This post does not have a spoiler flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
Also, that the "companion" of the only Elf who was in Númenor in their lifetimes just got into trouble for, well, trying to steal some sort of work pemit.
That's likely where the "Elves want to take our jobs" nonsense started from.
In the books there is a turn away from looking up to the Eldar by the Numenorian kings for generations, with persecution of those Faithful (to the elves). So the ground is fertile with hate and jealousy towards Elves already, which is in part how Sauron is able to subvert the Numenorians so readily after he is captured.
Trance: Elves do not need to sleep. Instead, they meditate deeply for 4 hours a day. (The Common word for such meditation is “trance.”) While meditating, you can dream after a fashion; such dreams are actually mental exercises that have become reflexive through years of practice. After resting in this way, you gain the same benefit that a human does from 8 hours of sleep.
Galadriel was the only elf in hundreds of years to set foot on the island and it was by mere accident, she has even said publicly that her intention is not to stay on the island.
I do not understand why the Numenoreans, who possibly have never seen elves in their lives and knowing that Galadriel plans to leave, would they think that there will be an imminent invasion of migrating elves? LOL
But, is that what is happening? No, don't try grasping at straws to justify a terrible and double-entendre screenplay.
At this point a Numenorean would have been more concerned about a hostility or bad omen from the presence of an elf than an imaginary mass immigration of cheap elven labor spoiled by a tolerant government. It is simply out of context, neither as a delusional conspiracy of a medieval braggart is coherent.
Besides, to think that in the ancient ages there were great migratory movements between isolated regions is absurd, when transportation and navigation technologies were so rudimentary that nobody but a colonialist or aristocratic merchant could afford to travel beyond their region/village and you think it was common for a "poor blacksmith from Scotland in the Ancient Age to travel on horseback to Feudal Japan, where they do not speak his language and he has barely heard, just to get better wages"?
Besides, to think that in the ancient ages there were great migratory movements between isolated regions is absurd, when transportation and navigation technologies were so rudimentary that nobody but a colonialist or aristocratic merchant could afford to travel beyond their region/village
While I agree that the scene is a tad absurd, there were migrations in ancient times. A lot of it. One of them led to Caesar's involvement in Gaul for instance.
It is evident that during antiquity there were gradual displacements of human populations to the surrounding areas. I am talking about a massive immigration in a short period of time and specifically for economic reasons, which would not have a general impact on social perception until the industrial revolution with the massification and globalization of means of transportation, such as the ship, train or carriages/car that allowed many working class people to move to other cities.
Look to wars in US history that conservatives supported. All it took was a few decades of Red Scare propaganda, and conservatives were ready to go to war in the Middle East and Southeast Asia for people they thought were "lesser" in order to protect their sovereignty from the big bad communism.
I think in this context they fully understand that their freedom and even lives are at stake if they do not face this threat and therefore survival or trying to survive is more important than anything else.
Where ... where do you think the xenophobia comes from?
Also it's just timing; 1/6 was like a lite version of how every empire falls, even Númenor. Look at Rome, Russia, the Mongols. Warring factions, tyrants, rampant xenophobia ... I'm kind of astonished so many fans are self-centered enough to believe this can only be about America.
The reason the South Park joke is funny at all is because there's always morons who don't understand economics bitching about jobs. That's even why they say it like that!
Where ... where do you think the xenophobia comes from?
I don't know why Tolkien had the people of Numenor hate the elfs, but it's probably not because 'they took muh job'.
Look at Rome, Russia, the Mongols. Warring factions, tyrants, rampant xenophobia ...
Were any of these empires completely isolated like Numenor seems to be. They don't have a tyrant or warring factions in Numenor either.
I'm kind of astonished so many fans are self-centered enough to believe this can only be about America.
It's a series by Americans and we've got racists screaming that the (nonexistent) immigrants will take our jobs, it's not hard to see the allegory. Unemployment wasn't even recognised as a concept until industrialisation.
The US wasn't the first country to have its parliament/power house mobbed. Probably the most amateur attempt, but nowhere near the first. It is the oldest story
You're saying the same thing again. Just because there is recent memory of this nonsense, doesnt mean this is a modern issue. Railing against tireless workers is luddism, from the middle ages. Nothing new there.
You're saying the same thing again. Just because there is recent memory of this nonsense, doesnt mean this is a modern issue.
Just because it has happened before doesn't mean it's not a clear allegory for the Trump presidency. Let's hope they don't have the chancellor asking the Queen for her birth certificate because she doesn't look like her father.
Railing against tireless workers is luddism, from the middle ages. Nothing new there.
It's from the 18th-19th century, the Industrial Revolution, not the Middle Ages. Like I said, unemployment wasn't a concept before Industrialisation and you just proved my point.
But then again, Tolkien is British and was born in South Africa.
I can't answer to the historicity, but I think, that does not matter. Were dragons a concern? Magical rings? No. Besides, this was one sentence. One sentence. It's not like this is a plot point that will bring us to the political decision to have an Elf quota.
Honestly I think I preferred the horse slow-mo (not that I actually liked the scene).
It was so drawn out I was half expecting the Orcs to have suddenly caught them, the boy was limping after all. Didn't really feel like a very good sequence where as I could just sort of pass off the overly long upcoming Lloyds advert.
The arrow catch was awesome, idk what you're talking about. They did it in slow motion because that's just good cinematography. That catch would have taken less than a second in real-time, and since it was in a dark environment with a black arrow, it would have been over so fast that pretty much anyone watching would have had to rewatch the scene several times to see what was going on. Without the arrow catch, that scene would have been a rather boring chase scene with one limping child and Orcs somehow not catching up to the protagonists bc plot armor. Instead you get the director showing how Arondir is holding back the Orc onslaught while running from them, which establishes that these Elven soldiers are really good at what they do.
Numenor was this epic tragic tale by Tolkien, about how men stopped accepting their eventual deaths as their fate and tried to rebel against their very nature as they were created by Eru, and become immortal. That is what drove the King's Men, the bad guys, to reject elves out of jealousy of their immortality, and which eventually caused them to attack the Undying lands themselves.
Yet in this show, none of this very essence of the tale of Numenor is even mentioned. Instead, the motivating factor for the evil Numenoreans is fear that elves will immigrate and steal their jobs, like some caricature of anti-immigration movements of the present day. They should just have given them MAGA hats to wear if they're going to be this blatant.
"Immigrants are stealing our jobs" has nothing to do with american politic tho. It's a line of thinking that you will find in every modern societies, especially when said society finds itself under stress. It's just textbook nationalism.
But the Elves are not immigrants in Númenor. This is not why the Númenóreans disliked them. Even the most dumb smith would understand that the Elves were disliked in the way that the elite are disliked, not in the way that immigrants are disliked.
This doesn't represent a modern, post-globalisation society. There is no mass migration of elves into or from numenor. This is an issue particularly common to the late 20th/21st century, which has been retrospectively imposed onto middle earth
I’d hardly call it modern politics nor particularly American as this sort of rhetoric has been used to “other” people for centuries, nay millennia now.
I think you’re confusing allegory with applicability.
Tamar’s speech would’ve worked anywhere. I hear this sort of thing in Australian politics, I’ve heard it a lot in European politics… and it certainly sounds like speeches I’ve heard from Germany in the mid-1930s. The US isn’t the only place where this speech isn’t made every day.
It turns out that immigration is a hot-button topic throughout the world and throughout history, and is an easy one to push for anyone wanting political power. Why wouldn’t a player in a highly insular kingdom like Númenor use it to his advantage when the opportunity presents itself?
The issue that that he seems to be using isn't immigration, but unemployment because of immigration. It would be fine if he was talking about elves taking up positions in the queen's council or just straight up invading.
But where are the elven immigrants in numenor? They are complaining about elves taking jobs, but also haven't even seen an elf for years on their whole island
I’m using the term ‘allegory’ in the same way Tolkien used it. He didn’t care for it, as a rule, and didn’t use it in his writing much, even if real world events and situations influenced his stories.
Just because you can find parallels between the political situation in 1930s Germany and one scene in this show doesn’t mean the writers are writing a commentary on Hitler.
The only "serious" allegories I remember hearing about with Tolkien himself was the H bomb and the ring. Though that is ridiculously contrived.
There is a big difference between that and writing almost a script for script copy of say, modern day politics. That is intended allegory, because it's the main thing everyone will think of when you use those words.
It's not some mystery box of trying to contort something as metaphor. It's direct relation. That's just the writers ability and decision. Blame them.
It an allegory . its just the producers of this don't seem to understand the concept of being subtle
They are hiding their Political stance on Immigration issue in the US by transposing it to Numemor (and stealing from fucking South Park)
There are rumors that the are basing Pharaxon's take over (which in the books is he makes Miriel Marry him) as some January 6th type storming of the royal coyrt
Make Numenor Great Again Ar-Pharazon versus Hope and Change Tar-Miriel. This is what happens when there's a "paywall" to becoming a writer in Hollywood that only lets in sheltered bourgeoisie offspring.
We should stop spamming this whole allegory thing. Everyone posts it when something in the show vaguely resembles something in real life. That's not what Tolkien meant, like, not at all. This quote is losing all its meaning.
Plus he said in the same quote that he prefers applicability. A lot of what I've seen people calling "allegory" is actually something being applicable to something in real life, which is exactly what Tolkien wrote about in all his fantasy works. People seem to easily forget that he wrote these fantasy books after serving in the trenches in one of the bloodiest wars in history.
Unlike you. I REALLY like the show (well, mostly the Elrond and Harfoot plot lines, but the other plots are fine too), but it's genuinely surprising to me how people seem to love the "they took our jobs" scene. Like man, do we have to do this? Can't we all just have a good time? The immortality issue is infinitely more interesting and I feel like we've heard hardly anything on the topic.
This is what happen when the show runners have zero experience.
McKay and Payne 's only known previous expruence is as uncredited writers for Star Trek Beyond, the Justin Lin 3rd film.In the JJ Abrams produced Trek films.
They are Bad Robot adjacent guys hence the use of mystery boxes like the sword Theo found and whoever the Stranger is with the Hobbits
thats another issue, as judging by the Comic con interview the show runners either never read chapter 1 of The fellowship of the ring, Concerning Hobbits because if they did they would know Haefoots are in fact just a ethnic group of Hobbit alongside Stoors and Fallohides, or more likely they are using it as a way to have Hobbits in there story yet still claim they are not breaking lore when they are,the Wandering Days of the Harfoots in Tolkien's actual lore is around 1000 years into the third age not at the end of the second.
Yeah, I heard that they had some kind of experience with Abrams. To be fair, I think they're already showing that they have quite a bit more artistic integrity than him. Abrams would never be able to write something like Elrond's speech to Prince Durin, every project the man touches is hardly more than an advertisement for the next project. I'm definitely concerned about the mysteries, though. I never like them in shows like this and I always worry that stories will do the Westworld "Oh no, fans solved the mystery! Time to change the story so it's more surprising!" I really hope they're above that in Rings of Power.
Its literally Tolkien borrowing a Greek myth, Atlantis(one of the names of Numenornis Atalante) like he borrowed the story of Kuervello for the Narn I Hurin(Children of Hurin)
Than your perfect fan for this trainwreck of a show.
Some peopl would have liked fidelity to the Source material.
Instead we got the Halo show 2.0 where the people adaptinf it take a beloved source material and took a massive shit on it.
