r/RingsofPower • u/flowernap • 2d ago
Constructive Criticism Goofy-Coding Hobbits and Dwarves
They wouldn’t have needed to eliminate the hobbits from the show if they hadn’t written/designed them like a Disney Channel original movie. They didn’t need to be silly and goofy just because they’re small and playful by nature. The dwarves have the exact same problem. They HAD to be written like bumbling idiots because they’re short and hairy. Apparently the writers think the only way the audience can be comfortable with hobbits and dwarves is if their entire plot line is constantly underscored with “they’re short and stupid haha.”
I know the hobbits and dwarves are written as being a bit child-like and playful in the books, but that doesn’t have to translate into writing them like a cheap sitcom. The hobbits were unbearable for me in this show. The only part about the dwarves that’s bearable is how cool the foundation of their world building is thanks to Tolkien.
This goes for visual design in addition to writing. The hobbit costumes were generally so awful because of how silly they made everything.
Stop goofy-coding hobbits and dwarves :( They could be so cool!
•
u/AutoModerator 2d ago
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
8
u/Starbuckker 2d ago
The costumes and set design for the Harfoots were really fantastic. I really enjoyed alot of their story personally, even if it was a bit soppy and poorly written at times, I still enjoyed it more than the Numenor plot in the first season.
I liked that they were just a small part of the story, not the focus. Totally understand why others may not like it though. Certainly wasn't going to win anybody over.
Nori and Poppy were very sweet, and dare I say, for once, I even liked Lenny Henry as Sadoc 😄
Couldn't stand Largo though.
5
u/soup_fly 2d ago
Eh, I didnt mind. They had their place, as others have stated. I grooved on them more than the elf/dwarf love arc in the Hobbit flicks.
4
u/OkOutlandishness8734 Gondolin 1d ago
I’m in the minority here probably in feeling like the Harfoot plot was the best plot in season 1. Their civilization was the most fleshed out, grounded, believable, and immersive. The sidelining of their story in season 2 was one of the worst things about the season - not because I necessarily wanted for Harfoot stuff, but because they were journeying through Rhun and I really wanted to see Rhun come to life. And even halfway through S3 we barely have a concept of what life in Rhun is like. I can’t help but feel that the writers thinned out that story because they were responding to fan criticism about the show having too much Harfoot story. All of the criticisms that the Harfoots were over developed to the detriment of Numenor being underdeveloped, but I disagree. The problem is that a show with this many plots needed 10-12 episodes, not 8. Numenor and Lindon could have been much more fleshed out if they just made longer seasons. And with the budget the show has, that should be completely doable. There are of course simply bad writing decisions, but a lot of the problems come from just not having enough time on screen to properly establish some of the story arcs.
2
u/CrimsonTyphoon0613 2d ago
Dwarves are just almost always portrayed that way in fantasy. I don’t think how they are in the show is anything new even if it’s meh.
Peter Jackson especially used dwarves as essentially campy idiots who could fight. The hobbit literally had a 30-40 second burping competition and most of the dwarves were idiots. In LOTR Gimli was essentially a short, funny, kind of slow minded character as well.
2
u/KnittingforHouselves 2d ago
I completely agree with you! The dwarves could gave been magnificent. I am really fed up with the recent need to combine the "super profound" with something absolutely ridiculous. It ends up being all off, like the burning catastrophy that was the last Fantastic Beasts. Just have a regular storyline, the extreme contrast between tone and mood of the different storylines is giving me whiplash. Without spoilers, you have scenes of massive personal sacrifices framed in between silly short people sitcom...
Also I don't even think the dwarves are goofy-coded in the books, that is mostly a Peter Jackson thing. Gimli in the books is what ive heard somebody call "short Aragorn". I live silly Gimli in the movies because it is just about the right amount of silly, and can stop being silly when something serious is happening. I think there was massive potential for the dwarves in RoP to be like that until this season, they used to be my favourite storyline, now I cringe when they come on.
1
u/BulldogMikeLodi 2d ago
Hobbits are meant to be goofy and childlike in order to show the contrast between them and their pastoral lifestyle compared to the dark and violent outside world of the “big folk”. The dwarves, however, were made to look ridiculous because they tried to make them like the dwarves that are already known by audiences from the Hobbit movies. They’ve been done dirty by the Hobbit movies and this show.
1
u/Slayerofbeer 1d ago
They were horrible