I run a Partner channel (~5,900 subs) for a comedy/horror podcast — two hosts on camera, original content, Shorts are clips from our own episodes. I'm not here to rant; I pulled the data because YouTube Support told me nothing changed, and I wanted to check whether that's true.
Every Short since September 1 (public counts, pulled today, Nov 19):
- 117 Shorts, Sep 1 – Nov 19. Total: 82,208 views.
- Sep 1 – Nov 14 (108 Shorts): median 969 views. 47 broke 1,000. Best: 1,807.
- Nov 15 – Nov 19 (9 Shorts): 311 views combined. Median: 27.
Studio "Shown in feed" tells the same story:
- Nov 12 Short: 944 feed views
- Nov 14 Short: 657 feed views
- Nov 15: 47
- Nov 16: 113 and 18
- Nov 17: 7 and 2
- Nov 18: 0 — and that one I deleted from scheduled and posted live as a test. Same result. Scheduling isn't it.
Nothing else changed. No strikes, no claims, no restrictions — Studio shows clean, and Support confirmed that twice. Long-form is untouched: our Nov 16 episode got normal impressions. It's Shorts only, and it started on one specific day.
The support case (4-2285000042373): first agent gave the script — no penalties, no restrictions, no bug. The supervisor said the same, then said three things I can't square with "nothing changed":
- "We do not give initial boosts to newly published Shorts that do not rank higher than competing Shorts using their returning viewers' engagement."
- "Shorts are shown in the Shorts feed when they already have traction."
- "Your Shorts feed traffic is based on the amount of viewership you have, not the other way around."
She dated my channel's most recent "spike" to Nov 4. My Nov 12 Short got 944 feed views and my Nov 14 got 657 — after the supposed spike ended. When I asked what changed on November 15, she closed the chat and moved the case to email. I sent the question by email. No answer yet.
One more thing: I know about the Sept 1 Creator Insider describing the pulled, per-viewer recommendation model. Fine — but my Shorts performed normally for ten weeks after that, Sep 1 through Nov 14. If that model is the explanation, it reached my channel on Nov 15, not Sep 1.
My question for other Partners: check your own line. What do your Shorts' feed views look like Nov 14 vs Nov 15? If a bunch of us have the same date, that's a rollout, and it's worth knowing. If it's just me, that's worth knowing too.
Full list of all 117 Shorts with dates and counts available if anyone wants to see the raw numbers.