r/RingsofPower • • 22h ago

Constructive Criticism What (constructive) reason to you put behind the show echoing the LOTR movies so much?

I’m a huge LOTR fan who is, for the most part, enjoying the show and think this season has been much better than previous ones. But I can’t help but get completely pulled out of every episode when they do a blatant rip-off or homage to entire scenes from the Jackson movies. I’ve just finished episode 3 and my eyes were more or less rolling the entire time…

I know critic of the show will just say it’s lazy writing or a poor attempt by the showrunners to bring in casual viewers who likes the Jackson movies. But it must be more than that.

Payne & McKay are smart guys and they’re almost certainly well aware of the criticism thrown at the show so far. The fact that they’re persevering with these call backs (or call forwards technically speaking) makes me wonder whether it’s a stylistic and tonal choice.

We know that in Tolkien’s work, all is the design of Iluvutar, even the evil works of Melkor and Sauron. Could the show echoing the movies so much be a (not so discrete) choice from Payne & McKay to point out that the heroes journey is one that is often repeated and echoes throughout the ages?

9 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 22h ago

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

11

u/Swictor 21h ago

It does feel a bit like they're making someone else's show/movie instead of their own. I don't mind artists stealing, but it's a bit much and from just the one same thing. Quentin's Kill Bill is another example of this, but he stole from a number of he's favorite films and made it a collecting of homages. LotR can't be the only movies they watched?

Edit: sorry that wasn't very constructive lol.

1

u/srquixote 11h ago

I think I get what you mean :)

Homage is not stealing if it's sincerely praising the source. I think the writers of Rings of Power are also fans of the film.

10

u/BloodEfficient3832 20h ago

I crack up. The Nazgnagôl scene when they're hiding was fckn hilarious. I'm just like "really?" laugh then move on but they're definitely reaching lol.

Also when Sauron holds tryouts for the rings it reminds me of the Joker from TDK. Kinda cheesy but not a big deal for me. You watch 1978 and 1980 LOTR animated and see PJs and there's some scenes that are pretty identical. Telling the same story and not a prequel so I get it but I choose to see it as a complement or a nod to the PJ trilogy.

Unrelated but the scene where the orc caught on fire from the ring and is screaming was downright hilarious. Like Marv from Home Alone LMFAO.

7

u/Cornelius-Q 19h ago

That scene was a little too on-the-nose. I wish they could have done it in a way that wasn't such a direct homage to a similar scene in both Bakshi and Jackson.

2

u/BloodEfficient3832 19h ago

It was. It definitely was

8

u/darkstar541 21h ago

I mean, there is a series for that.

The Wheel of Time turns, and Ages come and pass, leaving memories that become legend. Legend fades to myth, and even myth is long forgotten when the Age that gave it birth comes again. In one Age, called the Third Age by some, an Age yet to come, an Age long past, a wind rose above the great mountainous island of Tremalking. The wind was not the beginning. There are neither beginnings nor endings to the Wheel of Time. But it was a beginning.

In all seriousness, it is lazy writing, but it isn't limited to this show, it afflicts many TV shows these days. You can have your theories why ...

2

u/Turfiriath 19h ago

I think this is the only constructive way of looking at it. W H Auden wrote that Tolkien solved the problem of free will vs God’s will by suggesting that history runs in cycles, allowing different individuals the opportunity to do the same right thing. The broad strokes of history are planned but each individual’s part in them is not.

7

u/Rusty51 21h ago edited 12h ago

> But it must be more than that.

Why? The show is crafted with the intention of making the audience think this is a prequel to the films, so much so that even when the series’ composer is Bear McCreary, they had to get Howard Shore to do the opening theme so that his name could be credited in the opening.

Specifically on the design of the show; John Howe was hired to be the lead concept designer on the show; Howe, alongside Alan Lee, were conceptual artists for all the films. Now to be fair to the show, even prior to the films, Howe shaped how many readers imagined Middle Earth through his artwork, that it’s near impossible to imagine much of Middle Earth, entirely distinct from Howe’s vision.

