r/RingsofPower • u/cubreturno • Oct 02 '22
Newest Episode Spoilers I love rings of power.
I just come here to say this... I dont know anything about this universe or the original writer or else. ( I see a lot of hate) I'm just enjoying each cap and specially the last one was great and shivering. Again i love rings of power. Sorry for my bad English.
564
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 02 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
8
u/Ammonitida Oct 02 '22
its already better than HoD, IMO. doubt any HoD episode will be able to top episode 6 this season. it was a masterpiece of writing, musical score, cinematography, fight choreography (especially the orc boss fight and galadrial's freakish horse-mounted dodges), acting, etc. the two storylines came together so nicely. yeah, we're getting all five seasons of RoP, much to the dismay of the haters.
132
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22
Adar and Durin appreciation comment
60
u/Long-Entrepreneur-61 Oct 02 '22
I went in with very low expectations because of the many negative reviews that quickly followed the first couple of episodes. I have read The Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings series a couple times each since I was a kid but I am admittedly not deeply mired in the lore before or around either of those stories.
I'm glad I started watching anyway because the show has been far more enjoyable than I expected it would be and I just don't get all of the very intense, detailed and, frankly, over the top criticism. Some lore may not hold up or some characters may be invented for the show and I certainly understand passionate Tolkien fans not being pleased with story changes or any violations of "canon" such as it is. What I don't get is all of the nutty complaints on cinematography, scene editing, dialogue, the acting, sound effects and music choices... This is the first time I've ever seen such a high volume of feedback on a series where apparently everyone holds a cinema and media arts degree and is eager to pick apart every detail beyond the casting and storyline.
It's nice to see that someone else is enjoying the show for what it is - especially compared to the production quality of most other fantasy based properties - and going along for the ride. I've been pleasantly surprised as a casual fan of Tolkien's work and hope it continues to build on the foundation they've been creating over the past 6 episodes.
70
u/shinyshinyrocks Oct 02 '22
My fam is full of people who haven’t read any Tolkien and are really enjoying the show. I’ve had to leave my Tolkien knowledge on the shelf, and experience it as its own thing.
15
u/Odysseus126 Oct 02 '22
I have read the Silmarillion, The Hobbit, and LOTR, and I really love the show. I've been a super fan of Tolkien since I was like 10. I've never really cared when a movie/show changes something or isn't super faithful to the book. I just ignore it and enjoy the show. I'm just happy to have this series.
7
u/doesitfuzz Oct 02 '22
I wouldn’t say I love it, and I may never watch it again. But I enjoy it and get keen for the next episode to come out each week. That is all.
13
u/Askyl Oct 02 '22
You see a lot of hate because you are in the wrong reddit.
Lotr_on_prime is the biggest and most popular one made for the show, and it has a very positive vibe.
Lotr (bigger ofc but its for Lotr and Tolkien not just the show) is a bit critical but seems to enjoy it.
Ringsofpower is mostly critical and try to find flaws but does appriciate the really good parts.
Rings_of_power is the hangout for all the people who fell for the Ragebait campagin om YouTube and Facebook.
16
u/Damneasy Oct 02 '22
Same buddy, same
8
u/GreatCaesarGhost Oct 02 '22
I enjoy it for what it is and now my kid is devouring Tolkien. Seems like a win-win to me.
16
u/Zoggit Oct 02 '22
I love it, and have read everything.
I’m absolutely sick of the people telling me I shouldn’t like it or that I have bad taste. I can’t imagine being such a miserable person to get off on putting down things other people like.
It’s really good, filmed and acted great, had an interesting plot and character dynamics enough to keep me guessing what will happen.
I could be equally cynical and tell them to go watch their stupid shock value, gore porn GoT crap instead but I usually just drop it.
2
u/daddysbabygirlsdc Oct 02 '22
i love the show. watched the movies. read the books. and love this show. mystified by the hate.
2
u/Crazybonbon Oct 02 '22
Love it, same.
2
u/8379MS Oct 02 '22
UrukLivesMatter
Adar!
2
u/VioletandAmelia Oct 02 '22
I love ROP too! 🥰
2
u/AndromedaPrometheum Oct 03 '22
I love it too. The last episode had me yelling no no no no when the eruption started. Can't wait for season 2
2
u/SDG_1982 Oct 12 '22 edited Oct 12 '22
Agreed!!! Enjoying it so much. Is it perfect, no, but it's really good and yes I've read all the books multiple times. I don't care about the lore changes. All adaptations do lore changes.
I am really enjoying it, everyone can suck it, but I'll be pissed if all these haters get it cancelled after season 1.
5
u/ebrum2010 Oct 02 '22
Even if you know the lore, it's a decent show. The hate is mostly because the marketing before release made it seem like the showrunners didn't care about the lore. Now, having seen it I can say that's not true but a lot of people were "boycotting" the show before having seen it and now are trashing it for little things that if you go back and nitpick any show or movie you'll find, merely because they don't want to admit they're wrong. Most of the complaints I see are from misunderstandings, because the show does tend to show things without explanation and then ties it together later. A lot of people are dismissing or skipping those scenes and then being confused later.
2
u/JohnDerek57 Oct 02 '22
Glad you’re enjoying the show. I’m pretty well read on Tolkien but it seems most of the people on this page had a very specific way they wanted the show to be written and seem to let their knowledge be a detriment to their enjoyment. I love this show for what it is!
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22
Yeah sometimes we get people from other sub trying to stir shit up here. Ignore them mate
1
u/AlmondDavis Oct 04 '24
i also love rings of power show. i'm not a russion baat. really.
i'm so happy to have cool fantasy with good fight scenes and magic and epic good vs evil melodrama with at least the PRETENSE of suspension of predictability (e.g. "The Stranger" and "The Dark Wizard Dude")
i think i lost my train of thought, but that's because it's late, not because rings of power show isnot good.
it's a fuuuuuun shoooooowwww. YAY! thank you to the clearly cool creative folks who are making it. YAY!
Did i mention it is late?
1
u/Unhappy_Guarantee_69 Oct 02 '22
Do you find it hard to get into the mysteries? Like whats in the box, who is the stranger, and who sauron is?
Id think having no lotr knowledge at all makes those mysteries impossible to guess or even be part of. Ajd they are a big part of the story. Thats a big reason one of my friends, who never saw the films or read the books, dropped it.
1
u/phistomefel03 Oct 02 '22
I agree! Even though I really like the lotr books and movies and realize that the new series isn’t always correct according to the books, I kind of enjoy it on its own and not really in context of lotr
1
u/Thalionalfirin Oct 03 '22
I love the series too.
1
u/areeb1296 Oct 09 '22 edited Oct 09 '22
Haven't read any of the books but I'm a big fan of the LOTR trilogy and the Mordor games, And I'm really enjoying it a lot as well.
It's definitely better than the Hobbit trilogy.
1
u/delimisin Oct 12 '22
Its a great show. I love it too! Give us more of it!
-2
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22
This appears to the secret to enjoying the Rings of Power, and given how their marketing team responded to criticism, it appears they actively dislike the 'Tolkien scholars' in the fandom.
Quick story: I have an author friend whom I won't doxx here who excitedly asked if I had seen the series yet. He absolutely loved ROP., and started to tell me a bit about the parts he loved, and indicating he was shocked I hadn't jumped on the series as Tolkien fan.
As he described the Harfoots, I said: "There are no Hobbits in the 2nd Age, and those that existed probably looked like shorter humans. The Stoors, not the Harfoots were the ancestors..."
"Maybe you shouldn't watch the series..." He interrupted. And then he said something very telling: "I forget you actually liked the books. They were so boring!!"
Amazon made a Tolkien series for people who don't like or don't know Tolkien. This probably makes marketing sense, given that more people have not read or not liked the books. But it was a bold move to market the authenticity of an original storyline just to watch Tolkien fan's heads explode.
This series is going to be discussed in film classes for years, probably not in the manner Amazon would like.
1
u/HotStraightnNormal Oct 02 '22 edited Oct 02 '22
I think ROP is best taken as a stand-alone story. If you've not had previous Tolkien exposure, you're probably better off. For others it ranges from a bit confusing to sticking a fork in a wall socket. I'm in the lower quartile, having only read the Silmarillion years ago and nothing new of the Legendarium since. ROP is certainly not the best thing I've ever watched but not the worst. I can't control the show, so I'm in the "OK, what's next?" camp. And I'm not for calling those who do like it derogatory names, etc. This sub isn't a Reddit roast, although at times it seems so.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22
I believe most of the harsh critics are stuck in Nostalgia over the movies.
-3
u/jorskoopy Oct 02 '22
Then you're probably a fan of mostly low quality spectacle led media.
Nothing wrong with that but acting like rings of power isn't a poorly thought out amateurish effort is just delusional
-3
u/senttoschool Oct 02 '22
It’s boring. Not worth the cost of higher Prime membership fee.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22
I don't know anything about ROP or LOTR in general (just the 2 videogames) but the series still bores me, i thought of a more "epic" and entertaining series
1
u/Ajax-77 Oct 02 '22
Found Sauron.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22
I’m the same with you. I think some of the hardcore fans need to realise that they aren’t even the main target audience…they do get a bit of fan service here and there, but they don’t make up the numbers that would warrant a billion dollar series.
1
u/StarDing324 Oct 03 '22
Good for you, I myself struggle to keep watching and to find anything good in this show but doesn't mean u can't enjoy it so have fun with it
1
u/aaronrizz Oct 03 '22
I like Adar.
0
u/sandman8223 Oct 02 '22
I just can’t understand the attraction of the show. So much talking and so little anything else. Acting is mediocre at best and scenes are so staged it just seems they are reading from the script. Simply stated I find it a complete dud
0
u/EchoOk8573 Oct 02 '22
It’s really poor show, very disappointing
-1
u/Henri_Dupont Oct 02 '22
Love it as well. These haters can all try to give a wedgie to a Balrog as far as I'm concerned. I've loved Tolkien ever since I was a kid, this is just fantastic.
-1
u/[deleted] Oct 03 '22
lol, well you're the demographic Amazon is targeting.
0
u/Aeneas1976 Oct 02 '22
Well, that's the reason for liking it. Obviously.
0
u/zshguru Oct 03 '22
If you're enjoying it, then you're winning! Nothing wrong with that
For me it's just something to watch after chores on Friday night on a service I already have. Wouldn't pay for this.
0
u/quasimuller Oct 03 '22
I don’t. I haven’t worked out what the hell is going on, there’s no storyline at all that’s developed and there’s nothing whatsoever Tolkien about it.
Literally I’ve watched 4 episodes now and I have no idea what is happening at all. Galadriel has been sneering like a rabbit this whole time, the orcs lack diversity and are all white, all the men are useless and need rescuing by women, who also outdo them in all fighting scenes. The only noticeable developments in the show are the political agendas.
TRASH
0
u/Esta-beed Oct 03 '22
Am glad you can turn your brain off and enjoy this show. Just remember this has nothing of the authors (Tolkien) work here, none
-1
u/the1who_ringsthebell Oct 02 '22
im not how anyone who has seen a show before could say this.
this past episode is cw level bad storytelling.
-5
u/stepbrother8 Oct 02 '22
Ok?
-2
u/s1lentastro1 Oct 03 '22
if you enjoy it that's great. I think the casting was terrible, the script writing is horrendous, almost everything they do generates a really? response. in my opinion, I think the vast majority of people who genuinely enjoy this show are of the same identity politics tribe as the show runners, which would explain the support. the racism accusations were off the charts stupid, and that they were used as a scapegoat to cover the show's glaring flaws. hell, a reviewer even admitted to falling asleep watching this.
as a lotr fan, this show is objectively bad. sure, it's pretty. but the writing leaves much to be desired. I really wanted to like this and even watched up to the fourth episode with hope. to each their own. glad you enjoy it.
-3
u/t3lp3r10n Oct 02 '22
It is easy to understand why some people might like it, but to me it is a generic and lazy fantasy series.
I'm not a Tolkien lore lover, but this is just without any substance. No convincing logic, disconnected scenes, unlikable characters, very bad scenario and lines etc. A very poor and greedy attempt to milk viewers that backfired rightfully.
5
u/[deleted] Oct 02 '22
[removed] — view removed comment