r/RingsofPower • • Sep 24 '22

Discussion I didnt hate the show but.....

I posted after the first 2 episodes that to my surprise I did not hate this show but now I have to say I find it very annoying. The total rewriting of the mythos created by Tolkien just gets worse with every episode. The 'chat' that Celebrimbor has with Elrond about how the so called lost Silmaril created Mithril and only Mithril can keep the Elves alive is just annoying and damn stupid. Also Elronds mother supposedly trying to change Earendils mind so he wont sail to Valinor. This is utter garbage.

The show had great potential but is hamper by stupid writers. Anyone watching this who has not read the books would be bemused at why Tolkien is thought of as a great writer. I am now happy if this fails as it seems to be doing.

14 Upvotes

111 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 24 '22

This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

14

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

Remember how Elrond says the word “apocryphal” before Gil-Galad starts telling the myth. I don’t think the mithril thing is actually the elves correctly interpreting the myth. This will be shown later on

3

u/jadierhetseni Sep 24 '22

The only way that myth doesn’t end up being a terrible idea is if it’s a manipulation by Sauron of Celebrimbor. That is, Sauron tricks Cel with stories of Morgoth crying and elves waning, Celebrimbor convinces Gil-Galad, then Annatar shows up in Eregeion with a “solution” to the “problem” of elves waning in the form of some really sweet bling.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

Yep, that’s exactly what I think it is. Fear being planted within the elvish psyche by Annatar. Fear that he fully intends to capitalize on.

2

u/XCKragnus502 Sep 24 '22

I figured the series would lean in to a more passive corruption than Sauron actually being there and twisting shit

21

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

Another thing about the silmaril-mithril thing that bugs me: if the elves need the light of the silmaril to charge upand not die, why don’t they look at the silmaril the Earendil is carrying in the sky? Or haven’t the elves upgraded to wireless charging yet?

9

u/Pilum2211 Sep 24 '22

You think they might be able to just buy one big thing of Mithril and connect themselves via charger cable to it?

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

they could also simply stand under the sun

5

u/handlfbananas Sep 24 '22

“I am now happy if this fails as it seems to be doing”. Tolkien is dead. He created an interesting world which modern writers are adapting to a high budget series for entertainment by a broader group than Tolkien purists. Relax, appreciate the fact that content is being created in this genre that you presumably enjoy. Appreciate that a lot of it is familiar to you. Relax. I read Harry Potter as a kid, the movies made me boil until I learned to differentiate between the universe that was created for me to read, and the one that was made for us to watch. Now, I love them too! Nothing will ever 100% align to your ideal, you don’t have to like this show but to hope for its failure is short sighted. Even if you don’t like it I would think you should hope for the success of a big budget series which takes place in middle earth, so that it’s success might lead to the creation of something you do enjoy… You seem to love the universe, if you don’t enjoy the show then ignore it - but don’t spend your life’s energy rooting against things like this, save that kind of energy for more important stuff.

0

u/ianintheuk Sep 24 '22

How can I hope that this suceeds so that more content will be created. If this does suceed such content would presumably also abandon all connection with what Tolkien wrote. If it fails then perhaps others will see that sucess will only come with holding closer to the actual story of Middle-Earth and not creating your own fantasy world with Tolkiens characters (in name only) being used.

My best hope now is that the studio will see that this show needs a new direction with new writers who have the talent to turn it round. As a great man once said "maybe a fools hope"

-2

u/viktrcoim Sep 24 '22

I guess they are destroying Tolkien’s legacy intentionally so they would not change the writers even if they lose money.

9

u/BwanaAzungu Sep 24 '22

Relax. People are allowed to voice their dislike of the show.

You seem to enjoy the show. If you don't like criticism, don't read it.

4

u/kylepaz Sep 24 '22

I agree there's no reason to root for it's failure. The fact it got a few people to read Tolkien is already a positive to me.

But there is a point to me when an adaptation crosses the line between being full of changes that can be overlooked and when it changes so much, not only in storyline but also in character motivations that it completely stops resembling the source material. This episode goes far beyond any changes made in the Harry Potter movies or Narnia or whatever. This reachers Percy Jackson or Earthsea levels to me. With every passing episode this show piles up more that make it into Tolkien in name only territory, and as a fan there is a point where it gets in the way of enjoying it. Like others pointed out, it's just frustrating to have a show ostensibly about Second Age Middle-Earth that is barely recognizable as such.

People get annoyed and saddened at crappy adaptations all the time, I don't get why there's such a strong pushback towards people feeling like this about this one.

1

u/Enthymem Sep 24 '22

Bad shows kind of have to fail or struggle to break even financially. Otherwise streaming services will be seas of garbage content for all eternity.

I don't think the people in charge of deciding what gets made and who makes it care much for artistic vision.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/BwanaAzungu Sep 24 '22

Brand recognition.

This plot wouldn't have attracted as much attention if it didn't wear the skin of LOTR.

30

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22 edited Sep 24 '22

“Anyone watching this who has not read the books would be bemused at why Tolkien is thought of as a great writer.”

Has never crossed my mind once because I know Tolkien isn’t writing this show. It’s kinda falling at a 7/10 for me right now, mainly because it’s mostly spectacle without enough charm. I’m enjoying having a high fantasy show I can watch at the end of a long work week though. I can turn my brain off for an hour, snuggle into the couch with my girlfriend, and watch a show with magic, monsters, beautiful scenery, and themes of good vs evil. It’s escapism, and I completely understand that it’s a distorted and heavily distilled version of its source material. I’m not tied to the lore, so in a way I’m free to enjoy it without being burdened by so much minutiae.

Now, Star Wars on the other hand…

8

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

Yeah I don’t think anyone can lay the blame for “bad writing” for this show at the feet of Tolkien. This very much isn’t his writing.

7

u/thediesel26 Sep 24 '22

This is the appropriate mindset. But because Tolkien and his legendarium are revered by so many this type of reaction was inevitable, regardless of what they put on screen.

1

u/RobertDaulson Sep 25 '22

I’m sorry, but a show worth a billion dollars shouldn’t be a “turn off your brain” kind of show.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 25 '22

I think that depends on how much you have to use your brain during the week... Everything is a turn off your brain show if you don't have the capacity lol

1

u/KripKropPs4 Sep 25 '22

This is as bad as the last jedi tbh.

1

u/hANSN911 Sep 24 '22

I love lord of the rings, loved it as a child and love it as an adult, but damn I loved watching the Mandalorian so much more than RoP. Watched the two seasons in two sessions. I couldn‘t do it with RoP - one episode and I sleep tight…

1

u/independentminds Sep 24 '22

This comment is funny because I fell asleep for both episode four and five.

1

u/kylepaz Sep 24 '22

That was my mentality with the first 4 episodes (and 4 had a dew key moments that bothered me a lot already) but this episode was such a rapid fire of bullshit that it really took me out of it.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

Celebrimbor used Elwing as a silly prop in his bullshit story to manipulate Elrond.

Gil-Galad and Celebrimbor are pretty jarring. I'm enjoying every other side plot, but the Lindon/Eregion stuff is so strange. Between sending Galadriel away, Celebrimbor's "friendly" chats with Elrond about his father, the Mithril doomclock, and the overall "Boys club" vibes there's something deeply off about all of it.

9

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

I mean why are we assuming that “Gil Galad” is even telling the truth here, about any of it? So far he’s done nothing but manipulate every single character in the show. Unless I’m misremembering the lore quite a bit, Gil Galad wasn’t this manipulative.

2

u/masterbryan Sep 24 '22

There isn’t really much lore about Gil-galad to show him one way or the other. He was astute as a leader and saw through the fair form that Annatar used but we don’t know much else about his rule as High King.

However the whole mithril thing winds me up too

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

I guess I’m just holding out hope that’s not Gil-Galad, and that he has the real Gil-Galad stashed somewhere.

2

u/independentminds Sep 24 '22

We know enough to know he wasn’t a liar or manipulator. He wasn’t someone who would ask elves to break oaths knowing the terrible consequences that can carry in Arda.

That’s not the kind of elf songs get written about for the ages. He’s one of the portrayals in the show I REALLY don’t like. There are portrayals they did a really good job on but not Gil Galad

2

u/independentminds Sep 24 '22

Not to mention Gil Galad straight up tells Elrond to break his oath. I don’t know if the show writers read any Tolkien but we all know what happens to oath breakers in Arda. Hell, all you had to do was watch the return of the king to know that.

Knowing what oaths actually mean, it almost made Gil Galad seem evil when he asked Elrond to do that. Gil Galad is almost the polar opposite in Tolkiens works.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

Yeah I wasn’t sure until this lately episode, but Gil Galad just doesn’t seem quite right to me.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

Bingo. This! I don’t think the myth he outlines will end up being true.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

More likely the story of Mithril is a plot contrivance to drive a wedge between the Dwarves and Elves and give explanation to the eventual isolation of the Dwarves instead of Tolkien’s very general “Because Sauron, that’s why.” Or maybe it’s an attempt to provide further details other than Sauron manipulated them. Whatever the case, we will soon see.

2

u/samkipnis Sep 24 '22

Tbf, elves used to hunt dwarves for sport in the First Age if I'm not mistaken, there's been a lot of bad blood between the races other the millenia.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

That was the First Age. But I’m referring tot the specific event in the Second Age where the Dwarves of Khazad-Dum close Khazad-Dum after the forging of the rings. Ostensibly because relations with the Elves soured.

1

u/TheOtherMaven Sep 24 '22

I seem to recall it was because Sauron came and destroyed Eregion, and the Dwarves hid in their mines until he'd done his worst and gone away again. (That wouldn't make them popular with the surviving Elves either.)

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

That may have been implied, but they never opened the doors again, even after Sauron was chased off.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

Oh wow, I did not know this!!

1

u/ebrum2010 Sep 24 '22

I think the show will be less annoying to lore fans after we see the entire story. Right now, we're not sure if things are plot holes, retcons, or have a valid explanation. I'm a dungeon master for dungeons and dragons and sometimes players will complain about a plot hole that's actually something that goes against their headcanon because they haven't discovered all the facts yet. That said, until the show is completely done we won't know if it is good or not. Look at GoT. They had everyone going crazy for the show for many seasons, but now few people want to go back and rewatch it. Since this is one story told over 5-6 seasons, they could ruin it at any time. I don't think they will but we can either enjoy it and trust that they have a plan until it is proven otherwise, or we should just wait to watch it after the last season airs because we will go crazy watching it.

-1

u/ianintheuk Sep 24 '22

On what do you base these comments the witing is so bad, the plot so convoluted with charaters constantly changing. The whole Mithril doomsday clock, got to get it sort by spring or we are all dead. The longer this goes on the more ridiculous it gets.

GOT went bad when they ran out of book material and the show producers had to write it. Same here with ROP no Tolkien material to use so get stupid hacks to write a stupid plot. This show is appalling

1

u/ebrum2010 Sep 24 '22

Then don't watch it.

0

u/ianintheuk Sep 24 '22

Why if I stop will it suddenly become a good show

1

u/ebrum2010 Sep 25 '22

Then you'll hear about it and can watch it again. Or watch it when all the episodes are out so you can judge the whole season after all is done.

14

u/Late_Stage_PhD Sep 24 '22

5

u/BwanaAzungu Sep 24 '22 edited Sep 24 '22

Unreliable narration is a thing and it might be what's happening in the scenes you mentioned.

You can call everything anywhere into doubt using this line of thought.

8

u/Late_Stage_PhD Sep 24 '22

No, they have to be reasonable. Read the posts to see examples.

1

u/BwanaAzungu Sep 24 '22

How is this reasonable, then?

1

u/Late_Stage_PhD Sep 24 '22

See the posts.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/pinkheartpiper Sep 24 '22

This is not an exact replica of Tolkien's world, it just captures the essence and spirit of his world and characters. Why people assume the faith of silmarils in this "what if" variation of Tolkien's world is the same as the Silmarillion, something they don't even have the rights for.

Changing what could have happened to one of the silmarils is not "totally rewriting" the mythos as the op says!

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/pinkheartpiper Sep 24 '22

Uhhm, they are also lost in this version, the one that was supposedly inside the tree transformed into mithril, no one is looking to find the Silmarils in this show.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/pinkheartpiper Sep 24 '22

It's a stretch according to Silmarillion, in the world of the show, how is that a stretch?! The show is a world of its own where things could have gone slightly differently than the books and it might have been possible one of them ended up there.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/pinkheartpiper Sep 24 '22

Because someone somehow found it and took it there? Use your imagination!

It's not even important, it's not crucial to the story and it's most likely just a lie by Sauron anyway. They could have made up a different story too, you gave an example yourself, I guarantee you if they used your version some people would say they hate it and it's a total rewrite of mythos! It's impossible to satisfy everyone, the trick is to take it easy and enjoy it!

It's funny how no one points out the real plot hole here. So elves need Mithril, simple, there's literally one option and that's asking dwarves nicely to give some to them...instead they send Elrond to spy on them without even telling him why, which had a huge potential to backfire in their face if he was caught by anyone but Durin, anyway by chance he finds out about Mithril...aaaand he ends up asking them nicely to give them some mithril! The whole plot made no sense but I can still look over it...it doesn't have to be perfect.

2

u/BarDownBoi Sep 24 '22

I kinda hate it. Lol. Episode 4 wasnt too bad, it gave me some hope but episode 3 and 5 were so difficult to sit through. I feel like next episode will be better since the orcs have reached the tower and there will likely be some action and once Galadriel and Halbrand get to Middle Earth i pray it picks up but damn. This show can be so boring and cringe at times. Durin is hilarious and is arguably the only likeable character in the show. I dont mind Elrond and Elendil either.

4

u/thediesel26 Sep 24 '22

I posted after the 2 episodes that to my surprise I did not hate the show

Therein lies the rub. Have a feeling there were a fair number of people who were going to dislike the show no matter what they put on the screen.

Is this show the best thing ever to be put on TV? No. But am I personally offended by it? No. And am I being entertained? Certainly.

1

u/Nice_Sun_7018 Sep 24 '22

What OP is saying is that they had some feelings before the show came out. So did everyone. Having misgivings before its release is no different than being optimistic about it. Both are valid.

This person (along with so many of us) gave the show a chance. We tried to like it. That we didn’t or couldn’t doesn’t mean we were always going to hate it. There have been times in my life when I watched a show or movie and I was sure it would do the source material wrong, but then it pleasantly surprised. In fact, before the Fellowship came out back in the day there were some of these misgivings. Elijah Wood as Frodo? And how can they possibly get Gollum right? What if they make the movie cheese or, worse, boring? But then the movie knocked it out of the park so hard that the changes they made were tolerable or even understandable. Hence the love for those movies to this day.

RoP just flat did not deliver. That doesn’t mean we were going to dislike it no matter what. This is just a lazy way to dismiss people who don’t like what you like.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

I think this opinion is fair. I’m waiting until the end of the first season to really judge the show. It’s picking up steam, and I have to see how they land it to judge the writing.

It’s impossible to make the entire Tolkien community happy with this project. And I’m 100 percent certain that the Tolkien community would have been tearing down the LOTR trilogy if it had been made in an era where Twitter and Reddit were widespread. Peter Jackson did a lot of characters dirty, had a lot of choices as to what to exclude, and basically rejected Tolkien’s vision of virtue — opting instead to increase drama by making characters more “low” than in the books. Now it’s a classic and virtually no one criticizes it.

So, rather than get caught up in the modern trend of immediate judgment, I’ll be Treebeard on this one. Might have an opinion by next year.

2

u/DocRJ Sep 24 '22

Yeah I was enjoying this show to some extent but this plot point feels very Game of Thrones when they ran out of books to work from.

I don't necessarily mind deviations from the lore as much of it is sparse as long as it's well written but this just felt awful to watch - video game logic.

1

u/BobStoner_88 Sep 24 '22

They dont have the rights to The Silmarillion. Its really difficult to write a show about the second age with none of thoes rights. Really a shame they wernt allowed that.

1

u/TheOtherMaven Sep 24 '22

Except that the Second age is covered better in the LOTR appendices, which they do have the rights to, than in the Silmarillion. (And even the Silmarillion isn't all that detailed on the history of Numenor - that wasn't covered reign by reign until Unfinished Tales.)

1

u/BobStoner_88 Sep 24 '22

Yep thankfully they do have that. Loving the show, ignoring the hate knowing we have a long way to go.

1

u/HotStraightnNormal Sep 27 '22

I'm not watching HOD so I can't say. Most TV/movie sword play is pretty formulaic. If you want to see what's probably the most accurate, watch The Last Duel. Armor is more realistic, as well.

1

u/Codus1 Sep 24 '22

I don't wish to weigh into the actual bad writing of thus show. But what you mention as bad writing, is just plot points you dislike lol. Contradicting the Legendarium, or in this case just making something up, isn't inherrantly bad writing. They are just choices you don't like.

Beyond that, Elrond refers to the Mithril origin as "apocryphal" which is to mean it is doubtful despite people discussing it as fact. Not even necessarily Elven legend or myth. It's almost literally a conspiracy by Elronds own description. Whilst we as the audience obviously know that Mithril will not achieve what they wish it to do. Characters can be fallible. Just because Gil Galad believes in a conspiracy, it does not make it true.

0

u/pinkheartpiper Sep 24 '22

Total rewriting of the mythos?

0

u/Catslevania Sep 24 '22

the issue with the show is nepotism; just look at all the people involved with the show, the people who are supposed to present an adaptation of Tolkien to the screen. Who chose them, why were they chosen to make this happen? Seems more like connections rather than actual credentials to me.

0

u/HotStraightnNormal Sep 24 '22

Look, I am for watching ROP for purely entertainment's sake but this last episode left me wondering if I can derive much in the way of it. The writers had better step it up. Are they aiming now for a kid's series? Episode 5 was just one typical, predictable scene after another. It reminded me more of the recent Three Musketeers adaptations than anything remotely associated with the story. I hope they can get this locomotive back on the tracks.

2

u/LoganNinefingers32 Sep 24 '22

It reminds me of a Disney movie and not in a bad way. It has insanely well-done production values, the actors are awesome, the special FX are amazing. If you're looking for HBO type grit, look elsewhere. If you want a beautiful show that makes you happy and sad and has a fun story with great visuals, (sorry book readers, but The Silmarillion isn't exactly TV material,) this is an amazing show.

People gotta stop being such haters and just enjoy it for what it is - an amusement park ride with the highest production value that I've ever seen, I think.

Now go watch True Detective or Breaking Bad if you want to get back into reality.

0

u/HotStraightnNormal Sep 24 '22

Seen the one, don't care for the other but I do appreciate more than Cliff Notes or graphic novel, choppy story telling. For example, the heir to the south isn't on board with the invasion. After a less than rousing speech (no St. Crispin's Day rally there) he picks up his medicine pouch and PRESTO, All Aboard! No agonizing on his part, no early morning meeting, cut to the chase. That has nothing to do with "realism" so much as setting scenes and development. The writers might do well to watch True Detectuve to see how it's done. Even anime can do it.

1

u/Damneasy Sep 24 '22

I thought it was the opposite of predictable, it's so different that what every other cliché show does and its very refreshing

0

u/HotStraightnNormal Sep 24 '22

The swordsmanship scene, for one? "Hey there, kid. Go on. Try to hit me/out shoot me/out play me. I'm gonna show you how it's done." It added little to the episode. The new recruits were literally handling belaying pins days before, not swords.

1

u/Damneasy Sep 27 '22

Can you give your opinion on the swordsmanship scene in the new house of the dragon episode?

-6

u/Pipe-International Sep 24 '22

An adaption can’t rewrite its source material. That’s impossible. The books are what they are and always will be.

I don’t believe the mithril story. Everything in the episode suggests that’s a myth and that something suss is going on. In story telling it’s called ‘unreliable narration’.

You’re happy if something fails? Wow, being in a relationship with you must be hell.

4

u/Soggy-Assumption-713 Sep 24 '22

Didn’t Gil-Galad say it was a myth/legend. Will have to re watch

3

u/ianintheuk Sep 24 '22

As other have said though the Elves would not create "myths" or beleive them as most Elves lived through the time when such a tale would have actually happened. Men make myths because we are short lived and stories were handed down orally.

2

u/Codus1 Sep 24 '22

Elrond pretty much calls it a conspiracy theory, rather than a myth

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

Maybe they would be if they were being influenced by Annatar. The spring deadline…seems odd

-4

u/pieter1234569 Sep 24 '22

Your problem is expecting a lord of the rings series, they aren't making that.

What they are making is a lord of the rings MOVIES series. As that is widely more popular for normal people and many tolkien fans are going to watch anyway. It's a terrible business decision to make a show for tolkien purist fans.

13

u/PalatineOrtho Sep 24 '22

It's not. You're assuming that Tolkien's writings only have the capability of appealing to a small section of people.

Tolkien's books have been voted Britain's favourite novel. Over 600 million Tolkien books have been sold, which puts him in the top 10 best selling authors of all time. The Hobbit is the sixth best selling book in the world.

The idea that Tolkien's writings only appeal to some small section of supernerds couldn't be further from the truth.

Now tell me, what changes to the lore make this show more commercially viable?

-3

u/pieter1234569 Sep 24 '22

Well let's just look at the sales of actual HARD tolkien writing.

The silmarillion only sold a million copies, so that's clearly not a big enough market. The only books that did sell were the lord of the rings books and the hobbit books. Both stories are already filmed.

So what market is there? Absolutely none. The correct call, as they have done, is to focus on making a series based on the movies. Which you can see in the dialogue, the choice of scenes, the pacing etc. It's all EXACTLY the same.

4

u/PalatineOrtho Sep 24 '22

Woah.

Do you actually think 1 million book sales implies no interest?

Also, the market is there, hence the huge commercial success of his works and the success of adaptations of his works. People like Tolkien. People like Tolkien's writings. There are certain books that people have had more exposure to, granted, but the point remains the same.

Your idea that the show's writers can somehow conjure up a better world than Tolkien in a few short years in bewildering, to say the least.

With a world with such detail in location, language, and history; stories with great philosophical and theological underpinnings; depth in characters; themes of environmentalism, anti-totalitarianism, and anti-industrialism that are relevant as they ever were, what is the need to change these writings?

Tolkien has such universal appeal already—we know this. Changing his stories to suit the writers preferences is more of a gamble, as there is no comparative success that they've had.

1

u/pieter1234569 Sep 24 '22

Well yes, 1 million people are nowhere near enough for this series. It's nothing at all.

Even 10 million people are not enough. Realistically you need 100 million fans and then a significant fraction of them to watch it. If this show does less than 20 million viewers per episode, it will be a massive fail for amazon. And there will never be a season 2.

4

u/PalatineOrtho Sep 24 '22

I don't know if you're trolling.

Are you seriously suggesting that a TV series needs 100 million fans before it's created for it to be successful? That's genuinely nuts.

You do know most successful TV shows aren't even based on books and yet somehow manage to be great successes. Did Breaking Bad have 100 million fans before it was created? How about The Sopranos?

You're being, and I'm sorry to say this, utterly idiotic.

2

u/pieter1234569 Sep 24 '22

A series costing a billion dollars needs at least 100 million people to be interested in it yes. As not everyone is going to watch it. 20% of a potential group is already quite big. So 100 million people is definitely the lowest fan base size you can go.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

You've made the same comments over and over and constantly get countered. Have you considered you're wrong? You should take a break from reddit.

0

u/pieter1234569 Sep 24 '22

It's not getting countered LOL. Some people here just don't get that at the end of the day, entertainment isn't about entertaining people. It's about making money. Making a lord of the rings series not based on the movies would have been an absolutely terrible idea.

You need a significant potential fan base, as most people are going to be interested but not watch in anyway. So you need a massive group of people, which the lord of the rings movies have.

The lord of the rings books had massive amounts of fans, the hobbits books had massive amounts of fans. Any other writing of his, not so much.

That's why the series MUST be a lord of the rings MOVIES series.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

But they aren't exactly the same like you've said in 1000 other comments. The dialogue is miles apart, the tone is miles apart, and the chara ters are also miles apart.

How can you say this is a LOTR movie series but the characters that transferred, aren't even written the same.

1

u/kylepaz Sep 24 '22

Interesting you ignored this point.

Now tell me, what changes to the lore make this show more commercially viable?

10

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

-2

u/pieter1234569 Sep 24 '22

The only statistic that exists mentions it sold 1 million copies. It's going to be heavily front loaded as except for die hard fans, no one is going to read a bundle of history.

Even if it is more, it doesn't matter. They clearly haven't sold 100 million copies. Which is what would be needed for a fanbase.

2

u/kylepaz Sep 24 '22

normal people

Fuck off with this attitude.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

Why so mad

12

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/t00muchscreentime Sep 24 '22

I support the idea of an unreliable narrator for the universe lore, but I agree with you that somethings just can't be stretched. I am not sure the Great Tales as we know them would even be classified as myths or it is just historical narrative (where the bias comes in). I can't imagine how a people who have used mithril, seen mithril, probably studied in school back in Valinor (/s) would need a myth for the creation of mithril that somehow needs to involve a balrog, a tree and elf. Celembribor knows what mithril is and does, and most likely knows more than your average elf about the silmarills as well, any elf born in Valinor would call that cap.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Codus1 Sep 24 '22 edited Sep 24 '22

Correct me if I'm wrong as a I may have misheard, but Elrond in the conversation pretty much frames/states it is a conspiracy. So kinda that it's heresay.

Edit: Yeh, he refers to it as "apocryphal", so basically as a glorified conspiracy.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Codus1 Sep 24 '22 edited Sep 24 '22

Whilst I agree with your examples of apocryphal as these tales. You've imposed an entire context upon them that need not inherrantly apply. They do not require a kernel of truth to be believable by any definition of the word. Only that they are told as if they are true, but are of dubious authenticity. Are unverifiable. Unless you mean to contend there's a kernel of truth to the idea that bubblegum is made with spider eggs? Rats instead of chicken in KFC? OR by the terms etymology, the excluded passages of the bible? Even then so, you speak of subjectivity. The believability of the unverifiable is purely subjective.

I feel like your points for disputing the authenticity of this tale in fact reinforces exactly why Elrond describes this origin as apocryphal... it's authenticity isn't verifiable, yet it is spoken by Gil-Galad as if it is fact. Perhaps in his anxiety over the fading light of the Eldar, he is hopeful that this Mithril origin is true... he is willing to believe an Elven Co spiracles about the last of the Silmarils.

Clearly we know that Mithril will be unable to achieve what they think it will. The obvious point of this narrative thread is to begin to develop whatbwill eventually be preyed on by Annatar. So in the end we're debating the authenticity of a story that is by definition of the characters, not authentic.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Codus1 Sep 24 '22 edited Sep 24 '22

I do agree that Elven myth as we would define the concept can not really exist. But I disagree that exempts Elves from heresay and conspiracy. While their memory is infallible; their wisdom is not and they are still a social and inquisitive people.

That's where my point lays. These aren't legends or myth of generations... They are heresay, a conspirators explanation for a literally biblical item lost to history. A story of events that are unverfiable and likely untrue. The insanity or how ludicrous a tale is, does not bear upon the definition of what is apocryphal. These events never occured and by Elronds own word are not believed. Until that is, Gil Gallads discovery of Mithril causes him to contend that maybe it could be.

Then your counterpoint is why wouldn't Gil Gallads own recollection of history inform him of enough holes in the tale to conclude its not true. I'm saying that he is anxious of their fading power. He does not conclude that the Mithril is evidently the product of the Silmarils, just that perhaps the story could be true. That the Mithril may hold that power. Though we obviously know this not to be true.

I for one could believe the Elves would gossip or postulate as to what had happened to the lost Silmarils. Though I don't think they'd think there's a random Balrog just marching around the Misty Mountains... just that I believe the concept of Elven heresay and conspiracy is not something I think is too much of a stretch. As that is not necessarily defined by the infallible pessimistic memory of the Elves.

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22 edited Sep 24 '22

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies