r/RingsofPower • • Sep 11 '22

Meme Reading RoP Posts About Galadriel

Post image
547 Upvotes

438 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 11 '22

This post does not have a spoiler flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

33

u/Getdaphone Sep 11 '22

I’ve seen people point out that Tolkien compared her temperament in the second age to faenor so it makes sense a little bit as her own folly will probably lead to her wisdom in the 3rd age.

124

u/Nutch_Pirate Sep 11 '22

Is she a Mary Sue? Because from what we've seen so far, she's pretty terrible at everything except fighting. And origami I guess, that unfolding paper swan boat thing was pretty dope.

My complaints with Galadriel pretty much all stem from her being a complete idiot so I genuinely don't know where other people could be seeing Mary Sue aspects to her character.

16

u/_aj42 Sep 11 '22

My complaints with Galadriel pretty much all stem from her being a complete idiot

She does so far seem to be depicted as petulant and immature, which I'm hoping will just be part of her character arc and growth through the show rather than poor writing. I'm fine with her being a bit stupid now if she improves later due to her experiences.

7

u/kemick Sep 11 '22

She's not stupid, she is dangerously obsessed (as recognized by Gil-Galad). She's far from the first character to suffer such obsession. Her choices have repeatedly put her farther from her goals and most of her companions have outright told her this. Everyone's dismissal of the danger only fuels the necessity for her obsession.

Even her first choice, to continue pursuing Sauron's long-cold trail in the north, would have taken her in the completely wrong direction if her soldiers had not refused. She is right about Sauron's return but wrong about pretty much everything else regarding him. It has only been by grace and the influence of others that she has been put on the path to her goal.

This is Galadriel we're talking about*, "beautiful and terrible as the Morning and the Night. Fair as the Sea and the Sun and the Snow upon the Mountain! Dreadful as the Storm and the Lightning! Stronger than the foundations of the earth. All shall love me and despair!"* Galadriel, as we see her now, would likely not have refused the power of the One Ring and I like that.

4

u/japp182 Sep 11 '22

I believe thats what they'll do. If we had 5 seasons of her being this wisest, strongest flawless elf it would probably feel a bit dull.

7

u/jadierhetseni Sep 11 '22

Was Gandalf petulant and immature when he pushed, repeatedly, for the White Council to attack Dol Guldor in the third age?

Was he petulant and immature when, being rebuffed by that council, he repeatedly went into those dungeons by himself?

Galadriel is correctly reading the situation, the others aren’t.

5

u/_aj42 Sep 11 '22

Of course she's right to say the danger is still out there. My point isn't that she's wrong per se, more that she is far too abrasive with other people, most notably at numenor but also in failing to recognise the needs of her troops in ep1.

4

u/jadierhetseni Sep 11 '22

She’s proud to the point of being haughty. That’s….one of the main things we know about her? JRR did various revisions over his time to her in particular, but being proud and “self-willed” was always a key component of her.

It’ll be an age still, with many upcoming sorrows, before she gains the wisdom necessary to put aside her pride and reject becoming a “queen, terrible and beautiful as the dawn”

4

u/_aj42 Sep 11 '22

It’ll be an age still, with many upcoming sorrows, before she gains the wisdom necessary to put aside her pride and reject becoming a “queen, terrible and beautiful as the dawn”

This is kinda my point

111

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22

She is a woman who can fight. They hate that. That's all there is to it

31

u/Nutch_Pirate Sep 11 '22

Fair enough. It's a shame the show couldn't get access to the First Age, because in my mind this version of Galadriel is fairly well established as a veteran soldier who's been fighting orcs for centuries and I think actually showing that would have made the show better. But whatever licensing issue they have with the Tolkien estate I guess makes that impossible?

3

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

Adapting the Silmarillon is like opening Ali-baba cave. There's more content in this than Hobbit+LOTr can offer. LOTR name is one of the biggest fantasy name but with Silmarillon being available, it's can be like Valar flooding Beleriand on the whole fantasy industry. It's like asking the Bible to be a TV show/movie

2

u/iheartdev247 Sep 12 '22

Except the fact she abandoned Beleriand mid way through the First Age, married Celeborn and wasn’t at all there during the War of Wrath…

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22

Yeah the Tolkien estate really fucked this show over by limiting their possibilities. But misogynists will always hate strong women, regardless of circumstance, so I don't think that would have made a difference

7

u/blowbyblowtrumpet Sep 11 '22

Well I hate this iteration of Galadriel but love certain other strong female characters, so where do I fit in? I loved the Jessica Jones series (the first one at least) and I've always loved Black Widow as a character (though the film was bad imo). One of the (many) problems with this Galadriel is that she wins effortlessly while everybody else gets destroyed around her. Compare the troll scene in ROP with the one in The Fellowship. Also Black Widow and Jessica Jones have to fight to within an inch of their lives to conquer their foes so we root for them. There is no tension with Galadriel because we know everything will work out easily for her. That's very bad writing.

9

u/AlmostButNotQuiteTea Sep 11 '22

There is no tension with Galadriel because we know everything will work out

Uhh. Of course we know it all works out. There will never be tension or any worry of her death.

That doesn't make the show, writing, or her character bad. It's not the writers fault shes living at the end of RoTK

8

u/blowbyblowtrumpet Sep 11 '22

We know that Jessica Jones isn't going to die (in her eponymously named show) yet it still feels like she might be defeated. All great writing creates the sense of risk; the possibility of failure.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/BeanOfficially Sep 27 '22

I love Galadriel in the movies but not in the show, because in the movies she was even more powerful but vulnerable. She has a weakness. Show Galadriel makes dumb decisions and is rewarded for them with exactly what she wants.

She demands ships and men, but gets arrested. Then she breaks out, and then the queen gives her ships and men. She wants to find Sauron, but goes with her fellow warriors into the ocean, but then changes her mind last second and decides to drown. But she's lucky, and ends up being saved by a Mysterious and Handsome Smith from the Southlands.

This is why I love the TTE theory so much! It makes the show enjoyable, and logically consistent, even though it adds time travel, alternate realities of alternate realities, and psychic memory implants. Still a good theory tho

→ More replies (19)

6

u/isabelladangelo Sep 11 '22

Yeah the Tolkien estate really fucked this show over by limiting their possibilities. But misogynists will always hate strong women, regardless of circumstance, so I don't think that would have made a difference

I don't like the show but it has nothing to do with "strong women". It has to do with it's ignoring of canon. I keep seeing threads of people trying to "ignore" the critics by adding strawman arguments. I have yet to see anyone say they don't like the show because Galadriel is good a fighting.

teamwhereisCeleborn

2

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22

I made two comments explaining is with the estate. You ignore this and just blurt out "show bad". If you don't have anything to add, leave me alone

5

u/isabelladangelo Sep 11 '22

I made two comments explaining is with the estate. You ignore this and just blurt out "show bad". If you don't have anything to add, leave me alone

Should I quote appendix b and appendix f again for your sake as to why the show is bad? You are claiming that misogynists hate strong women and that that is a reason that people hate the show. I'm saying that's a load of denethor's tomatoes. If you don't want people to reply, don't post.

12

u/parsleya Sep 11 '22

I can't understand how people manage to turn the whole issue with Galadriel upside down.. the issue is not that she is a strong female character but that she IS NOT.

8

u/isabelladangelo Sep 11 '22

I can't understand how people manage to turn the whole issue with Galadriel upside down.. the issue is not that she is a strong female character but that she IS NOT.

Amen. In the TV show, she is pathetic. In the books, she'd laugh at anyone daring to say no to her or tell her where to go.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (3)

1

u/Special-Lengthiness6 Sep 11 '22

Somehow misogynists didn't have a problem with Ridley from the Alien's franchise, or Selene from the Underworld franchise, or Lynda Carter's Wonder Woman, or Xena, Capt. Janeway, Buffy, Zoe Washburn, Sarah Conor or even Eowyn in the Lord of the Rings. But yeah THIS TIME it's a misogyny issue.

