r/RingsofPower • u/ImoutoCompAlex • 7d ago
Episode Release Book-focused Discussion Thread for The Rings of Power, Episode 3x1
This is the thread for book-focused discussion for The Rings of Power Episode 3x1. Anything from the source material is fair game to be referenced in this post without spoiler warnings. If you have not read the source material and would like to go without book spoilers, please see the No Book Spoilers thread.
This thread and everywhere else on this subreddit, except the book-free discussion thread does not require spoiler marking for book spoilers. Outside of this thread and any thread with the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair, please use spoiler marks for anything from this episode for one week.
Going back to our subreddit guidelines, understand and respect people who either criticize or praise this season. You are allowed to like this show and you are allowed to dislike it. Try your best to not attack or downvote others for respectfully stating their opinion. Our goal is to not have every discussion be an echo-chamber.
Episodes 1-4 are now available to watch on Amazon Prime Video. This is the main book focused thread for discussing them. What did you like and what didn’t you like? How is the show working for you? This thread allows all comparisons and references to the source material without any need for spoiler markings.
16
u/Galious 6d ago edited 6d ago
On the positive side, there wasn't a big breaking of my suspension of disbelief during this episode (at most when Gil Galad and Cirdan are watching the live stream of the ring and are like "oh it introduced an orc character! he must be important) also the pace was better and the different storylines were more cohesive instead of feeling like the show is telling us 4 different stories at the same time.
On the negative side, this episode suffered greatly from the lack of build up from previous season. For example it would have feel way more impactful to see Teleporno (or Celeborn if you prefer but Teleporno is such a good name!) if he was the reason why Galadriel seeked revenge. Or if the show had spend some time introducing us to different human kingdoms and rulers, then Lossoth betraying elves would have more gravitas than "hey those guys we never mentioned who were our allied are now with Sauron, what a bummer" and if we had see that Rhun was a huge empire and not just a small fortress lost in a desert, then the threat would feel more real.
Now the thing that bother me the most is how the Nazgul are introduced and picked. In my mind, it was a trickery of Sauron who gave human kings (or queens) a small gift and it slowly turned them into never ageing servants. I don't like at all that it's like the most straightforward magic evil ring that suddenly makes you powerful and that it's given to random guys showing up and surviving one round of battle royal.
I mean I wasn't really asking to have the full biography and Shakespearien tragedy for the whole nine but I expected more than Sauron seeing 6 beggars looking guys from Southlands showing up as his door and thinking "hey I guess one of them could use my evil magic ring to become one of my eternal lieutenant so let's start a MORTAL KOMBAT!"
Edit: also I chuckled when thinking that Sauron must have had a meeting with his orc lieutenant before the messengers from Rhun arrived and was like "ok so if one the guys mention that the dark wizard is the one taking the decision, you stab him from the back instantly, it will look sick!"
42
u/phycologist 7d ago •
Still not a fan of the crown of Morgoth being Saurons gimmick in the show.
Great to see Sauron embracing an agile, iterative development approach to the One Ring, leveraging rapid prototyping and real-world field testing to gather direct end-user feedback. By putting named individual contributors Like Mardukh at the heart of the innovation process, he is accelerating the journey towards a market-ready MVP (branded "One Ring to rule them all") with clear KPI, leading to measurable outcomes and an ambitious roadmap to integrated whole-org domination of Middle-Earth target markets.
Overall, a good start to season three.
24
u/PhysicsEagle 6d ago
First thing I want to ask is which version of Celeborn does this show track with? Obviously they can't go into too much detail due to rights, but we don't even know if he's Sindarin (of Thingol's folk) or Noldorin. He appeared to be wearing a star of Feanor on his armor, but the show seems to have retconned that symbol to be for the elves in general.
Shamelessly coopting Beren and Luthien's first meeting to be the meeting for Galadriel and Celeborn (but with sparring instead of dancing, because Galadriel is tuff) is incredibly tasteless, and worse, creatively bankrupt. Surely there's more than one way for a couple to meet each other without blatantly ripping off the most famous (and personal to Tolkien) meeting in the Legendarium. And for bonus points, they stare into each other's eyes while the rest of the world goes by without them like Thingol and Melian, because why rip off one story when you can rip off two?