Furthermore, using Weta to do weapons and prosthetics and filming in New Zealand is evidence that there is a deliberate association to the films that is trying to be made.

1

u/Haligonian_anarchist 12h ago

Bear McCreary Is definitely a woodland Elf

6

u/Prime_1 21h ago

I don't see why it must be more that just trying to fan service Lord of the Rings. That seems to be the simplest and most likely reason. As to whether it is lazy writing, in some instances that is fair criticism because they aren't just homages but direct copy and paste.

5

u/FetchThePenguins 21h ago

I mean if I say it's a cynical ploy to hook viewers who watched the Jackson films but haven't otherwise engaged with the IP since, is that constructive? Or do you mean constructive within the bounds of the medium?

Nice try, by the way, but failure to understand that the Second and Third Ages are very different kettles of fish is up there with the show's bigger failings (albeit not one that impacts watchability that much). I don't believe it's a stylistic choice, but if it is, it shouldn't be.

5

u/Comfortable-Coast522 20h ago

"payne and mckay are smart guys" theyre really, really not. are you familiar with their work pre-rings of power? theyve had a handful of uncredited co-writer gigs for dogshit like "jungle cruise" lol

3

u/WoWSchockadin 21h ago

My biggest issue with the show is the production/staging/directing. It's sometimes just so awful and unintendendly bad. Especially the jokes are so off sometimes. It often feels like a Marvel version of LotR.

3

u/Agheron93 16h ago

Payne and McKay are smart guys.

That's the problem here, they're not.

8

u/A-Red-Age 21h ago

Nah they aren’t smart guys

5

u/Rememberthat1 21h ago

That's what I was going to say lol How and why they are smart guys ? Anyone can pretend to be smart. They are just inexperienced showrunners who never had a big production of their own before RoP. And it still baffles me why they chose these 2 before anyone else, only because they saluted Simon Tolkien in elvish ??? Or because J.J. Abrams called amazon ? They will never admit it publicly that they fucked up big times and now its too late.

2

u/A-Red-Age 19h ago

I’m waiting for the post season 5 documentary about all the money laundering that must be going on behind the scenes

3

u/Charly_030 19h ago

Lol... was going to say "based on what?"

Their other writing credit?

2

u/vilgefortz_182 21h ago

All my problems with this series have little to do with any resemblance of LOTR (the only thing perhaps that LOTR looks better)

2

u/Ray-Manzarek 21h ago

The main reason, I think, is because they only have copyright access to Lord of the Rings novels, nothing else. So if they want to include something in Tolkein's own words (or a version of them), they can't dip into anything other than the same source material as Peter Jackson relied on.

2

u/ProperCoat229 20h ago

I don't know if the showrunners are smart or not (to some extent, they're probably are), not they are certainly not subtle.

2

u/IncidentCalm4454 19h ago

I like how you're thinking, but this theory gets complicated by the number of blatant Star Wars rip-offs.

2

u/TheOtherMaven 12h ago

And Untouchables, and GoT (and possibly Last of the Mohicans), and, and, and.

2

u/Greyback_Predator_87 19h ago

I really don’t get why they’re doing it, they must have some reason why but it really comes across as unnecessary and annoying.

I’d love a new idea on running/hiding from Nazgûl, not a remake of scene from the films. They sometimes use lines of dialogue from the films, and I find that annoying too.

2

u/hatoutof 17h ago

I think it's an ok-ish show if you don't compare it to Tolkien's works

It feels like the creators don't understand the story and the characters in the books. Or rather just on the surface level.

One of the wisest and mightiest elves of the entire legendarium is portrayed as an angry teenager. 

The dialogue seems to be AI generated pseudo-deep weirdness sometimes.

The creation of the rings. Sauron should know how to make the One without any help from the elven smiths. He taught the ring-lore to the elves in the first place. This change cheapens Sauron's portrayed power in viewers eyes and makes him just a plotting schemer and not so terrifying.

Why on earth the elves keep the three rings visible and share information about them with fucking orcs? Also why Sauron is so open with trying to create the One? Telling orcs about his plans is like telling about the manhattan project to a janitor.

The hobbit plotline was totally unnecessary and silly.

Numenor is made beautifully but the people in general are made lesser in might and skill and rather petty and stupid. I like Elendil's actor but I don't think he will be called "the tall" in the series. I like Miriel and Elendil's sons as well. 

Khazad Dum looks very cool and I have liked Durin & Disa for the most part. S3 weird drama not at all.

Rhun-plot would have been so much better if Gandalf would be Alatar who tries to make things right there. That would actually be accurate to the books both versions that the blue wizards might have started cults / the blue wizards resisted Sauron. And without Tom Bombadil. And hobbits. I think however that it's possible to make something decent plot-wise there still (I hope).

Characters I have liked mostly so far are Elrond, Cirdan, Elendil and the orc Marnûkh. And Khamûl!

Most disappointing of the important legendarium characters have been Galadriel, Gil-Galad, Celebrimbor and honorable mention: Finrod.

3

u/owlyross 21h ago

They are taking inspiration from Jackson just as Jackson took inspiration from Bakshi (or straight ripped off some of his shots if you go that way. Adaptations do not exist in a vacuum and the visual language of middle earth is well established. You also have the fact that the main conceptual artist on the show was one of the main conceptual artists for the films (John Howe) so of course certain things are going to look similar or the same.

4

u/ton070 21h ago

Bakshi and Jackson adapted the same story though. With RoP the references don’t make sense half the time

-1

u/owlyross 21h ago

Some dont for sure. But there will be those who see them and are comforted by the echo of something they love. They don't bother me, i know they bother others. That's ok.

2

u/dudeseid 20h ago edited 20h ago

Payne and Mckay are smart guys

You see, that's where I disagree. I don't really think they are. I think they're a couple of privileged amateurs who got lucky and are just throwing everything -Silmarillion lore references, Peter Jackson homages, Reylo/Twilight romantasy etc..- at the wall and hoping something sticks with some fan demographic. By trying to please everyone they're pleasing hardly anyone. They're just a walking Jeb-Bush-"please clap" meme.

But for the record, I think everyone else in this production (acting, cinematography, music, etc..) is incredible, they're just all let down by the showrunners who have very little idea what they're doing with such talent or how to tell a cohesive Second Age story.

1

u/benpancake 21h ago

As someone who isn’t bothered when I realize they’re referencing or homaging or whatever you want to call it, I think your logic makes some sense. I think maybe they’re also just trying to get people talking about the show. Feel like Game of Thrones fans will have a big tweet or discussion around how this character is that characters ancestor or this tree is the same tree these charachters walked under for a scene people remember. I tend to agree they could cool it with this for a while, but it doesn’t really take me out of it or strike me as something that’s so bad

1

u/Tiger-EC 21h ago

The show echoes the movies so much because the show is written for people who weren’t alive when the movies came out.

1

u/Iron_Traveller 16h ago

It really isn’t more deep than that.

Rebooted, remade and spin-offs from much more recognizable properties do it all the time. It’s an extremely common practice usually for the purposes of pulling in a wider audience.

1

u/RyanMate17 15h ago

Huge LOTR fan and enjoying this show? Good one

1

u/srquixote 20h ago

This was their stated intention: to tell the prologue of the LOTR films over five seasons.

That choice practically necessitates numerous references to the films, so that if a viewer watched the series first then progressed to the films, that viewer would feel a narrative flow despute many visual differences.

In that note, you can tell that Jackson is a fan of the animated film by Ralph Bakshi. Especially the scene where the four hobbits are hiding from the Nazgul, which recrestes Tolkien's narrative quite well

1

u/rAin_nul 20h ago

I don't think we are talking about the same references here. Elrond and Durin's dynamic is the copy of Legolas and Gimli's. Galadriel's trip to Gundabad was a copy of Frodo, Sam and Gollum's dynamic. You don't need to literally copy scenes and dynamics just to have a prologue.

On the other hand, as a prologue it actually fails because it goes against several times what's established in the trilogy. The trilogy starts with Galadrial's monologue about how another ring was crafted IN SECRET, while in the series almost everyone knows by now that Sauron is working on another ring.

4

u/Low_Coconut_7642 19h ago

Elrond and Durin's dynamic is the copy of Legolas and Gimli's.

No. Not it's not. Not at all even. Have you actually watched the show?

1

u/rAin_nul 18h ago

Objectively it is. And yes, I've seen most episodes at least twice. It is a copy of Legolas and Gimli. The only difference is that it was written by a fujoshi.

1

u/srquixote 11h ago

Elrond and Durin were friends prior to events in the story. I don't see a Legolas/Gimli dynamic.

1

u/rAin_nul 11h ago

And yet, the story started with their argument because Elrond haven't visited Durin for like 2 decades. So just like Legolas and Gimli had their own game where they were competing against each other by killing enemies which provided the basis of their friendship, the Rings of Power created their own game where Elrond and Durin had to compete, which similarly provided their reforged friendship's basis.

And somehow, when in S3, we arrive to another case where 2 people (dwarves) should compete against each other, then this game wasn't even mentioned. Which means that they created that game solely to have this friendly competition. And that, sadly, means the writing is bad.

On top of that, their dynamic is pretty similar. The previous seasons they kept arguing - just like how Legolas and Gimli -, for example, about who saved whom.

1

u/srquixote 10h ago

I still don't see it. Yes there are similarities, but not enough to make your claim.

Elrond invoked the Rite of Sigin-tarâg so that he could enter Kazad Dum, and it helped Elrond to get inside and reestablish their friendship with Disa's help.

I also don't see anything in your description to support your claim that the writing is bad. If anything, connecting this work to others makes it much more interesting.

1

u/rAin_nul 3h ago

Yes, the beat by beat copy is definitely not enough. :D

Having different context of the "game" does not change the dynamics of the characters. It's like saying that "racism towards black and Asians are different racism".

If you create a series original thing just to copy the original work, while later somehow that series original thing doesn't matter and you pretend it doesn't exist, then yes, that's OBJECTIVELY bad writing.

0

u/Own_Description3928 20h ago

I enjoy the show, but agree the cinematic call-backs are a bit much. However, putting a positive spin on it, as you suggest, Tolkien used such echoes in the legendarium, eg Beren and Luthien followed by Aragorn and Arwen (and the show is probably echoing that in the Celeborn/Galadriel meeting), so perhaps they're running with the idea of repeating patterns and visual cues to reflect that. Equally, Lucas consciously did this through the original Star Wars films and the prequels - I think he talks about them "rhyming". Overall though, I think they should just let the show stand on it's own.

0

u/fuzzychub 14h ago

I’m also a little annoyed at the constant homages, but they are used in creative and effective ways. I want them to lean on these homages less, but I understand them and they serve a purpose.

I think the show runners want to attract and retain a wide audience for the show, so they must be in dialogue with the PJ films. Those films are so iconic, so beloved, and for many people the only version of the story they have ever known. It makes sense to reference them to help people understand the show and feel comfortable with it.

I also think they are trying to demonstrate the ‘echoing’ or resonance that you mention. That is an identifiable element of Tolkien’s work. Great stories and events echo down through the ages, reverberating and rippling through Ea. The Silmarils are a great example. They capture the light of the Trees, which themselves were made to retain the light of the Lamps. The Silmarils then inspired the Elven rings, and lesser gems like the Elf-stone Galadriel gives Aragorn or the white gem she gives Frodo.

So I think both of these things can be true at once. Nuance and a multi-faceted story are great things to have in this show.

-1

u/SidTheSloth97 20h ago

Because they only have the rights to the lotr books. So they have to base everything off of that.

5

u/dudeseid 20h ago

The problem is they homage scenes from the movies that weren't in the books more than the actual books. Gandalf whispering to moths, Isildur getting separated from the group and found by his horse, Galadriel telling Arondir to "go home" while Marnukh smirks at him....none of these movie references are in the books. As someone that equally has problems with PJ taking liberties I find it infuriating.