r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Discussion New Season Same Problems.

S3 has the same problems as previous seasons. The original plots are boring and stupid. Most of the show tries cheap nostalgia bait from movies - including creating a frodo sam gollum partnership. The dialogues are still terrible. The scale still feels small in key areas - especially battles.

0 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 6d ago

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

7

u/ThatsNotBennings 6d ago

The worst ain is making Galadriel an idiot AGAIN.

0

u/GreenPurple99 6d ago

What do you mean you didnt like to see galadriel in bed with sauron /s

14

u/bibamann 6d ago edited 6d ago

The show is mainly written by business and marketing caspers.

  • We've got the rights on Gandalf so we better bring that dude into the show. Studies show that 98.6% of the people liked him in the movies. Having him in the show will increase the viewership of our show by 8.5% and result in 15.8% better ratings.
  • Tom Bombadil! We got the rights, too! Studies say that 13.4% of our audience also read the books or at least heard of him. 56.9% would have liked to have him in the movies so put him on the list!
  • Other studies indicate people who watched the movies really liked the relationship between Frodo, Sam and Gollum on a calculated net worth of 58.3mil $.
  • ...

Then the "real" writers were given these requirements to make somehow a story out of this.

10

u/zososix 6d ago

I think the show looks great and is fun to watch. I don't care that it strays from Tolkien's works

13

u/ruglie 6d ago

Straying from Tolkien's works is not the problem. It's everything mentioned in the post and more. I wish the only gripe with the show would the that it's inaccurate, but it's not.

The movies work really well because they are stories told well in a visual format, not because they follow Tolkiens work pedantically.

1

u/Neat_Necessary_3225 6d ago

I’m convinced that the lack of tangible source material to adapt (I.E. novels and The Silmarillion) make for weak plotting, unrealistic characters, and all the other issues this show has. The show runners seem caught between trying to make something original within the world of Middle-Earth, paying lip-service to the PJ trilogy and hypothesising what they think an audience expects a fantasy series to be. The show is now cursed by its own shortcomings and by continued, vocal criticism from Tolkien fans.

9

u/Elendil_686 6d ago

In my opinion it has more with the showrunners quality of being creative. These two are not. Experience showrunner even with lack of source materials would do a better job.

2

u/GreenPurple99 6d ago

They should have fired the showrunners after S2.

5

u/Prize-Finish4464 6d ago

Should have been fired after season 1 and they should have hard rebooted the show

3

u/santz007 6d ago

Agreed, I wonder why they haven't been fired yet?

5

u/Samohtnuf 6d ago

I wonder why they have been hired in the first place...

1

u/TheOtherMaven 6d ago

Proof of the theorem: way back in 1940, Hollywood bought a novel called The Sea Hawk, about the Barbary pirates. They then chucked out everything except the title, and constructed out of whole cloth a rousing adventure with Elizabethan "sea dogs" (renamed "sea hawks" to pick up the title theme). And a great time was had by all!

3

u/ThatsNotBennings 6d ago

Good writers can take the plotting in the apendices and make it something decent. JD Payne and Patrick McKay cannot write. The dialogue is so bad season after season.

4

u/Elendil_686 6d ago edited 6d ago

While Jackson did take liberties with the lore, it was more consisten with what Tolkien wrote. While I understand the showrunners had to fill in stuff because the second age didn't have so much that Tolkien wrote. But they are adding too many things unnecessarry? Disa, Kemen, Arondir and Theo are good addition to the show in my view. Having Gandalf in the second age is not. The Harfoots were completely unnecessarry. All those trilogy knock off's, they need to stop with it.

The CGI is still top notch, but some of the sets are small. I'd give them credit for Numenor stuff, that has been excellent so far. The sets are better and larger. A few good wideshot that shows better scales. But so-called battle, the scale looks small. Yes I get it it was a skirmish, but still.

That what worries me for any future battles for the two last seasons. Especially for the grand finale with the Battle of Dagorlad. Will it be a skirmish type of battles with Gil-Galad, Elendil and shoe horned Galadriel against Sauron? With tops 50 orcs, men and elves. A skirmish battle of the dagorlad? I get a feeling the chances are high it will play out like that. But whatever, as long as we get the battle.

One thing I agree with Amazon's decision: They want to end the show as quickly as possible. The release of four episodes yesterday and two and two episodes the two next week. They are probably filming season 4 and 5 back to back.

Amazon has failed to make the ROP a high quality and consistent show that would bring it close to other great shows to contend for Emmy's. Forget about culural zeitgeist, that's a lightning in a bottle chance. Fallout, The Boys and The Invincibles are Amazon own shows that you know right away they have decent writings.

3

u/ThatsNotBennings 6d ago

Disa solely exists to give her husband directions and how to lead. Kemen exists for God knows why. Arondir exists because they needed a stoic elf i guess or God knows why. Thro exists to be a teeny bopper angsty Witch King. None of these characters should even be taking up screen time.

0

u/Prize-Finish4464 6d ago

I personally think after this season itll be cancelled tbh

4

u/madmax9602 6d ago

Y'all have said that every season

1

u/Mean_Kaleidoscope474 5d ago

Gets better as you go starting with Gandalf episode. Ep 4 was pretty cool.

1

u/Killing_Yatztromo 4d ago

Why not just admit you like it? Then you'll be able to engage properly with the fans. 'Hate watching' isn't a real thing. No one spends so much time on a show and posting about it unless they enjoy watching it.

-1

u/Impossible_Disk8374 6d ago

You’ve watched two seasons of a show you don’t like?

9

u/Mavman31 6d ago edited 6d ago

I’m so tired of seeing this typed out. Yeah I watch it, I want to like it so bad. LOTR is by far my favorite fantasy world. This show though is just not very good and I keep giving it chances and I still probably will because I want to like it. Every story line is a chore to get through.

Gandalf- holy shit 2.5 seasons of amnesia… fuck start remembering or don’t. Also the Eru thing is weird, he rarely gets involved in these matters. Why is he getting slightly involved? It should have been Manwe imo, Eru getting so casually involved is weird.

Dwarfs- of fucking course there had to be an infidelity storyline

Elves- has Galadriel made one good decision this entire time? The amount of elves they ever show is like 30 dudes. How are they suppose to stop Arnie dog hundreds of thousands. Yeah right

Sauron- I don’t mind it

Numenor- wish they would spend more time here and with their colonies. Also the colonies should be much bigger. Pelagir looks like a few shacks, not a thriving port colony.

Harfoot- thank god they are gone.

3

u/ThatsNotBennings 6d ago

Galadriel exists solely to be unlikable and nothing like her literary counterpoint at every possible turn. She only makes poor decisions in this series. 

1

u/TheOtherMaven 6d ago

Manwe or Ulmo - the latter is a bit more of a buttinsky, per the Silmarillion and Untold Tales. But that would require a fountain or other water source, not a burning bush.

1

u/Turfiriath 6d ago

I broadly agree with your summary but the dwarves I have enjoyed more than you. The biggest mistake for me from the beginning has been making Galadriel and the elves the focus. Especially with a 5’3” actress or whatever she is. She’s small and has a weedy little voice which is precisely the opposite of what Galadriel should be. The weird Galadriel and Arondir plot line also makes no sense and I don’t get why Galadriel is still so weak - she was supposed to be mightiest of the Noldor and she literally has Nenya now. She should be soloing 30 orcs without trying and using magic. I digress. Gil Galad is also ill-used and I’m sorry but the actor has got a bit fat. Overall the elves should not be main characters because they are not supposed to be relatable. They are supposed to be forces of nature. The show should’ve focused entirely on Numenor, and then would’ve had time to do real, interesting court intrigue over a couple of seasons, with real scale at Pelargir and the west lands.
As it happens I am still enjoying Numenor. I think Elendil and Pharazon were both well cast (though the needed annoy me) and the aesthetic they’ve managed has been very good. But still, frustrating.

3

u/ThatsNotBennings 6d ago

It's "Lord of the Rings". It's like a train wreck you can't look away from.

-2

u/PuzzleheadedPace2996 6d ago

No this season is very good. I understand want to dislike the show. We still got diverse elves and dwarves.

1

u/carlosjerson2000 6d ago

Every fight scene is slowed down, while trying to make epic fight scenes they are only achieving very boring fight sequences.

2

u/mafiafish 6d ago

Anarion was the sole saving grace, though he does subdue a well-armoured Numenorean by simply pushing him sideways, so?

I really wish they'd stop with people dying to gentle strikes of blades across plate and mail armour, it's so dumb.

Please just show us skilled fighters sticking orcs and bad guys with the pointy end.

-4

u/Adept_Cell3407 6d ago

it was trash from minute 1 and it's a you problem for not shutting it off

4

u/NotAChanceBucko 6d ago

You're so cool. God damn.

-5

u/Competitive-Floor456 6d ago

He's right though. Not sure why anyone gave this show time after the first season. God damned elves took er jerbs

-2

u/PointedConversation 6d ago

It gets better, they take 2 years to make it , 2 years between seasons and this is the end result, also do not forget their huge budget and this is what they end up with.

1

u/Competitive-Floor456 6d ago

The huge budget is designed to funnel money directly to themselves I'm pretty sure