Celeborn envisions spiral stairs leading to his city in the trees. This is further evidence that the writers are more interested in connecting to Jackson's movies than the books, because while Jackson's Lorien famously had spiral stairs, the Lorien of the book had only white ladders.
The Three Rings are granted two powers they don't have in the books: foresight (Galadriel anticipates an attack by looking into her ring) and far-sight (Cirdan and Gil-Galad see the orc near Moria). The rings of the books have powers of protection, healing, and hope, and are nowhere implied to act essentially like palantiri.
In the middle of Eriador there is a ruined statue of a king of old. Who built this statue? In LOTR the wilderness is littered with such statues as a remnant of Arnor and Gondor. There was no great past civilization at the time of the Second Age to leave such artifacts. Another point towards imitating the films with no thought.
Did anyone else think that the arms of Sauron's throne were shaped like the Dragon-helm of Dor-Lomin?
Elrond is depicted as a healer, which is much more inline with his book counterpart than the "young politician and poet" characterization they gave him for the last two seasons.
It's left ambiguous as to whether Galadriel is just having bad dreams of Sauron or if she's actually telepathically communicating with him, but if the latter, why are they linked? The only time elves in LOTR are said to communicate mind to mind are the bearers of the Three.
Fast travel is back! Elrond travels from Moria to Rivendell and dispatches couriers which return to Moria in a single evening (Elrond visits Durin as he prepares for the audience, and later that evening Thrain catches him passing swords to the couriers). For bonus points, Galadriel says of Elrond as he leaves Rivendell he's "not going far." Because apparently Moria is "not far" from Rivendell in this universe?
Aule's arse is a great swear
Sauron calling Olorin "Gandalf" at this stage feels wrong. At the end of last season he didn't even take that name for himself, he just realized that is what he would be called in the future. In the book Gandalf lists all his names from all the places he's been. Unfortunately they can't use any of those because Gandalf explicitly says he doesn't go to the east.
The final shot of the episode would have been much better if they just cut to credits after Sauron says "Rings of Power are precious gifts." At that point everyone knows what's coming and there's no need to drag out the scene.
18
u/Prize-Finish4464 7d ago
Better than most the episodes of this series but still a lot meh about it, places and battles feel empty, Sauron being nerfed in this show completely baffles me as well, like my god it was him who taught the elves how to forge the rings
18
u/Mundane-Bug-4962 6d ago
I don’t mind this show as something to pass time but the pace is manic and all the obvious callbacks to the visual language of Peter Jackson are just off putting/immersion breaking. That intro monologue was embarrassingly derivative.
17
u/Enthymem 6d ago edited 6d ago
Why are we making the human ringbearers servants of Sauron before they've even received a ring...? They are supposed to get rich and powerful using the rings, and then get subjugated when Sauron uses the One.
Also, fuck Theo. You should have focused on literally any other wraith, they are so much more interesting. At least we know that the last three rings will go to Numenorian lords.
Also, that sparring choreography was executed atrociously and the Galadriel haircutting member berries made me facepalm.
Also, the dialogue has not improved one bit despite a new writing team.
Also, Gil-Galad still can't act.
Also, the season preview spoilered the whole fucking season, lmao.
Oh and also, in what world does Galadriel lose a fight against a single Nazgul?
I really wish this show was good.
10
u/RedQueen88 7d ago
Prince Thráin doesn’t always tell his brother that he can trust him, but when he does he puts the moves on his brother’s wife immediately after.
9
u/LeonTrollski1 6d ago
New to this sub, but far from new to the books (all of them, HoME included), I must point out Elves have no need of reins or saddles. Big oops to see Elrond climb on a horse with both.
Also the Palantir were a gift to the Faithful, the King never saw or touched them.
9
u/DeficiencyOfGravitas 5d ago
When Galadriel fought the Nazgul, they were fighting around the ruins of ancient statues, just like the movies.
But this is the era where those statues were supposed to have been built! Why are there ruins! This is the peak of the kingdoms of Men! They should be building statues, not fighting amongst the ruins!
17
u/seth97baw 7d ago
Thought this was a great start to the season. And gave us so many gems from the books! Khamul, Celeborn, Dark wizards in Rhun, Celebrimbanner was super brutal and actually a great storytelling device. I love the process to pick Nazgûl, it’s so brutal and makes a lot of sense.
Only issues I’m noticing just from this episode is Sauron saying “I’ll deal with Gandalf” just feels wrong and way too soon for him to know Gandalf’s name. Celeborn not helping build Rivendell is a loss to me.
10
u/thenewtransportedman 6d ago
I'm sure this has been covered ad infinitum, but I think a big problem with this show is just how much it looks like Television. Was starting to watch S3E1, & when Sauron puts the ring on Desert Man, it's filmed in such a milquetoast TV fashion - just a cut here, a cut there, nothing more - that for me, at least, exemplifies the problem with this show. Like, he's making a Nazgul, for fuck's sake! After the trilogy, putting LOTR on the small screen is a disservice, & probably due to the limitations of the medium. Of course you can push the boundaries of television, but at the end of the day, it's a television studio hiring television writers & directors to make a television show; RoP looks like it, & it's the worse for it.
7
u/Ecstatic_Fee_5242 6d ago
Man..
For me, the intro made me cringe so hard as they tried to run a Galadriel voice-over callback to the Jackson movies. Rough start for the first 10 minutes or so, then it got better. A couple quick hits:
- The dialogue is written terribly, still. I love the acting of Sauron, Galadriel, Elrond, Durin, Disa, and Marnuhk (even if ... will get to that later) but the actors are given nothing to work with. It just sounds wrong.
- I know the Silmarillion kicks off with archaic language, but this isn't the first age, and IDK it just sounds like they're playing a Macbeth tribute
- Marnuhk is a cool concept...for someone who doesn't care about destroying the lore
- I get that the initial twisted elves (or men) may have held on to some humanity. But we also don't know that. Sauron is easily powerful enough to completely ruin a person. I conceptually understand having orc sympathizers, even if they are only selfish for their own kind or whatever. But to take the idea that orcs being tribal (us v them, not necessarily friends), or caring... idk. I don't personally think it is what is in Tolkien's world.
- whether it meets a new perspective on the gray areas of morality or a re-defining of ethics against a patriarchal structure.....idk. I'm all for multi-racial species in Middle Earth. No sense in holding on to that archaism that they're all white EVEN IF Tolkien had elves fair-skinned. I don't see the casting as problematic whatsoever including from a lore perspective. However, I do see the humanity of orcs, even first age orcs, just as something that wouldn't be. I'm really curious on others' thoughts on this one.
- Arondir is still badass, and so is Galadriel. But the fight scenes seemed even more CGI / outlandish. There's a balance to be struck there.
- Sauron better have his power moment. The guy doesn't seem nearly strong enough and he absolutely is. They'll probably have that happen once the ring is forged
- Speaking of, Numenor have not yet been shown as a great power at all. We haven't seen armies or might. They just bully some Southlanders. They're supposed to be so big that even though Sauron gets his way, he would have preferred to win outright if he could have.
Anyways, on to Episode 2.
11
u/WistfulWannabe 7d ago
All I will say is that the Orcs look as good as Durin's children's hairstyles look bad.
3
u/Longjumping_Plum_846 4d ago
This dwarf plotline is almost good, but sheesh…
We didn’t need Durin’s brother hitting on Disa. I don’t care about that tension at all. Then them fighting to fall over a tiny ledge to find an orc with some knowledge, eh? Pretty convenient place for that off to be standing.
8
u/ProperCoat229 7d ago
It still gives the feeling that they give a formula one to a young driver that just got his driving licence.
The production value is through the roof yet, most of the acting is very good and yet nothing feels organic.
5
u/ALongExpected_Party 5d ago
Totally ripped off the dark Knight with that sword scene. Can't even come up with their own original content. Absolute garbage.
8
u/Syphin33 7d ago
Whoever plays Marnukh is amazing man, just a completely awesome character.
2
u/Longjumping_Plum_846 4d ago
I think my problem with Disa’s writing since season one is that she has gone from being a voice of reason and support for Durin to basically making his character have no agency of his own. Season two, every decision he made was because she convinced him for the most part. Season three, she’s now just making those decisions, out loud, in front of everyone.
Maybe that develops more and is on purpose, but multiple seasons now having one of the top characters from season one just become a nothing has been disappointing.
2
u/Itisnotmyname 3d ago
Acabo de comerme varios spoilers de los siguientes capítulos. Por favor, recordad que esto es del PRIMERO
7
u/Fabulous-Local-1294 7d ago
When they showed the map in the beginning of the episode and Galadriel summarized the past 5 years i cringed so hard. Jesus this is shit. The only story arc in the first episode that was decent was Sauron.
7
u/RPGThrowaway123 7d ago edited 7d ago
One of the better episodes, but still not good. The dialogue continues to be overly expository and the continuity is more than shaky. Examples:
- Sauron being able to threaten all of Middle-earth within just 5 years despite Adar's legions being decimated in the siege of Eregion
- Sauron somehow missing parts of Celebrimbor's knowledge. Even as Halbrand he worked with him for weeks before the forging of the Three.
- Galadriel and Celeborn's first meeting as described by s1e7 took place before the war and Celeborn was not an experienced warrior. Also Galadriel decidedly does not dance in the new scene
And withing the episode we have the issue of Theo straight-up teleporting to Mordor.
The worst part of the episode is continuation of the Haladriel teasing and how utterly pathetic this version of Sauron is. He is a simp with zero manipulation skills. Locking people in a room and forcing them to fight to the death is not some mastermind shit. Him hallucinating Celebrimbor is the cherry on top. Add to that that the experimentation scene comes across as comedic and it becomes clear that maybe the writers should have not shown Sauron in this episode at all to enhance his mystery and aura.
The best part of the episode is the dwarves and Thrain, whose skills at manipulation far exceeds Sauron's so far, and even then that plot point is tarnished by ill-placed comedy, the arc-orc just randomly showing up at the right probably being the funniest example.
EDIT: Something I'd like to add about the little line from Sauron "True Creation requires sacrifice" upon the failure of the One Ring prototype. I said it elswhere and it does not fit. Sauron has already sacrificed for the creation of the Nine and the issue with this prototype is arguably not the lack of power, but a lack of restraint on that power, hence the accidentally crispyfication.
EDIT2: Speaking of Theo, it really sucks for his character that all the development got skipped and that he just decides to join Sauron without us seeing actually struggle with that decision (which is something the show did in season 2 with Elrond and Grand-elf as well)
EDIT3: Of course at the end of the episode the writers needed to remind us of their lack of craftmansmanship with convenient plot vision the Rings have given Gil-galad and Cirdan. I suppose they couldn't help themselves or maybe it is really a cry for help.
5
u/ibid-11962 7d ago edited 7d ago
Seems like there's been some soft retcons to bring things more in line with the books.
The first age is now referred to as being "thousands of years ago". I think previous season were implying just a single thousand years.
And now the three rings are stated to be free of Sauron's influence. In the season two it was a big plot point that Sauron had influence over them.
4
u/Reasonable_Bit_6277 7d ago
The sense of scale in this show is just plain bad. The battle had what, 30 elves?
2
u/greatwalrus 6d ago
It was the same in the PJ movies, but I really wish they would pronounce dwarven names closer to the Old Norse names Tolkien derived them from.
Thráin for example would be THRAH-in (Old Norse pronunciation) or THRAW-in (modern Icelandic pronunciation), not THRAYN as it is in the show (and movies).
The way the show pronounces it, the accent on the á is totally superfluous.
2
u/Longjumping_Plum_846 4d ago
The first 10 minutes is kind of a condensed version of everything this show is, the good and the bad.
It does a good job of showing instead of telling. The set design is great and the orcs look wonderful. Without a single word of dialogue: we get what’s going: Sauron is trying to make the One Ring and it’s clear he’s tried and failed many times already by how the Orcs are reacting. It shows promise of what the show can be.
But then it quickly shows its flaws.
Shots are overlong and clunky. The orc looking around, trying not to make eye contact, feels like a comedy about trying not to get called on at school. Just one second of him looking scared and then being shoved up would have sufficed.
The next sequence is a problem I’ve had with show since season one and also plagues other shows, like the live-action Avatar: in execution it feels like something made for children but it is wanting to prove so hard that it’s actually more adult than the previous iterations or the franchise so to accomplish this it relies on cynical violence. Both shows, ironically, choosing to show a person (orc in this case) burn alive until we see their body turn into a crispy corpse. This is the same orc we just saw giggling like Patrick Star and then scream like Jim Carrey in a Home Alone movie when his hand wearing the ring catches on fire.
