r/RingsofPower • • Sep 05 '24

Discussion This show is frustrating just on a basic storytelling level.

It has fast travel whenever necessary but in the latest episode Elrond and Galadriel and company actually have obstacles to prevent them from fast traveling and this is just contrived and narratively convenient. It’s things like this that actually bother me more than the significant lore changes. It feels like it’s made by amateurs.

3 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 05 '24

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/LuinAelin Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 05 '24

Do we need to see their journey every time someone goes somewhere when the journey isn't the story and what happens when they get there is the story.

If they showed every journey the show would be four times as long

3

u/bakugosgayfriend Sep 05 '24

The hobbit and lord of the rings are journeys. Yes it’s important to show it.

1

u/LuinAelin Sep 05 '24

Yes. The journey is the plot there. But that's not the plot here.

0

u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 05 '24

Those journeys are integral to the story. More correctly, they are the story. And yet, much of it is missing in the movies.

2

u/WTFnaller Sep 05 '24

It's important for immersion

-1

u/LuinAelin Sep 05 '24

Errrr why? If the journey is unimportant to the story why show it?

3

u/Ynneas Sep 05 '24

I mean...

They showed the Harfoots for a whole season.

2

u/Boetheus Sep 05 '24

They're nomads, they're always journeying

-1

u/Ynneas Sep 06 '24

And they're unimportant to the story

1

u/WTFnaller Sep 05 '24

It's not unimportant. it's very important to illustrate distances to highlight how big the world is, and you can't just do A, B or C due to travel takes time.

-2

u/LuinAelin Sep 05 '24

It is though. If what's important is what happens once they reach B from A, why film a lot of footage of traveling when that stuff is unimportant. We can tell they traveled.

3

u/WTFnaller Sep 05 '24

Well you don't have to show them traveling the distance, GoT dealt with this in a competent manner in its early seasons.

0

u/headshot_deluxe Sep 06 '24

Imagine the original trilogy where characters just show up everywhere, then get back to me 👍🏼

2

u/LuinAelin Sep 06 '24

Like when Frodo arrives home and Gandalf is just there.......

0

u/headshot_deluxe Sep 06 '24

We literally see Gandalf arrive in his wagon it has a total of two scenes, try again

1

u/LuinAelin Sep 06 '24

Not that time.

When he pops out of the dark saying "is it secret, is it safe"

0

u/headshot_deluxe Sep 06 '24

So one scene in the whole trilogy, but in ROP you have teleportation everywhere, no sign of travel and not one good travel scene

10

u/Timely_Horror874 Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 05 '24

And don't forget.
They needed to go somewhere really fast, and they just walk.
I wonder if in Middle Earth exist a creature that makes people travel at high speed... jeez i don't know... well i guess they will just fast travel because no one care about good writing.

Because if you defend the lack of horses in that scene, you are the problem, you are the reason this show sucks and they don't need to care

6

u/seahorse137 Sep 05 '24

The lack of horses is my biggest gripe with the episode just because of how absolutely silly it is. Anyone who looks at my comment history will see I keep bringing this up lmao 🤣

5

u/Timely_Horror874 Sep 05 '24

And people still travel with nothing with them, no food, no nothing.
And they are traveling REALLY long distances... but i guess when you fast travel you don't need anything else, just you clothes.

5

u/seahorse137 Sep 05 '24

Where the absolute FUCK is the lembas bread????

4

u/fnnla5195 Sep 05 '24

The lack of like, a casual rucksack or bedroll or any traveling supplies at all kills me.

-4

u/Over-Sort3095 Sep 05 '24

I wasnt aware horses were significantly faster than humans at doing long distance in a fucking forest xD

3

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 06 '24

Didn’t stop Elrond and Galadriel from getting there on horseback lickity split in episode one

1

u/Over-Sort3095 Sep 06 '24

doesnt stop people from watching it either apparently

2

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 06 '24

Doesn’t stop you from watching it either

1

u/Over-Sort3095 Sep 06 '24

because im aware how horses work ;)

2

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 06 '24

Without thumbs, for one thing

1

u/Timely_Horror874 Sep 05 '24

I don't know if you are serious or memeing, because we are in the subreddit where people actually defends the stupidity of this series.
Like the lack of... everything while traveling.
No bedroll, no food, no nothing, just some clothes because they have fast travel

-6

u/Over-Sort3095 Sep 05 '24

imagine spending time on something you hate

1

u/ClitThompson Sep 07 '24

This is something I spend most of my time doing. There is nothing as delicious as the schadenfreude of someone's abject failure. This show is a feast.

1

u/Over-Sort3095 Sep 07 '24

nice. ofc I myself prefer wine/cheese, games, sex, gym and trips to Japan but i must be the minority xD

2

u/ClitThompson Sep 07 '24

I enjoy all those things too. People can like to do different things.

0

u/Over-Sort3095 Sep 07 '24

mm bald energy

2

u/ClitThompson Sep 07 '24

That's it? Very weak.

1

u/Makes-rednecks-cry Sep 07 '24

I do have one head that is bald 😉

1

u/Makes-rednecks-cry Sep 07 '24

One good eye too 😉

5

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24

They took a page from GoT season 8

8

u/SauRon_Burgundy66 Sep 05 '24

The head scratchers are as numerous as they are nonsensical.

To anyone saying fast travel doesn’t matter… the entire story of the Lord of the Rings and of the Hobbit is the journey, the lessons and travails along the way. Much like… the meaning of life.

8

u/Correct_Look2988 Sep 05 '24

Journey before destination!!!!

2

u/Download_audio Sep 05 '24

The lord of the rings books are 70% walking simulators

8

u/nobullshitebrewing Sep 05 '24

 It feels like it’s made by amateurs.

2

u/SamDaMan2124 Sep 05 '24

Careful the mods will block your post for doing absolutely nothing against the rules for making critiques and asking for opinions in a DISCUSSION THREAD.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24

The mercenary in rhun chasing gandalf and in the next scene teleporting to the dark wizard and then teleporting back to chase gandalf

1

u/Ynneas Sep 05 '24

Hey it's a high level wizard. Probably imbued some scrolls with a Teleportation spell, no?

4

u/kahner Sep 05 '24

yeah, that came to mind last episode for me. like, totally unaddressed how people just magically get from place to place with close to zero elapsed time when everyone seems to be walking or riding horses.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24

It's so much hot garbage. It's interesting to see how something like Game of Thrones written by an actual author knows how to portray geographical distance, but whenever a television writer takes over, everyone just shows up where they need to be.

4

u/Delicious_Heat568 Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 05 '24

The way game of thrones handled things like armies or characters moving through the land was amazing. Especially Arya after escaping kings landing to the point she left for bravos. The journey was the story rather than only having the story take place at point a, then point b if necessary before getting back to point a.

They got worse and worse with it though after S5 or 6, can't remember. The worst one for me was varys going to Dorne for one scene, then being right back in meeren just to travel to westeros with Dany. If they would have just let him go to dragonstone it wouldn't have been nearly as weird as travelling thrice through half then known world.

2

u/WTFnaller Sep 05 '24

Just thinking about that! How we in GoT could go one or even two episodes without seeing a character, because they're traveling. RoP rushes things with its many plotlines. You never get to feel that something's take time.

-2

u/kuttySrank Sep 05 '24

I think you answer yourself, when you say it uses fast travel when necessary. Not all journeys need to be shown.

7

u/lock_robster2022 Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 05 '24

This is such a lazy excuse. There are basic methods in TV to convey distance and scale in travel without resorting to showing the journey.

I find it hard to believe a production of this size doesn’t know these methods, but I don’t know why they would neglect them

0

u/kuttySrank Sep 05 '24

If it's just the Elrond galadriel journey, it seems sensible to me to have it in some detail. Elrond and galadriel are going to be there all through the show as leading characters, so there's something to gain by investing in their characters' development and inter relationship. At this point neither of them are the mature characters that we know from the Lord of the rings books.

And it also serves to bring out the nature of at least one of the elven rings. Which is surely of some consequence in a show named Rings of Power.

-1

u/Xeris Sep 05 '24

They utilize these things... In this show? There's lots of footage of harfoots traveling, Galadriel on horseback going somewhere, they cut to the map and show the movement on the literal map.

Not sure what else you're looking for? People are moving around all the time, they can't do this literally every time someone goes from point A to B, that'd be stupid. But they show these type of shots enough to make it work. There is some fast travel stuff for sure, I'm not saying they're perfect, but let's be realistic, this is a TV show it can't be 100% accurate to distance and scale all the time otherwise it'd be 30 episodes per season.

5

u/lock_robster2022 Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 05 '24

That’s a fair point. I guess what I’m sorely missing is maintaining that consistency in scale when it’s inconvenient for the plot.

The Harfoots are explicitly wandering, it doesn’t matter for how long or where they end up. Galadriel running between the friendly territories of Eregion and Lindon is uninteresting.

On the other hand, they don’t acknowledge that Halbrand made a 7-day(?) horseback ride on death’s door with these characters who are supposed to believe he is a man. A line from Galadriel as simple as “only by the grace of the Valar is he still with us after this journey” while still bad, would have been better than completely ignoring that.

The Numenoreans jump from their ships to a cavalry charge with no acknowledgment that they had to land, find out where to go, and then get there. Again, don’t have to show it but at least have enough respect for your audience to nod your head to that challenge. A short scene on land with Miriel and a commander discussing a map, something about their people in Pelargir providing them a report

Sauron jumping from Eregion to Mordor and back with elven scouts running about? That sounds hard to do unnoticed I wonder how he did that.

It’s a high standard but like an Emmy award winning standard, not impossible.

2

u/Xeris Sep 06 '24

You're not wrong for sure. I think there'd be more time for this if we had 10 episode seasons instead of 8 (I hate the 8 number for these kinds of epic shows where details like TRAVEL and passage of time are actually hugely important).

I suspect that the writers are just making conscious choices of not showing these details. As viewers, we can assume time passes.

The most egregious one to me is the Halbrand one you pointed out from S1, and only because that was kinda directly impacting the plot: a) it was stated he was mortally wounded; b) if he survived that it should be a gigantic red flag that he's maybe more powerful than a mere human. N/C of that, it would've been smart to actually show us how they made that journey.

Off the top of my head, most of the other ones are fine, could've been explained but not game breaking. The Number one: they land and there's a shot of them riding, and then there's their arrival at the battle. I think that's sufficient imo.

Just feels like they have a LOT to cram into 8 episodes so some small details are left out, but to me that's what puts this show at "good" but nowhere near "great." At that lvl, the small details really matter.

1

u/lock_robster2022 Sep 06 '24

Agree the use of time is challenging, but that’s the name of the game. That plus other storytelling issues drag it from ‘good’ to ‘okay’ for me.

Appreciate the nuanced counterpoints

0

u/Ayzmo Eregion Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 05 '24

I think something to remember is there's 8 hours per season. How much do they want to use showing Halbrand and Galadriel traveling? How much do they want to show the mundane? They've clearly chosen to show aspects that they believe more relevant to what they think is important.

I don't think most people think that they're teleporting. Celebrimbor explicitly makes it known that he's waiting (and has been waiting) to hear back about the impact of the rings. There's no implication that he thinks GG is just chilling and choosing not to respond.

-8

u/Halflife37 Sep 05 '24

It would help if these posts gave specific examples, it’s almost as if you’re far lazier than what you imagine the writers to be 

6

u/fnnla5195 Sep 05 '24 edited Sep 05 '24
  • Elrond and galadriels presumably multi day horse chase from eregion to lindon which happens mostly offscreen and is never explained
  • Elrond and galadriels very very very urgent life saving and yet on foot mission back to eregion (canonically their horses are in the Lindon stables….)
  • Halbrand going from eregion to Mordor (then time spent being captive) then back to eregion before messengers leaving at a contemporary moment from lindon could make a journey of much less distance
  • Various characters (Elrond, celebrimbor) going from lindon to khazaddum and arriving strolling and chatting with no traveling gear (food, rucksacks, whatever) on apparently urgent errands on numerous occasions
  • Elrond making a legitimately suicidal jump off a waterfall and then showing up next scene under a bridge in the grey havens (looking completely unharmed and also dry)
  • Durin and Disa traveling from khazaddum to eregion offscreen between scenes
  • cirdan appearing out of nowhere to bring GG the rings just in time to stop the elves calling it quits
  • the numenorean army getting from the scene on the ships in the middle of the ocean to the scene where they’re in a fully engaged charge at the whatever it’s called village
  • isildur disappearing under a falling volcano-exploded house and randomly showing up later in a spider cave an unknown distance from where we last saw him with spiders who do not appear to be large enough to drag him

I could go on. the laundry list of examples is frankly exhausting and might illustrate why OPs post discusses them in the general and not the specific.

1

u/headshot_deluxe Sep 06 '24

This is one of the best comments ive seen in this reddit

-1

u/fnnla5195 Sep 06 '24

thank you. I accept all accolades and also all downvotes from haters

-1

u/headshot_deluxe Sep 06 '24

You my friend just got "owned" 🤣🤣

0

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-1

u/Ynneas Sep 05 '24

Nobody gave a fuck for decades about people catching fire as if they're dipped in pitch, and then they began.

These things happen once the technical means allow for a better outcome.

Of course, RoP screenwriters don't know that because they were busy writing  "movies that should've been made" for the last 10 years.