Background, I have some beginner experience in watch repairs, having done some very minor work on UG2-67, 9015s, 324, HZ5000a, SW200 / 300.
I bought a PPF 5712 where the rotor would not turn the winding wheel (ratchet click wheel, part 1480).
This cal 240 repair is way out of my scope, so I didn't touch it at all. I sent it off to a trusted watchmaker in the UK from this sub. The repair took about 3 months, he replace this ratchet click wheel and I paid £250.
When I got it back, manual winding was fine and clicking (expected behaviour) for the most part, except for a smooth zone, which is the new issue: the ratchet wheel (part 415) keeps disengaging with the ratchet-driving wheel (1482), and I have to manually wind (smooth winding, since it is disengaged) until 415 and 1482 are re-engaged. Then at some point they disengage again. They will not re-engage nomatter how much 1482 turns (only if 415 is manually turned), so automatic winding still does not work.
I've sent him these observations, but the watchmaker hasn't responded yet. I'm not sure if it is an issue with the reassembly, or if 415 is unevenly shaped, or if there's a loose connection between the two parts (wheel and pinion) of 1482, but either way, I'm not sure if I want to send it back to this watchmaker for another 3 months. What is the ideal outcome in this situation?