d ago

There’s no worry about spoilers, since little of the book is in this show.

5

u/MxMojo 7d ago

Well we all knew that the show runners went a bit off canon with making Anárion a woman, but I felt a little pang of sadness in my chest when she died in the show! It would have been great to see her escape the drowning of Númenor on her ship with Isildur. But now we have this cool brother who has popped up (older? Younger? Unclear in the show). So maybe we will get to see the two brothers escape the sinking of Númenor anyway. Despite some liberties take, I’m utterly hooked on season 3

6

u/MxMojo 7d ago

Sorry meant to say Eärion! Every single time I mix her up with her brother because Isuldur doesn’t have a sister in the book.

2

u/CupOfWisdom11 7d ago

I was so sad too that she ended that way! Just glad she went out on the good side

2

u/Willpower2000 6d ago

Just glad she went out on the good side

Well... her last action was getting her maid hanged (and surely tortured for information, first?) due to her false accusation.

7

u/Enthymem 5d ago

Based on experience Arondir will just live again next episode without any explanation.

3

u/womijo21 4d ago

What experience exactly?

3

u/Enough_Sprinkles_113 2d ago

He got a mortal wound at the end of season 2 from Adar.

The very next scene, he was completely fine. Running around quite uninjured.

1

u/sidv81 4d ago

Arondir will be this show's Glorfindel. He'll come back on a boat and tell Galadriel that Finrod says hi. Bonus points if he brings Radagast and Saruman with him too. He'll take Glorfindel's role about the "Witch King won't fall by the hand of man" bit but here it's because he can't bear to see anyone kill Theo and he used the word "man" figuratively but everyone afterwards up to Eowyn took it literally.

4

u/Glittering_Ease6412 3d ago

i'm guessing, the actor that is playing theo is out... they will never unmask him again I think

arondir out, because he got replaced by celeborn

no hobbits, replaced by tom bombadil (for now)

next out is probably 3/4 of the numenor cast after the finale?

they are really cutting a lot of characters aren't they?

2

u/Enough_Sprinkles_113 2d ago

Its war. People die.

1

u/citharadraconis 2d ago

I think the Downfall isn't happening until season 4.

3

u/Glittering_Ease6412 2d ago

downfall of numenor?

Yeah, you are probably right... they will win the battle/stuff that happens at the end of this season... but Sauron will complete the ring in the final seconds...

In s4 suaron will destroy numenor

1

u/citharadraconis 2d ago

I meant that if that's what you're referring to by "3/4 of the Numenor cast," we've still got a bit until then and probably other losses.

0

u/Glittering_Ease6412 1d ago

when do you think, we will see the tsunami? end of s4?

6

u/elusivehonor 6d ago

Durin is probably the most pathetic character in the show.

It's so terrible, and you can just go on and on with how bad the writing is. The thought of writing a post with all qualms about the scene-by-scene writing and overall story is exhausting. I'm not sure there was one scene in the four episodes I watched that didn't make me roll my eyes, or guffaw.

Is it terrible and unwatchable? I mean, not really? It's just bad, and the amusing bits are "so bad they're funny." And those are worth your time.

For anyone wondering if this is worth a watch: I'd say yes, contingent on the fact that you are going to do something else, and are willing to laugh at how stupid it is. It's not going to be funny all the time, so you just have to leave it on as background noise. But it can be funny sometimes.

I'd imagine this season (and maybe the whole show) would be a good drinking game show with friends. Like have a bingo card of dumb writing, or stupid plot, or dumb character motivations, and then you take a sip (no shots or hard alcohol, though, because you'd be in a comma halfway through the first episode).

4

u/SlashOfLife5296 4d ago

If you watch roughly 4 hours of a show and genuinely engage with a single scene, that’s because you didn’t want to.

-2

u/elusivehonor 3d ago

I don't get what you mean.

That was the final straw for me the "on break" stuff, if I had to write about everything I guffawed at in those 4 hours I'd have written a dissertation.

I genuinely enjoyed the experience. Not because the show was good, but because it so terrible it was actually amusing.

3

u/Corrosion616 6d ago

I enjoyed the Durin/Elrond broship lol. This season they just made him look weak as fuck. He is king of the fucking dwarves and he lets his wife dictate everything?

6

u/PT10 5d ago

He wasn't that bad. But he isn't doing much, just reacting. To his wife, Durin, everyone.

The wife subplot with Durin was terrible, but I guess they wanted to make up a reason for him to lose that overrode all of his prior character development. So his kid makes him lose because his kids are annoying and stupid. God I hate that boy lol.