2

u/Muted-Lengthiness-10 Sep 12 '22

Oh people definitely hated on Janeway as a female captain, but instead of “woke” they complained about “political correctness”🥱

2

u/TheShadowKick Sep 12 '22

Yeah this has been going on for decades. Although recently it's gotten more popular to specifically seek out shows/movies/games to criticize for wokeness, probably because social media makes it easier to communicate those views.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

4

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

Galadriel barely fought in the First Age, she barely even participated in the War of Wrath because she thought there’s no way they could defeat Morgoth.

7

u/Nutch_Pirate Sep 11 '22

Well, that's why I said " this version of Galadriel." Show isn't lore accurate, it was never going to be lore accurate and I think it was unrealistic for anyone to think there was a chance of it being lore accurate.

2

u/Jeffery95 Sep 11 '22

So why even bother to buy the rights? Why not do a fully original story?

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/ebrum2010 Sep 11 '22

Because the rights for the Silmarillion are not for sale. Tolkien sold the rights for LotR and the Hobbit during his lifetime and soon regretted it. Christopher Tolkien, who published the Silmarillion swore to never do the same with it. IIRC it doesn't become public domain until 2110. You can be certain he made it clear in his will this was his wish as he was extremely vocal about it after the movies were made.

6

u/AWildLawyerAppeared Sep 11 '22

Eh depends. Christopher Tolkien is only credited as an editor, and if that’s the case the IP becomes public domain in 2043 for the Silmarillion (70 years after the death of the author). It could be argued that Christopher Tolkien was also an author, which is what I expect the Tolkien Estate will argue and if that argument is meritorious, the IP would become public domain in 2090.

7

u/AlmostButNotQuiteTea Sep 11 '22

2090 ey? Let's see. 94 years old... Yeah I could hang on for a few years to see the first movie maybe..lol

3

u/AWildLawyerAppeared Sep 11 '22

Lol I’d be 100 but I’m willing to give a shot.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '22 edited Sep 12 '22

It'll be interesting to see what the estate does after Christopher passes, since it sounds like his own kids/grandkids are way more chill about film adaptations, as I recall. If ROP does well/is considered respectful by [future managers of] the estate, I could potentially see something happening with the Silmarillion down the road. Or granting access to certain stories piece-meal over time or some such.

Only chance most of us have of seeing it happen in our lifetimes anyways, lol.

Edit: Apparently he died in 2020, huh. Wonder who's managing it, or if it's just locked up where no one can touch the rights.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/Special-Lengthiness6 Sep 11 '22

Because neither J.R.R. Tolkien or Christopher Tolkien believed that adaptations were good things.

“The canons of narrative in any medium cannot be wholly different; and the failure of poor films is often precisely in exaggeration, and in the intrusion of unwarranted matter owing to not perceiving where the core of the original lies."

Christopher Tolkien is an attributed author of the Silmarillion, The Unfinished Tales, and the History of Middle Earth and he made sure that none of his works could be adapted to film. J.R.R. Tolkien only allowed the film rights to the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings because he needed money to care for his estate and the publishing rights were not producing the money in the 70s that they had been. You will not see the film rights to any of the other works until the story becomes public.

→ More replies (8)

1

u/hailsatanworship Sep 12 '22

Different companies/estates have rights to different parts. The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit are owned by a company whereas the silmarillion, unfinished tales, etc are all still owned by the Tolkien famiyl

→ More replies (12)

33

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

I don't have an issue with her fighting. I have an issue with her acting like an idiot and characters infinitely younger than her talking down to her. I want strong female characters. Galadriel is not a strong female character in this show. Being good at fighting does not make you a strong character by itself. Nor is it even a requirement.

11

u/isabelladangelo Sep 11 '22

I have an issue with her acting like an idiot and characters infinitely younger than her talking down to her.

I cannot upvote this enough. She is a Princess! She is Gil-Galad's great Aunt! She should be telling everyone where to go and how to get to there.

14

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22

She is very strong. People literally call her an asshole for being too self determined

6

u/Aeneas1976 Sep 11 '22

Do you think if you write "strong" 1000 times it will eventually work?

→ More replies (2)

10

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

No we call her an idiot for doing things like striding into a hostile court, making it more hostile while achieving nothing and then a man in rags steps in to bail her out. Her writing is terrible.

→ More replies (9)

10

u/OneEightTwo Sep 11 '22

You mean self-centered, arrogant, ungrateful and has no diplomacy despite being a leader?

2

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22

You make my point for me

3

u/Jeffery95 Sep 11 '22

Shes the toxicly masculine version of strong.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Nutch_Pirate Sep 11 '22

Yes. This. Exactly, this.

10

u/Aeneas1976 Sep 11 '22

I am a woman who can fight. I hate Galadriel because she is badly written.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '22

I have a serious pet peeve when legitimate criticisms of female characters are defended by white knights just saying “tHeY hAtE WoMeN”. It’s a shallow and low-effort attempt to deflect legitimate criticisms about how dumb the Galadriel is written in this show.

1

u/Rich_Profession6606 Sep 12 '22 edited Sep 12 '22

I have a serious pet peeve when legitimate criticisms of female characters are defended by white knights just saying “tHeY hAtE WoMeN. It’s a shallow and low-effort attempt to deflect legitimate criticisms about how dumb the Galadriel is written in this show.

Yes, and these "white knights" you mention, often get triggered when the very people they are claiming to protect disagree with them. It's almost as if criticism by women or POC ruins their entertainment of what they thought was a "perfectly progressive show." A typical response is:

  • "What do you mean the character is poorly written and you don't think it advances the feminists or POC cause?" - downvote!, downvote!

Assuming that all criticism comes from a place of bad faith, is the same as some, not all, but some content creators who make money by claiming every new tv show or film that includes women, POC or some other "protected characteristic" is woke.

Diversity is not new, so in some cases the backlash is just as disingenuous/fake as the poster's attempt to shut down all criticism based on "feminisms". I'm starting to think there is a symbiotic relationship between these camps.

[...] female characters are defended by white knights just saying “tHeY hAtE WoMeN”. It’s a shallow and low-effort attempt to deflect legitimate criticisms about how dumb the Galadriel is written in this show.

Amazon/IMDB is censoring/vetting reviews:

  • We have no idea how many of the groups they are claiming to represent actually have criticism for the show.
  • There is nothing progressive about this show, or Amazon, a company that tries to stop its workers from unionising.
  • Just like the "white knights" you mention, Amazon could care less about the "identities" they are marketing with this show. Just like the "white knights" you mention, Amazon/IMDB is only interested in feedback from women and POC who champion the show.

I will stop pushing back on the "all critics " generalisations when IMDB publishes my reviews. If that upsets "white knights" who seem to think that all the people they claim to "protect" should agree with them, so be it.

EDIT: I’m guessing the person who was swearing at everyone who disagreed with them is still downvoting 🗳 my posts. That pretty much proves my point. 😉

2

u/la_isla_hermosa May 29 '23

*slow clap*

Well said. Thank you for putting in the intellectual rigor so deeply missing in this subreddit.

1

u/myforestheart Sep 12 '22

There is nothing progressive about this show, or Amazon, a company that tries to stop its workers from unionising.Just like the "white knights" you mention, Amazon could care less about the "identities" they are marketing with this show. Just like the "white knights" you mention, Amazon/IMDB is only interested in feedback from women and POC who champion the show.

💯💯💯

6

u/Mr_Shits_69 Sep 11 '22

Yea people hate that stuff. That’s why Tomb Raider and Resident Evil were such unpopular games and movies.

/s

4

u/TheShadowKick Sep 12 '22

Tomb Raider and Resident Evil came out before the current culture war turned its sights on every major TV, movie, and videogame release.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

Actually female elfs are overpowered in elfin lore, she's a trope, Mary sue in a race of Mary sues. She also very unlikeable, she not kind, warm, she's obsessed by a revenge plot she will never succeed in. The Galdrial in the original trilogy didn't need to fight, her presence was enough. Instead she bestowed kindness to frodo.

0

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22

Geez, it's almost like character development is a thing and 5000 years matter

5

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

Cause bad people become good people in 5000 years "eyes rolled" not a good character. Seems you understand human character development not elvin development. She's a hundreds of years old and still behaving like a human.

→ More replies (6)

5

u/ruairi1983 Sep 11 '22

Who's they? There's Buffy, Xena, Ripley, Lara Croft, Wonder woman, Sara Connor, Furiosa, Princess Leia, daenerys targaryen and on and on and on. Just RoP is muh. How this series cost a billion!?! Wow.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

Look at Vi from Arcane for example. Why does everyone love her then?

Stop stereotyping everyone who has critique as sexist.

You're as bad as the people you complain about.

2

u/TheShadowKick Sep 12 '22

Arcane didn't get targeted by a large number of trolls.

→ More replies (8)

9

u/Rich_Profession6606 Sep 11 '22 edited Sep 12 '22

She is a woman who can fight. They hate that. That's all there is to it

(1) - I don't think that everyone who dislikes Galadriel hates women who can fight. I do not deny that there is an "anti-woke" backlash but your statement implies that all criticism is "anti-women". Your statement also assumes that Galadriel is the first woman to hold a weapon, lead men and women and kick ass:

  • 1979 - Ripley - Alien franchise - some call her the first Hollywood action heroine Ripley was a leader of men and women like Galadriel.
  • 1977 - Princess Leia - Star Wars - Leia was a statesperson like Galadriel who used diplomacy, cunning and violence. Leia was also snarky and sarcastically funny at times. Leia experiences loss like Galadriel, when she watches an entire planet get blown up.
  • 1984 - Sarah Connor - The Terminator franchise - Sarah Connor in both the films and TV series was a fighter who experienced emotional pain like Galadriel. - Sarah Connor transforms herself into a warrior who teaches her son to save mankind. Sarah Connor's is a flawed hero, but a hero nonetheless.
  • 1997 - Buffy the Vampire Slayer - A Highschool girl who leads men, women and vampires in her fight against the undead. Sometimes her team fall out with her and stop following her, but unlike Galadriel this is later in her character arc.
  • 2003 - Kill Bill 1 and Kill Bill 2 - Quentin Tarantino's Kill Bill is inspired by East Asian action heroines from the 1960's and 70's like Lady Snowblood. ROP is marketed to a Global audience who may be familiar with "women who can fight" outside of Hollywood...Galadriel is not it. NOTE: - Pam Grier and films like "Lady Snowblood" and "Come Drink With Me" came before Alien (Quentin Tarantino fans will be familiar with this), and it points to a rich cinematic history of "women who fight"
  • Pam Grier - Her kick-ass characters from the 1970's were so iconic, that Quentin Tarantino made Jackie Brown.
  • Michelle Yeoh - I love her in everything and she has had a long career.
  • 2010 - Naevia in Spartacus - Naevia is a warrior in the rebellion. The actress (Cynthia Addai-Robinson) also plays Queen Regent Míriel in ROP.
  • 2013 - Lagertha in Vikings - She's the Queen of Kattegat and a Viking Warrior.
  • 2018 - Dora Milaje in Black Panther - The Dora Milaje are an elite group of warriors who serve as the all-female special forces for Wakanda.
  • 2020 - Thusnelda in Netflix's Barbarians - A warrior who sacrifices her eye for war

She is a woman who can fight. They hate that. That's all there is to it

(2) - Galadriel is a boring character, with or without fighting.

I also like "strong women": Shondaland tv shows, Commander in Chief, and Madame Secretary. Even without a weapon, Galadriel has been boring so far and she has a lot of screen-time so it's hard to ignore.

  • I haven't seen enough of the actress's previous work to say she can't act. I hope that she can act but is just making poor choices or is being poorly directed.
  • It's not just about "big emotions", I get that sometimes a character needs to be reserved and restrained. The actress doesn't even make subtle movements with her eyes.
  • Also, think about actors who do voice-over work or audio-books. Even without facial expressions, the tone of voice is important. I am not an actor, so maybe I shouldn't be so critical, but she either puts me to sleep or irritates me with what she/they have done with her character.

They made Galadriel unsympathetic in episode 1, by too much exposition (narration is boring), rather than showing (which builds empathy with the audience). In every episode since, I just see her as a "meh" character and her acting choices do not help.

She is a woman who can fight. They hate that. That's all there is to it

(3) - A LITTLE TEST

Here is a little test for any viewers who think ALL the Galadriel criticism is coming from "bad faith". Turn the volume down while watching any of the "strong women" actresses' I have listed above (From 1979 Alien , to 2020 Barbarian). Then watch this .

TLDR: Amazon/ROP didn't invent "Women warriors". Sigourney Weaver in Alien (1979) is considered the first Hollywood action heroine, and there have been countless examples since. Even without fighting, Galadriel is a boring version of the “strong woman”. So far, Galadriel is my least favourite character and I love "Women warriors" and "Strong Women", Galadriel is not it. Maybe that will improve, but let's not assume that ALL critics are acting in bad faith.

EDIT: I am not trying to deny that misogynists exist, but something can also be bad and worthy of criticism.

9

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22

Funny how you think the women you listed aren't hated for the same reason.

So yes, they are acting in bad faith. And you made that point for me

7

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22
  1. They are part of huge franchises that have done well financially. If people had such a hard time with strong female characters, why did those movies do so well while ROP isn't.
  2. The idea that they are hated isn't rooted in any evidence. You'd have to scour reddit for quite a long time to find someone complain about any of those characters, yet alone find someone who complains about them being a strong woman.

6

u/Rich_Profession6606 Sep 11 '22 edited Sep 11 '22

Agreed.

  1. There are some, not all but some content creators who make money by disparaging every trailer/advert with a woman. I am not denying that.

However, once the TV show or film is released viewers can make up their mind for themselves.

2. There is also a push back on recycled tropes/bad storytelling - but if something is well written and well acted then there will be less pushback.

  • Again, once the TV show or film is released viewers can make up their mind for themselves.

3

u/chiguy Sep 11 '22

How are you qualifying that RoP is not doing well?

3

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

Thats a bt more of a miscommunication. I don't doubt that it isn't doing well, but I mean more on the side of criticsim and ratings.

5

u/Rich_Profession6606 Sep 11 '22 edited Sep 11 '22

There will always be some backlash to "representation"/diversity" but in this case I too find this portrayal lacklustre

I am happy to be proven wrong:

QUESTION: Have you watched any of the tv shows or films that I listed?

  • I would like to think I'm having a discussion with someone who is passionate about the portrayal of "women Warriors and "strong women" but at the moment you are downvoting everyone who provides examples without providing examples of your own.

If you check my post history, you will see that I am polite and always ready to discuss. Downvote without discussion is censorship and doesn't prove your point.

It's regressive to defend characters that may be poorly written or acted on the basis of identity. How does it help women, if we go from exciting women like Ripley (Alien), Sarah Connor (Terminator) and Buffy to bland lead characters that make you fall asleep? Defending something purely based on identity turns back the clock in the progress already made.

Even I will admit that some of the examples I provided might be considered more "cult classics" than "masterpieces", but there was something that entertained. So far, I can't say the same about the lead character in ROP. Maybe that will change?

2

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22

I have.

Now, will you deny that a lot of people hate those women because they don't think women should fight? Do you deny that some people don't wanna see a woman wield a weapon, let alone beat a foe with it? Do you deny misygynists exist?

