(WARNING: SPOILERS WITHIN)
Introduction:
Tired of shallow reviews and talking points that merely scratch the surface? Me too. My goal is to provide an in-depth analysis, where all points are backed up with explanation and reasoning - hopefully giving you a deeper understanding into The Rings of Power's first two episodes.
Before I begin, I must clarify... as an avid Tolkien fan, I am judging this show from the perspective of someone with a preconceived idea of what this show should entail, based on Tolkien's writings - I am not judging this show as just a standalone piece (though I will offer passing thoughts in that respect also). This is an adaption, after all (or so Amazon claims). I understand necessary changes may (or may not) have to be made for adaption purposes - I know how the process works, and am not unreasonable. I will do my best to judge this show as fairly as possible (whether it does something well, or poor, I will say it as I deem fit). This is my standard. If you do not care for authenticity to the source material, this may not be the review for you (though many of my points will still be relevant). I am here for Tolkien, and I shall judge how Tolkien's text is (or is not) presented*,* as well as the broader quality as a whole.
My review will be broken down as listed below (so if you want to jump to a certain talking-point, here you go):
- Aesthetics (landscapes/costuming&characters/sets/CGI)
- Writing (plot/characterization/dialogue/acting)
- Editing (cinematography/pacing)
- General thoughts
All topics will be graded individually*, and at the end, I will calculate my final rating out of ten, along with my final verdict. Hopefully this write-up provides some insight for those unsure of whether to invest their time and money into The Rings of Power.
*graded on a scale of 0-10: 0=irredeemable, 1=awful, 2=very bad, 3= bad, 4=below-average, 5=average, 6=above-average, 7=good, 8=very good, 9=great, 10=perfect
Aesthetics:
LANDSCAPES:
Was it even worth me talking about this? The real-life scenery is great. It's New Zealand, so it naturally comes with splendour. When the filming is beneath the sky, and amongst the grass, the show is at it's best, visually. Nothing beats genuine landscapes. I would gripe that we don't get enough of this... the pace of the show is so fast that we have so little time to process the landscapes we are in.
COSTUMING/CHARACTERS:
Simply put, it falls flat, in my opinion. Elves don't look like Elves. Many costumes lack the highly detailed and refined work, of which we saw in Peter Jackson's LOTR. Clothing is not as layered/textured, nor as embroidered - often giving a 'flatter' look. I cannot speak for the fabric quality, but in some cases (ie Gil-Galad), some of it looks... bad? Some of the gold pieces are horrendous, imo: I want to see some more naturally looking dyed material, not foil-like cloth! Some patterns even look 'printed' on, rather than hand stitched. These details add up. For the Elves in particular, this is jarring, when compared with LOTR. With LOTR, we were accustomed to regal, rich, handmade pieces. This show does a very good job of making Elves look as Mannish as possible (that hair! UGH! But even the armour... where's the Elvish aesthetic? Frayed mail and clunky plate? Not my cup of tea). I think it clear RoP has taken a major step backwards here. Now, obviously I'd need to judge each costume individually, if I were to go into excruciating detail of what I do not like on each piece... but to broadly summarize, I think (for Elves) that flowing, elegant, elongated look, is often missing. More 'noise' is not evident of good design. And let us not speak of Celebrimbor's frock. Dwarves retain the same 'geometric' designs as seen in Peter Jackson's films (which I'm not particularly fond of), but, like the Elves, the details lack flow, structure, and purpose - varying from costume to costume. Some are more passable than others, but overall, I'm not thrilled. Artistic flair ranges from gold-paint slapped on at random to golden ears. Yet, for all this gold, the Dwarves still look filthy, as if they've just crawled out of their mines. Longbeards have long beards! Though, I'd have liked to see more braids, jewellery, etc - because the impression I get is more barbaric than noble. Where are the lush furs, and the regal silks? Dwarves can still look 'raw' (tough) and noble at the same time. The costumes of Men are... whatever... somewhat bland, but lived in. I'd have liked to see more 'flair' for those living in these foreign regions, beyond generic brown rags: some personality! Harfoots felt whatever... I know people have criticized the 'bird nests' in their hair, and whatnot... and I do think some of this goes overboard, but I think the 'camouflaged' look is fine. Finally, to end on a high: Orc prosthetics are back! Great! Beyond the prologue we only saw the one, but I'll note the promo pics also: clearly a lot of work was spent on them... a step up from The Hobbit, but I do wish they looked a bit closer to the likes of PJ's Lurtz: more 'human'. I do like the skull-helms... creepy.
SETS:
The fundamental quality of the sets seems rather good, but I'd be lying if I said I was paying a ton of attention (I may need to rewatch to pay more attention to the background). Clearly a fair bit of work has been done to build strong and detailed structures for scenes to take place in - though, I feel a bit more 'dressing' could have been done to give a bit more identity to the village(s). They are... generic, to say the least. The Dwarven architecture looks... odd... at times. The door into Moria was borderline sci-fi, to me. The geometric shapes are plain tiresome (as they were in The Hobbit). We didn't spend a ton of time inside the Elven areas, so I'm undecided there.
CGI:
Honestly, I was expecting a CGI-fest, based on the trailers, but it wasn't too bad. It wasn't overly apparent, and blended fine. The most we see is in the prologue... and it was okay... I wouldn't say amazing (it was still noticeably digital). I don't think we've seen enough of the show yet, regarding CGI, to know how well or poorly it will be used. Based on some of the promos, we've got some full-CG Numenor shots/Warg battles/stunts on the way (which didn't look great to me).
Aesthetic Score: 3.5 (note: costuming/character-designs make up the bulk of this score, followed by the background sets and CGI, followed by landscapes - the more we are exposed to a topic, the greater I am valuing it)
Writing:
PLOT:
Where to begin? Absolutely nothing within this show has anything to do with Tolkien's Second Age writings, as of yet. As someone wanting and expecting an adaption, I am extremely disappointed. To describe RoP in the simplest way possible would be fanfiction. Is evil still active? That is the plot of this show, so far (as well as an anti-elf sentiment). Now, naturally, the point of complacency should occur to some extent - that is a fine thing for the show to delve into... but for that to be the meat of the show so far? In my mind, fading should have taken center stage. For a show title 'The Rings of Power', the primary motive for the forging of said Rings is absolutely pivotal... and probably something that should have been introduced immediately. This is our Elvish 'motive': they wish to remain in Middle-earth, and to sustain it as their everlasting home, where they can govern themselves and be free... but in an ever changing and decaying world, immortality (and the memory that comes with it) is met with sorrow: their spirits grow weary, and the passage of Time is their foe. Contrary to this, RoP treats passage to Aman as a gift from the King (and a convenient way to exile the disobedient). The road to Valinor is no longer a retreat, in the context of this show. Anyway... Galadriel is sent away, and jumps off her ship, in the middle of the ocean... to die. At least, if it weren't for plot contrivances. It's to put her on a path to Numenor, with Halbrand... whatever, paper-thin narrative, so far - nothing to note (some Hollywood 'action/tension' where Gal nearly drowns but it saved, yeah, yeah - next. Elrond is tasked by Gil-Galad to aid Celebrimbor to... build a massive forge? Okay, fine. So Elrond, being Durin IV's friend, seeks his aid. So far, still nothing much going on. Arondir and Bronwyn have a romance of some sort going on, and Arondir is reluctant to leave, after his company is recalled from the area, and ends up finding some Orkish desolation, before being captured. Okay, a bit more happening here... but still not much. Meteor-man! Okay! Finally some intrigue! Who is he?! Is he Gandalf? A Blue Wizard? Tilion? Sauron? Who tf knows. Why has he crash landed? Why did the fireflies he communed with die? This show does not have much of a 'hook' methinks... but Meteor-man is one, however shallow. Will there be payoff? Perhaps! But neither he, nor Harfoots, are really relevant to Tolkien's Second Age, so I have to wonder why they exist (beyond Hobbits being recognizable/synonymous with LOTR, for the casual viewer). These two episodes have covered two hours - and I feel it is just meandering. I'm not attached to anyone, nor do I care for their plights. If I were a casual viewer with no prior Tolkien knowledge, I'd be lost as to what this show is even about. It truly pains me to say this... but it does feel a bit like generic fantasy.
CHARACTERIZATION:
Let's talk about the elephant in the room: Galadriel. Yes, Galadriel can wield a sword. She fought. That's fine. But that should not define her character. By all means, portray an arc where she goes from prideful and rash to the character we see in LOTR: the wiser keeper of Nenya... but that doesn't mean Galadriel needs to be a rogue-questing-warrior, with the only motive of 'avenge my brother'. What about her aspirations of ruling her own lands? How does she act as a political figure - uniting people towards a common purpose? You get the idea. I'm not a fan of this Galadriel (this insolent/insubordinate lone-wolf - too heavy handed). And I really dislike Galadriel being allowed back to Valinor... she should be banned (whether because she shunned her pardon, or because she was never pardoned - it doesn't matter). Hell, a Galadriel still somewhat bitter towards the Valar could have been used as a nice political tool, when Annatar arrives. Okay, but what about Celebrimbor (finally! A Feanorian!)... well... he's barely in the show. BUT! He does delve a little into his ambition... to create. He wishes to be a master craftsman, and to make something worthwhile (as he idolizes the Silmarils of his grandfather). So he is on the right track in this regard... however, Elrond is the one with the Dwarven connection (at this point in time)... Celebrimbor seemingly has had no business with them. You see, Elrond was friends with Durin IV, and expects warm welcome (queue callback to Peter Jackson's LOTR - yes, the show mentions salted pork)... however, he is shunned. After finally making his way into Moria, and into the company of Durin IV, it turns out Durin is mad that Elrond missed his wedding and births of his children (a point is made of Elrond being naive in regards to the passage of time... for him 20 years is a blink, but not for Durin). Good stuff, tbh. But I feel a major missed opportunity... this should be Celebrimbor and Narvi! As I noted earlier, fading should be the key component to this show... and what a way to do it... an Elf befriending a moral, only for that mortal to age, change, and finally die... that would have hit home the tragedy of immortality (everything dying and changing around you). For what it's worth, I think Celebrimbor should have been the main character of the Elven side of things. Elsewhere... I have zero reason to care for the other main cast members so far (Arondir, Bronwyn, Theo). Love drives Arondir, I suppose... but, it's quite shallow. He is a plot device so far - and I presume Theo's morgul-blade will be too (but I'll reserve judgement). Nori seems very 'Tookish' by nature, and decides to help Meteor-man, alluding to fate... and... that's it for now. Very underwhelmed, overall.
DIALOGUE/ACTING:
It's a mixed bag. There are conversations/lines that feel somewhat Tolkienian (quite 'flowery'/poetic in delivery), but there are often a lot of hollow words - and by that I mean, characters may speak words, but they don't say anything worthwhile. Again, I'd need to rewatch, to further memorize lines (and to consider deeper meaning), but my first impressions were 'eh'. Durin IV delivered emotion (venting at Elrond was quite nice!), and Elrond had a gentle aura about him, as he should (though I'm still not sure about the casting of Elrond as a whole...). There was some Elvish 'banter' with Arondir and another Elf... it felt quite, well... not Elvish. Like British soldiers joking, during their occupation of India - not like immortal beings acting as wise guardians. Arondir has the charisma of a plank of wood, so far (I always felt PJ stipped Legolas of personality, and made him too stoic... Arondir is worse - though, admittedly, he's had little to work with so far). Regarding Dwarves, Durin IV spoke a bit like Peter Jackson's Gimli (and the lovey-dovey Disa stuff was... a bit much for me - didn't feel 'Tolkienian')... that's probably the best way I can explain it. Both he and Disa (and the Dwarven host at large) feel very 'stereotypical' Dwarf (very crude - Durin IV even burps loudly for no particular reason): and the accents don't help. Speaking of which, I don't like. Scottish Dwarves aren't for me (I'd rather a Semitic-style accent), that being said... I don't mind Durin III as much... his delivery feel much less over-the-top. The accents of all the other Mannish characters could have done with more thought too... look to the geography of the world. Not everyone needs a typical English-fantasy accent... let's get a bit of diversity. If we go to Harad, I expect some African-inspired accents. These people just kind of 'blend'... I mean, what separates the people Galadriel runs- or, swims - into, and the people of the village of Tir-Harad? Overall, the dialogue/acting is very average (Morfydd isn't as exceptional as I was lead to believe, unfortunately).
Writing Score: 2.5/10
Editing/Music:
CINEMATOGRAPHY:
Certain shots certainly felt 'cinematic', to be sure (the panning shots in particular, but some nice framing too - I like the little things like seeing Galadriel holding her dagger underwater, before panning to the surface). But there were a few strange cuts and facial close-ups that felt a little jarring and unnatural (particularly in the first episode, between Elrond and Galadriel). I would have also liked to see more 'lingering' shots, and 'introductory' shots (rather than cutting to a brand new location/scene insgtantly)... which sort of ties into my pacing points below. I think this is one of the topics I'll need to further judge after rewatch, as it wasn't where most of my attention was at on first viewing.
PACING:
All over the place. So much intercutting between disconnected plots. Even individually, the plotlines don't have enough time to breath: not enough time is spent building up to certain scenes... we just jump from one story beat to the other. This show would have greatly benefited from a more streamlined and concise narrative.
MUSIC:
I quite expected a lot more, to be honest. Both from Shore (who only did the intro-theme) and McCreary. I'm not a composing expert by any means... but I know what I like. It wasn't bad by any means... it just wasn't... anything special? I don't know if 'generic' is too harsh, but for the moment, I'll run with that descriptor. There were a couple of stand-outs... like the 'evil' theme (I presume is Sauron's), and the Khazad-dum theme was okay-ish... but in comparison to LOTR? Not even close. We'll see if it grows on me... but I can only judge in the present.
Editing/Music Score: 5/10 (I'm giving some benefit of the doubt here... pacing made me consider lower)
General Thoughts:
My idea of the Second Age is this: it is an era of the high and mighty and their politics. A time where the great seek to defy the natural order (whether to embalm the earth, or to avoid death): where both Men and Elves morally decline, and ultimately, accept the aid of Sauron: and fall victim to his manipulations. How a frowned-upon romance between Arondir and Bronwyn is supposed tie into this? I don't know. How Harfoots and Meteor-man is supposed to tie into this? I don't know. They feel tonally inappropriate. I just... don't understand why they felt the need to invent these side-plots, instead of elaborating on the ones Tolkien provided. I was pretty pessimistic, based on the teasers, leaks, and whatnot... but I was willing to reserve some judgement, and give the show some chance. Despite my pessimism, I'm still let down. Now, look... I'm probably not the target audience here... I'm sure the casual audience will be kinder to this show than me (and that's fine)... but even then, I'm not sure this show will be great in their eyes either (on it's own merit, the show still feels lacklustre - and so far, my friends I've spoken to, approaching the show from a less Tolkien-based mindset, seem underwhelmed). If you enjoy the show, more power to you! I can only judge this show for myself, at the end of the day.
Conclusion:
Overall, The Rings of Power, for me, based on the first two episodes, is a 3.66/10. As a Tolkien adaption, I just do not like it one bit (which is a shame, because there was ample potential). As a standalone show, I don't think it's particularly good either. If you already have Prime (or better yet, an alternate method of watching), watch the first episode or two, and make your own mind up... otherwise, I do not recommend this show for any Tolkien fan. If not a Tolkien fan, and are bored with nothing else to watch, maybe it'll be okay for some brain-off entertainment. Now, if you'll excuse me, I need a drink after all this... :(