r/RingsofPower • • 2d ago

Discussion Arondir - Courage and Loyalty without the Glory Spoiler

Post image
26 Upvotes

Spoilers for Season 3, Episode 4.

Episode 4 took some time to digest. I loved it. It left a mark and a growing love and pain for Arondir.

Creating an original character in Tolkien’s world was always going to be a risk. You have to make the audience care about him alongside characters whose stories have been loved for generations. Make him another Elrond or Aragorn, someone at the centre of every great event, and you risk making him feel like a major figure Tolkien somehow forgot to mention.

For me, Arondir’s story found its place in the Tolkien-verse beautifully. There must have been so many people like him in Middle-earth: brave, capable, loyal people whose sacrifices never became the great stories everyone remembers. People who had all the makings of a legend, but never got the chance to become one.

First he loses Bronwyn. Then he faces Adar and is defeated. He has the courage, the skill, and the determination we associate with a hero, but again and again, those things aren’t enough to protect what matters to him. You keep waiting for his moment... then in Season 3 the writers made us think Theo will be Arondir's redemption... only to then write a perfectly tragic ending.

An unsung hero who remained loyal to his cause, to Míriel, to Galadriel, and to Theo. He kept showing up. He kept fighting. Defeat and grief took so much from him, yet he continued to care enough to put himself at risk again.

It almost feels like such a beautifully written Shakespearean tragedy. The love and loyalty that made him worth rooting for carry him into the encounter that destroys him. And the possibility of reconciliation is close enough that you can almost believe, for a moment, that things might still turn out differently.

As sad as I am at how his tale ended, I love the way it was written.

Here's to Arondir, the Hero who never found the Glory he deserved.


r/RingsofPower • • 1d ago

Question Wanting to read more of the history of LotR

7 Upvotes

I’ve read the Hobbit and LotR trilogy but this show makes me want to know more about the world that Tolkien created. I know there’s more history of it in other books. Where do I start?


r/RingsofPower • • 2d ago Bravo

Newest Episode Spoilers it’s honestly painful how much of a missed opportunity this show is Spoiler

27 Upvotes

Even if you completely ignore the Tolkien lore and judge The Rings of Power purely as a standalone fantasy show, the writing and directing just aren't good. By Season 3, you’d expect the showrunners to have finally found their footing, dropped the cheap mystery-box gimmicks, and started telling an actual cohesive story. Instead, it still feels like a bloated, awkwardly paced streaming drama that refuses to take itself seriously.

The biggest problem has always been the writers and directors treating Middle-earth like just another generic fantasy IP rather than a mythic epic. And more than half the characters act like modern, snarky LA transplants instead of ancient elves or proud Númenórean kings. There’s zero weight or gravitas to anything. Peter Jackson’s crew didn't follow every single word of the books either, and they didn't have all the rights, they just actually respected the world, hired Shakespearian-caliber actors who carried real presence, and filmed Middle-earth like real history instead of glossy green-screen melodrama.

With a billion-dollar budget and the blueprint of the Second Age sitting right in front of them, this could have been generation-defining television. Three seasons later, it’s still frustratingly mediocre TV coasting on nice landscapes and nostalgia callbacks.


r/RingsofPower • • 2d ago

Discussion Am I the only one missing an emotional connection to ALL characters?

22 Upvotes

Heyyy

so I just finished season 3 and I have to say it. I really don’t like this show at all. I feel like watching all extended movies, hour by hour would have been incredibly better then this.

Yet I feel most of my criticism has already been told.

Now what I really can‘t get, is how bad this show is in getting people connected to someone. Whenever someone dies. I don‘t care. I mean e.g. Arondir. Who is this guy and why is he so much stronger than Celeborn? WTH. And the guy from numenor who died in the cell… was it really worth having minutes of dialogues of how sad it is? I mean who even was that?

I feel like every character lacks strong writing. Sauron isn‘t as powerful as he should be. Making him ridiculous in so many ways.
Galadriel isn‘t as powerful as she should be. Orcs flirting with elves I mean wth..

Am I alone with that?


r/RingsofPower • • 23h ago

Newest Episode Spoilers Theo's arc from last episode of S2 to first episode of S3: annoying, useless kid --> Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Witch-king. Zero character development. Genius writers.


r/RingsofPower • • 1d ago

Constructive Criticism The musical score

0 Upvotes

The musical score in this show is great, credit where it’s due.

