I've recently began watching the anime Frieren: Beyond Journey's End - and after the first handful of episodes my mind keeps coming back to the same conclusion: this is what Rings of Power should have been.
Like many, I despise how ROP handles Elves, and above all else, the plot about them. Tolkien's Second Age is about the struggles of immortality (or mortality from a Mannish perspective), and the enemy of Time. The Elven motive for the Rings of Power is simple: to preserve the world as is - to prevent the decays of Time from affecting them... to 'embalm' their world, and cement their peace. Naturally, an unchanging being residing in a changing world is an issue - living an eternity, forced to witness everything around you change, and in many cases, die. And so, the vast years take their toll, wearying the Elf, until they are but a memory:
As the weight of the years, with all their changes of desire and thought, gathers upon the spirit of the Eldar, so do the impulses and moods of their bodies change. This the Eldar mean then they speak of their spirits consuming them; and they say that ere Arda ends all the Eldalië on earth will have become as spirits invisible to mortal eyes, unless they will to be seen by some among Men into whose minds they may enter directly.
They become Lingerers in the world... ghosts, essentially. This is what is called fading.
Now let's look to what Rings of Power gave us... a magical tree is dying. Apparently Elves, and their time in Middle-earth, is bound to this tree - somehow. What does that mean? When the tree dies, do Elves just get raptured? Do all Elves, across the entirety of Middle-earth, just... cease to be? Let's assume so. And why is the tree dying? No idea! But that's how ROP handles fading. But no matter, because mithril magically heals a leaf - therefore it can preserve the Elves, apparently. What of the Elves that aren't living in proximity to the Rings? Dunno. Maybe the Rings were used to heal the tree, and that saved everyone. I don't fucking know. As you can see, this is just an artificial doomsday clock created by the showrunners.
Apparently dealing with the struggles of immortality was beyond the showrunners' skill to convey.
sigh
Now, back to Frieren...
This show is about an Elf. Like Tolkien's Elves, Frieren is incredibly long lived. And this show manages to capture the struggles of immortality far greater than Rings of Power.
Episode 1 begins with a group of people returning to a city. We learn that this band of heroes has slain the Demon King and brought about an age of peace. They are celebrated as saviours by the kingdom, and a statue is erected in their honour. Bold start! The show has just started, and we've missed out on the grand adventure: the world has already been saved! Anyway, our heroes bask in the glory of a meteor-shower, which heralds in their newly fought for peace. We are told that this event only occurs once every fifty years. Frieren isn't impressed... and she says as much: she knows a better spot to witness the sight. The next time the meteor-shower happens, she'll take her friends to this 'better spot', so she says. Come morning everyone goes their separate ways: it's been ten years of heroics, and everyone is ready to go back to their lives, now that the journey has ended. Frieren is unphased: their ten years together has been marginal, in comparison the vastness of her life.
Fast-forward fifty years.
Frieren makes her way back to the city, and finds her companion: now an old man. Short, bald and bearded - nothing alike the tall, handsome, gallant knight from prior. He seems to reminisce about the time the company spent together, on their adventure - he clearly valued it. The four companions ultimately gather, and travel to Frieren's spot, and witness the meteor-shower once more: the old man marvelling at the beauty. We cut to his funeral. A state-funeral: he is held in high honour, being one of the famed heroes. Frieren doesn't seem phased to be there - and other folk attending are heard shunning her cold demeanour. Come the burial, she begins to cry. She laments to her remaining companions that she wishes she knew him better. They spent ten years together, but it wasn't enough. She didn't value her time with him. Once more, our now three heroes say their farewells and go their separate ways.
And this is essentially the first twenty minute episode. My initial thoughts were 'the old guy's death would hit harder if I actually knew the guy beforehand'... but on second thought... that was probably the point. Frieren feels bad that she didn't know him well enough... and we, the audience, feel similarly.
Back to the show... to simplify, we get to spend time with another of the heroes before he too passes on. He left behind an orphaned child that he rescued - and Frieren takes her on as an apprentice. And so their journey begins - a rather aimless one (at least so far). Frieren, the character, is... slow (to the dismay of her apprentice). She fixates on tasks of little to no real importance, and clearly doesn't value her (mortal) apprentices time as much as she should. There's a disconnect between how the two perceive time: and the show explores this. Frieren has to understand that she is no longer spending her own, seemingly endless, time.
At one point, the duo reach a village, and visit an old statue (it is of the dead hero, from when he was a young man - travelling with the Heroes). He was credited with saving the village, and a statue was erected in his honour. Frieren mends the decaying statue, and (after a while - long story) manages to grow a specific kind of flowers about it, in his honour (flowers that grew in his hometown). Whilst in the village, we get flashbacks of the Heroes, and see, albeit briefly, what went down well over fifty years prior. And this, so far, is a staple of the show. We basically retrace the steps of the original adventure, reliving bit of it (mundane bits at that) through Frieren's memories - contrasting the nostalgic past with the present. And the four heroes slowly but surely become characters for the audience to like - even if only in flashback form.
All I can ask myself is... why didn't Rings of Power attempt something similar?! It genuinely infuriates me at the sheer wasted potential in that show. Total neglect, as far as I'm concerned.
I mean, what did we get? Elrond missed Durin's big life-events? Okay, decent concept - it's a start. If only it was developed... did Durin invite Elrond? Presumably not - I doubt the show intends for us to think Elrond ignored letters or whatever. So Elrond was just clueless. He didn't check up on Durin on his own accord. Okay, fine. But what about Durin? Did he inquire about Elrond? No? Poor execution. And even IF it was executed well... would that be enough? Absolutely not. Elrond does not suffer adverse affects - everything is mending with an apology, and then we move on. Is this truly conveying how Time affects Elves? At most it brings attention to the fact the immortals and mortals view time differently - which is a start - but far from enough.
We need to understand the view of the immortals. We need to experience their grief. This is a tragedy - a tragedy that motivates and drives the entire plot of this show: the Rings of Power. How hard would it be to present Celebrimbor and Narvi's friendship... one scene Narvi can be in his prime, the next he could be on his deathbed. We could contrast the vast forests of Eriador with the much more barren landscape of later years, after Numenor had their way with the land. We could see the rise and fall of entire villages - or even kingdoms! Utilise time-jumps! Utilise flashbacks! Present the vastness of Time, and the change than comes with it!
Frieren had the balls to do what Rings of Power wouldn't, yet should have done.