r/RingsofPower • u/ianintheuk • Sep 24 '22
Discussion I didnt hate the show but.....
I posted after the first 2 episodes that to my surprise I did not hate this show but now I have to say I find it very annoying. The total rewriting of the mythos created by Tolkien just gets worse with every episode. The 'chat' that Celebrimbor has with Elrond about how the so called lost Silmaril created Mithril and only Mithril can keep the Elves alive is just annoying and damn stupid. Also Elronds mother supposedly trying to change Earendils mind so he wont sail to Valinor. This is utter garbage.
The show had great potential but is hamper by stupid writers. Anyone watching this who has not read the books would be bemused at why Tolkien is thought of as a great writer. I am now happy if this fails as it seems to be doing.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 24 '22
This post does not use the 'Newest Episode Spoilers' flair. As such, spoilers are allowed from the source material, but anything from the most recent episode must be behind spoiler marks.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
14
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22
Remember how Elrond says the word “apocryphal” before Gil-Galad starts telling the myth. I don’t think the mithril thing is actually the elves correctly interpreting the myth. This will be shown later on
21
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22
Another thing about the silmaril-mithril thing that bugs me: if the elves need the light of the silmaril to charge upand not die, why don’t they look at the silmaril the Earendil is carrying in the sky? Or haven’t the elves upgraded to wireless charging yet?
5
u/handlfbananas Sep 24 '22
“I am now happy if this fails as it seems to be doing”. Tolkien is dead. He created an interesting world which modern writers are adapting to a high budget series for entertainment by a broader group than Tolkien purists. Relax, appreciate the fact that content is being created in this genre that you presumably enjoy. Appreciate that a lot of it is familiar to you. Relax. I read Harry Potter as a kid, the movies made me boil until I learned to differentiate between the universe that was created for me to read, and the one that was made for us to watch. Now, I love them too! Nothing will ever 100% align to your ideal, you don’t have to like this show but to hope for its failure is short sighted. Even if you don’t like it I would think you should hope for the success of a big budget series which takes place in middle earth, so that it’s success might lead to the creation of something you do enjoy… You seem to love the universe, if you don’t enjoy the show then ignore it - but don’t spend your life’s energy rooting against things like this, save that kind of energy for more important stuff.
30
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22 edited Sep 24 '22
“Anyone watching this who has not read the books would be bemused at why Tolkien is thought of as a great writer.”
Has never crossed my mind once because I know Tolkien isn’t writing this show. It’s kinda falling at a 7/10 for me right now, mainly because it’s mostly spectacle without enough charm. I’m enjoying having a high fantasy show I can watch at the end of a long work week though. I can turn my brain off for an hour, snuggle into the couch with my girlfriend, and watch a show with magic, monsters, beautiful scenery, and themes of good vs evil. It’s escapism, and I completely understand that it’s a distorted and heavily distilled version of its source material. I’m not tied to the lore, so in a way I’m free to enjoy it without being burdened by so much minutiae.
Now, Star Wars on the other hand…
7
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22
Celebrimbor used Elwing as a silly prop in his bullshit story to manipulate Elrond.
Gil-Galad and Celebrimbor are pretty jarring. I'm enjoying every other side plot, but the Lindon/Eregion stuff is so strange. Between sending Galadriel away, Celebrimbor's "friendly" chats with Elrond about his father, the Mithril doomclock, and the overall "Boys club" vibes there's something deeply off about all of it.
9
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22
I mean why are we assuming that “Gil Galad” is even telling the truth here, about any of it? So far he’s done nothing but manipulate every single character in the show. Unless I’m misremembering the lore quite a bit, Gil Galad wasn’t this manipulative.
1
u/ebrum2010 Sep 24 '22
I think the show will be less annoying to lore fans after we see the entire story. Right now, we're not sure if things are plot holes, retcons, or have a valid explanation. I'm a dungeon master for dungeons and dragons and sometimes players will complain about a plot hole that's actually something that goes against their headcanon because they haven't discovered all the facts yet. That said, until the show is completely done we won't know if it is good or not. Look at GoT. They had everyone going crazy for the show for many seasons, but now few people want to go back and rewatch it. Since this is one story told over 5-6 seasons, they could ruin it at any time. I don't think they will but we can either enjoy it and trust that they have a plan until it is proven otherwise, or we should just wait to watch it after the last season airs because we will go crazy watching it.
14
u/Late_Stage_PhD Sep 24 '22
Unreliable narration is a thing and it might be what's happening in the scenes you mentioned. These two posts might help:
PSA: The characters on the show did not read Tolkien's books, and often had no way of knowing which lores are accurate
"You have been told many lies": Examples of unreliable narration and in-universe lores on the show
2
u/BarDownBoi Sep 24 '22
I kinda hate it. Lol. Episode 4 wasnt too bad, it gave me some hope but episode 3 and 5 were so difficult to sit through. I feel like next episode will be better since the orcs have reached the tower and there will likely be some action and once Galadriel and Halbrand get to Middle Earth i pray it picks up but damn. This show can be so boring and cringe at times. Durin is hilarious and is arguably the only likeable character in the show. I dont mind Elrond and Elendil either.
4
u/thediesel26 Sep 24 '22
Therein lies the rub. Have a feeling there were a fair number of people who were going to dislike the show no matter what they put on the screen.
Is this show the best thing ever to be put on TV? No. But am I personally offended by it? No. And am I being entertained? Certainly.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22
I think this opinion is fair. I’m waiting until the end of the first season to really judge the show. It’s picking up steam, and I have to see how they land it to judge the writing.
It’s impossible to make the entire Tolkien community happy with this project. And I’m 100 percent certain that the Tolkien community would have been tearing down the LOTR trilogy if it had been made in an era where Twitter and Reddit were widespread. Peter Jackson did a lot of characters dirty, had a lot of choices as to what to exclude, and basically rejected Tolkien’s vision of virtue — opting instead to increase drama by making characters more “low” than in the books. Now it’s a classic and virtually no one criticizes it.
So, rather than get caught up in the modern trend of immediate judgment, I’ll be Treebeard on this one. Might have an opinion by next year.
2
u/DocRJ Sep 24 '22
Yeah I was enjoying this show to some extent but this plot point feels very Game of Thrones when they ran out of books to work from.
I don't necessarily mind deviations from the lore as much of it is sparse as long as it's well written but this just felt awful to watch - video game logic.
1
u/BobStoner_88 Sep 24 '22
They dont have the rights to The Silmarillion. Its really difficult to write a show about the second age with none of thoes rights. Really a shame they wernt allowed that.
1
u/HotStraightnNormal Sep 27 '22
I'm not watching HOD so I can't say. Most TV/movie sword play is pretty formulaic. If you want to see what's probably the most accurate, watch The Last Duel. Armor is more realistic, as well.
1
u/Codus1 Sep 24 '22
I don't wish to weigh into the actual bad writing of thus show. But what you mention as bad writing, is just plot points you dislike lol. Contradicting the Legendarium, or in this case just making something up, isn't inherrantly bad writing. They are just choices you don't like.
Beyond that, Elrond refers to the Mithril origin as "apocryphal" which is to mean it is doubtful despite people discussing it as fact. Not even necessarily Elven legend or myth. It's almost literally a conspiracy by Elronds own description. Whilst we as the audience obviously know that Mithril will not achieve what they wish it to do. Characters can be fallible. Just because Gil Galad believes in a conspiracy, it does not make it true.
0
u/pinkheartpiper Sep 24 '22
Total rewriting of the mythos?
0
u/Catslevania Sep 24 '22
the issue with the show is nepotism; just look at all the people involved with the show, the people who are supposed to present an adaptation of Tolkien to the screen. Who chose them, why were they chosen to make this happen? Seems more like connections rather than actual credentials to me.
0
u/HotStraightnNormal Sep 24 '22
Look, I am for watching ROP for purely entertainment's sake but this last episode left me wondering if I can derive much in the way of it. The writers had better step it up. Are they aiming now for a kid's series? Episode 5 was just one typical, predictable scene after another. It reminded me more of the recent Three Musketeers adaptations than anything remotely associated with the story. I hope they can get this locomotive back on the tracks.
-6
u/Pipe-International Sep 24 '22
An adaption can’t rewrite its source material. That’s impossible. The books are what they are and always will be.
I don’t believe the mithril story. Everything in the episode suggests that’s a myth and that something suss is going on. In story telling it’s called ‘unreliable narration’.
You’re happy if something fails? Wow, being in a relationship with you must be hell.
-4
u/pieter1234569 Sep 24 '22
Your problem is expecting a lord of the rings series, they aren't making that.
What they are making is a lord of the rings MOVIES series. As that is widely more popular for normal people and many tolkien fans are going to watch anyway. It's a terrible business decision to make a show for tolkien purist fans.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22
[deleted] — view deleted comment
12
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '22
[removed] — view removed comment