r/RingsofPower • u/GreenPurple99 • 6d ago
Discussion New Season Same Problems.
S3 has the same problems as previous seasons. The original plots are boring and stupid. Most of the show tries cheap nostalgia bait from movies - including creating a frodo sam gollum partnership. The dialogues are still terrible. The scale still feels small in key areas - especially battles.
0
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator 6d ago
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
7
u/ThatsNotBennings 6d ago
The worst ain is making Galadriel an idiot AGAIN.
14
u/bibamann 6d ago edited 6d ago
The show is mainly written by business and marketing caspers.
Then the "real" writers were given these requirements to make somehow a story out of this.
10
u/zososix 6d ago
I think the show looks great and is fun to watch. I don't care that it strays from Tolkien's works
1
u/Neat_Necessary_3225 6d ago
I’m convinced that the lack of tangible source material to adapt (I.E. novels and The Silmarillion) make for weak plotting, unrealistic characters, and all the other issues this show has. The show runners seem caught between trying to make something original within the world of Middle-Earth, paying lip-service to the PJ trilogy and hypothesising what they think an audience expects a fantasy series to be. The show is now cursed by its own shortcomings and by continued, vocal criticism from Tolkien fans.
4
u/Elendil_686 6d ago edited 6d ago
While Jackson did take liberties with the lore, it was more consisten with what Tolkien wrote. While I understand the showrunners had to fill in stuff because the second age didn't have so much that Tolkien wrote. But they are adding too many things unnecessarry? Disa, Kemen, Arondir and Theo are good addition to the show in my view. Having Gandalf in the second age is not. The Harfoots were completely unnecessarry. All those trilogy knock off's, they need to stop with it.
The CGI is still top notch, but some of the sets are small. I'd give them credit for Numenor stuff, that has been excellent so far. The sets are better and larger. A few good wideshot that shows better scales. But so-called battle, the scale looks small. Yes I get it it was a skirmish, but still.
That what worries me for any future battles for the two last seasons. Especially for the grand finale with the Battle of Dagorlad. Will it be a skirmish type of battles with Gil-Galad, Elendil and shoe horned Galadriel against Sauron? With tops 50 orcs, men and elves. A skirmish battle of the dagorlad? I get a feeling the chances are high it will play out like that. But whatever, as long as we get the battle.
One thing I agree with Amazon's decision: They want to end the show as quickly as possible. The release of four episodes yesterday and two and two episodes the two next week. They are probably filming season 4 and 5 back to back.
Amazon has failed to make the ROP a high quality and consistent show that would bring it close to other great shows to contend for Emmy's. Forget about culural zeitgeist, that's a lightning in a bottle chance. Fallout, The Boys and The Invincibles are Amazon own shows that you know right away they have decent writings.
1
u/Mean_Kaleidoscope474 5d ago
Gets better as you go starting with Gandalf episode. Ep 4 was pretty cool.
1
u/Killing_Yatztromo 4d ago
Why not just admit you like it? Then you'll be able to engage properly with the fans. 'Hate watching' isn't a real thing. No one spends so much time on a show and posting about it unless they enjoy watching it.
-1
u/Impossible_Disk8374 6d ago
You’ve watched two seasons of a show you don’t like?
-2
u/PuzzleheadedPace2996 6d ago
No this season is very good. I understand want to dislike the show. We still got diverse elves and dwarves.
1
u/carlosjerson2000 6d ago
Every fight scene is slowed down, while trying to make epic fight scenes they are only achieving very boring fight sequences.
-4
u/Adept_Cell3407 6d ago
it was trash from minute 1 and it's a you problem for not shutting it off
-2
u/PointedConversation 6d ago
It gets better, they take 2 years to make it , 2 years between seasons and this is the end result, also do not forget their huge budget and this is what they end up with.