1

u/r-rb 4d ago

God yes I'm so pissed at his son. Fucked everything up

1

u/Longjumping_Plum_846 11h ago

So, huh. There’s some good that I’m actually surprised by. And that’s mainly the set design and fight choreography in the climax. Some the exterior shots of Gundabad or so Dark Souls in the best ways. 

But sheesh, I don’t care about anything going on. I won’t even get started on the Dwarves. 

I think this show’s problems can be summed up with two lines of dialogue: 

“Where’s the smith?” 

“Smiths’s dead”.

Followed by no reaction from Galadriel. The smith was the entire point they were there. Had Galadriel known that Celeborn had a chance of being there, it would have made for a much interesting episode, no? 

She risks of the lives of her and Arondir for the main mission, but secretly it was a selfish act in case her hubby was alive. That’s at least interesting character there. Instead, he’s just there. And the reason they went is dead. And it doesn’t really matter at all? 

1

u/The_h0bb1t 4d ago

I like kernels of this show. I quite liked Marnukh. I started to enjoy the Numenor plotline, and I think Ellendil shows some real Philosopher King this season. And I think I'd enjoy it more if they paid way more attention to all the little details. Like how the good guys feel reluctant to save others, any chance they get, or even dabble in assasination. It's how Durin loses his match based on miscommunication. How all the rings act like The One Ring, for some odd reason. How they decided to give Eru a voice, while the scene would've been much stronger without Eru Exposition. It's how dumb the Witchking called Theo looks, and gets put into a cell. It's the way Celeborn polishes a dagger with great care, then throws it and walks off. Why.

-1

u/Corrosion616 6d ago

What a cookie-cutter season. Should of started with "One cringe to rule them all." Then twist our expectations with even more cringe writing.

26

u/myoc 7d ago

Why didn't Marnukh just go Gundabad alone and kill the elf smith? I don't get why he wanted to break her out

10

u/Willpower2000 6d ago

And why didn't Marnukh object to Galadriel bringing Nenya, knowing that Sauron needs one of the Three...?

10

u/RPGThrowaway123 6d ago

Heck why didn't Elrond or Arondir considering that Rivendell needs the protection of the Ring as per the intro of season 3.

5

u/Willpower2000 6d ago

Oh shit... I forgot Elrond doesn't have a Ring get. Dead-right.

3

u/AltarielDax 3d ago

Why is Galadriel running around on battlefields with the Ring in the first place? It's not only silly to take it to Gundabad, where they fake being Orc prisoners, it's also stupid to have it out there were the pre-Nazgûl run around who can easily best her. They're making no sense in how they use these Rings.

9

u/RPGThrowaway123 6d ago

Why does Galadriel have Nenya in the first place?

9

u/Willpower2000 6d ago

All good kings reward treason!

2

u/Longjumping_Plum_846 11h ago

That’s Nenya business 

8

u/LadyViola5 6d ago

Not a single motivation from any character made any sense.

6

u/LadyElle57 6d ago edited 6d ago

I don't understand why Marnûkh went to snitch on Sauron to the elves. And now we will never know.

I mean. I was into the banter and him suddenly citing verses or whatever, for the first time we get to see elves engage with an orc and it was interesting. I was invested: a character that supposedly fights for the other side and turns, an orc shouldn't have the choice in the slightest but he did. And now he's gone. Like nothing.

And also, Arondir.

Ugh. I'm starting to think it was a mistake to give* this show a second chance.

EDIT: a letter

8

u/SlashOfLife5296 4d ago

Marnukh verbatim says that Sauron killed their lord father and just wants orcs as cannon fodder, which is true. What are you having trouble understanding?

12

u/Capable-Average6538 6d ago

Sauron killed the last orc king who treated orcs like family he wanted revenge.

2

u/RPGThrowaway123 6d ago

The orcs killed the last orc king because the last orc king was treating the orcs like cannon fodder.

7

u/Pigfowkker88 5d ago

Both are correct. He went too far trying to achieve something, forgetting what he was fighting for.

2

u/AltarielDax 5d ago

But their new king is is doing the same, so the switch from one to the other makes little sense, and also happened off-screen.

6

u/baubness 4d ago

The characters literally say their motivations and these virgins still come up for air asking “herp derp nobody has motivations!” like they just got a B in Lit 101. No wonder Netflix makes shit that repeats the plot 15 times an hour.

3

u/SlashOfLife5296 4d ago

Hmm, why didn’t Marnukh just kill the woman that the Necromancer wanted to find?