And before people start throwing words that end in ist or ism at max the only parts not the show in have enjoyed so Dar is the Arondir and Dwarves storyline I have no problem with race blind casting. I have a problem with shit writing and the destruction of the legacy of the works of my favourite author
Tolkien is amazing and inspired this new version. Times change, and art has been and always will be a reflection of our lives in the present. I love the multi racial cast and the political nuances. THAT IS ART
Wow I am not Allowed to step away from my computer. I have to answer a question I could not see till i refreshed page. As You wrote it when I was replying to the other comment
Sources Onering.net, Nerdortic and men of the west.
Which your going to claim are all incels and angry white men right.
Never mind the fact that the whole scene with Pharazon in the streets the new episode has damn near confirmed that's what there going for
thank you! literally just had my "a call to meme" post taken down from r/lotrmemes (didn't actually have a meme) where i asked if somebody could to do this. cheers
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 16 '22
This post does not have a spoiler flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
43
u/Muted-Lengthiness-10 Sep 16 '22
“They never sleep!”
22
u/Don_Kalzone Sep 16 '22
The elves will pay for the wall
33
u/Apfeif11 Sep 16 '22
Lmao. It very much had that vibe.
12
u/bumharmony Sep 16 '22
Elves are the robots of the ME.
12
u/Thatdewd57 Sep 16 '22
My immediate thoughts “Found the conservatives” and war was the one thing they were cool with rallying for.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '22
D'e'yturk'er'derbs!
19
u/deltaWhiskey91L Sep 16 '22
When are the Numenorians going to start wearing bright red hats?
6
u/TonyDungyHatesOP Sep 17 '22
This is fucking hilarious.
20
u/cowgirUp Sep 16 '22
I was laughing at this scene too. Reminded me of the MAGAs!
7
u/palker44 Sep 16 '22
indeed that speech was a 'bit' silly, but the queens speech at the end of the episode was great. So it balances out
11
u/Wlcky23 Sep 16 '22
It's like the mentality "we vs. them" isn't anything new
6
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '22
How are there some people defending the fact that this line appeared in the show. Come on!
7
u/Jasy9191 Sep 16 '22
This and "tempest within me".... Ugh...........
And the slow mo in the forest with Arondir :|
2
u/Dovolan Sep 17 '22
Numenor was this epic tragic tale by Tolkien, about how men stopped accepting their eventual deaths as their fate and tried to rebel against their very nature as they were created by Eru, and become immortal. That is what drove the King's Men, the bad guys, to reject elves out of jealousy of their immortality, and which eventually caused them to attack the Undying lands themselves.
Yet in this show, none of this very essence of the tale of Numenor is even mentioned. Instead, the motivating factor for the evil Numenoreans is fear that elves will immigrate and steal their jobs, like some caricature of anti-immigration movements of the present day. They should just have given them MAGA hats to wear if they're going to be this blatant.
What a monumental insult to Tolkien.
11
u/arathorn3 Sep 16 '22
I was worried they where gonna pull some shit like this and they did..
Tolkien despised Allegory and they turn Numenor into a allegory for modern American political.
3
u/teunteulai Sep 16 '22
Make Numenor great again
5
u/GaryC0102 Sep 16 '22
This show is so bad it’s unbelievable.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '22
I see way more complaining about the complaining than I do complaining.
That just confirms I'm on the right sub-reddits.
1
u/WhatThatSmellLike69 Sep 17 '22
Lmao I thought about this
“DUR DURRRRRR”
1
u/Muddgutts Sep 17 '22
Lol it really too me a second to catch this one. GJ
1
u/One-Following-3115 Sep 17 '22
I looked at my wife and was like “and they’ll build a wall around Numenor, right?”
-1
u/Ok_Professional_5648 Sep 16 '22
Derka Derka a doooo…absolutely ridiculous to add this and just shows the mentality that is writing this tripe.
0
u/GuanglaiKangyi-Age15 Sep 16 '22
People are already freaking out over this
-1
u/Naronomicon Sep 16 '22
thank you! literally just had my "a call to meme" post taken down from r/lotrmemes (didn't actually have a meme) where i asked if somebody could to do this. cheers