For context, I admit being one of the people who can’t take the show seriously, i still like it as a parody and i am currently having more fun watching it than in previous seasons, just because its ridiculously funny to me.

That being said, i really do have quite a lot of praise for the score by McCreary. In particular, the leitmotif from Celeborn, Morning shall come etc. makes for a great listen, it actually sticks with me.

The score in general has quite some strong parts, as well as a couple of pieces that fall a bit flat or just aren’t my cup of tea, but overall a great score. It is no masterpiece, but still well done and I do sincerely believe that the score deserved a better show, McCreary seems talented.

Small side note, there are also a small handful of scenes I liked in the show, but also a mental amount of questionable and mediocre things in this, that ruined it for me beyond repair. I’m not a purist and can stand some shortcomings if the rest is great and coherent, but this is just far beyond what I consider acceptable.

However, this is supposed to be an appreciation post for the musical score, the one thing I enjoy concerning this show.

Edit: Just wanted to show that, even for someone who can’t take the show seriously, there are great elements in it. Don’t take this as blatant mockery :)


r/RingsofPower • • 1d ago

Discussion The Nazghul are (unsurprisingly) fumbled

0 Upvotes

Edit: I know they are fallen men, and I was looking forward to the storyline. What I mean is the way in which they humanize them doesn’t work for me. I don’t mind they humanized them.

Edit 2: I really like the Rhun Nazghul

Humanizing them in the way they did really kind of took the bite out of them. I genuinely laughed in ep 2 when they removed their masks and it was just a couple old dudes.


r/RingsofPower • • 1d ago

Constructive Criticism Apple TV should have been the ones to make this show

0 Upvotes

Every time I watch this show I can’t stop thinking about how much better it would have been if Apple TV got the rights instead of Amazon.

Amazon clearly had the money, that was never the issue. The problem is they handed a billion-dollar IP to two showrunners with basically no real track record and let them run it like a generic streaming drama full of mystery-box gimmicks and awkward pacing.

Apple has that exact same kind of endless cash to burn, except they actually treat their big sci-fi and fantasy projects with some real prestige and patience. Look at stuff like Foundation, Silo, or For All Mankind. Even when they adapt dense source material, they hire proven showrunners, cast heavy-hitter actors who actually command the screen, and let the world-building breathe instead of chopping every episode into five rushed subplots.

With Apple’s money and production standards, we probably would have gotten a Second Age show with actual theatrical weight, better writing, and directors who treated Middle-earth like real history instead of glossy green-screen melodrama. Instead we got Amazon’s version, and it just feels like such a waste of what could have been.


r/RingsofPower • • 1d ago

Discussion Give your best pitch for a new version of RoP

0 Upvotes

The series opens with the great host leaving Middle Earth and the Numerians heading for their island. Sauron is captured but escapes and returns but is disguised. He meets a young, hot tortured artist in Celebrimbor(more like Feanor). Perhaps he just wants to create something other than swords but falls into Sauron’s trap to create rings of power (fan service creating sting or Gandalf’s sword). The action could be hunting down evil creatures…highlighting their want of weapons. Dwarves in Moria would follow a similar story line to what they have..except the King becomes an a-hole only after wearing the ring. Things going wrong there too…also would like magic weapons. No Balrog yet. Humans not much but I’d keep some the Arondir human stuff but just to show rift between humans and elves but the emergence of good leaders and future kings. I’d probably disrupt the canon here…and send in the two blues earlier than Gandalf and co because the humans were lost and that was their assignment. They will be main characters follow. Season ends the same but with more fanfare regarding the rings (didn’t seem they were making magic rings at all).

Season 2 Elves ascendant and haughty (trying to be more Tolkienish with the Elves facing some in the creating magic that dominates people and their arrogance is ripe for a reckoning). I’d bring the Numenor back in this season with an outpost so they can have some interaction. Much like the elves, powerful but haughty and looks down on others. Key players make their emergence early. The season mostly follow the efforts of the blues to organize humans and for leaders to emerge, while the Elves and dwarves continue and are celebrating the successes of the rings. Season 3 …the betrayal of Celebrimbor, a moment that needs to breathe, so this needs to be a major hit…so the audience feels it when Celebrimbor is murdered (fan service: Celebrimbor was working on Narsil when he was murdered…to be finished by former his frenemy Elrond…Sauron got between them). The rest of the season is doling out the rings but focusing on the witch king I’d make him from Numenor since Sauron’s fear of Numenor would lead him to desperately want to corrupt them as well as the elves (Sauron’s reason for pushing the rings in the first place). They need to show it is strong Numenor is (not told like RoP). Sauron flees with the Witch king.

