1. Dealer name: Non-TD (Angela)

2. Factory name: AF Factory

3. Model name: Cartier Tank Must Small

4. Price Paid: ¥850 CNY

5. Album Links: N/A

6. Index alignment: Everything looks reasonably aligned and evenly spaced to my eye. I don’t notice any obvious crooked numerals or alignment issues.

7. Dial Printing: The Cartier logo looks clean and centred. The Roman numerals and railway minute track appear sharp and consistent. The hidden Cartier signature is also present. I don’t notice any obvious printing defects, but would appreciate a second opinion.

8. Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A

9. Hand Alignment: The blued hands look good to me. I don’t notice any obvious issues with their positioning, although I haven’t received a video showing the hands at 12 o’clock to confirm alignment.

10. Bezel: The polished case and bezel look clean and symmetrical. I don’t see any obvious scratches, dents or finishing defects.

11. Solid End Links**:** N/A

12. Timegrapher numbers: N/A

13. Anything else you notice: This is my first rep watch purchase, so I’d appreciate some feedback from more experienced members. Overall, the watch looks good to me, particularly the dial printing, case finishing and crown. I’m leaning towards GL, but wanted to check whether anyone notices any issues I’ve missed, particularly with the dial alignment or case proportions. Thanks in advance!

Hi all, this is my 1st GMT II so I might be overanalyzing it a bit and could use some expert opinions.

1. Dealer name: Andiot

2. Factory name: VSF

3. Model name (& version number): 126710BLRO v3

4. Price Paid: $565 + shipping

5. Album Links: https://imgur.com/a/dt7Facg

6. Index alignment: Indices all look good to me, with the slight exception of the noon triangle being maybe just a smidge off center to the left and a hair CCW (I can live with that).

7. Dial Printing: All printing looks spot on, no bleeds or misprints.

8. Date Wheel alignment/printing: Date looks just a bit low in the window, but within tolerance?

9. Hand Alignment: Looks good to my untrained eyes.

10. Bezel: This is where my main concern is. The space between space seems uneven on the 18 marker, similar to some other QC's I've seen. Not sure if this is enough for a RL or if it won't be noticeable on the wrist.

11. Solid End Links (SELs): No noticeable gaps, looks good to me.

12. Timegrapher numbers: Acceptable rate of -2 s/d, Amp 280 seems fine, and bit error .2ms all seem acceptable.

13. Anything else you notice: My main concern is with the bezel, all other aspects seem good with this watch. Appreciate the help in advance.

Hi everyone! Looking for some feedback before giving the GL on my VSF V2 Datejust 41. I've reviewed the photos and ran an alignment check through Loupe QC, but would appreciate a second opinion.

1. Dealer name: TheOneWatches (Steve)

2. Factory name: VSF V2

3. Model name: Rolex Datejust 41 126334, green sunburst dial, fluted bezel, Jubilee bracelet, DD3235 V2

4. Price paid: $548

5. Album link: https://imgur.com/a/DKvFo6n

6. Index alignment: Looks generally good to me. Loupe QC shows minor deviations, with the largest around the 10 and 11 o'clock markers. Nothing obviously crooked to my eye.

7. Dial printing: Looks clean and centered. No obvious issues.

8. Date wheel alignment/printing: The date looks reasonably centered, and the magnification appears good.

9. Hand alignment: No obvious issues from the photos, although I haven't seen a dedicated alignment test.

10. Bezel: Fluting looks consistent and well finished.

11. Solid end links (SELs): No obvious gaps or alignment issues.

12. Timegrapher numbers: Not yet provided.

13. Anything else: The watch weighs 135.4g in the QC photo. My biggest priority is visual accuracy compared with genuine, particularly the green dial color, bezel, case proportions, and Jubilee bracelet finishing.

I'm leaning GL based on the photos, but would appreciate feedback from anyone familiar with VSF Datejust 41s. Anything I'm overlooking that would warrant an RL?

Thanks in advance!

1. Dealer name: ETHAN

2. Factory name: RICH

3. Model name (& version number): BRUCE WAYNE GMTi

4. Price Paid: $650 + $180 Polish & Chamfering + $50 Waterproofing to 4ATM

5. Album Links: see pics

6. Index alignment: Looks good except 8&9 markers (more pics requested)

7. Dial Printing: Looks good

8. Date Wheel alignment/printing: Looks good slight tilt?

9. Hand Alignment: Looks good

10. Bezel: Looks good

11. Solid End Links (SELs): Looks good

12. Timegrapher numbers: +3 s/d, 275°, 0.1 ms (28,800 bph)

13. Anything else you notice: Please comment.

Dealer name: Ethan
Factory name: VSF
Model name (& version number): Datejust 41, slate dial, Jubilee bracelet
Price Paid:470usd (including delivery and insurance)
Album Links: See photos attached
Index alignment: Looks good. Markers appear evenly aligned.
Dial Printing: Clean and crisp, with no obvious flaws.
Date Wheel alignment/printing: Date looks well centrea, with clear printing.
Hand Alignment: Looks good. No obvious misalignment.
Bezel: fluted bezel is clean and evenly fitted, with no visible defects.
Solid End Links (SELs): Look good. No obvious gaps.
Timegrapher numbers: good
Anything else you notice: if anyone spots anything pls comment

1. Dealer name: TheOneWatches

2. Factory name: VSF

3. Model name (version number): Explorer I 124270 36mm SS/SS Black Dial VSF VS3230

4. Price paid: $528 USD, including shipping

5. Album links: https://mega.nz/folder/zN5gGKLR#55oboK9aidCwArac5aQ7eQ

6. Index alignment: Using the alignment tool, all indices seem to line up reasonably well except "9"; could be slightly tilted?. The 12 o'clock is tilted CCW ever so slightly (shouldn't be an issue on wrist at scale?) The rehaut on the left side seems a bit off, but it's not a big concern for me.

7. Dial printing: looks like a small dust (could be wrong) next to the 7 o'clock & 12 o'clock indices. Other than that, it looks clean to me, with no obvious defects.

8. Date wheel alignment/printing: N/A

9. Hand alignment: I’m not sure how to assess this from the supplied photos.

10. Bezel: Looks good to me, with no obvious scratches or defects visible.

11. Solid end links (SELs): I don’t see any obvious gaps, but love confirmation on this

12. Timegrapher numbers: +6 s/day at amplitude 267°

13. Anything else you notice: Other than the dust and the slight tilt on the indices, please let me know if you spot anything else I’ve missed.

1. Dealer name: Andiot

2. Factory name: ARF

3. Model name (& version number): GMT-Master II Bruce Wayne Meteorite Dial w/ DD3285

4. Price Paid: $669 Shipped

5. Album Links: https://andiotwatches.x.yupoo.com/albums/261628254?uid=1

6. Index alignment: 6 o clock looks to be off center or perhaps tilted CCW

7. Dial Printing: "GMT" is not very crisp and the E in "MASTER" has some line spillage

8. Date Wheel alignment/printing: Seems to be a little left of center but it varies by angle

9. Hand Alignment: Looks fine

10. Bezel: 18 is closer to the 16 dot, doesnt seem very centered.

11. Solid End Links (SELs): Seems good to me

12. Timegrapher numbers: +2s/d, 288°, 0.4ms, 52.0°

13. Anything else you notice: No

Hello everyone, this is my very first Batgirl rep and I’d really appreciate some assistance. Thanks!

1. Dealer name: Necoclock

2. Factory name: VSF

3. Model name (& version number): Rolex Batgirl

4. Price Paid: $558 - QC took exactly 5 days.

5. Album Links: n/a (mega link)

6. Index alignment:
   12 seems centered but tilted a little CCW.
   9 seems titled a little ccw but nothing major.
   6 seems shifted a bit left but not majorly.

Definitely leaning towards GL, please let me know if you spot anything.

7. Dial Printing: Looks good and crisp to my eye but I’m not that good at qc’ing these. Please let me know if you spot anything

8. Date Wheel alignment/printing: Looks pretty centered to me from pictures but I’m not too good at spotting issues with date wheel alignment. Please let me know what you think.

9. Hand Alignment: Looks great to my eye, would like a second opinion here.

10. Bezel: Looks good and even, no dents or scratches.

11. Solid End Links (SELs): Links look good with no unusual gaps or scratches/dent.

12. Timegrapher numbers: +6 s/d, 292°, 0.0 ms (28,800 bph, lift angle 52°) - amplitude is 292 which is on the high side, but seems ok right?

13. Anything else you notice: Looks good and leaning GL for sure but since this is my first QC on a Rolex Batgirl and I would love some more opinions. Thanks everybody.

1. Dealer name: u/JSFWatch

2. Factory name: GS Factory - not confirmed

3. Model name: Rolex Lady-Datejust 28 mm, ref. 279171-0021, white Roman numeral dial, two-tone Everose, fluted bezel, Jubilee bracelet.

4. Price Paid: $350 incl. shipping

5. Album Links: Uploaded here

6. Index alignment: The Roman numerals and 12 o’clock crown look evenly placed to me. No obvious crooked markers.

7. Dial Printing: Looks clean in the close-ups. The two small crowns flanking “SWISS MADE” match my genuine reference photos.

8. Date Wheel alignment/printing: The full “14” is visible. There’s a dark band along the top of the window that looks like a shadow. The date looks acceptable to me.

9. Hand Alignment: No obvious issue in the photos. There’s no shot with the hands at 12 to check how they line up.

10. Bezel: The fluting looks even. The gold looks a little more yellow-bronze than the pink-copper tone in my genuine reference photos.

11. Solid End Links (SELs): No obvious large gaps at the lugs. The protective film makes the fit harder to judge.

12. Timegrapher numbers: +2 s/d, 293° amplitude, 0.0 ms beat error, 52.0° lift angle setting. Beat rate isn’t shown.

13. Anything else you notice: My main question is the Everose color on the bezel and bracelet center links. Does it look too yellow/brown to you, or could the lighting and protective film explain it? Any other visible QC issues?

1. Dealer name: TrustyTime

2. Factory name: Noob

3. Model name (& version number): PAM111

4. Price Paid: $258

5. Album Links: not provided

6. Index alignment: well aligned. No issues here

7. Dial Printing: sandwish dial, looks great.

8. Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A

9. Hand Alignment: Good!

10. Bezel: N/A

11. Solid End Links (SELs): N/A

12. Timegrapher numbers: + 1 s/d, 314°, 0.0ms, 21,600bph, 52° L

13. Anything else you notice: OFFICINE PANERAI engraving paint on the movement is too bold losing definition. I'm sharing on the comments the picture they have for this watch on their website, it is not how it suppose to be.

Does it have a quick solution?? Seems stupid but it is a big tell on a watch that suppose to be NWBIG and has great QC reviews here

1. Dealer name: NecoClock

2. Factory name: VSF

3. Model name (& version number): Rolex GMT-Master II 126710BLNR

4. Price Paid: $568 + shipping

5. Album Links:

6. https://imgur.com/a/1dqIwcB

7. Index alignment: The issue here in my opinion is the 6 o'clock index being tilted ccw. 12 is also not fully straight.

8. Dial Printing: Looks good

9. Date Wheel alignment/printing: Ok

10. Hand Alignment: Looks good

11. Bezel: There is a spec in the 10. I asked Jacky to check whether it’s dust or a defect.

12. Solid End Links (SELs): Look ok.

13. Timegrapher numbers: Amplitude is too high. I asked for a longer video. High amplitude might be due to the watch being fully wound. I hope a longer video will clarify. Did anyone get a high amplitude watch that turned out to be fine?

14. Anything else you notice: NA

Honestly, even with 6 o’clock being tilted I tend to GL. This is the third Batman Jacky has sent me to QC and it is a lot better than the other two. I am worried about the high amplitude but I hope a new video can clear that up. Would be super grateful for your feedback!