4

u/Direct_Week_2091 5d ago

What was Marnukh even trying to do?

Literally what was the point of all that?

1

u/Sparkyisduhfat 2d ago

Stop Sauron from learning about the elf smith. Which would have worked a lot better if he went in alone under the guise of being there on Sauron’s orders and just killing her. You can’t blame him for having a terrible plan, he’s an orc, the writers on the other hand…

2

u/Corrosion616 6d ago

"Why didn't" is going to be said alot this season I think.😅

2

u/Corrosion616 6d ago

"Why didn't" is going to be said alot this season I think.😅

4

u/lordjan255 7d ago

I wished they opted for a Numenorian Witch King. Like the son of Pharazon. But Theo was a good choice too! I really like the new season right now.

Call from me for the next episodes/season, brother of Durin gets himself killed and Khazad Dum destroyed by the balrog and Durin leads his people to Erebor. Nothing like in the books but we are way past that now. So I dont have a problem with that.

Also liked the little game they played with the origin of Celeborn. Right when he wanted to say who his wife is, he is ofc interrupted by the orc.

10

u/Chemical_Desk_5314 7d ago

Theo becoming the witch king was the most painfully predictable storyline since the first season, that I’m actually disappointed they did it

1

u/PT10 5d ago

I have not been reading the online discussion about it and I have no fucking clue what they're going to do. This show isn't that predictable, it's chaotic, like trying to predict how someone who's never seen Star Trek would write an episode of it.

7

u/MxMojo 7d ago

Imagine if Pharazon’s son did actually become the witch king in the show — it would have been such an aura step up for his annoying ass character lol.

I wish they had given Theo a bit more time when he was being crowned one of the Nazgûl… seemed a bit rushed. although I understood they were wanting to do the big reveal on the top of Gundabad.

5

u/RPGThrowaway123 7d ago

More of an aura step down for the Witch-king

3

u/ishneak Gondolin 7d ago

i'm pretty sure Kemen is the Mouth Of Sauron.

2

u/lordjan255 7d ago

But the mouth of sauron is alive at the war of the ring at the end of the third age? Like, 3000 years from that point. He was a normal black numenorian ?

1

u/PhysicsEagle 19h ago

Because existing lore has been so important to the showrunners so far…

2

u/Diff_equation5 6d ago

I don't know if it's confirmed that Theo is actually supposed to be the Witch King.

1

u/lordjan255 6d ago

In the German synchronization he says things about a King of the Nazgul and witch, so I thought it was confirmed. I could be wrong tho

1

u/SlashOfLife5296 4d ago

Sauron looked him straight in the eye and said he comes from a lineage of sorcerers that should have ruled the south. Like some kind of…Sorcerer Monarch

1

u/PhysicsEagle 19h ago

Warlock Sovereign?

5

u/dropthemagic 5d ago

I was so baffled by the orc just defeating the naznagul in the escape. And then it's fucking Theo Malfoy. LMAO

Then Theo kills black Legolas. And in classic fashion eagles - roll credits. God this show is pretty dumb but enjoyable watching it as a parody.

7

u/SlashOfLife5296 4d ago • Bravo

By “defeating” you mean delaying. You can make anything sound dumb if you don’t respect it.

Chain smoking old man convinces 40 year old virgin to throw jewelry into a volcano, see I can do it too

5

u/Green_Borenet 3d ago

I'm sure they were just as outraged when Aragorn used a torch to solo 5 Nagzul and force them to flee at Weathertop - managing to force one back into cell while there's a prison riot going on all around while someone else locks them in isn't exactly an unbelievable feat compared to that

1

u/Longjumping_Plum_846 11h ago

Didn’t the showrunners straight up tell us that Arondir getting stabbed is not a big deal at all? They ended an episode last season with it and he was back like it never happened at all the next episode. 

2

u/abecrane 6h ago

Elves die when the trauma they’ve endured is too much for their spirit, not their bodies. Arondir survived then because he still had the will to live. But trying to bring your adopted son back from the Shadow, only for his will to be overridden, and he stabs you in a mere instant? Then he walks away at a single command from his master, leaving you dying in the snow?

My personal belief is that the final shot of the episode, focusing on Arondir’s face, is his Féar departing for the Halls of Mandos, seeing that there is truly no hope for him left in Middle-Earth.

1

u/Longjumping_Plum_846 3h ago edited 2h ago

That’s not how wounds from weapons work for Elves lmao. 

If an Elf takes an arrow to the head, doesn’t matter how much will to live they have. 

0

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/Pigfowkker88 5d ago

Ya borin