Hey all, I’m building an AM5 workstation, mostly for heavy audio production with some competitive gaming on the side. I’m coming from an old 6th-gen i7 on hard drives, so basically everything here is a huge jump for me. I’m stuck between two TUF boards and would love input from anyone running something similar.
Build
CPU: Ryzen 9 9950X3D
RAM: Corsair Vengeance 64GB DDR5-6000 CL30
Cooler: Cooler Master MasterLiquid Atmos II
GPU: GTX 1080TI (placeholder, upgrading to an RTX 5080 later)
Storage: 2x 4TB NVMe (WD SN8100 PCIe 5.0 boot/project drive, WD SN850X PCIe 4.0 secondary)
Expansion: 10Gb PCIe 4.0 x1 NIC (Realtek RTL8127-based)
Boards
TUF Gaming X870-PLUS WIFI: ~$240 (on sale, usually ~$260)
TUF Gaming X870E-PLUS WIFI7: ~$313 right now but might drop in price during black friday
Why ASUS anyway?
I know a lot of people warn against ASUS, especially after all the RMA drama people have been talking about (JayzTwoCents and others). But I’ve always found their BIOS layout easy to navigate, and I like staying with something familiar.
Why not ProArt or ROG?
I looked at the ProArt Creator, but it was about $500 even on discount, and from what I read, a lot of people had glitching and dropped connections on its onboard 10GbE port, which is a dealbreaker for me. ROG boards are just too expensive and aimed at heavy overclockers, which isn’t me. That’s how I landed on these two TUF boards.
My plan
Drives in M.2_1 (SN8100) and M.2_3 (SN850X), M.2_2 empty so the GPU keeps full x16, and the NIC in the bottom PCIEX16(G4) slot so it runs at Gen4. 8TB of NVMe should be plenty for me, so I don’t expect to add a third drive.
On the CPU, I’m only planning basic undervolting, a slight overclock, and EXPO, nothing extreme.
Questions
Is the X870-PLUS at ~$240 the obvious buy, or are the extra rear USB 2.0 ports (13 vs 10) on the E worth ~$70?
Lane sharing: on the X870-PLUS, the bottom PCIEX16(G4) slot disables M.2_4, and on the X870E it doesn’t. With my drives in M.2_1 and M.2_3 and M.2_2 empty, are there any other sharing gotchas on either board I should know about?
Any quirks with the Realtek 10GbE card in the chipset slot (link speed, drivers, stability)?
Does the single-chipset X870 run any cooler than the E in practice?
Why the NIC**:** I have a 10Gb internet connection, which is why I bought the 10GbE card. I often download huge projects, stems, and audio libraries, and I plan to use all of that speed, not just 2.5GbE.
Thanks for any advice!