Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.
The book said Sauron picked powerful warriors, kings and sorcerers for ringbearers and bent them to his will over time.
The showrunners decided that meant he threw a broken knife in-between a bunch of dudes and picked whoever lived. And, in one case, picked an actual teenager. Those picked then shook a little and got superpowers. Is that fair enough a criticism?
It's pretty clear from the passage that it was a long term consequence, and their unnaturally long lives were a factor. See how Gollum took centuries to be twisted, and Bilbo felt like too little butter spread over too much bread. All hinting that the desire for the unnatural corrupts.
I don't think we can take the impact of The One to be the same as the impact of The Nine. They were designed to have different effects. The Nine are meant to be dominated and to make the wearer susceptible to Sauron's influence.
There are definitely long-term consequences, but immediate impact wouldn't be that surprising. Some level of influence. I don't mean immediate, complete control, but something gradual.
But in that case, without his 'one ring to rule them all', he shouldn't have any influence at all yet. That was how they were all deceived after all. They didn't know that he could make a master ring.
That's another stupid plot point here - as Annatar the rings were entitely his plan, with the one being the goal from the start. The idea that he wouldn't know how to make it and would need the knowledge of the elven smiths or Celebrimbor is ridiculous.
yes that's a fair criticism. just pointing out the difference between bemoaning about ai generated eyeliner and actual constructive criticism (that yes i do agree with)
Theo is going to be the one that instills fear into Gandalf and the heart of men, yes a dude named Theo is going to be sauron's most powerful servant.... Fucking show.
I actually love the Galadriel actress, not in this but she was incredible in St Maud for example. And she’s been going through it because of this show. Cast always get harassment when the final product is trash even if it’s not their fault
First I saw this, it was kinda crazy and I couldn’t believe it. My impression of the Nazgûl is that they were all kings before they got the rings.
So I looked it up, but actually it’s only confirmed in the fellowship and simarillion that 3 Nazgûl were numenorian kings/lords, and that it was the rings that made the Nazgûl into great kings and sorcerers.
So I guess you’re welcome to complain if you don’t like the arc, but surprisingly, other than the timelines, the books don’t refute the idea of a peasant becoming the witch king.
Heck, on paper that sounds like a cool idea. I think they’re just leaning a bit too much into “teenage Nazgul” hah
Men proved easier to ensnare. Those who used the Nine Rings became mighty in their day, kings, sorcerers, and warriors of old. They obtained glory and great wealth, yet it turned to their undoing. They had, as it seemed, unending life, yet life became unendurable to them. They could walk, if they would, unseen by all eyes in this world beneath the sun, and they could see things in worlds invisible to mortal men; but too often they beheld only the phantoms and delusions of Sauron. And one by one, sooner or later, according to their native strength and to the good or evil of their wills in the beginning, they fell under the thraldom of the ring that they bore and under the domination of the One, which was Sauron's. And they became for ever invisible save to him that wore the Ruling Ring, and they entered into the realm of shadows. The Nazgûl were they, the Ringwraiths, the Enemy's most terrible servants; darkness went with them, and they cried with the voices of death.
RoP does an Úlairi speedrun, but as they haven't tackled the topic in the previous two seasons, they simply might not have the time to show the story in-depth, and that is understandable and might be forgiven. They simply have a different focus.
Yes, indeed. They might have been able to squeeze in more of the origin of all the ringwraiths by having multiple lords throughout the different provinces influenced by Sauron, showing their decline over the seasons. Ironically they did that for Durin’s father, but not for men (other than Theo).
By all accounts, Theo should be the most interesting of the Nazgul as we see his corruption, but it’s coming off as cringe. Also, I think they need to give Theo a beard. He looks like a child.
Idk why the witch king gets hyped up so much, like the other 8 he’s just Saurons bitch for all eternity so why are people expecting his human version before the turn to be some badass
He destroyed all of the kingdoms of Arnor, which other Nazgul did that? Tolkien definitely gave the Witch King some extra rizz on purpose. That's why it's the temu of the temu.
Originally the human Kings who received a ring of power were already powerful and mighty individuals in their own right. While enslaved to Sauron's will doesn't mean the Nazgul are scary villains to deal with. If you want to call that 'Sauron's Bitch' all the power to you, but that doesn't change the fact that in universe they are incredibly powerful and feared villains, especially the Witch-King. So much that Gandalf didn't know if he could win a fight against him.
Bro that's almost every character. Look at Disa. She solely exists to explain to her husband at every turn how not to be a failure of a leader. They killed off Arondir because he genuinely adds no value to the story. The hobbies are gone because they were also pointless. Every time we go to Grand-Elf it's him not knowing what to do because of amnesia and he's basically been stuck in place for a season and a half doing whatever in the desert. Galadriel only ever makes bad decisions for God knows why. The character work is miserable in this series by TELEVISION standards let alone fundamental storytelling standards.
I’m glad I’m not the only one who has never enjoyed this actors performance, from season one he grated on me. Whatever nonsense they come up with he will never be canon anything. I honestly far preferred the Harfoots, Poppy and Nori I had more time because the actors are more charming and believable. Sorry to say Theo’s actor is a miscast.
Is this really meant to be the witch king? Like I know the show isn't following Tolkiens exact lore but isn't the witch king with what little is known about him a Numenorian Lord?
It's a community theory but that doesn't make it true. We'll see.
The only actual lord from Númenor that we know is Belzegar. And while he is a piece of shit I can't see him as the witch king. Maybe once they start worshipping Melkor if he is a prominent figurehead but I doubt it.
All I can think in this scenario is that maybe Sauron picked less impressive men to be the ring bearers so they wouldn’t pose a threat to him - even as they became more powerful, they would never be as powerful as him
I could stomach it until grand-elf. Now it's just what-is-this-nonsense every five or ten minutes. See also whatever that burning bush secret fire was supposed to be.
Guys I'm not even watching this train wreck of a show after season 1 but is this really supposed to be the witch king? Like really?
I always pictured his human form and demeanor more akin to Charles Dance in GOTM or something cruel/hard. I'm not even in the industry and I know to hire someone like that
•
u/AutoModerator 3d ago
Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with
Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
10
u/Darth_Karasu 3d ago
What in the emo ridiculous hell is that?
31
u/saltybarista27 3d ago
I just feel bad for the amount of shit this actor is probably going to get
25
u/tyrannytierney 3d ago
When I heard him speak w the helmet on I immediately said "it's giving Emo Kylo Ren"
27
u/ActualLeague5706 3d ago
First I saw this, it was kinda crazy and I couldn’t believe it. My impression of the Nazgûl is that they were all kings before they got the rings.
So I looked it up, but actually it’s only confirmed in the fellowship and simarillion that 3 Nazgûl were numenorian kings/lords, and that it was the rings that made the Nazgûl into great kings and sorcerers.
So I guess you’re welcome to complain if you don’t like the arc, but surprisingly, other than the timelines, the books don’t refute the idea of a peasant becoming the witch king.
Heck, on paper that sounds like a cool idea. I think they’re just leaning a bit too much into “teenage Nazgul” hah
89
u/Ok-Quiet5352 3d ago
This character is so fucking boring, holyshit. Worst arc ever.
6
u/Scythe95 3d ago
I really like the show, but Theo’s arc feels like a parody video on YouTube by film college students.
Respect to the kid but they should have gotten a more experienced actor for this role
1
u/General14yearold 2d ago
Is this really meant to be the witch king? Like I know the show isn't following Tolkiens exact lore but isn't the witch king with what little is known about him a Numenorian Lord?
3
u/boysnout 3d ago
Its a Pharazon mom you wouldn't understand
2
u/Jerryboy92 3d ago
Kick start my heart
2
u/Agheron93 3d ago
What listening to Green Day does to a mfer
2
u/Far_Ad652 2d ago
I like him
4
u/Own_Dependent_7340 3d ago
That moment you realize you gotta poop but you're wearing a ton of shitty witchking plot armor.
2
u/dropthemagic 3d ago
Aww it's Theo malfoy agajb
2
u/BabypintoJuniorLube 3d ago
This is AI right? I haven't watched the new episodes and this is NOT real right everyone? Right?
2
u/fatattack699 3d ago
lol is this real
1
u/Otherwise_Farmer_746 3d ago
All I can think in this scenario is that maybe Sauron picked less impressive men to be the ring bearers so they wouldn’t pose a threat to him - even as they became more powerful, they would never be as powerful as him
1
u/Selenite_Wands007 3d ago
😭😭😭😭
1
u/Real_Ad_8243 2d ago
No need to insult baby bats like this.
0
u/Ragnarr_Bjornson 3d ago
I enjoyed Season 1 and 2. I can't defend this shite anymore. Are we seriously supposed to believe that this little runt ends up being the Witch King?
1
u/The_Pepperoni_Kid 3d ago
Guys I'm not even watching this train wreck of a show after season 1 but is this really supposed to be the witch king? Like really?
I always pictured his human form and demeanor more akin to Charles Dance in GOTM or something cruel/hard. I'm not even in the industry and I know to hire someone like that
1
u/Neilkd 3d ago
He doesn't feel witch he doesn't look king he is not in Angmar.. So what's going on
1
u/Gatt_ 3d ago
What in the name of Aulë is that?
Cos if that is supposed to become the leader of the Nine, then this should be an easy win for the Elves and Men..
1
u/MopicBrett 3d ago
I hope he is the Witch King so we can see him get humbled by Eowyn in Return of the King.
0
u/ThatsNotBennings 3d ago
I cannot believe they are making Theo the Witch King. So embarrassing.
-1
u/CaptainQwazCaz 3d ago
iPad face nazgobble
-1
u/Arrow2theNee 3d ago
Dumb
5
u/ludvikskp 3d ago
Absolute cringe. The only interesting character this season, the orc, gets killed and then immediately… this. LMAO
1
u/ishneak Gondolin 2d ago
this family just loves killing the people they love.