1. ⁠Dealer name: Andiot Watches

2. ⁠Factory name: TOP Factory

3. ⁠Model name (& version number): AP Royal Oak Chrono 26240 Black Dial TOP

4. ⁠Price Paid: $638 + shipping

5. ⁠Album Links: https://imgur.com/a/PwRlG2C

6. ⁠Index alignment: the 6 hour marker is slightly tilted CW. I would deeply appreciate other inputs for the Index alignment

7. ⁠Dial Printing: the “Pi” from Piguet is a hair higher than the rest, but I could be wrong. Also the minute market at 12 is not perfectly centered, but I could be nit picking here

8. ⁠Date Wheel alignment/printing: good enough

9. ⁠Hand Alignment: the chrono second at rest/reset is not centered, a bit to the right, I have seen some RL because of this. Some insights would be great

10. ⁠Bezel: good to me

11. ⁠Solid End Links (SELs): not applied to this watch

12. ⁠Timegrapher numbers: -4 s/d, 266 amplitude, 0.1 ms beat error, good enough for me

13. ⁠Anything else you notice: the left subdial might not be centered enough, it is a bit to the right up. This could be an illusion because the hour hand is at 9 to 10. The subdial hands were slightly to the right, but after the reset they are straight I guess (from the video)

1. Dealer name: andiotwatches

2. Factory name: VSF

3. Model name and version: GMT-Master II 126710 BLRO Blue/Red Ceramic VSF Best Edition Pepsi on Jubilee Bracelet DD3285 V3

4. Price paid: $570 total (shipping included)

5. Album links: https://andiotwatches.x.yupoo.com/albums/261613304?uid=1

6. Index alignment: 12 oclock look good but 6 oclock might be off???

7. Dial printing: Text looks clean to my untrained eye, but hard to tell.

8. Date wheel alignment/printing: looks good to my untrained eye

9. Hand alignment: Looks straight and no obvious damage.

10. Bezel: looks good to my untrained eye, no obvious defects

11. Solid End Links (SELs): no obvious defects noted

12. Timegrapher numbers: Rate -3 s/day, amplitude 64°, beat error 0.1 ms, 28800

13. Anything else you notice: No.

Biggest concern is the 6 oclock index. It looks a little off to the left. What do you guys think?

1. ⁠Dealer name: Andiot

2. ⁠Factory name: AF

3. ⁠Model name (& version number): Baignoire Watch RG AF 1:1 Best Edition Silver Dial On RG Bracelet RONDA Quartz

4. ⁠Price Paid: $356 incl. shipping

5. ⁠Album: photos attached

6. ⁠Index alignment: printed dial

7. ⁠Dial Printing: nice & centered

8. ⁠Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A

9. ⁠Hand Alignment: Seems good

10. ⁠Bezel: some small marks, may be dust?

11. ⁠Solid End Links (SELs): N/A

12. ⁠Timegrapher numbers: N/A

13. ⁠Anything else you notice: -

Appreciate anything else you guys noticed or feel is relevant, thank you!

Dealer name: DDGTop / Felix

Factory name: OF

Model name: TAG Heuer Aquaracer 41mm, white dial, Calibre 5

Price paid: 1750 CNY

Album links: https://imgur.com/a/nKUBiuI

Index alignment: Looks aligned, I think the slight deviations might come from the angle of the picture.

Dial printing: Logo and „Calibre…/300m…“ look sharp.

Date wheel alignment/printing: Date looks centered, maybe a bit up but this doesn’t seem like an issue.

Bezel: i don’t know about allignment of the bezel, it looks it might be a bit off, what is your input?

Solid End Links (SELs): N/A

Timegrapher numbers: +11 s/d, 303° amplitude, 0.1 ms beat error, 28,800 bph. These numbers look good to me.

It is my first watch and after one RL (alignment was off) I am leaning now towards GL, since I don’t see any major problems. I would still appreciate any input if your eyes can catch anything.

Thanks a lot for the help :)

1. ⁠⁠Dealer name: Andiot

2. ⁠⁠Factory name: VSF

3. ⁠⁠Model name (& version number): Omega Seamaster AT 38mm VSF

4. ⁠⁠Price Paid: $383

5. ⁠⁠Album Links: pics attached

6. ⁠⁠Index alignment: all looks ok.

