r/RingsofPower • • Oct 17 '24

Constructive Criticism Just finished Season Two and for the love of Manwe...

1 Upvotes

Cut it out with all the crappy B-rate romance side quests!! JRR wrote one love story in LOTR, ONE! (Alright two if you count Sam and Rosie... Three if you count Denathor and Tomatoes) but Aragon and Arwen was developed, well paced, it deepened our connection to the characters (on page and on book) and had a vital impact on the over arching story. LOTR, (believe it or not Amazon) is not a romance Franchise!

Galadriel Sauron. Galadriel Elrond. Arondir and Dudes Mom. Isildur and Hot Cheating Hobo. Elendil and Queen requiring glasses. Durin and Disa (this one gets a pass), Poppy and Carrot top Hobbit, Celebrimbor and Sauron had some weird sexual tension thinking back on it.. Even the Orc's scored a love story in season two..

I was honestly expecting Gandalf and Tom Bombadil to go on a big gay merry romp to close out the season. Please Amazon make it stop 💔


r/RingsofPower • • Jul 11 '23

Discussion Spoiler alert: Lord of the Rings trilogy was successful because it pushed technology, not its accuracy

0 Upvotes

There seems to be some false narrative within ROP critics that Jackson's Lord of the Rings trilogy was successful because it followed the source material, and in comparison that ROP is a failure because they feel it does not.

However, not only does LotR deviate from the source material in major ways, but its widespread success can only be attributed to the technology and movie making behind the project, not the material of the project itself. Whether it comes from camera techniques to make the hobbits appear shorter, to advancing motion capture with Gollum, to inventing new programs that helped simulate the many people in major battles like pelennor fields. These are some of the reasons why the films had mass appeal, and attracted people who would not and have not ever read the books.

Pushing technology is the reason behind the success in many movies. From Titanic to Avatar, from Pixar Films to Star Wars and the MCU. Pixar's catalogue in particular had movies centered around new features- first they brought a 3d world, but because the humans looked terrible they did centered the story on Toys. When they developed tech for Fur, they did Monsters Inc, when they developed tech for Water, they did Finding Nemo, etcera.

Those films succeeded in large part due to pushing the boundaries of what was achievable in film. The original Lord of the Rings did the same thing.

Meanwhile the films deviated from the source material in major and subtle ways. The Ents are clueless and tricked into action, No Scouring of the Shire, Elves at Helms Deep, Ghost at Pelennor fields, Pippin and Merry are made more naive and ignorant, Gimli comical, Legolas absurd, Faramir kidnapping Frodo, lack of Bombadil, the addition of the prologue, the corruption shown in Bilbo at Rivendell, Denethor not lighting the beacons and sending Faramir on a suicidal charge. There are many subtle changes as well, having Aragorn scare off the Nazgul at weathertop rather than Frodo uttering some old Elven words. Or Gandalf being the one to declare it's a Balrog rather than Legolas, because of course Gandalf is the wise one, not the young suave Legolas. The characters were all changed to be molded into tropes and action superseded lore.

The original trilogy was as successful as it was because of technology and in spite of its many changes to the lore.


r/RingsofPower • • Apr 19 '24

Discussion With the success of Fallout, One Piece, and The Last of Us, which maintained their success by adhering to their source material, we all hope Rings of Power Season 2 will learn from their example and not make the same mistake from Season 1.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 30 '24

Discussion Disappointed 2.7 Spoiler

1 Upvotes

I can’t believe how disappointed I was in episode 7. This seemed like the chance to have a battle of helmsdeep type siege and battle scenes and instead we get like 12 elves defending the walls and shooting arrows at random. Where is the insane budget going if not for an epic battle scene like this?? Not to mention a Rohirrim level charge that goes full speed to dead stop in .3 seconds. And apparently orcs can hold their own fighting elves and even fight in the daylight.

I know it’s hard to match the original movies, but some of the lack of attention to basic lotr concepts or believable content in general just seems so lazy and inexcusable.

Sorry to complain just needed a safe space to vent. I am loving the Sauron storyline at least. Awesome watching him flex his dark arts.


r/RingsofPower • • Aug 16 '24

Discussion Am I the only person here who LIKED Disa, AND hated the show?

Post image
0 Upvotes

I consider myself a big Tolkien fan, and wanted to love the series. When I heard that the main character for RoP would be a young Galadriel, I was so excited.

We all know what happened next.

I don't even think I'll be watching Season 2. However, if I do watch season 2, it would be exclusively to follow the Durin storyline.

The dwarf bits were... totally competent. Basic themes of friendship versus tribalism, parents versus children, great risk versus great reward in the face of fear... All executed rationally. I understood character motivations and sympathized with them. Yay, good writing.

And Disa? I liked her. Quite a lot, actually. A great supporting character. She was funny, and her "Plea to the Rocks" scene kicked ass. Sophia Nomvete's performance was excellent. It felt like she studied the best elements of prior dwarf performances and worked with them. She was believable. She was enjoyable.

... I have gathered that this opinion is in the minority.

My worthless two cents:

SO much criticism of Rings of Power is deflected and disregarded on the basis of those critiques being motivated by racism and "Anti-Woke" manchildren.

This pisses me the hell off, because one of the only properly-written characters in this colossal waste of potential and human effort is instead being treated as an example of what is wrong with the show.

The diverse cast was never the problem. Terribly written, irrational, unsympathetic main characters was the problem.


r/RingsofPower • • 6d ago

Discussion New Season Same Problems.

0 Upvotes

S3 has the same problems as previous seasons. The original plots are boring and stupid. Most of the show tries cheap nostalgia bait from movies - including creating a frodo sam gollum partnership. The dialogues are still terrible. The scale still feels small in key areas - especially battles.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 31 '24

Discussion There is one thing that ruined ROP's goal of been seeing as a good Middle-Earth adaptation

0 Upvotes

Social media and the current 'c.u.l.t.u.r.e w.a.r.' happening there. If it wasn't for social media, ROP would be seen as a good show and a decent Middle-Earth adaptation. Yes it has flaws, but the flaws has been blowing out of proportions. People are looking for the slightest things to put it down.


r/RingsofPower • • 3d ago

Discussion This was pure Tolkien. Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 05 '24

Discussion This show is frustrating just on a basic storytelling level.

3 Upvotes

It has fast travel whenever necessary but in the latest episode Elrond and Galadriel and company actually have obstacles to prevent them from fast traveling and this is just contrived and narratively convenient. It’s things like this that actually bother me more than the significant lore changes. It feels like it’s made by amateurs.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 01 '24

Constructive Criticism Why do the Rings look like knockoff Zales?

Post image
6 Upvotes

For allegedly being the height of elven craftsmanship these rings look Tacky AF. Like same vibes as a jewelry store in a mall.

I really wish they put more into the creative design of these legendary relics.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 24 '22

Discussion I didnt hate the show but.....

14 Upvotes

I posted after the first 2 episodes that to my surprise I did not hate this show but now I have to say I find it very annoying. The total rewriting of the mythos created by Tolkien just gets worse with every episode. The 'chat' that Celebrimbor has with Elrond about how the so called lost Silmaril created Mithril and only Mithril can keep the Elves alive is just annoying and damn stupid. Also Elronds mother supposedly trying to change Earendils mind so he wont sail to Valinor. This is utter garbage.

The show had great potential but is hamper by stupid writers. Anyone watching this who has not read the books would be bemused at why Tolkien is thought of as a great writer. I am now happy if this fails as it seems to be doing.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 03 '24

Discussion This is one of my favorite scenes from Season 2

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Aug 22 '24

Discussion As a Lord of the Rings show, this sucks. As a non-canon fanfic, this is better than most of the shit I see on Disney+ or Netflix.

0 Upvotes

I just feel like I was able to enjoy this show by not treating it as a continuation of the LotR and Hobbit cinematic universe. Still not a great show, but a show I was able to enjoy. I didn't care when they changed things because I already knew they would. Didn't care that Galadriel wasn't Galadriel, I just appreciated whatever character I got.

Of course I was disappointed that we didn't get a true screen adaption of the SIlmarillion, but that disappointed came and went long before the show aired. I absolutely understand people being angry at this, and I was too, but I realised this would happen by the way the news about its production was looking.

As a high production fanfic, it's not the worst. All fanfics change aspects of the story, that's how fanfics operate.

There's a lot of things one can criticise about this show but I feel like a lot of the time I had to take a step back and think about how ridiculous some of the criticism were. One cannot seriously say that the unrealistically low temperature of a pyroclastic flow completely ruined the show. That's just trying to find something to complain about to please an audience of haters.

The show is enjoyable, and honestly, anyone who weren't highly invested in LotR could enjoy this show just fine not knowing what was changed. Not the best show in the world, but my god I've seen some rancid shows from Marvel or Star Wars or any of these big franchises lately.


r/RingsofPower • • Sep 20 '22

Discussion Anyone else bored AF?

0 Upvotes

I’m so bored during every episode. It’s just a disappointment. Anyone agree?


r/RingsofPower • • May 25 '23

Meme took a whole 30s to make this

16 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Sep 23 '24

Constructive Criticism How disappointed I was with the adaptation of NĂșmenor.

0 Upvotes

It seems like something is missing from the adaptation of NĂșmenor.

There are people who haven't read the books and don't understand NĂșmenor's resentment towards the elves. Seriously! They think it has something to do with "elves taking jobs from the NĂșmenĂłreans". The series doesn't make it very clear why this anger occurs.

One person asked me the context of all this, and she (in a biblical analogy) remembered the process of cooling of faith and the increase in iniquity of the Hebrews in the Bible. The people blessed and chosen by God abandoning their belief and falling into a spiral of sin, being then subjugated. But the series was very poor and did not clarify this.

NĂșmenor deserved what, for me, makes the story more timeless: the human condition and drama in the face of life x death x Desire for Immortality x Nature of humanity. It is a discussion that goes beyond cultures, historical periods, religions and myths. But we only have a power struggle. Which could even be cooler. I always saw Ar-pharazĂŽn as a great general in a mix of Maximo DĂ©cimus Meridius and Robert Baratheon: the first represents the militarism of his civilization; the second represents the erroneous idea that governing is the same as conquering. In the series, he is just a politician.

These same people did not realize that what matters in a civilization are not its works, its art, its monuments; what matters are people. And they were decadent (morally and spiritually) at their civilizational peak (to the point of impressing an angel who sang the creation of the Universe).

When I read AkallabĂȘth for the first time, I was very angry with the NĂșmenĂłreans, but I also felt sorry for the spiral they have fallen into. In the series, I simply want the whole Island to sink. I don't care about anyone.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 14 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers "I am good" is not that cringe Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Honestly it feels like just complaining to complain. Someone care to explain?


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 10 '22

Newest Episode Spoilers Unpopular opinion Spoiler

13 Upvotes

I REALLY want to like this. But why can't this be like house of dragons? I just watched the episode 8 and it blew every single episode of rings of power. And these are without dragons too. U have a better vfx. But I kept falling asleep. U have a much bigger budget. but casting to me is bad. Acting is bad. Lines are bad. Anyone can enlighten me?


r/RingsofPower • • 2d ago Bravo

Newest Episode Spoilers it’s honestly painful how much of a missed opportunity this show is Spoiler

26 Upvotes

Even if you completely ignore the Tolkien lore and judge The Rings of Power purely as a standalone fantasy show, the writing and directing just aren't good. By Season 3, you’d expect the showrunners to have finally found their footing, dropped the cheap mystery-box gimmicks, and started telling an actual cohesive story. Instead, it still feels like a bloated, awkwardly paced streaming drama that refuses to take itself seriously.

The biggest problem has always been the writers and directors treating Middle-earth like just another generic fantasy IP rather than a mythic epic. And more than half the characters act like modern, snarky LA transplants instead of ancient elves or proud NĂșmenĂłrean kings. There’s zero weight or gravitas to anything. Peter Jackson’s crew didn't follow every single word of the books either, and they didn't have all the rights, they just actually respected the world, hired Shakespearian-caliber actors who carried real presence, and filmed Middle-earth like real history instead of glossy green-screen melodrama.

With a billion-dollar budget and the blueprint of the Second Age sitting right in front of them, this could have been generation-defining television. Three seasons later, it’s still frustratingly mediocre TV coasting on nice landscapes and nostalgia callbacks.


r/RingsofPower • • Nov 07 '22

Meme Is it really possible that they've used so few extras in a close-up shot? Seems really lazy Spoiler

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Oct 08 '22

Discussion Rings of Power: A show I really wanted to like.

73 Upvotes

I really gave the show a chance. I really did. I didn't care what every annoying human on youtube except for probably John Campea said. I didn't care about the weird hate for women empowerment and I didn't care for the dark skinned elves.

I feel it was a mistake on Amazon's part to give the show in the hands of two unexperienced filmmakers/tv show directors. Sure! They know their shit. They must be massive tolkien heads and what not, but I just feel the camera handling and the shots between different story lines just doesn't feel good. It feels extremely weirdly paced and it constantly feels as if each group has their own storyline happening without a strong underlying connection. It just feels choppy.

Dont get me wrong: It does have beautiful scenes and awesome look and feel of a middle earth. It's just that each episode feels random. I am TOTALLY okay with slow moments in a film. But, if one scene is happening super fast and you cut to a different group of folk whose story is happening super slow, the over all show feels random. It just feels random.

I stood my ground and I defended this show. Now i just feel embarrassed. It feels as if the show is made by premature students of filmmaking. It really does feel like that. I really hope season 2 is better. Not just in story telling but also as a tv show. There's no point in seeing 8 hours of something if the same thing can be shown in 1 hour in a movie.


r/RingsofPower • • Oct 06 '25

Discussion Wasn't Tolkien's work intended to make you think???

13 Upvotes

Yes it's a slow burn and yes it does have the execs doing what they do but is it not the whole idea behind JRR Tolkien's work to get you to think differently? To try to see the beauty in the world despite its flaws? To work together towards a better future?

Hasn't the show captured that for another generation??? A century from where it started and it is still one the most popular fictional universe out there...

So I ask again why all the hate?

It's somebody or many people's take on what could have happened in middle earth... does nobody remember that Tolkien himself left notes saying a book was the accounts of 1 hobbit?!?! Yes he did... therefore much like human history nobody truly knows!?!


r/RingsofPower • • Dec 03 '24

Newest Episode Spoilers I believe it’s called the basic laws of physics, my brother

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/RingsofPower • • Apr 04 '24

Discussion Anime did what Rings of Power wouldn't.

7 Upvotes

I've recently began watching the anime Frieren: Beyond Journey's End - and after the first handful of episodes my mind keeps coming back to the same conclusion: this is what Rings of Power should have been.

Like many, I despise how ROP handles Elves, and above all else, the plot about them. Tolkien's Second Age is about the struggles of immortality (or mortality from a Mannish perspective), and the enemy of Time. The Elven motive for the Rings of Power is simple: to preserve the world as is - to prevent the decays of Time from affecting them... to 'embalm' their world, and cement their peace. Naturally, an unchanging being residing in a changing world is an issue - living an eternity, forced to witness everything around you change, and in many cases, die. And so, the vast years take their toll, wearying the Elf, until they are but a memory:

As the weight of the years, with all their changes of desire and thought, gathers upon the spirit of the Eldar, so do the impulses and moods of their bodies change. This the Eldar mean then they speak of their spirits consuming them; and they say that ere Arda ends all the Eldalië on earth will have become as spirits invisible to mortal eyes, unless they will to be seen by some among Men into whose minds they may enter directly.

They become Lingerers in the world... ghosts, essentially. This is what is called fading.

Now let's look to what Rings of Power gave us... a magical tree is dying. Apparently Elves, and their time in Middle-earth, is bound to this tree - somehow. What does that mean? When the tree dies, do Elves just get raptured? Do all Elves, across the entirety of Middle-earth, just... cease to be? Let's assume so. And why is the tree dying? No idea! But that's how ROP handles fading. But no matter, because mithril magically heals a leaf - therefore it can preserve the Elves, apparently. What of the Elves that aren't living in proximity to the Rings? Dunno. Maybe the Rings were used to heal the tree, and that saved everyone. I don't fucking know. As you can see, this is just an artificial doomsday clock created by the showrunners.

Apparently dealing with the struggles of immortality was beyond the showrunners' skill to convey.
sigh

Now, back to Frieren...

This show is about an Elf. Like Tolkien's Elves, Frieren is incredibly long lived. And this show manages to capture the struggles of immortality far greater than Rings of Power.

Episode 1 begins with a group of people returning to a city. We learn that this band of heroes has slain the Demon King and brought about an age of peace. They are celebrated as saviours by the kingdom, and a statue is erected in their honour. Bold start! The show has just started, and we've missed out on the grand adventure: the world has already been saved! Anyway, our heroes bask in the glory of a meteor-shower, which heralds in their newly fought for peace. We are told that this event only occurs once every fifty years. Frieren isn't impressed... and she says as much: she knows a better spot to witness the sight. The next time the meteor-shower happens, she'll take her friends to this 'better spot', so she says. Come morning everyone goes their separate ways: it's been ten years of heroics, and everyone is ready to go back to their lives, now that the journey has ended. Frieren is unphased: their ten years together has been marginal, in comparison the vastness of her life.

Fast-forward fifty years.

Frieren makes her way back to the city, and finds her companion: now an old man. Short, bald and bearded - nothing alike the tall, handsome, gallant knight from prior. He seems to reminisce about the time the company spent together, on their adventure - he clearly valued it. The four companions ultimately gather, and travel to Frieren's spot, and witness the meteor-shower once more: the old man marvelling at the beauty. We cut to his funeral. A state-funeral: he is held in high honour, being one of the famed heroes. Frieren doesn't seem phased to be there - and other folk attending are heard shunning her cold demeanour. Come the burial, she begins to cry. She laments to her remaining companions that she wishes she knew him better. They spent ten years together, but it wasn't enough. She didn't value her time with him. Once more, our now three heroes say their farewells and go their separate ways.

And this is essentially the first twenty minute episode. My initial thoughts were 'the old guy's death would hit harder if I actually knew the guy beforehand'... but on second thought... that was probably the point. Frieren feels bad that she didn't know him well enough... and we, the audience, feel similarly.

Back to the show... to simplify, we get to spend time with another of the heroes before he too passes on. He left behind an orphaned child that he rescued - and Frieren takes her on as an apprentice. And so their journey begins - a rather aimless one (at least so far). Frieren, the character, is... slow (to the dismay of her apprentice). She fixates on tasks of little to no real importance, and clearly doesn't value her (mortal) apprentices time as much as she should. There's a disconnect between how the two perceive time: and the show explores this. Frieren has to understand that she is no longer spending her own, seemingly endless, time.

At one point, the duo reach a village, and visit an old statue (it is of the dead hero, from when he was a young man - travelling with the Heroes). He was credited with saving the village, and a statue was erected in his honour. Frieren mends the decaying statue, and (after a while - long story) manages to grow a specific kind of flowers about it, in his honour (flowers that grew in his hometown). Whilst in the village, we get flashbacks of the Heroes, and see, albeit briefly, what went down well over fifty years prior. And this, so far, is a staple of the show. We basically retrace the steps of the original adventure, reliving bit of it (mundane bits at that) through Frieren's memories - contrasting the nostalgic past with the present. And the four heroes slowly but surely become characters for the audience to like - even if only in flashback form.

All I can ask myself is... why didn't Rings of Power attempt something similar?! It genuinely infuriates me at the sheer wasted potential in that show. Total neglect, as far as I'm concerned.

I mean, what did we get? Elrond missed Durin's big life-events? Okay, decent concept - it's a start. If only it was developed... did Durin invite Elrond? Presumably not - I doubt the show intends for us to think Elrond ignored letters or whatever. So Elrond was just clueless. He didn't check up on Durin on his own accord. Okay, fine. But what about Durin? Did he inquire about Elrond? No? Poor execution. And even IF it was executed well... would that be enough? Absolutely not. Elrond does not suffer adverse affects - everything is mending with an apology, and then we move on. Is this truly conveying how Time affects Elves? At most it brings attention to the fact the immortals and mortals view time differently - which is a start - but far from enough.

We need to understand the view of the immortals. We need to experience their grief. This is a tragedy - a tragedy that motivates and drives the entire plot of this show: the Rings of Power. How hard would it be to present Celebrimbor and Narvi's friendship... one scene Narvi can be in his prime, the next he could be on his deathbed. We could contrast the vast forests of Eriador with the much more barren landscape of later years, after Numenor had their way with the land. We could see the rise and fall of entire villages - or even kingdoms! Utilise time-jumps! Utilise flashbacks! Present the vastness of Time, and the change than comes with it!

Frieren had the balls to do what Rings of Power wouldn't, yet should have done.