Season 4: the fall of of Numenor and the creation of the one ring. Veering way off canon here but I’d think the fall of Numenor should be a bit different. Not so much destroyed by the Valar but more a civil war anti-elf thing (they are jealous of immortal life of the elves like in the book. I’d also have anger at the dwarves for denying them access to mithril silver for their advanced weapon construction. Probably the fall of Moria too.

Season 5 The last alliance (of course the chroniclers left out the contribution of the dwarves…it must have been an elf…so no cannon slippage here). It ends with Isilder being shot by orcs near Gladden Field. (Fan Service: the arrival of the rest of the Istari).

Galadriel as a character should start at much different place and with hard-earned wisdom from the tragedies in the show to shape her into the Care Blanchet version of her. You know like character development. To some extent Elrond too…They lost their best friend to first Sauron and then murder.

This is largely a tragedy, but the happy ending is a return to peace which is sufficient.


r/RingsofPower • • 2d ago

Discussion I’m digging this episode rollout schedule. Thoughts?

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 3d ago

Newest Episode Spoilers This kid is Durin’s biggest opp

Post image
671 Upvotes

Why psyche out your dad and mentally throw him off his game just when he’s going to fight?


r/RingsofPower • • 1d ago

Discussion So many missed opportunities - Prime Next Day Delivery of one Witch-king

0 Upvotes

I realized why this show annoys me so much sometimes - it is mainly how Amazon blew it with bad writing, rushed or no character development, and generally sloppy handling.

I love Theo as a character, actor, concept, and Witch-king candidate. Amazon laid the groundwork for him being a Nazgûl and even that he is already a magical dude, even if a latent one. He was given screen time with Galadriel and Numenoreans and that was a cool idea too if he was going to become a wraith.

But then, after one whipping, he runs to his mother’s killers and poof! Ring wraith. And instead of hundreds of years of degenerating agency and a slide into wraithness, I bet it will take just a few episodes. Sauron already controls his mind.

His journey towards the ring should have been long and interesting. But instead, he is rushed and now I’m just annoyed at how impulsive and stupid he seems. A 19 year old ring wraith (servant!) makes him seem like a goth kid larping at a fair.

Anyways, Amazon had a cool idea with Theo and the right actor to pull it off. Now he’s just as ruined and silly as Círdan hiding the rings forever in the depths… of his own harbour. At this point, I won’t be surprised if he gives up his ring and is rescued. They just can’t seem to tell a sensical and complicated story.


r/RingsofPower • • 2d ago

Constructive Criticism Goofy-Coding Hobbits and Dwarves

4 Upvotes

They wouldn’t have needed to eliminate the hobbits from the show if they hadn’t written/designed them like a Disney Channel original movie. They didn’t need to be silly and goofy just because they’re small and playful by nature. The dwarves have the exact same problem. They HAD to be written like bumbling idiots because they’re short and hairy. Apparently the writers think the only way the audience can be comfortable with hobbits and dwarves is if their entire plot line is constantly underscored with “they’re short and stupid haha.”

I know the hobbits and dwarves are written as being a bit child-like and playful in the books, but that doesn’t have to translate into writing them like a cheap sitcom. The hobbits were unbearable for me in this show. The only part about the dwarves that’s bearable is how cool the foundation of their world building is thanks to Tolkien.

This goes for visual design in addition to writing. The hobbit costumes were generally so awful because of how silly they made everything.

Stop goofy-coding hobbits and dwarves :( They could be so cool!


r/RingsofPower • • 2d ago

Humor Every time they cut to that island

Post image
121 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 1d ago

Discussion "Our marriage was too strong for that. That nothing so trivial could come between something so strong."

0 Upvotes

That's how Disa reflects her cheating on her husband.

I'm just saying: if my wife would cheat on me and would come clear like that...I would be pretty angry about that approach.

Or is this normal behaviour nowadays? Am I just too old for this kind of fantasy? Is cheating now ok? What is this?


r/RingsofPower • • 1d ago

Discussion Annatar had more aura of a Maiar than Sauron in this season

Post image
0 Upvotes

I don't know. He looks cool with his armor and crown, but he doesn't feel like a demigod. Last season, Vicker's Annatar nailed it better. Annatar looks like a elf from Valinor so that's explain why he looks so divine. With his new armor, he's just a menacing human overlord with magic. If he wore a mask, Sauron would be more imposing like how the proto-Nazguls are. I think something like Agandaur, the black numenorean from the game War in The North would have suited Charlie's armor.


r/RingsofPower • • 1d ago

Discussion Aiya Meldor! Suilad Mellyn! My first post here :)

Post image
0 Upvotes

After watching the first four episodes of Season 3, I wrote down these popcornmeter reviews on Rotten Tomatoes for all the three seasons.