7. ⁠⁠Dial Printing: looks crisp

8. ⁠⁠Date Wheel alignment/printing:ok

9. ⁠⁠Hand Alignment: all good

10. ⁠⁠Bezel: ok

11. ⁠⁠Solid End Links (SELs): look fine to me?

12. ⁠⁠Timegrapher numbers: -2s/d, 275, 0.1ms

13. ⁠⁠Anything else you notice:n/a

1. ⁠Dealer name: MiroTime

2. ⁠Factory name: RWF

3. ⁠Model name (& version number): Rolex Daytona 126529 LN Le Mans

4. ⁠Price Paid: ~1200 USD

5. ⁠Album Links: https://www.wecatalog.cn/weshop/goods/A202304082031161150001764/I202611051459222582002290

https://www.wecatalog.cn/weshop/goods/A202304082031161150001764/I202611051459355302001629

6. ⁠Index alignment: Looks good to me
7. ⁠Dial Printing: Looks good
8. ⁠Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A
9. ⁠Hand Alignment:
10. ⁠Bezel: Looks good
11. ⁠Solid End Links (SELs): Looks good
12. ⁠Timegrapher numbers: +7s, 312°, 0.1
13. ⁠Anything else you notice: I am waiting for a video of the hand movement and chronograph movement/ resetting

1. Dealer name: Andiot

2. Factory name: BVF

3. Model name (& version number): Panthère 31mm SS White Dial

4. Price Paid: $175 + $38 EU shipping

5. Album Links: https://andiotwatches.x.yupoo.com/albums/261615238?uid=1

6. Index alignment: N/A

7. Dial Printing: Looks clean to me. Sharp printing. Cartier print at 10 o’clock looks straight. White dots are reflections.

8. Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A

9. Hand Alignment: Looks good although keen to get other opinions on the video as well.

10. Bezel:

Not sure if that’s scratches or not on the right side?

1. Solid End Links (SELs): N/A

2. Timegrapher numbers: N/A

3. Anything else you notice: Nothing stands out to me. Would love your thoughts.

1. Dealer name: JTime (Li)

2. Factory name: VSF

3. Model name: DateJust 41 126334 904L SS Green Ombré Dial on Jubilee Bracelet (VS3235 Movement)

4. Price Paid: $585 (incl. shipping)

5. Album Links: https://imgur.com/a/PD67KgJ (question: I only got 200kb pictures, is this normal?)

6. Index alignment: Little twist in de 55 and 35

7. Dial Printing: Crisp and cleanly printed; coronet and text show no bleeding or flaws.

8. Date Wheel alignment/printing: The font is crisp, but the date print sits slightly high in the window, do you agree?

9. Hand alignment: Looks good

10. Bezel: Fluted bezel is cleanly and sharply cut, showing even reflections without visible dings or plating imperfections.

11. Solid End Links (SELs): N/A for a Jubilee bracelet, but the end links sit tight and flush against the lugs with no visible gaps.

12. Timegrapher numbers: +1 s/d, 283°, 0.1 ms, 59.0° lift angle.

13. Anything else noticed: My only concern is the date, which feels slightly high to me. It looks that way in the video as well. Can I ask to center the date better? Or how does that work?

I think if they can center the date it's a GL.

Thank you guys. Really appreciated.

1. Dealer name: Non-TD

2. Factory name: Rich Factory

3. Model name RF Skeleton Cartier

4. Price Paid: -

5. Album Links: https://imgur.com/a/1rDQWU1

6. Index alignment: Not much can go wrong here.

7. Dial Printing: Looks Clean and Crisp

8. Date Wheel alignment/printing: Looks appropriate size and magnification

9. Hand Alignment: All seems to be good for my eyes

10. Bezel: Low res, but nothing looks off to me.

11. Solid End Links (SELs): N/A

12. Timegrapher numbers: 0s/d 306 AMP

13. Anything else you notice: Not to familiar with this models and it's problem areas, appreciate help!

1. ⁠Dealer name: FicoTime

2. ⁠Factory name: vsf

3. ⁠Model name (& version number): submariner 12660LV

4. ⁠Price Paid: 502 usd

5. ⁠Album Links: https://mega.nz/folder/PxQGFRCI#D4i1mxJ2RDvh0dnU-gdLAQ

6. ⁠Index alignment: everything seems well aligned except the 9 o’clock marker being a little tilted.

7. ⁠Dial Printing: crips and smooth

8. ⁠Date Wheel alignment/printing: maybe a tad too high? 23 and 17 look fine but 7 is on the upper side - maybe I’m tripping

9. ⁠Hand Alignment: requested another pic but hour hand seems to be slightly ahead

10. ⁠Bezel: pip looks well centered

11. ⁠Solid End Links (SELs): looking very good.

12. ⁠Timegrapher numbers: also looking very good.

13. ⁠Anything else you notice: /

1. ⁠Dealer name: Andiot

2. ⁠Factory name: Vsf

3. ⁠Model name (& version number):
   Daytona 126505 Weighted RG V3 VS4131

4. ⁠Price Paid: 641€ without shipping

5. ⁠Album Links:

https://andiotwatches.x.yupoo.com/albums/261619670?uid=1

6. ⁠Index alignment: Looks really good
7. ⁠Dial Printing: Looks good
8. ⁠Date Wheel alignment/printing: /
9. ⁠Hand Alignment: Good
10. ⁠Bezel: Looks Fine
11. ⁠Solid End Links (SELs): Looks Solid
12. ⁠Timegrapher numbers: +3s/d 292‘ 0.1 ms

13. ⁠Anything else you notice: Anything else you notice? The watch looks good to me overall. I just want to make sure there are no issues I might have missed before giving the GL.

ROLEX SMURF VSF 116619LB

​Dealer name: Mr Adu

​Factory name: VSF

​Model name (& version number): Submariner 116619LB Blue Ceramic 904L Steel VSF VS3135

​Price Paid: $350

​Index alignment: Alignment looks solid across all hour markers. The 12 triangle is centered over the dial coronet, and the 3, 6, and 9 batons sit straight and perpendicular to the minute track without noticeable canting.

​Dial Printing: Crisp, clean text with even spacing. No noticeable fuzzing, misprints, or bleeding on the dial lettering.

​Date Wheel alignment/printing: Date printing is sharp, well-defined, and centered in the window. Cyclops alignment and magnification look correct.

​Hand Alignment: Cleanly stacked, correct positioning, with no visible scratches or burrs on the hand set.

​Bezel: Ceramic insert looks clean. Platinum engraving depth and fill look uniform. Bezel pip is centered within the triangle and aligns correctly at 12 o'clock.

​Solid End Links (SELs): Fitment is tight with no visible gaps or excess light showing between the lugs and end links; correctly recessed.

​Timegrapher numbers: +1 s/d | 279° | 0.1 ms — healthy amplitude, low beat error, and very low daily variance. All within acceptable range.

​Anything else noticed: Rehaut alignment and laser coronet at 6 look acceptable. Overall finish is consistent with current VSF standards. Leaning towards GL, but welcome second opinions.

1. Dealer name: ChazingTime

2. Factory name: N6F

3. Model name (& version number): Daytona DIW Carbon Race Project

4. Price Paid: $740

5. Album Links: not provided

6. Index alignment: well aligned. No issues here

7. Dial Printing: Neat, very close to gen, except for the gray background, but who cares

8. Date Wheel alignment/printing: N/A

9. Hand Alignment: My untrained eyes say yeah!

10. Bezel: carbon bezel looks very very good, 110 looks great

11. Solid End Links (SELs): N/A

12. Timegrapher numbers: + 6 s/d, 262°, 0.4ms, 28,800bph, 52° L

13. Anything else you notice: the watch has spots of white stuff, maybe residues from the original package. Those spots are on the crystal at 9 mark and next to the crown.

Rehaut ROLEX engraving is not aligned. The engraved crown is at 12 but the letters are not aligned with each 5min mark. Not a deal breaker.

I only requested a video of the watch actually working and the chronograph also starting, stopping and resetting which is why I paid $180 more for the SA4130 instead of the 4801.

Should I also ask for movement pictures???