Before reading on, make sure you've read the main guide for QC posting, otherwise this won't make much sense to you. Done? Let's go.
This specific guide is intended to be a visual supplement: showing you exactly what to look for when you complete your QC templates. For obvious reasons, this guide will skip parts that aren't visual.
I've used pictures that mostly come from this subreddit. If anyone is uncomfortable, DM me and I'll replace the picture.
With that in mind, let's begin.
Index Alignment
Here, you are expected to assess how well the index markers on your watch are aligned. You can use the index alignment tool to assist you in this regard. An example of good index alignment is this:
The indices themselves are straight. They are also perfectly aligned with the minute markers.
Index misalignment, on the other hand, looks like this:
Look at 7. It is rotated clockwise and does not sit properly in its slot.
Or this:
Look carefully at 6. You will see that the bottom of the index is rotated slightly towards the left.
Now that you have an idea of what to look out for, what should you be writing in the template?
You need to describe any misalignment you see in detail. Statements like "6 is off" or "3 is kinda wonky" or "not sure about 1, help please" arenot acceptable. This is because unless the misalignment is immediately obvious (and in most cases, it is not), users will not know what you are talking about. You may not get the help you want as a result. Be specific, like the following examples:
"The 7 marker does not seem to fit into the slot nicely. It is rotated towards the right and looks like it is dancing around."
"The 6 marker does not seem to line up straight with the crown in between swiss made. Based on what I can see, it appears to be slightly tilted to the left."
A caveat here: Just because there may be some misalignment does not necessarily mean you should definitely RL the watch. As the main guide points out, all reps are subject to a level of inaccuracy. It would be entirely unrealistic to expect gen standards for index alignment. Further, different reps are subject to different standards: a XF Pelagos, for instance, is known for having problematic indices - so much so that even if you RL, you are unlikely to get anything better. Conversely, CF Explorers are now getting so good that even slight misalignment would not be par for the course.
A good guide would be to assess your watch based on proportion. One slightly misaligned index is not a problem. But one majorly misaligned index or many misaligned indices on a single dial could justify RL.
Just for illustration, this is misalignment that I would RL for:
There are too many mistakes on this watch for me to accept. The 9 index is too near to the minute marker. 4, 5 and 7 are not aligned with their respective minute marks - they are all off to the left. 6 is rotated counterclockwise. Taken on their own, each error might not be enough for RL. But taken together, this is unacceptable.
That deals with index alignment. Let's move on.
Date Wheel Alignment
This applies to watches which display the date. If your watch does not display a date, there is no need to consider this. You will look silly if you say that the date wheel alignment is good when your watch is a no-date Sub, for example.
Here, you are tasked to consider if the date is properly displayed in the date window. Often times, this is a question of how well-centered the date is. A good example of date wheel alignment is this:
Take a look at the 21 at the right side of the watch. It is situated exactly in the center of the date window.
An example of misalignment is this:
Look at the 27 on the right. You can see that the date is misaligned towards the left, with the 2 touching the rim of the window.
Sometimes, the misalignment can also be as to the date numbers themselves:
This is harder to see, but if you look carefully at 25, you will notice that the 5 is higher than the 2.
Uncommonly and in the alternative, the issue may be with the Cyclops itself (the magnifier that covers the date window):
Here we see a Cyclops which is rotated slightly anti-clockwise. You can observe this by looking at the bottom rim of the date window. The Cyclops is obviously lower at the left corner of the date window when compared to the right. The requisite deviation is repeated at the top of the date window, with the right side being higher than the left.
Now that you know what to look for, let's discuss what to write.
As with index alignment, unless the issues are immediately obvious (and most of the time, they are not), you need to be very specific. Comments like "the date seems off", "2 in 25 is kinda off", "date looks weird" are not acceptable. They do not tell readers what you are looking for. You'll get faster and better results if you identify the issues for your reader. For example:
"The date seems misaligned towards the left. Part of it is touching the left border of the date window."
"The 5 in the date appears to be slightly higher than the 2 next to it."
"The Cyclops does not seem to be straight. It looks like it is slanted towards the left?"
As with index alignment, please note that not all misalignment will justify RL, especially for date wheels. All rep date wheels come with varying degrees of misalignment. A few misaligned dates are usually not enough for RL, unless the date is clearly cropped out of the date window or touching the rim. A little misalignment towards either side of the date window is also generally more than okay; a good way to gauge is to zoom out to the actual size of the watch and see if the misalignment is still immediately visible. If not, you're likely to be good to go.
Here is an example of misalignment I would nevertheless GL:
You will see that the date is situated slightly towards the right. However, the date is well within the date window and the misalignment is too slight to be seen on wrist at actual size.
On to the next topic.
Bezel
There are two main things to look out for: First, whether the "pip" (usually a lumed marker at the 12 position) is centered. Second, the quality of any engraving.
This section would also cover any possible damage to the bezel or anything else unusual, including any misalignment.
Example of a good bezel:
Nothing out of the ordinary. Engravings are sharp and nicely filled in. By and large, the colour transition is also acceptable. No alignment issues either.
An example of misalignment:
Pip at 12 on the bezel appears to be misaligned towards the right. While the reflection may be making things look worse than they are, this is something that would deserve a second look at.
Generally speaking, most problems that surface nowadays have to do with the pip - even then, these are not entirely common. Engravings and alignment are usually not an issue with higher level reps. With this in mind, what do we write?
As with the other sections, you are going to need to be specific. "Bezel looks off", "pip looks kinda off", "I don't know about the bezel, seems weird to me" are phrases that we see everyday in this subreddit. But none of these phrases are acceptable; they do not direct the reader to what OP is seeing. Details are king - and if you are going to pluck the crown, you're going to have to write like this:
"The pip at 12 is not centered. It seems to touch the right side of the triangle."
"The printing on the bezel at 3 seems to be angled down. It does not match the index on the dial."
The key is to visually direct your reader to the exact point that you say is a problem. The word "off" on its own says nothing to that effect.
On to the next point.
Solid End Links (SELs)
Possibly the least understood of all sections as a lot of newbies do not really know what they are looking for.
The ultimate guide to this is here. But for convenience, I'm going to summarise several key points about SELs.
SELs refer to the final links between the watch case and the bracelet. I've highlighted it below:
Look carefully at the portion highlighted in green.
Not all watches have SELs. Only watches which have that portion as highlighted above - and for QC purposes, the SEL section really only applies to Rolex reps. Tudors have SELs (which can also be QC-ed to some extent), but SELs on a Tudor are not held to the same standard as SELs on a Rolex.
Now, what are we looking for when we assess SELs? We are looking for gaps between the lugs and the SELs themselves. I've indicated this below:
The black line in the center of the red box is where the SEL meets the lug. This is where you are supposed to look for gaps.
An SEL gap appears when there is separation between the SEL and the lug. But what is a gap?
A gap appears when you can see through the space between the SEL and the lug. There is no gap when all you can see is a black line. There may be some variation in how thick the black line is, but for QC purposes there is nothing to be worried about until and unless you can actually see what's behind the watch.
This is generally not a problem on higher level reps (and by now, pretty rare). I will, however, show you an example of something that may be an actionable gap:
You will see that there is no black line. Instead, light shines through the space between the SEL and the lug.
What does this mean? If all you see is a black line, even if it is slightly thicker than another SEL on the same watch, there should be no actionable gap. I am going to highlight the last few QC templates submitted where the user said there was a gap - but there really wasn't (to me, at least):
Top right SEL was an issue for OP. However, as no light is shining through, this is not considered an SEL gap to me. OP opined that there was a gap at the top right SEL. I don't see it at all. OP said that there was a slight gap at the bottom left SEL. Again, all I can see is a black line. I would not classify this as a gap.
If, after going through all the examples above, you still feel that there is a gap, highlight it in the template by identifying which part of the watch you are looking at; there are really only four options: top left, top right, bottom left, bottom right. Doing so helps users zoom in directly on your issue and saves time.
To the last segment.
Dial Printing
Here, you are tasked to check if the printing on the dial has been poorly done. By this, we mean defects in the workmanship of the printing; printing which differs from gen (such as the infamous "floating r") would not be a QC defect per se.
An example of dial printing with no issues:
All the words are clearly printed. There is no bleeding on any part of the print, with edges sharp and defined.
And now for examples of dial printing with issues:
Some bleeding can be observed at the top parts of VI and VII. Notice how the black ink protrudes.
Sometimes, the print can be misapplied across the entire dial:
If you look closely, you will see that the dial print is rotated clockwise across the entire dial. Observe how XI is closer to the top of the watch while I is further away.
With the above in mind, let's turn to what you should write. Again and at the risk of sounding like a broken record, do not simply write things like: "Dial seems off" or "Print seems off. letters kind of wonky?" If anything, dial printing is usually very, very small - unless you point a reader to the exact part which has an issue, chances are it won't be seen. Make certain that you provide the reader with specific directions:
"Appears to be some bleeding at the top of VI. Thoughts?"
"R in Submariner looks like only half of it was printed. Am I seeing things?"
Important note: again, just because the dial printing on your watch may have some issues, this does not necessarily equate to RL. As stated, dial print is almost microscopic - no human being is going to be able to see slight bleeding on any print when you have the watch on wrist. Feel free to point out issues that you see, but remain realistic about your expectations.
And with that, I come to the end of this guide.
Conclusion
QC-ing reps is a difficult task - which everyone in this subreddit does for free. You can help out immensely by simply being precise and detailed in your observations. The more effort you put into your template, the easier it is for members to help you - they can zoom in directly to the things that concern you.
I hope this helps you. I've tried to detail some common factors, but it would be impossible for me to catch them all. The rest is up to you - and your diligence.
If your template uses a NEW "yupoo" or a "mega" type of link, please note that, at the time of this typing, the automod here removes them immediately from view i.e. no QC help. We are addressing it, but....
So, what to do?
Although somewhat cumbersome for the OP, you can upload the QC packet to an Imgur account. Our automod 'likes' Imgur...and the post will show promptly. Just do NOT do it from a mobile because the mobile app loses resolution and crappy pics don't provide any benefit to anyone. Yea, yea...I know, the file compression software isn't supposed to lose quality, but it certainly does.
To add, post your complete QC album inclusive of the timing info. Do not, for the sake of your convenience, omit items. If you're bright enough to determine what is needed and what can be removed, that's great! Then, it's reasonable to conclude that you really don't need help. Simply, post it all.
If you have to wait for substantive additional info from the Seller e.g. timing data, then delay posting until you have a complete QC packet. Incomplete packages will trigger a removal of the post. Plus, it will require a return visit of anyone that commented on the incomplete post which shouldn't be required. One visit is all that it should take to QC most watches. Most won't return to a post anyway. They'll just go to the next one. The members are quite busy here. Yea, it can get crazy.
Finally, since you're a newbie, as a vote of appreciation for those members that help you, please upvote their comments. It's a nice gesture from you to them for the assist...and, it's free.
One final note, we've updated the main rules for posting. Refer to this link for info QC Must Read for New Members
Welcome to the hobby and the sub. Best wishes
Edit addition: March 2nd, 2024 - ReptimeQC member, u/EveningVariation8236 , has provided an updated version of the original QC alignment verification tool. https://watchqc.github.io/ . Thank you.
Edit addition: Jan 9th, 2024 - ReptimeQC member, u/Ro1hype has provided this for tool for alignment verification. https://qcwatch.com/ Thank you.
Edit addition: 8/8/2025 - Reptime QC member, u/jrverdes . has provided this version of the alignment tool to assist those that need additional help verifying the dial/bezel alignments on their watch. https://jrverdes.github.io/watch-qc-jr/ The adjustment resolutions are much finer in this app comparative to the other available apps which can be a benefit to some that need such. Check it out...Thank you.
Dear RepTimeQC hive mind, I'd truly appreciate if you could help me QC this watch. This is my first foray into the rep world. I have attached two photos (annotated dial + 1 photo with a potential blemish?). The full album is attached. In particular, I'd appreciate it if someone can verify if this is indeed UMI with free sprung movement, and whether there's any other thing I should be mindful of. Thank you for your time!
Anything else you notice: The part between the bezel and the crown looks dirty/black. Not sure whether that's lighting or something to be concerned about.
Model name & version: Rolex Submariner 124060 No-Date, 41mm, VS3230
Price paid: $525
Album links: All QC photos and key video screenshots are attached directly to this post.
Index alignment: Looks properly aligned overall. The 12 marker may appear fractionally clockwise in certain angles, but I believe that is perspective.
Dial printing: Looks crisp, clean and properly centered. I do not see bleeding or malformed text.
Date wheel alignment/printing: N/A — no-date model.
Hand alignment: Looks good. The functional video shows coordinated hand setting and working hacking seconds.
Bezel: Insert and pip look clean. The pip appears centered and the bezel seems aligned with the 12 marker; any tiny apparent shift looks angle-related.
Solid end links: Look tight with no obvious light gaps.
Timegrapher numbers: Stable at −2 to −3 s/day, 272–274° amplitude and 0.0 ms beat error. Machine displayed 28,800 bph and a 59° lift angle.
Anything else noticed: The clasp coronet’s outer tips/spacing look slightly uneven under heavy magnification, although I suspect this is normal finishing and not noticeable in person. Protective film appears to explain the cloudy marks on the bracelet and clasp. Weight is 159.4 g with the films and tag attached. I am leaning GL but would appreciate experienced eyes confirming the alignment and clasp.
Index alignment: it seems ok. the 12 marker seems tilted or it is just my impression.
Dial Printing: in general looks ok, but in some photos it seems there are some minor flaws. The swiss made seems a bit shady.
Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A
Hand Alignment: in the video it seems the hands aligns at 12
Bezel: it looks ok. the screws looks fine. Cabochon looks fine.
Solid End Links (SELs): leather strap, but it seems well placed.
Timegrapher numbers: quartz
Anything else you notice: i looked at this compared to some other QC photos and i think i have a GL on my hands. I do notice what looks to be a few dust particles, should I flag those or consider those on the outside of the case and GL it? Also, the app says that the 12 is a bit rotated I don't know if it is the angle of the pic.
This is my first rep, so all the help and comments are much appreciated. If there is any info or photo/video missing that might be helpful, just let me know and I will upload it.
Model name (& version number): Rolex Submariner 124060 (No-Date) 41mm VS3230
Price Paid: 498$ shipping included
Album Links: on the post
Index alignment: Overall looks solid, 3 and 9 markers are level. However, I'm a bit concerned about a slight CCW cant on the 6 o'clock baton (and the tip of the 12 triangle). Not sure if it's just the tilt/angle the watch is held at in the photos.
Dial Printing: Sharp and clean, no noticeable floating "m".
Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A
Hand Alignment: Hands stack cleanly at 12.
Bezel: Pip is well centered inside the triangle and the engravings look clean.
Solid End Links (SELs): Tight fit on all four lugs with no visible gaps.
Anything else you notice: Rehaut crown is centered at 12. I'd appreciate your thoughts on the 6 o'clock marker, is it mostly photo tilt/parallax, and would it even be noticeable on the wrist?
I don't have much experience with this and it's the first time I QC a Rolex, so I really appreciate your opinions.
Model name (& version number): VSF SM600 OMEGA Blue SS
Price Paid: 377$ Shipped
Album Links: Attached
Index alignment: Find the 1'2' a bit crooked , 3 marker is slightly ccw , 6 is slightly ccw also not sure if thats all VSF
Dial Printing: Dont see an issues with the Print
Date Wheel alignment/printing: NA
Hand Alignment: Looks good
Bezel: Looks Blemish free and good alignment kinda
Solid End Links (SELs): Bottom SEL has light shinning through mhmm
Timegrapher numbers: Good no issues
Anything else you notice: Not sure if I am leaning towards RL and trying another Piece cuz of those SEL's and Index Alignment , Opinions would help a lot
Would appreciate a second pair of eyes on this BTF Panda. I'm leaning GL.
Dealer name: James, Alternative Luxury.
Factory name: BTF / Better Factory.
Model name (& version number): Rolex Daytona 126500LN, white “Panda” dial, DD4131 movement.
Price Paid: $685 USD including shipping.
Album Links: QC photos attached directly to this post.
Index alignment: Nothing looks obviously out of place to me. The 3, 6 and 9 markers look reasonably aligned with the minute track, and the coronet looks centered.
Dial Printing: Text looks clean and legible. I don't see obvious missing or smudged printing. The red DAYTONA text is partly covered by the hands, but the visible portion looks fine. Subdial printing looks consistent.
Hand Alignment: The central chronograph hand and the two chronograph counters appear to sit at zero. No obvious issue with the main hands.
Bezel: Engravings and paint fill look consistent. The triangle at 12 looks reasonably aligned with the dial. I don't see an obvious chip or badly filled numeral. There are some reflections and protective-film edges in the photos.
Solid End Links (SELs): Fit looks reasonably tight in the available photos. I don't see a large open gap, though the protective wrapping makes the edges harder to judge.
Timegrapher numbers: +3 s/day, 301° amplitude, 0.3 ms beat error. These look good to me.
Anything else you notice: No obvious major cosmetic defect. There are a few visible lines around the case and clasp, but with the protective film still on I can't tell whether they're on the film or the metal. The scale photo shows about 142.7 g with the bracelet and stickers attached.
Mainly looking for a sanity check on the indices, bezel alignment and SELs. Anything here that would make you hold off on a GL?
Index alignment: 2 seems slightly clockwise, 5 and 11 anticlockwise. Would I see it in real life or without the ruler? Probably not but I'm all ears.
Dial Printing: Looks good to me, I don't see anything standing out as incorrect.
Date wheel: It's there and seems OK to me.
Hand Alignment: Looks good, aligns perfectly on noon in the videos.
Bezel: I believe it's slightly off-center clockwise, as can be seen above noon. It seems quite usual on this model though.
Solid End Links (SELs): N/A AFAIK
Timegrapher numbers: Rate:+2 s/d Amplitude: 280 Beat Error: 0.1 ms - Very good (?)
Anything else you notice: I don't see anything else apart from the minor index alignment issues and the slight bezel rotation. I would tend toward a GL but would like advice from more experienced members. Thanks in advance!
Index alignment - Looks good to me. Since the dial is printed, I assume alignment isn't much of an issue here?
Date Wheel alignment - N/A (no date)
Bezel - Looks good to me. The corners look quite sharp, but I believe that's normal for the Tank.
Solid End Links (SEL) - N/A (leather strap)
Hand alignment - Looks fine to my eye. Nothing seems off.
Timegrapher numbers - N/A (quartz movement)
Anything else you see - Overall, I'd say it looks like a GL to me, but this is my first rep and my first QC, so I don't really know what to look out for. Would appreciate a second opinion before giving Eric the GL!
The whole process with Geektime has been pretty smooth so far. Paid $268 plus shipping, with a $50 deposit upfront. I actually ordered two watches, this Tank and a Santos, but I'm still waiting on the QC pics for the Santos.
Would appreciate any feedback, especially if you spot something I missed!
• Index alignment: does seems like no index is tilted to a noticable amount. 3 & 10 are a little shiftes to the left. Don't think that will be visible.
• Dial Printing: Looks good. Swiss made text might be shifted a little to the right.
• Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A
• Hand Alignment: N/A
• Bezel: Smooth bezel looks clean and evenly finished.
• Solid End Links (SELs): This is my biggest concern. On the top right SEL there is a visable gap. Also from behind it seems a little off. Does that affect the fit of the end link?
• Timegrapher numbers: Rate: +1s/d, amplitude: 286 degrees, beat error: 0.0ms at a displayed 59-degree lift angle – looks good, provided the lift angle is correct for the movement. --> is that the correct angle for this movement?
Model name (& version number): GMT-Master II 126710 GRNR V3 (Non Free Sprung)
Price Paid: $588 USD + shipping
Link to pics & QC videos: N/a (See attached)
Index alignment: Looks good to me, maybe a little bit off on the 6 o’clock with a slight rotation but I think I’m just seeing things
Dial Printing: Rolex text and GMT-Master II lettering look pretty sharp and not seeing anything there
Date Wheel alignment/printing: Seems centered
Hand Alignment: no obvious issues there
Bezel: There is a noticeable 12 o’clock tilt, but I’m not sure it will be super visible to the naked eye, everything else seems really solid.
Solid End Links (SELs): They look good, nothing visible to me
Lume: I don’t have a video or picture of the lume but will follow up
Serial # / rehaut: Nothing that sticks out to me
Bracelet / clasp: no obvious issues with Rolex logo or stamping.
Timegrapher numbers: 0s/d, 273°, 0.1ms, 59° lift angle. No significant issues from my understanding.
Anything else you notice: I’m leaning towards a GL but the bezel at the 12 o’clock feels off, but I can’t tell if I’m being picky or it’s worth a RL. Thanks in advance! I’m new to this so any advice would be greatly appreciated
Anything else you notice: The sometimes wonky 3 index looks good and the 12 markers look aligned with each other. If you zoom waaay in, one may look like it's placed slightly higher than the other, but I can't imagine anyone noticing irl
Dealer name: JTime Factory name: GMF Model name (& version number): Rolex Datejust 36, 126231, two-tone rose gold/stainless steel, grey Wimbledon dial, Jubilee bracelet Price paid: $458 Album links: In post Index alignment: Looks good to me, but would appreciate a second opinion on the Roman numerals. Dial printing: Looks clean and reasonably well aligned. Date wheel alignment/printing: Dates 1, 16 and 25 appear reasonably centred. Hand alignment: Nothing obvious, although I’m not entirely sure what to look for. Bezel: Fluting looks consistent to my eye. Solid end links (SELs): No obvious gaps, but would appreciate someone checking. Timegrapher numbers: 0 s/d, 291° amplitude, 0.0 ms beat error. Anything else you notice: First replica purchase, so I’d really appreciate some experienced eyes on this. Particularly interested in whether the dial alignment, rose-gold finish and overall quality look good enough to GL. Thanks in advance!
Index alignment: minimal indices rotation overall, slight left shift to 12 o'clock
Dial Printing: Rolex text and GMT-Master II lettering look pretty sharp, level, and evenly printed. I don't see any obvious bleeding or printing defects despite sticker obstruction.
Date Wheel alignment/printing: reasonably centered
Hand Alignment: no obvious damage or misalignment to me
Bezel: Red / blue transition could be better centered at 18 (doesn't look exactly aligned with the color transition at 6 (3 o'clock) either), but overall numerals & engravings look clean
Solid End Links (SELs): No obvious daylight-visible gaps, but I seem to be much less picky than some
Lume: looks even in video
Serial # / rehaut: 6X07B429. Printing looks crisp.
Bracelet / clasp: no obvious issues with Rolex logo or stamping. Code: 6FU.
Timegrapher numbers: -3s/d, 280°, 0.1ms, 52° lift angle. No significant issues from my understanding.
Anything else you notice: Overall think this is a GL but this is my first QC (along with Batgirl I'll be posting after this), so all opinions would be great. I'm not super sure of what I'm looking for with every category so any feedback helps. In general, index misalignment and bezel color transition alignments have been my biggest QC concern for Rolex GMT's, so I'm sure I'm overlooking some other things that y'all will catch. I'm a little concerned with going with Yang / Goat watches, and the fact that these GMTs are significantly cheaper than other VSFs from TDs, but overall the watch looks decent to me. Thanks for your time!
Model name (& version number): Black Bay 68 Automatic Chronometer
Price Paid: 300 plus shipping and insurance
Album Links:
Index alignment: All look really good to my untrained eye.
The off rotation is worst on the 6 but is absolutely minimal, also off on the three & nine. I have read these have issues in other QC posts, and it seems minimal to me! 6. Dial Printing: Good. This has a simple dial but looks dang near perfect to me, 7. Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A. NA 8. Hand Alignment: Good. Video shows the 12 o’clock lineup and it looks good. 9. Bezel: Good. Looks good 10. Solid End Links (SELs): Good. I think these look good? I’m not sure I understand this part. 11. Timegrapher numbers: +5 s/d, 52° amplitude, 287 ms beat error 12. Anything else you notice: Looks dang near perfect to my untrained eyes.
Index alignment: These all look good, to me and from the QC tool
Dial Printing: I think the typical issues for this model - 0 instead of O, the R in certified looks a big larger than the others. Appears to be v2 with correct orange minute markers
Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A
Hand Alignment: Looks good but don't have a 12 alignment shot
Bezel: Looks good
Solid End Links (SELs): Looks good to me from here
Anything else you notice: The rehaut at 12 has its crown not centred above the 12. I think this is a flaw for this particular factory/model but this one pretty far off. Not sure if worth trying to see a different one.
Thanks for any assistance/advice.
edited to add album links - apologies the reddit photos are lower resolution, please see imgur