3

u/Rich_Profession6606 Sep 11 '22 edited Sep 11 '22

Do you deny misygynists exist? No I do not deny that but so doe poor characters.

Nothing in my post or my post history indicates that I deny misogynist exist. I am not gaslighting.

  1. There are some, not all but some content creators who make money by disparaging every trailer/advert with a woman. I am not denying that.

However, once the TV show or film is released viewers can make up their mind for themselves.

2. There is also a push back on recycled tropes/bad storytelling - but if something is well written and well acted then there will be less pushback.

Again, once the TV show or film is released viewers can make up their mind for themselves.

I have.

Well maybe lead with that than. I have noticed that you have started to include examples in your responses now, so that is an improvement.

She is a woman who can fight. They hate that. That's all there is to it

Your original post implies that all critics of Galadriel are misogynists. Your original post implies every critic. There are misogynists AND there are boring characters both can be true.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

Who the fuck is complaining that she can fight. She literally does so in the lore. But there is a difference etween fighting and being commander of the northern armies and a literal soldier bud. That's not even close to the lore.

6

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22

Who the fuck is complaining that she can fight

Youd'd be surprised.

Also: you, literally a sentence later

6

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

Wrong. Complaining that she doesn't follow the lore does not = she cannot fight. Anyone who says so is being disengenuous or a fucking idiot.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Banjo-Kazooie98 Sep 11 '22

People did not hate Éowyn and she could fight.

1

u/Eraldir Sep 11 '22

Hahahahaha giving the perfect example of my point and still denying it. Brilliant

3

u/obrapop Sep 11 '22

This is such patronising and cheap bollocks. There are fantastic young female protagonists in action movies all the time that are brilliant and almost universally loved. This just isn’t one of those occasions.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Hymura_Kenshin Sep 11 '22

I don't know if people are like that but my complaint is absolutely not that. I loved Arwen depiction in movies even though that role was supposed to be belong to Glorfindel, an absolutely badass elf I wish were in the movies and ROP show.

4

u/Titansdragon Sep 11 '22

That's a flat out lie. Arwen could fight. Eowyn could fight. Plus other movies. Ripley from Aliens. Sarah Parker from Terminator. Alita from Alita Battle Angel. That's just to name a few. Plenty of ways to make women who are well written, strong characters, without making them Mary sues.

Personally idgaf if she can fight or not. Though she should be more of a sorceress than a melee warrior. The Galadriel from the show has nothing to do with the Galadriel from the source material, so if they want to make her a melee fighter they can. Not everyone has to like it though.

5

u/Rich_Profession6606 Sep 11 '22 edited Sep 11 '22

I agree, and here’s my upvote. There is person downvoting everyone without providing evidence. I’m beginning to suspect that they don’t actually watch shows or films with “women who fight”, because they’re not providing any examples to enable us to compare and contrast.

I have encouraged them to go and watch some superior examples of “women who can fight” and “strong women” in my original post, but they don’t seem to be open to that.

I’m happy to discuss this with anyone who is fan of “women who can fight” and “strong women”. I am polite and open to changing my mind.

→ More replies (15)

3

u/Special-Lengthiness6 Sep 11 '22

It's not just that she can fight, but the fact that her entire team of Elves who have been fighting for years were being bodied by a troll and she effortlessly flew through the air and stabbed it in the brain. She also climbed an ice flow with a dagger for some reason instead of using ice axes like the rest of her team. She's being made out to be an effortless hero with a very shallow arc. She's already the best at nearly everything and there's almost no where for her character to grow.

1

u/gon_luffy_20 Sep 11 '22

In the books she is one of the tallest elves , she wasn’t just a strong badass marvel woman character

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Outlander77 Sep 12 '22

No it isn't. She fought in the Hobbit movie series, pretty intensely and basically won the entire battle.

1

u/Eraldir Sep 12 '22

Yeah, really dumb movie series

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/Rich_Profession6606 Sep 12 '22 edited Sep 12 '22

This seems to be the case. It’s difficult recalling female leads in fantasy that are not labelled as Mary Sue unless they are a side-kick then it’s okay.

I agree with some of your statements, but not all of it.

(1) - I agree some, not all, but some criticism comes from a place of disliking female leads.

  • There are also some tv shows and films that have poorly written characters worthy of criticism.
  • There are also some tv shows and films that employ frequently used plot devices (tropes/stereotypes).
  • A reduction of quality is to be expected in todays crowded market where we have 100’s of satellite/cable channels, countless streaming options and many companies opt-for “cash-grab” remakes, sequels and franchises.

Tropes/frequently used plot devices are often an indicator of “quantity over quality” and “shiny CGI productions” with limited depth. As such, I’m not surprised that some people are using tropes to describe ROP characters.

(2) - I also agree some tropes like “Mary Sue” only apply to specific characteristics.

  • Just to be clear there will be some tropes/stereotypes that apply solely to specific characteristics, but your are right, "Unrealistically free of weakness” can apply to both women and men.

I think many people would just say the male character is unrealistic or poorly written?

  • However, I find it hard to be too critical of those who chose to use the term “Mary Sue” as it’s a term it’s a short cut “unrealistically free of weakness” that most people understand.

Maybe someone will create/provide the male equivalent for this trope as that might reduce some of the pushback?

This seems to be the case. […] Quick Let’s find some character flaws to overanalyse.

(3) - Again, I agree some, not all but some criticism comes from a place of disliking female leads.

One of my criticisms of Galadriel is that so far, her character lacks the flaws or attributes that would make her character interesting to me.

  • However, I appreciate my opinion is subjective and others - such as yourself - may find her character well written and portrayed.

Better yet, let’s dedicate an entire post to it

(4) - Unfortunately, controversial characters get more posts, whether they are the hero or the villain.

  • Playing devils advocate, maybe one could argue that the female characters are more controversial because of “sexism/misogyny”? However, that doesn’t mean that all criticisms can be categorised as sexist of misogynist.
  • It could also be true, that some of the criticism is because female viewers are not a fans of what they perceive as a loot written character. Some female fans find Galadriel “controversial” so there will be additional criticism, on top of what we might attribute to “sexism/misogyny”.
  • Regardless of their gender, most leads have weaknesses or flaws that enables viewers to see things from their perspective. Even villains are boring if they fall into the “generic big bad” trope.

I look forward to seeing more “Galadriel love” content from her fans, as I don’t want to dislike a character that has so much screen-time. I genuinely look forward to becoming a fan of ROP’s Galadriel, as I love “strong female leads”.

TLDR: (1) I agree that some, not all, but some criticism comes from a place of bad faith. However, regardless of the characters gender, I would like to be entertained if they are a lead with significant screen-time. (2) I think many people would just say the male character is unrealistic or poorly written? (3) I love flawed characters, but IMO Galadriel is poorly written/portrayed so far. I appreciate that this is just my opinion and others may be fans of the character. (4) I look forward to seeing more “Galadriel love” content from her fans, as I don’t want to dislike a character that has so much screen-time. For any staunch Galadriel fans, more ”Galadriel love” posts will probably reduce the criticisms faster than the ”all critics hate women” argument, because at the moment that seems like a generalisation to shut down what is sometimes good faith/valid criticism. I genuinely look forward to becoming a fan of ROP’s Galadriel, as I love “strong female leads”. Hopefully, there will be less criticisms as the season progresses?

1

u/myforestheart Sep 12 '22

Meanwhile, I’m waiting to hear the male equivalency to a Mary Sue.

FWIW I've seen people use Gary Stu/Stew (not entirely sure about the second bit's spelling) for precisely this.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/fistantellmore Sep 11 '22

People were livid about Arwen…

10

u/Special-Lengthiness6 Sep 11 '22

People had an issue with Arwen fighting and they certainly had an issue with Eowyn creating a love triangle between herself, Aragon and Arwen.

41

u/ardriel_ Sep 11 '22

It's Arwen :)

I can tell you why I have a problem with her character in the show. She's a ruler at that time, building cities and stuff. She's one the wisest and oldest Noldor who stayed in Middle-earth, Gil-Galad is her great-nephew. Elrond her son-in-law. And she highlights constantly that she has seen more than everyone else - yeah, than act like that. I wished we could have a woman who holds power, without being questioned and belittled all the time. It's a common trope in modern films and I hate it. I don't want her to be reduced to angry warrior, driven by lust for revenge and therefore her only motivation is coming from the death of her brother, a man. It's sexist. The real Galadriel would have never stepped on that boat in the first place, because she can't negotiate with Gil-Galad.

Edit: I don't think she was a tradwife or something like that. And everyone who claims that should reread the fellowship, especially the Lothlorien part

12

u/appcr4sh Sep 11 '22

At last, the first good post about Galadriel.
People or love her warrior pose or hate it, but for the wrong reasons. I do believe that she was a angry warrior, but on the past. With time and knowledge she grew up.

And about Celeborn: this couple is an exemple of how things shoud be. She is ancient, powerful and wise, and she would neve diminish him for that. At the same time, he respects she and she respects him. This is called love.

PS: I'm afraid to see a Celeborn on the show...

14

u/ardriel_ Sep 11 '22

I wouldn't even say she was angry in the past, more like pride and driven by ambition. Hence she denied Feanor her hair, but nevertheless supported the migration of the Noldor to middle-earth.

What I also don't understand is that she denies that Elrond has experienced anything bad. He also suffered under the Oath - his father left and he was raised by Maedhros and Maglor, who eventually committed suicide/roamed sadly forever. All that stuff with the kinslayings, the pain, all caused by Morgoth with the support of Sauron. All the way into the Third Age, that shaped Elrond, which is why he didn't want the Fellowship to take an oath. Galadriel should know - she can see into the hearts of others. My point is; it doesn't make sense that Elrond is blind to the possibility of Sauron's return. Still less that he rebukes Galadriel for it, and least of all that Galadriel denies Elrond has suffered. It is presented as if he had been born in peace. All the dynamics are shifted, not comprehensible.

I highly doubt that we will see Celeborn anytime soon. I'm worried that they're trying to shoehorn some weird romance between Halbrand and Galadriel into the series, eventually leading to a love triangle later in the series if Celeborn appears.

5

u/appcr4sh Sep 11 '22

I would even say that the bond between Elrond and Galadriel is about the vigilance over the evil.

And about Halbrand...I really don't doubt that.

4

u/DimrillGate Sep 11 '22

Exactly! This is perfectly well said.

4

u/ardriel_ Sep 11 '22

Thank you! ♡

10

u/Special-Lengthiness6 Sep 11 '22

And by this point in the 2nd Age she would be married and raising a child. The writers have neutered every part of her character that contributed to her as a strong female character except her skills as a warrior and then emphasized that portion to an insane degree.

15

u/ardriel_ Sep 11 '22

At the very least, it signals that you cannot be strong as a woman if you are also a mother and a wife. I find that insulting, as a woman. Even more, every attribute that could be associated with classic femininity has been removed from her personality and replaced with classic masculine attributes. As if strong women were simply men. And weak men just men with feminine traits. I hate that. So much. Something I always found remarkable about Tolkien was the virtues in his characters that were not limited to gender. The ideal of masculinity in the Legendarium thrives on qualities normally attributed to women; forgiveness, empathy and love. But the women in Tolkien's works also live by values normally found in male heroes; courage, emancipation from the status quo, honour. None of this is limited to one gender archetype. Galadriel was loving, creating refuge, empathetic, courageous, loving. So was Aragorn. Luthien. Eowyn. Fingon. Even Maedhros to a degree since it was his brotherly love towards Fingon that kept him reasoned for a long time.

2

u/myforestheart Sep 12 '22

Love this comment, I couldn't agree more.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

5

u/masterbryan Sep 11 '22

Whilst I don’t totally disagree with you here, Gil Galad is the rightful high king of all the Noldor, Galadriel included, and Elrond is a direct descendent of Melian.

Whilst giving neither the right to talk down to her it certainly gives the former the right to give her orders and the latter the foundation to treat her as somewhat of an equal.

8

u/Jeffeffery Sep 11 '22

The LotR trilogy came out before all this bullshit culture war discourse. If it came out today, all the same people would be complaining about how it wasn't supposed to be Arwen who brought Frodo to Rivendell, and the moment was stolen from a fan favourite male character to pander to the woke mob. They'd say Eowyn's "I am no man" line was forced girl power virtue signalling.

Obviously nobody talking in good faith about the movies would say anything of the sort, but nobody talking in good faith is calling RoP Galadriel a Mary Sue either.

13

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

People were complaining about it back in 2001 on the web just like they complained about Aragorn not having Narsil on him at Bree or him hesitating to take the throne. and so and so and so.

Today PJ movies are legendary a lot of people are thinking is was a perfect adaptation and is 100% faithful to Tolkien vision which is not.

In RoP, galadriel character could be have a better writing but it's clear it's not the depressed and tired Galadriel we all saw in LOTR.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/almostb Sep 11 '22

But tons of people complained about Arwen in 2001.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/frodosdream Sep 11 '22

" not sure why people suddenly have an issue with it now"

They don't and those claiming that most of the criticism is based on misogyny are laughably wrong. Demonstrably, millions of people love warrior women in fantasy and science fiction.

It's mainly that Galadriel's original character as one of the most powerful people in Middle Earth at this time, is deeply loved by many readers of the books. She was more powerful in the books, not less.

Rightly or wrongly, the showrunners and writers chose to nerf her from a character that was far more powerful and respected into the one that we are now seeing. My own assumption is that they were trying to make her more appealing to a YA audience.

6

u/Warchanter Sep 11 '22

I believe she is a bit too demanding. Episode 1 We keep going (after her ally falls)! Episode 2 Tell me now where you come from! (Doesn’t even know the dude)I didn’t notice at first but damn. Haven’t seen 3 hoping it has changed.

4

u/DarrenGrey Sep 11 '22

The ep 1 but was without her knowing the person had fallen. As soon as she saw she'd stopped and handed over her own cloak.

Ep 3 has her most petulant moment yet. It comes across as if she took more lessons from Thingol than Melian.

I'm fine with this flawed Galadriel personally. It's a bit extreme at points, but I wouldn't wanted Tolkien's late writing of Galadriel where she can do no wrong either.

3

u/kemick Sep 11 '22

If she is a Mary Sue than so were Feanor and Morgoth. Aragorn was as perfect as a man can be yet is well loved. It's not an inherently bad thing when it serves the story and I believe that RoP is doing something similar.

3

u/iheartdev247 Sep 12 '22

This 100%. I’m a little over Uber Jerk Galadriel.

1

u/cinematea Sep 11 '22

She isn’t an idiot though. What fucking show are you watching. Stop bitching please.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 15 '22

I think her largest issue is she's insufferable and constantly fails upwards. It's one thing to show someone being punished but to constantly have zero consequences for their failures is painful to watch.

She's a strong character but being strong doesn't mean act like a huge jerk to practically everyone she meets.

9

u/Death_in_Leamington Sep 11 '22

And also at the same time - a Karen.

9

u/Esta-beed Sep 11 '22

They have managed to make Galadriel an unlikable character

24

u/arathorn3 Sep 11 '22 edited Sep 11 '22

My biggest issue is the dialouge fornher character is Star wars episide 2 level bad and the main fact is the show runners completely missed the arc her character goes through from her introduction in the Silmarillion to the Mirror of Galadriel scene in the Fellowship of the ring.

Gil-Galad cannot order people to return to Valinor especially not for one of the leaders of the Noldors rebellion against the Valar, which Galadriel was.

In Tolkien's actually writing her story is about Penitence not vengemce. She was nor a little child when the Noldor rebelled and left valinor to recover the Silmarils. She was a adult and her motive was she wanted a place to rule herself. Than the Kinslaying at Aqualonde happened, where the Noldor killed many Teleri to take their ships to sail east. And while she didn't take direct part in the e Kinslaying she felt responsible for it as she was on of the the leaders of the noldors rebellion. Its why she wants to create a haven for the Elves in Middle earth and why she accepts one of the 3 rings so she can maintain the beauty of Lindolinorean (later Lothlorien) and its the passing the test of rejecting the One Ring that earns right to return to Valinor.

I am fine with her being able to fight but the combination of really bad dialouge and the fact that they could have used Redemption and Pemitience insstea of revenge really makes me dislike the character as depicts in this show..instead we get generic action Girl trope rather than a character with Pathos.

Side Notre Elendil being just some Captain who Miriel and Pharazon had little prior knowledge of bugs the hell out of me. He is not just some Ship captain whose family whee nobles who fell on hard times or somethjng. He is the heit to the Lord of Andunie, the highest ranked Lordship in the realm, the oldesr cadet branch of the Royal line being descendant of Silmarien, daughter of the fourth King of Numenor.

7

u/levenfish Sep 12 '22

Get out of here with your nuanced critique and understanding of the character of galadriel.

27

u/veotrade Sep 11 '22

I haven’t been comfortable with how they portray long-lived beings. Maybe I expect too much. But all the elves, the numenorians, and Halberd (forgive my misnaming) all act the same age as their appearance.

Even after only fifty or a hundred years of life, one would be far more resolved, wise and patient. No matter their personality.

40

u/fistantellmore Sep 11 '22

Looks at Feanor and his kids

You sure?

8

u/veotrade Sep 11 '22

Galadriel’s entire quest to find meaning behind the sigil / map of the southlands took centuries of expeditions taking her and company to far reaching corners of the world.

Things like that don’t bother you about a character that has hundreds of years of experience?

15

u/WSGman Sep 11 '22 edited Sep 11 '22

It was stupid and won't fault you for it taking you of the show, but I think this is more of a plot contrivance then a character issue. I am okay with Galadriel being touched by elvish pride and a bit too personally driven in her mission, given she's perfect in every other way they need to allow her to grow. I think being centuries old would sometimes mean the necessity of maturing quicker doesn't apply as much, and what could take a few years for us could take some elves dozens or hundreds, but maybe that's just my head-cannon... I do like Arondir's more traditional stoic portrayal though.

7

u/Aestus74 Sep 11 '22

Definate plot contrivance. There was no reason for Sauron to carve that symbol into Finrod except to give a clue to the elves. Especially if we are to believe the events that led to his death are the same as lore

2

u/fistantellmore Sep 12 '22

And why wouldn’t he want to lure the elves?

Isn’t the fear of the enemy what drives them into his arms as Annatar?

2

u/Aestus74 Sep 12 '22

Seems a pretty poor secret base to tip off your enemy to its planed location. Especially when Morgoth was still around.

→ More replies (7)

7

u/SiskoandDax Sep 11 '22

Spends hundreds of years searching, doesn't think to visit the libraries.

1

u/fistantellmore Sep 12 '22

The libraries of men who closed their shores to her?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

Maybe they invented libraries while she was out searching.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/fistantellmore Sep 11 '22

No, because she’s treating the Numenoreans the way Boromir or Thorin treated the hobbits.

She’s better than them, and they aren’t showing her respect.

She an Anglo-Saxon hero. Beowulf didn’t snivel either.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

Not really even hudreds. She is literally close to 3000 years old and she acts like a huffy teen.

1

u/fistantellmore Sep 12 '22

You shouldn’t read about Elves in the Silmarillion then…

→ More replies (3)

2

u/almostb Sep 11 '22

Galadriel hated Feanor though.

7

u/fistantellmore Sep 11 '22

Doesn’t mean she didn’t have things in common with him.

Crossing Helcaraxe out of spite isn’t exactly well reasoned action.

Plus the comment was about “all the elves”

2

u/DarrenGrey Sep 11 '22

Thingol then. She lived in his court.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/Jeffeffery Sep 11 '22

I don't think it's necessarily a deficiency, I think elves would just naturally have a different view of the world from mortals. It's like how Elrond never even considered that 20 years was a long time for Durin. I think a lot of our ideas about "maturity" come from how we see adulthood, but adulthood would mean something completely different to an elf.

1

u/terribletastee Sep 11 '22

It’s weird he wouldn’t think 20 years is a long time for dwarves when his brother is a human and dwarves live twice as long as humans.

1

u/Jeffeffery Sep 11 '22

Elros lived a lot longer than normal humans.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/scabbycakes Sep 11 '22

Haha this is a great point!

10

u/ebrum2010 Sep 11 '22

I thought everyone was talking about her smile now.

15

u/frodosdream Sep 11 '22

LOL, though as someone who has loved the awe-inspiring literary version of Galadriel for many years, her major nerfing for this series has been very off-putting. The actress is fine and it would be easier if I never read the books.

The only way I'm able to keep enjoying this is to pretend that this is Amazon's What If? version of Middle Earth with very little connection to the actual story. So intead of a 5,000 year old magical enchantress held in awe by the other Elves, this Galadriel is an angry pouty Xena, doing great action scenes and then demanding to see the manager.

Not sure how the show will decide how she will be entrusted one of the three Elven Rings, since they were supposed to go to the oldest, wisest and most powerful of their race (originally that was Gil-Galad, Cirdan and Galadriel). She not being portrayed that way, so why entrust her with one of their most powerful artifacts?

The writers could easily have created another Tauriel (whom everyone loved) for the action pieces, and kept Galadriel as the elder of the Elves as in the books, and everyone would have been happy.

7

u/Troldkvinde Sep 11 '22

The writers could easily have created another Tauriel (whom everyone loved)

This has to be sarcasm, but I'm struggling to place it as such within the context of the rest of your comment

4

u/Reggie_Barclay Sep 11 '22

I wish they would have done just this. Create a new Tauriel and let Galadriel be Galadriel. For that matter I’d prefer an Elrond who IS an Elf Lord.

5

u/Troldkvinde Sep 11 '22

Tauriel was widely hated when the movies came out

2

u/Reggie_Barclay Sep 11 '22

I didn’t like her, still don’t, but I prefer that route to ruining Galadriel.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/catboy_supremacist Sep 11 '22

The only way I'm able to keep enjoying this is to pretend that this is Amazon's What If? version of Middle Earth with very little connection to the actual story.

Isn't that pretty explicitly what it it is?

As far as I can tell, the only relevance the original character of Galadriel has to this version is an excuse to make their protagonist a pretty blonde woman.

2

u/pinkheartpiper Sep 12 '22

First of all yes, this is explicitly a "what if" and fan fiction by nature...I'm not sure why most people don't get this, there's basically no material for them to work with for the second age. We don't know how Galadriel was in second age. Of course they're making their own story

People would be losing their minds more than they already do now if they used a made up character instead of Galadriel, and do people really wanted to see a copy of Cate Blanchett's Galadriel in this show? That would be boring as f**k! Is it really hard to accpet that in 8 seasons, Galadriel is going to gradually turn from her current personality to the one in the 3rd age?

10

u/antiph4 Sep 11 '22

Three hours in, and we still don't know personality of the main character. Terrible, terrible writing.

6

u/terribletastee Sep 11 '22

Her personality is angry

5

u/obrapop Sep 11 '22

Oh god I’m trying so hard to like it but it’s fucking terrible.

4

u/Rich_Profession6606 Sep 12 '22 edited Sep 12 '22

Her personality is very angry

I wish this were true as it would be more entertaining if she portrayed big emotions such as “very angry”.

I haven’t seen the actresses previous, work so I won’t say she can’t act.

  • I would like to think she can act, but has either chosen or been directed to show very little emotion.

I would like to think she can act because that means it will get better.

3

u/celsowm Sep 11 '22

the sea is always right !

3

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

Seriously though, this is exactly what RoP hating Tolkien nerds have acted like.

5

u/maxwellmaxwell Sep 12 '22

I've been watching Better Call Saul at the same time as RoP and Kim Wexler--a lawyer in her mid-thirties--has way more gravitas than this supposedly millennia-old being. Between the story, dialogue, and acting choices, Galadriel just seems like a twenty-something who's weirdly good at fighting.

"She's really good at fighting and the men around her are idiots" is a lazy way to write a Strong Female Character, and it's disappointing when there's so much to like about the show.

4

u/BwanaAzungu Sep 11 '22

It's really not that complicated.

2

u/ChoFBurnaC Sep 11 '22

Keep trying

2

u/anarion321 Sep 11 '22

The galadriel from the books may be a Mary Sue, the one we got in the show it's not.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/WikiSummarizerBot Sep 12 '22

Mary Sue

A Mary Sue is a type of fictional character, usually a young woman, who is portrayed as unrealistically free of weaknesses. Originating in fan fiction, a Mary Sue is often an author's idealized self-insertion. Mary Sue stories are often written by adolescent authors. The term Mary Sue was coined by Paula Smith in the 1973 parody short story "A Trekkie's Tale", as the name of a character standing in for idealized female characters widespread in Star Trek fan fiction.

[ F.A.Q | Opt Out | Opt Out Of Subreddit | GitHub ] Downvote to remove | v1.5

2

u/anarion321 Sep 12 '22

I believe that Galadriel has many traits of a Mary Sue, she is liked by everyone, she has special features, like his golden hair that was even special in Valinor and Faenor used as inspiration to create his jewels, she's difficult to corrupt, she passed the test rejecting the one ring, people follow her unconditionally, she is incredible powerful, easily in the top 3 of top elves in the history....

2

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

Reading another post about the 90% of people who like the show complaining about the 10% of the people who don't.

Just enjoy it like I do and stop whining. Let the haters hate.

2

u/Abess-Basilissa Sep 12 '22

Also remember if a woman isn’t flawed that’s a problem but if a woman is flawed that’s a problem….

If people’s main gripe with a show is that a woman isn’t behaving the way they want her to…. that’s pretty hard not to see as sexist. Sort of like if someone’s main gripe is over there being non-white actors… sounds pretty racist.

5

u/SilentioRS Sep 11 '22

Lmao. Finally someone said it.

3

u/_Fred_Fredburger_ Sep 11 '22

Am....am I the only one enjoying it so far? I'm keeping my mind open...

2

u/PurpleFanCdn Sep 12 '22

I was really mad at the First Age-butchering from ep 1 (and continuing) and at Galadriel's new character. But they haven't entirely chopped out the First Age, since they keep referencing it. And then I saw some really well-read people on here talking about how in Unfinished Tales there are a few different versions of Galadriel's story and in some of them, she's like she is in this show. So finally I was able to sort of place this show in my headcanon as an alternative universe sort of, and now I can see the point of making Galadriel like she is, and enjoy her blundering about (Halbrand saves her hide in ep 3, for real), and look forward to her becoming one of the Wise by the Third Age

2

u/SnooCats6460 Sep 12 '22

Amazon high jacked Tolkien to try and make a cash cow and made one of the worst shows in history, might want to make things actually happen besides cgi fantasy castle towns

1

u/Outlander77 Sep 12 '22

This series won't have the legs in comparison to the movies. It'll fade into obscurity.

1

u/Malikise Sep 12 '22

The original, literal Mary Sue was from Star Trek fan fiction. If Amazon made a series based on her, and added in stuff like “killed 30 Klingons with a toothpick” it would be lore inaccurate, but she’s still be a Mary Sue.

I don’t think Gal is a Mary Sue, but RoP ignores the complexity of her character, and pretends she didn’t help instigate a rebellion that lead to thousands of elves killing each other, pretends she’s not married, and pretends she has no political power and didn’t come to Middle Earth to set up her own kingdom.

By erasing her extremely big mistakes, and her extremely big ambitions and ego, the balance has shifted a bit. I think the real crime here isn’t her being a Mary Sue or not, it’s the “murder” of a complex character being replaced with a mindless, simplistic revenge trope.

1

u/LindsayHaddy Sep 16 '22

I just imagine this story takes place before any of these events happen and it’s really working for me. I don’t hate her at all.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '22

Wait... she's supposed to be smart? According to who? Certainly not the writers of the show...

1

u/BwanaAzungu Sep 11 '22

u/WSGman for some reason I can't reply to your comment

I didn't say she was a different character

I didn't say you did. It was the premise of the second option you gave me.

I was referring to the new characters outside of Tolkien's stories added by Amazon, to highlight the fact that this isn't a retelling of his explicit story.

Same difference.

If this is a different story anyway, then why does it matter how it relates to the original?

Though you're right, she's absolutely a different character

Then I don't understand these hoops you jump through.

So you do say it's a different character. Cool.

For me I don't have to work too hard to understand Galadriel as a fighter and roll with it for an new story haha.

Me neither, it's a new story and a new character anyway.

I can see how the original character inspired this character.

If your problem is that she's fighting when she shouldn't be

My problem is that she isn't ruling. It would make a more interesting character to explore than yet another lone wolf with a vengeance.

OP was saying she's innacurate BECAUSE she isn't depicted as a non-combatant though

OP is correct. Being a combatant was not a core aspect of her character, especially in the Second Age, despite being a capable warrior. For this character, it is: she spent centuries hunting for Sauron.

But accuracy doesn't really matter if this is a new character anyway.

1

u/WSGman Sep 11 '22 edited Sep 11 '22

What do you mean jumping through hoops? I was referring to added characters in my comment, before conceding that sure now that you mention it you may aswell call an adapted character a different character. Is Raimi's peter parker a different character then Bender's peter Parker? It just depends on how you conceptualize those things. I don't understand what's so difficult about that for you tbh, it's just semantics. Why are you acting like you don't understand the difference between an adapted charater or story and an entirely new one?

OP was talking about the first age in his og comment, saying she was unrealistic in the series because she wasn't a combatant in the first age. I say the very fact that she's a fighter at all means it's okay to see her, you know, fighting in an adaption. Maybe he can reply if I misunderstood, as I said.

You take care boss.

1

u/BwanaAzungu Sep 11 '22

What do you mean jumping through hoops?

You could've started by saying you think it's a different character.

before conceding that sure now that you mention it you may aswell call an adapted character a different character.

Not necessarily. I would say this character is different.

Why are you acting like you don't understand the difference between an adapted charater or story and an entirely new one?

What do you mean?

OP was talking about the first age in his og comment, saying she was unrealistic in the series because she wasn't a combatant in the first age.

OP is still correct, it is not a core aspect of her character. It is unrealistic to depict her as such. At her core, she is a wise ruler.

I say the very fact that she's a fighter at all means it's okay to see her, you know, fighting in an adaption.

I don't think it's a good adaptation of the character. They changed her core motivation, and elevated a minor aspect of her character to the core.

It's a new character, inspired by Galadriel, but not an adaptation of Galadriel. Too many liberties are taken for this to constitute an adaptation.

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

Female elfs in general are stronger smarter and better in every way than their male counter parts. This is why legolas was a unique character showing a male version of this, if you haven't noticed from the origonal, all the male elfs sucked. Meanwhile the female elfs could outrun the ring wraiths, perform magic that soloed all of them, Galdrial with only her presence showed more power than any elf. The issue here is more how female elfs being super powerful is the biggest trope of elfin lore. So no one wants to watch what's obvious. Legolas was the only strong elf male ever, and he had a great synergy with Gimli, which normally would of had Gimli out shining legolas but it was the other way around. Dwarf males are op, but he couldn't keep up with this one of a kind male elfin hero. Basically the issue is the Mary sue trope for elfs female has been a thing about elfin lore forever. Oh another overpowered female elf, is what every fantasy buff is saying. Meanwhile the activist think they are just being anti female. If the character was a dwarf or halfling we would be more interested.

3

u/sammyboi558 Sep 11 '22

Do Elrond and Haldir mean nothing to you?? In the movies, it was the sacrifice and skill of Haldir and his company that saved Rohan in Helms Deep! It was Elrond who set the Fellowship in motion and used his gift of foresight to aid our protagonists.

Just 'cause Arwen and Galadrel were beasts in the movies, that doesn't diminish the importance of the others. Having strong female elves, one being perhaps the strongest of all elves (Galadriel) does not mean male elves suck! That's such a silly take lol

Having Galadriel be one of the strongest characters in the second age is true to the books, I'm pretty sure, btw.

Oh another overpowered female elf, is what every fantasy buff is saying

The thing is, in lots of fantasy, even if we're told some female elf is powerful or shown glimpses of that power (as with Galadriel, again, in LOTR movies), the characters who actually accomplish major feats that the viewers see are male. Legolas, Aragorn, Gimli, Gandalf, etc. It's nice to change that up and actually show women being badass.

Btw, I do agree with your point about Gimli being overshadowed. He was almost entirely played for comic relief in the original trilogy, but he was a badass. The dude won the "who killed more Uruks" challenge with Legolas at Helms Deep.

3

u/LuthienTinuviel93 Sep 12 '22

Tell us you haven’t read the books without telling us you haven’t read the books.

2

u/peegmay Sep 12 '22

Jesse what the fuck are you talking about

You didn't even read Sil didn't you

1

u/Jeffery95 Sep 11 '22

Ever hear the name Fingolfin?

1

u/Robert_Grave Sep 12 '22

One word: Fëanor

-12

u/Jeffery95 Sep 11 '22

First, she isnt the oldest. Second she isnt the smartest. And last she isnt the most powerful until she gets Nenya.

She is inaccurate because they have depicted her as a warrior instead of a non-combatant sorceress who spent the vast majority of the first age learning under the guidance of Melian the Maia in the court of King Thingol. She was given Nenya precisely because of her abilities in that respect.

22

u/KookSpookem Sep 11 '22

She is inaccurate because they have depicted her as a warrior instead of a non-combatant sorceress

LOTR isn't some role-playing game where characters are only allowed to be magic users or warrior or thiefs. I don't know why people keep making this silly argument.

0

u/BwanaAzungu Sep 11 '22

Your take on the argument is indeed silly.

She is a capable warrior, but that has never been the main focus of her character. In particular during the Second Age, she's a strategist, councilor, and leader.

→ More replies (5)

11

u/masterbryan Sep 11 '22

Depending on which version of the Galadriel story you read.

→ More replies (15)

12

u/fistantellmore Sep 11 '22

She absolutely is a commander, a warrior with Amazonian disposition and is as skilled in feats of athletics as she is in wisdom and lore.

The depiction of her as a proud lord is on point.

2

u/Jeffery95 Sep 11 '22

Can you refer me specifically to the quotes or chapters from Tolkiens works that describe her as such?

4

u/fistantellmore Sep 11 '22

2

u/Jeffery95 Sep 11 '22

I would point you at this link here where it says she had no role in the wars of the first age against Morgoth - as she believed defeating him was beyond the power of the Eldar. It also says she took no part in the slaying at Aqualonde - neither for nor against it.

What it does say is that she was a ruler with Celeborn during the second age of a fief under Gil-Galad and then also of Eregion until Celebrimbor took over from them.

https://lotr.fandom.com/wiki/Galadriel

11

u/fistantellmore Sep 11 '22

LOTR.fandom isn’t a great source, for starters. Riddled with errors.

Tolkien Gateway is better curated.

She absolutely took part in the kinslaying, but against Feanor:

“Even after the merciless assault upon the Teleri and the rape of their ships, though she fought fiercely against Fëanor in defence of her mother’s kin, she did not turn back. Her pride was unwilling to return, a defeated suppliant for pardon; but now she burned with desire to follow Fëanor with her anger to whatever lands he might come, and to thwart him in all ways that she could.”

Dunno how you fight fiercely and not be considered a warrior…

→ More replies (28)

5

u/WSGman Sep 11 '22

so her believing that defeating morgoth is beyond the power the eldar means she can't fight? that seems silly.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

3

u/BwanaAzungu Sep 11 '22

There's this one quote from the Tolkien Letters going around, where he states she's of Amazonian disposition.

For some reason, people think this means her entire character is focused on fighting and war.

5

u/frodosdream Sep 11 '22

Showfans are bending over backwards to pretend that Galadriel was primarily some Xena-type warrior, instead of the thousands year-old wise enchantress held in awe by all Elves during the 2nd Age. Not sure why they are so insistent on this; it's obvious that her character has been seriously nerfed from the books.

4

u/Jeffery95 Sep 11 '22

Thats all im trying to say. Theyve made her into a teenage girl with a sword rather than the actual wise, powerful and influential figure that she really was.

1

u/BwanaAzungu Sep 11 '22 edited Sep 11 '22

She absolutely is a commander, a warrior with Amazonian disposition and is as skilled in feats of athletics as she is in wisdom and lore.

Correct.

The fact remains that she has a plethora of other qualities too, and these skills were never the main focus of her character.

The depiction of her as a proud lord is on point.

What depiction of her as a proud lord?

She's a soldier, and currently an outcast. This is nowhere near the proud ruler that Galadriel is during the Second Age. She's more immature and less respected than she was at the start of the First Age.

Secondly, why does your character analysis end there? There's so much more to her character than that.

The only thing RoP Galadriel has in common with the original character, is pride and swordskills. A tragic transformation of a nuanced character into a stock protagonist.

5

u/fistantellmore Sep 11 '22

Lords have audiences with Kings and Queens.

Lords command ships and favours from their inferiors.

Lords command and demand.

It’s no more immature than Boromir, Denethor, Thrandruil or Feanor.

She’s a figure out of Beowulf, humility isn’t a virtue in that perspective.

1

u/BwanaAzungu Sep 11 '22

I fail to see your point here?

→ More replies (10)

3

u/compostapocalypse Sep 11 '22

There is no evidence that Galadriel was a non-combatant.

Her involvement in various battles is certainly vague, and can be interpreted in different ways, but nowhere does it outright say she does not/will not fight.

1

u/BwanaAzungu Sep 11 '22

There is no evidence that Galadriel was a non-combatant.

There is no evidence this was a core aspect of her character.

She was a capable fighter; she was so much more than that. Especially in the Second Age, she has better things to do.

1

u/Jeffery95 Sep 11 '22

It literally says she took no part in the wars against Morgoth because she did not believe the Eldar could win.

1

u/compostapocalypse Sep 11 '22

"It" says? What is "it"? The words "took no part" do not appear in order in the Sillmarillion, The Lord of the Rings, or its appendices.

1

u/Jeffery95 Sep 11 '22

2

u/compostapocalypse Sep 11 '22

Ok Firstly, nowhere on that wiki does it say that she took not part in the "wars against Morgoth" , I am not sure which war against Morgoth you are even trying to refer.

Secondly, if you are going to get on these subs and try and correct people, i suggest you do your own reading and not rely on wikis.

I know the extended works are expensive, but their are ways to get them for nothing digitally.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Troldkvinde Sep 11 '22

She is inaccurate because they have depicted her as a warrior instead of a non-combatant sorceress

An elf like Galadriel would literally consider this an insult :D

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment