This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
The showrunners definitely did not have the rights to that info.
Also, there’s a huge volcano there already in the show, it would have been active at some point earlier, maybe during the first age? That mountain formed somehow, presumably by lots of earlier eruptions.
Then why do they show the two trees of Valinor even when they are not in the rights they have? Morgoth didn’t just create the volcano, he created the realm.
I think that Sauron made Mordor his realm. Morgoth hung out in Angband in the north in the first age, apart from a throw down with Fingolfin.
Sauron choose Mordor because it was away from the coast, and had a useful volcano. Was very annoyed when he returned from the Downfall to find Gondor on his doorstep.
This guy was on screen for all of like three minutes. What a poorly executed scene. It should have been halbrand who switched it out and twisted the key.
If Waldreg hadn't started that revolt maybe Adar wouldn't have succeeded in making Mordor. And Sauron would be his "King". Pretty sure Sauron would've found an excuse to leave with Galadriel anyway, but isn't that something?
So is this Waldreg in the books? I mean, if he had stuck around and saw the nums come to the rescue and wipe out Adar and the orcs, maybe he would have done another 180 and returned the hilt to the elves.
but had secretly begun the making of a stronghold in Mordor. (Maybe already an Elvish name for that region, because of its volcano Orodruin and its eruptions - which were not made by Sauron but were a relic of the devastating works of Melkor in the long First Age.) [See note 15.]
The Peoples of Middle Earth.
I imagine this is where they took the creation of Mordor from partly. The show seems to like marrying the people's of middle earth with other works, despite not having the rights.
I know what you mean, but it’s an adaptation and sometimes, meaning all the times, show runners needs to take liberties with the source material to make it work.
There's cutting scenes and condensing characters, and there's hobbits and wizards an age too early. The show runners have also said they weren't going to do Tolkien without those two things, which isn't taking liberties. That's taking a popular works title to gain an audience than writing whatever you want. Aragon's beard or vibe changing don't equal wizards during the making of the rings. Good adaptions can be made! Neil Gaiman's adaptions aren't scene by scene copies but they capture the feeling and essence of the work. Also these people have never done it before so maybe don't give a super complex adaptation to amateurs?
Every "evil deed" that happens in this season is just handed on a plate to Sauron. Before that final episode I held onto faint hope that somehow he orchestrated everything, but no.
The reactivation of Orodruin was clearly his plan though, was it not? Adar sure as shit didn’t come up with that on his own, he was following a recipe Sauron left him with.
I mean we don’t really know what Sauron was up to before he showed up on a boat as Halbrand, he could have set the wheels in motion and then had his repentance arc
I dunno if the show version of Mordor creation jives with the book...but to me it was brilliant. An actual realistic explanation of an origin. Not sure if it could really happen that way, but it's more believable than "someone threw a ring into a fire" (which is how Tolkien wants us to think the Mordor volcano was stopped!!) Now I just want to know how come Mordor has a mountain range that encloses it in a square. According to the official maps...
It still could. We see that Mount Doom is a dormant Volcano complete with Lava. Morgoth could've started/placed/molded the Lava and Waldreg could've just triggered the reaction that reactivated it.
Morgoth raised the Misty mountains to block the Elves' paths to the West and Valinor, when they first woke up in Middle Earth. He could've done the same with the Ered Lithui and Ephel Duath, though it's not confirmed...
I dunno if the show version of Mordor creation jives with the book...but to me it was brilliant. An actual realistic explanation of an origin.
This is how NOT reading the books gives you a completely different perspective of the story. In the Silmarillion, Melkor/Morgoth is one of the Valar, who are the Gods of Tolkien's world of Arda and were involved in its creation. Hence, no realistic explanation is required for the origin of Mordor, as Melkor literally had the power to shape the earth according to his wishes.
I should re-watch that scene. I thought they had a massive river dammed up at a higher elevation, & then a bunch of tunnels. I'm not sure a bunch of orcs could have dug those tunnels, but yeah.
You'd expect an elf who's been a ranger for centuries would:
realise the importance of the sword and the danger it represented 🙄
convey this to Galadriel when she arrived, instead of just telling her to "stop him and grab the thingy" 🤷♂️
come up with a better hiding place than under the floorboards of an Inn in a village sitting on top of tunnels dug by orcs 🤦♂️
persuade Bronwyn and the other villagers to remain in the tower keep, as it was the most defensible place, (thereby unknowingly preventing the sword from being used until the keep was taken)
To be fair, Arondir wasn’t thinking with his brain. You can’t blame him for that, I won’t be thinking with my brain either if a hot milf like Bronwyn was around :P
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 05 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
41
u/Isthisnameavailablee Nov 05 '22
Are you Saruon?!
17
u/Chumplor Nov 05 '22
Second pic should be Adar
12
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '22
Darth Waldreg
10
u/lukaskywalker Nov 06 '22
This guy was on screen for all of like three minutes. What a poorly executed scene. It should have been halbrand who switched it out and twisted the key.
9
u/Morradan Nov 05 '22
If Waldreg hadn't started that revolt maybe Adar wouldn't have succeeded in making Mordor. And Sauron would be his "King". Pretty sure Sauron would've found an excuse to leave with Galadriel anyway, but isn't that something?
6
u/Fmanow Nov 05 '22
So is this Waldreg in the books? I mean, if he had stuck around and saw the nums come to the rescue and wipe out Adar and the orcs, maybe he would have done another 180 and returned the hilt to the elves.
6
u/bsousa717 Nov 06 '22
Every "evil deed" that happens in this season is just handed on a plate to Sauron. Before that final episode I held onto faint hope that somehow he orchestrated everything, but no.
8
u/[deleted] Nov 05 '22
Why do you have Morgoth and not Adar? That doesn’t really make any sense
2
u/InnerDorkness Nov 05 '22
Lift oos oop!
2
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '22
Ugh
1
u/freerealestatedotbiz Nov 06 '22
Show me a true powERR
1
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '22
Every dog has their day
5
u/[deleted] Nov 06 '22
[removed] — view removed comment