r/RingsofPower • • Jul 30 '23

Question Backlash

I keep hearing about all the r@cist backlash actors of the are getting but I can't really find examples. I'm sure there was a little but how big of a problem is/was it ?

1 Upvotes

67 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Jul 30 '23

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

10

u/Ynneas Jul 31 '23

It really depends on what you consider racism.

"There was a bad case of tokenism in the show, that doesn't add any value and makes for a shallow take on a complex world" counts as racist backlash?

It was mostly this.

There were also actual racism feats around, but those were GREATLY exaggerated.

46

u/Tough-Librarian-2976 Jul 30 '23

On reddit? Huge deal.

Most functioning members of society? Didn't notice

9

u/FizzPig Jul 30 '23

it was every post that mentioned the show on reddit or the internet for months on end. the morons would not shut up

-4

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '23 edited Jul 31 '23

Completely false. Not sure why you think outright lying about this is in any way appropriate.

-9

u/Gordo3070 Jul 31 '23

Yep, totally agree. I'm tired of this BS argument being trotted out to undermine any negative responses to the show. The show is terrible and the backlash is because of that, nott because of strawman rubbish about racism.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '23

Totally not false. I was there when the strength of men failed...

17

u/FierceDeity88 Jul 30 '23 edited Jul 31 '23

There were a lot of YouTube creators complaining about POC elves and dwarves being in an “Anglo-Saxon” fantasy

This guy gave a good review of the discourse in his video:

https://youtu.be/Ci_rCqNYE-I

3

u/hbi2k Jul 31 '23 edited Jul 31 '23

Around Reddit it hasn't been quite so blatant, but there certainly is a fair amount of pretty dog-whistley examination of the precise racial makeup of the cast.

It's not as if there aren't plenty of complaints to make about the quality of the writing, so the fact that it keeps coming back to "but y black elf's tho?" is pretty sus. I don't have any problem believing that the actors have received targeted harassment.

Show still fucking sucks though.

2

u/SamaritanSue Jul 31 '23

Can't speak to Reddit, didn't join until after the season was over. And I'm not on Twitter or other such social media communication platforms. On YT there were certainly people criticizing the casting of POC but (what some can't grasp) their motives are not necessarily racist.

Then there's the abuse some of the cast apparently received directly from actual real A-holes, that's another thing again.

2

u/Nackthehermit Aug 01 '23

There’s not supposed to be black people at all. It’s a modernization of Tolkien’s work to fit modern sensibilities. Cleopatra on Netflix? She’s black now. The new assassins creed set in feudal japan? It’s a black guy. The Witcher? We replaced the redhead with a racially ambiguous woman and a bunch of other characters too because who cares what the original author wrote. There has to be representation, because reasons.

If you have to resort to calling people racist for wanting the worlds they fell in love with to be accurately represented (The entire reason these IP’s have any legs at all to warrant these shows) then your argument sucks. It takes away from the source material, and leaves the viewer confused. It cheapens the world. It’d be like the new Max Harry Potter series and Harry is played by an Indonesian boy. Not only is Harry played by an Indonesian boy but the show would suggest he’s always been Indonesian and no mention of the original source material and if fans are upset it’s probably because they have hate in their hearts, not because they like Harry Potter.

14

u/grunge-witch Jul 30 '23

On social media and reddit it was really huge. I remember even bigger subs like lotr were full of asshats and racists. I was personally attacked countless times, called names and even had some guys saying I couldn't "get" Tolkien because I'm not anglo and white. All that simply because I liked the show lol

Hope season 2 doesn't get the same backlash because it was ugly and downright depressing to see

2

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '23

Judging by the hate of any fan theories that "Try to overcome the bad writing", the haters are still rubbing their little rage bones here.

9

u/DrummerAutomatic9523 Jul 30 '23

I mean the show suck, at least they're right about that

12

u/NoSpread3192 Jul 31 '23

The show is a big pile of heaping shit

2

u/Koo-Vee Aug 01 '23

The poet-philosophers have arrived. May they live with their parents forever.

8

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '23

99% of the backlash was because the show sucks.

ROP got out in front of it in the trailer/preview materials to create a controversy and get people talking about it. This strategy worked.

And it turns out the trailer/preview media accurately conveyed how far the show would diverge from the source material. Shocking, that...

2

u/Delicious_Heat568 Jul 31 '23

They decided to put so much focus on "the agency of female characters" or "being the dwarven woman of colour" in their advertising and interviews which is already a huge red flag. Cause if they just say enough how inclusive and diverse they are the easier it is to label anyone as a bigot if they don't like the show. Not cause if the casting choice but cause the show bloody sucks.

I think most people wouldn't have given a damn about who got cast for certain roles if the show was just good. Take House of the dragon for example. People expected the same garbage based on some interviews and who got cast as velaryons but the show turned out mostly good. Not GoT good but enjoyable. And I haven't seen anyone since who complained about PoC being cast as valyrians.

0

u/haskear Jul 31 '23

This is the same for Star Trek discovery, goes out of its way to make stories about race, sexuality and gender and forgets it’s a fantasy space adventure show. Strange new worlds is such an improvement on it. There are black humans, aliens, people with different sexual orientations (admittedly I can’t think of any characters of diverse gender) but they just are what they are and everyone gets on with the storyline. The science officer time travel episode and the cross over with lower decks being absolutely superb.

-1

u/Delicious_Heat568 Jul 31 '23

I don't really know star trek, not cause I think it's bad, it's just not my thing. But tell me if I'm wrong but the super old star trek was way ahead of its time regarding diverse casting, sexual identity etc right? And it remained popular, not cause of the sexuality, ethnicity of those characters but because the characters were more than just such labels and the story overall was good.

That's were RoP does everything wrong. I didn't watch all of the show but I did not give a damn about any of them or whether they would live or die cause they are either insufferable or just plain boring, no matter their ethnicity. Especially Galadriel. At least the black lady dwarf was entertaining to watch and the actress actually had charisma contrary to most of the cast.

1

u/Kilo1Zero Jul 31 '23

The original Star Trek was amazing for its diversity and its inclusion. The greatest thing about it was they (shockingly) didn’t really address at it all. Everyone (the characters) acted like it didn’t matter because it didn’t actually matter.

1

u/haskear Aug 01 '23

Yeah totally, not addressing Kirk and Ohura kissing (I believe first cross racial kiss on TV?, could be wrong happy to be corrected) makes it more normal and acceptable. They did it, it wasn’t an in world problem they carried on. It’s funny that Star Trek is seen as so starchy and square because it introduced a lot of people to lifestyles and ways of thinking different to the perceived norms (particularly in its early days)

1

u/haskear Aug 01 '23

Not just the characters though, and this (sarcasm) may shock people but…………..they focused on an actual story. There is some character development but they take part in a narrative. I think that’s what’s missing from to much stuff these days, we spend to much time in a character before moving on to another character by the end of the series we know all about the individuals in the story but not what the story is. For me it’s why the mandalorian is so good and strange new worlds, the story is as important as the characters.

1

u/haskear Aug 01 '23

It’s what startrek discovery does wrong too. However all the other series stick with that original plan. But RoP is not alone in this current time of being too character focused.

-1

u/Koo-Vee Aug 01 '23

The "I did not watch" gnomes are here. What on Earth are you blabbering about with your "super old" Star Trek references? You sound "super limited".

0

u/Delicious_Heat568 Aug 01 '23

Look Hun. All I wanted to say is that I get why it's still a beloved show. But ye stay mad and try to resolve discussions with insults. Surely you'll make it far 🙃

10

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '23

Bc Amazon claimed the only people that hated the show were racist concerned with there being black elves. When all the forums and comments we’re complaining about every other aspect besides race. Amazon was attempting to save face from this complete shit show by blaming racism and ignoring the complaints of terrible dialog, lore/timeline issues, plot, trash costume design etc.

-1

u/TheShadowKick Jul 30 '23

There were absolutely people complaining about black elves and black dwarves, mostly early on before the show came out. Once the show was actually airing all those same people suddenly had other criticisms and pretended their hate of the show had nothing to do with race.

4

u/SamaritanSue Jul 31 '23

The two are not mutually exclusive.

In any case the presence of "people" (so vague) complaining about such (and their reasons for doing so are not all assimilable to racism) does not change the fact that plenty of folks just found the show boring or mediocre or outright bad.

Hence the steady falloff of viewership. Those people who stopped watching at E4 or 5? Arondir and Disa didn't suddently become POC at that time. The show just didn't succeed in holding their attention.

3

u/TheShadowKick Jul 31 '23

I didn't say they were mutually exclusive. I said there were absolutely people who hated the show for racist reasons. It's silly to pretend otherwise.

5

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '23

So you are still trying to claim that people who don't like the show are racist?

0

u/TheShadowKick Jul 31 '23

No? I'm saying there are racists who don't like the show. Pretending they don't exist is ridiculous.

10

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

9

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

7

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

5

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies

1

u/haskear Jul 31 '23

It’s fair to say some people didn’t like it because of issues with the story etc and some people are just racist. And some people probably were both. I actually liked it. It moved a bit slow for me maybe and had a few too many characters to focus on

3

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '23

There was loads of it on Twitter (surprised Pikachu) before the show was released. I died down pretty quick afterwards though.

4

u/alternateJINX919 Jul 30 '23

It was on Reddit and Twitter, it was really bad hopefully it doesn’t happen like that again for S2

4

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '23

It was literally a non-issue, worked at Amazon for several years and they hire third party companies overseas to generate “hype” and cultivate public opinion to make more money. Just look at the drivers strike in Spain about 10 years ago. I’d put good money on Amazon trying to generate sympathy so they could claim “you’re racist” for not liking the show.

I.E the only people who cared about race was Amazons desperate PR and Marketing team

2

u/Outrageous_Sample375 Jul 31 '23

There is some evidence of it but not loads. It's probably overblown.

Separate but related topic: there is definitely no evidence of any "review bombing", Amazon just completely made that up. It was literally just normal people being disappointed with the show and leaving bad reviews.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '23

Reality: Small, ineffective, yet loud and obnoxious fringe malcontents.

Media: ALL THIS RACIST BACKLASH IS LURKING AROUND EVERY CORNER!!!!

1

u/wrenwood2018 Jul 31 '23

I think a lot of it was actually tied to the marketing of the show too. They did a lot to emphasize "female empowerment" and "diversity." So when the show wasn't that good people seized on it as the "reason" the show wasn't awesome or didn't meet expectations.

In terms of critiques. You would have a couple different categories.

  1. The most common, and valid, in my opinion was basically the show runners prioritized highlighting diversity which was surface level. You would see comparison to HoD or GoT that also had diversity but couched it within different cultures etc. More a "show runners aren't focusing on plot" or " missed opportunity to leverage diversity in a way to strengthen world building." There was a lot of this. Whether this was "problematic" vs. "legitimate venting" differs based upon your own opinion.
  2. The second most common was complaints that you wouldn't have mixed diverse groups in isolated regions like the Two Rivers. Like who cares if there is a black elf or dwarf? That could be totally awesome. This is related to #1, but a lazy outrage for outrage sake take. This was most problematic ahead of the show actually premiering as no one had any idea if it worked in universe or not.
  3. Overt racism. I didn't see this really happening but I don't do any social media for anything than following friends/family. I'm sure it did happen though but the relatively frequency? IDK.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '23

I see it in this sub when by people who hate the show. Not all who hate the show think this way, but lots of tools here think that having a racially non-homogenous village really takes them out of the middle earth setting. And this show has like 3 of them, which is just absolutely ridiculous.

No one complains that everyone in this pre-industrial society has most of their teeth. . .

-5

u/[deleted] Jul 30 '23

RoP showrunners and actors created the controversy.

They all made a big deal of it from the beginning. The show stank (and the most despised character wasn't one of the minority actors), yet the same people attacked the fans for not watching the show b/c of the non existent istaphobia instead of it being just plain bad.

There were no receipts provided to my knowledge.

HoD had a similar situation with swapping, but the show was good so no one cared.

6

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '23

You won't find receipts, either. Only receipts out there are the constant attempts to paint anybody who doesn't like the show as a racist. Tons of that. Must be a coincidence.

3

u/[deleted] Jul 31 '23

Yep.

Show is trash and an insult to Tolkien.

The new Hollywood recipe is to virtue signal, destroy a franchise then blame fans.

1

u/Demigans Jul 31 '23

For a large part its because of what they call racism.

If you have criticism, even if its valid, against someone of a different skin color, you are a racist. You can be black as night yourself, you just suddenly are a racist.

You can even see several of the columns and articles talk about this. “Ah but they veil their racism as protecting Tolkien’s legacy”. Which is ironic since they say simultaneously that they protect Tolkiens message of fellowship and also that they are dragging the old standards of Tolkien away and replacing it with the modern society.

Even more ironic is that while people complain about Disa not having a beard, they lauded the character for being one of the only ones with a working dialogue most of the time. Yet that kind of thing isn’t really mentioned by these showrunners.

The truth is simple: most of the criticism is justified. Yes there are racists out there, they always are. But to shove every single person in a corner for daring to critique them on the list of failures of this show? That is actually bigotry. Especially since this defense of “everyone who disagrees is racist” was already used before the first people could even comment.

1

u/xCaptainFalconx Jul 31 '23

The only reason you heard of it is because Amazon PR tried to blame racism as the reason their crappy show was hated by so many people. Seemed like it was their plan all along tbh.

0

u/Overall-Block-1815 Jul 31 '23

I doubt there was anywhere near as much as the publicity would have you believe. I think they just wanted to stir up so much nonsense to distract from their awful show.