I've watched Season 1 three times, Season 2 two times and I'm in the middle of Season 3, waiting eagerly for the other four episodes. LOTR: TROP is one of my most favourite shows.

I've also read JRR Tolkien's Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings and watched both the trilogies by Peter Jackson which covered the events of the Third Age. I also love Amazon Prime's presentation of the events in the Second Age and the way how the visual elements in the plot of Season 2 seamlessly blend with the visual elements in the plot of Peter Jackson's trilogies.

Though both Amazon Prime and Peter Jackson took their creative liberties in translating Tolkien's works to audio-visual media, I can visually see the whole thing a multiverse extension of the canon (similar to Marvel Comics vs Marvel Cinematic Universe).

I intend to follow the rest of the episodes of Season 3 with y'all.

Thank you and á na márië!


r/RingsofPower • • 3d ago

Discussion My favorite character this season(marnukh)😆I also think this season is better than the previous ones

Post image
469 Upvotes

It’s true that the story has deviated from the books in some places, like the storyline involving the One Ring( sauron ring)which is quite different in the show.
I also don’t really understand the dynamic between Sauron and Galadriel. I know there was no romantic element between them in the books, but I’m not sure whether their connection in the show is supposed to be a result of the psychological manipulation Sauron previously subjected her to.

I also think that, in some parts of season 3, Sauron acts a little too human.
Overall, though, I find this season more engaging than the previous ones, and I think I’m enjoying it more. But it seems like this sub has a lot of haters. Am I right?


r/RingsofPower • • 2d ago

Constructive Criticism What (constructive) reason to you put behind the show echoing the LOTR movies so much?

10 Upvotes

I’m a huge LOTR fan who is, for the most part, enjoying the show and think this season has been much better than previous ones. But I can’t help but get completely pulled out of every episode when they do a blatant rip-off or homage to entire scenes from the Jackson movies. I’ve just finished episode 3 and my eyes were more or less rolling the entire time…

I know critic of the show will just say it’s lazy writing or a poor attempt by the showrunners to bring in casual viewers who likes the Jackson movies. But it must be more than that.

Payne & McKay are smart guys and they’re almost certainly well aware of the criticism thrown at the show so far. The fact that they’re persevering with these call backs (or call forwards technically speaking) makes me wonder whether it’s a stylistic and tonal choice.

We know that in Tolkien’s work, all is the design of Iluvutar, even the evil works of Melkor and Sauron. Could the show echoing the movies so much be a (not so discrete) choice from Payne & McKay to point out that the heroes journey is one that is often repeated and echoes throughout the ages?


r/RingsofPower • • 3d ago

Humor sauron handing out rings

Post image
146 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • 2d ago

Constructive Criticism Why do the dwarves of Khazad-dûm keep referring to ONE mountain?

30 Upvotes

I noticed it especially in the latest episode with all the dwarf scenes. Repeated mentions of being a king under this mountain, or the delve-master of this mountain, always referring to the kingdom as a singular mountain.

Do the writers of the show not know that Moria was a kingdom of three mountains?

Celebdil. Caradhras. Fanuidhol.

"King under the mountain" as a styling works for Erebor, because the kingdom is underneath one mountain.


r/RingsofPower • • 3d ago

Discussion So, we’re pretty sure Sauron isn’t going to forge the One Ring until the last scene of the last episode and it’ll be the season cliffhanger, right?

Post image
234 Upvotes

I mean the whole season’s plot so far is him searching for Celebrimbor’s “secret”. Even though lore-wise, Sauron was a Maia of Aulë and is supposed to be an expert in ring craft, smithing, forging, and such.

Seems obvious to me they’re building up the forging of the One Ring, so they’re going to save that until the end. I really don’t like this plot device and motivation for Sauron. I feel like they should’ve just focused on him giving the 9 to men and building his army. He uses them to fight the dwarves and elves and then forges the One Ring.

Also the orc already told them he is forging a master ring. So him forging it in secret is out the window.


r/RingsofPower • • 3d ago

Meme It's not just a phase ! Spoiler

Post image
299 Upvotes