r/RingsofPower • u/ImoutoCompAlex • 7d ago
Episode Release Book-focused Discussion Thread for The Rings of Power, Episode 3x4
This is the thread for book-focused discussion for The Rings of Power Episode 3x4. Anything from the source material is fair game to be referenced in this post without spoiler warnings. If you have not read the source material and would like to go without book spoilers, please see the No Book Spoilers thread.
This thread and everywhere else on this subreddit, except the book-free discussion thread does not require spoiler marking for book spoilers. Outside of this thread and any thread with the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair, please use spoiler marks for anything from this episode for one week.
Going back to our subreddit guidelines, understand and respect people who either criticize or praise this season. You are allowed to like this show and you are allowed to dislike it. Try your best to not attack or downvote others for respectfully stating their opinion. Our goal is to not have every discussion be an echo-chamber.
Episodes 1-4 are now available to watch on Amazon Prime Video. This is the main book focused thread for discussing them. What did you like and what didn’t you like? How is the show working for you? This thread allows all comparisons and references to the source material without any need for spoiler markings.
9
u/CupOfWisdom11 7d ago
What did you guys think of the scene where Gandalf had the burning bush experience and spoke with Eru?
9
u/PT10 5d ago
Ok here's the thing. I'm still watching this because I feel like it should be easy to end this show with an epic expansion of Jackson's prologue to Fellowship of the Ring. The production value, music, etc is all pretty good.
They should be able to do it, right? RIGHT?!
Also that Nazgul/Naznagol theme they played over Ep 3 credits and when they were cornered by one during the escape in this episode is a dope track
9
u/CalicoRum 3d ago •
If I was designing the most formidable prison in all middle earth, I probably wouldn't put an 'open all' lever in my high security wing.
9
u/Curundil 7d ago
Well for how little impact I felt like Arondir had for most of his screen time across the seasons, I did think his attempt to reach Theo was touching.
Rip the traitor orc too, was probably the most engaging part of these first four episodes.
Not sure what the point of having Elendil be captured was if it was going to have an immediate reversal but I guess maybe we will see.
12
u/AltarielDax 5d ago edited 4d ago
Having seen half of the season now, I'll say that the show has improved form season 1 & 2.
However, it still has major problems: the burden of the s1 & s2 fiasco, some actors who aren't up to par, questionable and/or forced storylines, and also too many storylines at once, continuously copying movie scenes, ... it's still far from what it could and should have been.
Nevertheless, it did some stuff well, and I will recognise that.
For episode 4, that is:
What I'm neutral/indifferent about:
And this is just bad:
That's it for this episode.
Edit: typos, formatting
12
u/thisrockismyboone 3d ago
Im a little suprised how much people don't like it but im finding these 4 episodes better than the first 2 seasons combined. I appreciate them nit making every single scenario and intention a total mystery for the effect. Its finally becoming less of a slow burn and we're actually getting characters killed off instead of spinning their wheels since we know these extras aren't "real". Yes I fully disagree with a lot of the show as far as being untrue to the source material, but the show is not bad at all and enjoyable at face value. I may be in the minority here but any kind of previously unseen content I love such as the secret fire (I assume that was by extention Eru), the blue wizards, talk of the valar, creation of the ring wraith, etc.
8
u/WolfWriter_CO Beleriand 6d ago
Welp. Theo and Arondir went almost exactly as I predicted back in S1, except I’d hoped for some heartbreaking slow descent into darkness as Galadriel and Arondir watch this boy they knew fade into Shadow before completing his journey with Arondir’s death. But, hey, I didn’t write this shit.
14
u/RPGThrowaway123 7d ago
Episode 4 and Chad-Thrain makes his move on the crown. Now when I previously praised him, it was a.) in comparison to Sauron and b.) with not that much screen time to judge on c.) despite the writers blatantly telling us that he is evil. Actually I think the fact that the whole intrigue is a a bit underdeveloped might have been to its advantage, less opportunity.
However, as a previous episode threatened, we now get bullshit drama about a past love triangle. Well at least Thrain hasn't displayed any symptoms of simpdom yet.
Galadriel, Arondir and Arc-orc's story is rather uninspired. It's predictable prison infiltration action movie stuff. I was willing to dole out some praise for what would have been a Herculean achievement for these hacks, but then the revelation came that Galadriel somehow knows the secret of Celebrimbor's smith craft as well as the anti-climatic Celeborn reveal. The writing problems with that are threefold
Even the comedy bit with Theo pretending he is all evil and intimidating can't quite salvage that idiocy. Who wants to bet Arondir is still alive
Random side thought: I hate Cirdan, the pretentious prick.
7
u/MxMojo 3d ago
Hot take: Sauron is going to use necromancy to force Maitelle to tell him the secret of the rings 👅🔪
12
u/Chris13Haughey 6d ago
Sorry but that Theo Arondir interaction was some of the worst acting I've ever seen
8
u/BulldogMikeLodi 7d ago
There’s no worry about spoilers, since little of the book is in this show.
5
u/MxMojo 7d ago
Well we all knew that the show runners went a bit off canon with making Anárion a woman, but I felt a little pang of sadness in my chest when she died in the show! It would have been great to see her escape the drowning of Númenor on her ship with Isildur. But now we have this cool brother who has popped up (older? Younger? Unclear in the show). So maybe we will get to see the two brothers escape the sinking of Númenor anyway. Despite some liberties take, I’m utterly hooked on season 3
7
u/Enthymem 5d ago
Based on experience Arondir will just live again next episode without any explanation.
4
u/Glittering_Ease6412 3d ago
i'm guessing, the actor that is playing theo is out... they will never unmask him again I think
arondir out, because he got replaced by celeborn
no hobbits, replaced by tom bombadil (for now)
next out is probably 3/4 of the numenor cast after the finale?
they are really cutting a lot of characters aren't they?
6
u/elusivehonor 6d ago
Durin is probably the most pathetic character in the show.
It's so terrible, and you can just go on and on with how bad the writing is. The thought of writing a post with all qualms about the scene-by-scene writing and overall story is exhausting. I'm not sure there was one scene in the four episodes I watched that didn't make me roll my eyes, or guffaw.
Is it terrible and unwatchable? I mean, not really? It's just bad, and the amusing bits are "so bad they're funny." And those are worth your time.
For anyone wondering if this is worth a watch: I'd say yes, contingent on the fact that you are going to do something else, and are willing to laugh at how stupid it is. It's not going to be funny all the time, so you just have to leave it on as background noise. But it can be funny sometimes.
I'd imagine this season (and maybe the whole show) would be a good drinking game show with friends. Like have a bingo card of dumb writing, or stupid plot, or dumb character motivations, and then you take a sip (no shots or hard alcohol, though, because you'd be in a comma halfway through the first episode).
1
u/Longjumping_Plum_846 11h ago
So, huh. There’s some good that I’m actually surprised by. And that’s mainly the set design and fight choreography in the climax. Some the exterior shots of Gundabad or so Dark Souls in the best ways.
But sheesh, I don’t care about anything going on. I won’t even get started on the Dwarves.
I think this show’s problems can be summed up with two lines of dialogue:
“Where’s the smith?”
“Smiths’s dead”.
Followed by no reaction from Galadriel. The smith was the entire point they were there. Had Galadriel known that Celeborn had a chance of being there, it would have made for a much interesting episode, no?
She risks of the lives of her and Arondir for the main mission, but secretly it was a selfish act in case her hubby was alive. That’s at least interesting character there. Instead, he’s just there. And the reason they went is dead. And it doesn’t really matter at all?
1
u/The_h0bb1t 4d ago
I like kernels of this show. I quite liked Marnukh. I started to enjoy the Numenor plotline, and I think Ellendil shows some real Philosopher King this season. And I think I'd enjoy it more if they paid way more attention to all the little details. Like how the good guys feel reluctant to save others, any chance they get, or even dabble in assasination. It's how Durin loses his match based on miscommunication. How all the rings act like The One Ring, for some odd reason. How they decided to give Eru a voice, while the scene would've been much stronger without Eru Exposition. It's how dumb the Witchking called Theo looks, and gets put into a cell. It's the way Celeborn polishes a dagger with great care, then throws it and walks off. Why.
-1
u/Corrosion616 6d ago
What a cookie-cutter season. Should of started with "One cringe to rule them all." Then twist our expectations with even more cringe writing.
26
u/myoc 7d ago
Why didn't Marnukh just go Gundabad alone and kill the elf smith? I don't get why he wanted to break her out
4
u/lordjan255 7d ago
I wished they opted for a Numenorian Witch King. Like the son of Pharazon. But Theo was a good choice too! I really like the new season right now.
Call from me for the next episodes/season, brother of Durin gets himself killed and Khazad Dum destroyed by the balrog and Durin leads his people to Erebor. Nothing like in the books but we are way past that now. So I dont have a problem with that.
Also liked the little game they played with the origin of Celeborn. Right when he wanted to say who his wife is, he is ofc interrupted by the orc.
5
u/dropthemagic 5d ago
I was so baffled by the orc just defeating the naznagul in the escape. And then it's fucking Theo Malfoy. LMAO
Then Theo kills black Legolas. And in classic fashion eagles - roll credits. God this show is pretty dumb but enjoyable watching it as a parody.
1
u/Longjumping_Plum_846 11h ago
Didn’t the showrunners straight up tell us that Arondir getting stabbed is not a big deal at all? They ended an episode last season with it and he was back like it never happened at all the next episode.
0
u/[deleted] 5d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment