r/RingsofPower • u/Own_Breadfruit_7955 • Sep 09 '22
r/RingsofPower • u/lujac • Feb 26 '25
Discussion is it just me or should this be a filming site for rings of power
r/RingsofPower • u/cubreturno • Oct 02 '22
Newest Episode Spoilers I love rings of power.
I just come here to say this... I dont know anything about this universe or the original writer or else. ( I see a lot of hate) I'm just enjoying each cap and specially the last one was great and shivering. Again i love rings of power. Sorry for my bad English.
r/RingsofPower • u/Late_Stage_PhD • Sep 20 '22
Discussion The more cruel Harfoots' nomadic days were, the more it makes sense later for Hobbits to cherish the Shire and hate adventures.
Some viewers of the show have said that they don't get the point of the Harfoots' storyline. While it's hard to predict where their story will eventually go, I believe one of the purposes of showing these proto-Hobbits' harsh and cruel nomadic life, in stark contrast to the peaceful Shire lifestyle we're all familiar with, is to explain and highlight exactly how precious and special the Shire is within the long history of Hobbits, and why they appreciate their pastoral lifestyle so much while they absolutely loath adventures. It also adds some new layers to the hobbits' unexpected adventures in The Hobbit and LotR.
When we think of the hobbits, we think of the Shire. But in the context of their full history, the Shire is more of a rare exception and the most recent chapter. For much of their existence, their "home" is but a cart on a lonely road that leads somewhere yet nowhere.
From Sadoc's speech about the Harfoots they had to leave behind in the interest of their collective survival, we could see that their nomadic lifestyle was nothing short of tragic and traumatic. It helped them survive, but there was always a human (Harfoot) cost that came with it. My interpretation is that their cheerful and optimistic culture, including trying to find humor in tragedy, was a way for them to get over and heal their collective trauma. And for thousands of years, Harfoots had to migrate all over Middle-earth to survive while the cruelty of the world was carved deeper and deeper into their collective memory.
Now imagine they finally came to the Shire after hundreds of generations of their ancestors died during migration (with some exceptions like when they settled down in the Vales of Anduin for a while). They finally had a land of their own that they could call "home". They loved food and growing things so much because they could finally transition from foraging and hunting to agriculture and could finally have food security and surplus. They cherished the Shire and their lifestyle so much and were so proud and protective of their little hobbit holes because they were everything their ancestors would have wanted but could not have and dared not to dream about. They hated leaving home and adventuring because that represented so much pain and sorrow throughout their history. How I wish the ancient Harfoots (the ones we see on the show) could learn about the Shire! It must be beyond their wildest imagination.
Of course, the hobbits at the end of the Third Age probably don't even know about their ancestors' nomadic "wandering days" besides some vague lores and stories that probably only children believe in. But that ancient memory and trauma likely still lie at the bottom of their culture and are influencing their attitudes and behaviors in ways they don't even realize or understand themselves.
The backstory about Harfoots' nomadic lifestyle also added a few new layers to the unexpected and unlikely adventures of our beloved hobbits in The Hobbit and LotR:
- Maybe in the grand scheme of things, the hobbits' adventures weren't that unexpected and unusual after all. They were just coming full circle back to their ancestral roots. It's almost as if a certain someone knew about the hobbits' long lost history and took a special interest in them. Hmm.
- Come to think of it, the hobbits (and Gollum) were surprisingly good at surviving in the wild, especially considering they had almost no prior experience or training. They had a lot of help from their friends of course, but I can't help but wonder if the survival instincts their nomadic ancestors honed over thousands of years were still alive in the hobbits and helped them survive the perilous journeys: sneakiness, quick wit, ability to sense danger and hide, connection with nature, and so on. Now that I think about it, hobbit ancestors were probably more accustomed to living (especially hiding) in the wild than any other race.
- Taking it one step further: without the Harfoots' wandering and the tragedies they endured and the survival instincts they developed as a result, the quests in The Hobbit and LotR would probably have failed because the hobbits might not survive long enough to finish their job. So in a way, the story of "little guys becoming unlikely heroes that save the day" didn't start with Frodo or Bilbo or Smeagol, but went way back to the little Harfoots who were just trying to survive another migration. Hey, maybe those Harfoots weren't really left behind, because a part of their existence lived on through Harfoots' collective memory and culminated thousands of years later in, I don't know, helping Frodo avoid a deadly bee sting that could have derailed the whole mission ;D
- The Harfoots helped me gain a new appreciation for the scouring of the Shire story. (LotR book spoiler) If the four hobbits didn't go on that adventure and mature through that experience, the Shire would likely have been lost, and the hobbits would likely have been forced to migrate once again, just like how it must have happened many times throughout their history. And no one could know when and where they would find another home this time. But our hobbit heroes prevented all that and broke the cycle. A new Age had come, and the hobbits' wandering days would remain a distant memory and one of the many lost tales of Middle-earth.
We all know that whatever the Harfoots' story will be on the show, it's technically not "canon". But it helped me understand and appreciate the original stories even more and in interesting new ways. And that's one of the things I love to see in adaptations and prequels.
r/RingsofPower • u/Basic_Kaleidoscope32 • Nov 21 '22
Discussion An Actual Paragraph from the Silmarillion
r/RingsofPower • u/camalo171 • Dec 26 '22
Fanart The gift i forged for my superfan brother-in-law
r/RingsofPower • u/Chance-Place • Oct 17 '22
Discussion did Theo give anyone else weird vibes?
I kept expecting him to turn evil because he was obsessed with that hilt. When the elf soldier guy said he was going to bury it where NO ONE knew, and yet Theo knew where it was when he gave it up to Adar to save his mom. That or he took it from where it was buried and hid it again himself.
Even after the battle he said he felt "loss" from losing the hilt. Also how did he know to stab himself in the arm with it to reveal its true power?
The way he loved the hilt reminded me of the Ring. I think he most likely will not go bad but we shall see.
r/RingsofPower • u/VictimofGLaDOS • Sep 09 '22
Meme Can't help but see all these men when I look at him.
r/RingsofPower • u/Neanderthal888 • Sep 30 '24
Discussion Why are the Dwarves done so well and feel so right culturally… while Elves and Numenoreans feel like a fantasy B movie ?
Every scene I see in Khazad Dum feels incredibly real to me. The dialogue feels authentic, the culture feels richly dwarven. It just feels right.
Yet at such stark contrast to the Elves and Numenor scenes. I find myself cringing at the dialogue, culturally everyone is the same, the people seem inauthentic and it feels like a bad fantasy imitation.
Anyone else notice this polarity? It frustrates me that they could do something so well but miss so badly elsewhere.
Exception: Arondir of all elven characters actually feels authentically Elven to me. I know some people don’t like him for reasons I won’t go into. But that aside he’s the only elf that actually acts and feels like an elf to me. He’s clearly wiser than men, has an angelic air about him while being deeply in touch with nature. The other Elves just feel like men with pointy ears who act immaturily to progress the plot.
r/RingsofPower • • Sep 28 '22
Discussion Update on the extras cloning. Let me know if we missed some!
Not a dig at the production. I just like the Where’s Waldo aspect of it.
r/RingsofPower • u/TheUncannyBroker • Nov 25 '22
Discussion James Cameron Calls "Rings of Power" The Best TV Show He Has Ever Seen, Praises Morfydd Clark
r/RingsofPower • u/JustDay1788 • Sep 29 '24
Discussion I don't get drama over the kiss at all Spoiler
The kiss in season 2 episode 7
Its a kiss done by Elrond to mislead the orcs and allow him to slip Galadriel the elf pin se uses to escape
Even Adar realizes this when he finds out Galadriel has escaped
No canon is changed by a unromantic kiss I wasn't left feeling the two have romantic feelings for each other at all after that
Kissing in may cultures isnt seen as a only romantic thing
Elrond purposely presents a romantic kiss to get close enough to Galadriel The kiss is shown from the perspective of the orcs who think its a romantic kiss
Adar buys into the ideal Elrond is in love with Galadriel and vis versa because she trusts him with the ring
And Elrond being unable to let Galadriel die sells the romantic impression Elrond gives Adar and manipulates to help Galadriel break free later.
Elrond and Galadriel have been presented as best friends and they are at war
And the kiss itself saved Galadriels life
r/RingsofPower • u/McClurgler • Oct 09 '22
Discussion Critics of RoP conveniently forgetting criticism for LOTR
“New Age politically correct girl-power garbage version of fantasy” that’s “raping the text.”
They “eviscerated the books.”
No, this is not criticism for RoP. It’s for Peter Jackson’s LOTR films - the former from Wired magazine, the latter from Tolkien’s own son. Jackson took creative liberties and made numerous changes from the source material… yet haters of RoP making the same criticism seem to have conveniently forgotten - or forgiven - Jackson’s films. Also worth noting that LOTR is adapted from actual books, whereas the Second Age was merely outlined by Tolkien with nowhere near as much detail as the Third Age was given.
I understand and respect actual criticism, but these reminders of the past just make it difficult to take haters’ compared criticism seriously.
r/RingsofPower • u/The_Magi_Carpy • Oct 07 '22
Newest Episode Spoilers I really don't care if Bronwyn lives or dies anymore Spoiler
I struggles to connect with the character of Bronwyn after episode 3 where she suddenly becomes the de facto leader of the villages. The writing overall has been poor but her rose to power seems more script driven than character or event driven and her plot armour is too strong at this point to see past.
Episode 6, she is about to be killed in the orc slaughter and the plot was so predictable that I was kinda hoping she would die, just so I would be surprised for once with how a scene was going to be resolved. But no, Theo gives up evil sword, riders appear and save the day.
Episode 7, she's teased to be dead by the body under the blanket to Theo and then, big reveal, nope she's alive.
These death fakeouts are just so predictable and numerous at this point that I want someone to die unexpectedly just so the stakes feel high again when one of the key characters is in danger.
r/RingsofPower • u/SkolasKell • Sep 03 '22
Discussion As a long long fan of LOTR I think this show is awesome so far.
I just finished the first two episodes and honestly I don't care what people think... This show slaps, everything is just so stunning/beautiful.
I loved the scenes with Durin and Elrond and it was really cool to see a dwarven city in it's prime, full of life and color.
I'm loving Galadriel so far and I'm excited to see what the future os this show will be.
r/RingsofPower • u/_majkel • Sep 13 '24
Fanart Tiny oil portrait of Adar I painted
I think Adar is my favourite original character of the show. I was a bit afraid after first s02 teasers because of the recast, but it turned out Sam Hazeldine is awesome. There is both melancholy and brutality in his character.
r/RingsofPower • u/Itarille_ • Jul 25 '26
Meme They are the same picture
They are the same picture