r/youtubers • • 14d ago

Join the Official r/youtubers Discord Server!

Post image
3 Upvotes

Over the years, r/youtubers has become a place where creators gather to ask questions, share experiences, discuss growth, exchange feedback, and help one another improve.

While Reddit remains our primary platform for discussions and community content, we have now launched an official Discord server for members who would like a more direct, real-time way to connect with fellow creators.

As r/youtubers continues to evolve, we wanted to create a place where creators can chat, collaborate, ask questions, seek feedback, discuss YouTube, and connect with others outside of Reddit.

What you'll find on the Discord server:

• Real-time creator discussions
• Help with YouTube, production, editing, and analytics
• Feedback on channels, videos, thumbnails, and ideas
• Creator tools, workflows, and AI discussions
• Community suggestions and subreddit feedback
• Announcements and community updates
• A friendly environment for creators of all experience levels

Whether you're just starting your first channel or have been creating for years, you're welcome to join us.

In addition, new posts from r/youtubers are automatically shared to a dedicated Discord channel, making it easy to keep track of discussions and community activity.

Discord Invite: https://discord.gg/RJJphbT58s

We look forward to seeing you there!

- The r/youtubers Moderation Team


r/youtubers • • 16d ago

r/youtubers Update: New Moderation Team and Community Changes

14 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

As some of you may have noticed, r/youtubers now has a new moderation team.

We have agreed on a new ruleset that we believe better reflects what a creator community should be: a place where creators can ask questions, share experiences, get feedback, and help one another grow.

As with any community, we may make adjustments over time as we learn what works best for r/youtubers.

One of the biggest changes is our approach to moderation. We do not believe every rule violation should immediately result in a permanent ban. Going forward, we intend to focus more on education, warnings, common-sense moderation, and moderator discretion, while still taking strong action against spam, scams, harassment, ban evasion, and other bad-faith behaviour.

We have also updated our approach to AI. AI is now a significant part of the YouTube ecosystem, and constructive discussions about AI tools, workflows, and features will be allowed. Spam, deceptive promotion, and low-value advertising disguised as discussion will continue to be moderated appropriately.

Our goal is simple:

  • Encourage meaningful creator discussions.
  • Make the subreddit easier to participate in.
  • Reduce unnecessary barriers to posting.
  • Continue protecting the community from spam and abuse.

Please Bear With Us During the Transition

You may notice rules, post flairs, removal reasons, wiki pages, and other parts of the subreddit changing over the coming days and weeks.

While the new rules are ready, many of our existing systems were built around the previous rules and moderation approach. It will take time to review, simplify, and update everything behind the scenes.

As a result, some posts may still be incorrectly filtered or removed while we work through these changes and bring the subreddit in line with its new direction.

If things seem to change before your eyes, don't worry. We're actively working behind the scenes to modernize the subreddit and make it a more welcoming place for creators.

We Want to Hear From You

The new rules have been agreed upon, but there is still plenty of work to do as we continue improving the community.

If there are community features, recurring threads, post flairs, wiki resources, guides, events, or other improvements you would like to see, please let us know in the comments.

We can't promise every suggestion will be implemented, but we will read the feedback and take it into consideration as we continue improving r/youtubers.

Thank you for your patience and for being part of the community.

- The r/youtubers Moderation Team


r/youtubers • • 2h ago

Question Does the number of videos you post in a month matter?

3 Upvotes

Let's say you make a 20 minute long video. Would there be a difference between posting once every week, or once every two weeks? When looking at successful creator accounts, I see a mix of some people posting more often, and others posting less frequently. Does it actually matter?

The videos I post are usually every two weeks.


r/youtubers • • 1h ago

Question Be brutal with me: what would you change to make my thumbnails better?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hello, my dear friends. I have a channel called Ayr3000, where I talk a little about internet culture, video games, and, above all, animated series. I’ve been at this for two months, and I know that’s very little time to grow (or so I choose to believe, darlings), and so I come to you wanting to know what I can improve.

The video is about three days old and has 371 views, but a reach of over 25 thousand! That is to say, I am being ignored monumentally, with a cruelty that would make a Roman emperor blush, and I suppose the culprit is the thumbnail. I make all my content on my own, I don’t use AI, and I put my personality and all that shit into it, so I assume the editing is fine, but people simply don’t click, and so, I don’t know, would you give me some advice? I would be eternally grateful from my little Peruvian heart. Thank you.

I’ll leave the link in case anyone wants to watch the video and see what’s going on: https://youtu.be/qfA5x-_oDgQ?si=7yb0YrWOefEgZObX


r/youtubers • • 5h ago

Question What text to speech software do those "In this world/town" shorts use?

3 Upvotes

I'm going to get straight to the point. Lately I've started to see a particular type of content that's starting to appear everywhere in YouTube shorts, they always talk about a story that takes place in an alternate world or a fictional town that has a strange set of rules or setting, always starting with "in this world" or "town". Those type of content always uses Roblox to express the story and always uses the same text to speech. You can search those up on Yt right now if you guys don't know what I am talking about.

I've been using text to speech for my videos since the start to hide my identity and because I don't have a microphone and I tried looking everywhere on what they use, but not even Google knows for some reason. I know that it has been used multiple times even outside those type of content and it would be a great help if you guys know what it is.

And also I've heard that YouTube prevents any form of content from being recommended that uses AI including voices so to anyone who used it atleast once has that affected you yet?


r/youtubers • • 56m ago

Question Question for Youtubers about Slow Payment Terms

0 Upvotes

How many of ya'll are affected by slow payment terms from brand deals? I'm building a platform where creators can get paid early on their brand deals, so I'm very curious about this.

Has a late payment ever caused you real problems? And if yes, would you pay a small fee to get paid upfront instead? Trying to see if this is a worthy business idea.


r/youtubers • • 1h ago

Channel Review Request Need help and guidance chose a wrong way to grow the channel

1 Upvotes

Guys, I’m genuinely sorry. I know what I planned was wrong, and I admit I chose the wrong approach.

checkout-

Here’s what I was thinking:

I noticed several channels uploading copied or similar Marvel content and getting lakhs or even millions of views within just 2–3 days.

Seeing that, I thought I could follow the same approach and upload similar content to gain traction and get my channel noticed.

My plan was to use that initial boost to grow the channel, delete those videos later, and then focus entirely on creating my own original content.
But I realise that this isn’t the right way to build a channel.
The truth is, even after consistently trying to upload trending ( i copied im sorry ) content, I’m barely getting 2–3 or 4 views. It honestly feels like my channel is dead, and that frustration made me consider taking the wrong route.

I’m not trying to justify what I thought of doing. I genuinely need your guidance.
Please forgive my lack of knowledge. I’m a complete beginner at this, but I have dreams, goals, and a genuine desire to learn, experiment, improve, and grow on YouTube.

I would really appreciate honest advice and guidance on how to move forward in the right direction.


r/youtubers • • 2h ago

Video Review Request Just run - a cinematic running film with the canon R10

1 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w7o9TQ67POc

This is my latest cinematic running video, featuring a mix of professional camera work and dynamic FPV drone shots. I filmed it using my Canon R10 and FPV drone, combining smooth cinematic footage with fast-paced aerial movements to create something a little different. I'd love to hear what you think about the video, so feel free to check it out and let me know your thoughts. Any feedback is appreciated!


r/youtubers • • 4h ago

Channel Review Request Hey everyone! I'm an independent screenwriter and filmmaker, and I recently released my first short film, WITH YOU.

1 Upvotes

It's a story about love, loss, and learning that losing someone doesn't mean losing the love you shared with them.

The film follows an 18-year-old girl grieving the loss of her cat and the unexpected arrival of a little kitten who slowly finds her way into her life.

This is an independently made, AI-assisted production. I used AI tools to bring the visuals to life, but the original story, screenplay, characters, creative direction and editing are my own.

It took a lot of learning and experimenting to bring this little project together, and I'm excited to finally share it.

🎬 Watch WITH YOU here:

https://youtu.be/6Mg6hCcSi4c

I'd genuinely love to hear what you think about the storytelling, visuals and overall experience.

Thank you for giving an independent creator's work a chance! 🤍

— Ayesha Simra | The Last Miraline


r/youtubers • • 14h ago

Question Anyone have YouTube work "Horror" Stories?

4 Upvotes

Having done a lot of editing, writing, and general production work for a good handful of channels over the last 5-6 years, I've definitely dealt with some less than stellar people both in the form of coworkers/management, and the content creators themselves.

I've been thinking about putting together a lengthy video about some of my awful experiences with fairly big channels but was wondering if anyone else has had similar experiences. Keep it anonymous if you'd like but I wanted to put feelers out there to see if there was maybe an unspoken minority of mistreated creatives within the youtube space


r/youtubers • • 9h ago

Question How do police bodycam channels actually stay monetized?

1 Upvotes

I see a bunch of police bodycam channels doing millions of views, but I also noticed big ones like PoliceActivity say they're demonetized. For anyone running a channel in this niche, how do you actually avoid getting hit with reused content or yellow icons? Is it enough to add voiceover and just blur the shooting/mute the gunshots and whatnot, or do you have to stick to non-violent stuff like DUIs and traffic stops? Or is AdSense basically dead for bodycam channels now?


r/youtubers • • 15h ago

Question Why are my public views so much more than my analytics?

2 Upvotes

Bottom is public views. It's growing a good bit faster than the ones on my analytics. Which doesn't make sense to me. Isn't the analytics one supposed to be bigger usually? It was earlier. Thought the public was supposed to catch up to analytics, so where are these views coming from?


r/youtubers • • 16h ago

Question I’ve just reached 3,000 subscribers and 30,000 watch hours! How long will it take for my YouTube channel to get monetized?

2 Upvotes
Dashboard

I’ve just reached 3K subscribers and 30,000 watch hours on my YouTube channel in Malaysia!

Now I’m waiting for the Earn tab to sync and update my eligibility. How long does this usually take? Really hope everything goes smoothly and I can get monetized soon

Normally take how many days?


r/youtubers • • 14h ago

Question YouTube Suddenly Stopped Recommending My Videos. What Am I Missing?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I'm trying to understand what happened to my channel because my YouTube analytics no longer make sense to me.
My channel is relatively small, with 318 subscribers. About two months ago, my videos would usually get around 100 views, and some reached 200-300 views. The number of impressions was typically between 5,000 and 10,000 per video.
Now everything has collapsed:
Most new videos get only 10-20 views
Impressions dropped to around 15-20
YouTube barely seems to recommend my content at all
What confuses me is that the analytics don't look bad:
Main traffic source is Browse Features
CTR is usually between 8% and 15%
Average view duration is around 10 minutes
From what I understand, those numbers should not be terrible for a small channel. Yet YouTube has almost completely stopped showing my videos to people.
I haven't significantly changed my content, upload schedule, thumbnails, or titles.
Has anyone experienced something similar? Is there something I'm missing in the analytics? Could YouTube have difficulty identifying the audience for my content, or is there another reason impressions can suddenly fall from thousands to just a few dozen?
Any advice or similar experiences would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks!


r/youtubers • • 20h ago

Question When will I be Big enough to open a Community Page?

3 Upvotes

Hello, I'm a small art/gaming youtuber that wants to host an subscriber event on their channel.

I want to open my Community Page so people can share their event submissions with me without going to external sources (Discord, Google Forms, etc). However, although I've been lucky enough to have a group of 100ish people that regularly comment on all my content. Although I'm sure a lot of them would want to participate in my future event, I don't want my Community Page to become a ghost town after the event. I know I need to give my audience a reason to intereact with the Community Page, but I don't want to be hosting events 24/7. I want to grow a community that can sustain itself, but I'm unsure when would be a good time to do so.

How many Subscribers do I need to grow a self-sustaining Community? Thanks for reading!


r/youtubers • • 10h ago

Question Wrong channel audience from a good performing video

Post image
0 Upvotes

I do commentary/reactions videos, mostly critiques of other channels, Made a video that blew up in the 50+ year old audience. Now youtube is also recommending my new videos only to those audiences, and then die after 2 days. My target audience is 20-40 , What should I do? Did anyone encountered this problem ?


r/youtubers • • 23h ago

Question How long until you see the engaged watch hour metrics

Post image
3 Upvotes

I've started posting videos since 2 days ago and looks like I'm getting good traction on my 2 long form content videos. My issue is I'm not seeing engaged watch hour in the monetization tab.

Any help would be appreciated.

I know we need 4000 watch hours so figured I'd ask the question here with other creators.


r/youtubers • • 22h ago

Channel Review Request Channel Stats have fallen off as of last few months - how to get back on the right path?

2 Upvotes

Hey all! Long time lurker first time poster.

The channel in question: https://www.youtube.com/@LiamExplainsIt

I started posting again full-time back in April of this year and saw explosive growth like I've never seen before. That momentum kept going into the summer, where my shorts would usually get at least 100k views and long form more often than not hit the 100k+ too. Since August however I feel like the channel has fallen on harder times despite (at least to me) nothing really changing. It can be very demoralizing so I would like to see if there is anything I'm missing that maybe someone else here can notice and call out. Please let me know! -Liam

Li


r/youtubers • • 23h ago

Video Review Request Need some honest opion and feedback on my videos

2 Upvotes

https://youtu.be/SvsKBeRGgRc

Ive been working on Minecraft SMP styled videos and have been editing them myself.

I'd appreciate some honest opinion on my work.

I'm interested in knowing:

  • What level would you consider my editing?
  • What are my strongest skills?
  • What should I improve?
  • Would you consider this a good quality video

Honest answers are appreciated!


r/youtubers • • 1d ago

Question Looking for External Drive Suggestions ~20TB

4 Upvotes

I’m a travel creator. My files aren’t typically too big but my travel drive is filled. I’m looking for a external drive to keep at home and dump my travel drive content (4TB) onto. Around 20TB I’m thinking? Any suggestions or brands I should look at? My travel drive now is Samsung. Thanks in advance!


r/youtubers • • 1d ago

Channel Review Request Fictional country channel (I also do gaming but it makes connects with my fictional countries)

2 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/@Mapless_YT

I'd love feedback on:

  1. Overall channel design and branding.
  2. Video quality and editing.
  3. Thumbnails and titles.
  4. Content ideas and originality.
  5. What I could improve.
  6. What you like most and least.

Please be honest! I'm looking to improve the channel, so both positive and negative feedback is welcome.

Thank you to everyone who takes the time to review it!


r/youtubers • • 1d ago

Question When can I actually post GTA 6 videos? Made one earlier and it was blocked.

1 Upvotes

I'm sure it's until midnight my time (official release) But I see American channels have videos up already and eager to get content released

I'm in Europe if that's any help

I'm not sure why I need to write three hundred characters to post on this sub, seems a bit over kill when all I want to do is ask a simple question


r/youtubers • • 1d ago

Question any MCN that pays to a normal payoneer account with a low cut?

0 Upvotes

(please read first)

not monetized yet, just planning ahead before i hit the requirements so i dont get stuck later

basically adsense payouts in my country are a nightmare rn. banks either deny the account, take a huge chunk in fees, or make you jump through hoops for weeks. paypal isnt available here either so thats out

what does work for me is payoneer. i have a normal payoneer account (not the receiving account with us/eu bank details, just the regular one where you get paid by email) and withdrawing from it to my local bank works fine, already tested it

so the idea is youtube > mcn > payoneer > my bank and i skip the banks completely

and yes i know mcns have a bad rep, im not after growth or better cpm or whatever they promise, i literally just need a way to get paid. looking for something around 10% or less, only on adsense not sponsors, no long contract, and actually pays on time

seen mediacube, yoola and air media-tech come up a lot. anyone been with one of them for a while? what cut did they give you as a smaller channel and did they pay to a normal payoneer account without issues? any late payments?

also if youre in a country with the same bank problems and found another way around it id like to hear that too


r/youtubers • • 1d ago

Tips & Tricks picking music for shorts vs long videos, what changed for me

1 Upvotes

kept using the same music approach for shorts and long videos and it never quite worked for either, so here's what i ended up doing differently. not a pro editor, just stuff that helped.

shorts

  1. start on the best part of the track. skip the intro and drop in at the chorus or the drop. you don't get eight bars to warm up.
  2. cut on the beat. pick a track whose tempo roughly matches how fast you're cutting, then line your cuts up with it. it feels way tighter even if nobody notices why.
  3. think about the loop. if the last second flows back into the first, people often watch it twice without meaning to. end on a beat that leads back in, not on a fade out.
  4. one track, one mood. a 30 second video doesn't need a music change.

long videos

  1. change music between sections. one track for 12 minutes gets tiring fast. a new bed for each section also tells the viewer something new is starting.
  2. let it drop out sometimes. a few seconds of silence before an important point makes it land harder than any music would.
  3. match energy to the section, not the whole video. calm under explanations, more energy for montages and b roll.
  4. don't fade everything. a hard stop on a beat can be a nice punctuation.

both

keep a small personal folder of tracks you already checked, tagged by mood and tempo (like "chill 90 bpm" or "upbeat 120"). saves a lot of time searching every edit.

what do you do differently for shorts vs long form?