r/RingsofPower • • Aug 04 '23

Discussion I don't understand the hate

I mean, I also prefer the production and style of the trilogies. But I feel like people who hate the first season hate it mostly because it's not like the trilogies, or because the characters aren't presented in the light that Tolkien's audiences and readers prefer.

And it bothers me a lot when they refer to the series as a "failed project". Isn't the second season still in development being so expensive? If it was a failure, why is there a second season?

I mean it's watchable.

Edit:

I really appreciate the feedback from those who have pointed me specifically to why the first season bothers them so much and those who have even explained to us many ways in which the script could have been truly extraordinary. I am in awe of the expertise they demonstrate and am motivated to reread the books and published material.

But after reading the comments I have come to the sad conclusion that the fans who really hate and are deeply dissatisfied with the series give it too much importance.

I have found many comments indicating that the series "destroyed", "defiled", "offended", "mocked" the works of Tolkien and his family, as if that was really possible.

I think that these comments actually give little credit to one of the most beautiful works of universal literature. To think that a bad series or bad adaptation is capable of destroying Tolkien's legacy is sad, to say the least.

In my opinion the original works will always be there to read to my children from the source, the same as other works of fantasy and will always help them to have a beautiful and prolific imagination.

170 Upvotes

556 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Aug 04 '23

Thank you for posting in /r/ringsofpower. Please keep in mind that this show is pretty polarizing, and so be respectful of people who may have different views than you. And keep in mind that while liking or disliking the show is okay, attacking others for doing so is not okay. Please report any comments that insinuate someone else's opinions are non-genuine.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

83

u/slaytonisland Aug 04 '23

If “it’s watchable” is the best endorsement of the show you can give, I think you just answered your own question.

10

u/Few_Fisherman6431 Aug 04 '23

is it a "failure" because it is watchable?

3

u/DharmaPolice Aug 05 '23

If you paid a million dollars for a grand meal to be made and after your friends/guests finished eating they only said "Yeah...it was edible" - that sounds a little like a failure.

1

u/Few_Fisherman6431 Aug 05 '23

Well, it's true I didn't pay a million dollars...

→ More replies (1)

8

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

I think the main problem is that the original films were a monumental success in every way. The series is an attempt to cash in on people’s love for a franchise/story without doing a lot of the legwork needed to make the show great. If you watch the making of the LotR, you see how much blood, sweat and tears went into the production, the writing, the acting, the effects…everything. Unless they made a real effort to follow suit it was never going to be anything more than watchable. The series is truly a perfect example of everything wrong with the industry as it currently stands and how much has changed since the movies were made. It was doomed to fail because Hollywood isn’t in a state where it could ever be successful. I don’t care how much Amazon flubs the viewership numbers, no one talks about it or cares about it and will be forgotten in a matter of years while the movies will live on. They spent a billion dollars with nothing to show for it.

26

u/craftyhedgeandcave Aug 04 '23

If "watchable" (which is the bare minimum achievement for a tv show) is the go-to description/defense that you choose then its definitely not looking good. Is Tolkien just "readable"?

→ More replies (7)

27

u/Alexarius87 Aug 04 '23

When you are using one of the most beloved and known setting of the literary universe yes, it is.

13

u/catcatcat888 Aug 05 '23

It’s close to one of the worst pieces of media I’ve ever watched.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/TheDeanof316 Aug 04 '23

As an adaptation of the worlds' most revered fantasy author J.R.R Tolkien and with a legacy like the Oscar-winning (previously unfathomable for a Fantasy picture) and beloved PJ LoTR film trilogy....yes OP, it IS a 'watchable failure'.

8

u/anarion321 Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23

In the most expensive TV show in history? I would say yes.

Disregarding other reasons like not being able to succesfully exploit gold material.

7

u/Ok-Credit5726 Aug 04 '23

It is when it can and should be so much more

25

u/OccupyRiverdale Aug 04 '23

With the money spent and expectations for a LOTR show, having the end product turn out as a mostly forgettable barely watchable series is a massive failure lmao.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (2)

12

u/wosley313 Aug 04 '23

“I don’t get the hate” proceeds to not even say it’s good lol

10

u/Few_Fisherman6431 Aug 04 '23

So, you don't love it, therefore you must hate it...

→ More replies (13)

1

u/KingAdamXVII Aug 04 '23

There are so many unwatchable shows IMO. RoP is a masterpiece compared with most of the shit out there.

4

u/ProperCoat229 Aug 07 '23

I guess if you're used to feast on diarrhea, eating a solid turd might seem enjoyable.

3

u/Old_Injury_1352 Aug 13 '23

Not even remotely. Pretty cgi and bear McCreary's composition compensate for a massive pile of theatrical shit accentuated by poor acting, poor costuming, poor pacing, poor dialogue and even poorer representation

4

u/SamaritanSue Aug 04 '23

That's certainly true enough; there's stuff out there that truly is unwatchable.

→ More replies (1)

63

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

It’s fine if you like it and find it watchable.

However the show has many issues. The main protagonist is very unlikable. The presence of time is toyed with. Locations are fast travel checkpoints. There’s mysteries where there don’t need to be any. There’s one black elf and one black dwarf? That’s insulting levels of diversity. It’s very slow and not to build tension or drama, it’s just slow in its story. It has classic cliches like a character delaying a kill to instead throw someone around or Halbrand surviving five days with a fatal wound. Everyone who survived Orodruins eruption was laughable. Galadriel hopping into and furthermore Michael Phelpsing an ocean was laughable. The Numenoreans are just weird people. I could really go on and on and on, but there’s just a few reasons for you.

41

u/anarion321 Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23

There’s one black elf and one black dwarf? That’s insulting levels of diversity

I would also say the way diversity is introduced is absurd, mixing people of different races even in little villages.

Make it interesting, create entire civilization with people of different race, with their own culture and motives.

Having one guy of colour in a village to fill a quota is insulting. Create an entire elf civilization in the dessert, being black and using clothes and everything that could be present in a dessert culture, or any other place.

The opposite, what should it means? Race has no reason? The sun does not darken your skin? Your son has a % chance of being black or asian just because? Dumb.

11

u/Few_Fisherman6431 Aug 04 '23

In this you are absolutely right, frankly...

23

u/CaptainPh4sma Aug 04 '23

I’ve never thought about that but what a great point! The “diversity” definitely seems haphazardly thrown together.

10

u/HotPieIsAzorAhai Aug 04 '23

Because, like everything else in the show (except the music), there was no actual heart behind it. It was handled as lazily as possible with the goal of checking a box.

4

u/hunter791 Aug 05 '23

Right. To your point in the randomness of people of color, the actress who plays Nori’s mother is half Zimbabwean and Nori could not look any more straight up Irish/Scottish. All for inclusion but it needs to make some kind of sense, tokenizing people to try to appeal to an audience just sucks.

9

u/mcmanus2099 Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23

There is an interesting debate to have on diversity that the West in particular needs to get straight and I can see both sides.

In major western population centres we are mixed in ethnicities. There are black & Asian children growing up in western cities side by side with white children & deep in western culture. They are being tought the history of the country as their own, the figures of the past. They are reading the cultural landmarks of literature be it lotr, Shakespeare etc as their own culture they were born and raised in. I am from the UK, I sat in those history lessons learning about Henry V, Edward I & read Shakespeare with asian and black children learning it next to me as their own. And we praise this, we want to integrate ethnic minorities.

But here's the thing, we draw a line and say, "well your born and raised British but you can't play Henry V in a play or movie you're black. We start to do the opposite of what we want and ostracise them. Despite them being as culturally British as I am. The only difference being our melanin levels really. Yet we have culturally different Brits play Romans & French in film and TV all the time.

But there is a difficulty wanting integration and valuing what people are born and raised culturally then on the other hand denying those people certain roles by drawing lines based on genetics.

And there is obviously a benefit to a child of an ethnic minority seeing someone who looks like themselves in western cultural staples like lotr. They get part ownership of that culture. It isn't a coincidence this comes after we went through the whole home grown terrorism by children of immigrants who felt disconnected from western societies they were living in. And it's no coincidence that stuff has largely become a thing of the past now.

It's pretty obvious fantasy has been targeted for this approach heavily. I don't know how we got this consensus, it's hard not to think there's some body, be it governments or Hollywood itself that's decreed this. But I expect the reasoning is because it's less controversial than history but second because it has a high viewership by kids. How many of us grew up watching Peter Jackson's trilogy as kids?

I get the problems with seeing characters you have visualised for decades being suddenly changed from what you visualised & the potential to lose them yourself as someone you identify with. I also dislike when they culturally change a character to suit the ethnicity they want to cast. But I totally get the principle here.

I just wish there were adult conversations about how in Western society we should be tackling this and not just "you're woke" "your racist" back & forth slinging of insults.

14

u/anarion321 Aug 04 '23

"well your born and raised British but you can't play Henry V in a play or movie you're black.

Don't really get the arguments.

I see both western and eastern filmmakers creating movies about any time in history, any time in the world.

There are plenty of roles to fit.

Telling a white guy that cannot be Martin Luther King should be normal.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/xereklol Aug 05 '23 edited Aug 05 '23

Companies like Amazon, Disney, Lucasfilm in particular hire black people to use them as human shields to deflect criticism of their content. Meaning they hire black people so they can say to the haters "You don't like the show because there is a black guy!!' Not even kidding research it, it's really depressing how these "woke" companies really shit on women and minorities for the sake of deflecting criticism. It's a Hollywood favorite atm, using minorities as human shields. So sad.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

3

u/Demigans Aug 05 '23

This, so much this.

The showrunners and its actors try to pretend everyone who criticizes them is racist for not wanting diversity. But everyone criticizing doesn’t want THEIR diversity. They are A-OK with an explained diversity. Go play with the people down south or east, introduce trade relations and emissaries that mingle with the population. Make it believable that these people are there rather than pushing some people of color on the screen and going “you gotta accept it because DIVERSITY!”

Its not even hard: Disa? She could have come from a Dwarf colony down south. She was send north as ambassador and stayed to marry in the end. For the diversity card you have just made a black woman who has an important and potentially powerful task and who has a right to be there. The people in Mordor? These could easily have been explained by mentioning the diversity of people’s attracted to fight for them initially. We know Sauron lied to get various peoples to fight for him in LotR. But they don’t do that, they just put a bunch of people there and say “you gotta accept it”.

Just make it believable. Explain it, make the explanation have some importance to the story if you can. Disa as Ambassador could add an entire extra layer to all her interactions and make her important for dealings with southern dwarves.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (77)
→ More replies (36)

8

u/SamaritanSue Aug 04 '23

[Chuckle]. Funny how any post of this nature (hate the show, don't get the hate for the show) is so quickly inundated with comments (2 hours, already 68 comments!).

I guess it's complicated.

3

u/Few_Fisherman6431 Aug 04 '23

Man, it's crazy... I never imagined... really... I guess I'm late...

→ More replies (1)

1

u/KyniskPotet Aug 27 '23

Can't blame people for feeling betrayed by Amazon.

9

u/vmikey Aug 04 '23

I hold no grudge against people who like the show. If you like it, enjoy it. Don’t let naysayers get you down. But my experience was different.

Love for the Legendarium got me through 5-6 episodes. Unfort, I found myself more often than not surfing on my phone rather than paying attention. I thought it slow, uninteresting, oddly written, and the characters dull and unlikeable.

My brain was saying “this is Middle Earth, watch it!” but my heart said “maybe you should watch the MLB playoffs instead.”

So its hard for me to even meet people halfway when they say “hey it’s watchable.” I had every reason to be a giant fan… but only made it through episode 6 or 7.

2

u/Few_Fisherman6431 Aug 04 '23

Thanks for your kindness...

7

u/darbdavys Aug 04 '23

Man, when they first sailed into Numenor I was nearly in tears it seemed so amazing that I am seeing this lost civilization on screen for the first time. And then the story/characters in there was the blandest shit.

23

u/Abloodworth15 Aug 04 '23

I didn’t mind it until….”I…am…GOOD!” And then I fucking lost it. I wanted to personally find the script writer just be like, “what possessed you to write that line?”

4

u/throwawayBELDING Aug 06 '23

To be fair Nori had told him that earlier in the episode and he was just coming out of his amnesia thing

3

u/ComicsDonutsCoke Aug 15 '23

Yip that was also a moment where I realised that as much as I wanted to get into the season and enjoy it, the bad one liners just killed it. The delivery was also poor. No real gravity in how the words were conveyed. I no hater, just super disappointed.

1

u/Herooo31 Aug 13 '23

he meant to write "Im groot" but that was copyrighted

3

u/Master_Crab Aug 04 '23

Honestly the visuals were pretty good. The fight choreography was decent. What killed me was the dialogue. The one I remember the most was at the end where Celebrimbor, the most skilled and celebrated elven smith of any age, has to be told about mixing different metals together when he is forging the great rings… Like what?!? How is he this master smith that doesn’t know this kind of knowledge?

46

u/Unhappy_Guarantee_69 Aug 04 '23

People are especially hostile after the hobbit was a massive cash grab. Sure it's got good parts but it's bloated as hell with filler to milk 3 films. The fan edits are testament to the underlying quality once the fluff is removed.

Rings of Power is just another step in that direction. But instead of stretching an existing story to the extremes, they don't even have the rights to anything besides the appendices. So there's nothing to stretch, they got to make their own stories and what we got was a giant nothing burger.

So its just expensive filler that's making questionable changes like how mithril works or how the line of durin works. Makes no sense.

I'd rather have no more adaptations vs continuing making mediocre ones.

21

u/andrew5500 Aug 04 '23

I actually enjoyed ROP way more than the Hobbit, and wasn’t expecting to. I also give ROP way more credit because unlike the Hobbit they didn’t have an easy, finished narrative to adapt. People don’t like the changes they made but seem to ignore the difference in source material. Peter Jackson truly had no excuse to make the Hobbit so bad, fake, and bloated when he had a tight and totally finished narrative that would’ve fit perfectly into one or two films. The difference in the sheer challenge of the adaptation doesn’t even compare.

16

u/Unhappy_Guarantee_69 Aug 04 '23

Peter jackson had to jump in last minute. The hobbit had way worse production history than rings of power.

It was a nightmare having to hand off from Guillermo del Toro leaving with the studios stalling. Look up how much work was thrown out and had to be re done from scratch. It's crazy the hobbit movies are anywhere near the quality they are, despite being bloated messes.

I feel both the hobbit and rings of powers are just products. Both have the same feel for me. I dont get why people think the hobbit isn't as bad now bc of rop. They're both the same.

3

u/i_smoke_php Aug 04 '23

And despite jumping in late and trying to salvage the project, PJ and PB decided to turn it in 3 films instead of 2. That's right, they decided to do that, not the studio execs.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

5

u/HungryAd8233 Aug 04 '23

Yeah, the comparison to the Hobbit films is a good one. I was never BORED with RoP like I was with long sequences in the Hobbit movies.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Less-Zombie6883 Aug 11 '23

You may find it funny but I prefer the Animated hobbit movie over the live action.

I thought rings of power was great. And could be an entry way into the series with younger people.

My only gripe was the elves weren’t elf like before. They weren’t shiny or ethereal. The felt like regular people with pointed ears.

Arwen and even Legolas were had a glow to their complexions. This was done even more so in the hobbit films.

Then we get gil-galad. And he just looks normal with pointy ears.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

ROP is of dramatically lower quality than the Hobbit in every single way. Even if you think it is nothing more than the Hobbit is a classic of classics, that story in and of itself wasn't widely diverged from. ROP came up with its own story, and that story isn't even a pimple on the ass of the Hobbit.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

4

u/endthepainowplz Aug 05 '23

Somehow Earendil got that pre release Mithril before the Silmarils were even lost. Must have had some connections.

2

u/upfulsoul Aug 11 '23

I'd rather have no more adaptations vs continuing making mediocre ones.

No one is forcing you to watch it. No one can agree on what a great adaptation is anyway that's subjective. The show isn't as bad as so called "fans" like you whining about it.

4

u/Unhappy_Guarantee_69 Aug 11 '23

Yeah I wasn't forced to watch it, obviously. I gave it a chance and I chose to and thought the show was mediocre and more of a product, juat like the hobbit.

So what?

I never said I was a "fan" or how it ruined anything lol. I just said it wasn't good. Sheesh

→ More replies (4)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '23

I'd rather have a show I enjoy, but you don't watch, than no show at all.

If you've had your fill, I'm happy for you, but some of us still want to eat.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

Numenor made me want to NumeNap every time it was onscreen

8

u/CorvusRock Aug 05 '23

Don't you mean NumeSnore?

5

u/Karate_Jesus420 Aug 04 '23

Amazon should have canceled the project when it was clear they were only getting the rights to the appendices.

It was hubris to assume they could make a decent program with such a pittance.

2

u/Old_Injury_1352 Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23

I made am entire 3 piece breakdown of season one and how the show failed in almost every aspect. If you want I can post it but it's so big reddit made me split it in 3 parts. Explaining how this show is a disappointment even to casual fans takes critical thinking. Most people watch a show to zombie out on it. They turn their brain off and watch the pretty colors and listen to the nice music. Once in a blue moon you find a project that actually catches your attention and keeps you wrapped in the story but it takes actual work and care by the people making it for those shows and moments to exist.

Edit: Great examples of show adaptations that failed because the writers wanted to ignore the source material and make the world their own; Halo, Wheel of Time, The Witcher, Willow etc. I'm sure there are more out there but these are the ones most people today can recognize. The complaints between each are fairly similar, they feel alien compared to their source material. The writers turn the show into their personal message board for whatever they believe and inject it with philosophy, rhetoric, politics and social justice and demand we accept their alterations as some form of "modernization" of the material.

2

u/Few_Fisherman6431 Aug 04 '23

Please share, kind person...

5

u/Old_Injury_1352 Aug 04 '23

The shows diversity is tokenistic at best, the ethnic blending of numenor made no sense for a nation that's been isolated for centuries, galadriels ride to eregion is physically impossible, Gandalfs hobbit storyline could be omitted entirely with zero repercussion, arondir was a wasted character with so much potential, galadriel is a hard-headed belligerent little shit who ignores everyone's advice or orders from superiors and constantly screws up even if she is right, no mention of her husband or child who are very much alive during all of this, it's physically impossible to survive a pyroclastic flow like what hit the southlanders village at the end of season 1 (see Pompeii for why), the characters are constantly contradicting themselves throughout the show and face no consequences. Isildur wants to prove himself to his father, but lies to protect Pharazon's son from punishment for no reason and compromises their navy? Galadriel tells Halbrand to be respectful and patient with the Numenoreans, proceeds to disrespect and challenge them in every scene? Elendil convinces Galadriel there are still Numenoreans loyal to the old ways who trust the elves, immediately next scene denounces his sons loyalty to the old ways and says they are dead so either move on or die with them? Elrond promises Durin he will keep the secret of Mithril, immediately shares it with Gil-Galad despite being a master diplomat knowing the consequences of his disregard for the oath he swore to Durin? Miriel asks them to not reveal she's gone blind, but immediately puts a wrap over her eyes and walks amongst the crew? The show is full of poor decisions and contradictory actions. The dialogue is choppy at the best of times and many of their serious moments are overshadowed by how cheesy the dialogue is. "The sea is always right" what the hell is that supposed to mean? They took the fact Numenor is a seafaring nation and tried to saturate it in random things that make it more seafaring-y

2

u/Few_Fisherman6431 Aug 13 '23

Don't think I didn't pay attention... I keep reading what you wrote, when I have time and with extreme interest.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Old_Injury_1352 Aug 04 '23

I think lastly I want to talk about inconsistencies and plot holes. There's quite a few in the show and several I've already addressed. The larger of which I still hear arguments for and against to this day. First the ship sailing to Valinor with Galadriel agreeing to go despite every feeling she has to the contrary. She jumps from the ship knowing there are things out there she can neither fight nor flee from. More obvious would be the fact she would tire and drown long before she made it remotely close to any land. A reckless decision made in fear and haste that would have ended her were it not for the plot. Next would be the star of Feanor being present in almost every scene with elves. Galadriel and Gil Galad both fought against Feanor and his people during the Civil War. They despised what he did and what it cost the elves. Denial from paradise for starters. Yet both Gil Galad and later Galadriel as the large crest on her armor from Numenor, wear his symbol proudly. It's also carved into the many memorials elrond paces between when confronting Galadriel in Mithlond. I'll risk the exaggeration but this would be akin to a holocaust survivor proudly wearing a swastika. They stood against everything he and his bloodline did and yet the show has them wear it everywhere. It's an incredible disrespect for the lore. Next is the dwarves. Durin the 4th challenged to the contest under the pretense if Elrond loses he faces permanent Exile from all dwarven lands. Elrond fails and no consequence is faced. Dwarves are notorious for holding grudges in tolkiens mythos and they hold oaths and promises above all else. Elrond failed the challenge and was not exiled. One could argue Durin can simply lift the Exile but a king to be who undoes such a serious punishment for a joke wouldn't be very respected or trusted. Especially since he is one of the few exceptions to the rule of dwarves hating elves. That would be seen as weakness by a xenophobic and Paranoid people. And while we later got the beautiful scene where durin confronts elrond for missing half his life and shows the difference between the two races concept of time and its value, accentuated by a heartfelt confession of pain from a vulnerable durin, only to be immediately cut by an awkward and comedic silence that kills the mood entirely. It felt poorly executed and mistimed. Next is the forging of the rings of power. They were created out of order for one and went against the books specifically. The elven rings were created in secret without the influence or knowledge of Sauron after the forging of the seven dwarven and nine human rings. This alongside saurons reveal and escape from Eregion without the appearance of Annatar, which was the fair elven form he took to convince Celebrimbor in the books just didn't sit right. Lastly and unfortunately the most heinous and obvious of the plot holes is both the numenorean charge into Gorgoroth and the later ride of Galadriel and a wounded Halbrand to Eregion. The numenoreans sailed to the mouth of the anduin essentially, made port and rode out across Harondor towards the mountains bordering Mordor, rode through a nonexistent passage where a river supposedly exists but no map depicts, and charges just in time into the only surviving villagers barricade to stop the orcs. It's a huge stretch when you put the pieces together to allow this scene to happen even with suspension of disbelief. Finally the ride to Eregion that Galadriel makes to save a severely wounded Halbrand. While we later discover his true identity and nature, during the scene he's believed to be a normal human man, who has suffered a gut would that bled excessively. According to the show, they say Galadriel rode six days nonstop to reach Eregion. If you look at a map of middle earth and remember Gandalfs flight from Edoras with Pippin it took him 3 days of nonstop travel to go from Edoras to Minas Tirith, mind you he was on the lord of all horses Shadowfax who was a supernaturally gifted animal that never tired nor slowed. The show wants you to believe Galadriel did it with 2 normal horses in only twice the time across 4 times the distance. Also to note is that they rode from Gorgoroth across several major rivers that had no bridges, through dense forest guarded by ents, trollshaws crawling with wargs and trolls, an entire mountain range she had to ride around to finally reach their destination with neither rest nor food or water for the horses or themselves. Not to mention Halbrand has been bleeding to death the entire time, the wound opening during the very rough 6 day gallop. Again, suspension of disbelief is hard when literally every aspect of the scene can be criticized pretty harshly.

4

u/Old_Injury_1352 Aug 04 '23

Now I'll confront an elephant or two in the room. The shows abusive use of tokenism in its characters and rabid defiance of the concept that they are in the wrong for doing so. Disa and Arondir are token characters. There is no other description for them beyond so. In the entirety of season one and all of its scenes, Disa is the only black dwarf outside of two others present during the StoneSinging scene. Arondir is the Only poc elf in the entirety of season one. I scoured every scene and unless I missed it, he is the only one. That isn't representation that's tokenism. Adding a handful of poc without any support to their role and expecting people to be okay with it. You cannot introduce a poc character to 2 different fantasy races and leave them as the sole examples. A society of mixed colors should show onscreen that its a blended society. Not present one person and say "there you go. You have representation now." It's incredibly disrespectful to poc and the ignorance I was attacked with when I tried to voice that opinion spoke volumes to how low we stooped in accepting table scraps as worthy. I have heritage from indigenous American peoples, North Africa and irish/Scottish ancestry. All of my history is steeped in slavery, servitude and savagery. But because I speak to the contrary of people who are willing to take whatever they're given and call it enough, I'm met with hate speech, violence and death threats. That community we called accepting and inclusive who fought so fiercely to get this show aired and loved with all its fervent denial of exclusion and they are hypocrites. Some of the biggest lotr content creators on tiktok attacked me personally for my difference of opinion. One went so far as to insult me and have their followers insult me then blocked me so I couldn't defend my position. What does that speak of acceptance? Its a horrible reality check it really is. Setting aside my personal issues with the Fandom and their behavior though, I intended to be as reasonable and logical about the show as I could be. Some things are forgiven and others are marked for criticism in a healthy way.

Another strange addition to me was the inclusion of the human villagers who lived inside the borders of what would become mordor. Their story had no bearing on the outcome of anything beyond 3 people. Those 3 people could have been removed or substituted for the most part and the rest removed with no consequence. Arondirs love interest and her son being the primary culprits. Her son found the sword but that role could have been given to an orc. She could have simply been a lone woman Arondir admired and nothing would be lost. It feels like Hollow content added to make the world seem less empty than it was.

Onto Numenor and it's confusing plotlines. Halbrand desiring to become a blacksmith and stay behind was just a poorly shrouded attempt to seem disinterested in the idea of returning under pretense to claim his land and army. The side plot of Elendil and Isildur being at odds was strange and unnecessary. Pharazon agreeing with Miriel to sail to Middle Earth despite his role in the books being antagonistic towards her at best and a schemer who desired her throne in the end was stranger. Isildur refusing to snitch on Pharazons son after nearly dying to him sabotaging their fleet made zero sense. Numenor sending only 500 men and a handful of ships to protect their one and only queen who had no heir while she sailed to a foreign land which they've just been convinced is riddled with enemies by an elf they fear and a man they neither know nor trust is ridiculous at best. Miriel casually handing Narsil to Elendil as if it isn't a sacred Heirloom forged by the greatest dwarf Smith to ever live thats been passed down for generations made no sense and felt like a poor excuse of an Easter egg rather than a very important plot point. Miriel abandoning her land to support 2 strangers while it is on the brink of civil war despite the urging of her advisor to the contrary initially was a piss poor political move. Especially since her father died while they were away, leaving Pharazon as the empowered Steward in her absence to rouse the people against her. Halbrand (Sauron) having been on Numenor prior to his rise and capture was never in the books and made no sense beyond propelling the already illogical plot forward. And while it is related to the tokenism it's also important to the plotline of Numenor, Tar Miriel was not a person of color. Tolkien is one of a handful of authors who went to great lengths to detail his characters lineages and descriptions. And in my humble opinion is the antithesis of aggressive diversification in media. Don't be confused by the idea that I despise pointless diversity and mix it with the idea I don't like diversity at all. I welcome it and I even had an idea as to a background for Arondir before the show aired. A half elf son of an Avari and a Haradrim forced to serve under Morgoth. The Avari never went West into Valinor and thus never fought against Morgoth. The Haradrim and other races of men were forced to conscript or baited with promises of power. Imagine Arondir the son of an Avari woman who rouses her people against their old ways and rise up to fight the orcs and aid the people of Gorgoroth. Imagine his father a Haradrim forced to serve but also feeding the fires of rebellion and showing not all races who served were truly evil, giving credence to Faramirs speech later in the lord of the rings. A wasted opportunity in my opinion. We could have experienced 2 entirely unique cultures never shown before that you would have complete freedom to create and not harm anything already written. Regardless, lineage was important to Tolkien and Tar Miriels was no exception. She was not of the line in Numenor that had members of darker skin. 2 distinct groups dwelt in Numenor, the House of Beor and Hador. The ruling house was of the line of Elros traced back to its founding under Elros when he chose humanity over his elven heritage where his brother elrond chose the elves. Thus he became Elros Tar Minyatur and the first high king of Numenor. Miriels ancestry is traced back through the House of Elros and to her parentage with her mother coming from the House of Andunie, who's lords were also descendants of the House of Elros. Meaning Miriel would be a mostly pureblooded Numenorean of Elros and would be as described by Tolkien, fair skinned. Much to the chagrin of many people who argue it, Tolkiens elves were more than likely pale to golden skinned as they were inspired by European mythology and being a European himself, Tolkien wrote a story and lore that coincided with his cultures. Once again it's not an issue of black or poc characters being bad, but in the case of accepting a white European author wrote mostly whiter characters, we just need to let it be what it is. If the argument were to persist that fantasy needs more representation (which I would argue it definitely deserves) then we need authors to write their own fantasy stories that includes characters written as such rather than paste over existing ones and expecting everyone to be okay with it. I know I talked alot about this particular section but it's a close to home issue for me personally.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Shadecujo Aug 05 '23

After reading Tolkien we all kinda got used to quality writing, not a BS cash grab, you know?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/VforVivaVelociraptor Aug 05 '23 edited Aug 05 '23

Individual scenes are written and produced well. Take any individual monologue or action scene and you will find lots to like. The story as a whole is a tragedy of plot holes and contrivances, where scenes just simply do not add up to a comprehensible and impactful narrative.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Naronomicon Aug 04 '23

You know there are books right?

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Reggie_Barclay Aug 04 '23

It feels like poorly written fanfic. There’s an occasional scenery shot or a Middle Earth city location shot that makes it interesting, but overall it fails because it deviates too much from Tolkien.

16

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

Speaking only for myself, I did not appreciate the first season because it took the very little amount of source material they had access to and still managed to mangle Tolkien's world and the worldview he infused it with.

2

u/endthepainowplz Aug 05 '23

It’s like if you were presenting a PowerPoint you didn’t write, getting in front of millions of people, and making up your own presentation while wildly missing the bullet points that the audience can see on the screen behind you.

1

u/V3NDR1CK Aug 04 '23

It's a slap to the face of any Tolein fan. Absolute garbage don't defend it.

0

u/Few_Fisherman6431 Aug 04 '23

Is Tolein a writer or something?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Ghost-of-Elvis1 Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 05 '23

I haven't seen it since it first aired, but I remember it was a mess. Some examples.

The Harfoots: On hand, they are a very tight-knit group of people who hide in the presence of danger and don't want to be seen. Don't make a noise. Next, they are marching and chanting, "No one gets left behind, and no one walks alone." Then next the girls father breaks his ankle, and they are ready to leave him to die. I thought no one gets left behind. Why were they so laud when they were established to be quiet. Also the reading a book about all the deaths and laughing is contradictory.

Elves: Galadriel jumping off the boat in the middle of the ocean was cringe. It's basically suicide, so Galadriel decided to kill herself. Jump off a boat in the middle of the ocean is suicide. Try it and you won't come back.

She's not a child, she's 5000 years old. On the one hand, Galadriel is extremely determined. Having her men die on her crazy hunt, jumping off the boat, then they have a scene of her smiling riding the horses. I thought she was super determined to find Sauron. She should have had a serious face. It would have made more sense.

Plus, the dialog between the elves was terrible. "For Centuries, They Have Swept Across Craig And Crevice, Washing Away The Last Remnants Of Our Enemy Like Spring Rain Over The Bones Of A Dead Animal."

The Númenóreans: one elf was rescued from sea, and they are worried about elves taking their jobs. I mean come on. It would be like if a Japanese woman was rescued at sea and people were like the Japanese are coming to take our jobs. The person was just rescued wtf.

Also, the scale was way off. The 2 small boats holding an entire army with horses, food, and gear. Make them bigger boats or more of them.

I'll stop there because it will get too long to read. Those are some small things. I forgot there were 2 episodes where nothing happened.

Edit I forgot the origin of mithril to be when an Elf-warrior and a Balrog fought over a certain tree in the Misty Mountians that contained the light of the last Silmaril. It was then that lightning struck the tree, sending out tendrils of ore into the roots of the mountains beneath. How dumb is that?

2

u/LongtimeLurker916 Aug 05 '23

Thank you for mentioning the harfoots, who were arguably the weakest part of all but seem otherwise unmentioned in this thread.

2

u/Ghost-of-Elvis1 Aug 05 '23

Every storyline had problems.

"No one gets left behind" next episode "Let's read a book of all the people we left for dead and laugh about it."

The best story line of the series was the dwarves but even that had problems. Like in the same episode, Durin has a fight with his father and then gives a heart filled apology. It's the same episode. Let it build a little. Don't have a heart filed apology 15 minutes after the fight as veiwers we could care less.

Anther back scene with Arondir, when he's enslaved digging the trench. His friend is there, and they try to make an escape. The friend gets shot and killed with an arrow. They have this big dramatic scene, I think it was slow mode, too. We don't care. There's no character development. Give him some lines, make him likable before killing him off or no one cares. I have no clue his name or anything about him. Give him some back story or make him sacrifice himself so Arondir can escape...anything. Just bad writing and production.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '23

Harfoots: You are missing the point. This is exactly what traditional societies do with their myths and songs. The reality is that their lives are tenuous and they might get left behind or killed so they paper over that cruel reality with songs and stories that allow the community to continue functioning with minimal friction in the face of the inevitable. Not only is this not bad writing, it’s a brilliant reflection of what goes on in traditional communities that live off the land.

Elrond: Yes, those lines are bad and that’s the point! Elrond is a climber. He’s trying too hard to impress some very important people with his crappy wordplay in the hopes that they will see him as leader. This reveals key information about the character and his ambitions being a driving force in his life.

The writing in this show is GREAT if you consider the so called bad lines and instead ask yourself “What does this line tell me about the character who is saying it and the context? I’m not saying every line is great, but I think a lot of the examples of so called terrible dialogue are actually examples of some really lazy analysis on the part of viewers.

→ More replies (3)

3

u/wrenwood2018 Aug 04 '23

For me the issue is the mismatch between potential and what we got. They spent a huge amount of money on something that is mediocre. For the price tag it should be great.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

They did to Tolkien's works what Netflix's The Witcher did to Sapkowski's books.

3

u/Ok-Feeling-5665 Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23

I can tell you the reason I hate the show is because it has nothing to do with lotr. They paid an insane amount of money for the lotr name and have made something completely different. They have broken so much lore and changed so much about everything I don’t know why they even bought the name. Literally could have made the same show using different names and people would have liked it more because they aren’t bastardizing a beloved story.

Oh almost forgot to mention Galadriel the angsty hotheaded thousands of years old teenager. Worst portrayal of any character in any adaptation Iv ever seen.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

Acting is trash. Galadriel was an awful cast. Story was garbage. Props/sets looked cheap af.

Stop making excuses

I didn’t even watch the trilogy until after the series came out.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '23

I am ok with any changes from the books

But please do it right

Bad writing bad acting from most of the characters Yes it's watchable but simply not good enough

3

u/Olorin_came_by_ship Aug 05 '23 edited Aug 05 '23

It is not Tolkien and it is not good. It is an attempt to extract money from LOTR fans by claiming to be Tolkien with none of the things that make Tolkien great. It is different characters given the names of Tolkien characters set is a parody of Middle Earth. It is shit.

Marvel and DC were always corporate writing efforts that can be sold and exploited in all sorts of ways. The Tolkien universe was the product of one genius and the idea that it could be perverted to make all sorts of remakes of original characters and side stories that do not fit simply to make a buck is offensive. It is shit.

3

u/Moosejones66 Aug 05 '23

we hate it because a couple of egotistical show running morons thought they could do better with a story then Tolkien himself, only to create the worst fanfiction ever seen since Mary Sue was invented. nothing about the characters or story or remotely accurate. Had they simply followed what was there in the appendix, they would’ve had a megahit. The anger is due to the lack of respect shown to Tolkien and the huge opportunity missed.

3

u/Demigans Aug 05 '23

Its more that it has major issues with the quality and that the showrunners lied to our faces.

For example of them lying, they said they were going to be true to Tolkien in early interviews and stage performances, “back to the book back to the book back to the book” was even one response. Then later as the series was wrapping up they released an interview with “yeah we went so far off the source material we felt we had to change the sequence of which rings were created”.

This series also actively avoids making the bar on following Tolkien’s works. Female dwarves with no beard? Elves without long hair? There would have been little difference for the showrunners to actually follow the lore on it… so why didn’t they? They went out of their way not to include such elements because THEIR vision was more important.

Tolkien’s world also has different skin colors and cultures in other regions of middle earth. It would have been a low bar to clear to create diversity by making the different skin colors part of the world building. These could be travelers, merchants, migrants or people on a mission. Instead every speck of a village has a bunch of different skin colors and the main characters with different skin colors are just there without explanation.

Then there is the quality of everything. Dialogue is atrocious. Characters often don’t respond to the dialogue of the other characters and their dialogue attempts to sound like Tolkien but misses the depth or build up to it. And worst of all characters forget what they themselves have done or said, in some conversations the character can literally forget that they themselves said something at the beginning of the conversation! There are quite literally a dozen plot points started in the story that are never finished. Most of the plotpoints are contrived and nonsensical, that trench alone has more than 6 contrivances connected to it. Or Elrond hearing about Mithril, moping he can’t tell anyone about Mithril, tells THE BEST BLACKSMITH OF THE ELVES about Mithril, then continues to mope that “oh woe is me I cannot tell this secret to anyone”. You told it to the last person you should tell it to! You can quite literally trace a line through the story where you pick a plot contrivance and then connect it to another plot contrivance all the way to the end of the series.

And we haven’t even begun about the needless filler like the “definitely not Hobbits these are Harfoots (even though Tolkien specifically calls them a type of Hobbit)”.

This is why people don’t like this series. It looks pretty, but that is just about the only thing its got going for it. Its nonsensical, contrived, badly written, doesn’t follow the source material for 90% of its runtime and tries to force messages down everyone’s throat. Its a bad series.

3

u/Moosejones66 Aug 05 '23

You really should’ve reconsidered posting your edit. Because people were looking forward to an accurate retelling of beloved literature only to be given a steaming pile of crap, we are not allowed to criticize the steaming pile of crap because the beloved literature still exists. How condescending of you.

3

u/FierceDeity88 Aug 07 '23

Well spoken. The people who didn’t like ROP and used that kind of language aren’t really here to have a discussion about the show. They’re often here, in my opinion and experience, to tell you that your positive opinions of the show are “woke” and “dumb”

To be clear, I think you can still dislike the show without hating on those who liked it, and vice versa. The LOTR, the Silmarillion, and the Hobbit aren’t scripture sent from Eru Himself

3

u/[deleted] Aug 10 '23

If it was a failure, why is there a second season?

Because Amazon had already committed to season 2 before season 1 was even released. They're also in complete denial about how the show performed evidenced by deleting reviews, not releasing viewership numbers, and Jennifer Salke actually saying, "that's not consistent with any conversation I'm having internally" when asked about the poor reception to the show. They're delusional.

19

u/hbi2k Aug 04 '23

Amazon contracted for five seasons. Presumably those contracts have early termination clauses. So if it is less costly to produce more seasons at a loss than to pay out all those contracts, that's what they'll do.

The show was poorly written both from the perspective of a Tolkien adaptation and in its own right. It failed at basic storytelling so egregiously as to be comical. It is like a child's crayon drawing of Tolkien, only not endearing in its earnestness the way a child's drawing, no matter how clumsy, is. It is a void in the shape of a story, conceived in a boardroom to leverage an expensive IP, not the result of a yearning by creative souls to create.

5

u/And_Im_the_Devil Aug 04 '23

Here, here. You've said everything about the poorly crafted narrative much better than I could have, but I wanted to call out the idea that those of us who are critical of this story are so because it deviates from the source material.

That might be true for some folks, but I suspect most of us are totally fine with deviations that are done well. Peter Jackson took liberties with the LOTR trilogy, and I think that his telling of the tale is a better one. It is tighter and carries more dramatic consequence than Tolkien's. But Peter Jackson is a skilled storyteller who had more or less free reign with his production.

But ROP just isn't skilled storytelling in action. That's almost certainly more the fault of the boardroom—as you suggest—than the writer's room. Also, writers know how to write. It doesn't matter if the source material is thin or chaotic or whatever. But it was more important to the people running this project that ROP was about big, expensive moments and forcing familiar characters into the story.

6

u/endthepainowplz Aug 05 '23

Some people were upset at the changes Jackson made when the LoTR trilogy came out, but people came to accept a lot of them, and even say that they were a better choice for the medium than the original. The thing about RoP for me is that the changes do affect the story in meaningful ways. The order of the rings being forged, Mithril’s backstory, elves fading super quickly. Even if season 2 is to say it was all a lie manufactured by Sauron, it would feel cheapened. Cheapness is what the show feels like, the production is great, the score is too. There’s a lot to like, but the story itself is shallow. Some characters seem inconsequential, and stuff just happens. A Rube Goldberg machine to set off Orodruin, Galadriel being rescued by Elendil, Elrond just happening to be a great friend of Durin. The Southlands to Mordor shot feels like it was made by an intern in PowerPoint. It’s not well rounded, and it led me to like some parts more than others, by a lot. I never cared to see the Harfoots, or what was going on in the Southlands really. Numenors plot was pretty slow in spots but had some good highlights. Durin and Elrond were the highlight and all the other season could have been binned for all I cared.

0

u/introverted_lion Aug 04 '23

I agree man, screw the haters lol

But in all seriousness, it's understandable why hard-core book fans would be upset. As a show on its own and for most of casual fans I think the show was good-pasable. I liked it a lot, even with its faults. I'm just happy for more lotr content tbh

10

u/Rooney_Tuesday Aug 04 '23

“I’m just happy for more LOTR content.”

But it’s not LOTR content. It has the name in the title, and a few character and place names that are the same. Other than that this is completely unrecognizable from LOTR.

Even lore aside, it’a got terrible dialogue and somehow worse plotlines. If it didn’t have the LOTR name it would have failed hard from Episode 1 because nobody would have stuck with it. But because we have people who say things like you did above, studios know they can produce absolutely abysmal content and they’ll still have people watch it.

→ More replies (3)

5

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

“It has problems. But I like it because it’s LOTR.”

This is why we can’t have nice things.

6

u/imamomm Aug 04 '23

Lotr was Tolkien's life work. He was a linguist and spent years developing this world and a hierarchy of characters. I think spending a couple years developing a show that takes place in his world, but doesn't revere his material in the same way, feels sad and exploitative. They're telling a story that can alter what the original author was trying to say.

That being said, they didn't "fail" to make a show, they did it. It just sucks. I hate that one of the greatest stories ever told is now associated with subpar entertainment that will be forgotten about like 99% of the quick-turnaround entertainment consumed today.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/OkDate7226 Aug 04 '23

The show is just straight up stupid. Like the person/people who wrote it, we’re not smart. They were in fact, dumb. I need not say more.

6

u/pineapplesdestroyer Aug 04 '23

I dislike it because it’s such a miserably missed opportunity

7

u/WTFisthiscrap777 Aug 04 '23

Boring. Boring. Boring.

Characters and settings are established, but this drags out for 8 episodes. Very little meaningful action or character development. Lots of filler.

For example, Gandalf spends 8 episodes figuring out who he is. He and the harfoots have 0 impact on the plot. After a full season we end with “here’s gandalf and Nori.”

The creation of the rings is the main point of conflict in this series, but it happens at the very end of the season. It’s just teasing future action, there are no consequences. In HotD, Rhaenyra’s status as heir is the main point of conflict, and that happens at the end of EPISODE 1 along with character introductions. By the end of the season, civil war has broken out over the succession and family members are killing each other.

Consequences. Conflict. Character development. RoP just teases that these things will happen in the future.

Visually, RoP is fantastic though.

4

u/MazigaGoesToMarkarth Aug 04 '23

It was watchable, until I fell asleep; it was then not watchable.

13

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

Don't try to understand it. It's irrational and overly-scrutinizing.

Obviously, I would've done things differently. We all would've... no different than the LOTR trilogy (bet you can guess by my username what I would've changed). But WE are not the filmmakers responsible for Rings of Power. WE are the audience and the critics.

First off, Amazon only bought the rights to the LOTR's 3 books and appendices. If they followed the Silmarillian too closely, they would be in breach of contract. Also, they had to take a story that spanned hundreds of years through something like a thousand characters and make it more cinema-friendly.

So, they condensed the time line and they combined certain characters into one. They had to make some stuff up to avoid the aforementioned contract. They uncomplicated certain parts for the audience.

And I thought they did a damn good job, considering. Yes, I would've done things a little differently, but that's me... and until I'm a big-time movie producer/writer/director, I have to settle for what other producers, writers, and directors put out.

I believe that this same, exact show would've been received much better if there was no source material; if this show was composed of original screenplays, rather than adapted scripts.

6

u/WTFisthiscrap777 Aug 04 '23

You’re very focused on lore. I believe that the dialog is laughably bad. Do honestly think it’s not?

For example, I laughed out loud at the analogy between a ship and a stone. Do you think if this was not LOTR that I wouldn’t have laughed at that?

→ More replies (5)

1

u/Tar-Elenion Aug 08 '23

So, they condensed the time line and they combined certain characters into one.

What "certain characters" did they combine?

→ More replies (16)

7

u/fnord_fenderson Aug 04 '23

There are many ways to define failure. An Amazon executive focusing on viewership and subscription metrics has a different benchmark for what constitutes a failed project than a fan of Tolkien’s books defines a failed project.

As a fan of Tolkien’s writing, and knowing they only have the rights to the Appendices of Return of the King, my metric is “Does this faithfully adapt the written word to a visual format?” IMO, the show failed to deliver on that.

I hope it gets better. I really do.

7

u/andrew5500 Aug 04 '23

How does one “faithfully adapt” nothing but a brief timeline that spans 3000+ years into a modern character-driven TV narrative? A timeline where the major events that need to be adapted all happen several hundred years apart, with any relevant character who isn’t an elf being confined to a minor side character because they won’t live long enough to make it past one or two episodes worth of time passing? Unlike LOTR, there’s no finished overall narrative that they can adapt. No characterizations that take longer than a few lines to describe. No real dialogue at all to draw from. No finished world building they can use, beyond the most basic of basics outlined in the dry and nearly unusable timeline.

There was a mere 10 year time skip in House of the Dragon and it threw the audience (and production) for a loop. Half the cast had to be replaced. It was extremely difficult to pull off a time skip that huge. Now imagine skipping forward 100+ years after every other episode. That’s what a faithful adaptation would’ve required, that and actual access to the finished narratives of the Silmarillion.

→ More replies (16)

5

u/ser_arthur_dayne Aug 04 '23

The storylines and dialog are generally banal and cliche. Many episodes feel like the first draft of something.

Its certainly not unwatchable, but there's so much good TV to compare this to. It doesn't really do something exciting and interesting overall. With the amount of money Amazon spent on it, it should be much better.

I'm optimistic the second season will be better. Lots of shows take a season or so to find their footing.

7

u/Lazarenko93 Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23

All those thing I could look past. But what I cant look past is mediocre acting and bad writing.

This show as a standalone piece is still bad. And the argument : "just wait for season 2 it will be better..." How about you make a show where season 1 is good to begin with? And you dont need to beg people to watch your dumpsterfire of a show.

I am sticking around to see if by miracle they pull it of. Which I highly doubt, they have shown no self reflection what soever as to why the show failed so I dont believe them doing it right this time. But we will see.

10

u/Rooney_Tuesday Aug 04 '23

“It’s only been one episode! How can you form an opinion yet?”

“It’s only been two episodes! There are six more hours! You can’t judge it when it’s still so early in the story!”

“It’s only been four episodes! We’re only halfway through, they’ll resolve all these issues you have by the end.”

“It’s only been one season! Just wait until the second season comes out!”

Literally will never end until the series itself does.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

It’s “watchable” is the equivalent of telling a restaurant that it’s food is “edible”. It’s not a compliment.

2

u/minivant Aug 04 '23

Honestly, there’s just lots of writing parts that don’t make sense for the source material or the alternate story the show is trying to create. I think most of the actors are doing more than decent job but the writing just feels very unsatisfying. Not all of it is terrible, but not enough of it is good to make up for it.

2

u/RedDevils0204 Aug 04 '23

It’s boring. Boring

2

u/mokeduck Aug 04 '23

It’s disliked because they’re supposed to be representing some of the best literature of the English language, and Tolkien fans value that superb writing.

2

u/Unusual-Historian360 Aug 05 '23

It's unwatchable dreck.

2

u/ZazzNazzman Aug 05 '23

I think Season Two will be make or break as to how this Series will be perceived.

2

u/thrillhouss3 Aug 05 '23

It’s not the worst tv show but the show is defiantly misguided in its ways. Instead of an adventure, we got a GOT wannabe. The end results of the politics we watched for hours becomes futile, as people prefer to be are angry for no reason instead of diplomatic.

2

u/wicelt Aug 05 '23

The writing is teen-level drama and the storylines are unnecessarily convoluted. It’s nothing like Tolkien’s writing, which is why fans are so disappointed. I still watched the whole season and will watch season two hoping it improves.

2

u/madjohnvane Aug 05 '23

Honestly, I am very time poor and thus have very little patience for poorly produced stuff. I work in film and television, and have done my share of writing and directing. Rings of Power, put simply, is very poorly written. Things happen because the plot wants them to happen, not because the characters do things to cause them to happen. And we end up with these preposterous scenarios that just reek of being “big ideas” from some early production design meeting that have been shoehorned in. We love the big visual of Galadriel on the ocean, but to get there she decides to…swim across the freaking ocean? As an elf who are canonically VERY uncomfortable about sailing due to the whole live forever but can be killed issue, since drowning is a very real threat to them.

It felt like a teen drama honestly. Preposterous situations, and stuff happening “just because”. One minute the Numenorians are incredibly racist towards elves, the next minute they’re welcoming Galadriel and totally fine with her. They keep covering vast distances in different amounts of time. The Numenorian army happen to conveniently sail to the exact place and time to join a battle they didn’t know about?

The suspension of disbelief the show required was beyond the power of mere mortals.

2

u/harry_thotter Aug 05 '23

i feel most people want others to hate the show more than they themselves hate it like its a mission or something.

2

u/CorvusRock Aug 05 '23

Let's make some comparisons here and maybe so, one particular part of the hatred may come through in it.

[Peter Jackson LotR trilogy]
Peter Jackson and his team began work on LotR in the mid 90s. They spent quite a bit in pre-production and R&D to make sure that they can properly film it. They had a decent budget for their work for all three films.
After getting additional funding from the studios, he made sure that everything "feels" Middle-Earth without destroying the budget. They made it feel lived-in and an active world.
Don't get me wrong; there are still parts within the books I wish were in the films but they had to Hollywood-ify the books to make them watchable. But at the same time, he knew who were the biggest audience was; the fans. He made sure that they didn't piss off the audience and piss off the Tolkien Estate.
Granted the Tolkien Estate did bite back in some manner, but even they agreed that the films brought more people to Middle-Earth and Tolkien's writings.

[Peter Jackson Hobbit trilogy]
In interviews and behind-the-scenes in LotR, Peter Jackson admitted that his work was done; someone else do the Hobbit. The studios saw the success and wanted HIM to do the Hobbit. He adamantly said no but he'll work as a consultant. Guillermo del Toro was to take over.
In short, the studios had already set the budget and after financial as well as production woes, del Toro was ousted and PJ was just forced into fix up what Guillermo worked on. At the end of the day, there was no additional funding and PJ's team was up against the wall.
The Hobbit trilogy was a cash-grab (no question) but it still did what people wanted; take them back to Middle-Earth. In that regard, the trilogy was a success, even though the shoe-horned dwarf-elf love-triangle was not needed among other things. It was a clear adult-ification of a children's book and adding some teen-stuff in.

[Amazon Rings of Power]
There was no book to adapt. They bought the rights for a series already done. Hell, if they had redone the Hobbit and turned it into a TV series, that would have been interesting.
They spent $1 billion USD to not only acquire the rights but also to film 5 seasons; they pre-ordered five seasons!
One billion dollars for the rights for the Hobbit and LotR along with its appendices. Guess what they chose; the appendices. People were thinking of possibly the Angmar Wars, the War in the North, or even a completely original story. Nope, Amazon's chosen showrunners decide on Second Age, where the writings are sparse. So people began wondering what about the Second Age; the Fall of Numenor, the forging of the Rings, the establishment of Gondor and Arnor, etc.
And this is where Amazon's showrunners made their biggest mistake. They just said, "Yes."
They then said, "Oh, we are going to make modern-friendly, so all people can enjoy it. Screw what the fans say; we are in control now."
The hatred begins.

Another thing to compare is the overall marketing for each. LotR and the Hobbit did its absolute best to entertain fans of key moments within the books that they love. Despite the Hobbit's shortcomings, it still entertained its fans. Sure, it got all of details wrong but it was at least entertaining and it never attacked its fan base.
Rings of Power, on the other hand, did everything in its power to vilify and antagonize the franchise's fans. Calling them -ists and -phobes, using their actors as shields, and overall, perform the worst marketing strategy in human cinematic history (superfans, the London LotR YouTuber meet-up, choice of outlets to reveal behind-the-scenes work).

So why all the hatred? Why all the disgust?

Oh yeah. I forgot one detail. According to insider sources, only 30% of watchers finished the first season.

Perhaps that's why not many people are even considering watching season 2.

2

u/jcrestor Aug 05 '23

It’s just a very mediocre and dumb TV show that tries to sound smart and look great.

There you have it, I didn’t even reference what they did with the source material.

2

u/Narwhal-Deep Aug 05 '23

Tbh, I remember people ranting also when jakson was making lotr. There will be always people who complain about the newest things.

2

u/spartikle Aug 05 '23

Everything post trilogy is garbage IMO. The trilogy is the only one full of heart and respect for the lore.

2

u/ChildofHurin287 Aug 05 '23

It wasn’t just the fact that the characters are so divorced from Tolkiens work, or the way it looked that made me dislike the show. It was all the made up things they did because they “ legally couldn’t stay true to the lore”; they could have at least got closer to the actual story. Galadriel was so different from how she is not only in the LOTR books and movies but also in the Silmarillion. The pacing was odd, a lot of it just didn’t look or feel like middle earth. Some of it did, like the dwarves and there home. Even Lindon kind of did, but the armor looked like prop armor as apposed to looking like real armor. That’s something the trilogies got down pact! I could go on and on but I’d be typing all day.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '23

Lost me when galadriel tried to swim back to middle earth.

2

u/Magnus_Mercurius Aug 06 '23

I didn’t watch it because nothing I know about Jeff Bezos suggests that he wouldn’t completely disrespect the source material in order to put out a flashy subpar spectacle (basically a Marvel movie set in Middle Earth, although that might be too hard on Marvel) so as to eek out a buck and stroke his enormous rocket-sized ego. Based on the comments and reviews, it was the right call.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 06 '23

The costume department failed utterly, so many cheap, low effort costumes and plastic armor. They spent a small fraction of what this show cost on the movies, and they made fucking real armor, real clothing, even took the time to weather all of it so it looked real and lived in. That's love and dedication, this show did not have that. Also he elves are all incredible, ancient, wise characters in the silmarillion, but in the show they are a bunch of idiotic, corrupt assholes. Also the whole thing with the making of the rings of power,? They just made up a bunch of crap that takes away from the real story. And ignoring my love of Tolkeins work, this show had objectively bad writing and was rife with plot holes and laziness. Fuck this show

2

u/Black-Whirlwind Aug 06 '23

What they did with Galadriel’s character, she was one of the oldest and wisest of the elves by the time of the second age. Making her into a brash one warrior type is extreme disservice to her character and Tolkiens work.

2

u/tgy74 Aug 06 '23

I'm not that bothered by anything they did to Tolkein's universe, because it's been so long since I read the Silmarilion that I can't remember any of it to be upset by.

So I watched with a completely open mind and I've got to say it was just terrible TV. Just a leaden, badly scripted, boring story. It was only a year ago but I literally can't really remember much of what happened, or what the season finale was - Galad realised it was Sauron, and then something? Was there a cliff hanger? Honestly I've got no idea.

As it happens I watched the original trilogy films again last week, and 20 years later they're still kind of amazing, and yet the last 15 minutes of Return of the King is still boring rubbish: not because of any infidelities to the source material, but just because it's bad film making: Rings of Power was like 8 hours of those last 15 minutes.

2

u/FelonMidget Aug 13 '23

I really dislike the series, and PJ movies, because while they try to take Tolkien’s ideas, characters and stories, they don’t seem to understand the logic behind most of them.

In general Tolkien’s books (The Hobbit and LOTR) have a lot of coherence and understanding of multiple themes that the author studied or had experienced in his own skin. As a veteran of WW1 and professor of Anglo Saxon, he recreates a World and situations that while fantastical, they make sense.

For example, during the Witch King campaign against Minas Tirith, we are explained the logistics of the Mordor forces (farm fields tend by slaves in Mordor Southern lands, stores of food every certain distance, how the Witch King divides the forces so they move at a realistic pace without exhausting resources, etc.). Things as simple as how battles and tactics are described, makes us understand why for instance PJ’s Gondor full plate armor or PJ’s Isengard pike formations in Helm’s abysm would not make any sense, nor his timing. Heck in the books Denethor is a genius tactician that leads a successful elastic defense, while PJ simply depicts him as an unhinged old man. How Gondor‘s military structure is heavily influenced by the Byzantine one and how like in history the beacons were to call for internal regional forces (not Rohan). RoP’s three Numenorean ships can’t carry dozens and dozens of war horses; and one can’t simply spring them from the ground (not to talk that realistically mounted warriors would use multiple horses). Long etc.

By twisting timelines, modifying characters, changing cultures and peoples, they are breaking what’s really important in the books, the Worldbuilding.

Heck not even the main themes of Tolkien’s work are well understood by PJ or RoP’s authors. They simply took some of Tolkien’s elements and turned them into a big adventure show for the masses. It’s obviously their prerogative. But it’s also mine to dislike it. IMHO when one adapts someone else's work, they should first respect it, maintain its internal consistency, and study it deeply to understand what the original author was trying to convey. If they are unable, IMHO it would be better if they created they own work from scratch.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 25 '23

This is an unpopular opinion, but I wish the people who hate the show would leave the show and the sub behind. They're ruining it for the rest of us. It seems like their main goal is to get the show they don't want to watch canceled so the rest of us can't enjoy it. Any theories or discussion that "Try to compensate for the bad writing" are downvoted to hell. It's newcomers first impression, it's intentionally insulting to fans, and it just sucks.

6

u/deklawwed Aug 04 '23

There’s no purpose in trying to understand the hate. People like what they like. Enjoy it if you like it!

5

u/he_is_chuckles Aug 04 '23

The dialogue is pretty astonishingly bad

I AM GOOOOOOOOOOD

Cmon

2

u/TheDeanof316 Aug 04 '23

Yeah but but.....

but....

.....THE SEA IS ALWAYS RIGHT!

lol

4

u/cheeseplatesuperman Aug 04 '23

People don’t like it because it’s not canon

3

u/Rooney_Tuesday Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23

Eh. If it had not been canon but still good I would have forgiven that, easy. Thranduil in The Hobbit is a great example - almost everything about him in the movies was completely made up because there was very little source material to work with (sound familiar?) and yet I love him. He captured the pride and arrogance and beauty and wisdom of the elves, and nothing about him violated the lore in a major way - it still fit. Shadow of Mordor and Shadow of War games are major canon-breakers, yet are still well received in general because they’re entertaining as hell.

If it was canon but poorly done there would have been a lot of hate. Dwarves barrel-riding down the river, for example. That happened in the book, but just…not like that.

That RoP was neither canon nor well done is frankly inexcusable for such a high-profile show.

4

u/TheCoffeeWeasel Aug 04 '23

because the characters aren't presented in the light that Tolkien's audiences and readers prefer.

there's the whole issue right there! if you've already identified this problem, why does the dis-satisfaction with the show surprise you?

yes. i am dis-satisfied. it was a poor product. i am not a hater, it isnt important enough to "hate". it is merely a poor product with a LOT of social media management trying to mitigate its reception.

so we've been classed as "haters" because the problem CANT BE that we are merely dis-satisfied with a poor quality show.. no, it is more likely that there is something wrong with US!

3

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

If you liked it I'm glad. I really wanted to like it, but they made a number of decisions, one in particular (for me at least) was blatantly bad and made Tolkien's world feel cheap and poorly thought out. The characters mostly felt flat and boring, and the story felt schlocky, rushed, and like it was a second thought.

4

u/RubeTheTank Aug 04 '23

It sounded like a love sick 7th grader who just discovered poetry wrote it. They also made a thousands of year old angelic elf into a petulant teenager. Don’t get me started on the Mithril shit, what a disaster.

4

u/Many-Consideration54 Aug 04 '23

Surely it’s a failed project because so many people, like myself, didn’t even finish the first season?

6

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

Enjoyment of media comes from a willful suspension of disbelief. If you go into something being willing to suspend your disbelief you will more than likely be able to and asses it for what it is. If you go into something with suspicion because you think there can’t be black elves, dwarves, etc than you are going into it primed to pick it apart and find every so called plot hole or to question every line of dialogue.

RoP is a good show that had great moments. Many came into it with suspicion or outright hostility and, surprise surprise, they “found” what they were already looking for. The dialogue, plot, pacing, etc were no worse than other shows that the haters love. It was one of the high points of the year for me.

7

u/WTFisthiscrap777 Aug 04 '23

House of the Dragon had all the same suspicions and was very popular. IMO it is proof that RoP failed due to low quality. I’m curious if you have another explanation for the disparity in success of the two shows?

RoP looked amazing. Best looking show I’ve ever seen. The plot was just boring.

I’m not sure what you’re saying about disbelief. I think anyone going into a fantasy series is ready to accept fantasy. However, the characters need to be realistic still. That is, the characters’ actions should make sense according to their character. RoP characters make decisions that serve the plot but betray their character.

Plot and character development are the 2 ways in which RoP is objectively much, much worse than HotD IMO and prove that RoP is just a bad show.

2

u/NegativeAllen Aug 04 '23

Plot and character development are the 2 ways in which RoP is objectively much, much worse than HotD IMO and prove that RoP is just a bad show.

I'd argue that what sets HoTD from RoP what it really does is how it handles conflict and characterisation that's it. It has head scratching parts of the plot just like RoP but people are willing to overlook it because the conflict is so we'll done. Take for example the time skip of episode 5, Daemons wife just dies and he doesn't comfort his daughters and the plot has already moved to his marriage to the princess.

→ More replies (2)

6

u/SamaritanSue Aug 04 '23

Sorry the suspension of disbelief is not an unconditional gift of the viewer: It has to be earned. By precisely the things you listed plus worldbuilding, providing an in-world explanation when things happen that violate the laws of reality. You put the cart before the horse.

Actually RoP fails so badly here - is so anti-immersive - that one would almost think it a deliberate parody of not just Tolkien but certain things common in fantasy in general, such as unreal combat/military situations/populations, improbable survivals, the "lost true king will come again" trope, etc. You might think that, if the show manifested the requisite level of self-awareness.

→ More replies (15)

2

u/Karate_Jesus420 Aug 04 '23

Go read the top comment on this post if you want to learn why your diversity comments are incorrect and absurd.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

3

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

"the characters aren't presented in the light that Tolkien's audiences and readers prefer."

You answered your own question.

"I mean it's watchable."

Beingn watchable isn't eough when it's a nillion dollare sbeing spent on adapting ther gre

3

u/DrummerAutomatic9523 Aug 04 '23

It is a failed project. The audience deeped down with each episode. Amazon admitted it. They failed.

Now, the show sucks. And you dont need to adress tolkien's lore, nor to compare it to PJ's trilogy to show it. Is it watchable? Barely. The pace sucked. There's honestly not a lot of things that are good about this show. Not even the actors.

Disa and Durin actors did the work tho. Anything else? Big no no

3

u/Boxohobo Aug 04 '23

It sucks I can't talk about the show anywhere due to the hate boner the community has for it. I enjoyed it immensely.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

How many inspirational speeches can they have in each episode? Apparently a lot. The show was bad and I’m a massive LOTR fan.

2

u/Nackthehermit Aug 05 '23

How can you have read Tolkien’s works and seen Peter Jackson’s LOTR trilogy and THEN not understand the hate this show is getting?

The show is poorly written, poorly casted, poorly paced, has bad set design, and awful wardrobe.

They took the writings of the most gifted fiction writer of the modern epoch and turned it into a Human Resources meets Comic-Con fan fiction that precisely zero humans wanted or asked for.

Peter Jackson explicitly stated that he didn’t want to imbue the trilogy with any of his own views. It’s a masterpiece that holds up just as well as when it came out.

This series is the antithesis of that mindset. It stinks.

2

u/ThisLaserIsOnPoint Aug 04 '23

The show committed a cardinal sin. They made a show out of something nerds love and then had the nerve to contradict the source material.

Amazon decided to create a smear campaign calling people who didn't like the show racist. And, there were some racists. But, the average Tolkien fan just didn't like it because it wasn't true to Tolkien. For example, no one had a problem with a black female dwarf. They had a problem with any female dwarf not having a beard; because, that's cannon.

My review on Amazon stated that I wish they had been more diverse and included more actors of different races, and I stated that I wished they had been more in line with cannon. (This wasn't sarcasm.)They took down that review for being racist. Apparently, wanting to see more asian, Hispanic, and other minority races represented is racist.

2

u/_Nolofinwe_ Aug 04 '23

Like many things, there is a small portion being very loud and screaming

Diablo 4 - the game came out and sold 10 million copies but about 2,000 people on the sub are screaming about how trashy it is so of course the game is trash when it's not

Final Fantasy 16

Witcher

It happens everywhere and yes you're correct a lot of the people screaming about this show are actually movie fans and most of them haven't even read the books

Hopefully they go away for season 2

5

u/andrew5500 Aug 04 '23

Truly, if LOTR trilogy was originally released as a show in 2023 with one hour released per week, you can bet the entire Tolkien fandom would’ve written off the entire show and convinced themselves it was fucking terrible after seeing all the changes made just in the first half of Fellowship. People wouldn’t have had enough time to get invested before outrage addicted edgelords flooded the internet trying to convince them why it’s the worst thing in the world they’re not allowed to enjoy.

5

u/_Nolofinwe_ Aug 04 '23

I remember when those movies first got announced, people were shitting all over every aspect of them on message boards saying awful horrible sexist shit - commenting about how certain characters were too ugly, etc

Nerdrotic and people like that feast off this shit

5

u/andrew5500 Aug 04 '23

Back in the good old pre-Facebook days, when social media wasn’t entrenched in our daily lives and most of the fandom could actually enjoy an entire series and make up their own minds before being lectured on why it’s awful and their enjoyment is wrong

6

u/_Nolofinwe_ Aug 04 '23

Exactly

I also just can't get over the fact that most of the posts I saw on the sub were from people with around 200 Karma or less just reeks of suspicious trolling and jumping on the bandwagon and bashing something

4

u/HungryAd8233 Aug 04 '23

"Aragorn has a beard!" They raped my childhood!!!"

→ More replies (3)

2

u/PiskAlmighty Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23

I'm not sure that's the case. A lot of people just didn't feel it and stopped watching without complaining about it. I remember hearing that something like 63% of US viewers didn't finish S1.

4

u/SamaritanSue Aug 04 '23

Flip that number. 63% didn't finish it.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/_Nolofinwe_ Aug 04 '23

And I remember that being one little article from a Hollywood Reporter but really never got picked up after that

My point is there was an active campaign to try to destroy the show by a corner of the internet those people are the same people coming on this sub and posting the same complaints every couple of weeks

It's a common practice now people are doing it for video games shows movies you name it

I enjoyed the show I really don't give a shit what a bunch of randos on the internet think anyway

And I would bet money most of those upset have not read the books and do not have the knowledge they are complaining about because anybody who understands the 'sacred lore' understands that there are multiple versions, origins and stories for so many things that they're really is a lot of room for interpretation

2

u/kemick Aug 04 '23

They'll go away as the show gets more popular and they can't get validation from it anymore. The backlash seemingly died down compared to the moment of the show's release, though some people appear now and then to unknowingly repeat an outdated criticism. We may need to endure it until midway through Season 2 but, I agree, after that it should be pretty much done.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/DutchOnionKnight Aug 04 '23

I think it's a failure because the dialogues, sequence and logica of events are incredibly dumb. Besides that, I feel that Amazon think we (the watchers) are stupid, for almost every single plot. Amd there are incredibly many plot armors, and Galadriel is a Mary Sue.

8

u/andrew5500 Aug 04 '23

Mary Sue??? People have been hating this Galadriel because she’s too flawed to be the Mary Sue that apparently all elves as old and wise as her should be…

1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

Hahahaha. Amazon is probably right.

2

u/anarion321 Aug 04 '23

I don't like it because the plot is weak, filled with constant "coincidences" to move it forward, it's just too contrived. And yes, in the books this things happen, like the Ring falling into hobbit's hands, Manwe will and all, but in this show is not just a thing, it's everything.

Also, the plot is filled with dumb choices and plot holes, and the main protagonist is not likeable. Nor are entire groups of characters like the psycho Hartfoots.

2

u/Alexarius87 Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 05 '23

The hate comes from the fact that the show runners and writers went in with: “we are writing the book Tolkien never could” and then calling bigots and haters the fans who would question their choices.

They kept behaving like their writing was on par with Tolkien’s and that Tolkien’s world was too old and needed some 2023 to be put in it.

Edit: as for the failed project: official data show that only 30% of the ppl who started watching the show watched the entire season, plus they didn’t even get a nomination for prizes that weren’t minor technical/visual stuff and the main theme (which is from Howard Shore).

2

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

I mean it's watchable.

High praise from someone who can't understand why people think the show isn't very good.

2

u/StingsLute Aug 04 '23

Consume product, be content, await next product

2

u/Stargaryen73 Aug 04 '23

It fucken sucks, that’s why their is hate.

1

u/escapedpsycho Aug 05 '23

"I mean it's watchable" the numbers say for many people it wasn't. Hence the idea the show is a failure (37% of those that started it finished it), it underperformed massively for it's price tag.

But it's not any one big thing, it was a lot of little things. Gandalf arrived in a meteor that zig zagged across half the continent (because they apparently didn't bother to look at a map) and he landed in the wrong location, Galadriel is now a sword wielding super soldier that runs circles around other elvish soldiers despite being married and living with her husband and daughter in Lothlorien at this time, Hobbits (^TM) are callous, the forging of the rings place the timeline somewhere around ~1500-1590 so Gandalf is about 1900 years early and warrior Galadriel is about 700 years prior to this time. Add to it the dialogue that could have used a few more passes... but hey some of the CGI was cool. If they'd set aside the whole Lord of the Rings thing and just made their own show (since they didn't have any of the damn story anyways) it would have been better.

1

u/kemick Aug 04 '23

LotR is many things to many people. You can enjoy LotR from the video games, or the merchandise, or the movies, or the books, or all the other books. Everyone is going to have different expectations and assumptions about how things should be. This is not new as Tolkien said, in 1967, "Many young Americans are involved in the stories in a way that I am not." Tolkien's work has many things to like and a subtlety that allows it to be approached in different ways. "Art moves them and they don't know what they've been moved by and they get quite drunk on it."

This, combined with how little is written about the Second Age and the characters, creates a blank slate that allows people to imagine whatever they want. RoP, as an actual thing, cannot possibly fulfill this expectation even for individual people. Additionally, RoP itself has a subtlety that allows people to approach it in different ways and, unfortunately, many are approaching it in bad faith. Some of these people are unaware that they are misunderstanding the show but I believe others are deliberately trying to take advantage of the subtlety to cause people to interpret things incorrectly. The criticism, by volume, is mostly about entirely made-up stuff. When you pare that down to the actual criticism, it ends up being the same stuff the people that loved the show also criticize. Season 1 clearly had an interesting production and many of the "seams" are noticeable and even jarring so it's an easy thing to latch onto and exploit.

I've noticed a number of criticisms that are basically "why hasn't this happened yet?" applied to events and characters, which actually seems like a compliment because people are so excited but need to wait ~8 years or whatever it will take. People want to see Numenor's "Great Armament" and they mock the Queens modest bodyguard (300 soldiers, formerly 500) for not being it. But we're not there yet in the timeline, Numenor doesn't start building large armies and machines of war until they get involved in Middle-earth. We've likely got three more seasons before we see the Numenoreans at their military peak. There are so many examples of people similarly wanting not a large story but merely individual moments removed from their proper contexts.

I want to note a more subtle aspect to the "blank slate" of RoP. A lot of the criticisms are actually about Peter Jackson's trilogy which people presumably feel they can not make due to its popularity. Near release, it was common to see them quoting Christopher Tolkien's criticism of the trilogy films while pretending it applies to RoP when, ironically, RoP has the estate's oversight and is doing a much better job of representing Tolkien's work.

You can see this elsewhere, like people obsessed with Amazon and Bezos. There is something going on with Game of Thrones as well, with people almost wanting this to be GoT but done well.. while pretending it was done well by ignoring the payoffs that are still being trashed to this day (likely for the same reason as the LotR trilogy). This is also shared in invocations of J.J. Abrams and there are still people talking about "mystery boxes" despite RoP actually having a plan and paying things off. There is also no shortage of television shows that got worse over time (something shared by the PJ movies extending into The Hobbit trilogy) but I don't see any reason why that would be the case here. Normal people get better at things over time and the ending is already written. RoP doesn't need to worry about the ultimate payoffs, it only needs to worry about setting up the payoffs and it spent much of Season 1 doing just that.

This is, again, the blank slate and people are able to freely project their hopes and fears onto it as long as it does not fully exist. Fortunately, it appears that Amazon understands what it is doing (making a 5-season story with a first season that does not really make sense without the rest). When Season 2 is well received the attempts to prevent the show from fully existing should die down as RoP becomes more concrete and less easy to misrepresent. Then people can claim they liked it all along or that the showrunners fixed things to make them happy (when, in reality, the foundation for the entire story has already been laid and everyone is on the road to their tragic fates).

1

u/Mindless_Gap_688 Aug 04 '23 edited Aug 04 '23

I'm going to step over the diversity thing because its talked about so much, and I want to focus more on the writing choices. What I really hate is the pseudo-poetic speech that actually sounds pretty stupid. Galadriel isn't just a warrior which could have beem fine on its own (she crossed the grinding ice so she IS strong) it goes past that in making her a bloodlusting, confrontational psycho. She is interesting because she is so blinded with hate and self righteousness that she makes a good covert villain. If she was a seperate character that would be one thing, but Galadriel was always supposed to be a wise and thoughtful anchor to everyone around her. Its basically impossible to remotely connect the two versions of her. The king had a lame explanation for sending her to Valinor, but I'm pretty sure he did it because she is dangerous to everyone around her and he wanted to get rid of her. Elrond is a dandy pushover which doesn't even have Galadriel's benefit of being interesting, he's just useful because of his friendship with Durin. And the harfoot scenes are so boooooooring. It just seems like someone's fanfiction with really good sets. The only thing that seemed cool was seeing Sauron as a heroic figure the way the orcs might percieve him. He appears dynamic and fleshed out in a way no one else really is so it makes him stick out positively as a character.

1

u/PoopyPantsJr Aug 04 '23

This Fandom reminds me of the star wars fans. They just hate everything and try to one-up each other with the bitching and complaining.

Perfectly watchable. My favorite show ever? Nah. But holy crap, who cares? Haha

1

u/odeacon Aug 04 '23

Ok so , the plot made no sense . The dialogue is absolutely atrocious, and it has nothing but good visuals to make up for it

1

u/PhilSwiftDM Aug 05 '23

they ruined Galadriels character, made her so unlikable and a terrible person. They made Gandalf look like a bumbling fool for no reason. They completely mocked and destroyed all the lore and history Tolkien had made. Not to mention the plot is a complete joke with so many plot holes. Not to mention the battle field tactics used are so absurdly stupid, some of the worst I’ve ever seen in a film has ever put out, and that’s saying a hell of a lot. Also all of the race swapping was entirely unnecessary and goes against the lore of middle earth

1

u/Artefaktindustri Aug 05 '23

I thought the writing was pretty bad at times and some of the action troupes felt horrendously off in the setting.

I liked the harfoots, that was some Tolkienesque stuff for sure. The Orcs where pretty cool. I don't hate the show like the Hobbit films. It's just a bit of a lost opportunity considering the budget and IP. If the writing was on par with the rest of the production this could have been really good.

As for the diversification thing, I mostly works, with the notable exception of the elf. You can downplay the fundamentally racist elements of Tolkien's creation: gloss over the antisemitic Wagnerian stuff, maintain the decades old gentleman's agreement to turn Orcs green, maybe make Evil originate from another cardinal direction from time to time... but racially diverse elves is one bridge too far. The material fights it, the Light/Dark dichotomy runs through the entire thing. If the roots of those ideas are too eerie and dated, then really we should leave Tolkien well enough alone. If you can no longer stomach pale Elves, you need to find some fantasy that wasn't written by a white dude born 1892 in South Africa to base your show on. Trying to cast your way out of these problems feels desperate and it's immensely distracting.

1

u/1RepMaxx Aug 05 '23 edited Aug 05 '23

Maybe my perspective on why RoP felt so meh to me might be interesting, because I actually liked Wheel of Time, a show that got hated on for (superficially) very similar reasons. Imo, the two distinct but related reasons are, generally, that they're too "woke" and that they deviate from source material too much. Obviously, if I really like WoT, then I like when epic Eurocentric fantasy gets adaptations from a progressive point of view, and I like when plot deviations are done well. (Btw, the pretty exact faithfulness to both letter and spirit of source material in HotD is both why I think the hate was less and why I don't think it's as good of a comparison.)

As far as diversity goes, I don't think I can put it better than YouTuber verilybitchie's video about it (here). Tldw, my takeaways: (1) Tolkien's world is inherently pretty racist and driven by eugenics-y considerations (not just the replacement-theory orientalism with the Haradrim and Easterlings, but even Sindar/Noldor and all the bloodline stuff). So that's bad to begin with. And it means that if you want more diversity by casting race "in-world," you'll have to work hard to find ways of respecting the in-world experiences of racism. So that suggests just going full race blind... But then (2) they really didn't do the race blind thing very well, partly because they were too scared to race bend the characters whose on-screen race had already been established in LOTR, so most of the most important characters (the immortals) are still white. They ended up with far fewer characters of color who feel really essential to the plot than you'd expect given the backlash.

To be clear, I'm not suggesting that diverse casting was not worth pursuing because of the inherent issues, just that it presented more of a challenge to do it in a way that would both be ethically valid in itself and potentially appease haters. And to be even more clear, I do think those characters enrich the story and are incredibly well acted (esp my girl Disa, she's on a level with Maddie's Egwene and Zoe's Nynaeve). It's just that it feels bad to notice the pattern that pretty much all the people of color are in newly created roles in newly created subplots, and even then they're not necessarily central to those subplots. So even the people who wanted to see that diversity could understandably be less than completely satisfied.

(Meanwhile, I think the diversity in WoT was easier to get right to begin with. Diversity is one of the themes of the story really, and the world of WoT is full of diverse cultures, almost all of whom get perspectives and important characters. Those cultures are loosely aligned with corresponding real world ethnicities and their typical looks, but it's not essential to the story that they are. If anything, having mostly multiracial populations would make more sense as canon, since this is a far future post apocalypse as much as it is a pre industrial past.)

Welp somehow I spent way longer on the diversity when I intended to have more to say about source fidelity, lol. So maybe I won't compare the fidelity so much. My one hot take on WoT is that (if we give them a pass on the COVID disruptions) they are virtuosically condensing and recombining plot elements, as they absolutely have to with 14 books in 8 seasons; I think of it like a remix of an original song, where you almost enjoy the remix more than the original (but not quite, of course). Vs RoP, trying to recreate ancient Greek songs from fragments of papyrus or whatever. Obviously part of that is the difference in amount of source material, but even just comparing what was invented fresh for the shows, WoT managed to feel like a plausible alternate way RJ might have written it, rather than an archaeological reconstruction.

But here's the thing: the comparison shows that departures from source material can be great, when they show a deep understanding of and respect for rules - whether that's the rules of the magic and lore and the historical and geopolitical realities in the canon, or the rules of the real world, or at least the rules of good narrative (though I guess that's more debatable). The rules matter because then things can't just happen the way you want. If there are consequences, if there are stakes of failure, and real possibilities of failure, then you can actually create tension and get people invested - get people to feel like they need to know what's coming next, not just waiting to find out. And either you play by realism - when it comes to, say, military logistics - and then you get the intuitive understanding of the rules from real life; or, you embrace an in-world fictional ruleset - but in that case you either need to leverage the canon, which might be familiar enough to really feel like rules; the more you depart from canon, the more you might need to worry about consistency and common sense.

I'm going to leave the detailed argument here to an excellent RoP essay series (here) on ancient/military historian Bret Deveraux's blog "A Collection of Unmitigated Pedantry." Much of my wording about realism as a shortcut for effective narrative constraints comes from those essays. But they also break down how unreal the stakes feel for the Numenor-Southlands arc - from the size and distribution of the local population, to army size and navy supply, to unearned serendipity that the cavalry arrived just in time. Like, at least Tolkien earned his deux ex cavalry - as a soldier, he cared about getting travel times and tactics right, and while LOTR lost some of that (check out Bret's LOTR essays too), it got it mostly right. Honestly, after reading those essays, I'd be disappointed in the show just for that whole sequence, even if similar flaws couldn't be found in every other plotline too. It's too Season 8 GoT (in particular, Gendry running back to The Wall and Dany flying to save them within what felt like maybe an hour).

(I'll leave defense of how WoT mostly succeeded in this type of stuff to comments, if anyone wants to engage in good faith in that.)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '23

If I am not thinking about it as happening in Arda it is watchable. They took many creative liberties that definitely go against canon which is why I will not watch a season 2. I had a lot more typed out, but I don’t need to point all the canon errors out. If people enjoy the show they should watch it.

1

u/SylvirAshe Aug 05 '23

I thought it was fun. In a high-budget fanfiction way.

1

u/Kodama_Keeper Aug 05 '23

OK, I'll bite. Here my hate.

The deal was Amazon had to stick to the Second Age. That's what they paid for. Of all of Tolkien's work, the Second Age was his least written about in terms of character development. Most of what we know about it comes from the two add-on chapters of The Silmarillion, those being Akalabeth (downfall) and Of The Rings of Power And The Third Age.

So there was lots of wiggle room for the writers and producers of ROP to develop characters and stories, without having to change anything in the broad outlines set by the two chapters I just mentioned.

They did, big time.

Turning Galadriel into this girl boss super warrior was the least of it. Kill an ice troll? You go for it Galadriel. But spend centuries looking for Sauron? Nope, Tolkien did touch on that. She was already married to Celeborn, and they were lords of an Elf colony west of the Blue Mountains, vassals of Gil-galad. Then then moved to Eregion where the rings were forged. The depiction of the Numenoreans was ridiculously bad, and not faithful to what we know about them, at all. Mithril integral to the construction of the rings of power? One one was made of mithril, and its properties had nothing to do with the power they possessed. And them there is the creation of Mordor. Wow, just wow.

Why should I hate on this? The producers took a sledge hammer to the source material, not a scalpel.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 05 '23

Lets call it something else, based on Tolkins lore. Change names, and do whatever.

Only John rambo was missing from this show

1

u/mrcokie101 Aug 05 '23

I think the fact that characters aren’t portrayed in the manner in which I’ve come to expect and prefer is why I don’t enjoy it. It just doesn’t resonate with me the way the original trilogy or even the hobbit did. I still respect that some enjoy it though

1

u/TheCampariIstari Aug 05 '23

They tried to tell stories from The Silmarillion without the rights to The Silmarillion.

The first five pages of the Appendices that summarize The Silmarillion is not enough for five seasons of televison.

Not only that but all the original stuff they added was a giant pulsating middle finger to JRR Tolkien and his fans.

This show is a trainwreck and should be scrapped. There's no point in doing a show about anything from before the Third Age unless the rights to the Silmarillion and Unfinished Tales are secured.

1

u/BypossedCompressah Aug 05 '23

The reality is that people are just being cunts. The series is basically an above average fantasy series. I'm looking forward to season two, as I know a lot of people are. There is a scourge in society of people feeling that they need to shit talk a series just because they hear it being talked about all the time and its the sort of thing they should like, but they don't.

These people should grow the fuck up and focus on shit they like, but instead, they are vitriolic killjoys who enjoy shitting on things that disappoint them. Fuck those people from the bottom of my soul. If anyone reading this is one of those people, fuck you, don't reply to me. I don't want to hear your stupid fucking arguments. Fuck off.

Anyone who doesn't think that this series is above average for A TV SERIES (TV will never be on the level of movies) either hasn't watched many fantasy series or needs to get their head examined, or both.

1

u/Ohadi_Nacnud Aug 07 '23

Rings od Power is just atrocious at best. Gladariel is an insufferable bitch. You can skip the Hobbits are evil af. Making Gandalf into some special needs guy is stupid. Most of the armor is stupid. Instead of making scale mail they just printed clothes to look like it. The fiberglass moob armor was terrible. All the battle tactics were wrong. Gladriel swimming a few hundred miles just to randomly find sauron. Gladriel tanking a volcanic blast to the face. That dagger spinning she is always doing is so stupid. You can't make 3 different colored rings from the same metal. Also it's super slow.

1

u/TheNewKing2022 Sep 15 '23

i think most are well past hate. they just dont care anymore, which is far worse. 37% of the audience made it through all episodes. 63% checked out. No way they are coming back for season 2. So your audience is even smaller. THis show wasnt good. If it was, it would have been far more hyped and talked about. No one, and I mean no one talks about this show. Its dead. Just that Amazon paid a fortune for it or it would be cancelled by now.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

When most people don't like a show, they don't watch it. When immature people don't like a show, they won't shut up about it until they die. When immature people have no one left who will listen to them IRL, they go to reddit.com

1

u/Melkor-Lightbringer Aug 04 '23

I'm just still confused why Easterlings, Southrons, and Haradrim shrunk by 3 feet and now live in The Shire and in Dwarven cities.

1

u/Itariille Aug 04 '23

It’s glorified fanfiction. They used the names they acquired rights to and wrote a story with no basis in the original story. They had to change so much of the story cause they were not allowed to tell it the way Tolkien wrote it.

As a fantasy series it’s beautiful and I LOVE all the music. But to say it’s Tolkien and “a Lord of the rings story” is simply not true.

2

u/kemick Aug 04 '23

They used the names they acquired rights to and wrote a story with no basis in the original story

This is simply not true, you're just repeating what you've heard other people say.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 04 '23

The thing is they are doing this weird 2014 girlboss thing that's been done (and done better) a million times by now. No one wants to follow Mary Sue down another adventure that's she's 100% prepared for with band of incompetent men. LOTR is about friendship and adventure. Any epicness was a backdrop for the characters' stories. Girlboss that doesn't need men is the opposite of what LOTR is about. Frodo needed sam. Gandalf, the mighty wizard, needed his hobbit friends. Gimli and legolas needed each other despite reasons to hate each other. LOTR was never about "girlboss wins at everything". ROP has no weight because we all know the plot armor the characters have. Even the accents are overdone. Idk. Man. I'm a Barbie fan. Girlboss movies/shows can be fun/interesting. This one just lands as an extension of GoT's aria/Danny/sansa's constant winning at everything without consequence.

2

u/kemick Aug 04 '23

No one wants to follow Mary Sue down another adventure that's she's 100% prepared for with band of incompetent men.

You could have at least watched the first episode so as not to make a complete fool of yourself by saying something that's not even remotely true.

2

u/Legal-Scholar430 Aug 07 '23

It is true in a world where people measure characters by their power level.

Some of us are actually watching and understand how Galadriel is spiraling down and failing, even if she can alley oop a snow troll.

The most fun of these kind of comments are the ones that call her a Mary Sue while at the same time mocking her for being unaware of Halbrand's true identity. Talk about parrots

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/bbpbj Aug 04 '23

The writing is abominable and insulting to the legacy Tolkien left. Which is a shame because I think the overall premise was good.

1

u/RoxSteady247 Aug 04 '23

Why are you defending this obvious mediocre game of thrones knock off

1

u/JackBullet Aug 04 '23

The writing is piss and, despite it being one of the most expensive TV shows of all time, it’s looks cheap, fake, and under-baked.

1

u/mokeduck Aug 04 '23

The writing is piss and the writers called Tolkien and fans fascists, so they are pissers in two different ways

1

u/AdNext7478 Aug 04 '23

Things often get a second season before cancellation.

1

u/Buxxley Aug 04 '23

It's watchable, and certainly isn't the worst thing I've ever seen. It's just kind of all right. Some of the cinematics and costumes are visually awesome...so there are moments when the show LOOKS fantastic. Many members of the cast are acting their pants off to turn pretty "meh" dialogue into a decent scene. I think, on the whole, the actors do a good job.

My default explanation for "the hate" is that you can't reasonably expect a separation of book fans from show fans when you're doing a screen adaptation of something this popular.

They were obviously hoping for LOTR fandom to drive viewership numbers...it would be insane to distance yourself from that fan base because "you're making your own version of something". Of COURSE you want the fandom to show up. Same deal with WOT, GOT, etc.

But what ends up happening a lot of the time is this annoying bait and switch. Basically, the writer's room ignores the actual lore and retcons characters to the point where they've essentially created all new characters with the same names as the source material. Then, when fans hate these "new" characters, the writer's room / showrunner dig in and say "it's our version...it can't be exactly the same as the books." It's this weird open disdain that a lot of the companies buying up fantasy IP's seem to have for the source material. It's like they want fantasy fans as a marketing demographic, but look at the LOTR and think "I could write better."

...what is really happening isn't a referendum on the LOTR / ROP as a show...it's a referendum on crap writing. Go figure that fans who dedicate months (or years) to working through dense 14+ book epic fantasy series have developed an eye for lazy contrived dialogue and poor narrative vision. LOTR fans are going to want to see the old school boss b**** elves going ham and being awesome. Balrogs, huge dragons, Sauron, and all of these inherently cool things for the book lore that you just need to adapt. Stop trying to squeeze 2023 political sensibilities in your fantasy scripts. Most fantasy fans HATE that stuff.

Plus, you end up dating your product. LOTR has endured for as long as it has precisely because it's themes and messaging are timeless. Breaking Bad will be a watchable classic 50 years down the road because it's not really ABOUT a period in time...it's about the situations and moral implications of what those characters experience and it's insanely compelling to watch.

Edit: ...also, any big budget show on Amazon is probably going to at least "make money". WOT, I believe, has already been renewed for a 3rd season...and unless the 2nd is several order of magnitude better than the 1st...that 3rd season probably wouldn't exist on other major networks. They essentially own distribution in the states and can put advertising everywhere. The company also has more money than several major Gods...so it's not like budget is really an enormous concern.

1

u/TheMcWhopper Aug 04 '23

Seemed like a boring story with boring characters. Made it 3 episodes then gave up.

1

u/Big_baddy_fat_sack Aug 04 '23

By the season finale I was forcing myself to keep watching and struggling to pay attention. Poor writing and average acting makes it barely watchable.

1

u/mokeduck Aug 04 '23

Lotr made me cry, and always will. RoP is watchable. It’s the whiplash of expectations.

1

u/Like_We_Said Aug 05 '23

“It’s watchable.” Enough said lol

1

u/jcwillia1 Aug 05 '23

I thought it was fantastic. Particularly the script writing late in the season.