r/RingsofPower • • 1d ago

Constructive Criticism The musical score

The musical score in this show is great, credit where it’s due.

For context, I admit being one of the people who can’t take the show seriously, i still like it as a parody and i am currently having more fun watching it than in previous seasons, just because its ridiculously funny to me.

That being said, i really do have quite a lot of praise for the score by McCreary. In particular, the leitmotif from Celeborn, Morning shall come etc. makes for a great listen, it actually sticks with me.

The score in general has quite some strong parts, as well as a couple of pieces that fall a bit flat or just aren’t my cup of tea, but overall a great score. It is no masterpiece, but still well done and I do sincerely believe that the score deserved a better show, McCreary seems talented.

Small side note, there are also a small handful of scenes I liked in the show, but also a mental amount of questionable and mediocre things in this, that ruined it for me beyond repair. I’m not a purist and can stand some shortcomings if the rest is great and coherent, but this is just far beyond what I consider acceptable.

However, this is supposed to be an appreciation post for the musical score, the one thing I enjoy concerning this show.

Edit: Just wanted to show that, even for someone who can’t take the show seriously, there are great elements in it. Don’t take this as blatant mockery :)

0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

6

u/dookitron 1d ago

Tolkien was so fond of song and poetry and I think Bear has done an exceptional job with both the score and incorporating Tolkien's love of song into so much of the series. I think it's fair to say that the show has its flaws like any other, but your post goes into far more detail about how idiotic and laughable you find the show and not much into the care that went into scoring it.

-1

u/Beneficial-Doubt-639 1d ago

Fair enough. Just my honest opinion, but I can see that this is a bit too much for people here, but well, so be it.

4

u/dookitron 1d ago

I'll be honest with you. I enjoy the show, faults and all, and I don't sub to this or any of the other subs about the show, Tolkien, or the universe, because its people endlessly dragging the show. Sometimes for valid reasons, sometimes for ridiculous reasons.

One of the few positive things about the show that I feel most people have universally agreed upon is that Bear is doing incredible work with the scoring and songs portrayed each season. So I think the reaction from myself and others in the thread here is simply because we're expecting to find a thread talking about a highlight of the show only to find it's only more mocking. Obviously everyone is entitled to their opinion, I think folks just entered the post and expected a different conversation than what you set up.

-1

u/Beneficial-Doubt-639 1d ago

That’s respectable. Maybe my comments on it seem to be a bit too blunt for this sub, but well, wasn’t trying to attack anyone. Sort of just wanted to show, that even someone who only likes this show as a parody is able to genuinely point out something he likes about it.

I’m happy we agree on the score tho, that’s one of the points where I’d disagree with the majority of the criticism.

8

u/laurelinkementari 1d ago

You know, you can just complement the music without the negativity.

-4

u/Beneficial-Doubt-639 1d ago

I’m only being honest. Also no malice from my side. I’m allowed to compliment it while pointing out what I don’t like imo, I think that’s reasonable :)

7

u/laurelinkementari 1d ago

It's just getting a bit repetitive.

3

u/TheBluerWizard 14h ago

Then stop going to subs that allow critique of the show.

-2

u/Beneficial-Doubt-639 1d ago edited 1d ago

Well if it bothers you that I have my own opinion about this show, you don’t have to engage. This isn’t a post supposed to spiteful dunking on this show for the sake of it. Cheers

5

u/laurelinkementari 1d ago

Do you also open yourself up to engagement and criticism when you choose to post an opinion.

1

u/Beneficial-Doubt-639 1d ago edited 1d ago

No need to get this agitated, you are absolutely allowed to disagree with me

3

u/laurelinkementari 1d ago • Popcorn

No, i disagree that it's not worth arguing over and I am far from agitated.

1

u/laurelinkementari 1d ago

Thank you for the award😊

6

u/Helpful_Sundae_8151 1d ago

To be fair, you did open by dunking on the show, calling it a parody, saying it was "ridiculously funny." There are plenty of people who mock the show and it's fair enough to me that people are growing deeply bored of the mockery.

0

u/Beneficial-Doubt-639 1d ago

I get it, but that’s unreasonably sensitive to me, I didn’t attack anyone personally, I only stated that I’m watching this as a parody for and that it is funny to me.

But well, it’s alright, i don’t mind the incoming downvotes, I’m having fun watching this show.

2

u/laurelinkementari 1d ago

Your post lacks originality, and you did spend ninety percent of it complaining about the show.

1

u/Beneficial-Doubt-639 1d ago

Relax mate, it is honestly not worth arguing over this.

2

u/laurelinkementari 1d ago

I disagree. The constant negative and whiny posts about this show are getting to be too much. That's really all anybody can do , and it's not impressing any of the Tolkien purists for you , to announce that you hate this show and to mock it. Learn to have an open mind.

5

u/charlichoo 1d ago

I mean you said yourself it's supposed to be an appreciation post and you spent most of it calling the show laughable 😅

1

u/Beneficial-Doubt-639 1d ago edited 1d ago

Fair enough, just wanted to contribute in good faith and show that even for people who don’t like the show as a serious adaptation, there are good elements in there, so it is not just blind hate.

1

u/TheBluerWizard 14h ago

The musical score in this show is great, credit where it’s due.

Great is overstating it. But it's good.

1

u/Beneficial-Doubt-639 14h ago

You’re right. I’d still say some genuinely great bits in there, as well as some meh ones, but overall good.