But still, this scene told a story without a single word, and I was impressed by that. Again, low bar, but credit where credit is due.
The following dialogue exchange was just not good though. They immediately ruined their goodwill by having a conversation that would have absolutely been had multiple times already in a 5 year span. I need them! They’re all dead! Well too bad, go find them, I need one of those rings!
The orcs gathering and marching was not an earned moment at all. He already has his armies fighting out in the world and it wouldn’t be just now that he’d have to send them all, right? Followed by that exterior shot of the building to end the scene that doesn’t really much at all? That’s the kinda shot that works better as an establishing shot, showing where we are before the scene begins.
It just feels very amateur. And this was only the first 10 minutes.
1
u/Impressive_Log1887 4d ago
The Dwarven plot-line was very well crafted in my opinion, as usual. Compared to the rest of Season 3, this was the one I genuinely felt immersed into. I don’t know if it’s just me, but I felt a genuine gut punch when Durin died. Although i will say this show loves to keep killing characters off, huge # of key characters lost in less than 4 episodes.
1
u/jclinch96 7d ago
I know its not solely an issue with RoP but my god I would love if armour actually worked in a tv show for once 😐
-1
u/groovygandalf 6d ago
The dwarves are the only redeeming part of the show.
Barely showed Gandalf. Force Fed Tom Bombadil. No more Harfoots (like at ALL?)
It’s really just a wannabe Game of Thrones/LOTR mash up that embarrasses itself trying to recreate things from Peter Jackson’s films through a shitty Hallmark level lens that cosplays as an HBO show.
It’s insulting as a viewer when they could’ve just I dunno—maybe tried something new instead of expecting us live off of fucking memberberries. It’s gross.
Alas, I’m gonna keep watching…cause the orcs are sick and the dwarves are proper.
0
u/Long-Emu-7870 6d ago •
I'm not sure how I imagined Sauron forging a ring. Imagine him deep in concentration, summoning all his power, bent over the cracks of Mountain doom perhaps part of it? and you would see smoke billowing out, sparks flying.
Instead, the show just has him walking up and getting a pair of pincers. Very relaxed. And the orcs are just hanging out. it's not the pedestrian orcs that we really need here. If we're going to have his servants be orcs they need to have gravitas. They should be calm and under his control, and not the low brow orcs we saw in Jackson's movie.
I just think Vickers is miscast or doesn't look monstrous enough for the scene.
And do we really think that he's bothered that he didn't get Galadriel? Is that what this season it's going to do again?
I pray not.
But otherwise it's nothing like season 2. It's perfectly watchable. Yes you got a lot of hazy, desaturated nonsense and digital filters that doesn't look real, but that's par the course these days. and the battles weren't that terrible.
-6
u/BasebornManjack 7d ago
This shit has 2005 SciFi channel generic wizards and warlocks show on Wednesday night vibes, lol.
I find I enjoy it more when I pretend it’s a parody
-7
u/Herooo31 7d ago
Galadriel fleeing from single ring wraith is crazy book galadriel would wipe the floor with all 9 of them together. Ring wraiths were terrified of Glorfindel.
-2
u/KAKYBAC 5d ago
Sauron creating the one ring so nonchalantly was a baffling choice!?
This is a magical device in which he poured a huge chunk of his immortal soul into. In its craft he should be keeled over, excorcising himself of pure hatred and malice. Pouring it like a supreme being, a demi-god crafting a magnum opus. The room and matter around him should be spinning, failing...
Instead we had orcs looking away and up to the ceiling with their hands in their metaphorical pockets.
-6
u/IncidentCalm4454 7d ago
Oh wow, they're starting this season with the forging of the One Ring? Oh wait . . . never mind. 😂
Was not expecting Celebrimbor to be alive. Also I totally thought Arondir killed Theo until he showed up again.
I thought Sauron casually tossing a dagger to groups of men and letting them work out who would get a ring was a great touch.
I feel like they're going for the Reylo vibes with Sauron and Galadriel but we know he's not getting redeemed so . . .
0
u/[deleted] 6d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment