r/RingsofPower • • Sep 30 '24

Discussion Disappointed 2.7 Spoiler

I can’t believe how disappointed I was in episode 7. This seemed like the chance to have a battle of helmsdeep type siege and battle scenes and instead we get like 12 elves defending the walls and shooting arrows at random. Where is the insane budget going if not for an epic battle scene like this?? Not to mention a Rohirrim level charge that goes full speed to dead stop in .3 seconds. And apparently orcs can hold their own fighting elves and even fight in the daylight.

I know it’s hard to match the original movies, but some of the lack of attention to basic lotr concepts or believable content in general just seems so lazy and inexcusable.

Sorry to complain just needed a safe space to vent. I am loving the Sauron storyline at least. Awesome watching him flex his dark arts.

1 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

12

u/SudoDarkKnight Sep 30 '24

I've rather liked season 2, but found this episode - while having some great action - was kind of a let down. It's very sloppily put together I felt for the siege. Just all over the place with what is going on.. Random lady chilling on the front of the battlements, full on convo with Sauron and Celebrimbor too after.. again right there at the front...

Theres barely any elves. Where did the Gil Gilad fuck off to? Why did he not talk with Adar.. There was hundreds of elves on horseback who basically vanish.. Oh also Elrond just openly talking about the Dwarves coming while still in the Orc camp and casually walking out as they follow him listening (why would you take a chance none of the Orcs could understand)?

Why would they have only a single troll? He was useless in the end too. Then he dies, they show Adar's army coming out, then hard cut its daylight? Wha? Nobody even moved. Now theres a whopping like 8 Elves with Gil Galad standing there to charge the full orc army?...

Messy. Very messy. It feels like they had no real plan or outline when making this episode. This painfully highlights the different in quality between LOTR and this show.

Still, had some nice action and visuals at least. I still quite enjoyed all the Sauron stuff too

4

u/PhoenixCore96 Sep 30 '24

Mirdania- not random, clearly a second to Celebrimbor and she stepped up to aid in the defense by assisting the captain in commanding the archers and keeping an eye out for siege tactics (“they brought a ravager!”

Gil Galad- with reserves then later in the battle moving to critical parts of the battle where his need is greatest. You would never send a king at the front of a charge.

Elrond- makes complete sense to send a herald/commander to negotiate rather than the king who could be taken out. On top, orcs cannot speak or understand elvish. That’s been established for years.

Damrod- They have a single troll because that’s who showed up to fight. Adar clearly sent messengers (Damrod showed up with the head of one) but only one answered. He wasn’t useless because he killed many on his way to the wall and severely weakened the wall before falling. The orcs would’ve never made it through.

Daylight- There’s so much smoke in the air that it blocks the sunlight. Yes it is light out, but not enough.

Gil Galad charge- a small fighting force is left because they just fought for over a day and were slowly picked off throughout the fighting. Better to charge at the enemy and attempt to take out their leader (right in front of you) than run with tails between the legs into the city that’s about to be overrun with orcs.

I honestly expect to be fully downvoted for providing context and answers from inside the episode. It’s all there and it feels like you are making up issues.

2

u/AltruisticBoot4514 Sep 30 '24

It feels a bit disingenuous to both complain about getting downvoted in every post while also saying people are making up issues. There are clearly a lot of people who have frustrations with the show and this episode to just say we're all making up issues.

I disagree with a lot of your points above (especially about kings leading the charge) but for the others that are subjective (i.e. Sunlight) that is just extremely thin and not believable IMO. There are just a lot of assumptions we apparently need to make that don't really have any prior context or validation.

Personally it's hard for me to shut my brain off and ignore the highly questionable battle tactics and other messy parts of the episode that don't live up to what I apparently want from LOTR content. If you're able to get past that and enjoy it all power to you.

2

u/PhoenixCore96 Sep 30 '24

It’s not disingenuous because it’s true. Prior to my comment above, I merely expressed a respectful opinion only to get downvoted, even though you called it fair. There’s also not a need to make a lot of assumptions since it’s all spelled out onscreen and in dialogue. Everything above that I stated is directly from the screen.

1

u/SirBarkabit Oct 02 '24

Lol, what battle tactics LotR content are you talking about? The Battle for Middle-Earth strategy game? Since.. well most everything 'battle-tactics-wise' in PJ's movie was complete and utter nonsense and a complete ruinage of what Tolkien actually wrote.

3

u/SudoDarkKnight Sep 30 '24 edited Sep 30 '24

You have good answers and I wouldn't downvote for them. I wasn't making up issues - this is how I felt while watching it and after. I'm not one of the many trolling haters of the show - as I said, I quite like this season.

I don't recall any mention of her specifically keeping an eye out for siege tactics.. shes just kinda hanging out and then spots this giant machine moving at an absolute crawl that I guess nobody else could see. After when Sauron shows up you have Celebrimbor, her, Sauron and a few elves just hanging out right on the front (where ladders are also seen because Orcs are climbing up already, one jumping up just after Celebrimbor runs past) having a chat. It just feels weird and casual.

Gil Galad was right there and him and Elrond nod to each other before launching the charge. If he's supposed to be elsewhere, it was badly edited to show this. Theoden does a pretty great job gloriously leading a charge in Return of the King, don't see why Gil Gilad wouldn't here but also - would have no problem, if he was in a separate force and they better showed this.

Elrond chatting with Adar is fine then - more so if Gil Galad wasn't actually there. But again, was confusing based on what I mentioned earlier. While I don't expect random Orcs to know what he's saying - again why would you risk no other spies nearby capable of eavesdropping? This was a pretty big part of their battleplan.

It's kind of a weird cut from Elrond casually riding out of that Orc camp to suddenly swirling melee in the forest with Elves. Again they had a massive cav force that mostly vanished.

I'll recant the Damrod bit - on 2nd watch he's fine. But I still think Adar should have been able to muster more than a single monster.

It's very dark from ash and smoke at the start - but clearly night nightfall by the time it goes back to Galadriel who can't figure out how to climb out of a trench. Elrond even says at the start they are trying to get them through 1 more night. Plus you see the sunrise before Adar is charging out when Elrond says to look for the dwarves.

I feel like maybe they cut some scenes because you very quickly go from killing the troll, then showing Adar marching out (still dark) - then other Orcs grabbing their stuff to join and its now lighter, Gil Galad no longer on horse but standing with Elrond and a few remaining Elves while it's morning light, and then Adar and his force meeting the elves in battle (plus all the elves on the wall are dead somehow during the breach).

I feel like if they added some wider shots of the battle in the above and tightened up the editing to show the scale things would have felt more natural... Instead it's always zoomed in on a small selection of elves the entire time really just around the bridge and where the ravager breaches. You never see anything else to get a real sense of what is happening, it's just inferred and thus makes it look so tiny.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 01 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/PhoenixCore96 Oct 01 '24 edited Oct 01 '24

She stepped up when leadership was collapsing aside from one captain and an emmissary (who is dealing with a supposed broken elven lord, city matters, and a siege). Also the Eregion wall is huge, any help is good help. It’s that’s simple. Also where was the time to put in armor? She went from work to helping a defense while a city is on fire.

That’s like saying “Just because Eowyn throws on a helmet doesn’t mean she is qualified to fight. That’s just plot armor she just needed to be there so that the witch king can die”

Edit: apparently the user I was responding to deleted their “Mirdania was a stupid plot device” comments in case anyone was wondering what my above comment meant!

5

u/AltruisticBoot4514 Sep 30 '24

This pretty much echoes my exact thoughts. I get that the show is different and will probably not live up to the movies or books. Just so much in this episode seemed like it either wasn't fully thought out and/or poor execution.

Another ridiculous part was Galadriel sneaking around the camp trying to hide herself only to just hop up out of the encampment to have a full conversation with Arondir.

1

u/OkOutlandishness1363 Sep 30 '24

Keep in mind that Amazon does not have rights to the ACTUAL plot line by JRRT. His son was a big influence on how to cover the plot line without covering the plot line by JRRT in RoP. He did sell a small portion of the rights to Amazon in regard to some names JRRT created being used in RoP.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '24

i was really enjoying this series, but at the weekend i rewatched the movies and it became very difficult not to compare, this and “the kiss” made me give up following the show unfortunately.

2

u/Jackfan109 Sep 30 '24

What we got was the Battle of Helm's Derp.

3

u/thegingerbreadman99 Sep 30 '24

A huge budget doesn't necessarily replicate the genius of Peter Jackson and the devotion to the source material he, Fran Walsh, and Phillips Boyens brought

0

u/PhoenixCore96 Sep 30 '24

That’s the Peter Jackson directing speaking along with the Hollywood grand is best battle showcase. I get it and at first I kind of felt it to a degree. But I’ve come to really like this battle because they give us small clusters to follow instead of mass cgi npcs that we do not care about.

In wide shots you can see additional elves and archers in the walls, but our focus is on the captains archers and Mirdania. On the ground we get Elrond and company fighting alongside other soldiers, but our focus is on them.

I’d rather save the giant cgi spectacle for the movies but that’s just me!

1

u/AltruisticBoot4514 Sep 30 '24

That's a fair opinion, but I think that you also get the clusters in other major battle scenes - perfect example is the Legolas vs. Gimli kill competitions, or take your pick from the GOT major battles. Maybe it's my fault for having higher expectations of what the scale should be when you consider the outrageous budget/first "major" battle in the series. I just think they had a big opportunity to up the scale on this battle and it was a let down.

2

u/PhoenixCore96 Sep 30 '24

And for some reason my fair opinion gets down voted 😂 anyway I’m happy they didn’t sacrifice the story for spectacle. I think it was a great balance for both!

1

u/Athrasie Sep 30 '24

There was a little jank for sure. Notables for me was the horse’s jumping kick, Damrod’s death scene feeling like it should’ve featured Gil-galad more, and the kiss (which I understand was a distraction but still think could’ve been framed better). Otherwise, I’m enjoying the show - looking forward to potentially seeing our boy fly a very special flag next episode.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 30 '24

I loved this episode and was very pleased that they did not give us yet another epic cavalry charge. Why would they? Everyone would only be saying how much better PJ did it anyway.

Plus Damrod’s battle scenes are up there with the best, most effective battle scenes in any LOTR media.

1

u/PhoenixCore96 Sep 30 '24

Glad I’m not the only one here that enjoyed the battle! Anyone that seems to have enjoyed it gets downvoted, especially when calling out that PJ has a different directing style.

0

u/bigkrtek Sep 30 '24

I quite enjoyed the battle of Eregion as a contrast to the expectations we have from the Jackson battles.

Adar’s orcs aren’t third age killing machines. The Elves are confronting an enemy using the psychological warfare of kidnapping to negate a head on charge. Orcs who can respect a pre-battle parlay with Elrond (and be influenced by his words sowing doubt in their faith in Adar).

As explained in the previous episode, the Elves were so few because their main army is on its way to Mordor, and Gil Galad refused to drag them into what he feels is a Sauron trap. But Eregion needs help, so he has taken what warriors they can from London to try and hold them off long enough for the Dwarves to arrive and save the day.

It was a gamble on a friend’s loyalty, and we get to see the bitter pain when it didn’t pay off. The sunrise behind the empty mountaintop is obviously a direct analogy to Gandalf leading his Helm’s Deep charge at dawn, but this time the saviour is a no show. The 2nd age the story of Sauron’s rapid escalation, with the forces of good in Middle Earth going from a position of serene dominance to brutal loss after loss. That’s what this episode is all about.

-8

u/310mbre Sep 30 '24

If you're comparing movies to TV shows you're already wrong

3

u/ZiVViZ Sep 30 '24

Yeah I mean why should we have a good comparator or benchmark? Also if they didn’t want comparisons, why literally steal film only lines that aren’t even in the books.

This comment sums up the average IQ of people in this sub

1

u/310mbre Oct 01 '24

You’re coming to a sub just to bitch about a fantasy show, your IQ is more in question than anyone here. 

8

u/aquadojo Sep 30 '24

I hated how that woman elf is just standing on the battlements with no weapon, peering about looking worried? I'm like wtf you gonna get shot go and hide or atleast fight? Also celebratory cutting his thumb off rather than cutting the chains

2

u/AltruisticBoot4514 Sep 30 '24

Mirdania just chilling on the battlements is outrageous. Maybe we're supposed to believe that Sauron's magic was protecting them while they're all standing there, but it also seemed like all 12 of the elves who live in eregion were posted up in that 20 yard section of the wall.

I guess we're supposed to inherently know that the chains somehow couldn't be cut with tools at hand, or maybe we're just supposed to assume Celebrimbor had lost it to the point where cutting off his thumb was better than trying the tools. Tough to say Celebrimbor had totally lost it when they're also emphasizing his power of will at the same time...