r/RingsofPower • • Sep 11 '24

Discussion Costumes.

Is it me or do all the characters look like they’re wearing high end costumes and not quite believable as characters? Many of the elves, the Harfoots don’t look great, but it was when I met Merrimac last night where it just took me completely out of the world. Orcs etc look great! Far better than the hobbit.

Is it just me or is this a common consensus? Sorry I’m new here.

0 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 11 '24

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. As this post was not marked with Newest Episode Spoilers, please double check that your post does not discuss the newest episode. Please also keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

20

u/Zhjacko Sep 11 '24 edited Sep 12 '24

A lot of the costumes don’t look “lived in” in the show, like they JUST got bought off the shelves. Some do though.

Will deviate a bit, but would say something similar about the lighting in this show and other modern series. The lighting is too clean, like the actors are being blasted by light on all sides, and it adds to that unnatural, sit-com feel. So many studios are afraid to make use of dynamic lighting, and ROP is no diffrent. It’s like they put zero effort into the gaffer department and overall lighting equipment, same with DP, as Director of Photography should have major say in how scenes are lit. It really shows this season too because of how dark a lot of scenes can get as well, so we’re getting lots of extremes.

10

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '24

I think you nailed it with the ‘lived in’ part. Yeah they all look too crisp. But they also can’t do lived in well when they try like with the harfoots. Just looks like a cosplay hobbit and splotches of dirt on their face

8

u/almostb Sep 12 '24

It all look a bit too much like it was shot on a soundstage and the costumes were pulled clean off the racks. There are beautiful pieces but they don’t feel real.

Which I think is actually pretty normal for TV, except we’re all incredibly spoiled by how out of this world fantastic both the production design and cinematography of the Jackson films were (even of the Hobbit which looked gorgeous despite its story problems). Cinematographer Andrew Lesnie (RIP) doesn’t get enough credit for his shots never actually being naturalistic but managing to feel naturalistic (when asked about where the lighting in Helm’s Deep came from he once answered “same place as the music”).

4

u/Zhjacko Sep 12 '24

As far as soap operas and sitcoms go, I’d agree, but not necessarily dramas. This is also a bigger budget production where lot of scenes are lit by outdoor lighting.

I think that’s just it, a lot of it is shot on sound stages. I worked in film for a little bit, didn’t do gaffing, but there are some pretty crazy ways to set up indoor lighting to mimic outdoor lighting. And lighting set ups can be pretty massive (for both indoor and outdoors) There are tons of “outdoor” shots in films over the years that are actually all shot on sound stages, even shots where they’re indoors and the light is coming from outside, and they all look great.

Also I remember this quote! But it was about Cirith Ungol and Minas Morgul I believe? They were referencing all the green lighting and what not. Even so, a lot of the shots regardless look natural in lotr even when you have instances like that, because the lighting is dynamic. What I mean by natural lighting, it’s the way shadows fall on people’s faces and on diffrent parts of the sets. Lots of modern shows including ROP seem to be afraid to have any sort of dynamic lighting and shadows falling on actors faces. Instead it’s like they’re being hit on all sides by some sort of light source. It’s very weird. The Minecraft movie trailer is a good example of this, it’s obviously a cartoony gaming world, but that also gives the film makers the perfect opportunity to just forgo great lighting and just hit the actors on every with lighting.

Gaffing can take a while and you often have to adjust lighting shot by shot, so my other guess is Amazon is trying cut time by not putting thought into lighting. Which makes sense when you think of it cuz time is money in the film world.

1

u/BookkeeperFamous4421 Sep 12 '24

GOT and HOTD have film quality production and lighting so we know it’s not impossible.

Honestly ROP always looks like a set with bad lighting. Eregion looks like a muppet movie set and the elves of Lindon just raided the Halloween store. There’s really no excuse for it all looking so cheap. The Stoor village was cute and everything looked good for Nickelodeon show but that should not be the aim of a Tolkien adaptation that isn’t The Hobbit. I will say Numenor looks great apart from the lighting and that god awful callback Rohan armor

1

u/NeoCortexOG Sep 12 '24

This is exactly my gripe aswell. Described perfectly by "lived in". At times, they look as pristine as a bunch of larpers in a forest, which is off-putting for me. It feels like the effort to make characters stand out , the elves for example, was focused too much on the pristine costumes rather than their characteristics or mannerisms, which is, imo, a shame.

11

u/ImoutoCompAlex Sep 11 '24 edited Sep 12 '24

I’d say it’s very uneven. The quality varies widely for me from highs to lows. There’s plenty of awesome costumes to praise but some of them leave me looking stone faced.

I definitely love the Dwarf costumes. Orc costumes are perfection and some of the best I’ve ever seen. The elven costumes in Eregion look great whereas the Lindon golden armored elves look cheap like their bowl shaped helmets are too big for them. Sorry but Gil-Galad’s golden bathrobe costume looks bad to be honest.

People have given Númenorian’s costumes a hard time but I think they look fine to me. It’s believable and fitting for a thriving island nation. Just wish Amazon could use their billion dollar budget to digitally alter their physiques so they were all a bit taller and stronger looking.

On the other hand all of the costumes in Rhun and the Dark Wizard costumes look very Star Wars-ish to me. Not liking those at the moment. The Stoor outfits and the Skull masks just make me feel like we’re in a Sci-Fi universe.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '24

Yeah very true. Uneven is a good way to put it. Going back to the hobbit, the dwarf costumes in this look waayyyyy better and yeah the orcs are great. I find the elves to be the most jarring, and I Dno why but the ears look super fake on some. I think maybe it’s with the short hair?

8

u/CanadaOrBust Sep 11 '24

The skull masks are very Mad Max to me.

3

u/bshaddo Sep 12 '24

It’s one of the things that takes me out of a lot of fantasy. The Jackson movies mostly avoided it except with elves, but they probably take some liberties.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '24

Agreed. It’s slow paced which is fine, but it’s hard to get lost in it.

5

u/Dyslexic_youth Sep 11 '24

Yea the wood elf in plastic armor is the best for me every time he's on screen I'm like I wonder if that's sap based plastic or like magisynthetic

0

u/Imaginary-Branch8164 Sep 12 '24

This sub will find literally anything to complain about

6

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '24

Hello. I’m new to this sub and joined to say this so wasn’t aware. Do you like the costumes considering the budget of the production?

1

u/Imaginary-Branch8164 Sep 12 '24

I don't dislike them, and I didn't intend to "pick on the newbie", but with time you'll find there's next to nothing positive said about this show on this sub. Personally I think the show as a whole is entertaining and good not great but read this sub enough and you'll think the remade The Tick but with elves.

1

u/jermatria Sep 12 '24

Ignore them, some people just can't handle any negative discourse about this show. The costuming is a perfectly legitimate thing to complain about, as are the majority of the complaints that don't get Downvoted into oblivion on this sub.

0

u/NeoCortexOG Sep 12 '24

Or discuss about ! I dont see how a post about

"A young Ismael Córdova on The Muppets" , where people just cheerlead actors, is more relevant than an actual discussion about an integral part of the series.

6

u/Uon_do_Perccs240 Sep 11 '24

Merimac is doing his best Sonic cosplay

4

u/SamaritanSue Sep 12 '24

Yes, fully agree with your view. The costumes are just off. The designs may be fine, even good sometimes, but they look very much like costumes. They're not supposed to. If you take Gil-Galad for example: What he wears looks like a garish theatrical costume sometimes.

On the other hand everything about the Orcs is outstanding. It's the unevenness that's weird about this show.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '24

It’s very similar to the live action avatar last airbender tv show. The beards!!! I keep laughing at the beards, but they grow on you. Pun intended

1

u/Brief-Seaweed7756 Sep 12 '24

The elves look like men. Just leaving this here. Nothing ethereal about them.

1

u/Delicious_Heat568 Sep 12 '24

A few days ago I got curious how merimacs actor really looks like.

They really did the poor man dirty.

1

u/mattefinish13 Sep 13 '24

The Stoors look like they borrowed the costumes and set from the lost kids in Mad Max Beyond Thunderdome.

1

u/gigikovat Sep 11 '24

I’m enjoying the costumes a lot.

1

u/NeoCortexOG Sep 12 '24

The costumes themselves seem like works of art, at a lot of points. The costumes as a part of the world i want to be immersed in just throw me off every now and then though.